We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Members' Business. - B & I Line Bill, 1991: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 131–275 of 275. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill B & I Line Bill, 1991
Enacted

No. 39 of 1991 ›

I am glad I was able to share at least one of my minutes with Deputy Lyons, even if it was not productive. Deputy Roche claimed that there would never be a more fortuitous time at which to carry out this transaction. I challenge him on that. Was it a fortuitous time with regard to not just the future profitability of this company but with regard to staff relations, given the acknowledgment accorded to the workers, whom the Minister praised, when the board only learned about the sale when it was reported by RTE at lunch time on Thursday last, when the B & I management and State consortium, MSBO, were still putting together details of their bid and believed they were involved in a productive constructive exercise, while they were just being given the run around? Does the Deputy still believe it is a fortuitous time when observers have expressed since then their absolute surprise that the Minister did not decide to hold on to the company for at least another year, considering its promise and profitability? Given the praise attributed by the Minister and everybody else to the staff and management of B & I, how is it that the board can convey to the Minister their disappointment that the Minister did not provide a forum in which the board, through their independent committee, could contribute to the process leading to decisions? That is the least any company about to be taken over and promised such constructive discussion could have expected. The board conveyed to the Minister the widespread disappointment and anger feltl at every level in B & I at the manner in which the decision was made and announced. If Deputy Roche believes there was not a more fortuitous time for this exercise, he knows nothing about industrial relations, much less any acknowledgment of the work and dignity of the people in a company, but that comes as no surprise to me.

The pension fund has been referred to and we must take this very seriously. Deputy Roche was most understanding with regard to that. There is a surplus in the existing B & I pension fund. What safeguard is there for that pension fund? Will it be used or will some of it be used as a cross-subsidy from B & I to Irish Ferries and the new company? What confidence can people nearing pension age, who have paid into the pension fund, have that they will be looked after? An outstanding question asked by the board was is in regard to an early date for an AGM and the publication of the 1990 accounts. Astonishingly, the Minister, and the Government, did not allow the publication of those accounts.

The Government did not allow the publication of those accounts in contravention of sections of the Companies Act, 1963. At a time of doom and gloom when we all hope for some good news it seems strange that that AGM and the accounts are denied.

Above all else we must ask what legal claims against B & I will be taken and by whom? For instance, we do not yet know the implications of the recent collision between the m.v. Kilkenny and the m.v. Hasselwerder.

Everything about this deal flies in the face of the Programme for Economic and Social Progress, of the social contract, of social partnership, of discussion and of the dignity and recognition due to workers and management and staff-management relationships. I find it a fine irony that the Taoiseach should return to this country in triumph because he and ten other countries had held out in Maastricht for a social charter exactly along the lines we are asking for in the treatment of the workers in B & I. If the social charter is adopted we will find ourselves, if Fianna Fáil are still in Government, traipsing to Europe to get the justice that has been denied in this shabby deal.

Comment on this
Michael Barrett Acting Chairman (Mr. M. Barrett) Fianna Fáil

I am calling Deputy Callely.

Comment on this

I am seeking also to contribute to this debate.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

As the Deputy knows, in eight minutes I will call the Minister and I am advised that Deputies Callely and Dempsey will share that eight minutes.

Comment on this

I am extremely disappointed at the way the Government are maintaining this guillotine.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

That does not arise now. The Deputy may discuss it later.

Comment on this

It does, to the extent that I wish to signal my interest in speaking in this debate. I wish to make a point and then I will give way under great protest. We indicated to the Government Whip that we could consent to the Minister winding up for 20 minutes provided there was no other speaker waiting to contribute. I demand the right to be heard in this House on this Bill.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I am calling Deputy Callely and he should be allowed speak without interruption.

Comment on this

I have listened with interest to the various contributions to the Bill. Many questions have been posed and I have no doubt that the Minister will respond adequately to them and, possibly, introduce appropriate amendments on Committee Stage.

As a relatively new Member I was surprised to hear the contributions by Members who, when on this side of the House, liquidated Irish Shipping. In that case many questions remain unanswered.

Comment on this

The Deputy is hardly one to talk about liquidating companies. The Deputy's handling of Eurokabin left a lot to be desired.

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy will withdraw that remark.

