Confidence in Government: Motion (Resumed).
Contributions 155–322 of 322. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I take this opportunity to congratulate my colleague, Deputy Enda Kenny, who was 21 years in the Dáil this month. I look forward to returning with him after the next election along with Deputy Higgins.
In the past few hours I have noted a subtle change in the speeches of Fianna Fáil and Progressive Democrats. This change has taken place because the people, particularly women, are reacting to the attack on the Minister. Any woman who wants to survive in this House has to be three times as good as a man.
Comment on this
Deputy Owen is one of the best Ministers for Justice ever, and women are reacting to the attacks by the Progressive Democrats and Fianna Fáil on her.
Over the weekend while this was unravelling one could see the pep in the step of the Fianna Fáil Deputies. They could see the mercs and the perks; they thought they were back in power again. When Commissioner Padraig Flynn was in Mayo he used to talk about "the car with the star". Members of Fianna Fáil will have to wait a long time for the cars with the stars. We have a star in this Government, the Minister for Justice, Deputy Owen, and she will be with us for a long time to come. She has done nothing wrong and everybody in the country knows that. Fianna Fáil are jumping on the bandwagon in the belief that they will be back in Government in a few weeks time. I have news for them. The people of this country are satisfied with the performance of this Government. They have had enough of Fianna Fáil. I remember when a car with a star was overturned in Tralee. The Tánaiste, who is from Tralee will not want to remind the House of that, but I will say it for him. I remember when those cars contained machine guns down in Kerry.
Nothing like that happened when Deputy Owen became Minister for Justice. When she came into office she was landed with problem after problem, problems she inherited from Fianna Fáil. Coming from the film "Michael Collins" last Sunday night a Fianna Fáil supporter told me that with Fianna Fáil backers with plenty of money they would make a Fianna Fáil version of it, but Deputy Owen is there for the long haul and no attack by Fianna Fáil will damage her because she is a woman of quality, a woman of compassion and, most important, a woman of ability. She has proved that.
The first item she identified on coming into Government was the problem with the bail laws. I am glad that, in spite of their attacks on the Minister, Fianna Fáil and the Progressive Democrats will be supporting the Minister in the next month to get the referendum passed. They recognise the Minister's quality and that she was right when she identified these problems.
Comment on this
I am disappointed because I had much more to say about this Minister. I am pleased to support her and the Government because we are a Government for the long road.
Comment on this
I hope Members, male or female, did not take exception to Deputy Ring's sexist remarks. When I see a Minister it does not matter to me whether that person is a man or a woman. If he or she is doing a good job I will not complain. We are having this debate not because the Minister is a woman but because she is incompetent and has failed to do her duty.
It is ironic that two years ago the Minister sat on this side of the House shouting across at the then Taoiseach and Government about a whole series of issues, particularly the fact that there was a seven month delay in dealing with a matter in the Attorney General's office. Deputy Owen could not believe that a file could be left unattended for seven months in the Attorney General's office. According to Deputy Owen, and her colleagues in Fine Gael and Democratic Left, it was a conspiracy, a cover-up, a sinister plot by the Attorney General, by the Government, by the Taoiseach, by the Church, by everybody. At that time Deputy Owen expected someone to be held politically responsible for the fact that a file was left lying in an office for seven months. She expected the Attorney General to pay for that mistake but she also expected somebody to pay politically. Ultimately a Taoiseach paid the price, even though he had less knowledge about that file than had the Attorney General.
Deputy Owen, who was present at a Cabinet meeting which agreed to delist Judge Lynch — and she was personally charged with responsibility for so doing — is pleading ignorance of the fact that the judge and the courts were not informed. A decision which she knew about, which she had responsibility to discharge, sat in her Department for three months and she did nothing about it.
I do not expect the Minister for Justice to know every judge sitting in all the courts, but I do expect her to know a little bit more about the judges sitting in the most sensitive court in this land. The Minister's explanation for not discharging her duty is that she did not see the letter from the Attorney General, that she did not see the letter or letters from the judge. I am told that the Protocol in this House is that, in the absence of direct evidence to the contrary, one must accept that the Minister is telling the truth when she makes statements in the House. I accept that Protocol, but there are thousands of people outside this House who are under no such constraint and I know what they believe and, if the Deputies opposite are listening to what is being said, they know what people believe.
If we accept what the Minister said, it means that a situation exists within the Department of Justice and within the Minister's own private office whereby she is not allowed to read her own mail, mail which is marked for her attention, mail which is marked personal. Does the Minister honestly expect anyone outside this House to believe that a letter from the Attorney General's office or from a judge is not shown to the Minister when it arrives in her private office? Could anyone outside this House believe that a judge in the most sensitive court in this land could write a letter to the Minister and that the Minister would not see it? Can any person imagine the Attorney General and a judge writing to the Minister and someone in the Minister's office deciding that these letters are not important enough to bring to the Minister's attention? It beggars belief. Whose correspondence does the Minister read? Obviously not that of a senior judge or the Attorney General. In this scenario it is possible to believe the Minister does not read correspondence from the Garda Commissioner, the Chief Justice, the Director of Public Prosecutions and the Chief State Solicitor, and that letters and files in her office are collecting dust because she does not read them.
