We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

An Bille um an Dóu Leasú Déag ar an mBunreacht, 1992: Céim an Choiste agus na Céimeanna Deiridh. Twelfth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1992: Committee and Final Stages.

Contributions 177–355 of 355. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Twelfth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1992
Rejected

No. 24 of 1992 ›

Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

There are a number of amendments in the names of Deputies De Rossa, Mac Giolla, Spring, Howlin and others. I note that many of these amendments are related. Amendment No. 3 is an alternative amendment to No. 2. Amendments Nos. 5 to 12, inclusive, are alternatives to amendment No. 3. Therefore, I suggest we debate amendments Nos. 2, 3 and 5 to 12, inclusive, together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed. That leaves three amendments to be dealt with at a later stage in the names of Deputies Spring and Howlin, De Rossa, Sherlock, McCartan and others.

Comment on this

Tairgim leasú a 2:

I leathanach 7, roimh an Sceideal, an méid seo a leanas a chur isteach:

"SCEIDEAL

CUID I

Ní theorannóidh fo-alt 3º den alt seo saoirse chun foirceannadh toirchis a chur ar fáil nó a fháil sa Stát chun cosaint a thabhairt ar bhaol réadach substaintiúil do bheatha nó do Shláinte mná torraí ach sin faoi chuimsiú cibé coinníollacha a fhéadfar a leagan síos le dlí.

CUID II

Subsection 3º of this section shall not limit freedom to provide or obtain, in the State, subject to such conditions as may be laid down by law, termination of a pregnancy in order to protect against a real and substantial risk to the life or health of a pregnant woman.".

I move amendment No. 2:

In page 6, before the Schedule to insert the following:

"SCHEDULE

PART I

Ní theorannóidh fo-alt 3º den alt seo saoirse chun foirceannadh toirchis a chur ar fáil nó a fháil sa Stát chun cosaint a thabhairt ar bhaol réadach substaintiúil do bheatha nó do shláinte mná torraí ach sin faoi chuimsiú cibé coinníollacha a fhéadfar a leagan síos le dlí.

PART II

Subsection 3º of this section shall not limit freedom to provide or obtain, in the State, subject to such conditions as may be laid down by law, termination of a pregnancy in order to protect against a real and substantial risk to the life or health of a pregnant woman.".

Amendment No. 2 seeks to replace the Government's wording with a new formulation. We have just seen by way of vote that the Government insist they want to proceed with a referendum. I argued on section 1 that if we were to have a referendum it should be to delete Article 40.3.3º., the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution, and thereby revert to the pre-1983 situation and leave this House free to deal with the question of abortion in Ireland in a way the legislators, elected by the people, would find acceptable and would have to defend to their constituents at a future date. That approach has been rejected by the Minister on the basis that he regarded it as an academic approach. I fail to see how the Minister could define it as such, but it has been rejected.

In the absence of the Minister accepting that approach I and my colleagues in Democratic Left submit that the wording which the Minister is proposing should be deleted and substituted by the wording of our amendment. It is a positive expression of what might be done in the event of this House legislating for abortion.

The amendment states:

Subsection 3º of this section shall not limit freedom to provide or obtain, in the State, subject to such conditions as may be laid down by law, termination of a pregnancy in order to protect against a real and substantial risk to the life or health of a pregnant woman.

Our amendment would be in addition to Article 40.3.3º of the Constitution and should be read in tandem with the statement therein that the foetus and the woman carrying the foetus have an equal right to life. The Supreme Court has already defined that section of the Constitution as in certain circumstances giving the woman's right to life precedence over that of the foetus.

The wording I am suggesting eliminates the proposal by the Minister and his Government that anything outside the conditions proposed in his amendment would be unlawful and, therefore, a criminal act. In a later amendment we propose that the reference to unlawful should be deleted. To include this reference in the Constitution is quite an extraordinary approach not only to this issue but to our Constitution. Nowhere else in the Constitution do we declare anything to be unlawful. We leave it to the Houses of the Oireachtas to make laws and decide what is lawful and unlawful. The Constitution generally states principles on which our laws should be based.

I remind the House that approximately 5,000 women per year, or at least a large proportion of them, in effect would be criminalised as a result of the passing of the amendment as proposed by the Government. The majority of those who go to Britain, as I understand the analysis of the statistics, go there not because of a direct physical threat to their lives but for in my view other legitimate reasons. Nevertheless, they would be involved in a criminal act by having an abortion for reasons other than a direct physical threat to their lives if we adopt the Government's amendment. Our amendment also seeks to provide that the termination of pregnancy would be permissible in order to protect the life or the health of the woman.

I have no doubt that much of the remaining time in this debate will be devoted to discussing how the Government expect it might be possible that the life of a woman can be distinguished from her health; how a doctor may be expected to distinguish a life shortening threat to her life as distinct from an immediate physical threat to her life. Indeed, we have heard conflicting statements from Government spokespersons on whether the Government's amendment is intended to eliminate life shortening illnesses as distinct from an immediate threat to life. On the one hand a Minister told us that it excludes any possibility of a termination in a life shortening situation and provides for situations where there is an immediate threat to life while on the other hand others claim that it is intended to cover both situations and no woman will be refused treatment if her life or, as the Minister claimed, her health are at risk.

Our amendment seeks to broaden the capacity of this house to deal with this issue. We very clearly insist in our amendment that health should be included as the basis for a possible termination and that it is to protect against a real and substantial risk to the life or health of a pregnant woman. We also seek to delete the phrase "mother" from the proposed amendment. By accepting the term "mother" we willy-nilly accept the thesis that what a woman is carrying from the point of conception is a child. There are serious and widespread differences of opinion, even among Roman Catholic theologians, on this issue. On Sunday a Roman Catholic theologian pointed out on RTE that there is a grave question mark over this issue. I do not wish to delay the House on this issue but it is tendentious to continue to refer to a woman who has become pregnant and is carrying a foetus as a "mother"; without question, it literally accepts the theological argument that life begins at conception. This is only a theological argument; it is not a medical argument. There is no consistent medical opinion which says that life begins at conception. Who knows, but perhaps in five or ten years' time it may be proved or disproved.

The inclusion of the phrase "a real and substantial risk" to the health of the woman would also provide for situations where the psychological health of a woman would be at issue. I find it both insulting and difficult to understand how it is possible for the Government to argue on the one had that there is a separation between the life and health of the woman and on the other to go further and argue that her mental health is of no consequence; that a threat of self-destruction will be banned and giving any recognition to the threat of self-destruction arising from a crisis pregnancy must, under the Constitution, be ruled out. This seems to be stepping back 100 years to the time when mental illness was regarded as something evil and had nothing to do with the physical well being of a person. It is obvious to anyone, even a lay person like me, that one cannot distinguish between the physical and mental health of any person in society, that one impinges and works on the other.

Amendment No. 2 seeks to achieve a situation where people can give their verdict that they want the Dáil to legislate for abortion in certain circumstances where the life and health of a woman is at serious and substantial risk. It states that this should be done by way of legislation in the Dáil; it would be regulated by the Dáil. Given the particularly conservative make-up of this Dáil, which is likely to continue for the foreseeable future, it is highly unlikely we will have what the Minister seems to fear, abortion on demand. The fact is that the 1983 Amendment has been interpreted by our Supreme Court in a way which virtually no one anticipated by way of its effect on information and travel and the way it was defined in relation to suicide and the right to a termination.

As Deputy Dukes said earlier, it would be far more beneficial for the health of politics and democracy here if the Dáil were allowed to do the job it was elected to do, that is to legislate; for the Constitution to lay down the principles and for the Dáil to legislate rather than try to incorporate legislation into our Constitution which is extremely difficult to change for obvious reasons. In a curious way it would probably work more in the interests of the so-called pro-life groups if the Dáil were permitted to legislate in the way it clearly feels it should.

I do not want to unnecessarily take up the time of other Deputies in this short debate. The Minister has consistently attempted to portray the Government amendment as a so-called pro-life amendment. I know from statements he is reported to have made at press briefings and so on, that the Taoiseach has said this is not an abortion amendment. The fact is that the Government's briefing paper makes it very explicit that this is an abortion amendment. Although it has not yet been admitted by the Government I assume this briefing document which was given to the Leaders of the Opposition parties was drafted by the Attorney General. Perhaps the Minister could clarify that point. Under the heading "Supreme Court Decision in X Case" the briefing document states:

The effect of the Supreme Court decision is that an abortion is permissible in this jurisdiction where there is a real and substantial risk to the life, as distinct from the health, of the mother which can only be avoided by the termination of the pregnancy and that a risk of suicide may constitute a real and substantial risk to life.

That is a clear statement that the Supreme Court judgment provided for abortion, termination of a pregnancy. The briefing document goes on to refer to the effect of the proposed Government amendment. It states:

The amendment is proposed as an addition to Article 40.3.3º. The effect is to leave undisturbed the existing affirmative acknowledgment of the right to life of the unborn, with due regard to the equal right to life of the mother, contained in that Article.

The amendment accepts the test set out in the Supreme Court decision in every respect except suicide. It therefore, sets out to negative the decision in respect of suicide but in no other respect. The effect is that where a pregnant woman is suffering from a physical medical condition such that her life is endangered, the pregnancy may lawfully be terminated if that is necessary to save her life.

That is a very clear, explicit statement that what the Government are proposing is the legalisation of abortion in this State. The Minister should stop the nonsense of trying to claim that in some way this does not permit abortion. The Minister's briefing document states that it does.

I welcome the fact that the Minister is at last breaching the theological ramparts that have surrounded this issue for so long. We have been caught up in theological argument about when life begins, when abortion is direct or indirect and whether if indirect it can be called abortion and so on. We have an acceptance by the Government that abortion may take place in a specific circumstance. That is an advance. I should like the Government to go much further and to respect the health of the woman. I should like them to respect her mental health as much as her physical health, but their amendment refuses to respect her mental health. That is where I disagree with them.

