Electoral (No. 2) Bill, 1991 [ Seanad ]: Committee Stage.
Contributions 125–253 of 253. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 44 of 1991 ›
I move amendment No. 60:
In page 39, subsection (5), line 10, to delete "the expression `Non-Party' " and substitute "any expression, which in the opinion of the returning officer—
(a) cannot be confused with the name of any political party registered in the Register of Political Parties as a party organised to contest a Dáil election;
(b) is not misleading or likely to cause confusion; and
(c) is not unduly long;".
This amendment would allow an Independent candidate to put something other than "non-party" opposite his name on the ballot paper. He or she should be allowed to put any description, within reason, such as "fascist", "communist", "environmentalist", "anti-drugs candidate" and so on. There are many precedents for this in other countries, particularly in Britain, in which Screaming Lord Sutch and his Monster Raving Loony Party stand in elections. If people want to describe themselves in that way on a ballot paper they should be allowed to do so. It would obviate the ridiculous practice which obtained in the case of our former colleague calling himself "Seán Dublin Bay Rockall Loftus". Do we really have to ask people to go to the trouble and expense of changing their names so that the issues for which they stand are apparent to electors when they come to a polling station to vote? It would be much easier to allow candidates to use a simpler description. I have gone to a lot of trouble in wording this amendment, which I hope will be accepted as it stands. The provisions of my amendment are very reasonable. Independent Deputies suffer many drawbacks in the run-up to elections, and indeed after, in the way they are treated in this House. They deserve a break, and democracy would be served by accepting this amendment. The Minister should use a little imagination. What possible harm could result from accepting this amendment?
Comment on this
I withdrew my amendment to this section but I support Deputy Garland's aim to include the word "Independent".
Comment on this
The Bill as drafted, which repeats existing law, provides that a candidate of a registered political party may have the name of the political party concerned shown in relation to his name on the nomination paper and on the ballot. It provides that a non-aligned candidate may adopt the expression "non-party" or leave the relevant space blank. Two of the amendments in this group would allow the non-aligned candidate to describe himself — or herself — as "Independent" or "non-party" or leave the relevant space blank. The other amendments would enable such a candidate to use any description of his own choice which the returning officer does not find objectionable on specified grounds.
I should like to explain that the system of registration of political parties was introduced in 1963 on the recommendation of an all-party Oireachtas Joint Committee on Electoral Law. The purpose of the measure was to enable the political affiliation of candidates to be shown in an ordered way on ballot papers. It would have been possible to achieve that objective in another way. For example, it could have been decided, as is done in the neighbouring jurisdiction, to allow each candidate to use a description of his choice, subject to limitation on the number of words used in the description. This approach introduced to the British public such delights as the "Monster Raving Loony Party", Freddie's Alternative Medicine Party" as well as "Miss Whiplash's Corrective Party".
The Oireachtas of the day wisely decided that the proper approach was to provide a system for registration of political parties. It appears to be generally acceptable that, on the whole, the system has worked remarkably well.
Under the terms of Deputy Garland's amendment we would be apting for both approaches, superimposing the British system on our existing one. Perhaps the hope is that this would give us the best of both worlds. In practice it would be more likely to give us the worst of both worlds. I do not see that any worthwhile purpose would be served by this change and I think the amendments should be rejected. It is rarely a good policy to change horses in mid stream; it is even worst to try to ride two horses simultaneously.
The amendments proposed by Deputies Kavanagh and Gregory would give a non-aligned candidate three choices — to leave the space blank; to use the expression "Non-Party" or to use the word "Independent". I do not see any practical necessity for providing this range of choices. I might stress that the use of the description "Non-Party" is entirely at the discretion of a candidate. Any candidate who does not wish to use that description need not do so and the relevant space on the nomination paper and ballot paper may be left blank.
I consider the expression "Non-Party" to be the most appropriate description for a candidate who wishes to make it known that he or she is not a member of a registered political party. It indicates briefly and clearly that the person does not belong to a registered party. It is a neutral expression whereas the description "Independent" could be regarded as a definite political statement.
Prior to 1963 the name of a political party could not be included on the ballot paper. There was a polite fiction that each candidate was contesting the election as an individual. The Electoral Act, 1963, recognised the reality that most people vote on a party basis. The provisions of that Act introduced a system for registration of parties. Candidates who wished to contest as individuals or did not wish to register their supporting organisation as a political party could describe themselves as "Non-Party" or leave the space blank. The present section continues this arrangement without change. The arrangement has worked remarkably well for almost 33 years. It would not appear to be an area in which there is any great clamour for change; it is basically sound. We shall not copy systems obtaining in other places for obvious reasons. Clearly our present system places nobody at a disadvantage; they may opt to use it or not as the case may be. We should change the system only if there are compelling reasons for so doing which I do not recognise exist.
Comment on this
The Minister's response was very inadequate. I am not familiar with the minutiae of the British electoral law not do I believe that to be necessary here. I mention it merely as an aside. It is quite clear that here at present political parties are entitled to insert the name of the party opposite a candidate, which practice I fully support; I do not think anybody has any problem with that. But, when it comes to Non-Party or Independent candidates the Minister is being extremely complacent. I would remind him that very severe tests are imposed on new political groupings wishing to be registered as political parties, as I know to my cost when it took us some months to be registered in 1981 as the "Ecology Party", as we were then known. In fairness it should be said that it is good that we do not make it too easy for political groupings to form themselves into political parties almost instantaneously. I accept that and that reasonable obstacles must be put in the way, along with reasonable requirements and regulations being laid down.
