We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1981: Report Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–125 of 236. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1981
Enacted

No. 7 of 1981 ›

The Minister will recall that yesterday, on behalf of Deputy O'Leary, I supported this amendment. I should like to know if the Minister has any thoughts in relation to any prospects of relief being afforded in relation to rent payments in respect of private accommodation. Is there any working paper or document available at Government level which might afford any measure of relief to such persons? It is not my intention to press the amendment but I was wondering if there was any intention of granting relief. It was interesting to hear Deputy Fitzpatrick of the Minister's party alluding to the need to give relief to persons paying substantial rents for private accommodation vis-á-vis the ordinary relief afforded to mortgage holders. It has been suggested that because of mortgage relief the Government should consider giving relief in the direction I have asked.

The Minister will recall that the general intention of the Labour Party amendment was that persons paying at least £10 and not more than £50 per week for rented accommodation should get some mortgage relief for such payments. The Minister told us he could not find his way to accepting that amendment but perhaps we might tease out from him if any thought is being given to that principle within the Department of Finance or the Revenue Commissioners. It may feature in the next three or four weeks in a certain campaign.

Comment on this

An amendment designed to provide some measure of tax relief in respect of people living in rented accommodation is desirable because if those people were living in a house which they had the ability to purchase they would get tax relief on the interest being paid on any loan they took out for that purpose. As a general rule one can say that people living in rented accommodation are less well off than people living in their own house because it is usual that they live in rented accommodation because they do not have any option. They live in such accommodation because they cannot afford to buy a house of their own.

It is somewhat ironical that there should be a tax relief for people who can afford to buy a house of their own on the interest they pay whereas those who cannot afford to buy a house do not get tax relief on any of the payments they make. The result of this has been a diminution in the amount of available rented accommodation because the rents that can be charged in these circumstances are not sufficiently remunerative to encourage people to provide adequate amounts of this accommodation. The result is a scarcity of rented accommodation in many parts of this city and other major towns. Deputy O'Leary's amendment will have the effect of making much more rented accommodation available in the medium term, because by giving relief to the tenant in respect of his or her rent it would become more profitable for both potential landlords and potential tenants to enter into more arrangements for the leasing of housing accommodation and we would have more rented accommodation, an easier situation in the housing market and more mobility in our economy, since rented accommodation is a more mobile product.

The Minister for Finance argued that any introduction of relief on income tax for rented accommodation would lead to an increase in demand for rented accommodation but no increase in supply, and hence to an increase in the rents and the benefit therefore going to the landlord. This, of course, is not true because rented accommodation can be made available relatively easily. The conversion involved internally in most houses to make them available for rental can be carried out relatively quickly. There is no need to buy sites or to get planning permission in most cases because making available rented accommodation usually involves merely relatively minor internal reconstruction. In the event of relief being made available for rented accommodation the supply could increase to meet the increased demand very quickly.

It is quite the opposite in making relief available for new house accommodation. It is not possible to make new house accommodation available quickly. An increase in demand for new house accommodation generated by an increased housing grant, such as the present Government have made so much of introducing, is not going to be matched by an increased supply as quickly as would be an increased demand for rented accommodation, because it has to involve the purchase of new houses. The concession for which the Government have the money to introduce — namely, the increased grant for new house accommodation — is certainly going to have the effect that the Minister mentioned of benefiting builders rather than home owners because supply cannot be increased physically quickly enough to match increased demand. The opposite is the case in respect of the concessions sought in this amendment and, therefore, the case that the Minister has made has no substance.

I do not know the basis upon which the Minister made the estimate of £40 million as the cost of this concession. I am sure he is well aware that many landlords who are letting rented accommodation at the moment are not paying tax. If tenants were able to claim their rent or even a part of their rent as relief against the tenant's income tax they would return the name of the landlord and in many cases this would lead to the identification for income tax purposes of landlords who hitherto had not been paying tax on the rents that they received. Far from costing money, a concession of this nature could generate increased revenue. The Minister, of course, in making his estimate took no account whatever of this phenomenon.

Deputy O'Leary's amendment may go too far in so far as it proposes to allow the whole of the rent up to a certain ceiling as allowable expenditure for expenses purposes on the part of the tenant. Even if a part of the rent were allowed, that would be my preference. That would have the effect of giving some relief to the tenant but it would also have the full effect of identifying landlords who have been avoiding income tax. If the Minister wanted to make a constructive move in this direction he need not have gone the whole way with Deputy O'Leary's amendment but he could have introduced his own amendment which would have cost less because of restricting the relief to less than the whole of the rent payment for the purpose of the income tax of the tenant while at the same time having the full effect of identifying landlords who might not at the moment be paying tax.

The Minister has adopted a shortsighted attitude in refusing this amendment, and it is significant that in this Finance Bill the same Minister proposes to give relief to landlords who build rented accommodation. They are going to get tax relief, but the proposal to give relief to the tenants as proposed in Deputy O'Leary's amendment is rejected by the Minister. We see his scale of priorities. He is happy to see an income tax relief going to landlords who build accommodation on the income that they might derive from the rents, but he is not happy to see any relief going to the tenant in respect of the tenant's income tax. That indicates his approach and the type of people who have influence on him in making policy decisions. It indicates a totally wrong scale of priorities and a wrong approach to the solution to this problem.

Comment on this
Padraig Faulkner An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this

Is there any response from the Minister? He has already spoken on the matter.

Comment on this
Padraig Faulkner An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Bruton has replied.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

This is Report Stage, but the Deputy will not be aware of that because he is not sure. The Deputy is well aware of my sympathies.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 9:

In page 8, before line 12, to insert the following:

"—For the year 1982-83 and any subsequent year of assessment the amount of reliefs and allowable deductions from the total income of an individual for income tax purposes, and the amounts specified in section 3 of this Act, shall be increased by the percentage figure as represented by the Consumer Price Index to mid-February of each year."

