Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - EEC School Milk Scheme.
- School milk scheme uptake 4 speeches
The Minister said participation is voluntary, with subsidised milk reaching over 40% of the potential market, and promotion led by the National Dairy Council. He agreed uptake was low but said schools and teachers must choose to participate.
Colm M. Hilliard, Austin Deasy
- Water contamination in supplied milk 12 speeches
Leyden cited a Galway public analyst’s report that 1.35% of milk was affected by water and urged an investigation. The Chair said the matter had already been discussed; the Minister noted it had been raised previously and answered in detail.
Terry Leyden, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, Austin Deasy, A Deputy, Michael J. Noonan
- School milk scheme participation and promotion 35 speeches
Deputies asked about the subsidy and why some children and schools did not participate, citing limited school enthusiasm and distribution difficulties in smaller rural schools. The Minister agreed there were deficiencies and undertook to involve his Department, Education, and the National Dairy Council in improving the scheme, including its promotion and availability; he also agreed to consider flavoured milk. The Chair moved on before another question was taken.
Michael J. Noonan, Austin Deasy, Seamus Brennan, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, Seán Byrne
asked the Minister for Agriculture if he is satisfied that the EEC school milk scheme is being fully availed of; if not, if he intends to improve the implementation of the scheme; the present consumption in schools; and its percentage of the projected total.
Comment on this
This is a voluntary scheme and schools cannot be compelled to use it. Increased participation depends largely on the efforts of dairies to induce schools to take part and in this connection the National Dairy Council is active in promoting the scheme.
In 1983 up to mid-June subsidy was paid on 1.37 million gallons of milk supplied to schools. This represents over 40 per cent of the potential market.
Comment on this
Will the Minister advise his officials that teachers can play a vital role in increasing the sale of dairy products through the schools? The fact that the Minister states that only 40 per cent of the potential sales is being sold at the moment invites a criticism of the Department. The Minister says that it is not his Department's function, but I understand that his Department would have some part to play in this.
Comment on this
The National Dairy Council are the people who are promoting the scheme. As I say, it is a voluntary scheme, but certainly 40 per cent is very low, considering the benefits which accrue from it. It is purely up to the schools and the teachers to avail of this benefit.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware of a report by the public analyst in Galway in relation to the milk which was supplied in certain areas?
Comment on this
That appears to be another question. That was asked about here and discussed at length.
Comment on this
The report states that 1.35 per cent was affected by water. If the Minister's Department are paying for the milk, I would advise him to investigate the circumstances under which 1.35 per cent of the milk was mixed——
Comment on this
Deputy, that is obviously a separate question which was thrashed out at considerable length here the other day. Deputy Noonan.
Comment on this
I might point out that the Deputy's constituency colleague, Deputy Naughten, raised this matter last week.
Comment on this
(Limerick West): Could I ask the Minister the amount of the subsidy on the milk supplies, if he has that information in his brief?
Comment on this
The amount of the subsidy is not mentioned. I think it is in the region of 15p per pint.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying that 40 per cent of schoolchildren are availing of this scheme?
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware of the large number of schoolchildren, particularly in the Dublin area, who are anxious to avail of this scheme but because of the lack of enthusiasm on the part of the particular school they are not availing of it? Could I further ask if the Minister is aware that there are many young children in these schools who are suffering from embarrassment because of this? Will he examine the position urgently because I suspect that a large number of Dublin children want to avail of the scheme but because perhaps they are in a minority in the school they are not able to?
Comment on this
I certainly agree with the Deputy that there is a lack of enthusiasm in certain schools to avail of the scheme. This is depriving children of this subsidised milk. I will get my Department to take up the matter with the schools and, in particular, get the National Dairy Council to do so.
Comment on this
In the interest of Deputies who have questions put down which will come up later on, we should pass on.
Comment on this
Just one point. The Minister is saying that only 40 per cent of the schools avail of this scheme, which is sad. Would he appeal to the Ministers for Education and Health to help in this matter? It is a matter of education and advice as to the value of milk to young children.
Comment on this
As this whole scheme appears not to be properly advertised —and the fact that only 40 per cent avail of it indicates that—the Minister should be serious about trying to increase the sale of dairy products here at a time when the EEC are telling farmers to cut back.
Comment on this
I understand that many parents, children and teachers are not aware of the variety of products which they can get under this scheme. It is not just applicable to milk alone but to yogurt and to cheese. Is the Minister aware of this?
Comment on this
I will take up the point that has been mentioned by Deputy Hilliard, Deputy Byrne and the other Deputies, to see that not just my own Department but the National Dairy Council and the Department of Education will become involved.
Comment on this
No, Deputy. I call Deputy Calleary and the Deputies should, in their own interest, let us pass to the other questions. Look at the time. Only four questions have been reached.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that perhaps one of the reasons for the figure being as low as 40 per cent is that many rural schools, particularly the smaller ones, consider the distribution to be excessive. That is the reason, certainly in some of the western counties, why this scheme is not in operation.
Comment on this
That is a separate question. However, I can tell Deputy Calleary that there are obviously many deficiencies in the operation of the scheme. They will have to be re-examined by a number of agencies and Departments.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not make inquiries about flavoured milk being made available under this scheme, as children have a preference for flavoured milk?
Comment on this
Would the Minister make some of his staff available to visit some schools to talk to the teachers, stressing the importance of educating the children to drink milk and telling them how important it is for the good of their health?
Comment on this
This has been a very interesting Second Stage debate. I assure the Deputies that I will get my Department, the Department of Education and the National Dairy Council together to see if they can improve the working of the scheme.