Confidence in Government: Motion.
Contributions 1–177 of 335. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move: "That Dáil Éireann reaffirms its confidence in the Government." Let me make one thing clear. What happened in relation to Judge Lynch's removal, at his own request, from the Special Criminal Court should not have happened. The decision taken by the Government on 1 August should have been implemented immediately. It was not and we do not yet know why. The Minister for Justice has instituted an inquiry which is being conducted by two independent, experienced and respected persons, Mr. Sean Cromien, former secretary of the Department of Finance, and Dr. Edmond Molloy, an independent consultant with expertise in the information technology area. Their report is expected to be with the Minister next Monday, 18 November.
The findings of this inquiry will be made available to the Dáil. The Minister has told the Dáil that when the inquiry is complete she will submit herself to more questions on every aspect of the matter.
The inquiry team will not just be looking at the raw data on the file, they will be able to seek explanations from anyone, inside or outside the public service, who can throw light on anything in the file or the issues surrounding it. Where documentary information is incomplete or partial, the inquiry team will be able to ask questions designed to fill in the gaps. They will also be considering what procedural, administrative or other changes should be made in light of the outcome of the inquiry. When all that is done and the report is complete, the Minister will answer questions in the House for as long as Members have questions to put. That is the fair way to proceed.
The Opposition parties, Fianna Fáil and the Progressive Democrats, knew that this inquiry was under way; the Minister told them so on Thursday. They knew the Minister would answer questions here next week when the inquiry was over, but they were not prepared to wait. They rushed in with their political motion of no confidence on Friday last. They decided that regardless of any facts the inquiry might disclose they had no confidence in the Minister. Quite literally, the two Opposition parties are prejudiced on this matter. They have prejudged the issue before the inquiry is complete. That literally is what prejudice means.
As Deputy Geoghegan-Quinn put it last week "somebody will be blamed", "the blame game" she called it. I could not put it better myself. As far as the two Opposition parties are concerned, it is just that, a game of blame. I do not think it is a game. What happened is serious. It should be seriously examined and it should not be prejudged, as it is by the motion tabled by the Opposition parties.
Comment on this
At this stage I do not know the full facts and reasons that the Government decision of 1 August was not promptly implemented. Let me repeat that I do not know the full facts. As the Minister for Justice made repeatedly clear last week, she does not know the full facts either. She also made clear that she did not want to give out partial information. She told the Dáil that she would not be doing so because "disclosure of partial information could be misleading to the House and possibly leave the propriety of the inquiry procedures open to challenge". That remains a valid concern. We need to know not only what happened but when and why it happened. Only a completed inquiry will enable us to achieve that.
The Minister is being criticised and her resignation called for because she did not tell the Dáil about an undated letter from Judge Lynch that had been first drawn to her attention shortly before she came into the Dáil to speak last Thursday. Because the letter had neither been dated by the sender nor date stamped by the recipient it was not clear to the Minister whether that letter was relevant to an assessment of culpability for the non-implementation of the decision of 1 August. If the letter had been received before the Government decision of 1 August it would have had no relevance to explaining why the Government decision was not implemented afterwards. Without a date on the letter, and given that it was no more than a simple inquiry pursuant to an earlier letter, the letter was impossible to situate in any chain of evidence.
We now know, because Judge Lynch has since told the Minister, that his letter was sent after the Government decision of 1 August and therefore is relevant, along with the two letters from the Attorney General, in establishing the seriousness of the lapse involved in the failure to implement the Government decision in the period after 1 August, but the Minister did not know that when she spoke in the Dáil last week.
Comment on this
It is wrong to accuse the Minister of wanting to conceal that letter. If the Minister wanted to conceal from the Dáil that letter or any other matter relevant to this issue, she would not have set up an independent inquiry with full access to all her files and correspondence, all her officials and indeed Mr. Justice Lynch, and anyone else they want to talk to. If the Minister had any intention in her speech last week of concealing anything she would not, in the same speech, have announced such an unprecedentedly far-reaching, free and independent inquiry and she would not have told the Dáil that she would be coming back with the results of that inquiry to answer questions on it. I am not aware of any inquiry of this kind instituted by any previous Minister of any Department into an administrative failure. I repeat that I want the facts to come out. If, to use Deputy Geoghegan-Quinn's well chosen phrase, Deputies want to engage in the "blame game" let them wait until they have the facts.
Comment on this
I want Deputies to ask questions and have them answered fully, but equally I want Deputies to be just in their judgments and wait for the evidence. In considering that evidence we need to understand the context. For this it is necessary to say a few words about the organisation of public administration in Ireland. The basic legislation is the Ministers and Secretaries Act, 1924——
Comment on this
——under which the Minister is legally responsible, in a formal way, for all matters relating to his or her Department. This Act has given us one of the most centralised government systems in the world. For many years commentators have queried the appropriateness of this legislation, particularly in the circumstances now prevailing in Ireland. As far back as 1975 William Smyth, a former civil servant, writing in Administration put it like this:
This model of civil service subordination, and ministerial omniscience, may have had some resemblance of reality up to, say, the mid 19th century... It can have no such reality today. The truth is that the archaic doctrine of ministerial responsibility covering all actions of civil servants serves to conceal the fact that there is an elaborate system of delegation... Apart from the vast size of Departments, there is the well known fact that Ministers must be away from their Departments a good deal.
That was written in 1975 and it was true in 1975, but it is even more true in 1996. It is a matter of fact that a wide gap has grown up over the years between the law and the way public administration works in practice in Ireland on a daily basis. Professor David Gwynn Morgan wrote as follows in his Constitutional Law of Ireland published in 1985:
It certainly seems unrealistic and dogmatic to expect a Minister's head to roll because some routine act of administration is badly executed by one of his or her civil servants. Departments include hundreds of civil servants and it would be artificial to regard one man as responsible for all their activities. Furthermore resignation offers no gradation of sanctions to deal with different offences of widely varying culpability. Finally, resignation would be impossible in a case in which the responsible Minister had left the Department before the error came to light.
Comment on this
While Ministers in this or previous Governments may not have been punished for the misdeeds of officials, in this Government Ministers, almost uniquely, have been willing to take responsibility for personal errors. The Minister of State, Deputy Phil Hogan, took responsibility for the premature release of budget information and resigned his position. Deputy Coveney took responsibility for a statement attributed to him which suggested a potential conflict of interest and resigned as Minister for Defence and Minister for the Marine.
Comment on this
Other Ministers have taken responsibility by making appropriate personal apologies in circumstances where that has been required. That is different from the record when the parties opposite were in office, particularly in the period 1987-94. I have reminded Deputies opposite often enough of an extensive and expensive recent inquiry where no responsibility was accepted by Ministers for anything that went on, for what they did or what their offices did.