That having been said, there are people who have a particular cause or issue to fight and who are being denied the right to state that issue or cause. We are very happy with our description — the Green Party — in that when people go to vote and see the Green Party, Comhaontas Glas, they know immediately what that is about, which is of great benefit to us. I do not know what people think the description "Fianna Fáil" stands for but people are very clear, when they vote for the Green Party, what that stands for.
Comment on this
I am speaking on behalf of Independent or potential Independent Deputies who are being seriously disadvantaged. Indeed I am disappointed there has been no response by the Fine Gael Party on this matter. I should have thought they would have agreed with me on that point.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 62 is in the name of Deputy McCartan. Amendments Nos. 63 to 65, inclusive, are alternatives and amendments Nos. 66 and 67 are related. Therefore amendments Nos. 62 to 67, inclusive, may be discussed together. Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 62:
In page 39, lines 26 to 30, to delete subsection (1) and substitute the following:
"47. —(1) A candidate at a Dáil election, or someone on his behalf shall, before the expiration of the time appointed by this Act for receiving nominations, deposit with the returning officer—
(a) the sum of five hundred pounds, or
(b) the sum of one hundred pounds and nomination papers signed by not less than 30 persons (being persons registered as Dáil electors in the constituency for which the said candidate proposes to seek election),
and if he fails to do so his candidature shall be deemed to have been withdrawn."
Three or four major provisions of this Bill stand out, the question of a £500 deposit to allow candidates stand for election being one. We have heard the Minister refer to the "Miss Whiplash's Corrective Party" and other such parties in the United Kingdom. I contend that our system has served us reasonably well in that we have not had the lunatic fringe standing as candidates here. But there have been individuals referred to, such as Seán Dublin Bay Rockall Loftus, who, quite rightly, stood as a candidate in order to highlight issues of burning importance to him. Probably he was the only former Deputy whose title, in addition to his Christian and surnames, was slightly different from that of the rest of us. Indeed those other types of funny candidates who emerge on the British scene also appear on the Continent; there is no shortage of them. Therefore we should make every endeavour to deter such people from standing as candidates in that they undermine the whole democratic process by making it totally laughable, which it most certainly is not.
Part of our amendment seeks the retention of the £100 fee when a candidate can obtain the signature of 30 persons living in the constituency in which they intend standing for election. There are probably famous cases on the record here of people who stood for election and who, at the end of the day, received eight votes, not even having persuaded their family members to support them. Those of us who have been involved in politics for any length of time will be familiar with the voluminous correspondence received from time to time from eccentrics or others seeking to highlight what are burning or very important issues to them and who use all avenues open to them to highlight or expose such issues. I received correspondence today and yesterday from an individual who is threatening to go public with his case, to picket hospitals and ministerial offices, and who is also planning to stand for election. Such people should not be encouraged. If the system is as open as it is, it is possible that lunatic types — lunatic is not the correct word——
Comment on this
——frivolous candidates or candidates who may be unwell may believe this is a way in which they might highlight their individual problems. The fact that we are seeking 30 persons to be joint signatories to a candidate's application is a safeguard that can be embodied in the legislation.
In conclusion, a deposit of £500 on its own as is proposed in this Bill is a retrograde step and we are opposed to it. In order to give recognition to the fact that we should not deter, in any undue manner, participation in the electoral process by serious people who wish to change society, the requirement in amendment No. 62 (i) (b) should be accepted by the Minister. I ask the Minister to accept this amendment.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I believe I am due to speak next because I have tabled the next amendment, amendment No. 63.
Comment on this
I hate to impede Deputy Garland, particularly as I understand he agrees with my amendment. I am delighted to say that I find myself at one and the same time the most liberal and the most conservative of persons on this issue. As far as I can see the amendment I put down and on which I am joined by Deputies Kavanagh, Mac Giolla and Garland——
Comment on this
I do not know. Maybe it is only a matter of time. We are all joined on this amendment. I find that all the other Deputies who have put down amendments on this, including Deputy Kavanagh, have muddied the waters by adding in various other considerations. Deputy Kavanagh, although he has withdrawn the amendment, would like people to——
Comment on this
I know and if the Deputy tries to ride two horses he will get into serious trouble. There are people who want to include signatures in this regard. I have a very simple view on this which is that I oppose the Government's attempt to raise the deposit from £100 to £500. I oppose that outright. I am not prepared to go along with any of the frills and furbelows that are being proposed by other Members to obtain 30 or 1,000 signatures. The idea of increasing the deposit from the current £100 to £500 is an unnecessary and a rather silly proposal. I cannot see any good reason for increasing the deposit. The Minister on Second Stage told us that if the deposit was now to be fixed at the same level, in real purchasing power terms, as it was in 1923, it should be £3,000. I could see some case for doing that if the Minister wished to be consistent with what was done in 1923, but I would oppose it also because I do not believe this has anything to do with real purchasing power. There is nobody in this House, and there are very few people in Fianna Fáil or in the well-heeled Progressive Democrats, if I may say so, Sir, who would agree with increasing the deposit to £3,000. I believe all Deputies would rightly reject such a proposal. I do not agree that there is any need to increase the deposit nor is there any need for these other frivolous measures that are being proposed, such as signatures of 30 persons, a person who is not the first nominated candidate of any other political party, or a petition of nominations signed by 1,000 electors.
