Intoxicating Liquor Bill, 1988: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–128 of 254. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 13 of 1988 ›
We are on amendment No. 5 and with amendment No. 5 we are taking amendments Nos. 6 and 46.
Comment on this
Perhaps I will restate what I was talking about before the sos. These amendments deal with the size of the waiting area of the anteroom adjacent to a restaurant. There is general agreement between the Minister and the different spokespeople about the fact that this should be designated in some way and — relating to Deputy Barrett's amendment — that those who are waiting should be waiting to have a meal in the restaurant. However, the Minister seemed to indicate that the ante-room or waiting area should be restricted to diners who are there before their meal and that it should not be available to those who have finished a meal, who have reached the coffee stage and who wish to finish their bottle of wine or whatever drink they have in the waiting area. This is a reasonable practice and, as Deputy Kelly said, it allows the restaurant proprietor to make room for other diners and to clear the tables. It is reasonable to request that the ante-room should be available for that purpose. I will be interested to hear the Minister's views because he seems to be indicating that he wants diners to finish their meal and, if they wish to have a post-prandial drink, to get into their cars and find a licensed premises somewhere in the locality. That is a most unrealistic suggestion.
Comment on this
I believe he means it but perhaps he has not given it full consideration. The Bill deals with high quality restaurants — not takeaways or fast food joints — and people who frequent such restaurants do not expect to be shifted and shunted around the locality to satisfy their needs for the night. At present, that certainly is not the case and it would ultimately be a step backwards if the Minister insists on such an interpretation of the Bill.
Section 7 (1) (iii) states that intoxicating liquor must be consumed in the waiting area of the restaurant before the meal by the person for whom the meal was ordered, consumed in the waiting area or else within 30 minutes of the finish of the meal, in the dining area. On a number of counts, that will not be easy to control. The waiting area should also be used for the consumption of alcohol after the meal in a reasonable fashion. Most people who go for a meal expect to finish it in comfort, including a bottle of wine, in congenial surroundings adjacent to the restaurant or part of the restaurant premises.
I do not know how the 30 minutes rule will be policed. Perhaps the Minister will say how he envisages that being dealt with. Diners who come in at 8 o'clock in the evening could finish their meal at around 9.30 p.m. or 9.45 p.m. but other diners may not start their meal until 11 o'clock. Who will be able to tell which diner has finished the meal, which diner is waiting and which has finished the meal an hour and a half ago? It cannot be policed and will bring the law into disrepute like so many other laws. It is high time we moved away from implementing legislation that is inoperable.
Comment on this
Many of the points made by Deputy Kelly, Deputy Cooney and Deputy Colley are reasonable, civilised and understandable. However, in relation to licensing laws, the average punter in the street fails to understand why places in Leeson Street are open until 4 a.m. and that some hotels will serve pints at 1 a.m. They wonder why they cannot get a drink in a ballroom. The law is being abused and it is very hard to argue against many of the points made. Nobody would object to people going into an ordinary restaurant having a meal and a drink and then going home. However, there are loopholes in regard to the special restaurant licence——
Comment on this
Of course it will depend on enforcement but the police have a lot more to do than going around every restaurant to check the position. We can provide for the sort of entertainment to which Deputies have referred in relation to people having a drink with a meal and, at the same time, tighten the provisions of this Bill to counteract the possible loopholes. That is why I have tabled amendment No. 6 to clearly indicate in legislation that a waiting area is a place where people wait to have a meal and have a drink while waiting.
The Minister indicated that he would look at these amendments. I do not know whether he intends to accept amendment No. 6. Perhaps he is not happy with the wording. Does he have a proposal for Report Stage? My amendment does not put an onus on Bord Fáilte but, if the Minister does not intend to accept it, perhaps he will explain why.
Comment on this
As I said earlier in dealing with the amendments tabled by Deputy Colley and Deputy Barrett, I am also very conscious of the size of the waiting area. I am anxious that waiting areas should not be large enough to constitute bars, as happened in Northern Ireland, when it was necessary for them to legislate to prevent these restricted licences becoming full bar licences in a very short period of time. Having regard to their experience it is my intention to limit, as a percentage of the restaurant dining area proper, the size of the waiting room. I do not intend to put any restricition on anybody having a drink, or a number of drinks, as I said in reply to Deputy Kelly. People may have as many drinks as they wish up to 30 minutes after their meal at the table where the meal was served.
Comment on this
For the simple reason that we would have no way of enforcing a provision if there was a free-for-all in a private room or a waiting room afterwards. We have learned from the experience in Northern Ireland where that happened.
Comment on this
The Deputy may say it is part of a meal if she wishes but, as far as I am concerned, a person may have the drink with the substantial meal. For instance, if I am having Ballygowan with my meal I do not necessarily want to have to believe that it is part of my meal.
Comment on this
I should like to tell Deputy Colley, who persists in going to the type of restaurant that does not allow her have her cup of coffee at her table, that she should consider going downmarket where she will find a number of restaurants who will allow her do that. I recognise the thrust of Deputy Barrett's amendment and I am prepared on Report Stage to come forward with a definite proposal which will limit the size of the waiting areas so as to avoid the creation of a new pub.
Comment on this
I do not think the size is the issue. It could be an issue if the waiting area was extended beyond what would be reasonable for a given sized restaurant but I am concerned about the use of the waiting area, whatever its size. We could restrict the size but we could have something we never intended. If the Minister accepts the wording in my amendment he will not be inhibited in bringing forward on Report Stage a provision in regard to size.