Comment on this

The purpose of amendment No. 9 is to introduce indexation in the income tax code. The Minister indicated on Committee Stage that he would not do this, but it is appropriate that this matter be considered on Report Stage also. It is of great concern to working people in respect of their taxation that the Government are able, through what is euphemistically termed buoyancy of revenue — namely, the fact that tax allowances do not in many cases keep pace with inflation — to get increased revenue without the necessity of coming into the Dáil and getting sanction for that simply because inflation has devalued the allowances and a higher burden of real taxation is charged solely as a result of inflation without any approval by this House. That is taxation by stealth, and indexation would remove the possibility of taxation by stealth — namely the increase in the real burden of taxation without the sanction of the Oireachtas — by increased allowances. Indexation does not prevent a Government from increasing the real burden of taxation if they consider it necessary, but it does prevent the Government getting increased revenue without the sanction of the Oireachtas. Consequently, this amendment is an appropriate one to be considered on Report Stage as it was regrettable that the Minister has not seen his way to accept this because it would not have prevented him from increasing revenue in future years. It would merely make him do in the open what he and other Ministers of all parties have in the absence of indexation been able to do in the past by stealth.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

This amendment is exactly the same as that put down by Deputy O'Leary on Committee Stage which was withdrawn after a very brief discussion. I pointed out at that stage a number of things regarding indexation. Of course, there have been many calls for indexation of the personal allowances and the rate band structures, but I will demonstrate to the House again, as I did on Committee Stage, the progress that has been made in that whole area during the term of office of the present Government. Individual taxpayers have benefited to a far higher degree or extent than they would have done had the allowances and structures been linked to indexation. I said that in the budgets of 1978, 1979, 1980 and 1981 the full year cost to the Exchequer of the improvement in the allowances in the rate band structures was £500 million. During the period of those four budgets had indexation as suggested in this amendment been used, the full year cost would have been only £324 million. Therefore the taxpayers because of the policies and because of the action of the Government have in fact run well ahead in that respect. There is £176 million of a difference. I can appreciate the Deputies opposite raising points like this because during the term of office of their Government this did not happen.

The improvements have been substantial and have been well ahead of what they would have been had there been indexation. I would also like to say that the Commission on Taxation must be looking at suggestions like this and when they report they may well have suggestions to make regarding this. As I said, the taxpayers have benefited to a far greater extent than they would have done by indexation. After a very brief discussion on Committee Stage the same amendment was withdrawn by Deputy O'Leary.

Comment on this

Not all the allowances have been indexed.

Comment on this
Padraig Faulkner An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We cannot have a Committee Stage discussion.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:

In page 8, before line 12, to insert the following:

"—Income derived from the payment of an old age pension to a person qualified under the Social Welfare (Consolidation) Act, 1981, shall not be assessed to tax for the year 1981-82 and any subsequent year of assessment.".

Comment on this
Padraig Faulkner An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Recommital is necessary in respect of amendment No. 11 as it involves matters which did not effectively arise on Committee procedure.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 11:

In page 17, between lines 10 and 11, to insert the following:

"17.—As respects any relevant accounting period within the meaning of section 38 of that Act, Chapter VI of Part I of the Finance Act, 1980, is hereby amended—

(a) by the insertion in section 39 after subsection (1) of the following subsection:

`(1A) The definition of " `goods' " contained in subsection (1) shall include—

(a) fish produced within the State on a fish farm, and

(b) cultivated mushrooms cultivated within the State,

in the course of a trade by the company which, in relation to the relevant accounting period, is the company claiming relief under this Chapter in relation to the trade and references in this Chapter to " `manufactured' " shall be construed—

(i) in relation to fish, as including references to produced, and

(ii) in relation to mushrooms, as including references to cultivated,

and words in this Chapter cognate to " `manufactured' " shall be construed accordingly.

(1B) The following provisions shall apply, for the purpose of relief under this Chapter, in relation to a company that carries on a trade which consists of or includes the repairing of ships—

(a) repairs carried out within the State to a ship shall be regarded as the manufacture within the State of goods, and

(b) any amount receivable in payment for such repairs so carried out shall be regarded as an amount receivable from the sale of goods.

(1C) (a) In this subsection " `engineering services' " means design and planning services the work on the rendering of which is carried out in the State in connection with chemical, civil, electrical or mechanical engineering works executed outside the territories of the Member States of the European Communities.

(b) Where a company carries on a trade which consists of or includes the rendering of engineering services, the following provisions shall apply for the purpose of relief under this Chapter—

(i) the rendering within the State of such services shall be regarded as the manufacture within the State of goods, and

(ii) any amount receivable in payment for such services so rendered shall be regarded as an amount receivable from the sale of goods.

(1D) The inspector may by notice in writing require a company claiming relief from tax by virtue of subsection (1B) or (1C), as the case may be, to furnish him with such information or particulars a may be necessary for the purpose of giving effect to that subsection, and section 41 (2) shall have effect as if the matters of which proof is required thereby included the information or particulars specified in a notice under this subsection.', and

(b) by the insertion after section 39 of the following section:

`39A.—(1) in this section—

" `the airport' " has the same meaning as in the Customs-free Airport Act, 1947;

"`company"' means any company carrying on a trade;

"`the EEC Treaty"' means the Treaty establishing the European Economic Community, signed at Rome on the 25th day of March, 1957;

" `the Minister' " means the Minister for Finance;

"`qualified company"' means a company the whole or part of the trade of which is carried on within the airport;

"`relevant trading operations"' means trading operations specified in a certificate given by the Minister under subsection (2);

"`trading operation"' means any trading operation which, apart from this section, is not the manufacture of goods for the purpose of this Chapter but is carried on by a qualified company.