Comment on this

I certainly will not.

Comment on this

It is totally out of order.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

This Bill is before the House because the Minister indicated last year that he was carrying out a detailed examination of future options for B & I and whether the Exchequer could continue to fund B & I to the extent as in previous years. There is an option to carry out that examination or to allow B & I to continue until they were crippled or went into liquidation. The Minister took the option of bringing in professionals and getting their opinion.

Comment on this

And then ignoring them.

Comment on this

We are talking about £106 million being put into B & I since 1965, £53 million of which has been put in since 1985. Stokes Kennedy Crowley indicated in their report that £115 million would be necessary over the coming four years.

Comment on this

If companies like Eurokabin paid their taxes we could afford this.

Comment on this

The report also strongly recommended that B & I should be sold. The Minister took this recommendation on board and exhausted all avenues to ascertain as to who in the marketplace would purchase it.

It is also my understanding that five companies expressed serious interest in the B & I. The best offer was from ICG which was £8.5 million. Some speakers criticised the sale price of £8.5 million. With a £36 million write-off, with assets in excess of £20 in a company heading for good profits — this year £2.5 million — that company will be much stronger and more viable without the debt. It sounds crazy that all this is selling for £8.5 million; it is definitely good value for money.

Comment on this

Why should we not keep it and let the taxpayers and the workers benefit?

Comment on this

The Deputy is totally out of order.

Comment on this

It is the Chair who decides that.

Comment on this

The best acid test to find market value is to put the item on the market and that is what the Minister did. The best offer was from ICG offer.

Many questions on the management-staff buy-out have been posed. B & I played a very important role in terms of employment and so on. I would welcome answers to the many questions on the management-staff buy-out. I have great admiration for the way the staff tackled some of the difficulties that B & I faced over the years. The workforce was reduced from 1,500 to 900, they accepted a pay cut of 5 per cent and a pay freeze to get the company back on the rails.

Comment on this

Fatten it up to sell it.

Comment on this

A number of serious questions relating to the management-staff buy-out should be answered. The first relates to the way they intended raising the capital to purchase the company. They intended interfering with the pension fund. I am seeking clarification about that. At the end of the day, however, the reality is that the best offer is the ICG offer.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy sharing?

Comment on this

I am sharing. It is hypocritical of people to come into this House and paint an incorrect picture. Let us look at the other side of the story. There was only one serious offer for the Minister to consider. He had to ensure there would be a fleet and secure the jobs of some of the employees of B & I. I am sharing my time with Deputy Dempsey.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy has two minutes remaining.

Comment on this

Again and again in the debate we heard the claim that this has all been done with undue haste. I do not know how Members opposite can say that when the Minister clearly signalled in March 1990 that he would examine B & I to determine how soon the company's dependence on Exchequer financial support could be ended. From then onwards the board of B & I outlined options, including a merger with other companies.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy must conclude now.

Comment on this

That was the shortest two minutes of my life.

Comment on this

The Deputy was to have two minutes to conclude.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Minister will give the Deputy three minutes.

Comment on this

I will be as brief as possible because I know the Minister has answers to the many points raised.

Comment on this

In accordance with the order of the House the Minister must be called on to reply at 10.40 p.m.

Mr. McCartan rose.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I must call on the Minister to reply to the debate.

Comment on this

I wish, once again, to register our protest and to point out that there are other Members in the House who will not be heard in the debate on this important Bill at this stage.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

That has nothing to do with me; I have called the Minister.

Comment on this

They include me. Does the Deputy want to raise personal matters?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Order, please. Allow the Minister to reply to the debate.

Comment on this
Seamus Brennan Minister for Tourism, Transport and Communications (Mr. S. Brennan) Fianna Fáil

I thank all the Deputies who have taken part in the debate. Apart from one short period, I was here and listened attentively and, I would like to think, objectively to it, and I have taken careful note of all the points made.

Comment on this

I hope so.

Comment on this

I should say that throughout the entire debate during the past two days I did not interrupt any speaker even though I was taking some stick. I would, honestly, like to be given 16 or 17 minutes to say what I have to say. If the Deputies feel they cannot do that, I will understand but I would much prefer if they could agree because everyone is entitled to have their say. People can take it or leave it, but interruptions get us nowhere.

