Ceisteanna — Questions. Oral Answers. - Examination of Animal Specimens.
- Ballydine animal specimen tests 4 speeches
Tests on specimens from three farms showed no exceptional animal health problem so far; extensive analyses were also sent to laboratories in the United States and Sweden. Mac Giolla questioned whether the methods tested for toxins and solvent damage.
Tomás MacGiolla, Austin Deasy
- Taoiseach's view of the Kavanagh inquiry 8 speeches
Byrne asked why the Taoiseach was dissatisfied with Minister Kavanagh’s inquiry and sought to dispel uncertainty affecting South Tipperary and Merck, Sharp and Dohme. The Chair ruled the newspaper controversy outside the question, and Deasy declined to comment.
Seán Byrne, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, Austin Deasy
- Further results from Ballydine tests 12 speeches
Deasy confirmed that animals on all three farms were tested and that no further complaints had been reported. About 97 per cent of the results were complete, with no abnormal health conditions or chemical residues found; remaining results were expected within two weeks, while detailed tests for blood-cell or bone-marrow effects were not available to him.
Tomás MacGiolla, Austin Deasy, Michael J. Noonan, Brendan Griffin, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick
asked the Minister for Agriculture if his Department have yet had any results from examination of specimens taken from animals on three farms at Ballydine, County Tipperary; if so, the results of the examination; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
Comment on this
Most of the tests and analyses on the specimens referred to taken from animals at Ballydine, County Tipperary, on 15 September last have been completed. The results so far received have given no indications of any exceptional animal health problem in the animals from which the specimens were taken.
Comment on this
What precisely was looked for in these tests? Were they looking for the existence of toxins, solvents or solvent damage? Is the Minister aware that the way tests are carried out could have different effects? This means that two different methods of testing the same samples could have different effects.
Comment on this
I am not an expert on the points raised by the Deputy, but I can tell him that the tests carried out were extremely exhaustive and extensive. Where the State was not certain that the tests and analyses could be carried out at the State Laboratory, the relevant tests were carried out in the United States and Sweden.
Comment on this
I would like the Minister to tell me why the Taoiseach was not satisfied with the inquiry carried out by the Minister, Deputy Kavanagh?
Comment on this
Why is there some uncertainty about this? It is very necessary that this element of doubt be removed for everybody's sake, for the future industrial development of South Tipperary and for the good name of the firm Merck, Sharp and Dohme (Ireland) Limited who are providing very valuable employment in South Tipperary. I am not too happy about the controversy in the Sunday papers——
Comment on this
The question posed by the Deputy refers to an article in a Sunday newspaper and I will not refer to the question——
Comment on this
Were the tests carried out on animals from only one farm or a number of farms and how many animals were involved?
Comment on this
In his question the Deputy referred to three farms. He was quite correct. There were three farms involved. The animals from three farms were involved.
Comment on this
(Limerick West): Is the Minister aware that the tests carried out are conclusive? Would he inform the House if there is any need for further examinations being carried out? Is he satisfied that as a result of the tests which have been carried out no further action will be needed?
Comment on this
I am not saying no further action will be needed because my Department and the other Departments involved in the investigation will have to consider the results which have not been completely evaluated yet. Because some of the tests had to be carried out in the United States and Sweden it has taken a considerable time to get the full results of those tests, but no abnormal health conditions were disclosed and no chemical residues were detected. I am told that the results are about 97 per cent complete.
Comment on this
As a Deputy from South Tipperary — Merck, Sharp and Dohme are in my constituency — I am pleased to learn that as a result of the exhaustive tests carried out there is no danger to the health of my constituents.
Comment on this
The Minister indicated that 97 per cent of the investigation and been carried out to date. When does he expect the final report?
Comment on this
We expect to have the results from the remainder of the tests within the next two weeks.
Comment on this
In the investigations did the officials look for red cell destruction or bone marrow dysfunction?