I firmly believe in the principle that it should be the right of every citizen in this country to present herself or himself for election if that is what they wish to do. Much of the chat that takes place concerning frivolous candidates is very misplaced. I know there have been some cases, but it is a relatively rare occurrence here. Some of the candidates we might sometimes regard as frivolous have gone through all types of contortions to change their names, to add phrases to their names, etc. and one or two of them have turned out to be relatively serious.
There was one such candidate who was a Member of this House at one stage who I understand took a decision on a particular night in January 1982 that he subsequently regretted. That had nothing to do with the frivolity or otherwise of changing his name. He changed his name for various other eccentric reasons best know to himself.
Comment on this
It was the best decision for this House on that occasion in the light of what subsequently happened.
Comment on this
Perhaps. I do not know, Deputy. Maybe we will have an election in four or five weeks time and we will have an opportunity in the interim to have a conversation about what might have been, although I hope we will be more concerned to discuss what will be at that stage. This particular candidate who, on some of the definitions here, would have been regarded as a frivolous candidate, was elected to this House.
Comment on this
He might have had a problem getting 30 signatures; he might have had a problem getting 1,000 signatures, but he got elected.
Comment on this
I do not think we are entitled to label him as frivolous. However, I did not agree with him; I did not agree with him on that night in January 1982 and there were a great many other issues on which I disagreed with him. However, I would not for a moment regard him as frivolous. If the Government are of the view that by increasing the deposit to £500 or by making a corresponding increase in the deposit for local election candidates they would deter frivolous candidates, I believe they are mistaken.
There was a case, not too long ago, in a constituency which is not represented by any Deputies in the Chamber at present — I beg your pardon, Sir, in your own city — where a candidate was elected in a local election, a candidate who could be fairly described as a frivolous candidate. If the deposit had been raised to ten times its then level, given the type of people who were behind the candidate, that person would have been sponsored, would have been a candidate and might even have been elected.
I do not believe this question in relation to the deposit is the only or necessarily the key question in deciding whether "frivolous" candidates are kept out of the electoral process. If there are people who wish frivolously to present themselves as candidates, then I do not believe that an increase in the deposit from £100 to £500 would make any difference. That being the case, Sir, the Government's proposal here is totally unnecessary, very unwise and should be resisted straightforwardly.
I am not sure, Sir, how you are going to go about putting this group of amendments to the House. Given what I have said I would not support Deputy McCartan's amendment because I do not believe we should agree under any circumstances to an increase in the deposit and, therefore, I could not agree with the second part of Deputy McCartan's amendment, which would require a deposit of £100 to be accompanied by 30 signatories.
I do not understand what Deputy Garland is seeking in amendment No. 63 and, therefore, I would not support that amendment. I do not support Deputy Kavanagh's proposal that we should keep the deposit at £100 only if the names of 1,000 electors accompanied the nomination.
Comment on this
Deputies must address their remarks to the Chair.
Comment on this
I do not support your amendment No. 64, but I am pleased Deputy Kavanagh supports amendment No. 65, which is simply to delete "five" and substitute "one" in section 47. I am open to persuasion by Deputy Kavanagh in relation to amendments Nos. 66 and 67. I hope the Chair does not intend to put this series of amendments by one question, because I would object most strenuously to some of them. I would hate to be presented with a choice of either accepting the mess of pottage that other parties have put up here rather than the simple straightforward proposition that we object to the Government's wrong proposal to increase the deposit.
Comment on this
I will not support the amendment in the name of Deputy McCartan because it includes £500 in some circumstances and I cannot accept amendment No. 63 either. If we had the luxury of having this Bill debated in a special committee like the Roads Bill we could have had a a good debate on amendment No. 64 in my name. My proposal is reasonable. In the circumstances in which we find ourselves today with a Bill being rushed through the only practical thing for me to do is to withdraw my amendment which was put down last Thursday. I was glad I got the support of Deputies Mac Giolla, Dukes and Garland.
Comment on this
I would have liked to discuss the other two amendments in my name, but I am prepared to withdraw them to allow us deal with the amendment to delete £500 and substitute £100. When £100 was suggested as a deposit in the early twenties it was done to exclude certain individuals and parties. A sum of £100 at that time was twice what my father earned for one year. I wonder why Governments since did not change the amount of the deposit. Although it has not been changed we have not seen frivolous candidates such as those who contest by-elections and general elections in Britain. People who might be regarded as being frivolous did not make a habit of going around all constituencies, although some people will seek cheap publicity, the sort one could not buy for £100, by adding their names to a ballot paper.
Some genuine people will find the increase in the deposit exorbitant. We suggest our amendment to meet the wishes of all Opposition parties. We do not know the views of the Progressive Democrats on this but nonetheless I presume all parties, with the exception of Fianna Fáil, are in favour of it. I will withdraw my other amendments so that we can concentrate on amendment No. 65.
Comment on this
I am surprised that Deputy Dukes does not seem to understand the way we work in the House.
Comment on this
The situation is very clear. We start at amendment No. 62 and deal with each amendment, unless it is withdrawn.
Deputies Dukes and Kavanagh should have done me the courtesy of waiting to hear me speak to my amendments before they dismissed them out of hand. I would have liked to have heard more about Deputy Kavanagh's amendment No. 67, but before explaining what it was about, he simply withdrew it.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 67 is separate from what we are talking about. It deals with how the deposit is to be paid. I hope we will not all go in with £500 in £1 coins weighing down our pockets.
