European Communities (Amendment) Bill, 1986: Committee and Final Stages.
Contributions 1–171 of 335. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 32 of 1986 ›
On a point of order, or of information, I understand there has been some difficulty about who voted and how many voted on the Second Stage last night.
Comment on this
I am not asking to have a post mortem. I want to know who voted last night, and where it is recorded.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 2, line 23, after "Articles 33 and 34", to insert the following:
"provided that
(i) nothing in the Single European Act or in the Treaties as amended by the Act shall authorise in the State, laws, measures or Acts of the Communities or of the State which are repugnant to the fundamental rights recognised in Articles 40 to 44 of the Constitution, and
(ii) a Declaration to this effect be notified to the High Contracting Parties of the Single European Act.".
The third amendment to the Constitution, Article 29.4.3, which permits Ireland's accession to the European Community, has the effect of legitimising all Community legislation in this country without restriction by any Article of the Constitution. Fundamental rights play an increasingly important part in Community law. The content of these rights is derived from the treaties, from the constitutional traditions common to the member states and in particular from the European Convention on Human Rights. The fundamental rights in Articles 40 to 44 of the Irish Constitution differ in some important respects from the fundamental rights of other member states. Notable examples are the right to life of the unborn and the rights of the family based on marriage which has been reaffirmed in the recent past by the Irish people, as we all know.
The Single European Act will extend the scope of Community law and will give the Community new powers to achieve a harmonisation of laws in the member states acting on a qualified majority. An analysis of the Act reveals the possibility that this extension of powers would lead to a conflict with fundamental rights in the Irish Constitution and that the Act would not provide adequate safeguards for such rights. The explanatory guide which the Government issued recently refers to such possibilities. In relation to abortion services, while the Government believe that possibility is removed by a particular provision in the Act, there is uncertainty and inadequacy in respect of this remedy. There is a serious danger in the Act to some constitutionally protected rights and values.
Economic and foreign policy aspects of the Single European Act are outside the scope of this memorandum. If ratification of this Act will serve the common good in economic and political spheres, it should only be done on condition that the fundamental rights in the Irish Constitution are adequately protected. A number of declarations have been appended to the Single European Act. They include a number of unilateral declarations, including one on insurance by this Government which reserves a position on various matters. While a unilateral declaration would be unlikely to influence the interpretation of the Act by the Court of Justice, it might well allow the member state in question to resist measures which conflict with the reserved position.
The proposed solution, therefore, is the addition of this further declaration to the Act stating clearly that the Irish ratification of the Act is without prejudice to the fundamental rights and values protected in Articles 40 to 44 of the Constitution. Consequently, this amendment is for the primary purpose of safeguarding family rights as enshrined in our Constitution, especially the right to life of the unborn. It is to ensure that no legislation, no new laws or directives emanting from Europe or anywhere else shall be allowed to compromise or undermine the cherished rights, so much valued by our people, in Articles 40 to 41 of the Constitution. This House puts down a marker to all our friends in Europe that a family, in so far as our Constitution is concerned, is basic and fundamental, possessing inalienable and imprescriptible rights antecedent and superior to all positive law.
Comment on this
In recent weeks and in particular in the last couple of days many people have shown their deep concern about the implications of the Single European Act for the protection of the fundamental rights recognised by the Irish Constitution. A clear case has been made and I want to hear the Government's response to it. These fundamental rights are enunciated in Articles 40 to 44 of the Constitution. As the House knows, these Articles cover personal rights, the family, education, private property and religion. The common Preamble to the Single European Act refers for the first time to the fundamental rights recognised in the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms under the auspices of the Council of Europe. It is argued that the Single European Act can be taken to authorise the Court of Justice to regard the human rights convention as providing that court with the principles to which it should adhere in the field of fundamental rights.
While Community law overrides not merely domestic law but also the Constitution and has the force of law, the Human Rights Convention does not have direct force of law in Ireland at present. This is the nub of the whole matter. The argument is that the fundamental rights set out in the convention, where they are in conflict with the fundamental rights as laid down in Articles 40 to 44 of the Irish Constitution, may well prevail. This would mean, in theory at least, that the European Court of Justice could overturn fundamental rights as enshrined in the Irish Constitution in favour of principles set out in the convention. I would like the Government to deal very definitely and satisfactorily with this issue by accepting this amendment. A case has been made and we would like to have it answered in this House. The view is held by many that the fears could be put aside if the amendment is accepted by the Government.
Comment on this
We were enabled, under Article 29.4.3º of the Constitution, to join the EC. That Article states:
No provision of this Constitution invalidates laws enacted, acts done or measures adopted by the State necessitated by the obligations of membership of the Communities or prevents laws enacted, acts done or measures adopted by the Communities, or institutions thereof, from having the force of law in the State.
That is the basis on which our membership rests. It enables us, under the Constitution, to be members of that Community. The very important words in that provision in regard to the measure, and in particular the amendment, that we are discussing are "necessitated by the obligations of membership of the Communities". What we are proposing to do by way of enacting an Act in this House is not necessitated by the obligations of membership of the Communities. It is far from it. We are passing the Bill into law to provide for the possibility of new and additional articles to be added to the Treaty of Rome. It is only under the articles of the Treaty of Rome as it was in 1972-73 that the words "necessitated by the obligations of membership of the Communities" come into play. It is not within the competence of this House to deal with anything beyond that.
While I support the intention of the amendment put down by Deputy Sean Treacy in a last desperate effort to try to retain some sort of sovereignty over our country, we are unconstitutional in what we are doing, in what we have been doing and in anything we will do following on the alleged power that will be given if this Bill becomes an Act. Those additional matters that are being talked about are not necessitated by the obligations of membership of the Community under the Treaty as it is and as it was when we became members. It is only in that context that we can possibly enact any measure whatsoever. Any additional measure that we enact is outside the mandate our Constitution gave us under the provisions in Article 29.4.3º. This is the nub of our entire objection to dealing with the matter in this manner. I hope the Minister will say how the Government can overcome what will be done in the future on our behalf by the Commission. Article 29.4.3º states that no provision of the Constitution invalidates laws enacted, acts done or measures adopted by the State necessitated by the obligations of membership of the Communities. The operative words are in Article 29.4.3º and they are outside the Articles of the Treaty under which we became a member and which were accepted by way of referendum. Anything beyond that is not within our competence to deal with until our people are consulted and agree to extend that mandate to cover future occurences. The Minister must have been satisfied by somebody that what I have said is not operative. Until he, with the best knowledge available to him, can convince me otherwise nothing will make me believe other than that what we are doing is beyond the competence of the House unless we go back to the people in a referendum.
Comment on this
The House amended the Treaty on a number of occasions since the referendum in 1972. I understand that the last time we amended the Treaty was to give budgetary powers to the Parliament. That was done by a vote in the House and not by way of referendum. The third amendment to the Constitution which allowed us to become part of the Community, defined the limits within which changes could be made. On the advice we have got we are satisfied that this is well within them. I made that clear last night and the Taoiseach made it clear, as did a number of legal experts in articles in newspapers. What we are doing now is well within our rights under the Constitution.
Comment on this
It is what is said in the House that counts; not what is published in the newspapers.
Comment on this
I was pointing out that a lot of the argument on this matter was outside the House. A case had been made by those who believe that a referendum should be held and by those who feel a referendum is not necessary. The advice of the senior law officer of the Government is to the effect that a referendum is not necessary and that we are not going beyond what was envisaged in the third amendment to the Constitution.
I should like to tell Deputies Treacy and Collins that the Single European Act does not authorise the Court of Justice of the European Communities to interpret or apply the European Convention on Human Rights, notwithstanding the reference in the Preamble to the Single European Act to the Convention. This follows from Articles 31 and 32 of the Single European Act. Article 31 provides that the powers of the Court of Justice of the European Communities, under the European Community Treaties, shall apply pursuant to the provisions of the Single European Act only to the provisions of Title II containing the amendments to the European Community Treaties and to Article 32 of the Single European Act. Article 32 provides:
subject to Article 3(1), to Title II and to Article 31 — just referred to, all of which concern the European Community Treaties and nothing else — nothing in the Single European Act shall affect the Treaties establishing the European Communities or any subsequent Treaties and Acts modifying or supplementing them.
These two provisions taken together have the following effects: (i) the jurisdiction of the Court of Justice remains confined to the European Community Treaties, (ii) the statements in the Preamble, including that on the European Convention on Human Rights, do not affect European Community Treaties and, accordingly, the contents of the Convention are not by virtue of the Preamble in any way imported into the Treaties and (iii) it should be added to this that the Court of Justice of the European Communities has already decided in the exercise of its jurisdiction under the European Communities Treaties as they stand that it is liable in its judgement by the principles laid down in the European Convention on Human Rights, in particular the Rutili judgment case number 36 of 1975, 1975 ECR 1219. The application of these principles by the Court of Justice can, however, only arise in the exercise of its existing jurisdiction under the European Treaties. Moreover, the best view seems to be that the court acting within this sphere does not have jurisdiction to lay down interpretations of the Human Rights Convention which, after all, has its own system of interpretation by the European Court on Human Rights.