Comment on this
The House should accept the Minister's willingness to consider this matter between now and Report Stage. We must never get away from the main purpose of the Bill which is to permit the serving of intoxicating liquor with a meal. We do not have a definition as to what is a waiting area in a restaurant and I hope one is produced between now and Report Stage. Is there such a definition in respect of restaurants that serve wine in accordance with their wine licence? I was interested to hear Deputy Taylor's comments in regard to a waiting area. I should like to get an assurance from the Minister that drinks served in a restaurant with a substantial meal will appear on the bill for the meal. That is important.
Comment on this
I understand Deputy Barrett's concern in regard to a strict definition of "waiting area" and between now and Report Stage I will try to produce an amendment that will tighten up that definition so that it will mean what we want it to mean, a waiting area where people wait while ordering a meal or waiting for a vacant table.
Comment on this
It may be that the Minister, when considering this between now and Report Stage, will have it suggested to him by his officials, or it may occur to him spontaneously, that some questions in regard to the use to which the waiting area may be put could arise in the context of possible abuse. In other words, it might seem to him, or his officials, relevant to consider questions of the provision of entertainment or the facilitation of entertainment over and above having a drink in a waiting area. If that should be so I should like to ask the Minister to incorporate a special power. I should like to ask him either to express in the Bill whatever restrictions he intends in this regard or to extend section 12, which empowers the Minister for Tourism and Transport to make regulations because, as it stands, it might not appear at a later date to a court to be wide enough to empower the Minister for Tourism and Transport to make regulations of a kind that do not relate to what might be called touristic standards. The question of deciding, for reasons which do not have anything to do with tourism but everything to do with not providing unfair competition, on regulations might put the Minister for Tourism and Transport in a position that he might do something ultra vires, have this struck down and umpteen prosecutions invalidated.
Comment on this
In section 12 the Deputy will see that if the Minister for Tourism and Transport makes regulations he must do so with the consent of the Minister for Justice.
Comment on this
I have no doubt that is so but my point is — I had not anticipated speaking about this point which came into my mind a moment ago and I would like to have had time to think about it — that each Minister has a certain role and a certain battery of statutory functions and he is not entitled to exercise those statutory functions by reference to purposes which are the business of a different Minister or authority. A plethora of authorities are involved in this legislation, the Minister for Justice, the Minister for Tourism and Transport, the Garda Síochána and Bord Fáilte. There are not too many Acts on the Statute Book that involve as many as four authorities in their administration. It is fine to give the Minister for Tourism and Transport power to make regulations provided they are relevant to his role.
Comment on this
My amendment seeks to insert the words, "which may be designated in size by the Board". The Minister has said that regulations made by the Minister for Tourism and Transport may deal with the size of the waiting area in relation to the restaurant but another provision in the Bill states that those regulations by the Minister for Tourism and Transport may not be made. Bord Fáilte, who will be in the position of designating a premises as a bona fide restaurant, should be given the responsibility of stating what constitutes a proper waiting area in the restaurant they are examining.
I do not think we should enter the size of the waiting room in the section but Bord Fáilte should have responsibility for maintaining a proper ratio between the two areas in the one premises. If they are given that responsibility we will get over any difficulties that may arise if regulations are not put forward by the Minister for Tourism and Transport. So that there will be no doubt in regard to this, I am suggesting that Bord Fáilte be empowered to designate the size of the restaurant and the waiting area. Officials from Bord Fáilte, after all, will be inspecting such premises on a regular basis. I would ask the Minister to consider that.
Comment on this
I must admit that this talk about the size of the waiting area as opposed to that of the restaurant area escapes me. I do not see the point of it. Are we saying that if the waiting area is small drinking per se is all right there? Is there a fear that if the waiting area is too large in comparison with the size of the restaurant the bar facility will thereby be abused? If the waiting area is small, that is all right. All of this is very far removed from what we are providing in the Bill.
We are saying that no part of this restaurant is to be used for the serving of drink without the adjunct of a substantial meal. That is the crucial element. What difference does it make if the waiting area is small, medium or large? If a restaurateur decides he wants a certain size of waiting area, that is his affair. The point which has to be watched is whether he uses this area purely for bar purposes.
We are making this Bill far more complex than it ought to be. To enforce this sort of thing one would need a large-scale map of every premises with the restaurant area edged in red and the waiting area edged in blue so that the gardaí could come in with a measuring tape to see if the boundaires are being observed. If a person wants to bring his dessert into the waiting area, is it the end of the world? This thing is getting out of hand and we are being carried away. If we go much further down this road we will end up in cloud cuckoo land instead of in a restaurant. We are talking about a restaurant premises where there is a waiting area and a dining area. We are trying to ensure that the drinking which takes place there is in association with a substantial meal. That is provided for in section 7. The only aspect with which I am not happy is that it does not provide for people to finish off drinks or have a drink after they finish their meal in the same way as before they start the meal. I do not see that any great differential ought to be drawn between those two situations. We must move away from these complexities which have been introduced because of pressures from outside lobbies. If we do not we will have messy, unenforceable and not very sensible legislation.
Comment on this
I would have to disagree with Deputy Taylor. The waiting area is of the utmost importance. Most Deputies have spoken about abuses. This area has the greatest potential for abuse. I do not like to hear about a percentage of the premises being designated as a waiting area. A large premises will have a large waiting area which will have the potential to be a lounge bar. There is no way it can be competently policed and controlled. The Minister is trying to ensure that these restaurants can supply intoxicating drink with a meal. If we provide a waiting area it will become a bar, a lounge, or a saloon for drinking purposes. Deputy Taylor mentioned taking the dessert to the waiting area at the end of the meal.
Comment on this
Then there is the 30-minute period. Is that where we introduce the toothpick? I am very concerned about abuse of this waiting area.