The first issue that needs to be addressed is the price. It has been claimed consistently by speakers that the sale represented bad value. A number of speakers said that it was a sweetheart deal, but almost in the same breath they alleged that the management staff buy-out consortium were cynically used by me to force ICG to increase their offer. They cannot have it both ways. This line of argument stands logic on its head. As I said before, any reasonable person would agree that the only way to establish the best value of any company is to seek competitive bids. The chairman of the B & I advised me to do just this in a letter dated 8 October 1991 in which he said:

We agree that, given a decision to sell now at the best price available, fair value is whatever is the best price that can be obtained in the marketplace. We support the view of the consultants that a true competitive bidding process between more than one buyer is likely to produce the best price. True market value will only be obtained where each bidder has confidence that if his bid is the highest it is likely to be accepted.

That is exactly what I have done in the case of the B & I Line. During the past year or so, two trawls of the international shipping market have been carried out. Apart from ICG and the earlier management-staff buy-out offer, which was also unsuccessful, two major international shipping companies looked at B & I. Both decided that they were not interested in making a bid for the company. A further foreign-owned company did make a bid about a year ago. They offered the Government a nominal sum of £1 for the entire issued share capital of B & I on the basis that the Government would assume responsibility for their liabilities which my advisers estimated to be in the range of £29.5 million to £43.5 million. I would prefer not to give the names of the companies involved at this stage for commercial reasons.

These are the hard facts which I am putting before the House. ICG's latest offer of £8.5 million is clearly superior to the management-staff buy-out consortium offer of £5 million, £3 million of which would be deferred. Indeed, the consortium's offer is inferior to even the previous ICG bid of £6.5 million. Let nobody therefore tell me that the sale to Irish Continental Group has not been made on the basis of the best price available in the market. The analysis put forward by Deputy Roche this evening in regard to the stock market valuation bears this out.

If I sold the B & I Line for £3.5 million less than the amount on offer would Deputies in the House not accuse me of squandering taxpayer's money and demand inquiries into why I did not take the best offer? Would they be as interested in the taxpayer's money in those circumstances as they appear to be in other circumstances where millions of pounds are at stake?

Comment on this

Yes, because another institutional investor is available——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Rabbitte, please allow the Minister to conclude.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Rabbitte, please desist.

Comment on this

In many cases, speakers adopt the attitude that suits them in relation to taxpayer's money. I was also asked to consider selling the company to the MSBO consortium in which there was substantial foreign investment. Several Deputies alleged that the consortium did not have adequate time to prepare a bid.

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Please, Deputy.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

It is true.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt any speaker. I would ask The Workers' Party to give me an opportunity to say what I have to say. I listened very carefully to what each of them had to say. Let me give a few facts to show why.

When SKC spoke to the Danish backers of the consortium on 2 October they clearly stated that they would only require two weeks to make a final bid. The reason no doubt was that they had already been associated with the previous bid made a year earlier and that their partners in the consortium were the company's existing management. In my own view, the existing management of any company should be able to make an informed bid for their company within two weeks.

On 21 October the chief executive of the B & I Line informed me that he could have a firm and final bid with me on behalf of the consortium within three weeks. I agreed to give him five weeks. Therefore those who wanted to make a bid got more time than they sought. Furthermore, the industrial relations officer of the Irish Congress of Trade Union, on behalf of the B & I group of unions, requested a period of one month within which to attempt to prepare a bid with the management consortium. I gave them five weeks. By any standards, that was adequate and well in excess of what they had sought from me. ICG were given the same five week period in which to prepare a revised bid. In many ways they were outsiders.

Comment on this

That is a misrepresentation of the position and the Minister knows this well. He also knows that I know it.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Please, Deputy Rabbitte, allow the Minister to conclude.

Comment on this

I would now like to deal with the question of the B & I pension funds. I wrote to the Irish Congress of Trade Unions on 1 November 1991. I want to read what I said to them into the record of the House. I said:

I wish to assure you that the Government will not accept that any sale transaction be conditional on the company liquidating the assets of B & I pension schemes for any amount. In my view, the control and management of pension funds are the responsibility of the trustees of such funds.

