ESF Certificate Graduates’ Grant Eligibility
O’Rourke argued that students who succeed in ESF-funded certificate courses should be able to progress to diploma or degree study even if their earlier Leaving Certificate results fail the VEC scholarship threshold. Hussey defended the scheme’s general academic and means-tested criteria, saying ESF-supported students had already received substantial assistance; O’Rourke maintained that skills were being wasted and sought to raise the matter on the Adjournment.
asked the Minister for Education the measures she proposes to take to rectify the anomalous situation whereby students at Regional Technical Colleges on completion of a successful two year certification course on European Social Fund grants cannot qualify for further funding for diploma and degree courses because eligibility for such funding still depends on earlier leaving certificate results.
Comment on this
I do not accept that any anomalous situation exists. Students who have completed a certificate course with the aid of an ESF grant may be eligible for assistance for progression to diploma or degree courses under the VEC scholarships scheme. Eligibility for assistance under this scheme is not based solely upon the leaving certificate examination results of the year of embarking on the ESF course but also upon a number of other conditions, including a means test. The conditions of the scheme are of general application in the case of all candidates and have been applied in the manner I have indicated since the introduction of such a provision in the scholarships scheme in 1977 specifically to assist ESF grant-holders to pursue advanced courses of study.
Comment on this
I want to be very specific about this matter. The Minister, inadvertently I am sure, chose not to attend to the salient point in my question. A young man or woman may qualify on means for a VEC grant but if he or she does not receive the required two honours in the leaving certificate because of the policy introduced by the Minister, not Deputy G. Brady or Fianna Fáil, in the summer following her appointment as Minister for Education, he or she does not qualify for the grant. If that person pursues a course successfully in one of the regional technical colleges and is awarded a certificate with distinction permitting him or her to take a diploma or degree course in a discipline, he or she will not get further funding because their leaving certificate continues to haunt them although their post leaving certificate achievements should supersede such credentials.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, the VEC scholarship scheme is of general application and if we start making exceptions it will not be equitable for many other people. It is also necessary to point out that students who have had two years completely free of fees and fully grant-aided from the European Social Fund have already enjoyed some advantage. Therefore, that group could not be considered to be the most necessitous for getting special help and for whom we should change the VEC scholarship scheme. Everybody must fulfil the same academic attainments of the 1983 scholarship scheme as students had to fulfil in other years. There is no way out of that.
Comment on this
It is unfortunate the Minister will not see my point. A young man or woman may attain a credit ——
Comment on this
—— thus indicating that he or she is on the right path but their skill cannot be utilised because that person cannot afford to proceed with his or her education. The Minister is missing a valid point, that the money is wasted in many instances.