Ceisteanna — Questions. Oral Answers. - Health Boards.
- Health board numbers and reform 8 speeches
Mitchell called for reform, citing weak accountability, overdue audits and top-heavy structures, while asking whether the number of boards should be reduced. O’Hanlon ruled out reducing their number but said he was reviewing board structures and management arrangements.
Gay Mitchell, Rory O'Hanlon, Robert Molloy
- Galway representation on Western Health Board 5 speeches
Molloy protested that Galway city had lacked representation on the Western Health Board since 1986. The Minister said Galway’s representation would be considered as part of a review of health board structures, but gave no timetable.
Robert Molloy, Seán Treacy, Rory O'Hanlon
- Health board spending and audits 4 speeches
Mitchell asked about health board spending and the audit backlog; O’Hanlon put total spending at approximately £750 million, without addressing the audit concerns.
Gay Mitchell, Seán Treacy, Rory O'Hanlon
- Galway representation on Western Health Board 12 speeches
Molloy again pressed the Minister to explain the delay in restoring Galway city’s representation. The Chair directed him to pursue the matter separately, and Molloy gave notice of an Adjournment debate.
Robert Molloy, Seán Treacy
asked the Minister for Health if he has plans to reduce the number of health boards.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree that the health boards are in urgent need of reform and democratisation? There is a feeling that they are aloof from the people and are not accountable to the Department of Health, to this House or to the local authorities. Would the Minister further agree that the spending of the health boards is not adequately monitored since the auditing of the health board accounts is in arrears and, again, there is no direct accountability either to this House or the local authorities? Because of those two points I ask the Minister to reconsider this matter.
Comment on this
I am satisfied the health boards are representative of the people, the local authority and the professional people working in the health service.
Comment on this
They are subject to local government audit in the same way as other local authorities.
Comment on this
The Minister will be aware that the local government audit in most cases is seriously in arrears. Will he agree that the health boards are topheavy at board level and programme manager level and that there is urgent need for reform? The whole system lacks accountability and any sort of credibility.
Comment on this
We are examining reform in the health boards. The Deputy's question refers specifically to the number of health boards, and it is not my intention to reduce the number. My intention is to review the structures in the health boards particularly in relation to the programmes and whether there should be a general manager in a geographic area.
Comment on this
I do not know how the Minister can claim the local authorities are represented on the health boards when he has denied the County Borough of Galway representation on the health board since he came into office and it has been denied since January 1986. For a period of two years one of the major local authorities has had no representation——
Comment on this
We are considering the structures in the health boards and representation from other authorities such as the County Borough of Galway will be considered in that context. The county councils and the boroughs of Dublin, Limerick, Waterford and Cork are represented on the health boards. Many of the local authorities are not but we will be considering the question in relation to Galway.
Comment on this
How much was spent by health boards in the most recent year for which the Minister has figures? How can he be satisfied with the current audit situation and the accountability that appertains in the health boards?
Comment on this
They lack accountability either to Parliament or the local authority. Will the Minister agree there is need for reform here? How much did the health boards spend in total last year?
Comment on this
The Minister in replying to the supplementary gave no clear indication of when he was going to give representation on the Western Health Board to the County Borough of Galway.
Comment on this
I wish to give notice of my intention to raise this matter on the Adjournment tonight.
Comment on this
This question asks what plans the Minister may have to reduce the number of health boards, full stop.