The sale to ICG is fully consistent with this commitment which I repeat this evening. I should remind the House once again that the management/staff buy-out consortiums offer hinged on the use of £6 million from the B & I workers pension funds.

Comment on this

What is wrong with that? The Minister seeks to undermine their offer.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Please, Deputy Rabbitte.

Comment on this

On a point of order, this is entirely misleading.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Rabbitte, resume your seat.

Comment on this

He is trying to raise a point of order.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it in order——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

You have not heard it yet.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Rabbitte, please resume your seat.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it in order for the Minister to mislead the House in terms of the advice available to him——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

He is not misleading the House.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Rabbitte, please resume your seat. The Minister should be allowed to conclude.

Comment on this

The Deputy should sit down and let the Minister conclude.

Comment on this

Even when the Deputy stands up I think he is sitting down.

Comment on this

The Deputy claimed that I had pulled the plug on management and staff at a time when they could have reached agreement with the Danish interests within a matter of days. Again, this is simply not true. On 4 December, I received a copy of a letter, sent to my advisers by AIB Corporate Finance Limited, in which it was indicated that the management and staff had withdrawn from the consortium bid and that an amended bid was being submitted on their behalf. This letter stated quite clearly that management and staff were still very attracted to the idea of a partner for B & I. However, they believed that discussions with possible partners, including Irish Ferries, could be postponed for at least 12 months. At that stage they believed they would be able to do a much better deal with a potential partner. This clearly shows that the suggestion that a deal could have been done with the Danish interests within a few short days, weeks or even months was simply not true. I have the letter here which I can read into the record if anyone is interested.

In relation to the question of time, it is over one year since I announced publicly the Government's decision to sell B & I to the Irish Continental Group. I issued a public statement on that occasion in which I indicated that I had reached agreement with the trade union movement. The trade union representatives confirmed that they were prepared to positively co-operate in the sale of the B & I to Irish Ferries provided they were given adequate assurances on key conditions affecting their members.

Comment on this

Which they were not.

Comment on this

There was little or no reaction at that time. I cannot lay my hands on any statements made by a number of the Deputies who spoke here this evening, but I reject the notion that this matter was rushed. This country, everyone in this House and all the parties involved had a year's notice.

Comment on this

What guarantees has the Minister secured?

Comment on this

It was said that AIB Corporate Finance has stepped in to fill the vacuum left by the removal of the Danish interests on the consortium. This, like some of the other statements made earlier, is not true. The bank merely confirmed that they were willing to offer the same day-to-day banking facilities to a management-staff bid as they were previously offering to the consortium bid. They were not offering to replace the Danish investment, just to maintain the usual and similar banking arrangements. The Danes represented some 50 per cent of the funding and, without them, or even without the possibility of their funding within a year, as indicated in the letter which I have here, the management-staff buy-out was greatly weakened, as any objective commentator would conclude.

Various speakers referred to the B & I as being highly profitable. I am surprised at their liberal definition of that word because there is no point in saying that if you ignore the debt, the company are profitable. Any successful company must be able to carry some debt and still be profitable so that they can renew their assets, develop their business and so on.

Deputy Yates said last night that B & I had moved from a loss of £9.4 million in 1984 to a projected profit in 1992 of £4.2 million. He went on to quote various trading figures which are not accurate. I have the correct figures here and I will read them into the record when I have more time. Suffice it to say that, after interest charges, all the so-called operating profits turned into losses.

Comment on this

All my figures were before interest charges.

Comment on this

In the same period, from 1984 to 1990, the Exchequer injected a total of £59 million equity in the B & I. Indeed, as many speakers pointed out, since their acquisition from the private sector in 1965, a total of £106 million of taxpayers' money has gone into the company. At the end of all that, the fleet needs to be renewed. SKC Corporate Finance Limited advised me that, on the basis of figures supplied by B & I, this could cost over £70 million. B & I have been — and continue to be — saved from liquidation by the taxpayer.

Comment on this

Tell the House about the rest of the advice SKC gave.

Comment on this

Despite the £106 million of equity injections there are still debts of £35 million to be removed from the company before they can be sold. They are hardly a profitable company. In spite of what some Deputies said, I wish to express my appreciation to the staff of the B & I who, over many years, put up with a lot of pressure and difficulties.

