Supplementary Estimates 1994. - Appointment of President of High Court: Statements.
Contributions 169–372 of 372. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Deputy McDowell is the first speaker I recall this evening who questions whether the former Attorney General was made aware——
Comment on this
I have not heard any other Deputy make that accusation. The system for dealing with extradition cases failed and it is our duty and responsibility as a Government to make sure it does not happen again.
Comment on this
I have taken the first steps to ensure the system will not fail again. New administrative arrangements have been put in place to ensure that the Attorney General is informed of every extradition request immediately it is received by the office. In addition, the Attorney General has directed that henceforth absolute priority over the other work, irrespective of its importance or urgency, will be given to any extradition request for a person accused of abusing children. I assure the House there will not be another Fr. Brendan Smyth case. The first essential steps are being taken. Three secretaries are considering the basis of management in the Attorney General's office and that is only right.
Comment on this
The systems in this office have been unchanged for too many years. There is no computerisation system or other such service and all those areas have to be reviewed. On behalf of the Government I am giving a full commitment——
Comment on this
A full review of the systems and structures is being carried out and in the meantime resources are being committed by Government and essential steps are being taken to ensure there is not a repetition of this case.
Comment on this
If, as the Taoiseach said on several occasions, the conduct of the Attorney General and the seven months delay was unacceptable, why did he appoint him as President of the High Court?
Comment on this
I did not say his conduct was unacceptable; I said the system that allowed this to happen was unacceptable, that the seven months delay was unacceptable, and I repeat that here.
Comment on this
In dealing with this matter, with the Fr. Smyth case generally and with many of the questions raised this evening, it is necessary to draw a very clear distinction between two explanations for the failure in the Attorney General's office: first, the failure to act because of serious misjudgment by an individual or individuals or because of inefficiencies in the way in which the office is administered; second, the question of deliberate intention not to act for what I describe as sinister motives — for example, an inclination to delay or somehow cover up serious offending simply because the alleged perpetrator was a priest.
Comment on this
I have seen nothing to suggest that the failure outlined in the second explanation was involved. Any suggestion that there was a deliberate cover up would amount to a most serious and damaging charge. For that reason I sincerely ask all contributors to the debate in condemning the failure to bear in mind the crucual distinction between the two types of questions.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach did not answer the question as to why he appointed the Attorney General.
Deputy Molloy rose.
Comment on this
I wish to give notice of my intention to ask a question. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle is not looking this way.
Comment on this
I have called Deputy Kenny. I want to be scrupulously fair in the allocation of time and the record will show that I have been.
Comment on this
In response to questions from the Taoiseach the former Attorney General, in his report said: "In view of certain innuendoes that have been made, I have been assured by the official dealing with the case that there was no contact of any kind from or with any political or other source concerning the case". In the Taoiseach's speech today he said: "In response to my personal inquiries, I have been assured that 4there is no question of outside influence being brought to bear in the case". Will the Taoiseach clarify what those inquiries involved? Did the Taoiseach speak to the former Attorney General or to the official who briefed the former Attorney General in respect of the report he issued?
Comment on this
A number of innuendoes were made about what may or may not have happened and I questioned the former Attorney General in that regard. I wish to state clearly and unequivocally that no extradition case was ever discussed with me since I became Taoiseach.
Comment on this
Were representations made about this case, by any method, to the officials concerned or to the Attorney General? Did the Taoiseach interview the official concerned or did he simply satisfy himself by interviewing the Attorney General?
Comment on this
I was assured that no contact or representations were made from any outside source to the official in the Attorney General's office in regard to this matter.
Comment on this
I thought I had put on the record of the House the information about the RUC, but I will come back to it.
Comment on this
I said earlier that the first step in practising the politics of consensus is to determine, when one does not have agreement, whether it is vital for a decision to be made. Why was it so vital last Friday for this shotgun decision to be made? Will the Taoiseach elaborate on that? If it had come to the Taoiseach's attention that the Attorney General was a member of a clandestine organisation, would it have influenced his judgement on the Attorney General's suitability for high office?