This Government has, in addition to requiring Ministers to be personally accountable where that is appropriate, decided to end the impossible and archaic position created by the Ministers and Secretaries Act, 1924. We will shortly publish the text of a public service management Bill which will amend that Act and bring public administration up to date for the 21st century. The new public service management Bill, which the Government wants to see enacted early in the New Year, will provide a legal mechanism which will allow responsibilities and accountability within the Civil Service to be clearly set out and assigned to identifiable individuals. The responsibilities and accountability of Ministers will also be identified, so also will be the responsibilities and accountability of officials at different levels of administration.
At the same time the ultimate responsibility of Ministers to Dáil Éireann, as well as their positions as heads of their respective Departments, will be preserved. Then no longer will responsibility for the implementation of Government decisions be undefined in terms of clear cut delegation and accountability because the basic legal framework for the Civil Service has remained unaltered since 1924. The enactment of the Public Service Management Bill will be but the latest step this Government will take to improve accountability at all levels.
Other steps we have taken include the following. First, Ministers and I have come before this House to deal specifically——
Comment on this
——with matters of public concern and controversy, such as, the position of a senior official in the Office of the Attorney General, the granting of a second mobile telephone licence, the Duncan extradition case, the hepatitis C issue and the BSE problem. Detailed statements were made, and, most importantly, extensive questions were answered and time and resources were made available to meet whatever concerns the House and the public might have had. Contrast that with the handling of the beef tribunal by Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
Second, This Government has expanded and reformed the committee system of the Dáil, which now gives Members unrivalled access to information and debate. To strengthen the working of these committees, we have introduced legislation to deal with the question of privilege for, and compellability of witnesses, and we will bring forward amendments soon so that we can progress this Bill within the next few weeks. The Bill is designed to make maximum information available to Deputies and thereby add to the accountability of elected representatives to the public.
Third, a Freedom of Information Bill will shortly be published, under which the public will be given a legal right to access official information.
Comment on this
The procedures and rules for dealing with Dáil questions have been changed to ensure that Deputies have the maximum opportunity to query the workings of Government Departments.
Comment on this
The Opposition parties are a little like a President of the United States who, it was alleged, was unable to chew gum and run at the same time. The Deputies opposite should remember that when they shout, they are not able to listen.
Comment on this
I appeal to Deputies opposite to allow themselves to hear what is being said here by maintaining a reasonable degree of calm and quiet. They might gain some knowledge.
Comment on this
May we have an orderly debate now without interruption from either side of the House. The Member in possession is entitled to proceed without this level of interruption.
Comment on this
An independent and permanent board to be known as the Courts Service will be set up within a week on a non-statutory basis. The body will be put on a statutory basis as soon as possible. Its function will be to manage a unified court system. Its chief executive officer will be recruited through open public competition. Responsibility for the prison service will be transferred from the Department of Justice to an independent, permanent, statutory board. Further details will be announced shortly.
Comment on this
May I be allowed by Deputies on all sides of the House to make these announcements without either interruption or assistance?
The Centre for Management and Organisation Development of the Department of Finance has developed a tracking system for ministerial correspondence. I have now asked the Minister for Finance to arrange that the system is immediately put in place in all Government Departments to ensure that, as far as possible, correspondence will be dealt with quickly and efficiently.
Comment on this
I have also asked the Minister for Finance to issue shortly to all Government Departments, new guidelines to follow through Government decisions. I do not minimise the seriousness of the failure to implement a Government decision in this case but this is not the first time in the history of public administration there has been a failure involving a judicial appointment. I draw your attention to the following. First, Judge Vivian Lavan was nominated to the High Court in 1982. It was subsequently discovered there was no vacancy in that court and the nomination had to be withdrawn. The Minister for Justice at the relevant period was Deputy Seán Doherty.
Second, Judge Jarlath Ruane was appointed to the District Court in November 1977. Because of subsequent uncertainty about whether he had the relevant professional practising certificates, he was obliged not to hear cases for five and a half years, even though he was paid a full salary for all those years. The Minister for Justice at the time of that appointment was Deputy Gerry Collins.
Comment on this
Third, Judge Michael Murphy was purportedly appointed to the District Court in 1981. His appointment was subsequently set aside in the High Court on the grounds that he did not have the requisite statutory qualifications. The Minister for Justice at the time of that appointment was Deputy Gerry Collins.
These are just three examples, presided over by Fianna Fáil Ministers, of administrative difficulties relating to judicial appointments. In no case did the relevant Minister resign. In no case was there an apology to this House. In no case was there even an opportunity for this House to debate the issue. Above all, in no case did the relevant Minister institute an inquiry or cause steps to be taken to ensure there would not be a repetition, and, if inquiries had been undertaken at the right time when those three errors were discovered, there would not probably have been a repetition.
Comment on this
Deputy Nora Owen as Minister for Justice has presided over a Department which, in less than two years, has introduced a major anti-drug package, a major anti-crime package, reform of the bail law, reform of the courts, a major prison places programme, and a root and branch review of the Garda Síochána.
Comment on this
At the same time, she has been an active participant in the Anglo-Irish Intergovernmental Conference and, more recently, in the Belfast multi-party talks. Since 1 July this year, she has presided over the work of EU Ministers for Justice and Home Affairs with outstanding success.
Comment on this
The burden she and her Department have been carrying is extremely demanding.
She has set up an independent inquiry to establish the circumstances surrounding the failure to communicate the Government decision of 1 August 1996 to Judge Lynch and to consider what procedural, administrative or other changes should be made in the light of the outcome of that inquiry. She has undertaken to inform the House of the outcome of the inquiry.
Comment on this
This emphasises the commitment of the Government to make information available and to account for its actions to the democratically elected representatives of the people.
I now come to the role of the Attorney General. First, it is important to understand that the Attorney General has no role in the administration of the courts. Nor does he have any role in relation to the communication or implementation of Government decisions. Government Procedure Instructions— a publication with which Deputies opposite who have served in Government will be very familiar — are very clear in that regard. Government decisions are recorded by the Secretary to the Government and transmitted by the Cabinet secretariat to the relevant Department or Departments for implementation.
Comment on this
The Attorney General and members of the Government were not the only people aware of the Government decision of 1 August. Following the routine post-Government briefing by the Government Press Secretary, it was referred to in the media and The Irish Times of 2 August specifically noted the termination of Judge Lynch's appointment to the Special Criminal Court.