It is a silly argument that what the Government are proposing is not abortion and what everybody else is proposing is abortion. The Government are proposing abortion. Let us get away from the nonsense that they are not and let us have a mature debate on how far we should go on that road. That is fundamentally what the debate is about. The Government say we should allow a legal abortion only where there is a substantial physical risk to the life of the mother. I say it should also include a serious and substantial risk to the health of the mother. I would argue also that where a woman or a young girl is pregnant as a result of rape or incest, that would be a serious case for allowing a legal termination of pregnancy.

I am not suggesting, as others have claimed that I am, that all a person should have to do is go to a doctor claiming to be suicidal and request an abortion. That is nonsense. What is at issue is whether we accept that there is a medical argument from psychologists. Every Deputy has received a briefing document from the Psychologists' Society of Ireland which goes into some detail in examining existing research. It raises the question in the same terms as the Attorney General's briefing. It is impossible to rule out the possibility that a woman's life may be at risk as a result of suicidal tendencies or in the longer term that her life may be at risk because her health is threatened or damaged by a pregnancy. I am not arguing that the case is made and accepted by everybody that suicide or health grounds are an absolute in terms of requiring a termination of pregnancy, but I object to the attempt to incorporate in our Constitution an absolute statement that under no circumstances will the health of a woman or suicidal tendencies be taken into account.

The Attorney General's briefing document states that even though the risk to life may occur in only a limited number of cases, we cannot rule out the possibility of its happening. We cannot rule out that suicide may result from a crisis pregnancy. We cannot rule out that a woman's quality of life may be destroyed as a result of a crisis pregnancy. We should not try to rule out these possibilities in our Constitution. That is why I am proposing the alternative wording in amendment No. 2 which would leave intact Article 40.3.3º but would qualify it by introducing some compassion. It would extract most of the piety and inject some pity into the whole problem of a woman who may be at risk as a result of pregnancy. I appeal to the Minister to approach this question in those terms rather than try to score political points against me or others by accusing us of wanting abortion on demand.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair appreciates that there are many amendments before the House from the Opposition parties. Deputy Mac Giolla also has an amendment. I propose to call Deputy Bruton and then the spokes-person for the Labour Party. I then propose to call Deputy Mac Giolla.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

I wish to discuss the amendments in my name which seek to remove the distinction in the Minister's proposed amendment to the Constitution between life and health. I have taken medical and legal advice on this point from people who would be very anxious to restrict abortion and who believe that a termination should only be available in life threatening situations. They nevertheless feel that inserting the words "as distinct from the health" creates a totally artificial tension between the two concepts, health and life. If the wording were left without the addition of these words, it would obviously remain the case that termination would have to be necessary to save the life of the mother. They do not understand why the provision as to health has to be inserted.

Doctors will have to start interpreting this new distinction in the Constitution and will have to look over their shoulders. If they are in an operating theatre, one of the people present might feel that the condition of the mother was health-threatening as distinct from life-threatening and the doctor might feel that he or she could be reported to some authority for giving treatment in those circumstances which would have the effect of terminating the life of the unborn. It is feared that this will introduce a legalistic atmosphere into clinical decisions by doctors in operating theatres and elsewhere. Who will be the losers? The women whose lives will be placed at risk.

In view of the increasing incidence of litigation and the costs of medical liability, doctors will tend when there is any doubt to take the most cautious course, which may not be the most efficacious course in regard to saving the life of the mother. While they would be able to argue afterwards that they did things to save the life of the mother they will not have done them as quickly or as effectively as they would have done, if they did not have to look over their shoulders in this way, because of this artificial distinction that is being introduced. By taking out the words "as distinct from the health" from this amendment one is not saying, although some would argue it, that health alone is a ground, because the words remain "such termination is necessary to save the life." I cannot understand why the Minister has taken this course. The argument he advanced in his Second Stage speech is unconvincing. The Minister basically concludes that if we take out the words "as distinct from the health" we will get an amendment which allows abortion on health grounds alone and that that would lead to abortion on demand. That is not true. There is no basis on which that can be read into the wording. If we take those words out the amendment will still read:

It shall be unlawful to terminate the life of an unborn unless such termination is necessary to save the life of the mother where there is an illness or disorder of the mother giving rise to a real and substantial risk to her life, not being a risk of self-destruction.

Those words clearly very narrowly circumscribe the circumstances in which a termination can take place. There is no need for the insertion of those words "as distinct from the health" and all the Minister is doing is putting in the Constitution words that will create the impression that this House and the electorate if they approve of this, are unconcerned about women's health and that we regard this as a lower order concern. I know that will not be the legal meaning of the words, but the fact that those words are put in will create that sort of atmosphere. Let us remember that the Constitution is more than a legal document. It is also a statement of our values as a people. To put in this hairsplitting distinction between life and health in these circumstances shows that we went to enormous trouble to exclude certain possible health threatening conditions from being considered, because we want to make absolutely sure that there will be absolutely no doubt. Given what I understand the Minister wants to achieve, he is not going about it in the right way. The Minister is making a very serious poitical error in including these words, as well as everything else, because he is creating a situation in which many women and doctors will feel they cannot support this amendment because of the words "as distinct from the health" being included gratuitously and unnecessarily.

The Minister in his speech said it is suggested that in any medical condition there is a spectrum of gravity and that it is impossible to identify a precise point at which the risk changes from a risk to health to a risk to life. The Minister went on to say that he did not think this would arise in this case but he did not make any case to demonstrate that point. The Minister attempted to reply to this concern by saying:

I think that I can provide reassurance on this point. The intention of the amendment is that a risk to health unrelated to a risk to life is not sufficient to warrant termination of the life of the unborn. It is not the intention of the amendment to affect in any way the degree of probability of risk to life that is necessary to warrant treatment resulting in termination.

I do not say it is the intention but the Minister's intention is entirely irrelevant. It is the words that go into the Constitution and how they are interpreted by the Supreme Court perhaps in five or six years time that will count.

The Minister and many others had lots of intentions during 1983 and many people outside this house and inside it gave assurances in 1983 as to the meaning of certain words; and they made it abundantly clear that it was not the intention to interfere with the right to travel or to prevent the dissemination of information. All these intentions amounted to nothing because the Supreme Court interpreted the words differently. The Minister's language in his speech was extremely tentative where he said "I think that I can provide reassurance on this point. That is unbecoming modesty on the part of the Minister. The people are entitled to more than that. The Minister attempted to suggest that if the words "as distinct from the health" were taken out we could have terminations where there was no risk at all to the life of the mother. I cannot understand how the Minister could come to that conclusion when the words of the amendment say that it shall be unlawful to terminate the life of the unborn unless it is necessary to save the life of the mother. The Minister based his case on the Bourne case in England. I do not know if the Minister has read the judgment in that case.

Comment on this

I have.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

That judgment was given in a criminal case where one cannot necessarily say that the judgment of the judge was the reason the jury came to their conclusion in the case. Mr. Justice McNaughton said on that occasion that if there is a doubt, any doubt as to the motivation of the person concerned, he was entitled to be acquitted. The case the Minister is trying to make is that the Bourne judgment would allow health alone to be a ground for a termination here. The Bourne judgment was uttered in a country where there is no written Constitution and where there is no custom of interpreting the Constitution. To suggest that the Irish Supreme Court might come to a similar conclusion to that in the Bourne judgment if these words were left out is fanciful in the extreme. In charging the jury Mr. Justice McNaughton said:

As I told you yesterday and as I tell you today the question that you have got to determine is not whether you are satisfied that he did it in good faith for the purposes of preserving the life of the girl. The question is whether the Crown have proved the negative of that.

In other words, that he did not do it in good faith for the purposes of preserving the life of the girl.

The important point to draw from that summing up of his judgment by Mr. Justice McNaughton was that the case was about whether the motive was to preserve the life of the girl, not the health. It was the life that was at stake in that case. I do not see how the Minister can draw a conclusion from this that it creates a ground for health alone being the judgment or for drawing any conclusions as to why the Bourne jury came to the decision they came to in that case or as to how that would apply in Ireland. I feel that the Bourne judgment is so ambiguous that it is not helpful and should not have been introduced into this discussion. We should be looking at the words that are in our Constitution as it stands.

I mentioned earlier that I would be particularly worried that the clinical decisions by doctors would become the subject of litigation. For example, a midwife involved in an operation might have very strong convictions and might feel that a doctor had acted on grounds of health preservation rather than life preservation, and might seek an injunction to prevent the carrying out of a particular operation. We might have a situation at a later date where a treatment given to save a mother's life which resulted in injury to but not termination of the life of an infant might lead to the infant or persons on his or her behalf suing the doctor who might be claimed to have acted to save the health and not the life of the mother. By introducing this distinction here, these sorts of issues will be contested on the strength of the wording in the Constitution.

I do not think that is the Minister's intention but I think it could be the result of this amendment. The Minister should very carefully reconsider the inclusion of those words "as distinct from the health" in the amendment. I do not believe he has proved to anybody's satisfaction that they are necessary. If he has doubts about the matter he could introduce accompanying legislation to make it very clear what he means by treatment necessary to protect life. There is no need to include the words "as distinct from the health" in the amendment. If the Minister wanted to achieve some measure of support for his approach he would have done that but it seems he has taken the view that because this is his starting position he is not willing to change or listen to any argument from any quarter. I feel very strongly that the Minister should take out these words "as distinct from the health". I do not feel any cause is being served other than causing gratuitous and unnecessary worry and hurt to women by the continued use of those words.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I understand that Deputy Taylor is giving way to Deputy Mac Giolla.

Comment on this

I refrained from intervening earlier because I understood the major debate would take place on the amendments. I am glad you have given me the opportunity of speaking now. Like everybody else, with the exception of Fianna Fáil, we in The Workers' Party also feel that this matter should have been dealt with by legislation. This was the feeling in 1983. A grave error was made in 1983 by putting in a totally unnecessary amendment to ban abortion which was already banned under the Offences Against the Person Act, 1861. This legislation was in need of amendment and updating, and that is the way this matter should have been dealt with.