Comment on this
Without casting any reflection on the information the Minister has given the House I should like to point out that he has not clarified my mind on this. It may be that my mind is slightly different from the minds of other Members. Following that explanation, the position is as clear as mud. The Minister and I campaigned very heavily in favour of Ireland joining the Community. We did so for all the best reasons, I hope. The very grave doubts expressed were answered at the end of the day by a statement that we could resort to the protection we have. I would not have campaigned at all but for the fact that I believed that the carrot that was held out in the form of the veto to protect our interests and our national sovereignty was available to us although our country would be in a great big pool in the EC. That pool has got a lot bigger since and it may be enlarged further. Our campaign on that was successful if one is to judge by the percentage that voted in favour of it.
If the Bill is passed the crazy deal worked out when the Twelve were together last weekend — 11 NATO members and our little self — will be accepted. If we do not adopt this Act, that deal cannot be implemented. I heard Members last night saying that the other 11 would go their own way and we would be left behind but left behind where? Where would the Eleven be going?
This Act cannot come into operation until the Houses of the Oireachtas have cleared it and it has been signed by the President. We are not obliged to do that before the end of the year and most other countries will not be approving it before the end of the year. For instance, I understand that Germany will not be ratifying it because of a pending election. They are taking the view that there may be changes in the Government. There may be changes in the Government here. It would be prudent to leave this menace until after the election. We must remember that there is no urgency about this. The veto, the last weapon, the irresistible weapon given to every country big or small, is being set aside and no amount of assurances, as were given by speakers on the Government side last night, about the vital national interest not being trampled upon will satisfy me. Who will decide what is the vital national interest as far as the Irish people are concerned? Is it the Commission, or the Council of Ministers, or the heads of Governments? The vital national interest will not be determined by us if we go along with what is before us here today.
What we are doing is not necessitated by the obligations of EC membership and is, therefore, outside the competence of this House to deal with. This law would take away those rights, and no amount of persuasion, assurances or soft talk will get away from the fact that the veto, our final weapon of defence, is being removed because, as the Taoiseach said last night, it was being abused. Damn me, we did not abuse it. I think we reluctantly used it once. If we had abused it we would not be in the sorry state we are in at the moment. It is because we did not use it that we are in the difficulties we are in vis-á-vis the CAP and all the rest of it.
It is because I do not agree with this that, according to the Taoiseach, I am suffering from a historic Irish inferiority complex. The Taoiseach said that we abused the veto and we have to set that side. As I have said, we did not abuse it and it is those who go along with this, not those who object to it, who suffer from the national malady of an inferiority complex. Having sold out the Six-Counties under the Anglo-Irish Agreement, we are now making a present of the Twenty-six Counties to the bureaucrats in Brussels. I have great regard for them but they must be kept in their place, and this is not the way to do it.
I say this is not within our competence because it is not necessitated by the obligations of membership of the Community, which is the mandate we have under Article 29.4.3º as enacted by the people in the 1972 referendum. Until that is amended we are running totally against the entire idea of controlling our destiny and handing it over willy nilly to whoever may come together, whatever their intentions may be, whether it is multinational profit, which seems to be what this is all about. The majority decision will determine our future and we will be dragged here, there and elsewhere, the little country that we are. We would never be there, in my estimation, if we did not rely on the final argument that the veto was our protection — we would have been campaigning against it. That might not have been good at that time, but if we are going to be a tiny appendage on the rock of Europe, dictated to by 11 NATO members in regard to everything, not just security and defence but all matters, the vital national interest which we have maintained for our protection will not be determined by us. We may claim that our vital national interest is being infringed, but who will decide? The other 11 will decide whether it is our vital national interest or not.
By adopting the Single European Act, therefore, we are cocking a snook at the electorate, cocking a snook at the Irish people and the Irish Constitution, and no amount of glib talk, true or false, will get away from the fact that this is not necessitated by the obligations of our membership. The veto, in effect, is being taken away.
Comment on this
Deputy Blaney's remarks go well beyond the two amendments before the House. He began by disputing the procedure being followed and suggested that this is not a matter on which this House is competent, and he suggested that the issue at stake is so fundamental that it should go to a referendum. What is involved here is a series of relatively minor amendments to the Treaty of Rome. There is nothing new about that. It has been amended half a dozen times since we became a member. The occasions on which the Treaty was amended are set out in the first paragraph of the explanatory memorandum.
Comment on this
Some of those amendments were relatively minor, for example, technical amendments when Greenland lapsed. Some of them were amendments of fundamental importance to Ireland, such as those relating to the budgetary powers of Parliament. Others were amendments of potential indirect importance to us, such as the enlargement of the Community by the inclusion of Greece and later Spain and Portugal. What is happening now happened on every previous occasion when the Treaty required to be amended. The original decision by the people contemplated that the Treaty would be amended from time to time, and that was correct because in a short period amendments were made.
Deputy Blaney suggested that these amendments are of a particularly distinct and fundamental kind. He made particular reference to the veto and said that what is involved here is a complete transformation of our membership because, he said, the basis of the case that he argued for membership no longer exists. He argued for membership on the basis that as a last resort as a small country, we would have the veto to protect us, and that that is no longer the case.
That is utter nonsense. There is nothing in the Single European Act, good, bad or indifferent, about the use of the veto, because the use of the veto is not in any sense governed by the Treaties in the first place, as Deputy Blaney must be aware as one who attended Council meetings in the past and who had served in the European Parliament. The veto represents a political compromise and it remains undiminished and is available to countries who seek to use it in their vital national interests. The confusion arises in some people's minds because while the Single European Act does not in any sense address the question of the veto, it addresses decision making in the Communities. A number of circumstances are laid down for decisions to be made by majority vote and for decisions by unanimity. All that the Single European Act does is to extend the circumstances to which majority voting will apply and correspondingly to reduce the occasions on which unanimity is required. It is the contention of this side of the House that the circumstances which are being added to the majority column, as it were, are very much to Ireland's advantage because they enhance the prospects of moving towards a genuine single market, one of the reasons why we joined the Communities in the first place.
In regard to the two amendments, there seems to be a complete misunderstanding of what the Community is about, what the Treaty of Rome is about and of the amendments to it which the Single European Act constitutes. Of course, our membership had legal implications for us, and constitutional implications. They have existed since the very first day. Nothing is being changed by the Single European Act, nothing whatsoever.
Deputy Treacy's anxieties relate to the Articles of the Constitution that deal with fundamental rights, Articles 40 to 44. Some of those Articles deal with matters that are not the business of the Treaty of Rome at all. So that the prospect of those questions ever being litigated does not arise. The Treaty of Rome does not have jurisdiction in relation to religion, morality or education. It is true that some of those Articles relate to areas where one could comtemplate decisions of the European Court of Justice arising. For example, areas of property are, in the nature of things, economic. There are areas where, it may be, there will be court decisions which will be of importance, just as there may have been court decisions of importance since our accession. But there is nothing new, in terms of a new jurisdiction being added by virtue of the Single European Act, nothing new whatsoever. The suggestion that the Single European Act incorporates, or tags on in some way, the European Convention on Human Rights is groundless. There are a whole series of decisions of our High Court and Supreme Court which assert very clearly — going right back to the early sixties — that the European Convention on Human Rights does not form part or our domestic law. The jurisdiction of the Court of Justice, established by the Treaty of Rome, is to interpret the Treaty of Rome and that which goes with it, not to deal with the European Convention on Human Rights.
If one wanders down to the Supreme Court, where constitutional cases are argued each day of the week one will find lawyers seeking inspiration from the European Convention on Human Rights, seeking inspiration from decisions on the French. American and any other Constitution. Equally, if one wandered into the American Supreme Court on a good day very likely one would find there judgments of judges like the late Cearbhail Ó Dálaigh or Mr. Justice Brian Walsh being cited. There is nothing unusual or abnormal in that. The jurisdiction of the European Court of Justice was established by the Treaties that gave the Community its base. Therefore, nothing has changed on this occasion.
The other fear that has been floated with regard to morality issues relates to the implementation of a single market. The argument runs something along these lines — that if people have an opportunity to sell their goods and services anywhere within the Community those goods and services may spray into the morality field and cause problems for us, such as the distribution of pornography or whatever. It was perhaps a remote possibility but it was a possibility. Therefore it was addressed by the Government in the course of these negotiations. The Single European Act provides very specifically that the grounds enumerated in Article 36 will continue to apply, that a country can rely on any one of those grounds in refusing to go along with the majority vote. Of course those grounds include public policy and public morality. There is no basis whatsoever for the suggestion that this has implications for our morality. I might quote from the list of grounds specified in Article 36 of the Treaty of Rome:
The provisions of Articles 30 to 34 shall not preclude prohibitions or restrictions on imports, exports or goods in transit justified on grounds of public morality, public policy or public security; the protection of health and life of humans, animals or plants; the protection of national treasures, possessing artistic historic, or archaeological value; or the protection of industrial and commercial property...
