Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Independent Local Radio.
- Proposed local radio authority 9 speeches
Leyden asked about the proposed authority and local radio plans. Mitchell said legislation was needed before details could be settled, with Cork intended as headquarters and no premises yet acquired.
Terry Leyden, Tomás MacGiolla, Jim Mitchell, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick
- Delay in radio legislation 4 speeches
Leyden asked why the legislation had been delayed; Mitchell cited lengthy consideration by the legislation committee.
Terry Leyden, Jim Mitchell, Ray Burke
- Potential number of radio stations 4 speeches
Mitchell clarified that the frequency spectrum could technically support about 30 stations, but that this did not mean 30 would be established; additional frequencies would increase technical capacity.
Terry Leyden, Jim Mitchell, John P. Wilson
- Authority establishment costs 2 speeches
Mitchell said cost estimates had been prepared, but costs depended on the legislation and its timing.
Terry Leyden, Jim Mitchell
- Authority premises in Cork 2 speeches
Leyden urged the Department to identify premises in Cork; Mitchell said it would take timely steps to ensure the Authority could function promptly.
Terry Leyden, Jim Mitchell
- Progress on radio legislation 2 speeches
MacSharry asked about the Bill’s heads; Mitchell said the Government had nearly completed consideration of the Bill and expected to announce progress shortly.
Raymond MacSharry, Jim Mitchell
- Expected number of stations 2 speeches
Asked how many stations he envisaged, Mitchell said that decision should be left to the Independent Local Radio Authority.
Albert Reynolds, Jim Mitchell
- Community stations and licensing guidelines 9 speeches
Reynolds challenged the Minister on commercial and community stations and how they would be licensed. Mitchell said different kinds of stations might emerge, but legislation would not dictate their number; Government consideration was nearly complete.
Albert Reynolds, Jim Mitchell, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, John P. Wilson
- Radio na Gaeltachta independence 5 speeches
Gallagher asked whether Radio na Gaeltachta’s independence would be protected; Mitchell said it was a separate question, which received no substantive answer here.
Denis Gallagher, Jim Mitchell, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, Terry Leyden
- Illegal local radio stations 8 speeches
Allen asked how existing illegal stations would be handled, and Mitchell said legislation would both provide for legal local radio and phase out illegal stations. Leyden sought clarification on whether they could apply for licences; Mitchell reiterated the phase-out policy, amid a brief pirate-themed quip.
Bernard Allen, John P. Wilson, Jim Mitchell, Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, Terry Leyden
asked the Minister for Communications when the proposed Independent Local Radio Authority will be in operation and in a position to issue licences.
8.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Communications the estimated cost of establishing the Independent Local Radio Authority; the estimated annual cost; and if he has included this cost in estimates for 1985.
9.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Communications if his Department have obtained premises for the Independent Local Radio Authority; the location of these premises; and the cost of rental or purchase.
10.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Communications if he will estimate the total number of independent local radio stations to be established under proposed legislation.
11.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Communications if he will approve the establishment of an independent local radio news and sports service to cater for independent local radio stations.
12.
Comment on this
asked the Minisster for Communications if his plans for local radio will allow local authorities to apply for licences to the Independent Local Radio Authority.
Comment on this
I propose to take Questions Nos. 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12 together.
It would not be appropriate, in advance of legislation, to make provision in the Estimates for an independent authority but the Deputy will appreciate that this would not prevent the Authority from being established in the current year. Neither have premises been acquired. As I indicated some time ago my intention is that the Authority's headquarters should be in Cork, but it will be a matter for the Authority to acquire whatever premises they need.
As many of the Deputies' questions anticipate the legislation about to be introduced, it would be better to wait until the legislation is before the House before I answer these questions.
Comment on this
Could I ask the Minister the reason for the long delay in bringing forward this legislation? I would remind the Minister that he has been in that office for the last two and a half years and in that time this legislation has not been brought forward. Could I ask the background for this long delay?
Comment on this
As the Deputy will appreciate, there have been great difficulties about this legislation.
Comment on this
One of the main difficulties is that it went before the legislation committee and took much longer than anticipated. That delayed the process by at least eight months.
Comment on this
In relation to the number of stations, the Minister is on record as saying that seven stations would be adequate. The Minister has had quite some mileage, newspaperwise, on this whole issue, without giving any factual statement at all. Could he indicate if the statement of the Minister of State, Deputy Nealon, as reported in the national newspapers, in relation to 30 stations would be in line with the Minister's statements that he is in favour of seven stations? Could he give some indication of the number of stations that he anticipates?