Comment on this
I was endeavouring while Deputy Colley was speaking to ensure that she would not be interrupted. I must do the same in respect of Deputy Jacob.
Comment on this
I am very concerned about the size and the use of the waiting area and how it might develop over a period. Will there be jugglers there to make it attractive or people doing handstands or playing the fiddle? We should be talking about a restaurant which has a licence to provide drinks with a meal. I should like the drinks and the meal to be incorporated on the same tab at the end of the evening.
Comment on this
We should be discussing the purpose of the waiting area rather than its size. The Minister has stated he will ensure that provision is made in the Bill to copperfasten this aspect of the Bill. We all know what happened when seemingly harmless clubs were given the go-ahead some years ago. I know one town in County Meath which has 15 clubs. Nobody knows how the books are kept and in some cases it is not known who is operating the clubs. The licensing trade has got out of hand. The Minister is to be commended on listening to every submission. It is important to ensure that there will not be abuses such as the addition of ballrooms to existing restaurants. I know that is not the intention but we must eliminate the possibility.
Comment on this
I am proposing to amend the definition of "waiting area" to read as follows:
"waiting area" means an area set aside as a waiting area in a restaurant the purpose of which is solely to accommodate persons who are waiting, bona fide, to have a meal in the said restaurant.
I am not talking about the size of the waiting area.
Comment on this
It says that it is a place set aside for persons intending to have a meal. What more can we say without repeating ourselves?
Comment on this
Section 12 gives the Minister for Tourism, with the consent of the Minister for Justice, power to make regulations to deal with the size of the waiting area. I do not see why we have to have a provision if a further amendment which Deputy Colley and I have down says that the Minister for Tourism and Transport shall make regulations, as distinct from may make them. We are guaranteed, if that amendment is accepted, that regulations will be made. Those regulations can cater for the size of the waiting area as provided in the Bill. In the meantime, let us talk about the purpose of the waiting area, which is what I am endeavouring to do here.
There is an impression that because you make a point you are against the person who wants to go out and have a meal and a drink with it. Like Deputy Taylor, I attend many restaurants in town and know what is happening. Equally, I know what is going to happen. I have been given evidence which shows that some of the bright boys have already moved in and bought premises where they intend opening night clubs under the legislation as it stands at present. The idea is that you have a disco on the ground floor or in the basement and a restaurant on the first floor. You call the ground floor or basement the waiting area and provide drink and disco music. How can you ask a garda to try to prove that any person there is not waiting for a table upstairs? I am not in any way trying to interfere with the normal restaurant with a waiting area, a place in which people have a genuine meal and drink, and a cigar if they wish, can chat for two or three hours after a meal and go home. I want to prevent the bright boys, under a special restaurant licence costing £3,000, from upsetting genuine businesses built up at very high cost and employing many people, paying PRSI and so forth.
I put this amendment down so that there would be no doubt as to the purpose of a waiting area. It is for people who are waiting to have a meal and the vast majority of those finish their meal, have a drink at their table, get up and go home. We do not want to interfere with them in any way. There is at present wholesale abuse of the licensing laws and we as legislators should be doing something about it. I do not want another loophole created on the introduction of special restaurant licences. I would ask people to think about the possible abuses. There are masses of abuses that could be introduced under this section at the cost of £3,000 and £50 renewal fee. I have no time for those who have broken the law consistently and put genuine people out of business. Of the three ballrooms in this city, one is up for sale at the moment. The city is left with only two ballrooms because there were abuses of the exemption laws in relation to licences. Because people who go to discos and get drink there, other people were put out of business, bands were put of business, causing a lot of unemployment.
Comment on this
I am not going to defend anybody who breaks the law, or to allow legislation to be passed when it is obvious that there will be abuses.
Comment on this
Deputy Barrett particularly makes the case that there are people who are already looking for loopholes in this legislation but it relates to the type of business in which there are already abuses — the disco and late night drinking fields. If the purpose of this part of the Bill is to provide legitimate restaurants with the facility of serving alcohol with meals, let us confine ourselves to thinking about those situations and deal on a separate basis with the anomalies that have already occurred in the present legislation. Let us not penalise the legitimate traders and restaurant owners.
Comment on this
Let me define what I mean by penalising. We are now going to refuse to allow legitimate restaurants to carry on their legitimate business as they do at the moment, which includes people retiring to a waiting area after a meal and meals being served throughout the day, on the basis that this will give rise to abuses, whatever that means. I put it to the House that, to a great number of people, it seems to mean that the trade carried on so far by licensed vintners may be threatened. In other words, we are not allowed to develop different aspects of the drink trade because it might impinge on the existing trade. That is incomprehensible and indefensible. If we continue along the road we are taking with the Bill before us, we will penalise legitimate restaurant owners because we will not allow them the full potential to which their business is entitled. I would be one of the first to say let us close the loopholes in relation to late night drinking and discos, certainly, but this is not the way to do it. They will find loopholes in this legislation too. Let us address that matter in proper terms in proper legislation.
Comment on this
It is not the intention of anybody to penalise the restaurateurs in any way whatsoever. It is very wrong to keep suggesting, as Deputy Colley is, that that appears to be the intention. It is not accepted by the restaurateurs that that is the intention, that that is what is proposed.
Comment on this
Representations made by the restaurateurs show that they are satisfied with what is there with regard to the waiting area. The genuine restaurateurs do not ever want to become involved in the bar trade. They recognise that in their own interests they must hold the line as much as we would want them to. Their licences come up for renewal at the end of the year and if they are involved in trade other than the bona fide restaurant trade, they will be in serious difficulty with regard to their licences.