It is plausible that there is a letter from the Taoiseach which has lain in her office for some time and which outlines his regret that because of the Allied-Brink's débâcle, the delay in providing extra prison spaces, the upset caused to Deputy Spring and Deputy De Rossa when the Minister announced a bail referendum prematurely, the shredding of the Duncan extradition document and other matters, he was reluctantly requesting her resignation. It is possible that such a letter, marked "Personal", is lying in the Minister's office and she has not seen it. It is possible because apparently the members of the Government have so much trust in each other that they do not even talk to each other.
That might sound implausible or even cynical but it is no more implausible than some of the comments from the Government in the last few days. Is it more implausible than the fact that the Minister for Justice saw none of the letters to which we have referred or that the Minister, having been alerted to the Attorney General's letter on 5 November, went home and did nothing about it until the following day or that the Minister went to the cinema when the crisis was developing and returned to the film when the scale of the problem was known or that the Minister went from the cinema to a party in Dublin Castle while 16 prisoners were released and rearrested? Is it more implausible than the fact that the Minister told the House last Thursday that she would present full information even though she decided prior to speaking that she would not mention a second letter from Judge Lynch? At a minimum, the Minister should have told the House she had the letter but was not sure of its date. She knew she had the letter before she came to the House and when she was questioned about this matter, but she withheld that information for the spurious reason that it might confuse us or somebody who was involved in the inquiry.
The Minister told the Dáil two years ago that the truth should not be drip fed but that is precisely what she has done in recent days. There were many words and hypocrisy from the Minister two years ago and we are getting the same now. Yesterday the Taoiseach defended the role of the Attorney General in this affair. It was clear he intended to exonerate Mr. Gleeson from blame. It is difficult to reconcile the Government's approach with the approach taken by the same Deputies to the former Attorney General, Mr. Whelehan. Deputy O'Donoghue put it aptly last night when he said: "Harry Whelehan did not know and did nothing, Dermot Gleeson did know and did nothing. Who is more culpable?"
The Taoiseach spoke about the Government's success and claimed credit for everything. However, there was not a word in his speech about the Northern Ireland peace process. We know what the Taoiseach thinks of the process from the remarks he made in Cork. It is obvious he still does not think much of it. He spoke about the function of the Attorney General and likened it to advising a client. He stated: "Clients, once advised, are normally responsible for action to be taken on foot of advice given by a professional adviser". Later he said that clients are expected to take responsibility for implementing advice received. It is clear from the Taoiseach's remarks that if the Attorney General is not responsible the responsibility lies with his client, the Minister for Justice.
Another interesting part of the Taoiseach's speech dealt with the inquiry that has been established. I have not seen its terms of reference but I understand from the Taoiseach's remarks during Question Time that the members of the inquiry will be able to seek explanations from anybody inside or outside the public service who can throw light on anything in the file or the issues surrounding it. Does that mean the inquiry can ask the Minister the serious and pertinent questions it must ask? It is necessary to ask what procedures the Minister has in place to ensure letters of an urgent nature are brought to her attention. She also must be asked what procedures were put in place to ensure that letters marked "Personal" are brought to her attention immediately.
These questions are vital to the inquiry and must be answered. If the Minister has no such procedures she cannot hold a civil servant responsible for this debacle, as Government speakers continually tried to do today. The Minister must shoulder responsibility for what happened because it is her duty to give leadership and direction to her Department. She has singularly failed to do that.
The Taoiseach outlined Deputy Owen's achievements last night. He omitted the most important one. After more than a decade, this Government has devised a response to GUBU. It is called NORA. When this Government is in trouble it shouts NORA, not our responsibility anyway.
Comment on this
From its first days this Government has shown signs of being out of touch with the needs of the nation. It was abundantly clear that a coalition of three parties which represented the extremes in Irish political life was bound to result in a major lack of focus and direction in policy formulation. It was also clear that the only unifying force was the desire to obtain power and retain it at all costs. However, the most cynical observer could not have anticipated how wrong the rainbow coalition could have gone in so short a time.
The anticipated lack of clarity and direction in policy has become a reality in practically all arms of Government. Aside from the scandals and conflicts which have dogged this Administration, there is a list of issues which have either been put on the long finger or shelved. What happened to the urgent need to deal with Cabinet confidentiality? Does anybody hear any more talk about the third banking force? What is the Government's policy on consolidation of our vital agriculture based industries? How are the serious problems of social deprivation and inequality to be tackled? How can we make serious inroads in the battle against crime and particularly against the alarming development of a drugs culture?
At this stage it is a waste of time to expect an indication of decisive action from the Government on these issues. Its track record is there for everybody to see and it is one of which one cannot be proud. The Government's brief history has been littered with scandals and mistakes which are depressing to recall. In the midst of this shambles even the most cynical person would expect that the core issues affecting Irish society would be protected from the rot which set in so early in many aspects of Government.