In those years medical decisions were made by doctors on the basis of protecting patients as they have always done. Even before the 1983 amendment, where a pregnant woman had an illness the doctor recognised that under the Offences Against the Person Act, 1861, his first responsibility was to his patient, that is, to the woman rather than to the unborn child. The unborn child was of the utmost importance to the doctor and the woman as far as treatment was concerned, but must be secondary to the treatment of the patient for whom the doctor is responsible, that is the woman. Under the Hippocratic Oath doctors must protect the life of their patients. Despite the 1861 Act and the 1983 Amendment of the Constitution, doctors have continued to do that. Article 40.3.3º only gives equal right to the mother but doctors continued to give prior right to the mother, as they must. The so called pro-life people who forced through the 1983 Amendment with the help of the bishops know this is the case and they agree with it. They said specifically that they do agree with it. They know that the woman is given prior right and yet they forced through an amendment giving her only equal right with the foetus.

The medical profession are now in an impossible position where they have neither legislative nor constitutional support or backing for their actions in saving lives. They are the real pro-life people, the only pro-life people in this business. The so-called pro-lifers salve their consciences by pretending that ending the life of the foetus to save the life of the mother is not abortion. That is fine, and nice and cosy for them but where does it leave the doctor? It has no legal standing and therefore the medical profession have no legal protection for their actions.

The words in the current constitutional amendment, particularly the words "as distinct from the health" put doctors in an even more impossible position. They are dedicated to protecting the health of their patients and in many cases they would find it very difficult if not impossible to say that where health is seriously affected the life of the patient is not at risk. How can they say in cases where health is seriously affected that the life is not at risk? This wording will leave doctors even more open to possible court actions either for not taking action to save the woman's health or for taking acton to save the woman's health which endangered or damaged the health or life of the foetus.

Whatever wording is decided in this amendment, legislation will still have to be brought forward to put the legislators' interpretation on the constitutional amendment and I think this was made clear by the Supreme Court. When the Taoiseach advised me of the wording being put forward he told me that if the wording were defeated in a refendum he would deal with this by legislation. I was delighted when I heard that and I said as much to him because now there would be a choice. If one did not vote for the referendum there would be legislation. People see that as a big stick held over the pro-lifers; perhaps it is but I still think that it is a good idea and hope that this will be explained to voters.

The question that must be asked is, where will we stand if the amendment is passed. If there is one lesson that we have learned it is that the wording that will be put before the people should be as simple and as straightforward as possible. That is the reason the amendment in my name has been formulated in simple terms. We have not included the word "unborn" because it is meaningless — an unborn what? One could not perform an abortion on a cat. Neither have we included the word "mother" which is equally dodgy and dangerous because it only covers women who already have one or more children. It does not cover women who are not mothers or indeed who may not be mothers following an operation to save their lives. They may then be incapable of having a child. The inclusion of ridiculous words such as "unborn" and "mother" leads to the creation of enormous legal difficulties.

What I have tried to do on behalf of The Workers' Party is outline the grounds on which it should be lawful to terminate a pregnancy. We make no mention of the word "unborn" but rather make a positive declaration in which we state that it should be "lawful to terminate a pregnancy where there is a threat to a woman's life or health and in the case of a pregnancy resulting from rape or incest." That is both simple and clear.

No man — and I have spoken to women about this matter — can understand the effect rape or incest has on a woman's mental attitude and feeling about herself. It affects them not only mentally but also physically in that they have a feeling that they are unclean and that their womanhood has been destroyed. No man can understand these feelings and given what I have been told in relation to the effect rape and incest have on some, if not all, women they must have a choice.

That is the reason we say the Government should outline the grounds clearly in the amendment because every comma is open to a legal interpretation. However, I presume it is too late to do anything about this matter now, having regard to the fact that two special Cabinet meetings have been held to agree on the wording to be put to the electorate and that we are wasting our time debating the matter. Fianna Fáil have had their wording accepted and they are going to push the Progressive Democrats to come in behind them on it. Even though it may be foolish to propose a wording, our amendment points to where we stand on the issue, and I am strongly of the view that we should be specific.

I should point out that even if the wording I have suggested was accepted we would still need legislation which would stipulate the period — say, 12 weeks or 16 weeks — within which it would be unlawful to terminate a pregnancy. Yet, when I asked if the Government's wording is passed would that be the end of the matter, the Taoiseach replied that it would. They are going to leave the matter hanging in mid air again, despite what the Supreme Court had to say, that the legislators had done nothing since 1983 when an amendment which was open to all sorts of interpretations was inserted into the Constitution. No attempt was made to introduce legislation to give effect to that amendment. It is absolutely essential, if the amendment is passed, that legislation be introduced.

The Workers' Party will be opposing the amendment mainly on the grounds that this is not the way to proceed. We believe that the matter should be dealt with by way of legislation. We intend to oppose the amendment to ensure that it is dealt with in this way. I am aware that we would then have another battle on our hands as to the legislation that should be introduced by the Government but that is the way we should proceed given that it would be open to any future Government to amend that legislation without the need to hold a referendum.

Mr. Taylor rose.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Shall I call the Minister?

Comment on this

I would be quite happy to give way to Deputy Taylor as he has been offering for some time but perhaps after that I should respond, otherwise I may not have an opportunity to contribute given the way things are shaping up.

Comment on this

The Minister might even make a dramatic and very important statement.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister might even agree with us.

Comment on this

Let me respond to some of the points raised. In relation to amendment No. 2 in the name of Deputy De Rossa, this would introduce abortion on all grounds where there is a substantial risk to the life or health of the mother. Clearly, this would lead to abortion on demand. This is what happened both in England and other jurisdictions.

Comment on this

No, it would not. I must object to that total distortion of what Deputy De Rossa and my party are seeking to do. I ask the Minister to address this issue without seeking to disparage meaningful contributions which have been made in this House.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am sure Deputy McCartan appreciates that later on he will be called and will have an opportunity to contribute. I hope he will not be interrupted; at least, if I am here, he will not be.

Comment on this

This is unacceptable to the Government and I am quite sure to the vast majority of the people. As I have explained time and again, the Government are not in the business of introducing abortion; this is a pro-life amendment. What we are doing is reducing the number of grounds, under the law since the X case, on which a pregnancy may be terminated. What the amendment is seeking to do is to turn that back, and we have consistently said this. It must also be borne in mind — and Deputy De Rossa should appreciate this — that existing medical practice will continue.

The Supreme Court test, which has been quoted by Members on all sides of the House since the debate started, is straightforward, and indeed, has already been interpreted by the Supreme Court. Consequently, there is no need at this time to pursue the question of further legislation because the interpretation is already in place. Today, under the law of the land, suicide or self-destruction is a ground on which a pregnancy may be terminated. What we are asking is that this be ruled out. We have been asked why on a number of occasions by Deputies McCartan, De Rossa and others. We have said it is a totally unsatisfactory criterion, that it is uncontrollable and defies regulation. I am advised that there are no scientific means to establish whether a woman is suicidal.

In present circumstances the law states, in so far as the Supreme Court judgment is concerned, that termination of pregnancy, abortion, is available here as long as the test is satisfied. One of the grounds for the test is that a pregnant mother is suicidal. We disagree with that and have been stating that quite clearly for some time.

Comment on this

The people voted for that in 1983.

Comment on this

When talking about suicide I might refer Deputies to a letter written by a Maura Ó Riordan which appeared in The Irish Times of Saturday, 24 October 1992 which read:

With reference to Dr. Anthony Clare's article on abortion and suicide — October 17th — it may be of interest that Dr. David Owen, the former leader of the SDP in Britain, boasts in his autobiography, Time to Declare, that he personally advised women to threaten suicide in order to obtain an abortion.

It is that kind of thing I was bringing to the notice of the House which leads us to believe that there would be those who would seek to use the suicidal element as a means of securing an abortion. It is to stop that possibility that the amendment has been framed in that we believe — and we believe a majority in the House believe — the people do not wish to see suicide as a ground for an abortion.

Comment on this

The writer did not mention the rest of Dr. Anthony Clare's statistical/scientific article.

Comment on this
Willie O'Dea Minister of State at the Department of Justice (Mr. O'Dea) Fianna Fáil

What is the Fine Gael position on this? Would they speak in one voice?

Comment on this

The Minister of State should apply that to his own party.

Comment on this

I am only stating a point made there.

Comment on this

We are testing the Minister's accuracy; foolish political jousts will do no good at all.

Comment on this

I am merely referring to something that appeared in a national newspaper that is worthy of mention.

Comment on this

Selective quotes.

Comment on this

Bearing in mind the Minister of State's record on this he should be very quite or reticent.

Comment on this

Deputy Shatter is on record and it condemns him.

Comment on this

I might refer to amendments Nos. 9 and 10 on which Deputy John Bruton made some comments. Those amendments refer to the deletion of the phrase "as distinct from the health". I am opposing those amendments. In proposing them Deputies raised various points. On occasion they referred to the innate offensiveness of the phrase "as distinct from the health" and claimed that the use of that term also could rule out operations that would be perfectly legal now if they were necessary to save the health as distinct from the life of a woman. While I can well appreciate that there is some strength of feeling in that regard, many of the comments made suggesting that the inclusion of the phrase could have adverse unintended effects are without foundation.

It has been suggested that a line cannot be drawn unambiguously between "life" and "health" and that this will give rise to difficulties. I have to point out, of course, that the Supreme Court has already drawn that line and had no difficulty in so doing. The essence of the Supreme Court judgment is that such a line must be drawn on the proper interpretation of Article 40.3.3º. That Article, on its true interpretation, will allow the right to life of the unborn to be superseded only where that is necessary to save the life of the mother, in the sense that otherwise she would die.

The Twelfth Amendment would not make any change to the constitutional test on this point, as it has been interpreted by the Supreme Court up to now, but rather would establish that interpretation as something which could not be changed at any time in the future without the consent of the people.