(2) Subject to subsections (5) and (6), the Minister may give a certificate certifying that such trading operations of a qualified company as are specified in the certificate are, with effect from a date to be specified in the certificate, relevant trading operations for the purpose of this section, and any certificate so given shall, unless it is revoked under subsection (4), remain in force until the 31st day of December, 2000:

Provided that—

(a) any trading operations in respect of which the Minister has given a certificate under section 70 (2) of the Corporation Tax Act, 1976, (or a certificate which has effect as if it were a certificate given under that section) shall not be certified as relevant trading operations unless the Minister is satisfied that those operations arise from an initial investment; and

(b) in determining what constitutes an initial investment for the purposes of this proviso the Minister shall have regard to the principles for the time being applied by the Commission of the European Communities in accordance with the powers vested in it by Articles 92 to 94 of the EEC Treaty.

(3) A certificate under subsection (2) may be given either without conditions or subject to such conditions as the Minister considers proper and specifies therein.

(4) Where, in the case of a company in relation to which a certificate under subsection (2) has been given—

(a) the trade of the company ceases or becomes caried on ceases or becomes carried on wholly outside the airport, or

(b) the Minister is satisfied that the company has failed to comply with any condition subject to which the certificate was given,

the Minister may, by notice in writing served by registered post on the company, revoke the certificate with effect from such date as may be specified in the notice.

(5) The Minister shall not certify, under subsection (2), that a trading operation is a relevant trading operation unless it is carried on within the airport and falls within one or more of the following clases of trading operations—

(a) the repair or maintenance of aircraft,

(b) trading operations in regard to which the Minister is of opinion, after consultation with the Minister for Transport, that they contribute to the use or development of the airport,

(c) trading operations which are ancillary to any of those operations described in the foregoing paragraphs or to any operation consisting, apart from this section, of the manufacture of goods.

(6) The Minister shall not certify, under subsection (2), that any of the following trading operations is a relevant trading operation—

(a) the rendering of—

(i) services to embarking or disembarking aircraft passengers, including hotel, catering, money-changing or transport (other than air transport) services, or

(ii) services in connection with the landing, departure, loading or unloading of aircraft,

(b) the operation of a scheduled air transport service,

(c) selling by retail,

(d) the sale of consumable commodities for the fuelling of aircraft or for shipment as aircraft stores.

(7) In the case of a qualified company carrying on relevant trading operations, the following provisions shall apply for the purpose of relief under this Chapter—

(a) the relevant trading operations shall be regarded as the manufacture within the State of goods, and

(b) any amount receivable in payment for anything sold, or any services rendered, in the course of the relevant trading operations shall be regarded as an amount receivable from the sale of goods.

(8) (a) Where at the end of any relevant accounting period a qualified company has fifty or more full-time employees, the aggregate of all amounts of relevant relief under this Chapter to which the company is entitled for all relevant accounting periods shall not exceed an amount determined in accordance with the principles for the time being applied by the Commission of the European Communities under the powers vested in it by Articles 92 to 94 of the EEC Treaty, and there shall be made such additional assessments or adjustments of assessments as may be required in any case in order to give effect to this subsection.

(b) In this subsection—

" `full-time employees' " means, in relation to a qualified company, employees who are employed by the company on a full-time basis in relation to relevant trading operations and the duties of whose employment are such that they are required to devote substantially the whole of their time to the service of the company;

" `relevant relief under this Chapter"' means the relief under this Chapter to which a qualified company would not be entitled but for the provisions of subsection (7).

(9) (a) The Revenue Commissioners may make regulations for the purposes of giving effect to subsection (8) (a) and to provide for any ancillary or consequential matters.

(b) Every regulation made under paragraph (a) shall be laid before Dáil Éireann as soon as may be after it is made and, if a resolution annulling the regulation is passed by Dáil Éireann within the next twenty-one days on which Dáil Éireann has sat after the regulation is laid before it, the regulation shall be annulled accordingly, but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done thereunder.

(10) The inspector may be notice in writing require a company claiming relief from tax by virtue of this section to furnish him with such information or particulars as may be necessary for the purpose of giving effect to this section, and section 41 (2) shall have effect as if the matters of which proof is required thereby included the information or particulars specified in a notice under this section.'.".

I would like to point out to the House that there is a minor drafting correction to the amendment in paragraph (a) of the new section 17. In the second line "subsection" should read "subsections". It is a minor drafting amendment.

This amendment is intended to extend the relief from Corporation Tax provided by Chapter VI of the Finance Act, 1980, that is the 10 per cent scheme, to trading profits arising to companies from a number of areas: (1) Sales of cultivated mushrooms cultivated within the State; (2) sales of fish produced in a fish farm within the State; (3) repairs to ships carried out within the State and (4) engineering services, design and planning rendered in connection with certain engineering work executed outside the territories of the member states of the EEC where the work in connection with such services is carried out in the State and certain trading operations of non-manfacturing carried on at Shannon Airport. That is mainly what is involved in the amendment.

Comment on this

Will the Minister tell us the relevance of the reference in paragraph 17 (2) (b) to Articles 92 to 94 of the EEC Treaty?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

The Deputy must be aware that when we replaced the export sales relief scheme with the new 10 per cent scheme I referred to, obviously certain approvals had to be obtained from the EEC. Furthermore, approval for any subsequent alterations to it, such as are now suggested, will have to be obtained as well. In the case of ship repairs full approval has been obtained. Approval in principle has been obtained in other areas and further discussions are taking place on the engineering services, design and planning.

Comment on this

What is the significance of the fact that the section to which I referred says: "In determining what constitutes an initial investment for the purposes of this provision the Minister shall have regard to the principles for the time being applied by the Commission of the European Communities in accordance with the powers vested in it by Articles 92 to 94 of the EEC Treaty." This does not say the Minister shall have regard to regulations made by the European Commission. If it were regulations made by the European Commission people who wished to know what their position was in regard to this relief would be able to refer to some legal tests.