Each one of those safeguards, might, in some circumstances, be of importance to this country. But, since the issue raised is that of public morality, I should say it is there in black and white, that the grounds which were available to a country by virtue of Article 36 of the Treaty of Rome, are available to a country concerned about a harmonisation directive.
Comment on this
I might revert to something to which the Minister for Foreign Affairs was referring at the end of his remarks last evening when it was said that the advice of the Attorney General, as it was offered to the House, was not accepted by this side of the House, and it has not been improved since. It is important at least to say that what we are concerned about here is something very fundamental. This is not a minor matter and cannot be, since it refers directly to the amendment in the names of Deputies Gerry Collins and Sean Treacy, which refer to the protection of fundamental rights as laid down in our Constitution. Anybody who would imply that there was anything less than fundamental about that is misleading the House.
Last evening the Minister sought to convey the advice that, in no way, was the European Convention on Human Rights going to be involved in the ratification of the Single European Act. We cannot accept that because there was considerable reference to it in the Preamble to the Act. While the Minister seemed to suggest that it would have no real bearing on the implementation of the Act, it is well worth bearing in mind that the actual words used in the Preamble are and here I quote:
Determined to work together to promote democracy on the basis of the fundamental rights recognised in the constitutions and laws of the member states, in the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms...
No matter how one seeks to convey a minimised version of the interpretation of that it still must be clearly understood that there is stated a determination to take on board the European Convention on Human Rights, make it part of the Community's law whether now or at some time in the future. It is to protect our interests against its possible implications that we have put down this amendment.
If we were to go further would the Minister suggest to us that there is no policy movement towards incorporation of that Convention into Community law either now or in the future? We would have to say that the stated intention, as laid down in the Preamble, definitely declares that that determination is there, to have that Convention taken on board and made part of Community law which would be enforced by the European Court of Justice and which would take precedence over constitutional measures, as is laid down in our fundamental statement.
It is not true to say that there have not been declarations and instruments in the past that have changed the attitude of Community law in so far as fundamental rights are concerned. Quite a number of them have been recorded. Some I should like to place on record as being noteworthy would be the Declaration of the Nine on European Identity — Copenhagen, 1973; the Declaration at European Council in April 1978; the Commission Report on the Protection of Fundamental Rights in the European Communities, 1976 and the Joint Declaration by the European Council and Commission of April 1977. These are declarations and instruments that have in some way infringed on fundamental rights as they would be enunciated and would apply in our situation also. Therefore there is at this time some movement away from what we would regard to be the fundamental issues laid down in Articles 40 to 44 of our Constitution.
It is well to take note of one of the matters that will clearly set out the fact that the Communities do have the declared intention, and have even gone further, to take on board the European Convention on Human Rights. Here I might refer to the Bulletin of the European Communities, Supplement 2, 1979 under the heading "The Accession of the Communities to the European Convention on Human Rights". That document has been supported by the European Parliament, which has strongly advocated the accession of the European Communities to the European Convention on Human Rights. In effect, therefore, they are binding themselves to the decisions of that Convention. The European Communities are already bound by elements of that Convention. I might now quote from paragraph 10 of that bulletin which puts in stark reality the position that the Convention now holds in Community law thinking. It states and I quote:
Since 1974, all the Member States of the Community have been contracting parties to the ECHR, which has led to the Court of Justice of the European Communities to derive guidelines for the constitutional conditions common to the Member States from the fundamental rights embodied in the ECHR;...
The important thing is that the ECHR is used as an indicator of the standards existing at Community level in the field of fundamental rights. Further down the paragraph states:
On one hand the ECHR represents a minimum standard of the general principles of law projected by the Court of Justice. On the other, it is arguable that the Community, in so far as powers have been assigned to it by the Member States, is already bound, on the basis of the principle of substitution, by the substantive provisions of the convention on Human Rights by reason of the original obligation of the Member States.
There is no doubt that only one interpretation can be taken from that and that is the Community's wish to have the European Convention on Human Rights incorporated as part of Community law and de facto it almost says that is the position at this time. This is confirmed again in the Preamble to the Act the Minister referred to last evening.
This Act will be the first occasion when the member states will formally acknowledge the role of the European Convention on Human Rights in the Community's Treaties. We must understand exactly what are the authority and the role of the Court of Justice. The incorporation of the Convention into the Treaties will have very serious constitutional implications for us. I refer further to the stated intentions of the Commission in regard to the status of the fundamental rights as set down.
The same bulletin in paragraph 16 talks about the strengthening of the institutions. I quote:
Finally, accession would reduce the risk of national courts using the absence of a written catalogue of fundamental rights formally binding upon the Community as justification for reviewing acts of the Council or the Commission by reference to their national constitutions...
The straight implication there is that they do not wish national Constitutions in any way to impinge on what they would regard as the fundamental rights of the Community as laid out in Community law. The Court of Justice, taking that on board, would then be obliged to take the right as seen by the ECHR as the basis for operation, and certainly many aspects of that convention are in direct conflict with our Constitution. For that reason we think it is not too much to ask the Dáil here to put beyond yea or nay the fact that genuine doubt has been expressed inside and outside the House about the possibility of that convention becoming part of Community law, and of its being in conflict with our Constitution, Articles 40 to 44. Why take the risk of leaving that loophole?
There is no doubt that the Community is putting us on notice that they would regard it as an impertinence of any member state to review any of the Community laws as accepted by them and as implemented by the Court of Justice. That is our basic reason for our attitude to this. We can well understand that there might be advice to the contrary, but if there is the slightest risk we would say that the Minister should not allow it to persist. There would be unanimity in here on the protection of Articles 40 to 44 of our Constitution. We seek to protect that and we think that this wording will achieve that end. We are not convinced that everybody in Europe is on the side of the angels. If in some way now or in the future that Convention were to be incorporated in Community law then it would be in direct contravention of our Constitution, the Court of Justice would have no alternative but to apply it across the board, it would be an impertinence for us to become involved to do otherwise and consequently our rights would be infringed. Because of the persistent and, we believe, valid doubts expressed we ask the Minister to relent on this so that he will have unanimity in the House.
Comment on this
I have listened carefully to what the Minister for Foreign Affairs and the Minister of State had to say in reply to the case being made for the adoption of these amendments, and I am not impressed. The Minister's attitude is utterly unsatisfactory and simplistic in the extreme. It is obvious that the Government believe that the doubts which we have expressed here in respect of these fundamental issues appertaining to our Constitution are clearly justified. They feel that the doubts being expressed are removed, say by Article 100A of the EC Treaty which allows a member state to apply national provisions on grounds of what is called major needs referred to in Article 36 of the EC Treaty. The adequacy of the certainty of relying on this remedy is open to fundamental criticisms and is very doubtful indeed.
In the first instance it should be noted that the proposed remedy could be authorised only in response to measures adopted by the Council under the new Article 100 A EC. For example, it would not be available to negate a directive on the proposed Article 118A EC or avoid a judgment in the Court of Justice that Ireland had failed in its obligations in respect of say, Article 171.
Article 36 of the EC Treaty applies primarily to the movement of goods. It does not contain the phrase "major needs". It permits restrictions justified on grounds of public morality or public policy and on grounds of the protection of the health and life of humans. Freedom of movement of services is provide for in Articles 59 to 66 without the restrictions available to member states under Article 36.
The restrictions on movement of persons under Article 48 are more limited than those in Article 36 and do not include the reference to public morality. In that context, therefore, the new provisions for services and capital in the new Article 100 A include provisions on grounds of major needs referred to in Article 36.
The new Articles on the internal market are stated to be without prejudice to other provisions in this Treaty. My concern is that the proposition contained in Article 100 A would authorise the application of nationalist restrictions on the movement of persons, services and capital on grounds additional to those in the original Treaties. That would be contrary to the thrust of this Single European Act. While there can be no certainty in the matter it seems more probable that the major needs referred to under Article 36 would be related to the needs to control the movement of goods for reasons specified in Article 36. This uncertain phrase could not be relied upon to authorise national provisions restricting the supply or sale of abortion services within the Community or to negate other undesirable measures of this kind. There appears to be no basis in Community law to distinguish between abortion services and the other medical or professional services. This is a serious flaw in our legislation.
Assuming that this procedure were available to restrict the supply of abortive services, the national provision would have to be deemed necessary on the ground of public morality, public policy or the protection of health of human life. If such a provision were challenged in the Court of Justice there might be a substantial difficulty in defending that provision, because the ground of public morality would imply that it was justifiable to regard abortion as immoral and offensive to the common good. But, in a legal tradition that regards at least some abortions as a matter of women's health or privacy, the Court of Justice might not accept such grounds for restriction of Common Law. We have no guarantee on that account.
Comment on this
On a point of order, can the Deputy give the House the reference to the document from which he is reading?