I will explain the purpose of my three amendments. One is simply to oppose the increase in the deposit. In order to broaden the debate it is reasonable to put other suggestions. Deputy McCartan's suggestion is excellent in many ways but I take issue with him on the number of people whom he feels are necessary before a person can be nominated. Thirty people is a little thin. Deputy Kavanagh talked about 1,000 electors but that is too many. A very strong case can be made for a signature system and 0.5 per cent of the electorate in any constituency would be a reasonable number for that. These people would state that in their view the candidate was a candidate with a serious political agenda. I suppose at the end of the day these arguments are not very important.
I would have thought that the purpose of my amendment No. 63 was patently obvious. I will explain it to Deputy Dukes. The point we are trying to get across is that each registered political party would be entitled to nominate one candidate per constituency and if they wished to nominate more than one they must pay the deposit. That is not unreasonable.
Comment on this
One per constituency. If the party wanted to put up a second candidate they would have to comply with whatever provisions for deposits we have in place.
Comment on this
As I said, it is very difficult for a group to be registered as a political party here and any political grouping that succeeds in being registered here is by definition a serious political party. There should not be obstacles to putting up one candidate in each constituency. That is not an unreasonable proposition. We will be totally inhibited by this increase. In talking about the substantive issue Deputy Dukes is making the debate a very simple one and perhaps he is right in the last analysis because the Minister will not for one minute look at any signature system or at any of the amendments I have tabled. That does not mean that they should not have been put down.
What case is being made for the increase in the deposit? I went through the records of the last election in 1989. We have 41 constituencies and there were 49 non-party candidates. That is a very significant number. The ballot papers are not being cluttered with 20 or 40 no hope candidates. There is no problem. The Minister is inventing a problem. One or perhaps two non-party candidates on a ballot paper will not be an unreasonable burden for people to accept. We would have to consider the matter if 20 or 30 Independent candidates were standing. We could decide to leave the fee at £100 and if we found at the election that now looks inevitable later this month that ten, 20 or 30 Independent candidates stood in each constituency we could reconsider that decision. However, there is no indication to suggest that that will happen.
Merely increasing the deposit from £100 to £500 will not deter wealthy eccentric candidates who are on some kind of ego trip and who have no serious political agenda. For such people a deposit of £500 would be buttons. Those who will be deterred by the imposition of a £500 deposit will be the unemployed — as was referred to by Deputy Kavanagh in one of his amendments — small political parties such as the Green Party and other small Independent groups. They are the people who are being targeted by the Government.
I wonder where the Progressive Democrats will stand on this issue. Without any doubt the Progressive Democrats are the most wealthy party in Dáil Éireann. They would have the least to lose in the increase of the deposit from £100 to £500, so I presume that in the interests of their own party they will support the Government on this provision. The final nail in the Government's coffin will be the likely attitude of the Progressive Democrats. Progressive Democrat Deputies have not bothered to have even one of their number in the Chamber to deal with the Committee Stage of the Bill in order to put some kind of a different gloss on the Government. Do we have a Fianna Fáil Government or a Fianna Fáil/Progressive Democrat Coalition Government? Where are the Progressive Democrats? They are not in the House. At this last moment I appeal to the Progressive Democrats to do the right thing for democracy by supporting this amendment and thereby opposing the proposed increase in the deposit from £100 to £500.
Comment on this
I think that the Democratic Left spokesman has already spoken to his party's amendment and I should be entitled to speak to my amendment before any other Deputy is brought in.
Comment on this
During the Second Stage debate I spoke fairly strongly on this issue. Amendment No. 65 is the only amendment I have put down to this Bill. I did not have to wait for Deputy Kavanagh's amendment to put down an amendment which proposed a reduction in the deposit from £500 to £100.
I feel very strongly on this issue and it is my opinion that the House should feel very strongly on the issue. At a time when the Dáil and the Oireachtas are becoming more and more remote from the people and people are becoming more and more alienated we should make every effort to have more participation in the electoral process and the democratic process than ever before. The democratic process should be extended outwards so that representatives can be with the people and the people can be with the Dáil and the Oireachtas.
No reason has been given for the increase in the deposit. I would love to know the thinking of the Government in providing for the increase. There is no reason for this measure. No reason has been demonstrated in any election. There has been no problem and no one has ever raised the issue before. All of the Opposition parties oppose the increase. We should strive to involve communities around the country in different areas in the whole process. More communities are beginning to get involved in the process and are putting up candidates on local issues in an area that has a particular problem — whether the problem concerns a planning matter, a dump or something else — and they are quite entitled to do so. Those candidates may not expect to be elected. One does not have to expect to be elected when one stands as a candidate in an election. The vast majority of people who have their names on the ballot papers do not expect to be elected; they expect to make a point and they expect to build up an area, an issue, a party or a process by way of the electoral system. The vast majority of candidates do not expect to be elected——
Comment on this
It is nonsense to say that people should have their names put forward only if they expect to be elected. That is the way in which the whole electoral process will be destroyed. That is the way in which the elite club will be provided for. People already recognise the political system as being an elite and exclusive system because of the difficulties experienced in coming forward and winning against the big parties. The increase in the deposit proposed is a deliberate decision to exclude, and it comes right before the election that seems inevitable in the coming weeks. I presume that this exclusive measure will be pushed through and signed so that it will be in time for the upcoming election. I am sure that the Minister has that thought in mind.
