We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Social Welfare Benefits.

Departmental replies and parliamentary questions

Summary

The Deputy asked whether the Department could respond faster to case inquiries, arguing that detailed facts were available before parliamentary answers. The Minister said representations received directly got the same attention, while the Chair ruled that supplementary questions on individual cases could not continue.

Arising from the Minister's detailed answers given to the last 15 or 16 questions I should like to know if, in view of the fact that a Government Deputy has had to resort to the parliamentary question procedure to get such replies, there is any way she can speed up such factual information either directly to the person concerned or to the Deputy, or representative, on the person's behalf? Obviously, the information given is factual, clear and up to date. If it is seen that a Deputy using this procedure can get replies very quickly the other 165 Deputies will adopt a similar course. Can the Minister introduce a procedure which will enable individuals, whom we are all concerned about, to get such information as has been outlined in the answers to the questions tabled by Deputy Donnellan?

Comment on this
Mary Flaherty Miss Flaherty Fine Gael

Obviously, where any decision has been made about any individual that individual is more aware than any representative of the action that has been taken. Such people are the first to know when a pension book is issued because it arrives at his or her door.

Comment on this

Some of the replies given are honest and straightforward and the factual information must have been conveyed to some of those mentioned in the questions as long ago as September, six or eight weeks ago, and surely that information could have been conveyed to the Deputy in the meantime rather than delaying the House? The Minister has told the House in some of the replies that the information was available to somebody as far back as last September. It is now 11 November.

Comment on this
Mary Flaherty Miss Flaherty Fine Gael

I am not responsible for the timing of the question or of the correspondence. I am not to know who is going to table a question or when. My responsibility is to ensure that questions are answered fully.

Comment on this

I am not arguing that point with the Minister but arising from the information that has been given to the questions mentioned I should like to know if there is any way the Minister can alter the system in her Department to give replies to representations by individuals and those who make representations on behalf of such people in a speedier manner than at present? Deputy Donnellan is entitled to put down such questions but so also are the 165 other Members and the Minister of State will be sitting here for the rest of the term answering such questions if that procedure is followed by all Members.

Comment on this

Payments are being made now and they were not being made this time last year. I was on the Opposition side a year ago and this was not happening.

Comment on this

Why are these questions down?

Comment on this
Mary Flaherty Miss Flaherty Fine Gael

The same attention and speedy response is given to representations that come direct to the Department and my office as is attempted to give here. We give the same attention to correspondence that comes directly to the office as we do to parliamentary questions.

Comment on this

Is the Minister now accepting that Deputy Donnellan, because of the unsatisfactory nature of the replies he received from the Department in relation to these problems, was forced to table these questions?

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

The Deputy did.

Comment on this

I wish to ask a supplementary.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Deputy Brady will have to move to the next question. There can be no supplementary on these questions because they all relate to individuals about whom we do not have any information.

Comment on this

Has Deputy Donnellan received any response to his representations? If so I should like to know if the response was similar to the replies read out today.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Independent

We must move on to Question No. 35.

35.

Comment on this