In Northern Ireland legislation framed as we are now framing ours, was grossly abused. We are learning from that experience. What Deputy Barrett has said is correct with regard to people trying to move in to get themselves ready to avail of loopholes. Some of those involved in the licensed trade generally are the first to see a loophole. On behalf of the vintners whom I have met, in the country and in the city, I must say that they are not interested in loopholes. They want this legislation properly set up and running from the word go. The main comment I get from those involved in the licensed trade is that there should be one rule right across the board for everybody and that if that law is enforced there would be no difficulties. We want to get as near to that as possible. Deputy Colley may not understand or know the scene as outlined by Deputy Sean Barrett.
Comment on this
If Deputy Colley does, she should readily understand why Deputy Barrett is trying to tighten up the definition of a waiting area. I accept the thrust of his amendment. I have no objection to it. My only difficulty is that I have already had discussions with the parliamentary draftsman to try to come up with an appropriate format of words, as I do not think that Deputy Barrett's format of words will do what he, I and others want it to do. On Report Stage we will have the benefit of the advice of the parliamentary draftsman, incorporating the thrust of Deputy Barrett's amendment.
It is wrong to suggest that restaurateurs would be penalised if the areas in which drinks could be had while waiting for a meal were specified as being within a certain size. I understand the concern Deputy Taylor showed in his contribution. The Deputy said that what we are talking about here is allowing drinks in association with a substantial meal. That is true, but we want to ensure that others who would not be half as scrupulous or as honest as Deputy Taylor and others in this House will not drive a coach and four through this so that we finish up having the Leeson Street strip scene throughout the length and breath of the country. That is what I am trying to prevent and I say that without apology to anybody.
I accept that Deputy Colley is not trying to advocate the extension of the Leeson Street scene but I am strongly advised that if we do not do as we are doing there is every likelihood that that is what will develop. If we define the size of the waiting areas it is not for the purpose of making anybody hang a chart on the wall saying that areas in green constitute the dining room proper and that areas in red constitute the waiting room, and so on. Nobody wants anything like that or to cause extra hassle for restaurateurs who are making a living and providing a good facility. The genuine restaurateurs are more than anxious that we tighten up this definition of the waiting area as is suggested by Deputy Barrett. That is why I can quite readily accept the thrust of what the Deputy is suggesting.
It is wrong to suggest when we are doing this that we are here representing any particular association. That was the second time here today that that accusation has come from the same party — from Deputy Colley now and from Deputy McDowell earlier on. That is not good enough and it is something I want to nail here and now.
Comment on this
Maybe the Minister is forgetting that my amendment is limiting the size of the waiting area.
Comment on this
I will call Deputy Quinn, then Deputy Cooney, and then Deputy Michael Lynch. The Chair reminds the House that we are still on section 6. I recollect from experience that a point can be reached on Committee Stage, and if one goes too far beyond it one could find oneself perhaps not employing the time available to the best advantage. I remind the House that Committee Stage must finish at 10.30 p.m. this evening.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach gave an undertaking this morning on the Order of Business that that matter could be reviewed.
Comment on this
The Chair must take what is before him at the moment and what I have stated is the position. I remind the House of the position. It is a matter entirely for the House to decide how they want to interpret it. Deputy Quinn.
Comment on this
I have been listening to this debate and I have been concerned, as is the House, at the rather slow progress. I do not know if the Leas-Cheann Comhairle was in the House when the Taoiseach gave that undertaking, that if we did not make sufficient progress the matter might be reviewed. That is outside of our control at this stage and it is a matter for the Whips.
A lot of restaurateurs are located in my constituency in Dublin South East and I have been approached by many and I am reflecting their views. The sort of restaurants I refer to would automatically be included in the top list of premises designated by Bord Fáilte and qualifying on all the other criteria. The restaurateurs' interpretation and their solicitors' interpretation of this Bill, specifically in relation to the points raised, is that where they have a bar they could well be required to remove it. We all know of restaurants around town which have in the waiting area a place where people can sit and drinks are served in the normal way. I accept that but it might be more appropriate to deal with this on Report Stage. However, my constituents' concern is that, on top of having to pay a licence fee, when the Bill becomes law, they will be required to change the layout of the waiting area and remove the bar.
I have been involved in the design of a number of restaurants and so on. The kind of restaurants we want to legalise, of necessity, have a waiting area and a waiting area traditionally has the facility to serve an aperitif or a pre-dinner drink. Because of the storage and the hygienic requirements associated with it, that usually comes from a bar. If the legal interpretation of this Bill is such that owners are required to remove the bar it would damage the operation of the premises as a first-class quality restaurant and we would remove what is the intent of this legislation.
I have read the amendment put down by Deputy Barrett on behalf of Fine Gael and the amendment put down by Deputy Cooney in his own name and I support them. I have been approached by quite a few restaurateurs who have drawn my attention to this point. Some restaurateurs would not apply for a licence because the additional cost implicit in what could be interpreted would be prohibitive along with the cost of the licence.
Comment on this
It seems to be common case that we all want to see a waiting room or an anteroom in addition to the dining area, where people will gather before proceeding to dine and where they will have drinks. The size of the waiting room in relation to the dining area is irrelevant, as Deputy Taylor said. The waiting room will be a premises that will mainly be used for the sale and consumption of intoxicating liquor. That is inevitable, because the liquor that will be consumed will be sold in that room. It will be billed with the meal, but the main use of that room will be for the consumption of intoxicating liquor, while people are waiting to have a meal. That will be the nature of the waiting room.
