Calls to reopen disputed convictions
Gregory asks whether the Minister supports Cardinal Ó Fiaich’s call to reopen cases including the Birmingham Six, Guildford Four and Annie Maguire. O’Keeffe declines to discuss individual cases and says he has not seen the full statement; he offers to study a copy. The Ceann Comhairle rules that questions about innocence fall outside the original question on prisoner transfers.
Does the Minister support the statement of Cardinal Ó Fiaich of 25 April last that the cases of Irish prisoners known as the Birmingham six, the Guildford four and that of Mrs. Annie Maguire, all of whom consistently claim to be innocent, should now be re-opened? Does the Minister support Cardinal Ó Fiaich's statement in this regard?
Comment on this
Here the Deputy is raising specific instances. What I must say is that the Government have made representations to the British authorities on behalf of certain prisoners requesting transfer when it was adjudged that there were convincing reasons justifying such requests. But it would not be appropriate in the interests of those concerned to give details of any of the individual cases which have been raised. It would be entirely in appropriate to do so and indeed not helpful to the cases that have been made on behalf of those individuals.
Comment on this
One final supplementary by way of clarification. The Minister may have misunderstood my last question. There are two aspects to Cardinal Ó Fiaich's statement, the first being that Irish prisoners should be repatriated. The second aspect was that in the cases of specific prisoners who claim to be innocent of the crimes of which they were convicted Cardinal Ó Fiaich is very concerned that the cases of 11 in particular should now be re-opened because of the lack of evidence in relation to their convictions——
Comment on this
The Chair is pointing out to Deputy Gregory that that is another question and does not arise under the question on the Order Paper today. The question on the Order Paper deals with the transfer of prisoners from Britain to Ireland to serve their sentences and does not raise any questions about their innocence or otherwise.
Comment on this
I have not seen the statement in its entirety. I presume the Deputy is referring to the statement which was reported in The Irish Times of 27 April last?
Comment on this
I would point out that there was a correction published in The Irish Times of 30 April last in relation to part of that statement, so the entire statement is not available to me. On that basis it would not be proper for me——
Comment on this
If I get a copy of Cardinal Ó Fiaich's statement, will the Minister let me know if he supports it?