Comment on this

That is the most cynical remark I have ever heard in this House.

Comment on this

When the dust settles they will see that their future is sounder now than it was at any time. The unions accepted that 12 months ago when I first announced the matter.

Comment on this

What guarantees were given to the workers?

Comment on this

I listened to Deputy McCartan——

Comment on this

The Minister did not listen to me because I did not get a chance to speak.

Comment on this

I listened to Deputy Rabbitte.

Comment on this

If adequate time had been provided I could have spoken.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Resume your seat, Deputy McCartan.

Comment on this

I did not like many of the remarks made on the other side of the House but I kept my mouth closed. I am just asking for manners.

Comment on this

Will the Minister tell the House the rest of the SKC advice which should be put on the record of the House?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Rabbitte, resume your seat.

Comment on this

I have also been branded as the Minister who was determined to sell the company to ICG at all costs but that is not so. I wish to remind the House that I appointed an assessment committee.

Comment on this

I wish the Opposition Deputies had manners. I did not interrupt anybody.

Comment on this

It is all part of the argy-bargy in this House.

Comment on this

The assessment committee comprised representatives of my Department, the Department of Finance and SKC Corporate Finance Limited, to examine the two offers. The assessment committee made a unanimous recommendation to me that the sale should be concluded with Irish Continental Group. Are the Deputies opposite saying that the Department of Finance, the senior officials in the Department of Tourism, Transport and Communications and SKC would behave other than properly in regard to assessing bids?

Comment on this

I know what they said.

Comment on this

I am coming to that. Indeed, the Deputy will not be pleased with what I will say.

Comment on this

That is certain.

Comment on this

I had a very full and frank exchange of views with the full board of B & I on Tuesday morning and I was given an unequivocal commitment by the chairman and the board that they would co-operate fully with the sale to Irish Continental Group. The chief executive of B & I has also given me a similar commitment on behalf of the management and staff of the company. I have had over seven meetings with the chairman and his senior people in the 12 month period while this has been developing, an unprecedented consultation.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is there no end to the misrepresentation?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

That is not a point of order. Resume your seat.

Comment on this

The Minister treated Alex Spain disgracefully.

Comment on this

I had seven meetings in 12 months with the chairman of B & I.

Comment on this

Not to talk about this.

Comment on this

No, we talked about The Workers' Party.

Comment on this

The Minister seems to be preoccupied with our party.

Comment on this

I should now like to comment on the question of redundancies. Let me be clear about one thing; there is no question of people being put out of a job before Christmas. The MSBO consortium and ICG indicated that they would assume responsibility for rationalisation after completion of the sale. ICG indicated that they would seek redundancies of about 250 people and they have assured me they will all be voluntary, if possible. Indeed, Irish Continental Group previously advised the union that they would guarantee existing rates of basic pay. I have no doubt that, following completion of the sale, ICG will sit down with the unions and negotiate a reasonable agreement.

Comment on this

What assurances in writing are there for the workers?

Comment on this

The original MSBO consortium——

Comment on this

What guarantees——

Comment on this

The first MSBO proposal involved 300 redundancies, the current number involves 150 to 250 from the management-staff buy-out. The level of consultations with the trade union interests in relation to this sale is possibly unprecedented. To date my Department have had approximately 20 meetings with trade union representatives, including the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, as well as numerous bilateral contacts. I met trade union representatives on three occasions.

Comment on this

Waffle, waffle.

Comment on this

Well, there were 20 meetings, the unions were there and the Deputy can call it what he likes. In regard to worker participation, I hope that ICG can work out a sensible arrangement with the workers in the joint company.

I want to refer to what Deputy Rabbitte said in regard to the document on which he laid his hands and which was on its way from the office of the Chief State Solicitor to me. The document which the Deputy waved around yesterday is simply advice to me after the Government took the decision to sell the B & I. It was advice about implementing the decision; I did not ignore the advice. It was purely legal and technical advice about how to implement the Government decision and it played no part in the decision. Therefore, I take it that the Deputy will withdraw his allegation in that regard.

Comment on this

The Minister's posterior was outside the window and he had to bring it back in.