Section 16 (1) says that a restaurant which has a special restaurant licence shall not contain a bar. The definition of a bar specifies that one of the ingredients of a bar is that it consists of a premises mainly used for the sale of intoxicating liquor, which is what the waiting room will be. The point is that the definition of a bar inevitably and unavoidably includes the waiting room that we have all been talking about. However, section 16 (1) excludes a restaurant from having a bar and we are defining a waiting room as a bar. We have a contradiction here. We cannot have a waiting room in the manner that we have been talking about if we have a definition of a bar as in this section.
Comment on this
The parliamentary draftsman's interpretation is quite acceptable to me. In broadening legislation, which is what we are doing here, we must ensure that we do not make any provision that will give rise to abuses. As I have said, the legislation was broadened so as to allow for the granting of special licences for discos and dinners. There have been abuses down through the years but I am glad that the Minister has reiterated what he said on Second Stage, that is, that there will not be one law for one section and another law for another. I am glad the Minister is sticking to his guns on this matter.
Comment on this
I will, and I will also take up Deputy Cooney's point with the parliamentary draftsman before Report Stage.
Comment on this
In relation to the points made by Deputy Quinn, surely we covered that ground this morning? Just like Deputy Quinn, I would like to be reassured, just in case I misunderstood the Minister, that this Bill will not require a restaurant owner to change what is essentially the decor or otherwise he cannot serve drink. Traditionally, there is some small area in a restaurant which looks like a section of what conventionally would be called a bar. I would like to be assured that there is nothing contained in this Bill which would interfere with the physical object, which we call a bar, in a waiting area.
Comment on this
He would have to comply with fire and health board regulations just like everybody else.
Comment on this
Let us be clear about this. As Deputy Quinn has rightly said the word "bar" has two meanings in this context. The first is a purely physical object which, as a matter of mechanics, is indispensible for storing beer barrels and allowing water to be put on tap to dilute drink. Surely, we are not going to require its removal if it exists at present in areas used by restaurants as waiting areas?
Comment on this
I would like to draw the Deputy's attention to a comment which I made in reply to points which he made earlier——
Comment on this
It is not the intention to dictate what the decor should be in any restaurant. Nobody has any intention of doing that.
Comment on this
I intended making a contribution when we came to deal with section 16 when I thought this matter would be properly dealt with but at the rate at which we are going I doubt if we will reach section 16. I can think of two restaurants in this constituency which would automatically qualify for this type of licence. One of them contains a counter. As Deputy Kelly has said, in order to be able to serve drink and comply with the hygiene regulations which Deputy Lynch is familiar with, one would need refrigeration, washing and storage facilities. These are combined usually in one physical object which fronts out into the waiting area. People either sit beside it or they sit on easy chairs or stand beside it. Alternatively, a person does business behind it and comes out from behind with a tray of drinks.
Comment on this
Those restaurateurs believe that, in order to comply with the Bill, if enacted, they will have to remove this piece of equipment from the waiting room. I am giving this information in order to assist the parliamentary draftsman and I ask the Minister to consider this point before Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:
In page 6, subsection (1), line 27, after "restaurant,", to insert "the area of which will be delineated in a map or plan,".
What I hope to achieve with this amendment is some consistency. As I understand it, when a person applies for a licence for a licensed premises they have to produce a map of the area to be licensed. There appears to be no reference in the Bill to such a requirement in respect of a special restaurant licence. I thought it might be worth while putting down an amendment in order to find out the actual position. It would be interesting to hear the Minister's views on this.
Comment on this
I would like to point out to Deputy Barrett that the intention of section 8 (1) is that the application for a special restaurant licence must show to the satisfaction of the Circuit Court that a Bord Fáilte certificate in respect of the restaurant is in force. It would be inappropriate that any provision as to the content of such a certificate should be included in section 8 (1). I note also that under the Deputy's amendment the map or plan would merely show the area of the restaurant concerned but need not show the disposition of the accommodation. The Deputy's amendment says that the area will be delineated and I presume the intention is that this would already have been done before the certificate was issued. If the intention is that the Bord Fáilte certificate should have a plan of the restaurant attached, a provision to this effect would I think be more appropriate to subsection (2) of section 8 in view of the definition of the Bord Fáilte certificate in section 6. The question as to whether a provision of this kind might be inserted in section 8 (2) will certainly be examined by me between now and Report Stage. I will come back to this matter again on Report Stage.
Comment on this
There is no requirement to produce a map of the area to be licensed, as is the case with licensed premises, in respect of special restaurant licences. A licence would be issued to an individual in respect of a premises. I wonder is there such a requirement in respect of special restaurant licences. If a huge extension is added on later it would not necessarily follow that that huge extension is licensed.
Comment on this
I share the concern of Deputy Barrett and I could see the difficulties which could arise if a large extension was added on to a restaurant following the granting of a licence. The licence will specify where drink can be taken but because of what the Deputy has said I will have this matter examined between now and Report Stage. I would be obliged if the Deputy would withdraw his amendment.
Comment on this
To the best of my knowledge, the entire yard of a licensed premises is also covered by the licence. It is possible for people to be caught by the Garda out in the yard.
Comment on this
We will now deal with amendment No. 11 in the name of Deputy Cooney who does not appear to be in the Chamber at present.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Cooney just wanted to discuss the amendment and did not intend to press it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:
In page 6, line 34, after "premises" to insert "or the number of previously granted special restaurant certificates in the neighbourhood".
