Lengthy Replies at Question Time
The Ceann Comhairle cited Standing Orders suggesting lengthy answers may be unsuitable for Question Time. The Minister defended answering the questions, while Deputies sought clarification and discussed the time available for questions and the backlog.
Deputy Andrews is being disorderly and he will resume his seat. Before moving to the next question I would draw the attention of both sides of the House — and this goes for Minister too — to Standing Order 35 (2) which states:
Where a question put down for oral answer is of such a nature as to require a lengthy reply or a reply in the form of a tabular statement, the Ceann Comhairle shall, at the request of the member of the Government to whom the Question is addressed, direct that the answer be furnished in the Official Report of the Debates.
That suggests that Question Time is not suitable for a question that needs a very long reply and I know that both sides of the House appreciate that.
Comment on this
I was asked the question and I answered it. It was the subject matter of questions before the conference and it would be inappropriate for me to have answered questions about it before the conference and not answer them after the conference.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I want to find out the exact effect of what you have just said.
Comment on this
That is all right. We have had experience here from time to time of very long replies by Ministers and by the Taoiseach of the day and I do not think any of us object.
Comment on this
I drew the attention of the House to Standing Orders as an indication that those who drew up Standing Orders seemed to think that a question which needs a lot of time is not suitable for Question Time. I did so for the consideration of the House. Question No. 16.
Comment on this
I am not on the question. I refer to the matter you have raised. I would hope to be helpful by suggesting that we look back over the years when 50 or 60 questions were answered in an hour. This would be very beneficial because a long list of questions going on for months is not satisfactory to anybody.