Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Resource Tax.
- Resource tax refunds 15 speeches
The Minister said £855,714 was refunded to 2,204 people, including interest for some taxpayers, because the Government judged the tax unfair; he noted some payments were not refundable under the Act.
Proinsias De Rossa, Alan M. Dukes, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick
- Cost of collecting and refunding tax 2 speeches
De Rossa asked how much it cost to collect and repay the tax, but the Chair ruled this a separate question.
Proinsias De Rossa, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick
asked the Minister for Finance the number of farmers to whom payments of resource tax have been remitted under section 17 of the Finance Act, 1982; and the total moneys remitted.
Comment on this
Resource tax has been refunded to a total of 2,204 persons in accordance with the provisions of section 17 of the Finance Act, 1982. The total amount refunded was £855,714.
Comment on this
That was the total amount refunded to those who had paid the tax under the provisions of the relevant Finance Act.
Comment on this
Is this all the money which the farmers paid to this tax? Have they returned all of the tax at this stage, or is there more to come?
Comment on this
There were amounts which were paid and not refunded owing to a number of provisions under the Act governing the operation of the tax itself. Indeed, included in the amount refunded was a sum of £14,643 in respect of interest which was paid to 134 taxpayers — 134 of those to whom tax refunds were made.
Comment on this
Am I to understand that the State has paid interest to the farmers for the tax paid?
Comment on this
That is correct. Those 134 were cases in which the assessments of resource tax were appealed but in which specified amounts of resource tax had been paid pending determination of the appeal. In those cases the legislation provided for a refund to be made with interest.
Comment on this
Here is a situation were people are being refunded tax which they were obliged to pay from incomes. Yet there is no provision for workers to claim back tax which they are paying and which they were legally obliged to pay. Could the Minister give any justification for the refund of tax in this case?
Comment on this
Yes. A decision was made to refund amounts of resource tax on foot of a Government decision based on the conviction that the tax in itself had been an unfair one to apply in the first place. This was subsequently borne out by events. Once that decision had been made, the Government moved on to a decision to refund the amounts which had been paid.