Comment on this
The purpose of this amendment would appear to make the number of special licensed restaurants in an area a ground for objection to the granting of a new such licence by the court and I cannot agree to the court having the power to refuse the granting of a special restaurant licence on such a ground. Restaurants often cluster in certain areas in towns, often bringing business to one another as a particular area acquires a reputation for good eating out facilities. I would also have no objection from a public order point of view to having several such restaurants in a particular neighbourhood. At the end of the day, and I am sure the Members of the House would agree with me, supply and demand will determine the number of restaurants in any area and I am quite happy with that. Therefore, I think the amendment should not be accepted.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In page 6, line 35, after "is" to insert "reasonably".
May I suggest, subject to the approval of the House, that amendments Nos. 13 and 15 be discussed together. They would involve a rephrasing of subsection (2) and, in a sense, they are inter-related.
Comment on this
Deputy Taylor suggests that amendments Nos. 13 and 15 be taken together for discussion. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
My amendment, No. 13, asks that the word "reasonably" be inserted between the words "is" and "satisfied"; in other words the subsection would read:
Where in relation to a restaurant the Board is reasonably satisfied that——
In other words the board must act reasonably in arriving at a decision as to whether they will grant a certificate. We say here that the board will grant a certificate but one might well ask: what is the reality of the circumstances? The reality is not that all the members of Bord Fáilte will travel down and look at a given restaurant. The reality is that one person, an inspector or perhaps one member of the board — I do not know — will go and look at a restaurant. We must be careful here that his level of satisfaction is a fair, objective and reasonable one and not subject to his whims or notions. It is fair that the word "reasonably" be inserted to ensure an objective standard and balance in the very important decision involved. When one thinks about it, the livelihood of that restaurateur may be at stake as a result of this decision. It may well be that unless he gets his certificate he may have to close his restaurant, it may not be viable or competitive. Therefore, it is a very important matter so far as the restaurateur is concerned. It could mean the difference to him as to whether his restaurant would continue to be viable or would not be able to compete and would fail. I would hope that the Minister would agree to insert the word "reasonably" to ensure a level of objectivity.
In my amendment No. 15 I am asking that the provision about regulations made by the Minister for Tourism and Transport on the conditions that have to be met be deleted. I want to say this about the generality of bringing in ministerial regulations. Very often in this House we go too far on this issue. Perhaps the parliamentary draftsmen have an idea that one cannot enact any Act of the Oireachtas without providing for ministerial regulations. One can. We go too far on this. Every measure we look at says that the Minister may make regulations on this, that and the other. The volume of regulations is becoming massive; it must be a factor of 100 or 1000 of the legislation that emanates from this House. I do not deny that it is necessary in many cases, of course it is, but I do not think we should allow ourselves to get carried away by the issue.
The Minister has set out in subsection (2) (b) a number of very well thought out conditions which I have read carefully, as I am sure have other Members. They are a very fine, broad set of conditions. They cover every conceivable aspect of what is reasonable to enable a Bord Fáilte inspector to reasonably determine what is required. I will just go through them briefly. For example, he must be satisfied that a restaurant is well equipped, well furnished and provides comfortable seating in the dining area and waiting area. That is comprehensive so far as that aspect is concerned. Second, he must be satisfied that the restaurant is operated by a competent management and staff and third provides a high standard of catering. That is all very good. The fourth requirement is that there must be at least one member of the staff who holds a recognised qualification in cooking or has sufficient experience in cooking to prepare meals of a high standard — that is first class and ideally meets the bill. The fifth requirement is that the restaurant maintains a high standard of hygiene. Those conditions are well and comprehensively set down. Why do we have to take on ourselves here and hand to the Minister the power to bring in other regulations of which the House would know nothing, would never realistically have a chance to debate — notwithstanding the saving clauses — because we all know what is the reality, particularly when the Minister proposes to arrogate to himself the power, in section 12 (2) (e), which is one of the most remarkable conditions. There are certainly some delusions of grandeur there. Having listed out certain parameters earlier on hygiene, catering, management, staff and so on, this subparagraph reads
(e) any other matter which the Minister for Tourism and Transport considers to be necessary or desirable.
That is some wide-ranging power the House is being asked to give — any other matter at all, no matter what he, the Minister, considers necessary, he may being into law without any realistic reference to this House. With all due respect to the Minister that is over-reaching himself.
The conditions required for qualification for a Bord Fáilte certificate are well set out there and cover every possible range of requirement. That adequately meets the position. It appears to me that the need for further regulations to cover any other matter whatever that the Minister thinks up, without reference to this House, is not necessary. I contend that, if anything else arises, he should come back to the House and seek that power.
Comment on this
With regard to amendment No. 13, I do not accept that the insertion of the word "reasonably" in the opening line of section 8 (2) would add anything to the sense of the provision as it stands. Indeed I am convinced that it would introduce an element of uncertainty. It might suggest that, if the board were not fully satisfied that the requisite standards were maintained, they might still issue a certificate.
With regard to amendment No. 15, I should say that its effect would be that the decision as to whether a given restaurant was of an acceptable standard would be left totally to Bord Fáilte. That would be the effect of that amendment, without any reference to regulations made by the Minister for Tourism and Transport under the provisions of section 12 (2) (e).
Comment on this
No, it would not. I might refer the Deputy to the provisions of section 8 (2) (b) which says:
(b) in case no such regulations are in force,...
So it will be only in the case of regulations not being made that the conditions set out would apply. In my view it is clearly necessary, not merely that minimum standards for regulations should be prescribed, but that every interested party should be in a position to know what are these standards. Clearly that objective would be best met by way of regulation.
The effect of Deputy Taylor's amendment would mean it would be a matter for the board to decide the standard to be met in every case but we will spell them out much more clearly in these regulations. Deputy Taylor knows as well as any other Member of this House that these matters are not beyond discussion in this House because any Member of the House may move their annulment within so many days and have the matter discussed here; it has happened before.