We confidently expected our system of justice would be in safe hands irrespective of the other disasters that regularly occur. Unfortunately we had ominous early indications that the Minister for Justice, Deputy Owen, was finding it impossible to come to terms with her brief. The lack of legislative proposals from the Minister was hidden to some degree by the excellent work of Opposition spokespersons Deputy O'Donoghue and Deputy O'Donnell. On many occasions the Minister refused to meet these Deputies halfway in a constructive manner. Instead, she adopted a negative approach and mindlessly opposed many excellent proposals from those Deputies, particularly in the criminal law area. When the Minister eventually woke up to the fact that crime was getting out of control, in the absence of legislation she lamely adopted Fianna Fáil Bills as a last resort.
The Minister's record in the management of operational issues has been equally disastrous. For example, her lack of information on the Brinks Allied raid and the Urlingford drugs fiasco was alarming to say the least. This did not deter her from availing of photo opportunities whenever possible. Her abject failure to deal decisively with the divisions in the Garda representative bodies has also been damaging. The only two areas where the Minister made an attempt to influence the course of events were in relation to the bail laws and the crisis in prison accommodation. Were it not so important her management of the bail laws would be laughable.
Early last year she told the nation on the "Farrell" television programme she would be organising the necessary referendum in the near future. Her public statement, obviously, was made without prior consultation with her Cabinet colleagues. Consequently, colleagues such as the Minister for Social Welfare, Deputy De Rossa, and the Tánaiste, Deputy Spring, who at that stage were attempting to cling to some remnants of their liberal agenda, were quick to put her firmly in her place. In the midst of all this bungling many law abiding citizens had to pay the price for the shambles in Government since they became victims of crime carried out by hardened criminals released on bail. If this was not enough the Minister was equally unsuccessful in tackling one of the main reasons which has led to the liberal interpretation of our bail laws by the courts, the serious shortage of prison spaces throughout the country. At a time when the Minister for Finance is only too happy to tell all and sundry about the surplus of cash in the national coffers, the Minister has failed in her attempt to obtain meaningful support for her extremely modest development programme. Thus, the events of last week come against a background of total ineffectiveness on the part of the Minister combined with a widespread failure on the part of the Government to carry out its duties to the nation.
The examples of standards and failures on the part of this Government are too numerous to mention. We do not have to go back far to recall the bi-location of the Minister for Agriculture, Food and Forestry, Deputy Yates, the hepatitis C scandal, the totally insensitive handling of illegal immigrants and ministerial resignations. The net effect of these events has been to undermine the very structures which the Government is contracted to protect and the general weakening in the quality of political life and debate in this House. When any Government puts aside the key principle of accountability there is only one path open, a path downwards. Even at the 23rd hour the Taoiseach must act decisively if he is to retain even the smallest amount of credibility and respect.
The facts relating to the Special Criminal Court debacle are clear. The Government made a decision in early August to transfer Judge Lynch, at his request, from the court and the Minister failed to take the necessary steps to ensure this decision was implemented immediately. I am tired of observing the drip feed of information on this matter when a four year old child could readily assess the situation. Clearly, the Minister did not take the trouble to pursue the decision as is her solemn duty. One wonders whether she has applied the same level of efficiency to implement the other Cabinet decisions over the past two years.
It is clear the Attorney General was aware of the non-implementation of the decision at an early stage. Clearly, he did not rate the matter as being sufficiently important to either telephone or fax the Minister or raise the matter at one of their, presumably, regular meetings.
Comment on this
These acts of omission are disgraceful and amount to a total dereliction of duty on the part of the Minister and the Attorney General. In the circumstances one would expect no less than an immediate, full and unreserved apology on the part of both individuals followed by an honourable resignation. If such apologies had been forthcoming at an early stage in the fiasco there might be some hope that every effort would be made to avoid major blunders in the future.
Comment on this
Instead, over the past two days we have been treated to a combination of brazen denials.
Comment on this
With your permission, Sir, I wish to share my time with my colleague, Minister of State, Deputy Eithne Fitzgerald.
Comment on this
I have no doubt that the House is right to reaffirm its confidence in the Government, the members of which, individually and collectively, have been working hard for the past two years as a united and cohesive team, dedicated to serving the public interest.
The Minister for Justice, Deputy Owen, and the Attorney General, Mr. Dermot Gleeson, have been two dedicated and outstanding Cabinet colleagues who have my full and unqualified support and that of all members of the Government.
It is not necessary on an occasion such as this for me to outline the many achievements of my colleagues and the progress made in my Department in the past two years. Those achievements are facts which stand on their own merits. The Opposition cannot credibly dispute those achievements. Instead, it seeks to argue that the House should withdraw its confidence in the Government as a result of the handling of the delisting of Judge Lynch. This is an entirely fatuous and opportunistic argument for a number of reasons.
It is said the Minister for Justice should resign because of errors made within her Department of which she did not have knowledge. Frankly, this is a ludicrous argument. Is the fate of every Minister in every Government of every political persuasion to be held hostage to termination at random, because of some action or inaction of which the Minister had no knowledge? That would be a most unjust and unwise policy and I totally reject it.
The Minister has accepted that errors did occur. She has accepted the gravity of the mistakes made. She has accepted political responsibility for what happened in her Department. She cannot reasonably be asked to resign over something about which she had no knowledge whatever. A distinction must be drawn between constitutional, legal and political responsibility for actions of officials, on the one hand, and personal or moral responsibility on the other. The Minister has constitutional, legal and political responsibility for what happens in her Department but she could only credibly be asked to resign if she had a personal involvement in the action taken — in other words, if she had a personal or moral responsibility or, to use a term referred to yesterday, if she had culpability. This was obviously not the case.
