Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Hormones in Meat.
- Hormone Use in Meat 12 speeches
The Minister acknowledged concerns about hormone misuse despite tests finding no excessive residues, and proposed tighter controls on availability, administration, withdrawal periods and abattoir testing. He hoped to introduce regulations in January and would examine abattoir legislation; he had discussed hormones with the Health Minister but not the reported cancer link.
Seamus Brennan, Austin Deasy, Michael P. Kitt
- Unlicensed Pork Butchers 2 speeches
A Deputy asked whether the Minister would legislate over pigs being slaughtered by unlicensed pork butchers. The Minister acknowledged that regulations were not being followed.
Ned O'Keeffe, Austin Deasy
asked the Minister for Agriculture the proposals he has to control the excessive use of hormones in meat for human consumption.
Comment on this
The results of tests undertaken on behalf of my Department do not show evidence of excessive residues of hormonal substances in meat for human consumption. To ensure that these substances are used responsibly in livestock production I propose to introduce the following measures: tighter controls on availability of hormones; rules on how, by whom and to what species of animal such substances might be administered; systems to facilitate checking that withdrawal periods for hormones have been observed; power for veterinary examiners in abattoirs and slaughterhouses to examine and test for hormone residues and to reject animals and carcases where such residues are present.
Consultations with the various farming, veterinary manufacturing and trade interests on my proposals are currently being conducted and I hope to have the new measures in force as early as possible in the new year.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that the new measures which he announced will control the problem which the Minister seems to think does not exist?
Comment on this
I do not know where the Deputy got that idea. I would be the last to deny that there is a problem in this area. Of course there is a problem and I have said so publicly on several occasions in the last few months, as long as six months ago when Deputy Shatter raised the matter initially. We must be vigilant because our whole export trade and indeed our home trade could be affected and I am determined to see that any abuses which exist are eliminated.
I shall outline some of the measures which I intend to take regarding the availability and uses of hormones. The appropriate regulations would be under (a) the Animal Remedies Act, 1956, (b) the Poisons Act, 1961, (c) the Agricultural Produce (Fresh Meat) Act, 1930, and the Pigs and Bacon Acts. Regulations under (a) will update existing prescription only controls and extend them to include all hormonal growth promoters. Regulations under (b) will prohibit the use of hormonal growth promoters in all food animals except bovines and will stipulate appropriate conditions for use. The administration of hormones will be confined to veterinary officers in accordance with a veterinary prescription or to persons known to and nominated by a veterinary officer. Cattle identification cards will be endorsed with the name of the substance used and the date on which the withdrawal period will expire. A veterinary officer may not issue a prescription if the ID cards are not presented to him. The sale for slaughter of an animal for which a withdrawal period has not elapsed will be an offence, as will the sale of meat which contains residues.
Comment on this
I wish to thank the Minister for his very comprehensive reply. Considering that there were no less than four Acts involved, including the Local Authorities (Local Government) Acts governing the area of abattoirs, which the Minister did not mention, will the Minister assure me that they will come before the House for discussion soon?
Comment on this
I intend to introduce these regulations in January and I am not sure if they can be discussed at that stage.
Comment on this
Yes, but the Department of Health and the Department of the Environment have functions in this matter also although I have primary control.
Comment on this
Has the Minister had any discussions with the Minister for Health concerning the report that there was a link between these growth hormones and cancer?
Comment on this
I have had no communication with the Minister for Health in that regard. I discussed the matter with him but that question did not arise.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that pigs are being slaughtered by unlicensed pork butchers and will he bring in legislation to protect that section of the community?