Comment on this
I have outlined extensively the basis that led to the decision. It has transpired that there was a misinterpretation on our part and I have said twice in this House that I and my colleagues genuinely regret any inadvertent offence caused to the Tánaiste and to our colleagues in Government in that regard. I now have the information requested by Deputy O'Donnell about the UK Attorney General's office.
Comment on this
There was correspondence from the RUC on 2 December 1993 requesting the up-to-date position on the Fr. Smyth case. This however was forwarded to the Chief State Solicitor for his attention on 9 December 1993.
Comment on this
As regards the rush to the Phoenix Park, at what stage did the Taoiseach discover that the Labour Ministers would absent themselves? Did he proceed to the Park to put Mr. Whelehan beyond accountability to this House in the belief that Labour Party Ministers had merely dropped out to hear the latest from the count centre in Cork?
Is the Taoiseach satisfied that the Minister for Justice was unaware of the existence of these warrants? Is it not the case that matters of far less serious import than a child abuser at loose in this jurisdiction would have been drawn to the attention of the Minister for Justice and that in this case this information was brought to her desk?
Will the Taoiseach answer the question to which the people want an answer? Why would he put his Government and own reputation and future as Taoiseach at risk for the purposes of making Mr. Whelehan President of the High Court? Does he recall the intervention of the former Attorney General to direct his senior counsel to intervene when the Taoiseach was being questioned at the Beef Tribunal about the motivation behind his decisions as Minister for Industry and Commerce and that this gave rise to the doctrine of Cabinet confidentiality which had the effect of saving his political neck?
Comment on this
Does the Taoiseach accept that the reason he appointed Mr. Harry Whelehan President of the High Court was to repay that debt——
Comment on this
I have no intention of raising to the bait; outrageous allegations are being made in the House.
Comment on this
He did intervene; it is on the record. Counsel were not permitted to inquire about the motivation behind the Taoiseach's decisions when Minister for Industry and Commerce. That is the reason he is President of the High Court and the Taoiseach put at risk the cohesion of the Government.
Comment on this
I am not doing the threatening in this House; I know who is threatening to look into my back rooms and those of Deputy McDowell.
Comment on this
I have no intention of rising to the bait. The facts were determined by Mr. Justice Liam Hamilton and I will leave his report intact. Deputy Rabbitte used the colourful phrase "mad rush to the Park". I explained the matter in detail to Deputy Mitchell who also raised that aspect of the case. I repeat there was no mad rush to the Park as the Deputy suggested. The Secretary to the Government was asked after the Cabinet meeting to make the appropriate arrangements. Other commitments had to be taken into consideration as I am sure the Deputy will appreciate. Saturday was not considered suitable for various reasons.
Comment on this
What about today or tomorrow?
Comment on this
When did the Taoiseach discover that the Labour Party Ministers had withdrawn from Government?
Comment on this
At no time did I discuss what Deputy Rabbitte is trying to infer, that somehow the former Attorney General involved himself; this is something I know nothing about. If the Deputy wants to substantiate this I will be glad to have the matter investigated for him.
Comment on this
Of course he did, it is a matter of record. He intervened directly to direct his senior counsel.
Comment on this
I am sorry, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, but Deputy Rabbitte also raised the question of the role of the Department of Justice. The impression created by media reports today on the role of the Department of Justice in the Smyth extradition case is misleading in that it proceeds on the false assumption that the Department was in possession of certain essential information. This is not the factual position. As is normal practice in extradition cases, a copy of the warrants in the Smyth case was sent——
Comment on this
I have no control over questions. Like everyone else, Deputy Rabbitte has the right to receive a reply.
Comment on this
The information contained in the warrants included the name of the person sought but without any reference to the fact that he was a priest. It also included a previous Northern Ireland address only and signified the offence by reference to named persons without giving their ages——
Comment on this
——and the relevant provisions of the Offences Against the Person Act, 1861, indecent assault against a male and in one case a female.
Comment on this
If Deputy Rabbitte wants the information that is his prerogative. If he wants to ask supplementary questions that is also his prerogative. If Deputy Rabbitte is happy with the information I have given to him I will not read the remaining two pages.