There are many good measures in the Bill. On the Second Stage debate I commended most of the Bill. Much of the Bill is concerned with bringing forward existing legislation and much of it is concerned with the introduction of new features, such as keeping polling booths uncluttered, all of which I commended previously. However, the Minister should really consider the way in which this proposal is perceived by the public and the way in which it is perceived by those who feel that the wrong people are representing them and that they should be doing something locally, which they are entitled to do, to ensure that better people are elected, local people or people who understand a particular issue. He should consider the way in which it is perceived by those who are for political parties and by those who are against political parties. All sorts of people have rights to have their say.
If there are substantial reasons for increasing the deposit they have not yet been put before the House. They were certainly not put forward on the Second Stage debate and I have not yet heard the Minister speak on this section. The Minister will need to give very good reasons for the increase. It is nonsense to speak of monster raving loony parties. Here in Ireland we have never had a problem with that kind of candidate; and even if we did in one election, would that destroy the whole electoral process? For a great number of years and through a large number of elections, through different political parties and various processes, the Irish electorate has become quite sophisticated. Our electors will be the quickest to write off any monster raving loony parties. As has been pointed out already, there is an assumption by the Government that frivolous candidates — we do not know what the meaning of the word "frivolous" is — come only from the poorer sections of the community, candidates who could afford a deposit of £100 but not a deposit of £500.
Comment on this
The most monstrous frivolity comes from the top, from the people who would be able to put up £500,000.
Comment on this
I ask the Minister to consider the effect on the electoral process and the effect on the perception people have of this House and of the Government that will come from pushing through this measure. I hope that the Minister reconsiders this issue.
Comment on this
I should like to say a few words in support of the amendments before the Committee. The whole idea of a deposit was clearly to discourage people from standing for election. Clearly, as has been said already, there is no necessity for that in our electoral system because we do not have a record of frivolous candidates standing for election. We do not have a record of ballot papers being cluttered with the names of large numbers of candidates. That has not happened even since the sum of £100 lost its value as compared with the time that that fee was introduced.
I want to question the whole idea of a deposit because it seems to be a very discriminatory way in which to seek to control the numbers of people standing for election. The sum of £500 is hardly likely to discourage a potential Ross Perot appearing on an Irish ballot paper but it would certainly discourage representatives of a local community organisation who had a particular point of view they wanted to have articulated through an election campaign. The idea of a financial deposit is a discriminatory method of discouraging candidates which penalises people and organisations which do not have the money. I do not think it should be part of our electoral system.
Comment on this
Deputy McCartan's amendment sought to introduce a new idea, which was to have a number of people sign a nomination paper. Clearly that amendment was tabled at a time when most of us anticipated there would probably be a greater length of time to debate and to tease out the idea. It would not appear we will now have that opportunity. The central issue that has to be decided today is whether the deposit remains at the present level or is increased to £500. I am of the view that it should remain at its present level.
The people who are looking in on the practice of politics, particularly during the past couple of weeks, are bewildered at the extent to which Members of this House, including very senior Members, can engage in political antics which bear no relationship whatever to the real problems that people are facing in their homes and in their communities. The last thing people need in the dying days of this Dáil and facing into a general election is for the Government to put through this House a measure which makes it more difficult for people, particularly those on lower incomes, to challenge the Government in the course of the election. The Government would be giving a retrograde signal to the public and adding to an already heightened degree of cynicism at the practice of politics in this country if they decide to increase the cost of standing for election, literally pulling up the ladder on those people who wish to challenge the Government or any Member of this House in the course of the coming general election.
Comment on this
I would like to say a few words. I am doing my best to keep as much cohesion as I can between the parties on the Opposition benches on these questions, but with very little success.
Comment on this
The Minister should not put himself out. He should save his energies for the parties over there.
Comment on this
We had a variety of proposals and it is interesting to note that none of them came to the nub of the question. What is a deposit? It is an earnest of public support; it is refunded if that support materialises. Nobody was gracious enough to admit that. Yes, there has been an increase, the first in 69 years. We will not talk about equivalent comparisons of what it was like then; we were not there, we do not know the circumstances. It is not an almighty hike over 69 years. It is refunded if the required public support materialises. I have reduced the requirement for refund of the deposit. Up to now one had to receive a third of the quota, but now I have reduced that requirement to a quarter, so that it is much easier to reach the stage where one gets a refund of the deposit.
Non-serious candidates, people who have no interest in a Dáil seat, have reasons other than representation for standing. This will perhaps act as a little disincentive, but I will not decide that today. We have before us legislation which sets out to do a number of things. It updates the electoral law in this country, the first reform for 25 years. It deals with all the matters relating to a supplemental register, the question of interference with voters going to poll and it proposes an increase in the deposit. The great majority of candidates have the deposit refunded. This is not a charge. This is not a sum of money which people are just being asked to pay. If you consider yourself a serious candidate, if you have a serious message, if it is reflected in public support and if you obtain a quarter of a quota, the deposit is refunded. Do not try to exaggerate what is involved here. I do not have all the wisdom to say where the figure should lie today. The deposit has been at the rate of £100 for 69 years.
Comment on this
That is not a reason. The Minister has said he will not increase it to anything like the same value as it was at in 1923. He has just said that for 69 years nobody saw the need to increase it. He has not given one single reason for increasing it.