It is also said the Minister should resign for not having had sufficient control over the actions within her Department. I do not accept that suggestion. A Minister is entitled to assume, unless there is reason to believe the contrary, that instructions given will be carried out, that Government decisions made will be implemented and that any actions consequential on ministerial directions will be taken. If it were shown that a Minister approved some departure from this practice the position would be different. That is not the case in the Minister's situation.
It is also said the Minister should resign because she did not inform the House of the existence of the second letter from Judge Lynch when she addressed the House last week. Clearly, the steam has been taken out of this argument by the publication of the actual text of the letter itself yesterday. The letter is, to say the least, innocuous. Its contents do not exactly cry out for attention. It is easy to envisage how the Minister could have concluded, in the brief time available to her, that her state of knowledge as to the letter did not warrant her departing from her speech in order to mention it specially. It was undated by the sender, it was not date stamped. She ordered that the letter form part of the inquiry.
The suggestion is made that the Minister is in some way being punished for this incident or, as it is put, denuded of her powers. This suggestion is totally misconceived. The Government decided, on the Minister's proposal, to establish new structures to improve the management of the courts and prisons. I believe those structures are long overdue and it is a credit to the Minister, Deputy Owen, that she is the one to introduce them. This is not a question of removing powers from the Minister for Justice. It is a question of separating the policy role, which remains with the Minister, from the role of administration, which is to be devolved to the new authorities. It is worth noting that prior to recent events, the Government had already agreed to the setting up of a courts service and work was already progressing on the setting up of a prisons agency.
I particularly welcome the decision to set up an authority to manage the prison service. This was a recommendation of the Committee on the Penal System chaired by Dr. T. K. Whitaker in 1985. When, in his previous capacity as a Member of the other House, my colleague Deputy Costello moved a Bill in the other House to implement the Whitaker Report during the lifetime of the 1989-92 Government, the parties opposite would not facilitate leave to allow the Bill even to be published. The subject of prison reform has at times been neglected over the years and I pay tribute to Deputy Costello for his work in keeping it on the agenda. I look forward to the early enactment of the new legislation. I hope we can also look forward to consideration of inclusion of structures for parole and for long sentence review in this legislation.
The Opposition has also chosen to raise the role of the Attorney General in this affair and, by implication, the Taoiseach as the member of Government politically answerable for the Attorney General's office. The criticisms of the Attorney have no foundation whatsoever. Deputy O'Donoghue makes great play of what he calls the Attorney's constitutional role as guardian of the public interest and considers that this role should have required the Attorney to take action in the matter. This argument is presented with almost breathtaking effrontery by the Deputy and contains more misconceptions than I have time to deal with in this contribution.
The Attorney's primary constitutional role is as legal adviser to the Government. His public interest role exists on the legal, not the constitutional, level and is by no means a general roving licence to do good in any and all matters, public and private. It is not in particular a licence to do the work of Ministers. The Attorney did more than enough in writing letters which he was not obliged to write, which he had every right to assume would be acted upon, and which in any case he had no obligation to follow up.
The speeches from Members opposite commit a serious logical and legal error in confusing the roles of legal adviser — a role which the present occupant of the office of Attorney General occupies with tremendous skill, helpfulness, and ability — and the role of Minister, with the responsibility to account for decisions taken or not taken.
There has also been reference to officials. I make no comment on this aspect because I do not wish to prejudge the results of the inquiry. However, I do not think we should automatically seek to hang officials for any and every error made by them. Despite the fact that the mistake made in not implementing the Government decision was extremely serious, we should be open to hearing explanations if and when they are forthcoming. None of us is more than human and not every offence is, or should be, either a sacking offence or unforgivable.
All the facts have yet to emerge and clearly there are many lessons for the future. One obvious lesson is that Government decisions affecting the legal position of third parties should not take effect on the day they are made, unless there is a guarantee of immediate communication of such decisions.
I await the inquiry with great interest. However, in the meantime, I have no hesitation in urging the House to reaffirm its confidence in this Government.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to speak in this debate and affirm my confidence in the Taoiseach, the Minister for Justice and the Attorney General.
That the Government decision of 1 August was not communicated to Mr. Justice Lynch with due speed, and the consequences of that, is a very serious matter. None of us denies this. Deficient systems and procedures must be rectified without any delay to ensure the situation is never repeated. To maintain public trust in our democracy, our systems of public administration must always be capable of administering Government decisions with due speed and efficiency. Where reforms are necessary to achieve this, the issues must be tackled head on and necessary improvements made. That is both the lesson of recent events and what people rightly expect.
There is a need to reform the public service. I served as a civil servant 25 years ago. In many ways the systems in place today have evolved little in that time. I have great respect for the dedicated work of individual civil servants and the ethos of public service they bring to their job. There is a need to reform systems within the public service and to devise new management tools to prioritise work and ensure proper procedures are in place. I believe the major reform task until the turn of the century will be that of ensuring the Public Service delivers quality service to this House, the Government and the public it serves.
