We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna — Questions. Oral Answers. - Road Traffic Accidents.

Inquiry into road traffic accidents

Summary

Andrews called for an inquiry into fatal road accidents and later asked whether accident information could be centralised; Barry said existing monitoring and published data made an inquiry unnecessary. Killilea questioned whether new arterial roads contributed to crashes, and Barry agreed to examine the claim.

asked the Minister for the Environment if he will now hold a public inquiry into the large number of road traffic accidents, many of which had fatal consequences; and if he will make a statement on the matter.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

I do not consider that the holding of an inquiry on the lines indicated by the Deputy would be necessary or appropriate. The incidence of road accidents is continuously monitored and reviewed by the Garda who investigate accidents on the spot and by the road authorities, who are concerned with road accidents. Details of the number of road deaths and injuries together with an analysis of the contributory factors involved are published on an annual basis by An Foras Forbartha. Specific research is also undertaken from time to time by An Foras and the Medical Bureau of Road Safety into particular factors which can contribute to death and injury on the roads.

All of these activities provide the basis for the formulation and implementation of traffic accident counter measures in respect of such matters as road planning and construction, the management of traffic, legislation and regulations and the promotion of road safety generally.

As the Deputy is aware, the importance of good road conditions is reflected in the objectives of the Road Development Plan, which include the elimination of accident black spots and the provision of adequate signs and markings. Regulations have been made providing for the introduction of a scheme of compulsory testing of heavy goods vehicles, buses, ambulances and taxis. In the interest of better driving standards a new driver licensing category, Class H, with appropriate test, has been introduced for articulated vehicles. I am also at present considering the views of interested parties on a proposed scheme of voluntary registration of persons giving driving instruction. I shall, further, be introducing in the near future a Bill in relation to the problem of drink and driving intended to strengthen the measures provided for dealing with this major menace on our roads. The work of the National Road Safety Association and the research activities of An Foras Forbartha will continue to receive support from my Department.

In the final analysis, however, road safety is a matter for the individual. Research has shown that the human factor contributes in nine out of every ten accidents. Legislation, engineering and enforcement measures must be accompanied by a positive response from road users themselves. Otherwise factors such as excessive speed, drinking and driving, the failure of drivers and passengers to wear safety belts, careless crossing of roads by pedestrians and their failure to make themselves more visible on the roads at night, which account for the major proportion of deaths and injuries on our roads, will continue to be reflected in our accident rates.

Comment on this

I am grateful to the Minister for that comprehensive reply and while I have no desire to under-rate the part being played in the area of road safety by the various agencies referred to by the Minister — they have been doing an excellent job — why, when so many people are being killed and injured on our roads, can the Minister not see his way to holding an inquiry, even of a limited nature, as to why we continue to behave like this on our roads?

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

I am not convinced that an inquiry would add anything to the volume of information available on road deaths, but I share totally the Deputy's concern in this regard. The carnage on our roads during the past ten years, which has resulted in more than 5,000 people dead, reflects on our individual regard for other road users. The number of people who drive with an excessive intake of alcohol is an absolute disgrace. Of the total number of convictions for drunken driving in 1980 more than 40 per cent of those convicted were shown to have had levels of alcohol that were twice the permitted levels. We do not need an inquiry to provide us with such statistics. Another factor is the number of defective vehicles on our roads. The quality of our roads, too, is not good enough, though I am not blaming anybody in particular for this situation. For generations we have neglected to make the capital investment in our roads that might help to eliminate dangerous driving though the standards of the roads are no excuse for such behaviour. In the last analysis if the individual in charge of a mechanically propelled and at times lethal weapon is not prepared to concern himself about the lives and safety of other road users, these figures will continue to come before us.

Comment on this

I appreciate the Minister's concern. While I do not hold strong feelings about an inquiry into this whole area, it seems that information in regard to accidents and so on is rather disparate.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Has the Deputy a question?

Comment on this

Yes. Is there any way of centralising the information instead of having these various bodies dealing with it?

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

I am not sure that an inquiry would alter that situation. I am prepared to do anything possible to reduce the number of road accidents but I am not convinced that holding an inquiry is the best way to deal with the problem. So far as I know most of the agencies concerned report either directly to my Department or to another body but all the information in regard to injuries and deaths on the roads is available in the Department.

Comment on this

I will pursue this matter again.

Comment on this

I agree with most of what the Minister has said but there is one aspect of this whole problem which might justify an inquiry. Would the Minister agree that most of the carnage is taking place on new roads, the main arterial roads, on which every other day we see wrecked cars and people either dead or badly injured? If this is the case it is not the lack of investment in roads but the investment we have made in them that has caused most of the damage.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

I do not have any statistics in that regard but I shall have the question examined with a view to ascertaining whether there is any substance in what the Deputy is saying.

Comment on this