In addition, in the debate on the Bill, a view was expressed that the test laid down by the Supreme Court cannot be read as including the words "as distinct from the health". The fact is that all five members of the Supreme Court spoke specifically in terms of the life of the mother and in no instance was health unrelated to a risk to life contemplated as a ground.

Comment on this

One judge only expressly made that distinction and the Minister has been obfuscating that——

Comment on this

Did the Deputy read Mr. Justice Hederman's judgment?

Comment on this

Is the Minister listening to women?

Comment on this

The distinction between life and——

Comment on this

I listen to everyone who makes sense.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We should all now listen to the Minister who is the only person in possession.

Comment on this

The distinction between the life and health was included in the general test laid down by the Chief Justice, which has been acknowledged by Deputy FitzGerald. It is clear that the distinction was accepted by the other judges and was inherent in what they had to say.

It seems that a test of whether action is necessary to save the life of the mother is straightforward and, in practice, should not give rise to difficulty. This test, as laid down, has existed explicitly since the decision was given in the X case. Indeed, prior to the publication of the Twelfth Amendment of the Constitution Bill I heard no suggestions about any possible difficulties in the operation of that test. I agree it has arisen since we came in here but, before that, there had been no reference, no complaints, no difficulties suggested that might exist in so far as the application of the test was concerned.

Comment on this

There has not been a queue of suicidal women since then either.

Comment on this

I accept that. Indeed the phrase reflects the Supreme Court decision in so far as it provides that the risk must be to the life of the mother in the sense that, unless the risk is avoided, she would die. The phrase is taken from the Chief Justice's judgment but it is clear that the other judges also had in mind a risk to life rather than a risk to health. The reality which we cannot ignore is that in other jurisdictions a risk of damage to health is the ground which has led to widescale abortion on demand; nobody is denying that. It was in order to prevent such circumstances developing here that the phrase has been included in the amendment.

Some doctors have expressed concern that the inclusion of the phrase could have the effect of restricting a certain flexibility which, under current medical, practice, doctors are permitted to exercise in the best interests of their patients. It is suggested that in any medical condition there is a spectrum of gravity, to which Deputy Bruton quite rightly referred. It is impossible to identify a precise point at which the risk changes from a risk to health to a risk of life. The concern of the doctors involved seemed to be that the wording may result in their being forced to have a greater degree of certainly about the risk to the mother's life before providing treatment which may result in the loss of the foetus, whereas normal medical practice cannot operate on the basis of certainty but rather on the basis of probability only. That is the key phrase.

When I used the words before "I think"— of which Deputy Bruton reminded me — the manner in which I used them was by way of reassuring Members. It is a mode of language the meaning of which is well known to Deputy Bruton. It is not the intention of the amendment to affect in any way the degree of probability of risk to life that is necessary to warrant treatment resulting in termination. In the X case the Supreme Court laid down the test as being a real and substantial risk to the mother's life arising as a matter of probability. There is nothing in the proposed wording that would change that.

I want to allay fears, expressed by some, that the use of the words "as distinct from the health" in the amendment might result in pregnant women being denied necessary medical treatment to protect their health. There is no basis for that fear and people should not express that fear.

Comment on this

It has not yet been tested.

Comment on this

Under the amendment women will continue to receive all necessary medical treatment to protect their health. Current medical practice in this regard will not be affected. Under current medical practice the question of termination of pregnancy arises only where there is a threat to the mother's life. After all the amendment does no more than adopt the test laid down in this regard by the Supreme Court in the X case. There has been no suggestion that medical practice regarding necessary treatment to protect woman's health has been affected in any way since that decision.

The suggestion that the words "as distinct from the health" should be omitted from the proposed amendment really boils down to this, that it should be possible to terminate the life of an unborn child where there is no risk to the life of the mother. Let there be no doubt about that. The amendment as it stands will allow all necessary treatment to be provided for an expectant mother in all circumstances where her life is at risk even if that would result in the loss of the life of her unborn child.

Comment on this

Can the Minister specifically guarantee that?

Comment on this

There is no basis whatever for the suggestion that the amendment we are proposing today will leave a woman without protection in any situation where her life is endangered. The clear intent of the amendment and the clear meaning of the words used in it is that medical intervention will be allowed in all situations where it is necessary to save the mother's life because of a life-threatening physical, medical condition. If the Government saw any way of omitting the words "as distinct from the health" without giving rise to the real danger that it might eventually lead to abortion on demand we would have left them out.

Comment on this

That is arrant nonsense.

Comment on this

It can be argued that a reference to life on its own should be sufficient on the basis that life means life and not health and that the reference to life in the existing Article 40.3.3º has been interpreted by the Supreme Court in the X case as not including health. However, the words "as distinct from the health" formed part of the test enunciated by the Chief Justice in that case. If those words were to be omitted now from a constitutional provision which reproduces the essence of that test, significance might well be read into that omission. In a future hard case health unrelated to a life-threatening condition, might be found to be a good ground for abortion, as happened in another jurisdiction, the result of which we are all familiar with.

Comment on this

If that is the legal advice the Minister is getting he should change his legal adviser.

Comment on this

Health, unrelated to a threat to life, has never been a ground for medical intervention where it is foreseen and therefore intended that the death of the unborn child would result. Unforeseen death of the foetus in the course of a medical intervention to protect the mother's life or her health, where all due care is taken to preserve the life of the foetus, is of course an entirely different matter and is not prohibited by law. What the proposed Twelfth Amendment of the Constitution seeks to do is to maintain a just and proper balance between the right to life of the mother and the right to life of the unborn child.

Comment on this

And a mistrust of women.

Comment on this

And doctors.

Comment on this
Pearse Wyse Acting Chairman (Mr. Wyse) Progressive Democrats

Order, please.

Comment on this

Deputy Bruton spoke about the word "intention", and I have sought to put into context exactly what that means. The Deputy must remember that the intention is important as long as the words support it and are interpreted as the correct words to satisfy that intention, and that is what is done here.

We all like to get the opportunity to quote from people of consequence in these matters. I took some comfort from the letter in the Irish Press of 26 October under the names of Patricia Casey, Professor of Psychiatry in UCD, Cornelius O'Leary, Professor of Political Science——

Comment on this

And Mary McAleese.

Comment on this

Yes, and Mary McAleese.

Comment on this

After the Minister's humiliation he is trying to get back in favour.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

We are discussing a very serious subject and everybody will have an opportunity of making a contribution.

Comment on this

We will not.

Comment on this

We will not have an opportunity to contribute.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I want to make sure there are no further interruptions. The Minister has a right to reply to questions without interruption.

Comment on this

The Deputy is safer up there than he is down here.

Comment on this

I am quite sure that if I wished to take up the time of the House it would be simple for me to read into the record, with some justification, the letter of these people, but I am not going to do that. I am simply referring Deputies to that letter.

Comment on this

Ministers are on record since 1983——

Comment on this

It is there, word for word.

Comment on this

Is it not interesting——

Comment on this

For whom?

Comment on this

For the Deputy, as one——

Comment on this

The Minister should speak for himself.

Comment on this

——and for many of his colleagues also. I will refer to the opening sentence of that letter in which these people said they welcome and support the forthcoming referendum on the substantive law on abortion and hope that all those who are pro-life will feel as they do and vote yes. The rest of the letter will be read no doubt by people individually. The letter contains some very interesting points and refers specifically to all the points that have been referred to by various Deputies.

Comment on this

The Minister should tell us what the Attorney General told him in regard to this proposal and the need for legislation. As the Minister is quoting from authority, he should tell us what the primary law officer of the country told him.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Minister is in order. There should be no interruptions.

Comment on this

If the Minister wishes to quote from newspapers he should tell us the Attorney General's advice to Government in regard to this proposal.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I have already replied to the Deputy; the Minister is in order. There should be no further interruptions.

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this

Deputy McCartan on occasion likes to raise his voice in pursuance of certain aspects of this matter.

Comment on this

On a point of order, may I ask if it is within your powers, a Chathaoirligh, to grant to other Deputies the opportunity of speaking? As one of the women in the House, I would be very interested in making a contribution, but I do not think that will be possible.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I am not responsible for the length of contributions made by Deputies and Ministers.

Comment on this

In fairness to Deputy Fennell, I hope she will have an opportunity to contribute. I would point out to the Deputy that I sat here for most of the day without contributing. I did not contribute to section 1 until people badgered me into doing so. As I said, I am very happy to contribute, and this is my first contribution since the first vote was taken. I have no problem in allowing all Deputies to make Second Stage speeches again on all these issues, but I do not want anybody to say that I did not respond to them. For that reason I am taking a little extra time, but I promise to be as quick as I can.

I was pleased to hear Deputy Mac Giolla's comment that he understands the reason the Government say that if the amendment is not endorsed on 3 December there will be need for legislation. While others may think that is some kind of threat, that is not the intention but it is the reasonable thing to do. Deputy Mac Giolla summed up the matter neatly when he asked what else would one do.

I would take issue with Deputy Mac Giolla in that he saw no reference to "mother". This is one of the points raised by many people but they seem to forget that what is involved is not 55 words, as was continually referred to by Deputy Bruton, but 133 words, the number of words in Article 40.3.3º together with the 55 words — I take for granted Deputy Bruton's numerical ability on that matter.

Comment on this

There are too many words.

Comment on this

It took 6,000 words to control dogs.

Comment on this

Deputy Mac Giolla missed the point that "mother" is referred to in Article 40.3.3º.

Comment on this

That does not make it right.

Comment on this

As the Deputy suggested, it is not referred to here. The Deputy also made the point that he does not favour an amendment at all, but that matter was disposed of this afternoon. The vast majority of people wish — and that wish has been realised — that there will be a referendum on this matter so that we will get it out of the way once and for all. Some people may ask why we are holding three referenda, but all the party leaders signed up for this.

Comment on this

That is incorrect.

Comment on this

All the party leaders signed up that referenda would be held before the autumn or in the autumn — I cannot remember the exact terminology——

Comment on this

On travel and information.

Comment on this

Yes, on travel and information.