Comment on this
It was also published in the Iris Oifigiúil of August 9 by the Secretary to the Government as per normal practice. On foot of the Government briefing, the Irish Independent referred to the appointment of Judge Haugh.
On 2 October, as is now well known, the Attorney General wrote to the Minister for Justice indicating that he had been in conversation with Judge Harvey Kenny who said there was an impression among the Judiciary that Judge Lynch was still a member of the Special Criminal Court. The Attorney General, in his letter of 2 October, requested the Minister to establish whether the Government decision had been notified to Judge Lynch and the President of the Circuit Court. At this stage, the Attorney General worked on the assumption that the Government decision had been implemented, that Judge Lynch had been delisted, but that it was simply the case that Judge Harvey Kenny had just not been informed about this.
Comment on this
It appeared to the Attorney General that it was likely there had been some failure of communications during the legal vacation, which was still proceeding at that time, and that word of the changes had simply not percolated through to Judge Harvey Kenny. The Attorney General was aware the President of the Circuit Court had been abroad on official business for an extended period during the summer and that judges were generally due to return to work on the 7 October, after he wrote the letter.
Why did the Attorney General not follow up his letter of 2 October, orally or otherwise? First, as I indicated, the Attorney General has no responsibility in the matter of implementing Government decisions.
Comment on this
Second, he had no reason to assume the matter had not been fully put in order before the law term began on the 7 October, either on foot of the original Government decision or on foot of his letter, and that whatever communications difficulty existed had been resolved. It is relevant to state that Judge Lynch had not sat in the Special Criminal Court at any time between 2 August and 2 October; he had last sat in that court in April.
Third, the Attorney General conducts a substantial volume of written communication with Ministers and civil servants each month. In October alone, between formal advices given by the Attorney General, and letters written by him, he had 112 such written communications with Ministers and senior civil servants, apart from the approximately 150 files he would handle in a normal month, and many other advices given by his legal staff.
Comment on this
It is not the function of the Attorney General, and never has been the function of any Attorney General, to follow up his advices by demanding to know whether they have been acted upon. The Attorney's function, as with any lawyer, is to give advice or information, but it is for the client to act on it. Nor would it be a sensible use of resources for an extremely busy office such as the Attorney General's to follow up every case where advice or information was given, make 112 phone calls or hold 112 personal conversations per month or follow up a similar number of written communications, apart from the fact that most clients would regard such a procedure as an interference with their business.
Comment on this
He does not telephone after a day, a week or a month to inquire whether a Minister has followed the advice or acted on information furnished. He should not and is not expected to do so.
Comment on this
That is not the way professional advisers work, either inside or outside the public service. Clients, once advised, are normally responsible for action to be taken on foot of advice given by a professional adviser. The Attorney General acts in that capacity vis-ávis the Departments, which are his clients.
Comment on this
There are tracking and follow up systems in the Attorney General's office. They are geared to tracking and following up tasks within the office's competence, which it is the business of the Attorney General's office to perform. Requests for advice or instructions by the Attorney to his staff, are all followed up as part of this system. The tracking systems do not cover matters that are appropriately for action by others outside the office. It is not part of the system to police compliance with his advice or action upon information which he may pass on by persons or agencies outside his office. This is normal for professional advisers, be they legal, medical or others, inside or outside the public service. Clients are expected to take responsibility for implementing advice received.
When the Attorney General wrote to the Minister for Justice on Friday, 1 November 1996, he did so because of an uncertainty raised by a newspaper report, as to Judge Lynch's status on the court which the Department of Justice would have been in a position to resolve. That second letter finally brought matters to a head, with results with which we are now familiar. The House cannot today be given a definitive explanation of where in the administrative system things went wrong because the independent inquiry has not completed its work. What I have given is an account of the actions taken by the Minister for Justice and the Attorney General. As the motion has been broadened by the Opposition to include, in effect, the Government as a whole, let me now give the reasons for public confidence in this Government.
As Taoiseach and Leader of the largest party in the Government, I conduct business in an open and honest way with my colleagues, the Tánaiste and the Minister for Social Welfare. Of course we have differences on some policy matters.
Comment on this
Our parties have different origins, different approaches and individual political philosophies. However, we work well together in Government. We are implementing an agreed programme, we respect each other's positions and trust one another. During the past two years we have shown what genuine openness and honesty can accomplish. Our legislative programme saw the enactment of 36 Bills last year and 33 so far this year. We have conducted an effective and efficient Presidency of the EU. This has been widely acknowledged by our European partners. Our economic record is second to none and it is the envy of many countries in Europe and further afield.
There have been record increases in employment, record increases——
Comment on this
——in new overseas investment projects, significant increases in real take-home pay in contrast with the stagnation of earlier periods, sustained low inflation, and low interest rates, benefiting investors and mortgage-holders alike. Mortgage rates are now at their lowest level for 30 years. We have been able to ease the tax burden on businesses and householders while at the same time make dramatic improvements in our public finances. Our economic performance and our success in following the strategy of responsible public sector management has meant that our qualifications for entry to the third phase of economic and monetary union are now fully accepted by the financial markets. Economic growth has been very high. GNP growth averaged 7 per cent, twice the rate projected in 1994 when we came into office. In 1995 growth here was four times the European average. In 1996 growth is expected to remain high at more than 5 per cent per annum. Medium-term forecasts suggest a continuation of strong growth throughout the remainder of this decade.
There has been record employment growth over the past two years since this Government came into office with an increase of 46,000 in 1994 in the numbers at work, measured by the Labour Force Survey, and 57,000 in 1995 alone in just 12 months of this Government.
Comment on this
The preliminary survey for 1996 indicates an increase of 45,000 up to April of this year in the total net number at work.
Comment on this
That is approximately 1,000 more people at work each week since this Government came to office and since I became Taoiseach.
Our economic success has brought our public finances under control with a Government deficit of less than 2 per cent of GDP and a ratio of debt to GDP moving consistently downwards to a point where our debt/GNP ratio is close to what it was more than 20 years ago. It has given us much lower interest rates and a strong balance of payments position which underpins our ability to achieve high growth on a continuing basis.
Our economic success has produced a substantial real increase in net disposable income. Policy for the 1995 and 1996 budgets has been focused on reducing the income tax and PRSI burden on employment, particularly for those on low pay who come very low in the Progressive Democrats order of priorities. These budgets saw personal allowances increased by almost 22 per cent and the standard income tax rate band widened by 22.5 per cent, increases in the allowance and the income tax bands that are more than three times the rate of inflation.
Furthermore, under budgets of this Government people with incomes below £9,750 have been exempted from payment of the health and employment training levies. I know these people would not be a high priority for the new ideologies on the other side of the House but they are a high priority for this Government.