Comment on this
I am using extended notes. The ground of protection, therefore, of health and human life would be more likely to favour abortion services——
Comment on this
——than to restict them, as the health of the woman would be preferred to the life of the foetus which in general in the European norm, is not regarded as a human person.
These are some of the reasons why we are concerned about the failure to make clear the will of the Irish people in respect of abortion as shown by the vote on this issue a short time ago. Our refusal to introduce abortion law could be held in the prevailing European view to be an arbitrary discrimination against women in favour of a non person in the womb. If the Commission were to take such a view it would appear that the national provision could not be applied. In any case where the Commission or any member state consider that a member state is making inappropriate use of a national provision they may bring the matter directly before the Court of Justice. The Minister should rethink his position on this matter. Only time will tell whether this Act will constitute a threat to our Constitution and the fundamental aspects in it. I greatly fear that the Single European Act would open the door to legislation from the European Communities which could be repugnant to Articles 40 to 44 of our Constitution. That door was unlocked by the third amendment in 1972 and it is not an overstatement to contend that the whole constitutional system of protection of fundamental rights in our Constitution is clearly endangered by this Act. That is why we wish the Minister to reconsider what we are asking. There is nothing fundamentally wrong in seeking to implement the will of the vast majority of the Irish people in respect of the intrinsic worth of our Constitution and all that it contains in respect of family life and the values to which we all subscribe.
I concur with the view expressed by Deputy Blaney and others that the issues are so grave that nothing less than a further reference to the people by way of a referendum will clarify these matters, the matter of sovereignty, the matter of neutrality and the matter of morality which are clearly involved, without proper safeguards being provided, so far as we can see. I urge the Minister to think again on what has been said here. Nothing will be lost, much will be gained and intrinsic values will be preserved if we accept the amendment in my name or in that of Deputy Collins, to safeguard the essentials in our Constitution.
Comment on this
Deputies, including Deputy Haughey, looked for a referendum on the subject. I would ask Deputies who advanced that suggestion, what question they would like to put to the Irish people? Is it, that we should not ratify or not adopt the Single European Act? Let us say the people decided to reject the Act, what then would we do? We would find ourselves in a position in which we would decide not to proceed with our membership of the Community. Is it the case that the question that the Deputies would like to put is that we would opt out of Europe? I do not know what Deputy Haughey wanted to put in the referendum when he called for one yesterday and I am not clear as to what Deputy Treacy wants put to the people but in fairness to the House they should spell out precisely what question they want put to the people and also what the logical sequence of events will be after that if the people decide not to adopt the Single European Act. What is happening is that people are being rather opportunistic about this. The Fianna Fáil position has dramatically changed in recent years. Only a few years ago when my colleague, Deputy O'Kennedy, was Minister for Foreign Affairs, he told this House——
Comment on this
The Deputy seems to be confused. The Deputy was not here. The Deputy is asking about proposals for a referendum——
Comment on this
What we are asking is that this amendment be incorporated in the legislation. That is all.
Comment on this
I understand that some people may have very strong views on specific points and may have certain fears but I do not share those fears. I do not attribute to Deputy Treacy any lack of sincerity or mischievousness that is coming from other quarters in the House, over people calling for a referendum on the subject——
Comment on this
——with the major Opposition party to know if they would tell the House just where they stand on the subject. My colleague, Deputy O'Kennedy, as Minister for Foreign Affairs——
Comment on this
I would remind the House that when Deputy O'Kennedy was Minister for Foreign Affairs he told the House in reply to a parliamentary question, as reported in the Official Report of 4 May 1978 at column 421:
We are, however, a member state of the European Community and as such we have committed ourselves to a policy of European integration with the long term aim of European Union.
That was the Fianna Fáil position. Last Tuesday, Deputy Haughey said that we had gone far enough, that in fact we had gone too far on this so-called moving train and he told the House that he had misgivings about the completion of the common market. The least that Fianna Fáil can do is to spell out precisely what status they have in mind for this country if we are to hop off the moving train. Do Fianna Fáil propose that we withdraw altogether from the European Community? Clearly there are certain things about the Community that they do not like, though I noted that Mr. Haughey and any other Fianna Fáil Deputy who spoke on it approved of the transfer of funds we have had from the CAP and called for more. I suspect that it is some form of associated membership of the Community that Fianna Fáil have in mind.
The message they appear to want to put across to the people at present is that they can have the transfer of funds and they need not have anything else they find in the least bit unappealing. If they want a referendum put to the people they should spell out what that question should be and if the people decide in the negative because of the so-called policy of neutrality or because of the fears which were voiced by Deputy Treacy, let them explain the consequences of that decision. We are hearing from the Opposition many half-truths and much opportunistic cant which is not becoming of a party who have had considerable experience in dealing with Europe and in dealing in Europe. I refer specifically to the commitment that Deputy O'Kennedy, as Minister for Foreign Affairs, described himself and his party as having to the idea of full European integration.
Comment on this
When Deputy Molony taunts this side of the House about calling for a referendum, the subject matter of the referendum and how it should be put to the people, is he not aware that the most eloquent spokesman calling for a referendum loud, and clear and unambiguously, was the Tánaiste last night?
Comment on this
Would Deputy Treacy express the question he wants put in a referendum? I am glad Deputy Treacy has asked me that question——
Comment on this
Because Deputy Kelly last night spelled out what he wants put to the Irish people. When we come to the next amendment I will express the views I have on how we should confront this question of neutrality.
Comment on this
What I am asking is that other Members of the House who call for a referendum should spell out precisely the specific questions they want put to the people. I understand the point Deputy Treacy has been making on these amendments but it has nothing to do with neutrality. It is some other question he wants put to the people. Fianna Fáil want us to have misgivings. Mr. Haughey said we must have misgivings about completion of the internal market. What question do Fianna Fáil want put to the people The Deputies who have called for a refernedum should state specifically the questions they want put.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy was not in sufficiently early to have heard and for that reason I will give him my reasons why I have suggested there should be a referendum. The authority to enter the Community back in 1973 was derived from Article 29.4.3º.
Comment on this
I am not giving you a short answer but what I am holding is that your dilemma on the other side of the House in producing this Bill is that you do not have the authority under our Constitution to do it. If you want to do it, it follows therefrom that you go to the people by way of referendum to get that authority. If you are required to do that, it would be for you to provide the wording to enable you to do what I hold you are not entitled to do under the Constitution as it stands. You raised, as we all did, certain other aspects of the matter which I do not think should be allowed to go unchallenged. You gave the throwaway reply to Deputy Treacy when he drew your attention to the Leader of the Labour Party talking loudly, clearly and succinctly on the need to consult the people on the matter of neutrality. I take it that you are sincerely of the belief that neutrality does not arise or is not challenged as a result of the passage of this Bill
Comment on this
As all 11 of our EC colleagues in some fashion or another are members of NATO who have nuclear missiles of all descriptions placed at every strategic point they can find in Europe and elsewhere, how can you in those circumstances give to the Community authority from this House on behalf of the people to deal with political co-operation, defence, foreign policy and security without there being the implicit outcome that neutrality will have gone out the window or, if not, its usefulness will have gone because we will be as suspect as those who lie with the dogs. According to the old phrase "if you lie with the dogs, you get up with fleas".
Comment on this
I allowed the Deputy to make a passing reference but he is getting to amendment No. 2 at present. We are not dealing with amendment No. 2.
Comment on this
We are not discarding either amendment No. 1 or amendment No. 3. I am just saying that amendment No. 2 deals specifically with the question of neutrality.
Comment on this
I was misled by the contribution of Deputy Molony. I can think again and come back on it later. I believe Deputy Molony is satisfied so far as I am concerned a consultation of the people is the only answer to my assertion that this matter does not have the authority of our Constitution and therefore, that a change will be needed in order to bring the Act into being. The reason I have said that for the Deputy's information is because the Ceann Comhairle told us he could consult the records but not even last night's records are available today, never mind the records of one hour ago. I hold that in the provisions of Articles 29.4.3º the operative words are "necessitated by the obligations of membership of the Communities". I hold that our obligations derive and relate solely and only to the Community as operated under the Treaty of Rome as and when we entered it and as it is today, and not as it will be amended tomorrow. Therefore, what we are doing is not necessitated by our obligations of membership but rather the projected obligations which will be placed upon us in the future as a result of the Single European Act.
Comment on this
I heard Deputy Blaney make those points earlier but I disagree with them. I accept the reply the Minister has given and I do not believe we are engaging in an unconstitutional act by adopting this Act. I know the point Deputy Blaney is making but there are others in the House who are seeking to have questions put and I am simply asking them to state what questions they want put to the people. I do not believe it is necessary or that we would be breaking the Constitution if we accept this Act but I would like those who are calling for a referendum, expecially those in Fianna Fáil, to spell our what questions they want put to the people.
Comment on this
Deputy Flynn spoke about the veto having been set aside but that is not true. The veto is not part of the Treaty of Rome. It was not referred to at any stage during the Inter-Governmental Conference and it is not part of the Single European Act. It is still there. A country can still invoke a vital national interest if it wants to block something.