The section says "the principles applied by the Commission of the European Communities". These may be administrative principles which are not formulated anywhere in statute, European or Irish. People, therefore, wishing to know their position have, within the terms of this amendment, no means of doing so because it merely refers to administrative principles. I cannot see how legislation such as ours should include administrative principles applied by an agency outside the State which need not necessarily be formulated in writing. The idea of our making legislation based on what the Commission officials may informally say to someone else in the Community and making the effectiveness or otherwise of our legislation contingent on that type of negotiation, of which people in this country may be quite unaware of and have no means of becoming aware, is introducing into our legislation something which should not be in it. It makes the legislation so completely imprecise as to be valueless. What does the Minister mean by the terms he has used in this context?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

In this section we are specifically referring to the Shannon operations. That condition limits the extent to which existing companies in Shannon, who have qualified under the Shannon exemption scheme, will be able to avail of the new relief. Details of how it will operate have yet to be finalised with the Commission. The legislation, as it is presently drafted, provides that the Minister will not certify any existing trading operations as relevant trading operations for the purpose of the new relief unless certain initial investment has been undertaken. This latter term "initial investment" has a technical meaning in the context of the principles laid down by the Commission for the co-ordination of regional aid systems. That is basically the reasons for that.

In the discussions to extend that scheme it was agreed that the relief would be granted subject to the principles laid down by the Commission. The benefits and the advantages are obvious. The Deputy asked why such a section is inserted. The reason is, as I have tried to explain to him, that the principles will be based on the concept of aids to initial investment for jobs creation. It is in the interests, basically, of extra jobs in that particular region and the aid that existed under the export sales relief to that type of industry in the Shannon region. It is merely endeavouring to assist those industries.

Comment on this

What are the principles now applied by the Commission in regard to this matter?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

They are based on a concept of aids to initial investment or jobs created and specify limits to such aids for different regions in the Community. In the case of the services sector, if aids were limited by reference to initial investments, little aid could be granted to that sector in comparison with the manufacturing sector. It is the alternative measure by reference to aid per job created which applies to this sector. Details of the principles have yet to be worked out with the Commission but they are in the interest of these extra jobs in the Shannon region.

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying that there are no principles in regard to this matter in operation at present?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I said there are principles.

Comment on this

The Minister cannot have it both ways. He says the principles are yet to be agreed. Therefore, there are no principles in operation at present.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I did not say that. I said details of the principles——

Comment on this

What are the principles?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Aids to initial investment or jobs created.

Comment on this

That is not a principle.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Under the principles currently applicable the maximum aid per job created that can be granted to a project by the Irish Government from 1 January 1981 is 17,500 European units of account.

Comment on this

Per job?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

To jobs per project. The Commission have agreed that businesses below a certain size need not be subject to any limits and we are at present trying to work out the details and numbers involved, the size of the business carried on by the company and the number of employees. We are trying to identify non-manufacturing companies at Shannon which can avail of this relief.

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying that a company with a project which is receiving aid of less than 17,500 u.a. shall not be subject to any control by the Commission? What is the relevance of the figure?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

The relief will be available only to new activities starting on or after 1 January 1981, the date the 10 per cent scheme was introduced. Existing activities which qualified for relief under the Shannon exemption scheme may, however, qualify provided there has been a fundamental change in the carrying on of those activities involving new investment.

Comment on this

The Minister is now saying that existing activities at Shannon shall not qualify for the 10 per cent corporation tax unless they are involved in new investment. Is that right?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Yes, and these are the details we are trying to work out at the moment.

Comment on this

The Minister is saying that new activities undertaken on or after 1 January 1981 will qualify for this purpose. How can a firm which is contemplating investment at the moment or has made investments in the last five months know in the light of this section whether it qualifies when the Minister is unable to tell us the principles being applied by the Community in regard to this matter?

Presumably these companies will be liable to tax in respect of new activities from 1 January 1981. On what basis will they be taxed between the period 1 January 1981 and the date when these new principles are enunciated by the Commission? If it transpires that the Commission laid down principles which are at variance with what that company expected when the investment was made, will they find that, in respect of incomes received from 1 January, they will be at a higher rate of tax than the 10 per cent rate they expected? This is the point I have been trying to make all along.

Although this section is extremely long, detailed and wordy, it means little or nothing and provides no guidance simply because there is no guidance as to what the principles are. I do not understand why the term "principles" is used. The Minister referred to Articles 92 to 94 of the Treaty of Rome. Article 94 says:

The Council may, acting by a qualified majority on a proposal from the Commission, make any appropriate regulations for the application of Articles 92 and 93 and may in particular determine the conditions in which Article 93 (3) shall apply and the categories of aid exempted from this procedure.

Given that there is specifically a power in Article 94 to make regulations to apply Articles 92 and 93, I do not understand why the Minister refers to "principles", instead of saying, in determining what constitutes an investment, that the Minister shall have regard to actual regulations, which he is empowered to make under Article 94, which will be in writing, and to which people can refer and know exactly where they stand. These principles are not referred to in any article of the Treaty of Rome. There is no procedure whereby principles may be enunciated under any of the three articles referred to by the Minister. How will people know whether they are entitled to the 10 per cent rate?

If this section is designed as an incentive to invest, people will have to know before they make the investment if they are eligible. We are using this section as an incentive to invest not only in the future but also to investments which may have taken place since 1 January. Yet those people have no means of knowing whether they are eligible for the 10 per cent rate. That is not much of an incentive. I would like the Minister to indicate why he is using the term "principles", and what are the principles in operation at the moment? He did not tell me about that. He said something about an initial allowance in regard to investment but his answer was not even a sentence with a verb——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Another professor dawning in the ranks of the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this

—— and there is no way of knowing what he meant. What are the principles now in operation? What remains to be negotiated, and when it is negotiated where will it be set out in precise terms so that people will know whether they qualify?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I have been listening to a lecture from Deputy Bruton, obviously delivered for the benefit of other people in the House. He is reading well this weather, playing to that group of people. We cannot deny him that privilege. We know too well what a malfunction he performed when he was in different Departments. He is now the new found professor, lecturing us across the House. Let me educate him. The principles he referred to are those laid down in a communication from the Commission in February 1975, referring to regional aid throughout the Community. It goes on to state that the Commission, with experts from member states, may sit down and discuss the details of how to co-ordinate and avoid distortions in different areas, or to adjust the principles to areas such as those we are trying to cover here, that is, the introduction at Shannon of assistance for new and existing companies.