Comment on this

The nettle had to be grasped by somebody. The B & I workforce performed well in difficult circumstances but, despite the injection of £106 million of taxpayers' money they remain in a weak competitive position My professional advisers estimated that up to £100 million required in the next decade would have to come from the taxpayers unless I took action. The amalgamated B & I and Irish Ferries now gives this island nation a strong competitive shipping giant under the Irish flag to compete with Sealink and other companies well into the next century.

Comment on this

Look at what happened to Sealink.

Comment on this

This new structure is fortunate because it has available to it the skills and talents of employees from the B & I and Irish Ferries to develop the company into the next century.

Comment on this

Answer the question on liability.

Comment on this

I appeal to all the staff to make it work. It is the best option for a secure future and without this action of mine and the Government it could have gone the way of Irish Shipping. Instead, they now have a fresh beginning and they deserve the support of this House.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

As it is now 11 p.m.——

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy should resume his seat.

Comment on this

——several Deputies asked the Minister to respond to the question of liability of legal claims against the B & I Line, but the Minister made no reference to that in his reply.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy should please resume his seat.

Comment on this

Deputy Yates should ask Deputy Jim Mitchell about that.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 72
·
Níl 64
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Minister indicate when it is proposed to take Committee Stage?

Comment on this

A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, on behalf of the Fine Gael Party may I indicate that there will be no agreement between the Whips that this matter will be taken next week?

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister must indicate the date on which it is proposed to take Committee Stage.

Comment on this
Seamus Brennan Minister for Tourism, Transport and Communications (Mr. S. Brennan) Fianna Fáil

Next Tuesday, subject to the agreement of the Whips.

Comment on this

——subject to railroading it through.

Comment on this

There will be no agreement between the Whips for taking this matter until such time has elapsed to allow the Minister answer the very serious questions which he has left unanswered as far this Bill is concerned.

Comment on this

May I take the opportunity——

Comment on this

The liabilities against the B & I Line——

Comment on this
Vincent Brady Minister for Defence (Mr. V. Brady) Fianna Fáil

If you were in Government, B & I would have been closed down a year ago.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy McCartan please resume his seat while we listen to Deputy Howlin. I will come to him in a moment.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister and the Government Chief Whip to reflect between now and the ordering of the Committee Stage of this Bill on the wishes of this side of the House and defer the Committee Stage until the next session so that some reasonable attention can be given to the drafting of the amendments.

Comment on this

On behalf of The Workers' Party I, too, would like to signal the absence of agreement on our part to the Committee Stage being taken next Tuesday and I join with the others in asking that time be given to this House to reflect on what is proposed, and in consultation with all concerned to reflect on whatever amendments may be brought forward on Committee Stage.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I must indicate the position of the Chair. We have had an indication from the Minister that the Committee Stage should be taken next Tuesday. Bearing in mind the comments that have been made, I am taking it that I must put it as a question. I will put that question to the House because that is the only way the Chair can deal with that matter. The Chair must act in accordance with the rules of the House——

Comment on this

Santa Claus comes on Tuesday.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Whatever about anyone who might come, if Deputy Rabbitte cannot behave himself, I know who will go.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Sir, I understood the Government proposition——

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. J. O'Keeffe Fine Gael

That is not the correct procedure.

Comment on this

If Deputy O'Keeffe could stop for just a moment.

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. J. O'Keeffe Fine Gael

I will make a point that needs to be made.

Comment on this

I understood that the Government proposition was that the matter would be taken next week, subject to the agreement of the Whips. I understood that indicated there would be in the intervening period an opportunity for the Whips to meet. In that event, I suggest that perhaps a better order for the peace of the House, if for no other reason, would be to allow the question remain over until the Whips meet and discuss the matter further.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair would like to think that he is as concerned about order and peace as much as any other Deputy, but the Chair must carry out the duties of the Chair in accordance with what is required of the Chair. It gives me no pleasure to be doing this, especially when the Chair does not enjoy the popularity that other people can when they are pursuing other lines. The position is that if the Minister indicates to me that he requests that Committee Stage be ordered for a certain date that is the question I shall put to the House.

Comment on this

It is the Government's intention to take Committee Stage of the Bill next Tuesday. The House should decide on that now.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That Committee Stage be ordered for Tuesday, 17 December 1991."

Tá 72
·
Níl 53
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?