Comment on this
Certainly the Minister would be favourably disposed to a proper and orderly discussion of the question of an annulment of these regulations if the circumstances arose.
I have no doubt but that, in effect, Bord Fáilte would establish their minimum standards. Obviously it would be in everybody's interests — particularly those of the restaurant owner — that the standards to be complied with would be laid down in statutory regulatory form. I see no reason in the world for the change suggested by Deputy Taylor in his amendments.
Comment on this
I really do not appreciate the Minister's point at all. I do not know exactly what additional requirements the Minister will introduce by way of his regulations. If my amendment was adopted the statute itself would provide that a restaurant has to be well equipped and furnished. It appears the Minister will bring in regulations to deal with equipment and furnishing. I am trying to imagine what might be contained in these regulations; for example, that the colour scheme has to be suitable to the eye, that the chairs had to have a cushion depth of, say, two inches. If there is a ground of reasonable objectivity provided by the insertion of the word "reasonably" those conditions are also set out in section 8, which is the right and proper place to do so. They are set out and my amendment does not delete those conditions, not at all. Rather it highlights them, rendering them the over-riding conditions by which Bord Fáilte would have to be reasonably guided. One might well ask: why did the Minister bother inserting them at all? It is right and proper that they should be set out in the statute and the Minister has rightly and properly done that. The conditions which a restaurant would have to meet with regard to furnishings, equipment, seating, competent management and staff and so on, are set out and I cannot see how much further regulations will advance this issue because these conditions are spelt out already in section 8.
Comment on this
That is the trouble. They are not spelt out but they will be spelt out properly and fully in very specific detail by way of regulation.
Comment on this
What more can be spelt out about furnishings — the colour of the curtains or whether they are lined? I think this has been borne out of the concept that we must have ministerial regulations for everything, whether or not they are necessary. I accept that they are necessary in many cases but when the Minister has gone to the trouble of laying down the parameters what is wrong with inserting the word "reasonably"?
If it is left to the satisfaction of the board they might say: "We are not satisfied with this restaurant". As I said, it is not the board who will decide that. I do not know how many members are on the board of Bord Fáilte but let us say there are ten members. They are not going to go down to Mr. Jones's restaurant to check out whether it should receive a certificate. Probably not even one member of the board will go down to the restaurant. An inspector will go down to the restaurant and it will be on his say so that the very important decision as to whether a certificate should be granted will be made. It will be done on the say so of one inspector in much the same way as an inspector in An Bord Pleanála appeals hears all the oral evidence and so on. The members of An Bord Pleanála who makes the decisions are never seen at these hearings and the same thing will happen in this case. An inspector who is not a member of the board will check out the restaurant. The real question is whether the inspector will or will not be satisfied that a restaurant meets the requirements. That is what will happen and that is why I say the element of reasonableness should be introduced into it. Why should an important decision, perhaps affecting a man's livelihood, in regard to obtaining a certificate be decided according to the whim of one inspector? Why should he not act reasonably and objectively in coming to that decision rather than being guided by his own personal whim?
At the end of the day I cannot see how the regulations are going to be any more definitive on matters such as the operations of a competent management and staff. When the staff see an inspector coming in to a restaurant they will, no matter what they are in reality, be very competent and efficient while he is there. It is fair that we should insist on the element of reasonableness and no doubt a court may deem it to be there even though it is not there. With the insertion of one word we could spell it out and assist a court, if a case goes to court on this issue, by saying that a person was adopting an objective standard and not his own personal foibles or views, which might well differ from inspector to inspector. There might be a half a dozen inspectors employed by Bord Fáilte to check out restaurants and decide whether a certificate should be granted. One inspector might have one idea on what is a high standard of catering and another inspector might have a different idea. Some balance ought to be achieved here and I ask the Minister to consider that.
Comment on this
I am anxious to help any Deputy who is trying to improve the Bill but I honestly do not see much need for Deputy Taylor's suggestion. As he hinted a moment ago in a subordinate clause, and as a lawyer, he knows perfectly well that even though a statutory power does not explicitly require the person on whom it is being conferred to exercise it reasonably and objectively, the courts take the view, and have for decades taken the view, that it must be so construed on the simple supposition that this House does not create powers with any other object in view other than they should be reasonably applied.
An inspector's set of perceptions are to some extent no doubt born into him and conveyed to him by his parents because no two people grow up in houses where exactly the same standards of order or cleanliness apply. They may differ only minutely but everybody has a different perception of where the line is to be drawn which will separate that which is clean from that which is not. That is unavoidable in human affairs and it is even unavoidable on the judicial bench. As Deputy Taylor knows better than I do, no two justices will take exactly the same view in exactly the same case on the same set of facts or if they do it will be an accident. That is why the public occasionally get excited and upset because a judge or justice takes what to them seems a very perverse view of something. It may be perverse but that does not mean it is not the result of an honestly exercised discretion. All the Dáil and Seanad can do in conferring a jurisdication or power upon a judge, court or authority is expect that it will be honestly and reasonably applied but there can be no rational expectation that it will be applied with a mechanically measurable consistency. That is not given to flesh and blood to command.
If I thought there were reasons to suppose that inspectors, in spite of that being the law, were nevertheless going to run wild I would be inclined to urge the Minister to make sure, at an official level, that that did not happen. However, since it would be against the law for an official to apply capricious views——
Comment on this
—— of what was in conformity with this or that kind of standard, I do not think this amendment is necessary. It is against the law as it stands without the insertion of the word "reasonably". I would be glad to put in a word for Deputy Taylor's amendment if I thought it would improve the Bill. I often used to make such points when I started off but over the years and, in particular, during the past ten or 15 years, the law on this has become so solidified that there is scarcely anything less in doubt than that a statutory power must be exercised within the four corners of natural or constitutional justice, as it is called now, and one of the many aspects that term includes is the aspect of behaving impartially, reasonably and with an eye to the objects for which the power was conferred on you.