Comment on this
The simple fact is that these issues have not been addressed. I am addressing issues in this House which should have been addressed years ago——
Comment on this
——and I am dealing with them. I will not be the person with all the wisdom to decide what the figure should be.
Comment on this
We are not going to debate that issue. I am prepared to have a look at a slightly lower figure. Beyond that, Deputies have totally exaggerated the impact of this increase. They have misunderstood, deliberately or otherwise, what a deposit is for, how it is refunded when you obtain the public support you expect and how I have rearranged the situation so that it is now much easier to obtain a refund than it was heretofore because you do not require the same percentage of the poll. As far as I am concerned, you are getting a very good deal.
Comment on this
The Minister made statements to the effect that the great majority of candidates have deposits refunded. I would like to see the statistics. What does the great majority mean? I would ask the Minister to prove that. The Minister cannot make statements about that unless he gives us the statistics in regard to refund of deposits in each election.
Deputy Smith rose.
Comment on this
Allow me to make the point. We are all aware of the fact that certain deposits are refunded if one achieves a certain amount of support. The fact is that, even though there is great enthusiasm, many first time candidates in an election do not get the required support, because of pressure from other parties, insufficient money for posters, leaflets, etc, and they do not have their deposits refunded. Those who are well organised and who have the money probably will get one-quarter of the quota and will have their deposits refunded. The Minister is missing the nub of the question, which is that of raising the initial deposit to £500.
Comment on this
I understand that certain political parties put up the deposits for their own candidates and therefore it never comes out of their own pocket. I have to say in the case of my party one had better find the money first. I have every hope of being refunded, but at a time when I am spending quite an amount of my own money——
Comment on this
Can we make some progress on this amendment?
Comment on this
I would hope to get my money back. I would not want my deposit left lying in the county registrar's office for two months before being returned to me, and by way of cheque, even though I had had to pay in cash. I hope the Minister will give consideration to my amendment. Even if we press our amendments, the Minister is not likely to accept them at this stage. However, if he were to give an indication that he would introduce an amendment on Report Stage to reduce the deposit to £200, I should be happy. Such a move would go some way towards achieving the agreement of all Members of the House.
Comment on this
I do not mind what vehicle is used to make the change. Because of the strained circumstances in which we are debating this Bill, perhaps the Minister would accept an amendment now to reduce the amount to £200.
Comment on this
I wish to make two brief points. The Minister seems to be missing the point. The point is that the deposit of £500 has to be put up front; one cannot give the county registrar a post-dated cheque. If a small party or an Independent candidate has to put up £500 they will find it but it means they will have less money to spend on leaflets, which are very important.
The Minister has offered us an olive branch and it would be very churlish of us not to accept some kind of compromise on the amount of the deposit, bearing in mind that we do not have any great choice in the matter. Could we not agree on a figure now?
Comment on this
May I suggest that this could be done under amendment No. 65?
Comment on this
That would be the only realistic way to deal with it at this point. I wish to say to Deputy Mac Giolla that I have represented my constituency for approximately 21 years and that during that time few candidates lost their deposits. On any occasion on which it did happen, only one candidate out of five was concerned. A high percentage of candidates in constituencies in my part of the country have their deposits refunded. I accept that the picture would be slightly different in Dublin but the overall percentage would not be very high. I do not have exact statistics.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 65:
In page 39, subsection (1), line 29, to delete "five" and substitute "one".
Comment on this
In an effort to reach agreement on this matter, I propose that the figure be set at £300.
Amendment No. 65 amended, by leave, by the substitution of "three" for "one".
Comment on this
We now come to amendment No. 68. Amendments Nos. 69 and 70 are alternatives. I suggest that we discuss amendments Nos. 68, 69 and 70 together. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 68:
In page 39, subsection (1) (e), lines 42 and 43, to delete "one quarter of the quota" and substitute "two per cent of the valid poll".
Amendments Nos. 68, 69 and 70 are basically the same. While we accept that the Minister has reduced the figure for return of deposit from 33 per cent to 25 per cent — we appreciate that this gesture is a move in the right direction — nevertheless it it still very high. For example, it means that a candidate in a three-seat constituency would have to get over 6 per cent of the total poll before he would get a refund. This figure is far too high.
There are two ways of dealing with this issue, one of which is to talk in terms of a percentage of the quota. Deputy Kavanagh proposes a figure of 20 per cent of the quota while Deputy McCartan suggests 12.5 per cent of the quota. The figure of 12.5 per cent would be more reasonable than the figure of 20 per cent. However, I would prefer the issue to be decided on the basis of the percentage of the valid poll a candidate gets. This would iron out the differences between three, four and five seat constituencies. It is more logical to talk about a percentage of the valid poll. It is arguable whether the figure should be 1.5 per cent, 2 per cent or 2.5 per cent. I think the Minister would have to concede that a candidate who gets 2 per cent of the electoral vote is a serious candidate. I hope we can make some progress on this matter.
