Ceisteanna — Questions. Oral Answers. - Mayo New National School.
- Neale school construction approval 3 speeches
The Minister said working drawings were complete and a cost plan was being prepared, but could not say when the project would proceed to contract.
Pádraig Flynn, Denis Gallagher, Donal Creed
- Procedure for grouping questions 11 speeches
Flynn challenged the practice of combining questions and asked whether questioners could object. The Chair said Ministers may group questions without the Chair’s permission, and the Chair would not limit supplementary questions on that basis.
Pádraig Flynn, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, Charles J. Haughey
- Neale school infestation report 2 speeches
Flynn asked about a health officer’s report alleging infestation at the school; the Minister had not seen it and offered to consider it if provided.
Pádraig Flynn, Donal Creed
- Neale school priority ranking 11 speeches
Flynn pressed for the school’s position on the Department’s capital priority list. The Minister confirmed a list existed but could not give the school’s ranking, inviting a written question; Flynn protested after Question Time ended.
Pádraig Flynn, Donal Creed, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick
asked the Minister for Education when approval will be given for the construction of a new national school at the Neale, Claremorris, County Mayo; and if she will make a statement on the matter.
37.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education when it is proposed to commence work on Neale national school, Claremorris, County Mayo.
Comment on this
I proposed to take Questions Nos. 36 and 37 together with your permission. It is understood from the Commissioners of Public Works that working drawings have been completed and a cost plan is being prepared for the proposed new national school at the Neale, Claremorris, County Mayo.
It is not possible to state when the project will be ready to proceed to contract.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Minister states that he proposes to take Questions Nos. 36 and 37 together and he also proposed a similar method of dealing with Questions Nos. 31 and 32.
Comment on this
He said "with your permission". What is the procedure in lumping questions together?
Comment on this
It is well established that the consent or permission of the Ceann Comhairle is not necessary to take questions together and that the Chair has no control over whether a Minister answer questions individually or groups a number of them together.
Comment on this
Is it available to the person posing the questions to ask the Minister not to lump the replies together?
Comment on this
It is open to the Deputy to do so but if the Minister proceeds otherwise nothing can be done about it.
Comment on this
You understand that this is a device being used by Ministers, not in regard to these two questions, to keep the regard to other questions, to keep the number of supplementaries to the minimum and I do not regard that as being strictly in accordance with procedure.
Comment on this
This is not a point of order and the Chair will not be influenced in regard to the number of supplementaries by whether the questions are being taken individually or together.
Comment on this
My recollection is that your predecessor circulated Ministers of the outgoing Government with the suggestion that we drop the use of the words "with your permission". Presumably you will adhere to that.
Comment on this
The Chair understands that before this occupant took the Chair a circular was sent to Departments pointing out that the consent of the Chair was not necessary. That is what I have been telling Deputy Flynn.
Comment on this
Concerning Question No. 36, is the Minister aware of the recent report by the medical health officer concerning the condition of the school in question? Would he be prepared to quote the relevant section concerning infestation of the school? Is he aware of a recent report concerning the condition of the Neale school and in particular the section which relates to the infestation of the school?
Comment on this
I am not aware of any such report. I have not got that report on my file. If the Deputy will make the information available to me I will consider it.
Comment on this
Will the Minister indicate the priority rating attached to approval for that school? I take it he has a priority list of approvals under his Vote. In what position is the Neale school on that priority list?
Comment on this
That is a separate question. I could not give the Deputy any indication as to where the school in question is on the priority list. He has made a case to me and I will have the matter examined. I could not give any more information at this stage.
Comment on this
Has the Minister a priority list for capital funding of schools in his Department at this time?
Comment on this
In that case I cannot see why he could not answer the previous question. What position does the Neale school occupy on that list?
Comment on this
The Deputy asked me where his school was on the list. I told him that at this stage I could not tell him. If he puts down a question I will reply to it. I answered the question he asked me.
Comment on this
That is not good enough. The Minister said he has a priority list and he will not indicate where the school is on that list.