Comment on this
Furthermore, the PRSI free allowance introduced by this Government, not when either Fianna Fáil or the Progressive Democrats were in office, has been increased this year from £50 to £80 per week. These measures have increased take-home pay.
Comment on this
Take home pay for a single person on the average industrial wage has increased by approximately 14.5 per cent overall of which 6.5 per cent arises directly from the real improvements made in tax and PRSI charges in the last three budgets of this Government. Those improvements in the income of people on the average industrial wage are nearly three times the rate of inflation.
Comment on this
I know Deputy McDowell and his colleagues are not particularly concerned about this because they are on incomes well above the average industrial wage but many people are on the average industrial wage and are doing very well out of this Government, a Government in which Fianna Fáil and the Progressive Democrats do not have confidence. I assure Fianna Fáil and the Progressive Democrats that the people have confidence in this Government.
Comment on this
The people have confidence in me, in the Tánaiste and in the Minister for Social Welfare. Fianna Fáil is like a long playing record stuck in a groove marked "December 1994".
In George Orwell's book people were able to project themselves forward to the year 1984.
Comment on this
In the case of the Deputy's party the animals have not been able to evolve beyond December 1994. This obsession with the words "a letter" or "Attorney General" on the part of Fianna Fáil——
Comment on this
——is traceable to one thing, namely, its deep disappointment that through mismanagement and the creation of distrust it is no longer in office.
Comment on this
That party had a golden opportunity which, through mismanagement, creating distrust and arrogance, it threw away.
Comment on this
Its members have sought to deceive themselves into believing it was all to do with Attorneys General, letters and matters of that kind.
Comment on this
That is not the reason Fianna Fáil is in Opposition today. It is in Opposition because its partners did not trust it.
Comment on this
They did not have reason to trust it because of the way Fianna Fáil handled the beef tribunal report. Because Fianna Fáil was unwilling to answer questions about the beef tribunal report and be accountable for any of its findings, trust between it and its partners in Government was destroyed.
Comment on this
It would be in the interests of people in the Fianna Fáil Party if they came to terms with the reality of what happened in 1994 and did not waste their considerable energies on this unhealthy, backward looking obsession with events that are now almost two years old.
Comment on this
I advise the Fianna Fáil Party to look to the future of this country and stop obsessively raking over the coals of its own unfortunate past.
Comment on this
The Deputy and his party are proper subjects for sympathy on this occasion.
As a result of the tax measures this Government has been privileged to introduce the increase in the tax allowance and tax bands for people on the average industrial wage is three times the rate of inflation.
Comment on this
I repeat this again because Deputy McDowell and his party need to be reminded constantly that they are the quintessential niche marketing party, a party that is after the niche constituted by the rich and well off.
Comment on this
I assure all the people they will be looked after by this Government but it is not a niche Government. It is a Government which represents well all the people of this nation and we will continue to remind Deputy McDowell, and other niche marketeers who are looking for their niche in history——
Comment on this
I am encouraged by the encouragement I am getting. I am glad the Deputies opposite are beginning to enjoy themselves at last.
Comment on this
It has always been said, and Deputy O'Rourke as a teacher will know this, that the first thing which must be done for instruction is to ensure the pupils are in a good humour. I am glad the Deputies opposite are in a good humour. They are in a mode where they can begin to learn and that is very good. It is very important they should begin to learn a little about their history which is most unfortunate.
Comment on this
It is in their interests, as one would say in the counselling business, to come to terms with their past. I invite the Fianna Fáil party to come to terms with its past. It should forget about Attorneys General and about letters.
Comment on this
It should remember that the important thing for it is to understand that, in a coalition, one cannot treat one's partners like those who are treated under the mushroom principle by being kept in the dark. One must tell partners what one is doing and why.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil is in opposition today and making more noise than it would in Government because it applied the mushroom principle when it was in coalition. It worked on the basis that it was appropriate for it to keep its partners in the dark. This coalition works well because we realise the error Fianna Fáil made in applying the mushroom principle. We keep each other well informed. That is why we have confidence in each other and why the House and the people have confidence in this Government.
Comment on this
Maybe the Leader of the Opposition will tell us if there was a plane on the tarmac in Germany?
Comment on this
The Taoiseach paid lip service throughout his speech to his Minister for Justice and reaffirmed his confidence in her. However, it is a peculiar way to show confidence in a Minister for Justice by taking away more than 50 per cent of her responsibilities in one go.
Comment on this
It is extraordinary to take away a whole core section in one go. The Opposition put down a motion which gave rise to this two day debate. The motion stated:
That Dáil Éireann has no confidence in the Taoiseach, the Minister for Justice and the Attorney General by reason of their failure to implement a Government decision of major importance which resulted in the Special Criminal Court not being properly constituted between August and November 1996...
and concluded:
...that Dáil Éireann condemns the Taoiseach's failure to oversee the proper running of Government and to understand or appreciate the gravity of these errors all of which undermine public confidence in the Institutions of the State.
The administration of justice is the oldest function of Government. It is its core function, the purpose for which it was originally instituted. Justice is central to any ordered society, especially a democracy. Confidence in the administration of justice is therefore equivalent to confidence in Government. How can anyone have confidence in a system where 16 prisoners, charged with serious crimes relating to the security of the State, had to be released and then rearrested because of errors made by the Government? Those who engage in crime, especially subversive crime, have little enough regard for the institutions of State. The legal charade last week of release followed by immediate rearrest could send a wrong message, likely to be cynically received, that the administration of justice can be manipulated at will. The procedure is open to legal challenge. I gather that a number of applications will now be heard under habeas corpus. The possibility that prisoners could be released again on a more permanent basis as a consequence of a ministerial error is damaging. Even Deputy Eric Byrne admitted the Minister would have to resign if one prisoner was set free.
In a case in 1991, where a judge was allowed to continue to sit because of an official error relating to his date of birth of which the Minister could not reasonably have been aware, the irregularity was fatal to conviction. John Kelly, in The Irish Constitution states——
Comment on this
John Kelly in his book refers to Article 30.4.1 of the Constitution which says that justice shall be administered in courts of law. He implied the judge purporting to administer justice had been validly appointed.
Coming only a few months after the Duncan extradition debacle, all this gives ammunition to critics outside this jurisdiction who would be less than impressed with another inefficiency at our end. This undermines the Minister's repeatedly declared will and determination to fight crime and subversion with all means at her disposal. From the beginning, the Minister for Justice has given the impression she is not in charge.
