Ceisteanna: Questions. Oral Answers. - Use of Native Timber.
- Promoting Native Timber Use 4 speeches
The Minister cited research, training and import-substitution efforts to promote Irish timber. He said production is expected to rise substantially and that policy is under review as output grows.
Brendan Daly, Patrick O'Toole
- Forestry Management and Inventory 4 speeches
Daly questioned forestry management and the delayed inventory; the Minister expressed confidence in staff and said timber supply is constrained by natural production limits and strong demand.
Brendan Daly, Patrick O'Toole
- Sale of Available Timber 4 speeches
Daly challenged the Minister’s claim that available timber had been sold, and the Minister maintained that it had.
Brendan Daly, Patrick O'Toole
- Timber Tendering and Supply 10 speeches
Wilson and Mac Giolla criticised the tendering system as slow and outdated and asked about alternatives. The Minister said State disposal rules currently require tendering, but a quota system had been added and a committee was reviewing ways to improve marketing and secure longer-term supplies.
John P. Wilson, Patrick O'Toole, Tomás MacGiolla
- Linking Timber Prices to International Rates 3 speeches
Daly argued that domestic timber prices should track international prices to compete with imports. The Minister said differing inflation and production costs make index-linking difficult; the Chair then deferred remaining questions.
Brendan Daly, Patrick O'Toole, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick
asked the Minister for Fisheries and Forestry the efforts he is making to promote the use of native Irish timber; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
Comment on this
The efforts being made to promote the use of Irish timber include:—
—An on-going research programme, undertaken by the IIRS and funded by my Department, into various aspects of timber technology;
—a variety of courses and seminars organised by the IIRS with my Department's support and encouragement aimed at improving the grading and handling of Irish timber in the interests of higher production standards;
—the steps being taken by the Department of the Environment, which has overall responsibility for import substitution in the context of building materials, to increase the use of Irish timber in local authority construction projects.
The overall objective is to bring about a greater awareness and acceptance of Irish timber in the market place and, judging by the increasing pressure on my Department for supplies of raw material, I am glad to say that the promotional efforts in train are proving very effective.
Comment on this
The Minister is aware that wood production is estimated to double within the next ten years and probably increase substantially after that. Is the Minister satisfied that all reasonable effort is being made and will continue to be undertaken to ensure that the maximum benefit is derived from that wood production? Is he also satisfied that the number of people employed in forestry and associated industries can be significantly increased from their present 6,000 to 10,000 up to 30,000 to 50,000 over the next 15 years? Is he satisfied that with the existing policy these results can be obtained?
Comment on this
The Deputy must be aware that any Minister in a Department where a development like this is taking place must at all times be ready to review the current operation, and that is ongoing, especially in the context of our knowledge of what will happen over the next ten years. I point out, for the benefit of the House, that our current production is approximately 1 million cubic metres per annum which by 1990 will be 1.7 million cubic metres and by the end of this century 3.3 million cubic metres. Operations are in train and the current position is kept under review to take account of that expanding volume of timber which will be coming on stream.
Comment on this
The Minister has already said here today that decisions have been taken and implemented which will determine the size of our timber products for the next ten to 20 years. Is the Minister satisfied with the whole management of forestry and that the proper decisions have been taken by the management in this area? There is also this inventory which was promised so long ago.
Comment on this
I am quite satisfied with the handling of the current position by my staff in the forests. The Deputy implies that there is something wrong somewhere.
Comment on this
The reason that there may seem to be something wrong is that the demand far outstrips supply of timatio ber, of its very nature, depends on nature and we cannot push that too far.
Comment on this
I can understand how the supply cannot meet the demand at present, but at the same time the Minister says that we have not been able to sell the available timber.
Comment on this
Arising from the Minister's reference to pressure for supplies, would he not agree that the system of inviting tenders from processors, sawmill owners and so on is primitive, antiquated and totally unsatisfactory?
Comment on this
I am surprised at the Deputy. Whether he knows it or not, he is quoting a certain gentleman in this country who made an attack on the Department a few weeks back.
Comment on this
The Deputy must know that we are talking here about a State asset and its disposal. Traditional regulations in relation to the disposal by the State of its assets have long been laid down and they cover all Departments. Until such time as that is changed by Government decision, this approach must be complied with. Indeed, we have taken steps to improve, hopefully, the tendering system somewhat in that also, side by side with tendering, we will have a quota system which guarantees supplies.
Comment on this
This is based on the preceding year's consumption. Before the Deputy came into the Chamber I indicated that at the moment an inter-departmental committee, which I established a few months ago, is about to report. They specifically zoned in on this problem of marketing and on how we can speed up the supply of timber and arrange for processors to take a more long-term approach to the processing end of the business. That report will be available to me shortly and I would hope it would improve matters.
Comment on this
Deputy Wilson has raised the question of tendering. Is the Minister saying that because that system has been there for 60 years or so it cannot be changed? Has the Minister any ideas on any system different from the tendering system which would allow, as Deputy Molony mentioned, private interests to get the type of supply they want?
Comment on this
I have just said for the second time and I will now say for the third time that I am pointing to a system which has been in situ down through the years. I am not averse to changing that system for the better and, to that end, an inter-departmental committee will be reporting to me in a matter of weeks. Obviously I have not seen the report yet, but I hope it will suggest something which will be an improvement on the present system.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware of the difficulty in the way the system operates? Is it not important that the price of timber here should be index-linked to the international timber price so that timber prices here can compete favourably with international timber prices? It is cheaper to import timber and, unless we can index-link our prices with international prices, that will continue to be the case.
Comment on this
I am sure the Deputy is aware of the difficulties in index-linked pricing especially in relation to timber. The theory of index-linking would be fine if the same level of inflation and production costs applied across the board. As the Deputy is aware, that is not the case, and thereby hangs the difficulty in the index-linking approach. That is the problem.