Comment on this

On a point of order, if the Minister wants to refer to an agreement between party leaders he should make sure his reference is correct. The record of this House shows clearly what the party leaders signed up for, and it is not what the Minister is trying to imply.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I do not think that is a point of order, Deputy.

Comment on this

I was only making the point that the party leaders agreed that there would be a referendum on travel and information and that the substantive issue would be dealt with by a referendum and/or legislation in the autumn. The Government have honoured that commitment, which people should recognise.

I should like to discuss amendments Nos. 3 and 12 as they are being taken with amendment No. 2. They deal with existing medical practice. Doctors may feel that, in some way, the inclusion of the phrase "as distinct from the health" in the Government amendment will inhibit them from acting until there is a degree of certainty in relation to the existence of a risk to life, which would be wholly impracticable in medical practice and which can only proceed on the basis of probability. I have explained previously to the House that the Supreme Court decision requires only that the existence of a real and substantial risk to life be established on the balance of probabilities — there is nothing in the amendment which would change that.

The phrase "necessary to save the life" does not mean that the risk to life must be imminent or immediate before action to terminate the pregnancy will be permitted. In this context cases of cardiac conditions or treatment involving chemotherapy in the early stages of pregnancy are mentioned; the test enunciated by the Supreme Court does not require that the risk to life must be immediate. The court specifically rejected that proposition, neither does the wording of the proposed amendment require that the risk to life should be immediate. I am advised that the phrase "necessary to save the life" means that the pregnancy could be terminated if the doctors were able to form the view that, even after childbirth and recovery of the mother, other treatment, for whatever condition from which she was suffering, would be ineffective to protect her life.

There have been suggestions that the Bill will render unlawful medical treatment for mothers where that treatment is for the benefit of their health as opposed to saving their lives. The Bill is not changing the law in this respect, it adopts the existing law as set out by the Supreme Court and nobody has ever suggested, as far as I know, that the Supreme Court decision has given rise to the consequences which it is now claimed would flow from the amendment. My understanding of current medical practice is that medical treatment for a health condition which is not life threatening is not permitted if the foreseen result of that treatment is the death of the feotus but that medical treatment is permitted where the life of the mother is at risk and the loss of life of the foetus from such treatment is foreseen. It may, of course, also occasionally happen that a drug or other therapy given for some condition causes an entirely unforeseen adverse response and leads to the loss of life of the foetus. I am advised that the wording proposed could not be held to imply a breach of the law in circumstances where the life of the foetus is lost as an unforeseen and unintended consequence of treatment carried out in good faith.

Comment on this

Matters like this raised in the debate have implications not only for the general public but for the medical profession. It is clear that medical care of women and the provision of that care when life is at risk should remain to the fore of the debate. The medical profession are called upon to deal with issues of life and death with the complex legal and treatment considerations of patients under their care. Individual doctors will be at the forefront of the decision making process implicit in the issues raised by the referendum on the substantive issue. It is not the referendum which brings this about, it is a fact of medical life.

Every day the medical profession provide expert medical and surgical care for pregnant women regardless of the medical complexities, rarity of diagnosis or the trauma which, in exceptional individual cases, may arise. It is necessary to reassure people generally — and women in particular — that that caring and expertise will remain fully available in our health services, regardless of the outcome of the referenda. It should be stressed that such treatment and care have been the hallmark of our health services for many years. It should be clearly acknowledged that the medical profession are obviously to the fore in deciding on matters that are the essence of life and death.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I do not want to interrupt the Minister. However, we are debating Committee Stage and some Members have made relatively lengthy contributions. Is it in order for the Minister to read from a prepared script? It is not normal on Committee Stage.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

I am just finishing a contribution which I thought necessary to put on the record. This has been appreciated by many of Deputy Shatter's colleagues. The exact position should be stated clearly and unambiguously on the record——

Comment on this

With certainty?

Comment on this

As the Minister understands it?

Comment on this

With the same level of certainty which applied in 1983?

Comment on this

With as much certainty as I can muster.

Comment on this

It is like an action replay.

Comment on this

It should be clearly acknowledged that the medical profession are obviously to the fore in deciding matters which are the essence of life and death and that reliance on the profession has been well placed as evidenced by the high national — and international — reputation of our obstretric and by gynaecological services in particular. This faith is clearly shared by the general public and must be safeguarded at all costs during the referenda debate. That is an important element. This has been a major element of the contribution to the debate of the Minister for Health in the House and outside it.

I know my contribution was long but, in fairness to those who made decent contributions in the House, the least I could do was to acknowledge that and respond in kind by giving a good, clear outline in as precise terms as possible.

Comment on this

I have listened carefully to the Minister during all stages of this debate and indeed prior to the Second Stage debate. Will he admit that he might be wrong this time as well? The Minister prefaced his remarks by saying he was "advised". Needless to say, he is being advised by a broad range of people on this occasion but I am sure he was also advised in 1983 when he got it miserably wrong. The people at least deserve an apology in that respect because of what the Minister said throughout that debate. Indeed, I questioned his motives on that occasion.

The Minister referred to the medical profession; with all due respect, he is doing a great disservice to the medical profession and if he had the respect for them which he claims to have he would not go about the amendment in this way because he will cause more problems for the medical profession. Problems were caused by the Minister for Health and the Taoiseach in their first attempts to explain what the Minister for Justice was trying to do, consequently confusion was rampant.

The Minister will not allay the fears expressed by myself and others that certain medical treatments which are available at present will not be available after the amendment is passed — if it is passed, which is doubtful. There might have been some possibility of allaying those fears if legislation had been enacted. I am at a loss to understand, after the Minister's last contribution, why the Government are reluctant to introduce legislation now that it is an option. However, the Minister will introduce it without any difficulty if he is defeated on 3 December. If it does not cause any problems to introduce it the second time round, why not do it properly and try to avoid some of the consequences of the awful mess we got into since 1983?

Judging by the conduct of the Taoiseach in Dublin Castle today, it appears that we are looking down the barrel of a gun in relation to a general election and I hope that courageous people will hold on to their nerve in the face of that election because, if we find ourselves on platforms within a matter of weeks, I trust the Minister for Justice will still stick to some aspects of his Second Stage speech which are a major advance on his previously adopted position. In that speech he said: "under the amendment, where a pregnant woman is suffering from a physical medical condition such that her life is in danger if the pregnancy continues, the pregnancy may be lawfully terminated if that is necessary to save her life". I trust that the Minister for Health will explain that sentence to many of his colleagues, male and female, who supported him on Thursday last because, if a general election is declared, as seems likely, and if Cabinet confidentiality and collective responsibility mean anything, then I suspect that many of the Minister's——

Comment on this

Is there something I should know about?

Comment on this

The Minister may want to read the newspapers. To answer that question quite bluntly, it is my opinion that the whole notion of collective responsibility has been thrown out the window in the context of the Taoiseach's remarks at the Beef Tribunal today.

Comment on this

When did this happen?

Comment on this

That is something the Minister can catch up on. I trust that Government Deputies will stick to the sentence I have just read out, from the Minister's Second Stage speech because from comments I have read in the press today it would appear that some of them neither understand it nor want to understand it and certainly do not want to support it. That sentence results from the advice of the Attorney General or at least that part of his advice that the Minister obviously accepted. Unfortunately, as was demonstrated when the Minister set out to explain the words in the context of the amendments put down in my name and in the name of Deputy Howlin, practically every word in the Minister's amendment to the Constitution is loaded with potential meaning. We might have had some opportunity to clarify the meaning if we were dealing with legislation. One thing is obvious: the statements of Government intent, even if they were clear and not as confused as they have been, are meaningless because it will be the Supreme Court who will again in due course — I would say it will not take another ten years, because I am sure these words will be tested before then — who will be asked to interpret the meaning of the amendment. The words and phrases that I do not think the Committee will have resolved by 6.45 p.m. this evening are, "necessary", "save", "as distinct from the health", "disorder", and "not being a risk of self-destruction". The potential meaning and the consequence of each of those both individually and taken together will, I believe, place many women at risk. I have not heard anything in the House this afternoon to allay those fears.

The use of the term "save the life", could, as I said in my Second Stage contribution be much better phrased as "protect the life". Somebody's life could be protected from the probability of a medical emergency in the future as opposed to protecting somebody's life from the consequences of that emergency, a distinction the Minister seems to have difficulty in accepting. Apart altogether from the offensiveness of the term "as distinct from the health" in its implying that the health of women is not an area of concern to the Members of the House, and that what we are having is a reflection of a debate that took place in this country about 40 years ago——

Comment on this

That is most unfair.

Comment on this

It is, Minister, but unfortunately, you did not say anything either in your Second Stage contribution or today that might allay those fears, as the women of Ireland will, I expect, demonstrate on 3 December.

Comment on this

Thankfully, that view is not shared by the Leader of the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this

On 3 December the women of Ireland will demonstrate that they consider the wording to be an insult to their health.

If the Minister has the opportunity to reply to this debate, perhaps he will say on what basis he was advised — he used the words "I am advised"— in relation to the operations which we believe may be ruled out as a result of the use of the term "as distinct from the health", operations that would be perfectly legal now if they were necessary to save the health as distinct from the life of a woman. Could the Minister give examples to which that advice relates? I think it is only if we have the concrete examples that we can know what we are talking about.

The phrase "is necessary to save the life", as distinct from saving the health, of the mother is also a matter of concern. After the Minister's previous contribution, I foresee that there will be grey areas and these areas will have to be dealt with by the medical profession when it is our responsibility to clarify what is meant.

The use of the word "disorder" does not include psychological and psychiatric disorders. Reference to that word in the explanatory memorandum circulated by the Government states that it is necessary to include ectopic pregnancies but it is unfortunate that it rules out — and the Minister persists in this exclusion — all forms of psychological and psychiatric disorders. I believe that to be an absolute insult to the advances that have been made in those areas of medicine in the past years. Again, that is an element the Government will have to examine.

The unfortunate aspect is that the Minister seems to have made up his mind.