The Minister for Justice and I were both elected to Dublin County Council on the same day in June 1979. I have known Deputy Owen since that time as a woman of great ability, integrity, ideas, imagination, hard work and commitment. We have been on opposite sides of the table on various occasions. I have had my differences with her at council level but have always found her direct, straightforward, keen to get the job done and above all, a woman of great integrity. Recent events have demonstrated these qualities.
It was a major mistake to fail to implement a Government decision in the Department of Justice. However, as soon as the Minister was belatedly told of the nature of the mistake, she immediately acted to rectify, as far as possible, what had happened. She released those who had been unlawfully detained and established an independent inquiry with no holds barred. This will be conducted by two eminent people, Mr. Seán Cromien, who has a profound knowledge of the public service and Dr. Ed Molloy, a respected consultant. They will examine the files, talk to those involved and discover what went wrong and what can be put right. There is a strong commitment to put any systems deficiency right. That report will be before the House next week and will be publicly debated. The Minister will answer questions and be accountable to the House.
Comment on this
There was no attempt made in recent days to fudge, hide, mislead or pretend that nothing serious had happened. We acknowledge on this side of the House that the matter is extremely serious. As the Taoiseach indicated yesterday, there will be an accelerated programme of renewal and reform in the administration of justice. I welcome the establishment of a unified, independent and permanent courts service and an independent board, separate from the Department, to run the prisons and probation service on a daily basis. These reforms are overdue and I am delighted to see them being implemented.
Comment on this
In addition to my respect for the current holder of the post of Minister for Justice, I have a great deal of respect and admiration for the previous holder, Deputy Geoghegan-Quinn, who was an excellent Minister for Justice. I welcomed her work as regards violence against women and the establishment of a special Garda unit.
The present Minister for Justice inherited the administrative systems and procedures in the Department of Justice from her predecessors, Deputy Geoghegan-Quinn and Deputy Burke. The number of prison places and certain systems in the Department were there as the Minister found them. I attach no blame to her predecessor, who was a good Minister for Justice.
Comment on this
It is important that when defects are found in a system they are acted on and rectified without delay. I welcome the introduction of these reforms which I hope will bring an end to the culture of secrecy which has surrounded the Department of Justice for too long.
The Government is doing the job it was mandated to do in December 1994 on the basis of an agreed programme and in a spirit of co-operation and trust, with due respect for each party's genuine concerns, traditions and sensitivities. We need look no further than its economic record to have confidence in the Government. We have the fastest growing economy in Europe. When I attend meetings in Europe my colleagues ask me how we managed to achieve record growth in the economy and reduce the number of unemployed. Over the past two years 93,000 new jobs have been created and these have been translated into a reduction in unemployment and the availability of more jobs for school leavers, women who wish to return to the workforce and returned emigrants. The record low level of inflation has helped to maintain fixed incomes and the incomes of pensioners, while low interest rates, which are of particular benefit to people with mortgages, have encouraged investment by businesses. Investors and consumers have confidence in the economy and prudent management of the public finances by the Government has ensured that we are well within the Maastricht criteria. The Government's performance in regard to the economy has been excellent.
Comment on this
The Government has reduced not only the overall level of unemployment but also the number of long-term unemployed. The 1995 Labour Force Survey shows that the number of long-term unemployed fell by 25,000 and that there was a greater decrease in the number of long-term unemployed than in the number of short-term unemployed. The focus on long-term unemployment, an issue dear to Deputy O'Rourke's heart, is beginning to pay off. However, more needs to be done in this area and we must not forget the need for special policies. The rising tide does not lift all boats. The Government's focus on long-term unemployment is beginning to pay off and this is a source of satisfaction. The Government is working in a cohesive way and will complete the tasks it set for itself on its formation.
Comment on this
The Dáil is debating the political accountability and culpability of the Minister for Justice. Mr. Seán Cromien is undertaking the administrative inquiry while we are holding the political inquiry. It is important to mark that distinction. Initially the Minister and the Government sought to have the entire fiasco dealt with by way of the administrative inquiry and valiant efforts were made by Government spokespersons to have the debate postponed. Before I deal with this political mismanagement saga, I wish to state clearly that I am not laying a personal charge against the Minister for Justice; rather I am making a charge of incompetency and mishandling by a Minister in charge of an extremely important Government portfolio.
The Minister for Justice, Deputy Owen, is personable and hard working but endless activity and amiability must be accompanied by a clear edged authority by those in charge of a Department of State. There is a marked lack of authority and incoherence in all the mishaps which have befallen the Minister. Previous Opposition speakers catalogued the list of earlier catastrophes and I do not intend to revisit that terrain. However, I intend dealing with the present debacle which began when the Minister brought to Cabinet her memoranda regarding the delisting of Judge Dominic Lynch.
Presumably there was a discussion at the Cabinet table, with the sponsoring Minister endorsing her view. There was a clear and unequivocal political responsibility on the Minister to ensure that the Government decision was acted upon and subsequently implemented. This action has three distinct phases, all of which are political: (1) preparation and supervision of the memorandum for Cabinet; (2) discussion and endorsement by Cabinet of that memorandum and (3) ensuring the implementation of the decision within the Department. Actions (1) and (2) were carried through but the crucial action of ensuring implementation was casually neglected. The beaches beckoned and blithe Nora went off.
