Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Tourist Petrol Vouchers.
- Tourist Petrol Vouchers 10 speeches
Foley urged petrol vouchers to attract tourists, but the Minister said they would cost the State substantially without evidence of extra revenue; he also argued petrol prices were not a significant attraction issue. The Chair ended questions and deferred the remaining questions to tomorrow.
Denis Foley, Michael Moynihan, Pádraig Flynn, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick
- Transport for Children with Disabilities 2 speeches
Tunney sought to raise the withdrawal of school transport for two children with disabilities; the Chair said he would communicate with him.
James C. Tunney, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick
- Potato Imports Through Dundalk 2 speeches
Farrelly sought to raise the importation of a boatload of potatoes through Dundalk port; the Chair said he would communicate with him.
John V. Farrelly, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick
- Question No. 2 Adjournment Request 2 speeches
Flynn sought to raise the subject of Question No. 2 on the Order Paper; the Chair said he would communicate with him.
Pádraig Flynn, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick
- Remarks on Irish Neutrality 2 speeches
De Rossa sought to raise British Defence Minister Michael Heseltine’s remarks on Irish neutrality and the Government’s response; the Chair said he would communicate with him.
Proinsias De Rossa, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick
- Future of Scoil Íde 2 speeches
Flaherty sought to raise the future of Scoil Íde, Finglas, following a departmental decision; the Chair said he would communicate with her and reminded Members that five Private Notice Questions had been allowed.
Mary Flaherty, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick
- Nicky Kelly Private Notice Question 5 speeches
Gregory challenged the rejection of his Private Notice Question about hunger striker Nicky Kelly, asking when the situation would qualify as urgent. The Chair said the question did not meet the criteria, declined to debate the ruling, and told Gregory he was being disorderly.
Tony Gregory, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick
- Bean Uí Mhurchú Imprisonment Question 2 speeches
Fitzgerald noted that his question about the imprisonment of Bean Uí Mhurchú had also been ruled out; the Chair said he was trying to raise a disallowed question indirectly and noted that Prendergast had permission to ask a Private Notice Question.
Gene Fitzgerald, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick
asked the Minister for Trade, Commerce and Tourism if he will consider the introduction of petrol vouchers for tourists to be distributed at the points of entry to the country and through the Bord Fáilte offices throughout the country; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
Comment on this
The question of a petrol voucher scheme for tourists has been examined from time to time.
There is no evidence which would indicate that a petrol voucher scheme would, in itself, generate any significant extra tourism revenue, while the costs to the State in terms of revenue foregone would be considerable.
Comment on this
We are facing a very poor tourist season and in these circumstances would the Minister not be prepared to reconsider the decision in respect of the introduction of petrol vouchers?
Comment on this
There is no possibility of assuring the Deputy that the matter would be reconsidered. During a period of time this question has been considered and the recommendations to date are similar to earlier ones. There are a number of grounds for that situation. First, only 40 per cent of tourists use their cars here and the difficulties in implementing a petrol voucher scheme for them would be very considerable. Because of that, and having regard also to the fact that transport costs represent the least part of a tourist's budget — accommodation being the biggest part — it is not considered that the introduction of a petrol voucher scheme would create any major or even any minimum growth in Irish tourism.
Comment on this
Will the Minister indicate the average price differential between the price of petrol here and on the Continent? What does he propose to do to attract tourists by way of reducing that differential?
Comment on this
In the opinion of my Department it would not be conducive to attracting tourists to Ireland as an investigation showed that a tourist travelling 700 miles in Ireland would save only £18 on petrol as against travelling the same distance in Britain or Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
That is not the answer to my question. I take it that the Minister does not have the information available. Does he accept that the price of petrol is detrimental to encouraging motoring tourists here? Has he a scheme which would relieve the situation and so improve the tourist season which is now commencing?
Comment on this
The price of petrol is determined by factors outside the control of my Department. The Department would not consider that the introduction of petrol vouchers would be conducive to increasing the number of tourists who will come to Ireland.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying there will not be fewer tourists in Kerry this year as a result of the price of petrol?
Comment on this
I wish to raise on the Adjournment the question of the withdrawal of school transport facilities from two primary school handicapped children in my constituency.
Comment on this
I wish to raise on the Adjournment the importation of a boat load of potatoes this morning through Dundalk port.
Comment on this
I wish to raise on the Adjournment the subject matter of Question No. 2 on today's Order Paper.
Comment on this
I wish to raise on the Adjournment the recent remarks made by the British Minister for Defence, Mr. Michael Heseltine, concerning Irish neutrality and the Government's response to those remarks.
Comment on this
I should like to raise on the Adjournment the future of Scoil Íde, Finglas, in the light of a recent departmental decision.
Comment on this
I will communicate with the Deputy. I should like to draw the attention of the House to the fact that five questions have been ruled as in order for answer as Private Notice Questions. I ask Deputies to bear this in mind when asking supplementary questions.
Comment on this
I understand that you, Sir, have disallowed for the second week in a row a Private Notice Question I tabled in relation to Nicky Kelly, who is on hunger strike, on the basis that it was not urgent.
Comment on this
I have ruled that the question does not comply with the criteria laid down for Private Notice Questions. The reason for this has been conveyed to the Deputy. I cannot allow a discussion on that ruling here. The Deputy will have to find another way to raise it.
Comment on this
I am not asking for a discussion but for guidance. At what stage does a hunger strike become urgent under the criteria of Private Notice Questions? Does the health and the life of a hunger striker have to be at risk before it is considered urgent?
Comment on this
The Deputy is being a little disorderly. It is not the business of the Chair to give directions as to when something will be in order.
Comment on this
It would seem the question is too embarrassing to be answered and that is the reason why it has not been.
Comment on this
The Chair also ruled a question of mine out of order regarding the imprisonment of Bean Uí Mhurchú.