Gregory’s refused prison visit
Gregory sought an explanation for being refused a visit to two prisoners at Portlaoise and asked about normal procedures. No specific reason was given beyond practical difficulties on the day; Noonan said visits are arranged subject to prison regimes, Gregory has no absolute right of access, and he would be facilitated in future.
asked the Minister for Justice the reason Deputy Gregory-Independent was refused permission to visit two prisoners in Portlaoise prison on 23 February 1985.
Comment on this
(Limerick East): The Deputy was advised on 22 February 1985, that it was not practical to facilitate him with a visit to the two prisoners on the following day. He was also informed on the same occasion that if he made an application for a visit on another day it would be considered. I have to say, a Cheann Comhairle, that the statement attributed to the Deputy in The Irish Times of Saturday, 23 February, does not give a complete account of his dealings with my office on the previous day which were along the lines I have just indicated.
Comment on this
What are the normal procedures in relation to allowing a Member of the House to visit a prisoner in any of our prisons?
Comment on this
(Limerick East): In normal circumstances if the Deputy contacts my office he will be facilitated, but that does not mean that he can just arrive at the door of a prison on any morning or afternoon simply by informing the office. The arrangement will be made for Deputies in normal circumstances, but it depends on prison regimes and so on. People must be reasonable about it. If they insist on going on Friday morning, it might be easier for the prisoners to have them there on Saturday.
Comment on this
I asked the question because I did not get all of the Minister's initial reply. I have been a fairly regular visitor to Portlaoise prison particularly when former prisoner Nicky Kelly was resident there, and I always adopted the same procedures which involved, as the Minister said, ringing the Minister's office and asking permission for a visit, and I had been told that to facilitate the prison authorities it would be better if I went early on a Saturday morning before the——
Comment on this
It arises directly from the Minister's reply. I did everything to facilitate the prison authorities. They suggested to me that arriving early on a Saturday morning would be best before relatives began to queue. On this occasion I contacted the Minister's office.
I made the usual request a couple of days in advance. I was refused and given no explanation for that refusal. Will the Minister tell me the precise reason why I was refused on this occasion? I did exactly what I had done on previous occasions when I visited Portlaoise prison. I fail to see why I was refused and I am entitled to an explanation.
Comment on this
(Limerick East): The Deputy said he contacted my office a number of days in advance. That is not the information available to me. As I said earlier, he was advised on 22 February that it was not practical to facilitate him with a visit to two prisoners on the following day. There were particular circumstances on that day and it was not practical for him to visit Portlaoise prison. He has always been facilitated in the past and he will be facilitated in the future.
Comment on this
I feel I am entitled to an explanation. I did not get an explanation by ringing and checking with the Minister's office at the time. I am now asking in the House why it was not practical on that occasion to allow me to visit the prison. It is not sufficient for the Minister to say it was not practical. Why was it not practical on that occasion?
Comment on this
(Limerick East): I should like to point out to the Deputy that he does not have an absolute right to visit prisons, but we will facilitate him. We have always facilitated him. On certain occasions it is not practical to have visitors in a prison. On this occasion it was not practical and the Deputy was facilitated subsequently, I understand, and we will facilitate him again.