The months of August and September went by in a haze of inactivity on this issue. On 2 October the Attorney General disturbed himself on foot of legal rumblings and wrote to the Minister for Justice inquiring about the position of Judge Lynch. When he received no reply to that letter he wrote a second letter a month later. Leisurely letters written one month apart is the stuff of an old fashioned, bygone Victorian era.
I lay a political charge clearly at the door of the Attorney General who has a definite remit as custodian of the public good. Despite the convoluted explanation given yesterday about the Attorney General and his clients, the facts are clear. Mr. Dermot Gleeson knew the precise implications of the non-implementation by the Minister for Justice of the Government decision to stand down Judge Lynch. He took no action, apart, of course, from writing leisurely letters. This is political culpability of the gravest kind which, to put it in its simplest form, could threaten the security of the State. We are not dealing with petty crime or minor traffic offences but with issues which could fundamentally affect the lives and safety of citizens who should be the primary concern of the Attorney General.
What do the letters contain? The Taoiseach gave alarming answers to questions today about those letters and undoubtedly there will be more developments in this area. The programme for Government states that people in high office should make themselves available for scrutiny by Dáil committees. Given the mystery surrounding his role, the Attorney General should submit himself to scrutiny by the appropriate committee. I ask the Tánaiste to deal with this issue in his reply.
The Minister for Justice did not, unbelievably, give instructions in her office for letters from such an eminent colleague as the Attorney General to be brought to her attention. The second letter from Mr. Dermot Gleeson was posted on Friday, 1 November and read by the Minister the following Tuesday. It is mind boggling urgency and I do not blame An Post for that delay. More ineptitude by the Minister now emerges cloaked in words like "intervention" and "initiative" when she speaks in the Dáil.
The Minister finally read the Attorney General's second letter on Tuesday, 5 November. What was her dramatic intervention then? She telephoned a principal officer in her Department and then went off without taking any further action. She went to Belfast on Wednesday and returned to see the film on Wednesday night. Thirty hours after she read the Attorney General's letter, she had to be called out from the film to take action. She then went back to the film and on to a party. Endless activity and amiability but no control of her Department.
That 30 hour gap shows so strongly the Minister's lack of focus, political perception and sense of authority. The moment the Minister finally read the Attorney General's letter on Tuesday, 5 November alarm bells should have rung. She should then have acted decisively as the political head of that Department, holding an immediate meeting with her senior officials to devise an urgent strategy. She should have perused the files and contacted the Taoiseach.
It is even stranger how it was only as she was preparing for the Dáil debate on Thursday afternoon that Judge Lynch's letter was brought to her attention. This sequence is quite unbelievable. It is further compounded given that the Minister came into the Dáil yet did not disclose the existence of the letter. Later, we were treated to a flimsy excuse but the fact remains that the Minister knew of the letter but did not tell us. It is obvious that knives are being sharpened for a junior official in the Department of Justice while the Minister quite brazenly wraps herself in the surreal frenzied plaudits of her rainbow colleagues.
Turning to a more general point, the Government is laden down with programme managers, advisers and press officers. Is the work of a private secretary and the Minister's private office often diluted by or perhaps merged with the mission of her programme manager? It is a question worth probing in the context of this debate and I would like to hear Mr. Cromien speaking about this matter next week. I hope we will hear him.
The word "trust" if often abused. The Taoiseach said last night the difference between 1994 and 1996 was that trust exists between the three rainbow partners. This much vaunted trust is based on desperation. As Johnson said, we either hang together or we hang separately.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach, the Tánaiste and the leader of Democratic Left should know there is another much more important trust — the trust of the citizens. The electors are far away from cosy rainbow alliances, waiting for an opportunity to cast their votes. Arrogance, ineptitude, evasions and mismanagement are the hallmarks of this Government. They endorse one another, cling together and hope for a new dawn but justice will be meted out to this Government when the general election occurs. We eagerly await that day.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy O'Rourke for sharing her time with me. The core issue is how the rainbow arrangement turned into what can only be described as the most farcical Government this State has had to endure since its foundation. Any expression of confidence in this Government can only be interpreted as the most cynical and self-serving of gestures, and totally unworthy of any self respecting politician.
As the Taoiseach and his droll band stumble from disaster to catastrophe, it is only too easy for those of us in Opposition to resort to opportunistic comment and point scoring. However, I do not intend to follow that route since the matter at hand is far too serious. It would not be going too far to say the abject performance of key figures within the Government is threatening to undermine public confidence in our democratic institutions to an unprecedented degree. Consequently, unless the current sequence of mistake followed by gross mistake is firmly brought to an end we will all be losers, ultimately.
It gives me some satisfaction to see and hear those who have adopted the high moral ground for some time, and who have pointed the finger at Fianna Fáil so often, having to come into this House and blatantly try to justify something which is unjustifiable. There is a trend in all their speeches. They start off by conceding that this is a serious matter in a sensitive area but nobody will accept ministerial responsibility for it. They will give us independent bodies, dismantle the Department and set up any kind of quasi-State apparatus rather than apportion responsibility for this. That is a change for some people. When we had the last serious problem in the Department of Agriculture, Food and Forestry we got an independent food monitoring authority and now we have another independent body.
