Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Rent Allowances.
- Rent allowance amounts and recipients 3 speeches
The Minister reported weekly allowances ranging from £3.40 to £35.63 and said 32 people had received allowances.
Rory O'Hanlon, Bernard Allen, Fergus O'Brien
- Publicity about rent assistance 3 speeches
Brady urged a campaign to inform elderly tenants of their rights amid confusion about rent assistance; the Minister said he would check that court forms were available and consider advertising.
Gerard Brady, Fergus O'Brien
- Scheme cost and applications 2 speeches
The Department set aside £10 million but could not estimate the scheme’s actual cost. The Minister outlined court cases processed and listed, including activity in Cork.
Bernard Allen, Fergus O'Brien
- Rejected claims and awareness 8 speeches
The Minister said 33 claims had been rejected, including cases involving dwellings not formerly rent-controlled and one means-based refusal. Deputies cited the figure as evidence of confusion about rights; the Minister said he would pursue a campaign to explain the benefits.
Vincent Brady, Fergus O'Brien, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick
- Allowance limits and means assessment 4 speeches
The Minister said there was no upper limit for qualifying recipients and none was planned. He outlined how a married couple’s means affected the rent contribution.
Máire Geoghegan-Quinn, Fergus O'Brien
- Alleged abuse of rent allowances 2 speeches
Ahern alleged the scheme was being abused and argued that pension income should be considered; the Minister said funds must be available to eligible claimants and defended erring on the side of generosity.
Bertie Ahern, Fergus O'Brien
- Rent tribunals legislation 6 speeches
Allen argued that rent tribunals would be more humane than court proceedings and asked when legislation would be ready. The Minister said it would be before the House during the next session.
Bernard Allen, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, Bertie Ahern, Fergus O'Brien
- Contact with Revenue Commissioners 1 speech
Calleary asked whether the Department was in contact with the Revenue Commissioners; no reply was recorded.
Seán Calleary
- Private agreements and rent assistance 3 speeches
Brady said tenants who made private agreements with landlords could lose access to the scheme through ignorance or fear of court, and asked that they be included. The Minister said tenants who made verbal agreements could return to the scheme.
Gerard Brady, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, Fergus O'Brien
asked the Minister for Social Welfare the amount of the highest and lowest allowance paid by his Department under the Housing (Private Rented Dwellings) Act, 1982.
25.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Social Welfare the number of persons who received allowances from his Department as a result of being subjected to very substantial rent increases under the Housing (Private Rented Dwellings) Act, 1982.
Comment on this
I propose to take Question Nos. 24 and 25 together.
The amount of the highest and lowest weekly rent allowance paid by my Department to date are £35.63 and £3.40, respectively.
The number of persons to whom rent allowances have been granted is 32.
Comment on this
I had to wait a long time for the information which I sought earlier. Would the Minister not agree, in the light of the information which he has just now given the House, that this would confirm the view that there is widespread confusion over the operation of this rent assistance? Would he give consideration to engaging in some way in a publicity campaign to alert elderly people of their rights in this respect? That would go a long way towards alleviating the dreaded fear which elderly people are experiencing at the moment. As a Dubliner, the Minister must be aware of that.
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy that we should do everything possible. I have suggested that in the courts where these cases are heard the relevant notices and forms be readily available. I will have it checked that that has been done and will also consider — and believe it is necessary — an advertising campaign. The Deputy in his opening remarks indicated that at least I had answered the question. I might add that the question has just now been put down for answer.
Comment on this
Could the Minister tell me the estimated cost to the State this year in implementing the scheme and the number of people who have applied under the scheme?
Comment on this
We cannot estimate the actual cost. We have put aside £10 million to meet any contingency in that area. We believe that that will be adequate to cover the amount. To date approximately 500 cases have been dealt with through the courts. That is at the rate of about 70 per week. A further 1,500 cases have been listed for hearing by the end of September.
For the rest of the country, rent cases are normally dealt with under District Court procedure and we have very few of them, except in Cork where about 40 cases a week are now being processed.
Comment on this
How many applications have, in fact, been rejected by the Minister's Department for assistance under this scheme?
Comment on this
Six claims have been disallowed as the dwellings were not formerly rent-controlled and one because of means.
Comment on this
Does that not indicate that people are not aware of their rights and of the facilities that are available?
Comment on this
As I have said, we are doing our best to mount a campaign to ensure that the situation is being dealt with properly and to make people aware of the benefits that are available. Perhaps people are aware of the situation but there appears to be general confusion about it.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that large amounts are being awarded by the courts on the assumption that Social Welfare will pay the difference between the existing rent and the new one? Have the Department placed an upper limit on the amount they will pay and, if not, is it the intention to introduce an upper limit?
Comment on this
Once a person qualifies, there is no upper limit and there are no proposals to have an upper limit. I cannot assume what impression the court might have in regard to what Social Welfare would pay.
Comment on this
How do the Department calculate the means? How much is allowed before one can qualify?
Comment on this
In the case of a married couple with means of up to £70, the rent would be £3.50. For the next £10 it would be 50p and thereafter pound for pound.
Comment on this
Would the Minister accept that the upper limit would rule out many people who, in addition to receiving old age pensions, are in receipt of, say, Department of Posts and Telegraphs pension or some other civil service pension? The amount allocated this year in this respect is probably far too much. The scheme is being totally abused and is feathering the nests of certain sections of the community who are abusing the legislation. The Minister should use his position to put an end to that abuse. The interested people in this city, and I do not have to name them, will co-operate to ensure that the £10 million is used. This is a scandal and is totally discriminatory so far as old people are concerned. The Minister should cut down that £10 million and bring the scheme back into the Fair Rents Tribunal in order to avoid filling the pockets of people who do not deserve this money.
Comment on this
We must make money available but we cannot mandate the courts to take certain action. These institutions, as the Deputy knows, are very independent. All we can do is ensure that moneys are available for people who are entitled to claim welfare allowances. The Deputy says we have allocated too much but in a case like this it is better to err on the side of being generous. Normally the complaints from the other side of the House are to the effect that we are not allocating enough.
Comment on this
Has the Minister been in touch with the Department of the Environment on the question of rents tribunals? I ask the question because the rents tribunals would take the whole issue out of the courts system and would be a far more humane system whereby information could be passed on to the people who are being subjected to treatment that they should not be subjected to. When can we expect the legislation in that regard to be ready?
Comment on this
It would result in the saving of a lot of money by the Department of Social Welfare.
Comment on this
The Minister indicated here that the legislation would be before the House during the next session.
Comment on this
Are the Department of Social Welfare in touch with the Revenue Commissioners about this?
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that very many tenants have entered into private agreements with landlords thus invalidating their legal right to avail of appearing in court? This has happened through ignorance on their part and through fear of the courts. If the Minister is aware of this situation, will he use his good offices to in some way extend the scheme to enable such people to avail of the benefit being offered?