No one could credibly say that about her predecessors all of whom performed their jobs in difficult circumstances to a high standard. We have great satisfaction on this side of the House in our last three Ministers and all our Ministers for Justice, including Deputies Máire Geoghegan-Quinn, Ray Burke and Gerard Collins. No one was in any doubt in their time that there was a firm hand in the Department of Justice which had the respect and confidence of colleagues in the ongoing fight against crime in very difficult circumstances.
Comment on this
If something went wrong, it was corrected. There was no attempt to evade responsibility. The last Minister for Justice nobly offered to resign if it would have helped save a good Government in the spurious dispute over the absence of a reference in the Taoiseach's speech to the Duggan case, something subsequently established by the subcommittee of the Select Committee on Legislation and Security as irrelevant. Fianna Fáil Ministers did not need extravagant and unbelievable testimonials from their colleagues and their civil servants.
I ask the Taoiseach, because he refused to mention it, if it is in the public interest to have Deputy Owen, a constantly embattled Minister on issue after issue, in charge of such a sensitive Department as Justice? What we discuss goes to the heart of the doctrine of democratic accountability. We are not discussing some minor administrative or technical error although the Government has tried extremely hard to no avail over the last five days to convince the Irish public this error is such. We are not talking about some technical issue down the line in the Department which no Minister could reasonably be expected to know about. There are plenty of such issues. We are talking about a matter in the personal charge of the Minister relieving a judge in the Special Criminal Court and appointing another. These decisions were taken at Cabinet at the request of the Minister for Justice. She had to be familiar with the case as did the Attorney General and the Taoiseach.
A decision was published the next day in The Irish Times of 2 August on foot of a briefing by the Government Press Secretary in an article by Geraldine Kennedy headed “Spring to act as Taoiseach while Bruton goes on holidays”. The article also stated “the Government also appointed Judge Kevin Haugh... to the Special Criminal Court to replace Mr. Justice Dominic Lynch”. I brought this article to the attention of the Taoiseach in a question about the role of the acting Taoiseach to which he finally replied on 8 October, and it is surprising that on that day it rang no bells.
The Special Criminal Court is one of the most important courts, its function is vital to the security of the State, which is the first responsibility of any Minister for Justice. In a High Court judgment on 19 May 1983, Mr. Justice Barrington made the point that the court was a creature of statute and that the conditions of the statute on which its jurisdiction depended must be vigorously and meticulously observed. In a Supreme Court judgment in 1990, Mr. Justice Walsh said that the provisions relating to the procedure of the Special Criminal Court must be construed strictly because an accused person was deprived of the constitutional right to trial by jury. If there have been irregularities before, they were not in the ultra-sensitive Special Criminal Court where particular care is necessary.
The Minister for Justice has a special personal relationship with the Judiciary. She is present at Áras an Uachtaráin when the President confers appointments on the most senior judges. Subject to Government decision, it is on the Minister's recommendation that all judicial appointments are made. Such appointments are brought to Government only after consultation with the Attorney General who is head of the Irish Bar, so he is equally involved. The Minister is also personally responsible for ensuring that the State's gratitude is expressed for long service in a court such as the Special Criminal Court which is a particularly onerous responsibility. Yet in this instance three months passed and a letter was still not ready for ministerial signature to notify Mr. Justice Dominic Lynch that he was being relieved as he had requested and at least thanking him for his service. The Minister clearly forgot to ask about the matter. A Minister who paid more attention to what was happening in her office might not have so readily forgotten. The Cabinet Secretariat were able to have the decision published in Iris Oifigiúil within eight days. It has been a time honoured tradition for Ministers to go through decisions with the Secretary of the Department or a senior official. That has happened down through the years in respect of all kinds of minor, not to mind major, decisions.
It is clear that Mr. Justice Dominic Lynch was concerned to get clarification about his position, that is why he wrote to the Minister on 10 October. We now have the terms of that letter which was belatedly brought to the attention of the Minister last Thursday, and read into the record of the House during this debate. Last Thursday the Minister stated the facts, "in so far as they could be established at that stage". She said she thought it was right that the House should have the facts but she did not think to mention the letter from Mr. Justice Lynch of which she was already aware. To paraphrase what the Taoiseach said in May 1995, if no one had asked her the question, would we know about it today? The Minister is clearly guilty of covering up the truth, and the extent of her failure in the matter is now clear to everybody. Revelation by drip-feed is totally destructive of confidence in Government. The mere suspicion of such a scenario was sufficient to lead Labour out of Government not just once but twice in November and December 1994. Where stands the Tánaiste today? Will the Minister state categorically— and it would be helpful if she did rather than engaging in more drip-feeding of the information — whether any court official was in touch with her or her Department about this matter? If so will she give the time and the circumstances?
The Minister and her Department are responsible for administering the courts. There is no autonomous court service in this jurisdiction. Perhaps the Taoiseach was right when he said today that perhaps we now need one, but it has been dragged out of him in the present circumstances, and we will come back to it another day.
Comment on this
The Minister, through her Department, should monitor as a matter of course what is going on in the courts. It defies belief that a Minister and a Department that administer the courts should still not be ready to officially notify a judge, even after three months, that he has been relieved by his duties by Government decision and is, therefore, no longer eligible to sit in the Special Criminal Court. One would have thought that one of the first priorities would to ensure that such a decision was communicated immediately, particularly when the court in question is vital to the security of the State. What has occurred is an appalling lapse in administration and accountability.
The Attorney General's office is also in touch with the courts on a daily basis. because of its overall responsibility for the representation of the State and the public interest in criminal and civil proceedings. The programme A Government of Renewal, refers to the Attorney General's office as "upholder of the public interest in the courts of justice". The Attorney General clearly failed to uphold the public interest in this instance. The matter eventually came to the Attorney General's attention, though only as "an impression", and he wrote a letter to the Minister for Justice on 2 October. Why was there no speedy follow up? Why in view of the importance of the matter, did he let it ride for another month? When the Attorney General wrote to the Minister on 2 October, was he aware of the serious legal implications? If not, that was surely a lapse on his part. If he was, surely the letter should have been followed up immediately by a telephone call or personal conversation on the many occasions that the Attorney General meets the Minister. As the Minister stated last week, the Attorney General's letter of 2 October requested "that I establish whether the Government decision had been notified to Judge Lynch and to the President of the Circuit Court". The Minister did nothing about the letter which did not receive her personal attention. How that happened is another matter. It is not good enough that another month should have elapsed before the Attorney General took any further action. He knew about it. If he knew the implications, he is in a very serious position.
