Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Bronchial Asthma Drugs.
- Asthma drugs under long-term illness scheme 9 speeches
Dr. O’Hanlon asked about covering asthma medicines and their cost for people without medical cards. The Minister said inclusion was under review but unaffordable with current resources; families could seek refunds for monthly medicine costs above £23.
Rory O'Hanlon, Barry Desmond, Seán McCarthy, Mary Flaherty, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick
- Medical card discretion and eligibility 11 speeches
Dr. McCarthy sought greater health-board discretion and quicker responses on special-circumstances medical card applications. The Minister cited a recent review of eligibility criteria and said boards had considerable leeway; the Ceann Comhairle curtailed further discussion.
Seán McCarthy, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, Barry Desmond, Mary Flaherty
- Additions to the prescribed illness list 3 speeches
Miss Flaherty asked when an illness was last added to the prescribed list, and the Minister promised to respond. Dr. McCarthy renewed his request to include bronchial asthma.
Mary Flaherty, Barry Desmond, Seán McCarthy
asked the Minister for Health if he will include drugs for bronchial asthma in the list of drugs available under the long-term illness scheme for children under 16 years.
14.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Health the estimated cost of making prescribed inhaled drugs or their oral equivalents available free of charge at chemist shops for those who are not holders of medical cards and who suffer from bronchial asthma.
Comment on this
I propose to take Questions Nos. 13 and 14 together.
The inclusion of asthma in the prescribed list of conditions covered by the long-term illness scheme is under constant review in my Department. This would provide drugs free of charge to children and adults not covered by medical cards. It is estimated that there are some 60,000 persons in this category. Because their needs very considerably, it is impossible to give an accurate statement of cost.
At present persons whose expenditure on a month's supply of medicine exceeds £23 may recover the balance over that amount from the health boards. If only a quarter of asthma patients regularly expend that amount, the yearly cost of supplying them would exceed £4 million. The cost of supplying the others could be of the order of £3 millions, giving a total estimated cost of £7 million. Unfortunately, the present financial circumstances do not permit the expansion of the scheme on that scale.
Comment on this
The Minister has stated that the inclusion of asthma in the prescribed list of conditions covered by the long-term illness scheme is under constant review in his Department. When is he likely to make a decision on allowing this to be categorised as a long-term illness? I have no doubt he is aware that many children under 16 years of age have very severe bronchial asthma which, without wanting to sound alarmist, can be a life-threatening illness. It is essential for them to have the necessary medications available but many cannot afford them because of the very high cost of these preparations.
Comment on this
The question of including asthma in the list of prescribed illnesses is regularly before us. As the Deputy is aware, asthma is probably the major condition which is not covered by the scheme. Lest the Deputy should be under any illusions, however, the cost involved is considerable and I do not have any money — nor am I likely to have any in 1984 — for extending the scheme. A very large number of people suffer from asthma and the cost of catering for it would be very considerable.
Comment on this
When was the last addition made to the list of prescribed illnesses? The average cost of medication for one asthmatic child, without any complications, is between £20 and £30 a month for inhalers, etc. This falls just under the limit beyond which one can apply for refunds so that the family——
Comment on this
——who are caught with that regular expense have no leeway if they are slightly over the limit. Would the Minister see what can be done for low income families under the special hardship provisions in the Department to give some relief to families who are marginally over the limit?
Comment on this
The position is that 39 per cent of the population are covered by medical cards. I would have great difficulty on the basis of existing resources available to me in including asthma and its associated illness, bronchitis, in the scheme. It will certainly not be this year and it is most unlikely to be next year either.
Comment on this
In view of the seriousness of bronchial asthma, which has killed many people, will the Minister allow more flexibility to members of health boards to exercise their discretion in allowing medical cards to be supplied to patients under special circumstances? These special circumstances forms are sent to many applicants for medical cards and are filled in appropriately by patients and their doctors but it seems to take a long time before any response is obtained from the board.
Comment on this
I was trying to help the Minister. Undoubtedly those who are just over the medical card income limit, the lower middle class, are the new poor.
Comment on this
There has been a major review of the situation in regard to eligibility criteria, the result of which was presented to us recently. It was because of Deputies Mac Giolla and De Rossa having raised the question of major regional disparities in eligibility criteria that I decided to have that review undertaken.
Comment on this
There is considerable leeway available to the health boards in respect of granting medical cards in exceptional cases. I have known the boards to be quite generous, so much so that nearly four out of every ten people now have medical cards. This represents an increase of from 35 to 38 per cent.
Comment on this
We must not spend any more time on this question. There are Deputies who have been sitting here all during Question Time but whose questions have not been reached.
Comment on this
We are not talking about medical cards now. I am calling Question No. 15. It is most unfair to other Deputies that a few should hog Question Time.
Comment on this
That is so, but the Deputy is capable of asking a very long question when she is called.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say when was the last occasion on which there was an addition to the prescribed list and, if so, what was the illness involved?
Comment on this
I will communicate with the Deputy on the matter. There is a large number of illnesses covered.