Comment on this
I would be happy to clarify the position for the Deputy. The Minister of State at my Department, in answer to a question from the legislative committee, said then that the frequency spectrum technically could carry about 30 stations of different orders of magnitude. A misunderstanding got abroad from that that what the Minister of State said was that there would be 30 stations. Subsequently, in order to clarify the position I said that while the frequency spectrum could carry up to 30 stations, if we went by the IBA standards in Britain the figure would be rather less.
Comment on this
There are all sorts of criteria, including the listenership criteria. For the information of the House, because of negotiations that have been more or less brought to a conclusion, the frequency spectrum available would be much larger. We will now have five national VHF networks available to us, compared with three hitherto. We will also have other regional VHF networks available to us. The technical possibilities for the number of stations will be greatly increased.
Comment on this
The Minister has stated that he is not in a position to include this in the 1985 Estimate because the legislation has not been passed by the Dáil and I accept that. Would this require a Supplementary Estimate for his Department and will he indicate if he has made some estimates? He has studied the matter for the last two and a half years and I feel sure that his advisers and his Department have advised him of the estimated cost to the Department of setting up stations or organising the Independent Local Radio Authority.
Comment on this
Of course, some exercises have been done on possible costs, but I cannot anticipate legislation yet to be enacted by this and the other House. The costs that would be involved depend very much on the outcome of that legislation and the time element.
Comment on this
It is proposed to locate the Independent Local Radio Authority in Cork. This is naturally welcomed by the Cork Deputies, but is a very small replacement for Ford's, Dunlop's and the other major factories which have been closed. Nevertheless since it will be located in Cork, would the Minister not think it appropriate, in view of the urgency of the legislation, that his Department could be in a position to have earmarked suitable premises for leasing or purchasing when the time comes?
Comment on this
The Deputy can take it that my Department will take every necessary step, and in good time, to make sure that the Independent Local Radio Authority, when set up, will be able to function pretty well immediately.
Comment on this
In view of his replies to Deputy Leyden, could I ask the Minister if the heads of the Bill are ready, if such heads have been before the Government and if they are agreed by the Government?
Comment on this
The position is that the Government have not only considered the heads of the Bill, but have almost completed consideration of the entire Bill. I hope to be in a position to make an announcement on the legislation very shortly.
Comment on this
Could the Minister now state to the House how many stations he envisages, following on the additional frequencies available to him?
Comment on this
I do not envisage any particular number of stations. That should be properly a matter for the Independent Local Radio Authority when it is set up.
Comment on this
Did the Minister not state very recently that in his view there should be quite a number of commercial stations and at the same time quite a number of community stations? If that be the case, how does he envisage the community stations licensing themselves?
Comment on this
I think that the Deputy is probably misconstruing what I said. I said that I anticipate a certain development. That is not to say that that will not take place — my guess is as good as anybody else's in this case. I imagine that we are likely to have different types of radio stations, some very local indeed and perhaps others more widespread. As the Deputy will be aware, there are a number of pirate stations in operation which are completely community stations, in that they are run by community interests and not for profit. There are other stations which are only profit-orientated. I cannot be precise and cannot anticipate how this will develop. I imagine it likely that we will have some sort of two-tier system.
Comment on this
I shall allow Deputy Reynolds a final supplementary and Deputy Gallagher a supplementary.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister is trying to mislead the House when he says that he is not in the guessing game? If heads of the Bill have been agreed by Government, surely he knows exactly the position and the guidelines which have been agreed at Government level to put to the local authorities on which they will base their assessment of the whole situation?
Comment on this
Just to clarify the point, whatever legislation this House may pass will not dictate necessarily the number of stations which will emerge. either at the very small community level or wider, regional or local level. It is very hard to anticipate exactly how many stations are likely to emerge.
Comment on this
In other words, the Government have not agreed their guidelines to give to the local Independent Local Radio Authority when it is set up.
Comment on this
I have already told the House that the Government have almost completed their consideration of the matter.
Comment on this
Can the Minister guarantee to the House that the independence enjoyed by Radio na Gaeltachta will not be interfered with in any way when these new stations are being set up?
Comment on this
How does the Minister propose to deal with the present illegal stations when the time comes to entertain applications?
Comment on this
That is also a separate question. I intend to introduce two pieces of legislation simultaneously, one dealing with illegal broadcasting and one making arrangements to set up legal local radio.
Comment on this
Would the Minister make a more specific statement in regard to the position of pirate radio stations? He has made many statements about these stations over the years. There is some ambiguity about his position, as he is well aware. He should put on the record of this House his views as Minister on the future of existing pirate stations, whether they will be free to apply for licences.
Comment on this
It is Government policy that we should phase out illegal radio stations as we make provision for legal local radio. That is what we intend to do.