Deputy Treacy said I am being too simplistic in my approach. The matter is not simple but it is not all that complex either. The Single European Act introduces majority voting in a certain number of cases to facilitiate the establishment of the internal market. Those who have participated in European Councils as Ministers will know that for the last ten to 12 years the ability to reach decisions has become more difficult. The larger the Community became the more difficult it became. It facilitates the taking of decisions by majority vote but in relation to Article 36 of the Treaty which is the one which concerned Deputy Treacy. That must be by unanimous vote of the Council of Ministers. Since that is so, it needs an Irish Minister to vote for a decision to amend or take action under Article 36. No Irish Minister can do that within the confines of the Constitution. It is as simple as that.
Comment on this
No, it refers to a lot more. Deputy Flynn also referred to the Human Rights Convention. That is referred to only in the Preamble. Articles 31 and 32 have blocked off any possibility of the Court of Justice using the Human Rights Convention. During his contribution Deputy Flynn referred to the Convention on Human Rights as if it was not quite savoury and something we should not have acceded to.
Comment on this
Yes, we have found out that there are a number of elements in it which are contrary to our law and we have been taken to court under it.
Deputy Blaney said we have no authority to do what we are doing. I would remind him of what the Irish people voted for in 1972 when both he and I campaigned in favour of this. I did not campaign just for transfer under CAP to the farming community even though they were very welcome. The economic benefits we have derived from our membership of the EC have been considerable. The people voted that we should accede to the Treaty established in Rome "determined to lay the foundation for an ever closer union amongst the peoples of Europe, resolving to ensure the economic and social progress of their countries and by common action to eliminate the barriers which divide Europe". They also voted to affirm the essential objectives of constant improvement of the living and working standards of the people of Europe. The Single European Act is very much in that spirit.
Comment on this
I wish to raise a matter about which many people will be unclear. We owe it to them in the interests of clarity to get an answer. I accept fully what the Minister is saying. We all accept that not everybody in a pub, factory or elsewhere will go through the articles detail by detail. Could I have an unequivocal assurance from the Minister that nothing which confers powers under this revised arrangement bringing the Single European Act into being could in any circumstances override something which is part of our Constitution? I have been approached, as I am sure other Deputies have been, by groups who are very concerned about family matters and who have a legitimate right to have these questions asked in this Parliament.
Abortion is specifically precluded under our Constitution but it is alleged in some documents we have received from concerned Christian family groups that under the proposed revised arrangements in Europe under part of the Single European Act, in the interests of health, an overriding decree could come from Brussels which it is feared could override our Constitutional provision against the introduction of abortion. I am sorry that is so long winded but I am asking the question in the interests of people who are concerned with family matters about which this nation, with its Christian heritage, feels very strongly. I should like to have a categorical, unequivocal, simple assurance from the Minister on that issue.
Comment on this
When approaching or changing treaties or laws which are passed in Europe the Government are very conscious of the provisions of our Constitution. When the Single European Act was going through we kept in constant touch with the Attorney General to make sure we were keeping within the confines of our Constitution. He has assured me that this Act is covered by the third amendment to the Constitution. Everything in the Single European Act, in so far as it relates to the European Communities, is protected by the third amendment to the Constitution. We were in constant touch with the Attorney General during the Inter-Governmental Conference and during the debate in the Council of Ministers.
Comment on this
Is it conceivably possible that at some future date a provision in our Constitution, which is the bulwark of our rights might be deemed to be ultra vires the Convention on Human Rights and so be overridden by some decree? What I am asking in plain language is if our Constitution is sacrosanct? Can it be overridden by a decree from Brussels? Can it be breached in any way?
I accept that the assurances given by the Minister are in good faith but those of us who deal with local authorities know that we get plenty of assurances in good faith in relation to housing, the settling of itinerants and so on. Sometimes it takes a long time to honour these assurances and in other cases they are not honoured at all. Is the Minister in a position to say that no provision of our Constitution, at anytime, can be overridden under the Single European Act by the European Convention on Human Rights?
Comment on this
If the Deputy accepts our amendment he need have no fears. We are doing it for him. He is getting a cast iron guarantee.
Comment on this
In reply to Deputy Collins I am not satisfied that the amendment, even if it were passed, would give me the kind of assurance I am talking about. I want a clear, unequivocal assurance from the Minister.
Comment on this
Deputy Prendergast asked whether it was possible that by reason of the Single European Act our Constitution could be invalidated having regard to the European Convention on Human Rights. He seeks categorical assurances that that could not happen. I say to him that that cannot happen for two reasons. The first reason that it cannot happen is that there are, as I mentioned earlier, umpteen decisions of our own domestic courts, the High Courts and the Supreme Court, declaring that the European Convention on Human Rights does not form part of domestic law. The second reason that it could not happen is that the European Convention on Human Rights is not the business of the courts established by the Treaty of Rome, the Courts of Justice that sit in Strasbourg. So, the European Convention on Human Rights does not arise one way or another.
Let me make one other comment at this stage of the debate. It is simply to remind people that what we are debating is an amendment Bill. It seems sensible in that situation to focus our considerations on what is changing. Some of the arguments that have been advanced, fanciful as they are, were indeed advanced at the time when we applied for membership of the Community in the first place. There was no basis for them then; our period of membership shows that, if anybody was in any doubt. There is no basis for them now. Let us look at what is changed by this. A certain number of harmonisation directives that previously required unanimity now require only a majority vote. In that some people saw a conceivable danger and so the Government responded and got the agreement of our partners to our position in requiring that where questions of morality or public policy arose unanimity would be required as heretofore. The only change and the only issue that we are debating is that some things that were previously unanimous will now be by majority vote and not by majority vote when issues of public morality or public policy arise.
Comment on this
A number of matters have been raised by the Minister that I should like to respond to. This amendment in the name of our spokesman and, I would have to say, in the name of Deputy Treacy, is to ensure that the provisions of our Constitution are protected and are in no way undermined or compromised by anything done here. It is also to ensure — and I do not think that the Minister for Foreign Affairs understands this himself — that what we are doing here follows automatically and directly from our Treaty of Accession to the European Communities — no more and no less. In the course of this debate we do not want to take on obligations in any area that extend beyond what we did and envisaged in signing the Treaty of Accession. That is reasonable and that is what the Irish people adopted by referendum.
It is quite clear that there are areas here that were never contemplated, never referred to, never brought before the Irish people at the time of the referendum. I propose to refer to them specifically and to ask the Minister specifically, either in legal or constitutional terms, how he can suggest that these are minor changes. If he has addressed these questions, how can he answer them? The European Community is a community of institutions and the institutions that existed when we signed the Treaty of Accession were the Commission, the Parliament and the Council of Ministers. There is a new institution now which is not referred to in the Treaty of Rome and accordingly is not incorporated at all in our Treaty of Accession. It is nowhere referred to in that. You will find it under Article 2 of the Single European Act and it is called the European Council. It is included now as an institution. It was not ever part of the institutions of the European Community.
Comment on this
Here the Minister is showing his lack of constitutional or legal awareness. It has been meeting informally. Right now, the big boys have dominated and pulled down this Community and directed it the way they want — towards security as distinct from towards the development of the interests of the peoples of the Community — those that refuse to give the adequate money to finance the policies for the budget — the Mrs. Thatchers and so on that refused every time to provide adequate resources — and we all know that that is the biggest problem of the European Community. Deputies Blaney and Treacy were both in the European Parliament and will know that what has blocked the development of the Community that we all joined has been lack of adequate funding. From whom and by whom? From and by one group alone, the Heads of Governments who were never an institution in the Community but who in this legislation are being given the status and are being specifically referred to in Article 2. They were not in the original Treaties but are in now. That is not just a small or minor change.
Comment on this
May I make one comment on that? If the Heads of Governments had done all the things that Deputy O'Kennedy suggested, it does not seem that they were inhibited from doing all those dreadful things by the fact that they had not a place in the Treaty.
Comment on this
This has been tolerated and that is why our voice should be heard publicly, reminding those who should have the interests of the peoples of the Community at heart that they have done quite the opposite, even informally. Now they are being institutionalised and what they could do informally they will now, I can assure the House, do formally. They will now make us feel the small boys that we are. There was no point in the Taoiseach yesterday trying, in his usual public relations projection of himself directed by the handlers, to make it appear that he had them all eating out of his hand at the European Council. The whole thing was amusing. Anybody who has been there, such as the Minister for Foreign Affairs, knows that to be a total farce. Nobody believes that. One can imagine Kohl and Thatcher eating out of the Taoiseach's hand.
Comment on this
That is a drastic change. I say to Deputy Molony that it should suggest to the Government what will happen and they make no provision in the Bill. They do not even incorporate the major change referred to in Article 2. On political co-operation, I have, as has the Minister for Foreign Affairs, sat on committees on co-operation which were informal and that was the significance of it. They sat to reach informal decisions with nothing binding in any way whatsoever. They tried to reach a consensus and where they could not they did not. I know this from two and a half years of experience there and the Minister knows it from longer experience.