As the Deputy should known, existing companies will have relief available to them until 1990 in the form of Shannon export sales relief, if they so wish. New companies, if they have fewer than 50 employees, are not restricted as to the amount of relief. That is the position we are endeavouring to incorporate here in the interests of generating further activity in Shannon. When the Deputy across tries to lecture me, I am saying to him that while this Government are here, and we will be here for a long time, we will continue to ensure that by every means open to us the principles of 1975 will be applied to the best advantage of the various parts of Ireland so that there will be additional job creation.

It seems to me the Deputy is opposing this section. If he is, let him come out and say so. If he does not want to have this aid extended to Shannon industries let him tell us, or is he arguing against our negotiating details of the principles that he does not know about but which were contained in a communication from the Commission of 26 February 1975 and relating back to 1 January 1975? The Government will continue to negotiate the details of those principles to the best advantage of the country.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for at last telling me where the principles are to be found. If I had not pursued the matter we would not have known that the principles are contained in the communication of 26 February 1975. Indeed people who might have been concerned to avail of such aid would not have known about it because during the debate on this section there has not been any mention or any explanation of the communication or where the principles were formulated. The Minister said the principles are in a communication of the Commission. A communication to whom? Where and for whom was it published?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

It is in the Official Journal of the European Communities, No. C319, dated 3 February 1979.

Comment on this

I am glad we have got that far. Would the Minister please tell me what are the principles? This is the first reference I have heard or seen to this communication in the debate or in the section. As an Opposition Deputy as competent as anybody else at trying to interpret the laws of the land, I did not have any way of knowing about the existence of this obscure 1975 communication addressed to someone as yet unstated. Apparently that communication is to determine the meaning of legislation we are trying to enact in 1981. Not having had the opportunity to see the communication in time, the Minister might have been sufficiently thoughtful to let me know that this was relevant to the section. If he had let me know I would have read the communication.

Not having read the document, would the Minister tell me what are the principles contained in the communication, in broad terms? One cannot determine the significance of this section if one does not know the details of the principles. Apparently details of the principles still have to be worked out. What has been worked out and what remains to be worked out and when will the negotiations be concluded?

The Minister tried to pretend I am opposed to the section because I asked questions about what the section meant. Of course I am not opposed to the section. I am in favour of relief by way of grants to industries, but relief for which people do not know whether they qualify or not is worthless. It is in order to ensure that the relief will be sufficient and that people will know whether they qualify for it and therefore make the investment we are all trying to encourage that I have been asking the Minister to explain these matters. Instead of making partisan points, I would have thought the Minister would have welcomed the fact that I had sought details so that the section would become more fully understood and so that the objective we all have in common, to encourage the establishment of industries, would be more fully achieved. I am surprised the Minister has adopted this attitude.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I do not accept responsibility to tell any Opposition spokesman what his role should be. He should do his homework, as I had to do in my Opposition days. However, I will try to give him as much information as I can on the position that applies now. The principles are based on the concept of aid to industry for jobs created and they specify limits to such aids for different regions of the Community. In the case of the services sector, if aids were limited by reference to initial investments, relatively little aid could be granted to that sector in comparison with, say, the manufacturing sector. The alternative method for applying aid in respect of jobs created is applied to this sector because obviously there is a different structure in the services sector, as the Deputy should be aware.

Under the principles currently applicable, the maximum aid for jobs created from 1 January 1981 is £12,106. The Commission have agreed that businesses below a certain size would not be subject to any limit on aid because, being small, their effect on Community trade is insignificant, and it has been agreed that for the services sector the criterion used in identifying the size of the business being carried on should be the number of employees and that for the purpose of identifying non-manufacturing companies at Shannon, any company with fewer than 50 employees will be regarded as not subject to any limit on relief. However, any company with 50 or more employees must be subject to a limit, to be determined in accordance with the principles. The details to be worked out, therefore, are in respect of companies with more than 50 employees.

Comment on this

When and where were the details promulgated of the principles to which the Minister referred and still subject to negotiation?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Where, obviously, is between our own people here and the Commission. When? As soon as possible. I am not in a position yet to say when specifically. But it is a matter of urgency that is being pursued with all possible speed in the interests of employment in Shannon. With regard to the maximum which has yet to be agreed, I was going to give the Deputy those points. It can be identified by reference to a number of things — the number of employees, the reference rate which will be changed from year to year, and it appears that there will be a rate particular to the beginning of each accounting period, the exchange rate and the period over which relief is granted. These are details that have yet to be worked out but will obviously be pursued quickly in order to get the maximum benefit for that type of activity in the Shannon region. The Deputy asked why it was introduced in this Bill, and why it could not be finalised before the introduction of this section. The Deputy will appreciate that if I had not brought in this amendment it could not have been introduced until next year's Finance Bill and I believed that it was important enough to introduce it in this year's Finance Bill despite the fact that some of the details have yet to be finalised.

Comment on this

Where will the details be set out? Will they be set out in any regulation which can be referred to by people wishing to know whether or not they qualify? Will it be merely an administrative agreement between the Minister and the Commission? If that is the case it would be unsatisfactory for people wishing to know whether or not they qualify because it would not be accessible in a public document.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

On the question of the employees, the Revenue Commissioners will be making the regulations. In the other areas it will be a matter for the Minister for Finance when the communications are received from the Commission and, of course, they will be available through the normal channels.

Comment on this

The section does not provide for the making of regulations. Subsection (9) says that the Revenue Commissioners may make regulations for the purpose of giving effect to subsection (8)(a) and to provide for any ancillary or consequential matters. But there is no provision in the section for the Revenue Commissioners to make regulations in respect of subsection (2)(b) which is the section in respect of which the Minister says regulations will be made. I would like to know under what power these regulations will be made. I will repeat that for the Minister when he is finished.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I am sorry.