How has the current unbelievable situation occurred where the Taoiseach and his Cabinet colleagues indulge in the most cynical of verbal gymnastics simply to hang on to Government? The root of the problem goes back to the formation of this rainbow Coalition. As is now only too evident, a mixture of perceived political expediency and weak leadership under pressure resulted in the Tánaiste, Deputy Spring, deliberately destroying an excellent Government two years ago. Bad as this act was in terms of betrayal of trust and political responsibility, the matter was seriously compounded when Deputy Spring and his colleagues attempted to wrap themselves in a blanket of moral superiority while at the same time maligning their Government colleagues without the slightest sense of fair play or honour.
Comment on this
In what were without doubt among the most vile and unjustified contributions ever made to this House — I had occasion to go through the speeches that were made two years ago and they were vile and unjustified — senior figures from Fine Gael and Democratic Left joined in the malice. As a result, the integrity of parliamentary debate along with the essential underlying respect between politicians of all parties was dealt a serious blow. Then we wonder why the currency of politicians, including Members of this House, is so low.
From those benches, Deputy Rabbitte, who is now a Minister of State, asserted he had information that would rock the foundations of this State.
Comment on this
Of course, there was not a scintilla of truth in that, either then or now, but that was done to provide an hysterical backdrop to remove the Government from office.
Comment on this
In such an atmosphere it is perhaps not surprising that the rainbow coalition had only one uniting objective, the desire to gain power and to hang onto it at all costs for as long as possible.
Comment on this
Thus the cement of a series of common goals which are so essential for cohesive and effective Government was totally absent in the current Government from its earliest days.
Comment on this
Deputy Walsh's colleagues should allow him to continue uninterrupted.
Comment on this
If at this stage this Government has any genuine interest in what is best for our democratic process, there is only one honourable option available to the Taoiseach and his colleagues. They should immediately resign from Government. By taking such a course of action they will responsibly admit the core deficiency of any moral centre to their Administration. Taking into account the wildly differing agendas of Labour, Fine Gael and Democratic Left, this simple reality is only too evident even to the most inexperienced bystander. By resigning, the Government will firmly place the initiative back in the hands of the electorate who will then be in a position to give their verdict on the matter. The electorate are hard taskmasters, however, and it is not so easy to face them, particularly when one has gone from blunder to disaster.
It is fine to come into this House and say we have a great economy. We have many great things but there is no honourable acceptance that the inheritance of a good economic situation was the result of post-1987 economic restructuring and the restoration of the national finances. Unfortunately, from the comments of the Taoiseach, the Tánaiste and the Minister for Justice, there is no sign of a sense of responsibility or contrition for the appalling mess they have created. Rather, we have had a series of depressing, shallow and shameless speeches which show no sensitivity to the stark reality that the credibility of their Administration has been well and truly blown apart. In what can only be described as the ultimate folly, we had the bizarre spectacle yesterday of the Taoiseach expressing total confidence in his Minister for Justice while at the same time using the scalpel to dismantle her Department. I have never seen such a daft performance in my political life. If the Taoiseach were captain of a stricken ship, I have no doubt he would confidently blow air bubbles into the hold as it slipped under water.
As it appears another major scandal will be necessary before this incoherent and fatally damaged Administration is finally forced to leave office, it is necessary to recall its brief history. The first hiccup came within weeks of it assuming office. Having regard to the Coalition's unique and comical working definition of the lofty aspirations of openness, transparency and accountability, it is not surprising that the first problem involved the advance leaking of sensitive budget information. Faced with the fearsome wrath of the Labour Party perched on the high moral ground, the head of the then Minister, Deputy Hogan, had to be sacrificed irrespective of the fact that he had no personal involvement in leaking that information. The whistle was blown and when the Tánaiste blows the whistle, one has to get out.
Many people thought the leaking affair would be a once off matter and that the rainbow Coalition would avoid further scandals during its remaining time in office. It was felt that the lack of meaningful policy potential between the far left, the centre and far right political parties would at least free the Administration to concentrate its energies on self-preservation and self-promotion, while basking in the reflected achievements of the Government that preceded it. Unfortunately, life is not that simple and Deputy Hogan had barely reached the dugout when the referee — the Tánaiste — was again furiously tooting his whistle. This time it was a Cork Minister's head that was at stake, that of poor Deputy Coveney
Comment on this
He was shown the red card for behaviour which was incompatible with ministerial office.
In this case pressure was put on civil servants in the Department of Justice to bail out the Minister. I have been a Member of the House for 20 years, have taken a keen interest in Government matters since the foundation of the State and, even in the troubled times, when taking over from the British, or during various Administration changes since then, I have not known any segment of the Civil Service to take political sides. Unfortunately, this has led to the break-up of that organisation, to conflicting statements from it and to an undermining of its integrity and neutrality. It is a shame the political heads in the Department of Justice put such pressure on civil servants.
Comment on this
I support a good Minister who has done a good job in difficult circumstances. The Minister for Justice cannot be blamed for a major administrative error. She did not do anything wrong. She performed her duties correctly. I hope the inquiry will discover who made the mistake and I expect such a poor administrative performance will not go unpunished.