I consider the Taoiseach's manner in offering the people this amendment which the majority of Members in the House consider to be unsatisfactory, and the manner in which he referred to legislation, to be a threat to the Irish people. What the Taoiseach is saying is that we can deal with absolutes in an extremely complex area. This is not a black and white issue. Unfortunately, we will not have the matter ironed out. The medical profession will carry the brunt of the lack of responsibility shown in this House on this occasion and, unfortunately, whether we like it or not, we will be back in the House legislating one way or the other within a very short period.

Comment on this
Pearse Wyse Acting Chairman (Mr. Wyse) Progressive Democrats

I call on Deputy Nuala Fennell.

Comment on this

Was the Deputy a member of the Government in 1983?

Comment on this

I clarified my position before the election, not like other leaders who got us into this mess.

Comment on this

It is extraordinary that the Deputy can keep referring back to 1983 and the previous amendment to the Constitution when he was a member of the then Government.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Order, Deputies.

Comment on this

I hold my party's brief at this stage.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I call on Deputy Shatter.

Comment on this

As a proposer of the amendment the Committee are now debating, I have no difficulty in giving way to Deputy Fennell but——

Comment on this

I am sorry, but——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

As far as possible, Deputy, I shall try to move the debate around the House. I am now calling on Deputy Shatter.

Comment on this

I am sorry, Sir, but you did call me earlier.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Shatter says he is holding the brief so he does have priority.

Comment on this

Could you assure me——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Will Deputies please make up their minds?

Comment on this

I assure the Deputy that she will have plenty of opportunity to contribute.

Comment on this

Will the call go back to the other side of the House after Deputy Shatter has spoken?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

It will go back to the other Opposition Party——

Comment on this

I should like to have the opportunity to contribute.

Comment on this

And I wish to speak also.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

——because the Minister will then reply to several questions. I understand that Deputy Shatter will give Deputy Fennell an opportunity. The Deputy complained——

Comment on this

I have no objection——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I shall try to facilitate as many Deputies as possible.

Comment on this

I do realise that everybody has a sincere contribution to make but——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I do not want to become involved in a dispute between two Deputies from the same party.

Comment on this

——I should like to think that both my colleague, Deputy Monica Barnes, and myself, who have 25 years experience of working with women, would get a chance to talk about this issue in Dáil Éireann, as we were elected to do.

Comment on this

Could I just say one word before Deputy Shatter starts his contribution? There were other Deputies from this side of the House who would have liked to contribute on the issue. Some of them came to ask if they might do so and I requested that, if they could, they refrain from contributing. Quite a number of Government backbencher Members would have liked to contribute at this stage——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Please, Minister. I have called Deputy Shatter. I think the Deputy should be as brief as possible and come to the point quickly.

Comment on this

I have not yet had an opportunity to talk on the Committee Stage in relation to the amendments that are being dealt with. I should like to deal with certain aspects of the amendments.

The Minister constantly makes an inaccurate statement — one with which Minister O'Dea, who briefly visited the Chamber this evening, seemed to agree — that the formula now presented to us derives directly from what the Supreme Court decided. The Minister correctly states that the Chief Justice made the distinction in his judgment when he referred to the life as distinct from the health of a woman. The Minister then takes unto himself insights of de Valeran proportion when he attempts to look into his heart to discover what was in the minds of the other four members of the Supreme Court, none of whom sought to make that distinction. It is an outrageous inaccuracy for the Minister to justify what is an appalling distinction in this wording — a distinction that is justifiably causing a great deal of concern to women, a distinction that should not be in a Constitution — by stating constantly that he is reflecting what is stated by the Supreme Court, because in the context of the majority judgments none of the judges with the exception of the Chief Justice made such distinction or felt that there was need to make such distinction. To state that to remove the words "as distinct from the health" from the amendment would in some way provide an open door to abortion on demand is such a gross misrepresentation as to be unworthy of the Minister, though it is worthy of the kind of approach we had from him in 1983.

In deference to colleagues who want to make a contribution, I do not want to delay the House by repeating the quotations from the judgments of Mr. Justice O'Flaherty, Mr. Justice Egan and Mr. Justice McCarthy which I put on the record of the House during the Second Stage debate. Suffice it to say that not one of those judges felt the need to make that distinction. What the Government are attempting to do is to insert a distinction into our Constitution which is, in legal terms, an obiter dicta of the Chief Justice, which was irrelevant to the decision that was reached because there was no question in that case other than that the mother's life was at risk and that issue was not teased out.

In this context it should be said that we have a great deal of worry that what the Government are trying to achieve in this amendment is something the Attorney General unsuccessfully attempted to achieve in the Supreme Court. Deputy Bruton, and other Deputies, correctly pointed out that a number of the words contained in this Article — if the Minister is trying to rely on the Chief Justice — do not arise in the judgment of the Chief Justice. Nowhere in his judgment did the Chief Justice talk about a necessity to save the life of the mother. The words "save the life" do not appear in the judgment of the Chief Justice. Indeed, one has a great deal of worry as to why that phrase is used.

Deputy Spring correctly asked whether, for the mother who does not require immediate medical treatment to save her life and it is only something that may be required in the long term, it will be available. The Minister is giving us assurances and telling us of his intentions on this, that and the other but, of course, the intentions of the Minister are irrelevant, it is what is in the wording that is important. It is worth referring to one passage in the judgment of the Chief Justice which has not been referred to in this debate. On page 32 he referred to the need for a harmonious interpretation of the Constitution and the necessity that it be carried out with concepts of prudence, justice and charity, to which my colleague Deputy Noonan referred earlier. He went on to say:

It leads me to the conclusion that in vindicating and defending as far as practicable the right of the unborn to life but at the same time giving due regard to the right of the mother to life, that the Court must, amongst the matters to be so regarded, concern itself with the position of the mother within a family group, with persons on whom she is dependent, with, in other instances, persons who are dependent upon her and her interaction with other citizens and members of society in the areas in which her activities occur.

In other words, in determining issues relating to the life of the mother the Chief Justice said a broad number of matters must be dealt with and addressed. These have not been explained. Neither the Minister nor the Attorney General in his statement explained how this portion of the judgment of the Chief Justice fits into the proposal we now have. What is interesting is the following reference by the Chief Justice to the Attorney General's submission:

Having regard to that conclusion, I am satisfied that the test proposed on behalf of the Attorney General that the life of the unborn could only be terminated if it were established that an inevitable or immediate risk to the life of the mother existed, for the avoidance of which a termination of the pregnancy was necessary, insufficiently vindicates the mother's right to life.

In other words, the Attorney General, on behalf of the Government, in the Supreme Court and in the High Court stated that for there to be a medical intervention to terminate a pregnancy there was a need for an immediate risk to the life of the mother. I wonder whether what the Attorney General could not achieve in the Supreme Court he is now attempting to achieve in the wording before us now in this House.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell Minister for Health (Dr. O'Connell) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy omitted the word "inevitable" for the second time.

Comment on this

The words "inevitable or immediate" were used in the Attorney General's submission. Both Fine Gael and the Labour Party have tabled amendments seeking to remove the words "save the life" and to replace them with the words "protect the life of the mother". I query very seriously why the words "save the life" are in this amendment. Presumably this amendment was sent by the Attorney General's office to the office of the Minister for Justice, was discussed within the Cabinet group that sought to reach a decision on this issue and then presented to us. I have very serious reservations as to whether this wording will allow medical intervention to take place in circumstances where there is a long term as opposed to a short term risk to the life of the mother.

Comment on this

Inevitable is not immediate.

Comment on this

Let no one say this is not a real problem because as recently as 28 September 1992 the story of the late wife of one Brendan Hodges appeared in The Irish Times detailing how during her period of pregnancy she suffered a reactive tumour in her back, having previously suffered cancer, and how medical treatment was delayed until it was too late. This woman lost her life and the life of her baby was lost also. That is a real example of a situation that can arise where medical doctors are confused as to whether they should intervene because of provisions in our Constitution. I understand that case is heading towards the courts but no one has objected to the article in The Irish Times.

Our case is that we cannot be absolutist about this. When the Minister gives assurances in the absolutist manner in which he has done this evening, he is replicating what happened in 1983. What we can properly and validly say is that this wording is open to disparate interpretations which can give rise to confusion. The distinction in relation to health as contained in this could result in treatments which women require more quickly being delayed; it could result in debates within the medical profession that are not concerned with saving the life of a woman but rather with whether doctors will be subject to court injunctions or constitutional actions.

Comment on this

Inevitable is not immediate.

Comment on this

This is not an interpretation. Obviously we are raising an issue that is of real concern to the Minister for Health because this is not some esoteric interpretation of these events that is confined to this side of the House. I should like to refer to one passage only from the speech by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy O'Malley — a passage to which I did not refer earlier — which states:

Another major concern about the proposed Amendment wording is the distinction to be drawn in the Constitution between "life" and "health". This could take away from doctors, from the courts and from this House any right to deal with those hard cases which will arise.

No one can really know whether a pregnancy which will, as a matter of probability, drastically shorten and devastate a woman's life, be permitted to be terminated under this proposal. It seems to me that the wording is calculated to try to distinguish between life shortening and life threatening pregnancies and to exclude completely "life-shortening" risks as a ground for termination.

That was said by a Minister who was privy to the advice of the Attorney General and who, presumably, participated in the Cabinet sub-committee. Unfortunately, he is absent from today's debate. It is worth repeating, that the Progressive Democrats were founded on the basis of standing by the Republic; on this issue it seems to me they are bystanders in the Republic.

This is a serious issue about the health of women and how we can predict this amendment will work out in practice. I do not pretend to have the foresight or prophetic vision the Minister has and say categorically that a particular interpretation of the workings of this amendment in practice or by the Supreme Court will happen. However, this amendment, like the 1983 amendment, is open to a variety of possible interpretations and because of its ambiguity one of its impacts could be to place the life of women at risk. I say this on surer footing than the Minister is on, in that, unfortunately, things I said in 1983 have come to pass. Queries I raised about the wording in 1983 have been proved correct. Practically everything the Minister said about the 1983 wording has been proved to be utterly and completely wrong.