Now we are into a different scene. Political co-operation has advanced a stage further. Now for the first time certain things "shall be" done and certain things "will be" done. The Commission is now being incorporated as an institution of political co-operation, which it never was. The Commission is meant to be the custodian of the values of the European Community. I acknowledge that it failed many times but its role is to protect the Treaties and the Minister says that there is no major change. It is stated in the Act:
The Presidency and the Commission, each within its own sphere of competence, shall have responsibility for ensuring that such consistency is sought and maintained...
It goes on to say what the responsibilities extend to, as follows:
Closer co-operation on questions of European security would contribute in an essential way to the development of a European identity in external policy matters.
They are ready to co-ordinate their positions more closely on the political and economic aspects of security. The Commission are being brought in to achieve this.
It goes on to say:
The high contracting parties are determined to maintain the technological and industrial conditions necessary for their security.
We do not know what is involved in that.
They are determined now to introduced a whole range of industrial innovation, as it is euphemistically called, for their security. We are talking about arms procurement, about the whole basis of industry, for instance, the United States which are inevitably and fundamentally linked with an armaments programme, about industrial research innovation. These are all linked inevitably with armaments programmes and that is what is being incorporated here. What has been done in American will now be done through the European Community. It says that they shall work to that end at national level. That is telling us in the clearest possible terms, as one of the high contracting parties signing this, that we shall work to that end at national level and, where appropriate, within the framework of the competent institutions and bodies. There is no point in making general statements or a briefing from the Attorney General. I know him and some of his advisers personally and I have practised law with them but I am not satisfied with a formal statement read by the Minister and a text prepared by officials. The Attorney General, allowing for his obvious conviction, is not regarded as being widely experienced in the law as he is the most junior Attorney General ever appointed. He came in at the level of junior counsel, he was not even an established senior counsel.
Comment on this
For what it is worth, I took silk after twelve years as a junior barrister. The Minister must have gone through the Act in some detail over a considerable amount of time in negotiations and he must be fairly familiar with the pitfalls associated with it. He should persuade us that it is right from the depth of his conviction and knowledge of the constitutional and legal implications, without reading from a text written for him by the Attorney General.
The terms in these Articles mean something specific. It says that nothing in this title shall impede closer co-operation in the field of security between certain of the high contracting parties within the framework of the Western European Alliance or the Atlantic Alliance. You could take two meanings our of that. It could mean that it will enable NATO and the Western European Alliance to continue on their present course and it could also be argued that nothing shall impede the closer co-operation in the field of security between the people in those fora. Whatever we do will certainly not compromise NATO. I could go through the Act endlessly, it is disgraceful that the House is confined to a few hours debate on such an important issue. I have sat here for a while but I did not learn anything from the Minister. We have not heard a clear statement which is not the case in relation to other member states. The Minister is certainly not enlightening us and his junior Minister, who has some experience in law, has not——
Comment on this
I read it. I have it in front of me and it says that the Community shall adopt measures with the aim of progressing, do you not understand what "shall" means?
Comment on this
The Deputies should address the Chair and those who have not the Floor should not interrupt.
Comment on this
Article 8 A tells us that we shall adopt measures with the aim of progressively establishing the internal market over a period expiring on 31 December 1992. Using a mix of political and legal experience, I have no doubt that when it comes to 1992 and if Ireland is still holding out against the harmonisation of laws because it does not suit us or we cannot afford it, we will be reminded that our veto has been tolerated for four years but that we had better refer to Article 8 A. The Act is full of provisions in relation to the role of the Commission and they clearly state that Articles within the existing Treaty of Accession shall be replaced by deletions of the original Treaty of Rome to which we acceded when we signed our Treaty of Accession which was confirmed by a referendum.
The amendments in the names of Deputy Collins and Deputy Treacy are at least a recognition that nothing done here will affect the Act. I do not understand why the Minister will not give us a clear declaration as happened is so many member states.
Comment on this
That was a most extraordinary contribution to a European debate in the House compared with others made by Deputy O'Kennedy when he spoke about the high ideals in Europe, the necessity to move Europe forward and his party's commitment to peace and security——
Comment on this
I did not interrupt the Deputy, please be quiet. The Deputy misrepresents the position. He did not quote the relevant part from Article 8 which says that setting the date at 31 December 1992 does not create an automatic legal effect.
Comment on this
Order, please. The Deputy should not interrupt. I said that when Deputy O'Kennedy was speaking and I am repeating it now.
Comment on this
To pretend there is a big plot by the European Council, which has been meeting "informally" three times a year for the last ten or 12 years and we are now formalising those meetings, is really like Alice in Wonderland. The Heads of State and the Heads of Government got together informally three times a year over the last ten or 12 years and made recommendations, which were in effect decisions, to the Council of Ministers which adopted them. One of those was at the Milan Summit and another one was the setting up of the Dooge Committee. Up to now these Heads of State and Heads of Government met "informally" and the formal decision was taken at another time. That was a charade. This is being formalised in the Single European Act.
The same applies to political co-operation. Up to now the Council has been meeting four times a year; that, too, is now being formalised. The pretended threat Deputy O'Kennedy sees in this is totally unreal as he knows well, because he was a member for two and a half years. Every decision can only be taken by consensus. Since the Single European Act was signed last February there has not been consensus on a number of major issues as Deputy Collins knows because I answered a question about it yesterday. The Twelve members of the European Community voted three different ways in the United Nations — abstaining for and against. That is the basis of political co-operation. Deputy O'Kennedy used a spurious argument to heighten fears. He knows we are merely formalising what has been the practice for the last ten or 12 years.
Comment on this
I asked the Minister if he would address himself to precise decisions and answer on the basis of a precise constitutional justification or a juridical interpretation of what these Articles mean. There is no point telling me in broad waffle about threats. I did not say they were a threat in every sense of the word.
I am worried because this was not an institution of the European Community initially for the very good reason that the founding fathers knew that was the forum where the big countries would dominate the small: the Heads of Government, amid the glare of publicity, meeting twice a year, would dominate the smaller countries and the Community interest would not be consistently expressed. In their wisdom the founding fathers excluded it. The Council of Ministers meet every one or two weeks and has a certain permanence and cohesion. For that reason it creates a different atmosphere.
As I said, this institution was not in the original Treaties but it is being established here as an institution. Why is the Minister not prepared to justify or explain the fact that this should at least involve a specific amendment because that particular section is not even being covered in this legislation.
Comment on this
The Irish people would be entitled to say they do not like what is happening even informally but they will worry a great deal about what will happen if it is formal. In my view the failure of the European Community over the last eight years particularly has been due almost exclusively to the informal meeting of the Heads of Government.
Comment on this
They are the people who failed to supply the funds. They are the people who dominated everything.
Article 8 is very specific and I do not understand how the Minister can be in any doubt about it. It says that we shall do certain things by a certain date. How can the Minister say I am misrepresenting this when I am only reading it? It says that the Community shall adopt measures with the aim of progressively establishing the internal market over a period expiring on 31 December 1992.
Comment on this
This is a declaration which does not create an automatic legal effect. Of course it does not create an automatic legal effect. Does the Minister think that is protection? It will not automatically take effect now, but in 1992 if we have not been acting in accordance with these provisions, we will be reminded that it shall take effect by 1992.
Comment on this
I would remind them of Protocol No. 30 at that point. I referred specifically to the statements——
Comment on this
I am not happy about just hopes. Like everyone else, I want guarantees that we have to implement. I want to ask the Minister to address himself to specific points. I want him to tell me how these are not major changes.
The external policies of the European Community and the policies agreed in political co-operation must be consistent.
The Presidency and the Commission, each within its own sphere of competence, shall have special responsibility for ensuring that such consistency is sought and maintained.
The Commission never had a role in this area before. It was purely a economic proposal.
(a) The High Contracting Parties consider that closer co-operation on questions of European security would contribute in an essential way to the development of a European identity in external policy matters. They are ready to co-ordinate their positions more closely on the political and economic aspects of security.
(b) The High Contracting Parties are determined to maintain the technological and industrial conditions necessary for their security...
If that is not linking the technological and industrial conditions to security needs I do not know what is. They will say it is necessary for security. These arguments have been made for some time. One of the things we have to look for is a common base on arms procurement. Anyone who ignores that is ignoring what has been happening in Europe for the last number of years.
I am saying that that is incorporating new elements which were not in the 1972 Treaty of Accession. These are not just minor changes in the Treaty, they are major developments. If the Government were to come in here and admit they were major developments and that they wanted to argue the rights and wrongs of them, at least we could have an honest open argument but when I am told in this House by the Minister and his Minister of State that these are only minor adjustments, that is an offence to the House. I have no doubt that Deputy Collins, Deputy Treacy and other Deputies will probably want better guarantees.