Deputy Rabbitte rose.
Comment on this
I wish to ask the Taoiseach a number of questions. In his opinion is the Attorney General responsible for maladministration in his office? In view of the fact that for some months prior to the appointment of the new President of the High Court he was well aware of the strong opposition of the Labour Party in the partnership Government why did the Taoiseach persist and proceed with the appointment? How did he come to the conclusion that the Labour Party Ministers were merely absenting themselves from the Government meeting to register their non-par-ticipation in the decision to appoint Mr. Harry Whelehan as President of the High Court when they did not return for the remainder of the meeting? The explanation given by the Taoiseach so far to the House is not plausible.
Comment on this
It may well be that the explanation given as to what went wrong in the system is not plausible or acceptable and I agree with the Deputy in that regard. I have already dealt clearly with the question of responsibility, accountability and culpability both in my statement and in response to questions. I quoted W. T. Cosgrave——
Comment on this
Will the Taoiseach answer the question I put to him without reading out what is written on the page to take up the remaining time?
Comment on this
I accept what Deputy McDowell said but the Constitution has not been changed. The responsibility clearly lies with the Government as a whole. I quoted what W. T. Cosgrave said when President of the Executive Council in 1924. He stated that given the necessity to have someone to answer for the Attorney General in this House, where he was not a Member, "in this arrangement the Executive Council has the general responsibility and must be prepared to answer for the Attorney——
Comment on this
The first Irish Government post-independence laid down where the responsibility lay in the Ministers and Secretaries Act.
Comment on this
If I am allowed, I might add that it is 70 years since that happened. I think the House would agree that as part of the strategic management initiative I am undertaking——
Comment on this
——it would be in everyone's interest to look again at the 1924 Ministers and Secretaries Act not just from the point of view of the Government but also from the point of view of Secretaries of Departments——
Comment on this
——who find themselves in an invidious position with regard to decisions taken down the line. That is an issue the Dáil could address profitably.
Comment on this
My colleague beside me, the Minister for Finance, Deputy Ahern, has responsibility for the public service which comprises 187,000 employees.
Comment on this
Is the House seriously suggesting that he should have to take full responsibility if any one of these 187,000 makes a mistake? He is responsible but not culpable. That is an exercise for a future date in this House.
Comment on this
The Chair does not have any discretion in that matter. If I had the discretion, I would accommodate the Deputy. By an Order of the House of this day I must now call on the Taoiseach to respond to the statements.
Comment on this
In the interests of consensus and co-operation I ask the Leas-Cheann Comhairle to allow Deputy Gay Mitchell to raise a final question, even though I have been answering questions for an hour and 15 minutes.
Comment on this
On a point of order it would be fairer if a spokesperson from each of the parties in Opposition was allowed to raise a question. Fair is fair.
Comment on this
On page 16 of his speech the Taoiseach said:
In my opinion it follows that I personally and the Government as a whole must take some responsibility for the deficiencies in the operation of extradition procedures in the Attorney General's Office as brought to light in the Smyth case.
Does this mean he is saying that the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and the Labour Party should share in the guilt of the decision he made last Friday? He said: "My view of good Government is that it must be decisive". Is he contrasting this with the Labour Party's insistence on accountability as indecision and in effect is he not getting in his retaliation first so to speak? Why was none of the 17 or so existing High Court judges from whom every President of the High Court since 1924 was chosen not suitable for the position on this occasion?
Comment on this
I will not go into the latter part of Deputy Mitchell's question, and well he knows it.
What I was discussing was the responsibility of the Government as laid down by W. T. Cosgrave, President of the Executive Council, in relation to the office of the Attorney General. Time and time again this afternoon I have tried to separate the actions, procedures and the systems in the office from what the then Attorney General knew and was not told about the Smyth case. I must have said it four or five times and I hope it is now clear. The answer to Deputy Mitchell's question is "no". It refers to the procedures and systems that have unfortunately failed dismally.
Comment on this
That concludes questions. I must now call on the Taoiseach to make a statement in reply.