Comment on this
Deputy Taylor mentioned specifically section 8 (2) which states "in case no such regulations are in force, the restaurant —" and it lists the conditions required in about eight to ten lines. I mentioned in reply to Deputy John Kelly earlier today that we have draft regulations practically completed. They are not completed yet but they are not far from it. There are seven and a bit pages in the regulations clarifying exactly for those intending applicants the conditions they will have to meet before they apply. This is an effort to make it easier for them to understand what is required of them and it will not be left to the whims of one inspector to say whether they are out or in. They will know exactly what they are entitled to and what is required of them so that they can best make their case for their application.
I want again to say to Deputy Taylor that the publication of these regulations will be of great benefit to all those who are interested in applying for licences because they spell out in great detail what is required of them. The House will have an opportunity of discussing them and to propose their annulment. If the Deputy is afraid he will not get an opportunity of discussing them I will use whatever good offices I have with my Whip — and I do not know how good they are — to see to it that there will be a discussion on them. I would not object to it because it is something we are all interested in. There is no political party divide on anything in this Bill, nor should there be.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:
In page 6, subsection (2), line 35, after "satisfied" to insert "including inter alia by annual inspection”.
What I intend here is that it be made quite clear that before Bord Fáilte issue a renewal certificate the premises are inspected annually. That is necessary so that standards can be maintained. I would also be anxious that the taxpayer would not be asked to fund the cost of these inspections. Would it be in order for the regulations the Minister is making to include a provision that the cost of inspections would be borne by the applicant? If it is not possible to do it that way, perhaps the Minister would consider introducing an appropriate amendment on Report Stage to see that that is done. It is only reasonable that those seeking licences should carry the cost.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Barrett for his contribution on this amendment. The regulations will provide that the cost of inspections will be borne by the applicant. If some poor restaurateur from Dingle is to bear the full cost of a journey from Dublin to Dingle——
Comment on this
I doubt if we would get anybody there. We could not afford these luxuries in working class constituencies. It is a matter that we are all conscious of. The cost will have to be borne by the applicant and it is a matter for the board to ensure that the inspector will inspect as many in the region as possible rather than charging somebody £200 to £500 for a visit; nobody would want to see that happen.
With regard to the amendment it will be noted that under section 12 (2) the intention is that arrangements for the inspection of restaurants in connection with the grant of a Bord Fáilte certificate is a matter to be regulated by regulations. I am satisfied that this provision is appropriate as such arrangements can be satisfactorily made only in the light of the contents of the regulations themselves, that is, the number of and the average standard in restaurants applying, and of course the staff of inspectors available to Board Fáilte. I am confident that the board will arrange for such inspections as are necessary to ensure that certificates will not be granted or renewed if the restaurant concerned falls below the requisite standard.
I note that Deputy Barrett's amendment calls for an annual inspection. It would be my intention to ensure, by way of regulation, that there would be more than just the one inspection. I think that would be Deputy Barrett's intention too. Certainly there would have to be an inspection before a renewal application would be decided on and I would like to think that inspections would be carried out at other times by the Bord Fáilte staff during the course of the operation of the licence. If the Deputy agrees that we should cover this by regulation I feel that this would be the best place to cover it.
Comment on this
What I want to be satisfied about is that we are not just going to have a situation where certificates are automatically renewed without somebody being satisfied that certain standards are being adhered to.
Comment on this
I agree totally with Deputy Barrett. Provision will be made in the regulations to cover the point raised by him.
Comment on this
I agree with what Deputy Barrett says in regard to the cost of these inspections but I do want to tell the Minister that, in my opinion anyway, if he intends that that should be so and if he intends that the regulations regarding standards should provide for levying a charge on the premises that are being inspected, it will have to be said in this Bill that those regulations may so provide. There is a case on this subject, already nearly 70 years old, Murphy and the Waterford Corporation, that appears rather analogous to what we are talking about.
Comment on this
Section 12(2) (d) provides that regulations may make provision for:
the inspection, and certification, of such restaurants by the Board and the fees to be payable in respect of such inspection or certification.
Comment on this
I agree in theory with the thrust of the amendment Deputy Barrett has introduced here but my concern is that Bord Fáilte simply will not have the numbers of inspectors necessary to carry out this work. Presumably it will mean an increase in work because this is not being done at present. If we are to keep control on it we need to make sure that these places are inspected. The Minister has referred to the fact that he is very keen to have this done also. I just would not like us to leave open and uncatered for a situation where there would be a wish to have an annual inspection or a wish to have more than an annual inspection.
Comment on this
It will be much stronger than that. It will be laid down in the regulations that it must be done. It is not just a wish or an intention or a hope or a desire. It will be done.
Comment on this
I understand that the Minister for Justice and Bord Fáilte will, presumably, work under the auspices of the Minister for Tourism and Transport. I just wonder where the tie-up happens.
Comment on this
That is there. I mentioned already this morning that the regulations are made by the Minister for Transport and Tourism but with the consent of the Minister for Justice. I have kept a hand in on that to ensure that it goes the right way. I take the Deputy's point and I recognise the difficulty as expressed there about the availability of staff but it will have to be done. There is no question of these licences being renewed on a "pay your fee and get your licence" basis. That would defeat the purpose of the Bill.