Deputy Collins's amendment says that nothing in this Act shall operate so as to limit or qualify the fundamental rights of the citizens and guarantee them protection by Articles 40 to 44 of the Constitution. These are fundamental rights which cannot be undermined by external action. That does not seem to be unreasonable. We should debate this for another month, and not just for the sake of debating it. People will look back on this Dáil in a number of years time and they will say, they were a petty, puny lot because they spent four or five hours debating something so fundamental that they did not seem to be aware of their own sovereign rights and obligations. In order that that does not happen we should do something about it now.
Comment on this
Deputy Haughey spent 22 years discussing the leadership and made no decision. The people could not get rid of him.
Comment on this
There was a great deal of time spent in 1972 on the question of our accession to the EC, advocated so strongly by Deputy O'Kennedy, the Fianna Fáil Party and the Fine Gael Party. They went to very considerable pains to bring this country into the EC. They twist this way and that way now, many years later——
Comment on this
They have twisted and turned in the course of this debate, conveniently ignoring that they were key instrumentalists in bringing us down that European road which brought us to the present position. The Labour Party and others campaigned against our entry to the EC. Many people outside might concede now that the prognosis that we saw emanating from our entry to the EC was a well judged one. The ills and serious economic problems of the country have flowed from our entry to the EC. If we had opted then to stay out — at that time it was a very real option — the economic development and the course——
Comment on this
The Deputy is probably a little bit away from the amendment, both in time and in material.
Comment on this
I do not accept that. I am putting the Single European Act into context with the development of the EC at present. I have to relate that to the position as it emanated since 1972. That is a reasonable thing to do.
Comment on this
The country is in its present position because we joined the EC. So many of our traditional industries have gone by the board as a result of our entry to the EC. Our entry to the EC contributed in a very large and substantial measure to unemployment. Is there any going back now? Are we in a position now to say to the other 11 countries in the EC, whatever our wishes on the matter might be as far as the Single European Act is concerned, that they have decided to go in one direction and we will now veer off and do what we could or should have done in 1972? This is not 1972; it is 1986 and the position is very different. Our food policy and our agricultural position would have been very different if we had stayed outside the EC in 1972. The economic development has proceeded along certain lines and that cannot be denied. There can be no going back. The industries that have gone cannot be recalled. We have to face up to the position we are in now. Can we go sideways or backwards on this? I think not.
We have to face up to the fact that the establishment of the internal market in 1992 is very serious. I am very fearful of what it may involve for us in terms of our economy. What is the point in the Minister referring to the declaration in Article 8 A? He said that the provision for setting the date of 31 December 1992 does not create an automatic legal effect. What is the point in introducing that? It means that there is no automatic provision that, ipso facto, on 31 December 1992 the internal market will come into operation by its own accord. This declaration says it does not mean that. That does not help. Of course it does not operate ipso facto. It has to be done. As Deputy O'Kennedy stated, and it is a fair point, we are nonetheless obligated to bring it in by 31 December 1992, be it automatic or not. If we fail to do that we are in trouble in an EC context. In 1992, the internal market, whether it is automatic, a compulsion of the EC court or whatever compulsory procedures are laid down in the context of the Treaty, will come into operation. I do not see the point in introducing that unless the Minister is saying that there is some method under which we can defer the internal market coming into operation either indefinitely or for a further length of time. If that was the position, that would be different and I would accept it. But that is not the case. We should face up to the fact that the internal market will come into operation in 1992. I have considerable fears as to what the effects of it will be on our economy, our employment, our financial position and the general development of the country.
Comment on this
The contribution made by Deputy Taylor has more to do with his own internal market ambitions than with the internal market of the European Community. I do not think anybody can argue that being outside the biggest economic bloc in the world could be better for a small trading nation like Ireland than being inside that bloc. That is absolute nonsense. I do not think even Deputy Taylor believes that.
In regard to amendments Nos. 1 and 3 of section 1, I cannot understand why Deputies are concerned only with articles 40 to 44 of the Constitution. Does that not indicate, if we were to agree to such an amendment, that the rest of the Constitution — Articles 1 to 40 and Articles 44 on — would be of no consequence, that somehow they could be overridden or that this House would approve of their being interfered with? There are other Articles in the Constitution which are equally as important. You cannot take one section of the Constitution and say it is more important than another section. We must be clear in what we are doing. We are passing legislation. This House has no right to pass any legislation which amends the Constitution. Therefore, we have no right or duty to pass any section or legislation which would uphold only certain parts of the Constitution. The Constitution stands on its own. It does not require the approval of this House or any comment from this House. It belongs to the people and not to the Parliament. It can be amended only by way of referendum after a Bill is passed through this House.
Comment on this
To take Deputy O'Kennedy's point, there is a strong indication that the intention in the amendment is to have this law in keeping with Articles 40 to 44 and not with the other Articles. That is a lot of nonsense. The House does not have the right to abrogate any Article of the Constitution; that function belongs to the people. But, the House has the right, if we are foolish enough, to dilute the powers of the House which are not subject to the Constitution.
I note that the Explanatory Memorandum accompanying the Bill refers to changes in the Treaty, including the incorporation of new procedures designed to enhance the role of the European Parliament in the Community's decision-making process. I would like to get an assurance from the Minister — leaving aside the Constitution which as far as I am concerned is sacrosanct and cannot be interfered with by the House — that the powers of the House not affected by the Constitution will not be diluted by the Bill vis-á-vis the powers of the European Parliament. If we are serious about the European Parliament we will have to give that institution powers at some stage but I do not believe that the way to do it is to insert a small section in the Bill. Will the Minister agree that the section does not interfere with the sovereignty of the House or the powers which by tradition have become its rights?
Comment on this
The Minister of State some time ago told the House that instances where majority decisions would operate were being widened and that the veto would remain. That would lead one to believe that if more matters are decided on a majority decision procedure the veto will not be used as frequently. The Taoiseach told us last night that the Single European Act was required because of the abuse of the veto and that what we were proposing to do in the Single European Act is to make obligatory what heretofore was done voluntarily by agreement. What in hell do we want it for at all bearing in mind what the Taoiseach said last night? Is that as porous as some other statements by the Taoiseach in the House and outside? If we need to make obligatory what we have been doing voluntarily why is the time of the House being wasted? Why has the time of the Heads of State been wasted? What is the reason for the Summit Conferences, Fontainebleau, Milan, Stuttgart and other cities? Why were they jazzing about sorting out the operation in Europe?
What is dangerous underlying that, something the Taoiseach did not refer to, is that because we agreed to certain matters before it does not follow that agreement was reached without the members of the Community getting their say in and shaping policies in a way acceptable to them. That is what consensus was about and that is why the veto was seldom used by us though abused by others.
Certainly, we could not be accused of having abused the veto, being the craven lot we are, suffering from a weighty inferiority complex as part of our national heritage. We have conformed; we are the conventionalists and the good Europeans. The Government, and previous Governments, in their approach to European matters dealt with them by screaming at home to get the headlines but conceding in Europe if the weight was heavy enough. We did not use the veto but while it exists we still have the possibility that our complex might lessen, that our feeling of inferiority will diminish and that somewhere some time some of the young Members in the House will stand up and assert themselves on behalf of our people, something we have not been doing. We have suffered losses since we joined the Community because we did not stand up. That is an irrefutable fact, to our great detriment. Let us think of what will happen in the future after we hand over the decision-making process in regard to everything concerning the country, our economic progress and so on. It will be decided by a Commission dominated by the major countries in Europe. The people who pay the piper are now calling the tune and we are rushing in, like before, to say, "yes, we will put this through before 1 January". How many other countries have passed similar legislation?
Comment on this
They have not passed similar legislation. If we do not pass the Bill we will be showing that we have grown out of our inferiority complex. The Taoiseach last night said that any Member who disagreed with what the Government are doing will be displaying the historical traditional inferiority complex of our race. I take the opposite view. It may be stupid but my view is that those who stand against the head will not be displaying inferiority but rather confidence and strength in themselves. We need that confidence like we never needed it before. We should tell other member states that this is not on, that we cannot agree to it. We should tell them that if they need this badly they should redress certain things. The Government should have done that before they asked the Parliament to give them a right that is ours now but will never be again. There is much that has to be redressed, so much that has to be cleaned up, things that are vital to us, including our economic wellbeing in the future.
It will be disastrous if we allow this thing to go through without correcting the things that have been going wrong for a long time, due to our inferiority complex. We entered the Community freely and by a vast majority, excluding the Labour Party whose speakers hope to adjust now. All of us in all the parties, some of us more than others, have our drones and bees, and you would never know whether it was the drones or the bees, which is which, and which is the worst: there were those who worked for it and those who did not, those who gave just lip service to it, but the referendum was carried on the clear understanding that whatever the final doubts might be, and there were many for those of us who were going for a "yes" vote at the time, there would be benefits for us. I remember a balance sheet for and against entry and it was as close as this: if the UK went in could we stay out? If we stayed out and they went in could we stay out, survive and progress in the future? The question was could we survive if we did not join this great new Community, this big new market that promised us so much then but has failed to deliver since. My doubts were allayed by the belief that if it came to the crunch, and forgetting about our national inferiority complex, we could use the veto, and by becoming bloody nuisances we could get our just dues. What we got was a dismantling of every industry that had been built up during the years under protective tariffs. As Deputy Taylor has said, they have been wiped out. That is the price we have paid, but we have not been paid a price even through the CAP and all that goes with it.