I regret we are dealing with this issue in this way today. Originally when the Taoiseach talked about the possibility of consensus certainly within the Fine Gael Party there was a hope that we would be involved in a genuine discussion and exchange of views to see whether this issue could be tackled in a way which would allow for a consensus to be reached. The Taoiseach's version of a consensus is simply that he puts up a proposal which everyone else must accept and there is no suggestion of taking on board genuine concerns from people——

Comment on this

That is hardly the way I heard the conversation between the Taoiseach and the Deputy's leader.

Comment on this

——who wish to address a serious issue in a serious way. Snide and foolish remarks, Minister——

Comment on this

I had to be a little snide there because that is not how it was.

Comment on this

——directed towards views expressed by colleagues who are sitting beside and behind me who have genuine concerns and worries about this are not appropriate to this debate. Considering the Minister's record on this issue I would have expected a little more reticence on absolutist statements today than we have had in the past.

Comment on this

I have been entirely consistent.

Comment on this

Entirely inconsistent. Everything that has happened since 1983 has been entirely inconsistent with everything the Minister and his colleagues have put on the record of this House. The Minister should have the decency to acknowledge that. The difficulty we have with the present situation is that if the Minister is inaccurate again some women could have their lives placed at risk and some lives could be lost.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy vote in the House?

Comment on this

I did.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy vote with the Government?

Comment on this

Which amendment is the Minister talking about?

Comment on this

The amendment in 1983.

Comment on this

I voted against the 1983 amendment. You voted in favour and created this problem.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputies spoke about the time factor involved, therefore, I ask them to refrain from interrupting and delaying the House further. I ask Deputies not to invite interruptions.

Comment on this

I will deal briefly with some of the reasons I believe this House should support the amendments tabled by Democratic Left in respect of a proposal to substitute a better formula of words to those put forward by the Minister, not just in respect of the difference between the life and health of women, but in regard to a number of other important aspects.

Throughout this debate the Minister has constantly sought to dismiss Deputy De Rossa and me, and indeed my other colleagues in Democratic Left, with a shake of the hand by suggesting that we propose a case for abortion on demand in Ireland. I thank the Chair for giving me the opportunity to deal with that briefly.

The manner in which the Minister sought to dismiss the proposals made by Deputy De Rossa in advancing his amendment was insulting in the extreme. The note I took of what the Minister said was that because, as a party, we propose that abortion should be available in the State to assist women faced with a real and substantial risk to their health as well as their life, we are, therefore, arguing for abortion on demand. He then used the cliché — and I do not understand why he continues to use it — that the Government and himself are not in the business of introducing abortion, that their amendment is a pro-life amendment. I am pro-life; I am the father of children but I am also pro-abortion to the extent that I recognise there are circumstances in which abortion is necessary to assist women to guard against threats, real and substantial, to their life as well as their health.

It is regrettable that the Government, with the wave of the hand and the use of abusive language, continue to dismiss those who in some way wish to address this debate, because they believe we support abortion on demand. My understanding of the words "abortion on demand" is that regimes somewhere in the world provide for the absolute right of a woman to present herself at a clinic up to a certain stage of pregnancy, to be given, without let or hindrance, an abortion as a means to terminate a pregnancy or as a method of birth control. That is what I understand abortion on demand to mean. No one in this House, and indeed no one in the wider debate outside this House as I understand it, has yet sought to make that case and neither Democratic Left nor I are making that case as a medical or other proposition.

In a document which we published during this debate — to which, regrettably, the Minister paid no regard or took no time to consider — we proposed that in certain specific circumstances set out in that document a woman should have the right to opt for termination of her pregnancy. Those circumstances include a case where the life or the health of a woman are threatened with a real and substantial risk, where the woman is subjected to rape or incest or where the medical advice and opinion is that the foetus has no hope of survival beyond delivery. In those circumstances, within a certain period of time, we proposed that a woman should have the right to opt, on medical advice, for a termination of her pregnancy. We set out a broad range of circumstances into which that regime should fit which included proper counselling and support before and after the termination. We suggested a proposition, which has the support at least of one Minister, because he made a similar proposition on our national airwaves, that there is a contradiction in insisting in those circumstances that abortions which take place in another jurisdiction should end and that we should provide for them at home.

Although the Minister has a much narrower definition of the meaning of abortion on demand, he must accept that it exists as a fact of life for many thousands of Irish women today. It has been estimated conservatively that more than 5,000 Irish women each year travel to England with a view to ending their pregnancies. Because he maintains it never happens here but can be facilitated by the right to travel and right to information on such services in a jurisdiction, in some instances no more than 60 or 80 miles away, is the Minister suggesting he is dealing with this issue in a morally correct manner? In a document the Taoiseach circulated to party leaders as representing the basic briefing material from the Attorney General to the Cabinet and upon which the Minister and the Government were making the decision with regard to the legislation, it is stated on page 3:

Some doctors are of the view that it is possible to treat these conditions without resorting to direct abortion. However, it seems difficult to advance, a categorical statement that circumstances could never arise which would require a direct abortion to save the mother's life.

Acting on that advice, that there can never be an absolute proposition advanced that rules out direct abortion in all circumstances, the Government should proceed and they have proceeded.

It is also regrettable that the Minister had absolutely no regard for the acknowledgment I recognised in the Government's proposals, limited though they were, that they squarely address the preposterous argument advanced by the pro-life group that there is an absolute formula of words that can be written into the Constitution ruling our forever the proposition of abortion being provided for in Irish law and medical practice. I acknowledge the Minister had at least taken that ridiculous proposition squarely on board and said categorically that it cannot be adhered to and that the Government were providing, although in restricted circumstances, for abortion in certain circumstances in this State. Yet, the Minister has said that his amendment does not provide for abortion, it is pro-life. Why are we engaging in such dishonesty even at this stage? We have had a reasonable debate on Second Stage and sometimes on Committee Stage. Therefore, why are we reducing this debate to the level of hurling insults across the floor?

The Minister's amendment makes proposals for abortion although he may want to call it something else. I am not worried if he wants to call it termination of pregnancy; that is his right and I do not wish to deny him that right. However, when someone stands up here and uses the word "abortion" it is not a basis upon which the Minister should dismiss us as if we were making some unreal proposition which has not been made in this debate. The Minister must listen to the arguments put forward.

Fine Gael have serious reservations on the distinction between life and health. The Government only want to talk about the right to life, which I accept, but it must be the right to a healthy life. It is no good the Government saying that they will allow women to survive without regard to their condition? Is there to be no regard by our medical profession, our Government and our legislators to the condition in which women will be left after they deliver their child? For instance a woman said on radio only last week that the advice she received was that the inevitable consequence of the delivery of her child to full term would have been incontinence for the rest of her life. Is such a woman to be denied the opportunity and choice to say, "if I want to be a healthy, living woman to care for the other children in my family, I cannot cope with that condition and, therefore, should have the right to consider, in consultation with my medical advisers, a termination of the pregnancy"?

What of the position of the Mrs. Hodgers of this world? Is it a proposition that they are to be helped to the point of delivery, and to survive for only two days after the birth? Can anyone explain to me, either by reference to the previous law which the Government say they are abiding by in this amendment or, indeed, in consequence of what is now before us, what the position of that woman or any woman will be should they have to go through that unbelievable experience, where the husband could stand at the front door of the hospital and hear his wife scream in pain four floors above? What medical practice, what proposition in law or what succour under the Minister's proposal is to be given to a woman in similar unfortunate circumstances?

We in Democratic Left have reservations that have been spelled out in the amendment. A paper prepared by Dr. Anthony Clare, one of the most eminent psychiatrists in this country, concluded — and I quote from the document he prepared: "The relevant literature is reviewed which shows that suicide is an occasional outcome of refused abortion and has fallen in those jurisdictions which permit abortion on psychiatric grounds". To my mind it is utterly inconsistent for people, particularly the Minister for Health, to argue that suicide, which is a clearly identifiable medical condition, cannot be considered as a proper ground for abortions on medical supervision or advice. I utterly reject the Minister's view that it is not scientifically possible to evaluate or establish suicide as a phenomenon. That flies in the face of all medical advice and beliefs as I understand it. It is an incredible statement by the Minister and represents a total shift of ground on his part of this debate because up to now the Minister had argued that if suicide was allowed as an option — following on the partial reliance on the David Owenses of this world — it would represent "abortion on demand". That was the only argument and proposition put forward by the Minister as to why the issue of suicide could not be considered. The Minister, in this preposterous statement, suggests that suicide is scientifically unquantifiable. That proposition must be totally rejected.

I am grateful for the opportunity to make this brief contribution in support of the amendment proposed by Deputy De Rossa and other Deputies in Democratic Left. I believe the Government could have done much better. We have put forward a number of alternative proposals and if the Government ever seriously considered achieving consensus on this issue, they should have adopted the amendment to remove the ridiculous proposition which makes a distinction between the life and the health of the woman. That in itself would have gone some way to meet the reservations on all sides of this House. I do not believe that the Minister, the Taoiseach or anyone on the opposite side of the House had ever any interest in achieving consensus on this issue.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I now call on Deputy Fennell and I will then call on the Minister to reply.

Comment on this

I had thought that following the request made by Deputy Fennell on behalf of both of us that we would at least be allowed to speak on behalf of women in these last few minutes of the debate.

Comment on this

I appreciate the views of all speakers in this debate, and I did not wish in any way to demean or diminish any other Deputy's contribution.

The Minister is deluding himself totally about his support in this House, which he has mentioned frequently. The Progressive Democrats did not support what the Minister was doing. It was a shotgun vote. As far as I am concerned there was not majority support in this House. The majority feeling was against this amendment which is now before us. I regret that the Progressive Democrats decided that this was not an issue on which they could make a stand. We heard the contributions of their two Deputies and we know how they feel about this issue. Therefore, I suggest that the Minister reflect and realise that he does not have a majority in this House for his actions.

