Point of order on question admissibility
Mr. Shatter challenged the apparent inconsistency in allowing a question on a matter debated the previous day when his earlier questions had been disallowed because they concerned matters raised on the Adjournment. The Ceann Comhairle initially refused to hear the point, then said he would look into the matter.
I resent the Deputy's intervention in this fashion. It is clearly to frustrate my ruling on this matter.
Comment on this
If the Chair allows me make the point of order, I will make it. It concerns Question No. 9 which we have just dealt with. I am glad we dealt with it——
Comment on this
I would like to draw your attention, Sir, to Question No. 9 which relates to a matter we debated in this House on Tuesday and Wednesday of this week. During the course of the past two weeks I have had questions disallowed on the basis that the matter had been discussed on the Adjourment in the past six months.
Comment on this
If the Deputy had raised that matter with me, I could have given him a considered reply.
Comment on this
One of the reasons for disorder in the House is that the Chair does not allow Deputies to raise points of order.
Comment on this
There are some Deputies who raise points of order which transpire to be points of disorder.
Comment on this
If the Deputy feels aggrieved in respect of my ruling on the matter I will communicate with him. However, the Deputy gave me no notice of this matter.
Comment on this
I have no objection to the question being taken. I am merely seeking clarification as to why it is apparently correct to raise a question today within 24 hours of the matter being debated in this House when other matters that have been dealt with on the Adjournment have been ruled out of order.
Comment on this
I assume there were good and cogent reasons as to why your questions were disallowed but——
Comment on this
They were disallowed on the basis that the matter had been discussed on the Adjournment.