When we went into the Community there was no doubt that we were going into a huge market which was undersupplied in dairy produce and beef. Today they are talking about butter mountains and milk lakes. When we went in they did not have enough. Unfortunately, we did not supply it all since. We made little contribution to the overall surpluses that have since developed. But the wise boys in the better off countries have taken advantage of the CAP that is weighing down the Community. It is being used by those countries: in the Parliament and through the Commission, and through their national parliaments they have been crying that in the Community we can no longer suffer the cost of the CAP.
We are all little farmers in Ireland. One of the mistakes our people in Europe make is to think of our farmers being big if they had 100 acres and 100 cows. All our farmers are small in the European context. We have allowed ourselves to be ripped off. We have compromised into milk quotas and we are being threatened with beef quotas and cereal quotas. At the same time, all of this is pouring in from North America at zero rate tax for the benefit of the multinationals who have set up herds of milch cows, as many as 3,000 in each herd, without owning an acre of land.
That is what we have allowed ourselves to get into. We have been big in Europe, we have been reasonable, we have agreed. I am not from milk country but I voted against on every occasion when there was talk of milk quotas. I fought for what might have been better if we had got them, tiered prices, in order to preserve the small farmers of Europe, to give them all a fair way of living and not to give it to the big, the rich, the better off farmers and ranchers who have been given a licence to continue to rip us off. All this has happened despite Article 29 of the Treaty of Rome which gave agriculture a special place.
How has this been handled by us? Our inferiority complex has dragged us down to a point when we may well become worse off in the near future than we were before we went into the Community. In the meantime, as Deputy Taylor said, many of our industries are gone. Only ten years after we joined, 70 per cent of what has been our industrial workforce in 1973 had gone from those industries. We were paying the price and yet we were being apologetic for existing in Europe. We do not owe them anything and we are not satisfied with the platitudes in the Preamble and the explanations we have been given about the Regional Fund and its benefits to us in the future and about the social fund being of such advantage to us. We do not want dole from Europe. We want a fair deal and we want the dole mitigated and got rid of.
The Tánaiste last night appeared to be a very naive man — I did not think he was. He made a statement which is not just untrue but misleading to a strange degree. He said:
In our approach to the Single European Act negotiations the Government were very conscious, however, that despite the Community's efforts the gap between the more prosperous central regions and the periphery had not narrowed appreciably since 1973.
He must have been in cloud cuckooland. The fact is that it has disimproved vastly since 1973. Relatively speaking, we are far worse off today vis-á-vis Germany than we were in 1973, yet there goes the poor man who leads the Labour badly, the Tánaiste, second in command to the Taoiseach, saying that “the gap between the more prosperous central regions and the periphery had not narrowed appreciably since 1973.” It must have been the Taoiseach who told him that one.
Comment on this
Just for the benefit of Deputy Prendergast and others who might rely on his interpretation, I will read the quotation again. It is: "The gap between the more prosperous, central regions and the periphery had not narrowed appreciably." That suggests that it had narrowed somewhat.
Comment on this
There is no man clearer than Deputy Blaney. The Deputy should not try to misinterpret him.
Comment on this
I only wish he would say the sort of things that I say but he does not. I shall continue to quote what he had to say:
In our approach to the Single European Act negotiations, the Government were very conscious, however, that — despite the Community's efforts — the gap between the more prosperous central regions and the periphery had not narrowed appreciably since 1973...
The clear implication being that they had narrowed somewhat. The fact is that they have widened the gap. That is the point I was making.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I hate to disagree with the very fine Second Stage speech being made by Deputy Blaney. I listened to him in 1972——
Comment on this
It is not a Second Stage speech. We are on section 1, dealing with amendments Nos. 1 and 3 to that section.
Comment on this
We should adhere to the amendments before the House and discuss them. If we are to continue at this rate we will not have disposed of the few amendments before the vote takes place this evening.
Comment on this
We are on section 1, dealing with amendments Nos. 1 and 3 in connection with that section. Would Deputy Dowling please resume his seat?
Comment on this
I appreciate what it is like to have to sit and listen. At least Deputy Dowling is entitled to rise, I was not, I was here six hours last evening and I was not allowed to speak at all. That is why I have to say so much this evening.
Comment on this
At least Deputy Dowling knows he can rise here. I do not. Deputy Taylor said that Labour did not want to join the Community. That is not news to me. All I would say to him in that event is: why support this Bill because what they were objecting to in 1972 is being added to? Therefore they should be with us this evening to defeat the God damn thing and put it out of pain until we get things sorted out.
Comment on this
Deputy Blaney should not forget that this is 1986 and the country is in a very different situation now compared with then.
Comment on this
I say that seriously to Deputy Taylor because I appreciate his viewpoint then and now. I do not appreciate his mode of deduction in the meantime. Nor do I appreciate what he has said just now — that time has moved on, this is 1986, and the situation is different from that of 1972. I quite agree with him. That is why I want to see this Bill not passed, so that we do not adopt the Single European Act until we have straightened out all the corners and bends on the wrong road we took since 1972. If we did that, then we could come back and talk about it, agreeably together, and to the benefit of the country.
Comment on this
What is happening here is that we are giving the authority to what will become the twelve wise men to rehash the Treaty of Rome, to add to it or take from it. Yet under the Constitution we do not have the competence or authority of the people to give that right to anybody. It should be remembered that they did not give it to us in 1972. To those who would make the point, that we have made various changes since, I would say that any changes effected since were done under the existing code which meant that one got agreement and unanimity or one did not effect the change. That meant that we had a voice equal to the voice of any other in the implementation of any such changes. Henceforth we will not have such a voice. That is what I object to. That is what I believe to be totally dangerous and which should not be considered until we have sorted out the problems obtaining within the Community at present.
In deference to Deputy Dowling who has run out of patience much quicker than I did last evening, I will cease for the moment.
Comment on this
I am not sure whether Deputy Blaney was suggesting that we should leave the EC. If he is not suggesting that, then his argument would suggest that that is what he would want.
Deputy Blaney made two major points, one regarding the effect on industries here of our joining the Community, referring to the number that have gone to the wall. I put it to Deputy Blaney that, irrespective of our membership of the EC, those industries would have choked themselves because many of them were archaic, old fashioned, badly-managed and were coming to the end of their life-cycle one way or the other.
Comment on this
I said that, in many cases, those industries were archaic and reaching the end of their life-cycle.
Comment on this
I thought the Deputy was talking about the régime coming to the end of its life-cycle.
Comment on this
No, I can assure Deputy Blaney that we are not coming to the end of our tether, nor are we archaic. Mind you the Deputy described himself as being archaic in as much as he said he did not represent the people any longer.
Deputy Blaney spoke also about the disparity between the richer and poorer areas of the Community and maintained that that gap was widening. I might draw the Deputy's attention to the Single European Act where, under the heading of "Economic and Social Cohesion", there is a commitment to narrow that gap. If the Deputy is interested in narrowing that gap, then he should support the Bill.
I might turn now to Deputy O'Kennedy's contribution. He said here that he had little or no respect for our Attorney General. It appears to me that on that side of the House our Judiciary have been insulted both this morning and afternoon. If Deputy O'Kennedy gives credit to experience within the judicial system then I might draw his attention to Pierre Pescatore, who, as the Deputy will know, is a former Justice of the European Court and a protagonist of the Single European Act, an eminent diplomat. He has said that the Single European Act — unlike what Deputy O'Kennedy said — constitutes a moderate and insignificant change from the Treaty of Rome. If Deputy O'Kennedy does respect silk and the judicial system generally, he should appreciate that remark.
Comment on this
Indeed, I could. Deputy O'Kennedy said also that this debate was too little, too late. An opportunity for debate was available to Deputy O'Kennedy's colleague Deputy Gerry Collins, who, as chairman of the Joint Committee on Secondary Legislation of the EC, could have demanded a report at any time which would have afforded an opportunity to have had this debate held much earlier.
Another aspect of this debate has been the implied insult to the contribution of the Government in bringing forward the Single European Act. It should be remembered that the cohesion aspect was subject to the beck and call of this Government, which has been totally under estimated and ignored by the Opposition. Perhaps Deputy Collins might reply to the fact that there was inadequate debate on the matter when he had opportunity to bring the matter forward for such discussion.
Comment on this
I am glad to have an opportunity of making a few comments on the two amendments before the House. Having listened to Deputy Blaney and others on the opposite side, one would be of the opinion that they were totally opposed to our entry into the EC. Yet they are now extremely anxious that we withdraw our membership.