British Nuclear Fuels safety allegations
Bruton pressed Burke on alleged safety failures at British Nuclear Fuels’ Sellafield plant and whether Ireland would pursue action under EURATOM or otherwise. Burke said the UK inspectorate was investigating, the Nuclear Energy Board was in contact, and the Attorney General was considering legal options pending the report.
asked the Minister for Energy the outcome of his inquiries regarding the allegation that safety precautions have been ignored and facts covered up by the management of British Nuclear Fuels Limited; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
Comment on this
The UK Nuclear Installations Inspectorate are carrying out an investigation into these allegations and will be preparing a report. I have stressed the urgency of clarifying the position and have asked to be informed of their findings.
Comment on this
In the light of this allegation, has the Minister taken any action under the obligations of the EURATOM Treaty to find out whether due safety is being observed by the British in the operation of their plants?
Comment on this
At this stage we have a bilateral arrangement of notification with the British of incidents that take place. The inspectorate are examining this accusation and the Nuclear Energy Board have been in touch with the inspectorate on my behalf. We are awaiting their report and on the outcome of that report further action, if necessary, will be considered.
Comment on this
Is it the Minister's intention to take legal action against the British for their repeated breaches of adequate safety standards? Is this not a perfect opportunity for the Minister to go to EURATOM under the provisions of that treaty and assert the responsibility of Britain in this case?
Comment on this
——and we are awaiting a decision under Article 37 of the EURATOM Treaty, which is due some time between July and August.
Comment on this
Yes. On the question of examining the type of action to be taken, the Attorney General is advising us on that matter.
Comment on this
When he was on this side of the House, the Minister was most vocal about this aspect of Irish life. Surely he is not going to rest on his laurels and tell the House that he will not take legal action against the British for this further outbreak in Sellafield? It is unbelievable. Will he consider taking immediate legal action?
Comment on this
The Deputy must not have been listening. As I have already said, the question of legal action, advice on the type of legal action and the particular range of the action is a matter which is being considered by the Attorney General, who is the law officer of the Government and is advising the Government in relation to the type of action to be taken. As far as this specific case is concerned, it is being examined. When we get the report to the NEB, the question of specific legal action in relation to the specific case——
Comment on this
It will be the British report. If the Minister were on this side of the House he would not accept that answer.