Comment on this

The Minister said that the regulations will be made to set out these details. The section, however, does not confer powers for the making of regulations for this purpose. There is a power for making regulations in respect of subsection (8) but there is no regulation-making power in respect of subsection (2)(b). I would like to know on what basis the regulations will be made.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I said earlier to the Deputy that the Revenue Commissioners would make regulations in respect of employee numbers. The Minister would then issue a certificate in respect of the other criteria. Subsection (2)(a) and (b) means that it is at the Minister's discretion to decide whether to issue a certifircate or not when the details have been worked out. That discretion rests with the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

The problem is that the basis upon which the Minister may or may not decide to issue a certificate is to be laid down not by the Minister but on the basis of principles applied by the Commission of the European Communities. To say that the Minister may or may not grant a certificate is not an answer to the problem because people will not know whether or not the Minister will be able to issue such a certificate unless they know what the principles are. The Minister said that these principles would, in part, be laid down in regulations made by the Revenue Commissioners in respect of the number of employees. I pointed out that there is no power in the Bill for the making of such regulations. I will repeat what I am concerned about here. Will the conditions be sufficiently precise for people to know whether they qualify or not and to know therefore, whether it is worth their while seeking to set up this investment in Shannon? I would like the Minister to indicate how these powers are going to be exercised.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

The position is fairly well protected on the basis that, as the Deputy knows from the operations in Shannon initially, the company so deciding or contemplating must get a licence to operate from the Minister for Industry, Commerce and Tourism and must then approach the Minister for Finance who may, after consultation with the Commission and the Revenue Commissioners, and if the criteria are right, issue a certificate.

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying that each individual case is going to be discussed with the Commission?

Comment on this
Mr. G. FitzGerald

It is a matter of interpretation. We are talking about the initial investment. An initial investment would be interpreted as investment in fixed assets, the creation of a new establishment, extension of an existing establishment or engaging in an activity involving a fundamental change in the process of an existing establishment. Investment in fixed assets by way of the taking over of an establishment which was closed or would have closed had such takeover not taken place would also be deemed as an initial investment. The manner in which initial investment is defined is identified in the regional aid systems of the Member States and will be examined by the Commission in the course of its review of existing aid systems under Article 93 (1) of the EEC Treaty. The Minister for Industry, Commerce and Tourism will give a licence to operate. If this is forthcoming the Minister for Finance may if the request complies with the details of the interpretations, issue a certificate in respect of the company.

Comment on this

Where will the detailed agreements in respect of the interpretations be published? That is what I am trying to get an answer to.

Comment on this
Mr. G. FitzGerald

They will not be published.

Comment on this

Then how will people know whether they qualify or not? The whole purpose of legislation and the purpose of this sort of debate is so that people will know what the law is after these provisions have been made. The Minister is now telling us that the applicability of this section will be determined by agreements which will not be published. We are wasting our time discussing this section if its applicability is based on agreements which have not been made and when made will not be published. The Minister will accept that it is not a satisfactory way in which to encourage investment here, to make laws which are so obscure that people will not know whether or not they qualify.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I am surprised at the Deputy who had a brief innings in the Department of Industry and Commerce. The Deputy is far removed from the scene. If we pursued the Deputy's line the details of every IDA project would have to be discussed here. This is enabling legislation to benefit the Shannon region and not a great number will be involved in it. From his brief experience on the fringes of the Department of Industry and Commerce the Deputy should be aware that certain exemptions have existed in Shannon. The details here relate to initial investment aid. The Revenue people will make regulations in relation to the number of employees but under the existing Shannon exemption scheme a certificate is given at the Minister's discretion and there are no published rules or regulations. The Deputy is not with it, possible due to lack of experience. If we were to lay down rigid guidelines we would inhibit rather than encourage and promote industrial development. If the Deputy is opposed to the help we are trying to give to the Shannon region he should say so.

Comment on this

I am not interested in what the Minister has to say about my past and it is irrelevant to the section.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

The Deputy is obviously accepting my comments.

Comment on this

I am anxious to elicit from the Minister what the section means. I regret that the Minister has to engage in personal remarks so as to get time to be briefed by his officials in order to answer my question. It is a pity that the Minister cannot answer the question without making a lot of irrelevant remarks at my expense which are merely taking up the time of the House.

The purpose of incentives is to encourage people from abroad to locate here. The IDA have the job of selling Ireland abroad and this section and the incentives in it will be one of the major ways in which to encourage investment particularly in the Shannon region. The IDA and others concerned with promoting Ireland, the private individuals who may meet foreign industrialists, might wish to explain the incentives available here. If I met a foreign industrialist I would like to be able to tell him what incentives are available but the problem in regard to this section is that the Minister is not able to say what the incentives are because he cannot say whether or not he would be able to issue a certificate under this section because the principles under which he may be able to do it are not yet agreed with the Commission and even when they are agreed they will not be published. People would like to know whether they can qualify, in advance of sending somebody from abroad at considerable expense to talk to the IDA. Having gone to that expense they could well discover that they did not qualify on the basis of agreements which have not been published and to which the Minister refers in this section. Why is the Minister not prepared to publish the agreements? If the Minister were to say that the agreements would be published we would know that when an agreement was entered into it would be published and people would be able to know whether or not they qualified. Will the Minister be so kind as to indicate that he will publish agreements? If that is done I will be satisfied.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

The Deputy should have some idea of the confidentiality involved in the approach to projects of this nature. We do not lay down in public the IDA criteria for any project and the IDA have been extremely successful. We are talking here about the Shannon Airport area which is controlled by SFADCo. The necessity is there for a licence by the Minister for Industry, Commerce and Tourism to operate there in the first place and a certificate from the Minister for Finance is also necessary. As the amendment says, a certificate may be given with or without conditions as the Minister considers appropriate. New companies know in advance that they are subject only to a restriction of over 50 employees because in their case the term "initial investment" is not relevant. The certificate under the existing Shannon exemption scheme is at the Minister's discretion and each case is looked at on its merits. After Commission principles are communicated, they are published in the Official Journal but not in advance. I am not trying, as the Deputy seems to infer, to hesitate to lay down rules and regulations but I am taking into account the practicality of doing it as it should be done. We are basically talking about initial investment. The Deputy seems to be saying that we should publish certain regulations. I put it to the Deputy that each project can be totally different and it is unreal for him to talk about laying down certain rules in that sort of situation. There is no change in what is happening at present in respect of the issue of certificates other than where we are talking about the initial investment where certain details have to be worked out. New companies know in advance that they are subject to a restriction of over 50 employees. In the Shannon region we are talking about mostly small industries employing sometimes considerably fewer than 50 employees.