We thought we had all agreed in this House that it was time to bring the Attorney General's office out of the age of Victorian bureaucracy and equip it with the latest technology to assist swift follow-up correspondence. We were told in the second report of the Review Group on the Attorney General's office in April 1996 laid before the Dáil: "In less than one year there has been a fundamental change. The culture of information technology is now firmly embedded in the office." This is obviously not the case. We were further told that the Attorney General is developing a case and correspondence tracking system, which when fully operative, will enable the Attorney General and senior management to keep sensitive office correspondence and files under continuing review. It is obviously not working, or working much too slowly.
On 15 October I asked the Taoiseach whether there was a large backlog of files in the Attorney General's office and whether there were priority cases lagging far behind and running into difficulty. The Taoiseach replied that any legal adviser had to prioritise his or her work, that he was not aware of any significant backlog and that his impression was that the Office of the Attorney General was working exceptionally well and to a high standard of excellence. All that confidence has been undermined in the light of what happened.
It is mind-boggling that the Minister does not have every letter from the Attorney General, the colleague at the Cabinet table closest to her in terms of function, put in front of her immediately as a matter of course. I do not suppose there would be a huge pile of such letters. When I was a Minister I insisted that I be immediately shown all letters from the Taoiseach, other Government Departments and senior officers of State. With my private office I developed a system of tracking such correspondence when it went through the Department for advice and further consideration. The Minister obviously has no such system in operation despite being nearly two years in office. She has had ample opportunity to instruct her private office about what she needs to see and does not need to see immediately. If the Minister is not interested immediately in seeing letters from the Attorney General she is culpable.
Comment on this
She has no effective system. She requested and knew of the Cabinet decision but did not implement it. She did not ensure that she immediately received, as a matter of course, letters from the Attorney General and from a senior judge so she could act on them. There is not just one letter involved; there are several letters.
There has been a litany of Fine Gael mishaps with technology in the lifetime of this Government. Deputy Hogan was sacked for using the fax machine; the Minister of State, Deputy Coveney, was demoted for using the telephone; the Minister for Agriculture, Food and Forestry, Deputy Yates, used a mobile telephone when he should have been in Dublin Airport. The Minister for Justice's story is different: she did not telephone or write to the judge to inform him of the Cabinet decision. The Attorney General did not telephone the Minister to tell her Judge Lynch was still on the bench and nobody rang Judge Lynch to find out when he sent his second letter updating the Minister.
On 27 October 1994, as can be seen from the Official Report, Vol. 446, Col. 1136, Deputy Owen told the Dáil: "Under the Ministers and Secretaries Act, 1924, a Minister is responsible for everything that happens in his or her Department". That is the law.
Comment on this
Following the controversy in the Brendan Smyth case the parties coming into Government, despite what they said in the Dáil, might have believed the legislation was too rigorous. The Taoiseach clearly does. However, the Government has not yet reformed it. I raised this matter with the Taoiseach on the Order of Business on 23 October when I asked him if the reluctance to act on promised legislation to improve openness, transparency and accountability was part of the Government's general sloth.
However, even if the legislation had been reformed the Minister would surely remain responsible and accountable for the execution of decisions which she prepared, brought to Cabinet and brought back from Cabinet. She is also accountable for lack of action on correspondence from the Office of the Attorney General and from Judge Lynch which was addressed to her. If the Minister and the Attorney General are not accountable for what happened in this case, is there anything for which they are accountable? Does the doctrine of democratic accountability not begin to break down?
The Minister offers a distinction between accountability and culpability which the Tánaiste dismissed two years ago on 16 November, 1994. He stated: "If this House were to accept that a Minister would never be accountable to the Dáil without direct culpability on his or her part, the principle of accountability would wither away. Without accountability the value of a parliamentary democracy would be fatally undermined". The quote is in the Official Report, Vol. 447, Col. 346. Does this still stand? I look forward to hearing from the Tánaiste.
The inquiry set up is a political red herring designed to focus attention on failures within the Civil Service. What are the terms of reference and do they exclude attaching blame to the Minister? It is obvious the Minister is more focused on public relations and does not have a hands-on approach to her Department. An inquiry is not necessary to show that.
Fianna Fáil in Government always worked within the 1924 Act. It was hard at times. It was hard for Fianna Fáil Ministers to take the political hassle but they answered to the Act. If certain civil servants fail to perform in a particular area their responsibilities can be re-allocated. That happened many times under Fianna Fáil Ministers. Ministers are entitled to demand the best service the Civil Service can provide but if civil servants fail they should not be scapegoated. They should not be scapegoated on their failures when Ministers do not make best use of the service provided.
I have great respect for civil servants in the Department of Justice and for their work in all types of difficulty. However, I take grave exception to the statement issued by the Association of Higher Civil Servants in the Department. It was most political.
Comment on this
This country has a tradition of having a politically neutral public service regardless of who is in Government. It is unprecedented that a Civil Service organisation would issue effusive public statements in support of a Minister who is likely to be subject to a no confidence motion in the Dáil. The Government must not corrupt the neutral ethos that has hitherto been the prevailing characteristic of one of the key institutions of the State.
Comment on this
The head of the Civil Service, the Secretary of the Department of the Taoiseach, should take measures to make it clear to those concerned that the statement was not in order and to protect its independence, an independence that has been maintained by all political parties in all circumstances.
Comment on this
The Government is responsible for staffing levels. It allowed public service numbers to rise by more than 1,000 persons since December 1994 and imposed a temporary embargo that has since been lifted. If the courts division is understaffed it is the Government's fault for not directing both existing and additional resources to where they are most needed.
The Government's argument appears to be that neither civil servants nor the Minister is to blame but something abstract such as lack of resources to do the job properly. This makes a nonsense of democratic accountability and the Taoiseach knows it. He said a great deal about democratic accountability during his many years in the House. The Taoiseach is answerable in this House for the Attorney General and has leapt to the defence of the Minister for Justice in terms which cast serious doubts on his political judgment. On 15 November 1994, the Taoiseach asserted that Ministers were legally responsible for decisions of Departments under the Ministers and Secretaries Act and criticised the then Government for alleged "evasion of responsibility, by shoving the matter into the hands of officials". He declared this "is not acceptable" in the Official Report, Volume 447, Column 39. What was not acceptable then is apparently acceptable now. The Taoiseach in Government has changed his mind about everything he said in Opposition or when he held any other office in the State.
It is obvious this Government came into office with a false prospectus. Its members said one thing but have now changed their minds. Most of the promised reforms designed to open up Government and improve openness, transparency and accountability have been reneged on, put on the long finger or are proving ineffective. The Office of the Attorney General continues to give rise to the same controversy as previously, even though the Taoiseach has issued two reports and claimed many times there are no problems there. We know there are many problems in that office.