Comment on this
I was asked to agree to take one question from Deputy Mitchell and I said that if the House agreed I would take it. I had to beg for the indulgence of the Chair to take the question. It is up to the Chair to decide.
Comment on this
I am working to an Order of the House of this day. We deviated from it with the agreement of the House but I must now call on the Taoiseach to make a statement in reply.
Comment on this
Sir, will you put the matter to the House?
Comment on this
I have answered questions for the past hour and 15 minutes. I have sought to give full, frank, open and honest answers to all the questions. Any fair minded person will accept that I have made a really honest effort to address all the issues raised by the Deputies in this House.
Comment on this
If the Deputy had been present at the Order of Business he would have known what would happen.
Comment on this
Sir, may I ask for a ruling on a point of order, is it in order for the Taoiseach to read a script at this point?
Comment on this
The word "contempt" was introduced in this debate this evening to describe my attitude to my partners in Government. I totally reject that.
Comment on this
I think my partners in Government would certainly accept that I was never contemptuous of them at any Cabinet meeting. I gave them every opportunity to argue their point and we had very successful Cabinet meetings. By and large, every Cabinet meetings, with few exceptions——
Comment on this
——dealt with the full agenda of the Cabinet meeting and we have made progress over the past two years. If we can put the mechanisms in place, we will continue progress for the next two and a half years.
Comment on this
——that persons are regularly extradited on foot of warrants alleging sexual offences.
Comment on this
Sir, did you hear that the Taoiseach has been accused of perjury. Will you ask the Taoiseach to admit to it or comment on it?
Comment on this
I did not hear such a remark. If I had heard such a remark from a Member I would take action.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach was not being accused of perjury. The Taoiseach accused somebody else of perjury 14 times I believe.
Comment on this
For example the latest report on the operation of Part III of the Extradition Act, 1965, which was laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas at the beginning of the year shows that during 1992 four persons were extradited to England for assault and sexual offences against children. During 1993 one warrant was received in respect of the charge of rape and the person was extradited.
I have taken the necessary steps to ensure that the system will not fail again. New administrative arrangements have been put in place to ensure that the Attorney General is informed of every extradition request immediately it is received in his office. In addition the Attorney General has directed that henceforth absolute priority over other work irrespective of its importance or urgency will be given to any extradition request for a person accused of abusing children. I can assure the House that there will not be another case of this type. I have also decided there should be a thorough review of the operations of the office and this will be completed in the shortest possible time, within three weeks and before that, if possible. Deputy Blaney in this House suggested that the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and I should get together and put the country and the economy first. I concur with those sentiments and I hope that this Government will not fall before it has had an opportunity to see the Programme for Government and all it entails carried through to a successful conclusion. The Irish people will be the judge of whether the Programme for Government will have their support for the future and they will say what they think of the Government during its period of office. It has been suggested by Deputy De Rossa that I am unsympathetic to Fr. Smyth's victims — that is totally untrue.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach did not apologise to them.
Comment on this
Many times I have said — so many that I cannot remember — that I deeply regret that offences such as this should happen and that any State organ should fail and thereby put children at risk of abuse.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach apologised to the Irish people but he did not apologise to the victims of Fr. Smyth for the negligence and pain inflicted on them.
Comment on this
I stressed that I abhor and condemn any such acts against children.
Deputy Bruton referred to the accountability of the Attorney General to this House. I have dealt with this matter fully in my statement. The Attorney General is an independent constitutional officer and is not part of the Executive of the State. As well as being the legal officer of the Government he has a quasi-judical role. In the case of the 1987 Extradition Act, he has a clear statutory function. He is not answerable to the Government nor to the Dáil for the exercise of this function. The importance of the independence of the Attorney General has been emphasised many times in our courts. As the Supreme Court put it in McLoughlin v the Minister for Social Welfare, 1956, the Attorney General is in no way the servant of the Government, his is an independent position. He is a great officer of State with grave responsibilities of a quasi-judicial as well as an Executive nature. While he is in office he holds, and must hold, if he is to do his duty and discharge his responsibilities, an independent position. He is specifically excluded from being a member of the Government which again underlines his independent position.