The Deputy is exaggerating. Basically this amendment introduces tax changes in respect of a group of things — including the Shannon Airport region. It is in the interests of encouraging further activities in that region. Since the fifties successive Governments have treated it as an exempted area. What we are doing here in the main is merely giving a concession to some small employers and it is certainly in the interests of jobs in the Shannon area. There is nothing sinister or wrong in what I am doing here. The certificate under the existing Shannon exemption scheme is at the Minister's discretion. There are no published rules and regulations.

Comment on this

The issue of certificates is not at the Minister's discretion. It is quite clear that in determining an initial investment for the purpose of issuing a certificate he is bound by the principles laid down in Articles 92 to 94 of the Treaty of Rome.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I accept that.

Comment on this

Therefore it is not at the Minister's discretion. The Minister has also said that the interpretation of these principles shall be contained in an agreement entered into by the Minister with the Commission of the European Communities. That would be an agreement made once and for all which would apply henceforth. I asked the Minister would that agreement be published and he said "No". I cannot understand how anyone could know on what basis the Minister would issue a certificate unless the terms of the agreement entered into are known. I cannot understand how the Minister would wish to conceal from the public the terms of an agreement which he will enter into in the future with the European Commission.

I do not believe for one moment that there is anything sinister in this, but there may be something sloppy, or something that will not work involved in this, simply because if one does not publish the basis upon which the Minister may issue certificates, no one knows where he or she stands. I never said that I wanted to know, or have published, the details of individual negotiations with individual firms. I am not concerned with that at all. What I am interested in are the principles of criteria for the granting of certificates, those principles which will be contained in an agreement which the Minister says will not be published. How can one interpret principles on the basis of an unpublished agreement? As I said, the Minister does not have discretion because he is subject to these principles, which are not only obscure at the moment but, if one is to understand correctly, will remain obscure. How can the Minister, or I or anyone else, in whatever capacity we may be, going abroad to try to sell this country and to get people to locate their industries in Shannon, sell it on the grounds that these people may get the 10 per cent tax relief if they qualify on the basis of principles which are contained in an agreement which we will not publish? One would not be in a very strong position to try to sell this country on that basis and that is what I am trying to elicit from the Minister and get him to elucidate.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

The Deputy used the word "sloppy" and I would not agree with that. It may be true to say that this is premature, but it is sensible and desirable that it should be. One could, of course, in typical conservative style, wait until next year's Finance Bill to introduce this and allow a year to go by when all the details of interpretation and so on had been worked out with the Commission. I would not like to do that, because a whole year would be lost. The Deputy has said that we are somewhat premature but we are premature in the interests of the Shannon region and I hope that the Deputy will accept that. Interpretation of the principles is one thing but changes in those interpretations obviously will be communicated and will be, as the communications themselves are, in the Official Journal.

Comment on this

Where will the agreements be published?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Agreements with whom?

Comment on this

With the Commission.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Any changes in the interpretations of the principles will, of course, be published.

Comment on this

Where will the agreement to which the Minister has referred, be published?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

The agreements will, of course, be published. But I am not talking about agreements with the Commission; I am talking about details of principles being worked out.

Comment on this

Will they be published?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Yes. On the interpretation, that is.

Comment on this

Where will they be published?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

In the EC Official Journal.

Comment on this

The agreement between the Minister and the Commission will be published?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

No, changes in the EEC interpretation. I think the Deputy is confused.

Comment on this

I certainly am, yes. I hope the Minister will be able to remove that confusion.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

This is to some extent premature. I accept that. However, it is premature in the interest of the Shannon region. I could wait until next year's Finance Bill.

Comment on this

It is not premature; it is late, actually. Might I explain why it is not premature at all?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I will not accept the Deputy's explanation because he is going to use a hypothetical argument——

Comment on this

No, it is not hypothetical. Would the Minister like me to explain it?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

——on why it did not happen on 1 January.

Comment on this

Yes, because it did not happen on 1 January and, far from being premature, it is extremely late. This interpretation should have been sewn in before the law took effect.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Again, the Deputy is showing his lack of knowledge of the situation. It is not law since 1 January. This section seeks to amend the 10 per cent scheme which applies to manufacturing industries from 1 January and to extend it to other areas—for example, mushroom cultivation in the State, ship-repairing in the State, among other things about which we are talking here.

Comment on this

This amendment will be effective from 1 January 1981?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this

So people do not know now what law they have been operating under for the last five months. So, this section is late. That is absolutely true.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

How would the Deputy argue if I did not bring in the section until next year?

Comment on this

The Minister should have brought it in last year, if he had been in his present office.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Would the Deputy not accept that the major difference between his party and mine is that we at all times try to improve existing legislation in the interest of jobs and job creation in this country? He has selected in this amendment a particularly small area, I wish it were very much bigger, but it is particularly small. We are talking about services within the confines of the Shannon region, for the most part about small service industries. This section is largely a framework for the relief to which I have referred. Changes in the interpretation of principles by the EEC will, of course, be published; but at the end of a day a certificate, with or without conditions, must be issued by the Minister for Finance. Is the Deputy saying that the strict details of how something can apply to company A should be published?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I am glad that he is not.

Comment on this

I am not concerned with individual companies.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

That seemed to be the line he was taking.

Comment on this

What I am concerned about is what are the principles, so that one can know. The Minister has not yet given the principles.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I read the principles to the Deputy.

