Departures, morale and buyout conditions
Birmingham linked departures to low morale and criticised confidence in the Minister; Noonan countered that fewer other ranks were discharged in early 1989 than in the same period of 1988. Members also disputed whether buyout conditions made it difficult to leave.
Would the Minister accept that it makes little sense to discuss recruitment without having regard to the numbers that have been leaving the Defence Forces? Would he accept that a very substantial reason for so many leaving the Defence Forces is the crisis of morale that now exists because of his stewardship? Does he feel any sense of embarrassment or shame at the fact that, for the first time in the history of the State, from senior officer level down to private, the Defence Forces throughout the State are expressing a lack of confidence in the Minister who leads them?
Comment on this
(Limerick West): Of course, the Deputy again is totally misrepresenting the facts. For his information, I shall tell him that for the first three months of 1988 12 officers retired from the Permanent Defence Force and 241 other ranks were discharged. For the first three months of 1989 the same number of officers retired and 229 other ranks were discharged, so there is a reduction in discharges.
Comment on this
With regard to buyout conditions, the Minister has made it impossible for them to get out.