It would clearly be quite inconsistent with the constitutional independence of the Attorney General if he were to be answerable to Dáil Éireann. My statement sets out fully the reasons the appointment of the President of the High Court was proceeded with and the circumstances involved. As I said, I was given no advance warning that my partnership colleagues intended to leave the Government meeting were the issues of this appointment to be decided. I repeat that I genuinely regret the misinterpretation that arose and any inadvertant offence caused to the Tánaiste or his ministerial colleagues or both.
Prior to that decision being taken the only outstanding issue was whether the decision required to be deferred in order to allow me to be accountable on the Attorney General's behalf to the Dáil on the extradition case. As I said, I sought advice on the proper procedures and was confirmed in my view that this postponement was unnecessary because accountability arises for all decisions that have been taken.
There is no question, as Deputy Bruton suggests, that I hold the Labour Party in contempt — I hope I have already dealt with that allegation. I paid tribute in my statement on a number of occasions to the indispensable role in both the Northern Ireland talks process and the peace process which the Tánaiste, Deputy Spring, has played. The two of us working as a team have reconciled the up to now irreconcilable position that existed for 25 years and for anyone to suggest that that success could be achieved by one of the parties involved having contempt for another is simply not plausible nor acceptable to me. The Tánaiste's ministerial colleagues and his party know full well that they too, along with the rest of us, have made a great contribution to the many achievements of this Administration and that we work well as a team.
Deputy Bruton questions the existence of precedence in relation to the appointment of the President of the High Court. I have already given him the statement of one of the most eminent authorities on constitutional Government in Ireland, Professor Basil Chubb. The practice of appointing Attorneys General to the superior courts existed prior to the foundation of the State and has continued since then. Thirteen Attorneys General have been so appointed since 1924——
Comment on this
——including Mr. Hugh Kennedy, who was appointed as Chief Justice on 6 June 1924; Mr. Conor A. Maguire, who was appointed a Judge of the High Court on 3 November 1936 and President of the High Court on 17 December 1936; Mr. Aindrias O'Caoimh, who was appointed a Judge of the Supreme Court on 16 March 1965 and was subsequently appointed President of the High Court on 15 August 1966——
Comment on this
——and Mr. Anthony J. Hederman, who was appointed a Judge of the Supreme Court on 30 June 1981.
While no provision was made in the Programme for Government for any alteration of this custom and precedent, I have made clear that I accept the desirability of such custom is open to question and we have agreed that it will no longer obtain.
Comment on this
As I said in my statement here today, I sincerely regret any offence or hurt that I may have caused in this particular situation. It was never my intention — it would be politically injudicious — to try to wreck a Government that is performing so well and which intends to carry out its full Programme for Government.
Comment on this
I realise politicians have to make their charges. I understand that and I never expected coming in here today that anyone on the opposite side of the House would agree with what I was saying. That is the business of confrontational politics.
Comment on this
I think that my Labour colleagues can give testimony to the fact that I have on all occasions——
Comment on this
——seen the implementation of the Programme for a Partnership Government as the paramount objective of this Government. In fact, if anyone cares to join me in my office after this debate, they will see that I carry out my own personal audit of the Programme for Government, irrespective of the other people who may be monitoring it.
Comment on this
Are we getting absolution from Father Dick Spring?
Comment on this
The new Cabinet should write a better script the next time. The system seems to be breaking down.
Comment on this
As reconciliation has finally broken out in the House I will conclude by saying that I have mentioned new mechanisms which I wish to put in place to ensure that there is no repetition of the breakdown which has occurred in this partnership Government.
Comment on this
I purposely left the details of this mechanism vague and general and would hope that the Tánaiste and our Labour colleagues would see this as a clear indication of my willingness not to put any parameters on those mechanisms, to underline the openness of my approach to ensuring that this effective Government stays in place to ensure the completion of its programme——
Comment on this
——to advance the peace process and to make Ireland more prosperous and more peaceful for our people.
Comment on this
A grovelling Taoiseach. He plays the right tune.
Comment on this
It does not come that early. I have committed myself here to continue to work for this country to make it a more peaceful and more prosperous place for our people of today and our children of tomorrow.