We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Garbage Disposal at Sea.

Dublin sewage sludge dumping site

Summary

The Minister said surveys found some localised problems but no significant deterioration at the Howth Head sludge-dumping site, and that alternative offshore sites were being considered subject to environmental assessment. He said studies showed no significant evidence of major damage from dumping, while McCartan urged moving disposal farther offshore, even to the Atlantic.

asked the Minister for the Marine if he will consider relocating the sludge dumping site in the Irish Sea used by Dublin Corporation and place it further out to sea, in view of recent information that the current site is not the most suitable location; and if he will make a statement on the matter.

Comment on this

In July 1988 a survey was carried out by my Department of monitor the effects of sewage sludge dumping at the approved site off Howth Head. The survey indicated that while dumped material was widely dispersed there were some localised problems. The report of this survey and a subsequent report reviewing previous surveys at the sludge dumping site were released by my Department early this year.

The Department is now looking at alternative dump sites further offshore. Before relocating the sludge dumping at a new site, the environmental impact of this action must first be assessed. This will be done by carrying out an environmental impact assessment, including the use of a predictive model. The model will subsequently be used for ongoing monitoring and will be tested against experimental dumping. The time scale envisaged is that the model will be available by the end of this year, with experimental dumping commencing early next year.

Comment on this

I welcome the long overdue movement in this area. It is a matter of grave concern to everyone, especially the people of Howth, that the sludge of the city of Dublin is dumped so close to them. Could the Minister indicate the general location of alternative sites further offshore? Having regard to the fact that the corporation ship travels once every two days, would the Minister consider that at a little extra cost the ship could in fact move well out into the Irish Sea, well off the south coast of Ireland, perform its dumping and return within the schedule currently available to it?

Comment on this

I have not got the precise details of the proposed relocations available here. However in the REMOT study which we commissioned there was no major signs of change from the previous study in 1983. As I have indicated already, we published that survey. The 1988 study was a reconnaissance survey and was not as comprehensive as that carried out in 1983, but it indicated that conditions on the sea floor had not deteriorated signficantly between the period 1983 to 1988. Because of the gaps in the information available we held meetings with the Department of the Environment and Dublin Corporation. Further studies are now being undertaken. As I said, the environmental impact assessment will be carried out on a new site and if further information becomes available I will supply it to the Deputy.

Comment on this

Again, I thank the Minister for his reply. Would the Minister accept in general principle the findings of the International conference, "Managing the Irish Sea", held in Dublin in November 1988 that the Irish Sea is more akin to a lake in which water has a life span of nine months and is to a great extent unsuitable for the dumping of sludge? Secondly, can the Minister tell us if the investigations are seeking to trace the build up of nitrates, and the related invasion of algae, in the bay associated with the dumping of sludge so close to the bay? In short——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Let us have some brevity, Deputy.

Comment on this

Would the Minister accept that the Irish Sea is not suitable for the dumping of waste and that we could show some great example if we were to dump our sludge in the Atlantic at little or no extra cost?

Comment on this

As I said, the study to which the Deputy refers indicates that there are no major pollution problems. It does indicate that overfishing is one of the major problems and points out that there is no significant evidence to suggest that any major damage is being done arising from this type of dumping. As the Deputy is aware, we are working closely with the Department of the Environment and the Dublin Port and Docks Board. There is a continuous process of examination and study and any further improvements that we can make in this area will be made.

Comment on this