Comment on this
These amendments propose that candidates who get less than one-quarter of the quota, as proposed in the Bill, should have their deposits refunded. The point is that the valid poll in city areas can be a very small percentage of the total poll: it can range from 50 per cent in some constituencies to 80 per cent in other constituencies. This does not seem to be a fair way to decide the matter. My amendment No. 69 proposes that a candidate who receives one-fifth of the quota should be entitled to have his deposit refunded. This is a move in the right direction. I am always afraid to move too far from what the Minister wishes to do as I believe he will reject our proposals out of hand. I regard this proposal as a small improvement, and I hope it is acceptable to the Minister.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 70 proposes that a candidate who receives one-eighth of the quota should be entitled to have his deposit refunded. The Minister proposes that a candidate should receive one-quarter of the quota before his deposit is refunded. The quota in my constituency is 9,000-10,000 votes. Therefore, the Minister's proposal would require a candidate in my constituency to receive 2,500 votes in order to have his deposit refunded.
Much reference was made in the debate on the previous amendments about frivolous candidates; the Minister referred to "serious" candidates. A person who receives 1,500, 2,000 or 2,500 votes is a serious candidate; he has a point of view to express which is supported by a very large number of people, even though it may not be sufficient to have him elected. I do not know what the Minister's personal experience has been but I lost my deposit on the first occasion I stood for election to this House. I thought I had done reasonably well by receiving 1,400 or 1,500 votes. Under Deputy McCartan's amendment a person who stands for election in a constituency similar to the one I represent — he may be an Independent candidate in a local area who wishes to highlight an issue of considerable importance to that area and to give people an opportunity to identify with it — would have to get in excess of 1,000 votes before his deposit would be refunded. That is a fair achievement for first-time candidates and candidates standing for small and large parties who find themselves trailing at the bottom of the list of candidates. I would ask the Minister to reduce the level at which the deposit can be returned.
Comment on this
It looks as if all my good deeds for today have been done. I tried to go as far as I could to give a positive response in regard to the earlier provisions, but I am not minded to make changes here. We have already cut the level from one-third of the quota to one-quarter of the quota. Setting the right balance is a matter of judgment. We have sought to make a positive change in the direction Deputies are seeking, although not going as far as Deputy Kavanagh is suggesting. There is not a great difference, however.
Comment on this
I am not pressing the amendment, but perhaps Deputy Kavanagh could use his powers of oratory to extract a further concession from the Minister.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 69:
In page 39, subsection (1) (e), lines 42 and 43, to delete "one quarter" and substitute "twenty per cent".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 70:
In page 39, subsection (1) (e), lines 42 and 43, to delete "one quarter" and substitute "one eighth".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 71:
In page 40, subsection (3), line 29, to delete "(disregarding any excluded day)".
Comment on this
Amendment No. 72 is in the name of Deputy Kavanagh. Amendments Nos. 73 and 75 are related. Amendment No. 74 is an alternative to amendment No. 73. Is it agreed to take amendments Nos. 72 to 75, inclusive, together? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 72:
In page 41, subsection (3), lines 1 and 2, to delete paragraph (a).
I seek an explanation as to what the Minister is trying to achieve in subsection (3) (a) which states:
(3) The returning officer shall object to the name of a candidate in a nomination paper if such name—
(a) is not a name by which the candidate is commonly known; or
What kind of name can be put down? Is it the Christian name, the Christian name and surname or just the surname? Years ago there was a candidate whose Christian name was not widely known. He was simply known as Backers Byrne because he was fond of betting on horses, as he still is. There were so many Byrnes in Wicklow that each had to have a nickname. Is the Minister suggesting that if the candidate's actual name is not commonly known his nickname will have to be given? It could lead to some strange names on the ballot paper. In the case of names like Byrne or Murphy it is an old custom to use certain characteristics or traits to distinguish one from the other.
Comment on this
Far be it from me to decide that a nickname should not be used. What is required is whatever name appears to be normal. I do not pass out very many bouquets to my opponents in Fine Gael and Labour who were in Government in 1986, but the then Minister was quite wise in making sure that extraneous material which would confuse would not be allowed the light of day. I have had reason to disagree with the great wisdom of the then Minister and I maintain that position now.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 74.
In page 41, subsection (3), line 5, to delete paragraph (d).
This amendment proposes to delete part of subsection (3).
Comment on this
That has already been discussed with amendment No. 72.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 76 is in the name of the Minister. Amendments Nos. 77, 168 and 170 are related. Amendment No. 78 is an alternative to amendment No. 77. It is proposed to take together amendments Nos. 76, 77, 78, 168 and 170.
Comment on this
If amendment No. 78 is an alternative to amendment No. 77, it seems it is also an alternative to amendment No. 76.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 76:
In page 42, subsection (1), line 31, after "constituency" to insert "or to any combination of such persons".
The existing law in relation to free postage for candidates at Dáil, Presidential and European elections is that each candidate is, subject to regulations to be made by An Post, entitled to send free of any charge for postage to each person on the register of electors for the constituency one postal communication containing matter relating to the election only, not exceeding two ounces in weight. Section 57 as drafted restates the provision of existing electoral law in relation to a candidate's free postage entitlement. There has been certain dissatisfaction with the present arrangements relating to free postage facilities, particularly the requirement that election material must be addressed to individual electors. Some parties and candidates would wish to send election letters to each household rather than each elector or, possibly, to vary the arrangements by addressing the election material to each elector in one area and to each household in another.
Consultations have taken place between the parties and the consensus is that free postage provisions should be amended to allow for more flexibility in its operation. Accordingly, amendment No. 76 provides for the amendment of section 57 by giving a candidate at a Dáil election the option of sending an election letter to every person on the register as at present or to any combination of such electors. The other amendments in the group provide for similar amendments to legislation relating to presidential and European elections. The official amendment will, I believe achieve the same objective as the amendment tabled by Deputy Dukes. It also has the advantage of avoiding the use of the word "household" which might be difficult to define in practice. The existing arrangements whereby two or more candidates of the same political party in a constituency are treated as single candidates for this purpose and are entitled to issue a single election letter only are continued in this section.