One of Ireland's senior businessmen privately observed recently that most of the Ministers in this Government, especially Fine Gael Ministers, are inexperienced. That is why so many of those Ministers, such as Deputies Owen, Lowry and Yates, have been found wanting in recent times.
Comment on this
A senior businessman makes a private observation. The Deputy is short of sources when he uses that one.
Comment on this
The Minister for Health, Deputy Noonan, has some experience. The Minister for Enterprise and Employment, Deputy Bruton, has a reputation for being incapable of making decisions. The Taoiseach is notorious for being something of a loose cannon, as we witnessed at the end of his speech. I recently heard that the Revenue Commissioners were put on alert to work out a tax break to give taxpayers a Christmas present. Everybody in the Department was running around until somebody held back the Taoiseach and said the idea was mad.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach has a long tradition of doing that. He reads something in a foreign magazine and goes charging off in that direction.
Comment on this
Former Ministers such as Deputies Alan Dukes, Jim Mitchell, Peter Barry and Austin Deasy are acknowledged as talented Deputies. Deputies Alan Shatter and Frances Fitzgerald languish on the backbenches because they are not clones of the Taoiseach and might present a challenge to him. All the experienced Deputies are on the back benches while the inexperienced are on the Front Bench.
Comment on this
The latest debacle is the responsibility of an accident-prone Minister who is also deputy leader of Fine Gael. For a whole year and a half she was unable to impose justice and law and order in a major Government Department——
Comment on this
Despite the Brinks-Allied robbery, the spate of murders, especially of women, the escalating drugs problem and the sense of State impotence and all the difficulties in the grossest street disorder, it was only after sustained pressure from this side of the House and from the public, especially local communities and the media, and following the murder of Veronica Guerin, that the Government was finally forced to change tack and to accept insistent Fianna Fáil demands for, among other things, a bail referendum, reinstatement of the prison building programme — which the Minister allowed to be scrapped when she missed a meeting — and legislation to seize the assets of suspected drug dealers. At last some heat has been brought to bear on drug dealers, not least by fed up communities, but it should have been done much earlier. There is still no great confidence that the Government and its law enforcement agencies are doing much to deal with the problem effectively.
The partners in Government, especially the Tánaiste, also bear some of the blame. One of the curses of this Administration has been the determination of the Tánaiste, with his legal background, and his office, to act as surrogate Minister for Justice, second-guessing all the Minister's proposals. In the last Government the Tánaiste was more exercised about who would get promotion to the High Court than about other serious issues. In those crucial days of November two years ago the old Bar network counted more with the Tánaiste, who twice preferred to listen to an Attorney General, of 48 hours standing and then three weeks, standing than to colleagues with whom he had served two years in Government. His friends at the Bar must have advised the Tánaiste that the extent of the crime problem was being exaggerated. He vetoed a referendum Bill proposed by the Minister for Justice, Deputy Owen. When the Minister for Justice was away, the Minister for Finance, Deputy Ruairi Quinn, cancelled the plans for extra prison spaces at Castlerea——
Comment on this
I have actually opened the first phase of it.
Comment on this
——and a new women's prison. It is appropriate that we will be voting no confidence in the Government as a whole. It is well deserved. I know of no one who is impressed with this Government's handling of the economy, particularly public expenditure and taxation. There are continuing difficulties in the peace process. Issues such as Telecom Éireann and BSE have been broadly mishandled.
The Government inherited much progress on all fronts. I am glad the Taoiseach today put on the record exactly how he inherited the economy and several other issues. He fails to put on the record anything substantial that he achieved in the last two years. There is not a solitary item he mentioned today that he can stand over and say is his.
Comment on this
Our Government was more focused. It is not my purpose to shift attention from the Minister for Justice. I will not refer to all the other issues. I want to keep this debate on the Minister for Justice, the Attorney General and the Taoiseach.
A new Fianna Fáil-led Government is essential for this country if all the progress of the last ten years is to be sustained. The sooner we have an election the better if that is what the Taoiseach is leading up to. Everybody knows we are looking at a caretaker Administration with at best only a few months to run. We have had the hepatitis C and BSE issues and this debacle. While I would not wish to deny that some good work has been done by some Ministers and some Ministers of State, the episode has highlighted the incompetence at the heart of the Government and it is surely time for the Taoiseach and the Government to test the people as we head into the fifth year of this Dáil. I have a suggestion for the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
Let us hear the Member in possession, please, without interruption from either side.
Comment on this
It is a suggestion for a new logo for the Government. We believe it should adopt the new tourism logo. It can show three figures in tight embrace, representing the dance of the dependants, the three parties in the Government all clutching each other for support. Inside the embrace, instead of a little shamrock, why does it not have a little unopened envelope? The logo would sum up the Government beautifully — three bodies holding each other up and trying to conceal the disasters behind the embrace of tatty teamwork. The Government claims the difference is that the parties trust each other. The Taoiseach's central theme is that this is a great Government. He continues to say it.
Comment on this
We were kind to the Minister today, he has had too many other days. I want to direct my remarks to the Taoiseach. The Government claims that the difference is that the parties trust each other and that this trust is keeping them all together. It is wonderful but it is also arrogant. What about public trust? Does it not matter to the Taoiseach? He talks continually here as he brushes this and that issue aside and he has no interest in the people outside. He arrogantly defends everything that is indefensible. He rarely apologises and glosses over everything as if he does not care about the public. That is his tactic. As an opinion poll showed in December 1994, the previous Government made up of Fianna Fáil and Labour had created the current economic boom, negotiated the EU funding, had responsibility for the three month peace process and enjoyed a high degree of public trust and support when it was abandoned. The Taoiseach's argument does not hold up.
Comment on this
We finally managed to achieve more than Private Members' time plus two hours for this debate, which gives us an opportunity to debate the central issues. The central issues will continue to be debated if the Taoiseach wins the vote. The habeas corpus cases are before the High Court. From what is a joke of an inquiry we will see what happens in the Department and what other information the Minister has.
Comment on this
The Deputy should reflect on the reference he is making to a joke of an inquiry where he is referring to individuals of high repute who——
Comment on this
The inquiry that is taking place is for the purpose of deciding how a Minister should have had a proper system in her Department. It is not an inquiry that is central to the following issues: how a Minister went to the Cabinet and asked for decisions about a judge, got those decisions, went back to her Department and refused to implement those decisions; how an Attorney General wrote a letter on 2 October and the Minister did not deal with it. It is about how the Attorney General wrote another letter on 1 November and nobody dealt with it. It is about how the judge concerned wrote a letter on October 10 and nobody dealt with it. The Minister could have made one mistake, but this House does not need to know what civil servant did what. We need to know how the Minister was so incompetent on every issue before her. She has been incompetent and culpable on every issue she has laid her hands on for the last two years and she should resign.