I make the appeal that we should be laying down principles in our Constitution, that we should not be inserting definitions such as we have discussed here today. This amendment is laden with uncertainty. It will create difficulties for doctors, in hospitals, and it will introduce uncertainties that were not there previously. It will make women fearful and uncertain when they are beginning a pregnancy. I can assure the Minister — and my views on this do not stem from the last letter in The Irish Times or the last television documentary that I have seen — that I am speaking from my experience as a woman and as a mother, and as somebody who has very close contact with the pregnancy culture, I know what women talk about. I know the kind of secret fears they have. I can assure the Minister that the legislation he is railroading through this House will compound that fear and that doubt.

I have three children and my daughter will soon give birth to a baby. It is a wonderful experience, but I can assure the Minister I have listened to the doubts and uncertainties that women have expressed. This debate, and the following debate, will make women even more uncertain about their treatment and about the kind of dictates that will be made by their doctors. The Minister should have listened to the views of women. He should have listened to people such as Justice Mella Carroll, who gave the Minister a very detailed brief. He should have listened to Frances Fitzgerald and the people in the Council for the Status of Women. He should have listened to the women TDs in this House. I suggest that I, no more than Deputy McCartan, did not like the snide manner in which the Minister referred to my feelings in this debate. Of course there may have been slight differences among the members of this party, but I am proud to belong to a party that allows us to have these differences. Since I entered the party in 1979 we have been allowed to express views that may be different from the mainstream. Unlike the Minister's party, we are not beaten around the head and told that there is only one viewpoint with which everybody must agree.

I support these amendments because I cannot accept the distinction between the health and the life of a woman. The Minister's contribution reads a little like something from a legalistic or moralistic Disneyland, where we are talking about matters which are not quite what they seem, the Minister's own definitions. So far as I am concerned, the life and health of a woman are the same. During my years working and being in close contact with women I have seen many women — some poor and a few with heart complaints — who were worried about their tenth or eleventh pregnancy. Such women would want the freedom to consult their doctors and make the right decisions. I have very little hope that this debate or the debate in the Seanad will change the minds of the Government or the Minister. It seems that these words are written in tablets of stone and it is not possible to change them at this stage. The approach being taken on the health and life of a mother, and excepting suicide, is seriously wrong and I regret it.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I call the Minister.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Dr. G. FitzGerald Fine Gael

Deputy Barnes wishes to intervene.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I have tried to be as fair as possible. I called on the Labour Party, Democratic Left and two speakers from Fine Gael.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Dr. G. FitzGerald Fine Gael

I do not want to speak; I was referring to Deputy Barnes.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I am calling the Minister to reply to some of the queries raised.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister will let Deputy Barnes contribute.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

If the Minister is prepared——

Comment on this

I shall be as brief as possible. Like Deputy Fennell, I appreciate the concern, anger and outrage which has been expressed by men and women during this debate about the proposed wording. I am glad to say that these feelings are shared by people outside this Chamber, particularly by fathers and men who care about the life and health of their wives. These men recognise that childbirth cannot be taken for granted and that it is a time of high anxiety. The Minister referred to the popular and warm approval given to this wording by the majority of people outside this House. He is either totally out of touch or he has not spoken to the majority of the people who believe otherwise.

Like my colleagues, I believe the word "protect" should be included instead of "save". The word "protect" is affirming ative and signifies life. Every pregnant woman needs to know that she will be protected in every way possible. The word "save" is stark and is regarded by women as life threatening. I do not know if the Minister is aware of the enormous difference between those two words and the fear "save" can engender.

I wish to refer to a point which needs to be pinned down here. The Minister said:

If there were to be only one case in one million, or even ten or more million, we would have to take account of it. There is a duty on all of us to ensure that nothing is put into the Constitution which might, even in the remotest possible case, mean that action that was necessary to save a woman's life would not be taken.

I welcome that affirmation but unfortunately it cannot be guaranteed by the wording in the substantive issue. My colleagues have referred to health and quality of life. As we know, women have been worn out, have become invalids, had their lives shortened and their quality of life destroyed as a result of a pregnancy and the health problems which can arise from childbirth. These problems may not be life threatening but they are life shortening and can destroy the quality of life not only of the woman but also of her husband and children. Consideration has to be given to the necessity for a good quality of life. Hopefully it will be recognised that a healthy and protected mother is the most positive unit in our society. The emotional and mental well being of a mother has a ripple effect not alone on her family but on the community as a whole. Everyone in this House knows that if women avail of the opportunities they get to enhance their lives this too will have a ripple effect on society.

Above everything else, I am astonished that the mental, emotional and psychological health of women is being excluded. It is already legally accepted that women suffering from post-natal or pre-natal depression cannot be held responsible for any crimes they commit. How can the Government say that mental, emotional and psychological problems are not life threatening? It has been legally established that a woman suffering from pre-natal or post-natal depression is of disturbed mind.

As Deputy Fennell said, there is a feeling among the Government that they consulted with everybody who needed to be consulted. I wish to state clearly in this House that neither women nor their representatives were listened to. The Second Commission on the Status of Women, the Council for the Status of Women, the Society of Psychologists of Ireland and 13 gynaecologist obstetricians from Cork, Dublin, Donegal, Kerry, Portlaoise, Wexford, Galway and Limerick were not listened to. The Minister may feel that he has listened and learned, but I wish to point out that women have an inbuilt disgust at this wording and feel they will have no control.

I am referring in particular to cases involving rape and incest where a young girl or woman will not be able to terminate a pregnancy. We all recognise that rape and incest represent domination and control and that they destroy people's lives. This violence should not be compounded by more domination and control where a woman is told she has no choice about terminating her pregnancy. This represents an invasion of the integrity of all women. Other Catholic countries and countries which care deeply about life have introduced legislation and, where necessary, constitutional amendments which dignified and valued women and did not sideline, marginalise and frighten them as this wording does.

Comment on this

I want to put on the record that I appreciate what Deputy Bruton said earlier in so far as he had taken advice on certain aspects of this matter. He fully recognised that the use of the words "as distinct from the Health" is in no way to mean giving less care and consideration to the health of the mother. That was generous of him. He put it on the record and he accepts that if that impression is given by the words as framed, it is the wrong impression. It is an important thing for him to say and I gladly acknowledge it. There is nothing that can be interpreted as not allowing all medical attention to be given to a pregnant mother in so far as her health and the protection of her life is concerned.

I had hoped I would not have to waste any time in dealing with a matter which Deputy Shatter persisted in raising on Second Stage, and on occasion today, regarding the words used in the decisions of the judges of the Surpreme Court. I would ask the Deputy to look again at those judgments. I could give quotations to show that all the judges, as well as the Chief Justice, were talking about life, not health. I take it Deputy Shatter agrees that Mr. Justice Finlay made that reference. The late Mr. Justice McCarthy used the phrase "when there is a real and substantial risk attached to her [the mother's] survival". Survival, I would suggest to Deputy Shatter means life, not health.

Comment on this

Nobody is arguing about that. They all said life, but none but the Chief Justice said life as distinct from health.

Comment on this

Deputy Shatter continually made his point about the use of the word "life". Mr. Justice O'Flaherty and Mr. Justice Egan, as well as Mr. Justice McCarthy, always made that distinction. It is quite obvious from their judgments that it can only mean life and not health.

Comment on this

They said life. They did not say life as distinct from health.

Comment on this

Regarding health as a ground for termination of pregnancy, several Deputies would like to have it both ways. I regret that. Deputy Shatter said it is not necessary to make the distinction between life and health, but what he is not prepared to say is whether a risk to health should be a ground for the termination of a pregnancy.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Dr. G. FitzGerald Fine Gael

If it is life-shortening.

Comment on this

He would rather have it judged by the courts. I cannot get a clear and unambiguous reply from Deputy Shatter or from Deputy Barnes.

Comment on this

He does not have one.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Dr. G. FitzGerald Fine Gael

If it is life-shortening.

Comment on this

I regret that, because it raises something in my mind regarding their understanding as far as health is concerned. It is quite clear in the contributions I have made that all medical attention will be given to a pregnant woman in so far as the protection of her health is concerned, in all circumstances.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Dr. G. FitzGerald Fine Gael

The saving of her life?

Comment on this

Regarding the saving of her life, all medical and surgical treatment that is necessary must be given, as has been the common medical practice for many years. It is not altered in one iota by the wording of this amendment. Everybody seems to accept that, except for a few chosen ones. I would ask the Deputies to reconsider. It is the fact of the matter that medical attention will be given to pregnant mothers in so far as the protection of their life and health is concerned, just as it is now, except that suicide is being ruled out as a ground for a termination of pregnancy. Some do not want that. I have heard on various sides of the House that they would like to see it included, but we have stated specifically that this is the real thrust of the Twelfth Amendment of the Constitution. Suicide as a ground for termination of pregnancy will not be included.

Article 40.3.3º is being retained and the right of the unborn is not diminished in any way by this constitutional amendment. The constitutional protection remains undiminished. It is worth remembering that. This is about protection of pregnant mothers and their entitlement to get all medical attention needed for the protection of their health and their lives. It is not just pro-life in so far as the unborn are concerned. It is pro-life in so far as the mother is concerned as well. That is what we are trying to convey in this amendment. I recommend it to the House.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

As it is now 6.45 p.m. I am obliged to put the following Question in accordance with the Resolution of the Dáil of 21 October: "Go n-aontaítear leis seo i gCoiste leis an Sceideal, an Réamhrá agus an Teideal agus go dtuairiscítear an Bille dá réir sin don Teach gan leasú; go gcríochnaítear leis seo an Ceathrú Céim; agus go ndéantar leis seo an Bille a rith. That the Schedule, the Preamble and the Title are hereby agreed to in Committee and the Bill is accordingly reported to the House without amendment; that Fourth Stage is hereby completed; and that the Bill is hereby passed.

Cuireadh an cheist.

Comment on this
Division

Rinne an Dáil vótáil.

Tá 57
·
Níl 0
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?