Comment on this
I am pleased to note that the Minister has moved in this direction and I would be happy to accept the Minister's amendment rather than press my own because it sets out to achieve the same result. I welcome the amendment and am glad the Minister has tabled it. Will this be one of the measures that will be in operation for the forthcoming general election?
Comment on this
I did not publicly indicate up to now that that would be my intention but I believe it is capable of being achieved. There is nothing I know of that can prevent it from being enforced.
Comment on this
I support the Minister's amendment. In regard to this section, I want to put down a marker for the future. It is an appalling waste of time, envelopes and trees by each political party to have people addressing envelopes. Surely it should not be beyond the wit of politicians to develop some system under which all political literature could be sent out to every household at the same time. That would save a great deal of time and expense. The electorate would also welcome it because it would mean they would get the political leaflets from every party in one envelope. The electorate are tired of getting literature through the post at election time.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 79:
In page 44, subsection (2), line 4, after "number" to insert "(being at least a minimum number to be prescribed)".
There is a difficulty when parties with multiple candidates deploy a large number of counters, agents and so on at counts. Parties with one candidate or independent candidates are unable to do a proper check or assessment during the count. Some limitations should be put on the number of people involved in the counts? The idea of, perhaps, 50 people turning up for one party, 30 for another and so on leads to difficulties at counts. There cannot be the surveillance to which each candidate is entitled because of the multiplicity of candidates. My amendment seeks to have a minimum number prescribed by the county registrar. This difficulty arises, in particular, at the count which can become quite a brawl, to put it mildly.
Comment on this
I can visualise circumstances where a minimum number would, be required but this is really a practical matter. The returning officer must take into account the various political groups and the accommodation factor. If a minimum number was set the figure would probably be so low as not to add anything to the corpus that already exists. I understand the problem but I do not believe it is possible to resolve it by means of Deputy Kavanagh's amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 80:
In page 44, subsection (3), line 8, to delete "one person" and substitute "four persons".
My reason for proposing this amendment is partly anticipation and partly sense. This amendment is designated to benefit from the fact that I hope people will no longer canvass outside polling stations. We will then have people from all the political parties carrying out the various duties we are used to carrying out inside the polling station. That would mean that the people carrying out duties inside the polling station would not have to remain there all day. If we are going to have the liberation of people who would otherwise be outside polling stations it might help the comfort of people who work for the parties if they could replace others or take terms of duty inside polling stations. My amendment seeks to ensure that will be the case.
Comment on this
Subsection (3) of section 60 allows each candidate to appoint one personating agent to attend at each polling station for the purpose of assisting in the detection of impersonation. A provision to this effect has been part of the electoral law since the foundation of the State.
The amendment would permit the appointment of four personating agents by each candidate for each polling station. If this amendment was accepted and candidates were to avail of their full rights in this regard, an impossible situation would be created in the polling stations where space is often at a premium. In practice many candidates are not in a position to avail of their present right to appoint one agent for each station. A typical situation at a polling station is that two or three major parties each have one agent.
The point is sometimes made that the personating agents have a long day and that there should be some arrangement to give them a break for meals. This is provided for in section 59 in the appointment of one deputy agent for each polling district. One of the functions of the deputy agent will be to fill in, as necessary, for personating agents. Some personating agents may be in a position to serve for only part of the day, morning or afternoon. The provision in section 60 allowing the appointment of a personating agent to be revoked and another to be appointed could be used in this situation.
Comment on this
I heard what the Minister said but I do not think he heard what I said. My amendment proposes that instead of the present position where, strictly speaking, it is either a nominated personating agent or an authorised subagent who can replace that person we allow the appointment of up to four personating agents, not more than one of whom should be present at any time. Since, I think, the Minister agrees that we should relieve people of these duties outside polling stations we will have more person power available to do the job inside the polling station. Therefore, we should provide for a rota of persons to carry out these duties inside the polling station. I am not proposing that four people should be available for each party at the same time.
I also have put down a related amendment to a later section to allow people to leave the polling station, and return with the permission of the polling officer. I am simply asking the Minister if he would not make life a little bit easier for the activists of all the parties by not requiring them to spend all day in the polling station but that we have the humanity that we are allowed to have now by banning canvassing outside to give us more flexibility inside.
Comment on this
It was clear to me that that is what the Deputy had in mind in the first instance. There is no problem at all in catering for that. I will ensure that that is what will arise from the passage of this legislation.
Comment on this
Is the Minister sure that he can do that by direction, or does he need this amendment in the Bill?
Comment on this
An appointment under this section may be revoked by a candidate or his election agent. Where an appointment of an agent under this section is revoked or an agent appointed under this section resigns or becomes incapable of acting during a Dáil election, another agent may be appointed under this section in his place, and where such an appointment is made a person making the appointment shall forthwith give written notice.
Comment on this
My advice is that it is possible to nominate in the way Deputy Dukes has suggested but I will clarify that further.
Comment on this
To make it clearer, I am not talking about people resigning or being disabled but about people being hungry or wanting to go and pick up the children from school or go and do the many other things that they have to do. I am not sure the Minister can tell us now that he can do that by direction.