Comment on this
"This is a political crisis, not an administrative one. Every time there is a political crisis in this House, this Government seeks to blame administrators and turn it into an administrative crisis. This is a political crisis touching on the integrity and veracity of Ministers."
These are not my words but those of the Taoiseach speaking here on 30 November 1994 Vol 447 Column 373 of the Official Report. This evening I propose to judge this Government by no higher a standard than that set by the Government itself for its own term of office.
It says in the programme for Government that the Government belongs to the people and the relationship between the Government and the people it serves has been damaged by a lack of openness. It says that relationship must be renewed so that the people have total confidence in government and in a political system which is fully inclusive. On 17 November 1994, Taoiseach John Bruton, then in Opposition said:
The lesson is that the truth should not come out in instalments. The truth, the whole truth should be given on the first day. Let the cards fall as they will after that. That is the good lesson for all of us who aspire to high office.
Why did the Taoiseach not take an opportunity today to answer some of the questions I posed over the last few days? Did the Registrar of the Special Criminal Court contact the Department of Justice or any other Department as regards Judge Dominic Lynch's position? Did a leading defence lawyer contact the Department of Justice and other Government agencies in early October, explaining what had happened in the Special Criminal Court? Did that defence lawyer telephone last Tuesday and threaten to go public if the matter was not sorted out? Why will the Taoiseach not publish the letter sent by Judge Lynch to the Minister or the letter sent by the Attorney General to the Minister? I believe the publication of those letters would throw light on this debate.
When the Taoiseach took office on 15 December, he said that the Government must go about its work without excess or extravagance, as transparently as if it were working behind a pane of glass. Behind that pane of glass there is now a stone wall which has been built and fortified by the Tánaiste, Deputy Spring, the Minister for Social Welfare, Deputy De Rossa and the Taoiseach, who pledged in the programme for Government to reform our institutions at national and local level so they would provide, service, accountability, transparency and freedom of information.
This debate is not about the personal integrity or the personal qualities of the Minister for Justice, Deputy Owen, who is a woman of the highest integrity. She is affable and hard-working and none of those qualities is in question. It is unacceptable to level criticism against her because of her gender. This debate is about confidence in the Minister for Justice, as the person who holds the most sensitive position in the Government. The primary duty of Government is to protect its citizens. If people cannot have confidence in the Minister in charge of that key ministry of Government, they cannot believe the Government is protecting them.
The Taoiseach referred to political point scoring. Would we have a bail referendum on 28 November if the journalist Veronica Guerin had not been murdered? Would we have a tribunal of inquiry into the Blood Transfusion Service Board if Brigid McCole had not died? Would we have an independent food inspectorate if Russia had not banned our beef? Would this Government have promised an independent prison services board if it had not been for the present fiasco? All these crises have led to Government action and without them we would not have had action.
The Taoiseach has sought to distract the public. He has spoken about point scoring, opportunism and playing party politics. He said today we were prejudiced and into the blame game. These are all colourful terms. We could make up a dictionary, of which the Taoiseach would be a great author, on how to make little of serious political debate. The accusations are wearing thin. There is no excuse for what happened in this instance. It is incompetent, insensitive and wrong. It is not good enough for the Taoiseach to constantly keep running for cover from his responsibilities.
Listening to the Taoiseach's speech I found it hard to believe he was the same person with whom I worked so closely in Opposition. The Taoiseach spoke about not understanding the concerns of the poor or the low-paid. As someone who grew up on a 39 acre farm in Dublin, I know all about poverty and low pay. I will not take lectures from the Taoiseach about not understanding those on a low income. The Taoiseach should be careful in the accusations he makes about others. I want to create the kind of opportunities I had for society. I want an enterprising and fair society and a system of Government where Ministers take responsibility for their actions. It is hard to believe that the former champion of Dáil reform is running for cover. I remind the Taoiseach of the former Premier of Denmark, Poul Schluter, who resigned in January 1993 because he stood by his Minister for Justice.
What are the legal implications of what happened? There is no more fundamental a court in this country than the Special Criminal Court. There is no more fundamental an error than the wrong composition of that court. The implications are serious and the prisoners in question are charged with serious offences, some in relation to the making or possession of explosives, others in relation to the investigation into the murder of Garda Jerry McCabe. These are not ordinary matters. The possibility that any of these prisoners could walk free because of Government incompetence is sufficient to demand ministerial accountability and responsibility. The Government cannot give us an assurance that none of them will walk free because it is a matter for the courts and not the Government. Deputy Eric Byrne gave conditional support to the Minister for Justice today — conditional on nobody being let free. I resent the fact that anyone would seek to put political pressure on the Judiciary by telling them if they make a certain decision the Government will collapse.
One of the definitive authorities in this area is Mr. Justice O'Higgins, who in a hearing in the case of the State, McDonagh v. Frawley in the Supreme Court in 1978, ruled:
In cases where it has not been shown to the satisfaction of the court that the detention is "in accordance with the law" in the sense indicated, the release of the detained person must be ordered and notwithstanding judicial dicta to the contrary, the order of release may not be coupled with an order of re-arrest. The protection of personal liberty which Article 40.4. is intended to ensure, would be hollow and ineffectual, if the order of release was not unqualified and unconditional.
That is a clear judgment. For this and other reasons, what has happened is extremely serious and cannot be dismissed as a clerical or administrative error.
Accountablility is not a buzz word. It goes further than transparency or openness. It strikes at the heart of our parliamentary democracy and is its cornerstone. The Government, which is the executive arm of the State, is accountable through the Dáil. The Government must be accountable through its elected representatives. It is the Opposition's duty in a democracy to be vigilant in ensuring a Government is accountable and the Opposition must be fair and even-handed. It must not just seek accountability when one set of parties is in Government. It is not only a matter for the Opposition to ensure accountability. It is also a matter for the partners in Government who have a duty to ensure that if things are wrong, they are put right. This is an absolute, not just something which can be chosen. What happened last night is similar to what emerged in the Duggan case. At 10.22 a.m. on 16 November 1994 the Labour Party was prepared to go back into office with Fianna Fáil. Later that day it told us all had changed because the Tánaiste had become aware of the Duggan case. What annoyed the Tánaiste about the Duggan case is that it had not been brought to the attention of the Dáil a few days earlier. He said that fundamentally changed everything.
If the Tánaiste and the Labour Party are to be even-handed and consistent they would have to admit, in fairness, that what happened yesterday evening is the same.