Comment on this

I have been spending a lot of time on this, because the Minister has not been giving answers to legitimate questions.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I am afraid that the Deputy has not done his homework on the Bill.

Comment on this

The difference between the Minister and myself is that I have done my homework on the Bill and that he does not appear to have done. However, that is not my concern; it is his.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

That was not apparent last week.

Comment on this

These certificates will determine whether people can have a 10 per cent relief. Whether or not the Minister may issue certificates is not at his discretion. He is subject to principles. The Minister has told us that those principles will be contained in the existing regulations of 1975 and by way of an agreement by him with the Commission. He has not told us yet if the agreement will be published. Therefore, people will not know in advance whether they qualify. I am asking the Minister again to tell us the reason for not publishing the agreement. I am not asking him to publish details of individual negotiations relating to individual firms. It would not be fair to do that but why not publish the agreement?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I have said that any change in the interpretation will be published in the EC Official Journal. We are talking about existing companies and the initial investment aid but the Deputy is aware that these companies can avail of the export tax relief—Shannon exemption—until 1990.

Comment on this

But new companies are not included. The principles are not elucidated.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

There is a clearly defined limit of numbers for new companies and that is 50 workers. The principles refer to the initial investment and to what is the interpretation of that. Existing companies can avail of the Shannon exemption until 1990 but the details of the interpretation of the principles have to be worked out and finalised with the EEC. They will be published. The Deputy is making a song and dance of what is basically something that I would wish to see being much better. We hope that what we are doing in this regard will be an encouragement to a number of small companies in the Shannon region. I do not understand why the Deputy is making so much of this. I have given him the principles in outline and reminded him that they have been published. I told him also that some changes will need to be made in the published document of 1975 in that regard if, as we are hoping, we will be able to bring about changes in the interpretation. Any such changes will be published. Basically what are involved here are aids to services-sector industries operating in the Shannon region.

Comment on this

I understand the Minister to say now that the agreement will be published.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I have not referred to the publication of an agreement but to changes in the EEC interpretation. When I was talking about agreements I meant agreements with companies setting up.

Comment on this

The agreements will be between the Minister and the Commission and not with individual companies. I take it that new agreements relating to the interpretation of the principles will be published.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Changes agreed with the EEC in respect of the interpretation will be published.

Comment on this

Goods are defined here——

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are having a good deal of repetition.

Comment on this

——as the production of fish on fish farms and the cultivation of mushrooms which is a form of agriculture. Why has the Minister not sought to extend the 10 per cent relief in these cases to agriculture in general?

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Both of the products referred to by the Deputy were covered by the export relief that did exist. Because of that we are endeavouring to assist two areas of operation to which concessions applied under the old exports sales relief.

Comment on this

I take it that it would not be contrary to EEC rules to extend this concession to other forms of agriculture.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

To do so would be extremely difficult. As I have pointed out, the two products concerned qualify for export sales relief and will continue to so qualify until 1990. For the purposes of that scheme both products were treated in the context of manufacturing, but I take the point the Deputy is making that that could be questioned. So far as I know the term used was "closely akin to manufacturing". Because of that situation we considered ourselves justified in having the concession extended to these two areas, but the Deputy will appreciate the difficulties of extending it further. To do so would go far beyond the budgetary situation and would only add to the difficulty in having any further extension accepted.

Comment on this

The application of the 10 per cent rate to an additional sector of the economy would appear to me not to be something that could be determined to be contrary to EEC rules. If the Minister were to decide in the morning that he wished to apply the 10 per cent rate in order to retain profits in agriculture as distinct from the income taken up by the farmers — I am not asking the Minister to do this but I should like to have the matter clarified since the farming organisations are looking for this concession — would that be contrary to EEC rules? If so the farming organisations who have been seeking this 10 per cent rate would like to be made so aware.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I am not saying specifically that that is the case but such a situation could possibly be described by the EEC as amounting to aids to agriculture. However, this is a totally different area. We are not talking about bringing in sectors who are not included already in the old scheme but we are trying to accommodate within the new scheme some of those who enjoyed the benefits that applied under the old export sales scheme. I appreciate the reason for the Deputy mentioning agriculture, particularly when fish production and mushroom cultivation have been mentioned, but both these activities benefited under the old scheme.

What the Deputy is talking about involves an entirely different area because it would not be confined to agriculture. There would be the construction and many other sectors also to be considered. Apart from the question raised by the Deputy as to whether there could be problems with the EEC in respect of any such move, there is the whole question of budgetary considerations, of how taxes are imposed and so on. This would be going back to the Commission on Taxation, to what is their view on corporation tax.

Comment on this

I accept all that but I am only trying to find out whether the extension I am advocating would be contrary to EEC rules.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I am not saying that it would be contrary to EEC rules but that it could be construed as being an aid to agriculture.

Comment on this

The Minister has said that fish farming and mushroom cultivation are analagous to manufacturing. The Minister is aware that poultry and egg production and, to a large extent, pig production, are analagous to manufacturing because of the intensive nature of such production. While there might be a case for not extending this to all of agriculture, those aspects are so industrialised that there could be a case there. I can see at some future date the Minister wishing to assist those sectors by applying the 10 per cent rate to them. I should like to know if that can be done now and that is the reason I am raising this issue.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I accept that there are many other sectors. The Deputy mentioned poultry, tomatoes and so on. What we are trying to do here is to use a rear-guard action to get into this new scheme mushroom and fish-farm producing which were under the old export sales relief. The other forms of production mentioned by the Deputy were not. The Deputy can take it that there will be no objections to that development.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The next amendment is No. 12 in the name of the Minister to which Deputy Bruton has tabled two amendments. Amendment No. 13 is related. The Minister will move amendment No. 12 and following that Deputy Bruton will move his amendment. Recommittal is necessary here.

Comment on this

At what stage will we discuss No. 12 as introduced?

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We will be in Committee on these amendments and they can all be discussed together. Amendment No. 13 is related.

Comment on this