The efforts by Fianna Fáil to implicate the Attorney General is irresponsible and irrational. If the Attorney General had not notified the Department of Justice when he did, I am sure Fianna Fáil would now be pointing out the errors of his ways. Members of Fianna Fáil must believe the electorate has a collective short memory. They would be better employed having consultations with Dr. Anthony Clare rather than with Terry Prone in Carr Communications. It is obvious they need deep psychological counselling to overcome the trauma of what happened to them two years ago. Fianna Fáil will need time to get over the mess it created in Government this time two years ago and if the mood of the electorate is anything to go by, it will be given every opportunity to rehabilitate on the Opposition benches during the next five years.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Keeffe should not worry, he will get his answer in time.
The Progressive Democrats and Fianna Fail have tried to divide the Government on this issue. They have not succeeded and will not succeed because there is a genuine trust and confidence between the parties in this Government. Fianna Fáil genuinely believes every party in power acts like itself. It will turn inwards and choke whatever party goes to bed with it. This Government is staying together because of trust and openness between its members.
Comment on this
They respect each other, something Fianna Fáil found difficult to do with any Government party. There are sharp differences between the parties in Government, but we agreed on a programme for Government and we will stick to it.
The Progressive Democrats are on a sticky wicket. For years Deputies O'Malley and Harney believed Fianna Fáil had horns, but when it is politically advantageous to get into bed with those demons, they are prepared to cast aside their infamous principles. They will do anything to get into a State car.
Comment on this
The Minister for Justice has performed well. The Government decision to take responsibility for the prison system from the Department is long overdue. There will be such a shake-up in this section in the next couple of years that the current prison regime will be unrecognisable in the future.
Comment on this
People at the lowest possible level should be made responsible for their actions. We should reward good practices and punish poor practice. How could a Minister for Justice be responsible for a prisoner being transported from one prison to another in the company of three or four prison officers and gardaí?
Comment on this
What could a Minister do about that? Similarly, what could a Minister do if a prisoner, deemed by medical professionals to be fit for imprisonment in an open prison, decides to go outside the prison walls for an hour or two? That is why reform of the prison system is extremely urgent.
The decision taken yesterday by this Government will have far reaching, advantageous effects on the prison system. The efforts of Fianna Fáil and the Progressive Democrats to drive a wedge between the parties in Government will not work. It will be seen by the public for what it is, a charade. They will have to make some other effort to destabilise the Government.
Comment on this
The Deputy should go down to the Four Courts, to hear the Minister, Deputy De Rossa.
Comment on this
I am surprised at Fianna Fáil and the Progressive Democrats moving a motion of confidence in the Government. They should have waited until the inquiry is completed. When we could have a constructive discussion on the matter. Today's debate has been pointless. The debate could have concluded last night and, as the Taoiseach stated, we could have got back to work.
This issue is different from what happened in November 1994. It should be a tragic reminder to Fianna Fáil of what happened then when, in the full glare of the Dáil, the former Taoiseach, Deputy Reynolds, sat here for four and a half hours flanked by Deputy Bertie Ahern. That Deputy did not pass that one crucial letter from the Attorney General's office to Deputy Reynolds. The Leader of Fianna Fáil would not want to be reminded of what happened then. That situation was different from the present one. I welcome the speedy investigation initiated by the Minister and I trust that proper systems will be put in place so that a similar situation does not occur in the future.
What is happening in the High Court in London will act as a reminder to people who are inclined to forget why the previous Government fell.
Comment on this
Deputy Reynolds told the jury he had not received a letter from the then new Attorney General, Mr. Eoghan Fitzsimons, concerning the Duggan case until after he had made his crucial speech to the Dáil about the handling of Fr. Brendan Smyth's extradition. He subsequently found the letter had been sent to the Dáil by staff in the Attorney General's office and had been passed through a number of hands before arriving in his ministerial colleague's bundles of files. He claimed it never reached him. When asked by Lord Williams who his ministerial colleague was, he replied it was Deputy Bertie Ahern. Lord Williams expressed surprise at the fact that Deputy Reynold's successor did not pass it to him.
Comment on this
This happened in the High Court in London, although I am sure the Deputy is not following it closely.
Comment on this
Deputy Reynolds said he hit the ceiling when he found the letter on his desk that evening.
Comment on this
What motivated Deputy Bertie Ahern not to pass on that letter to Deputy Reynolds? Did he foresee a situation where Deputy Reynolds would step down as Leader of Fianna Fáil and he would, perhaps, be appointed?
Comment on this
Did Lord Williams say which official in the Attorney General's office had that letter?
Comment on this
If Deputy Noel Treacy was following the case in London, he would be familiar with those facts.
Comment on this
Deputy Treacy, we had an orderly debate until you arrived. I ask you to control yourself, please.
Comment on this
I support the Minister for Justice. This has been a successful and united Government through all the problems it inherited from its predecessors. We all remember how that Government fell.
Victims of crime should be more important than the criminal and the bail laws should be more important than political games, which is what this debate has been about for the past two days.
Comment on this
Drug-related crime is not only important in Dublin but in my constituency of Cavan-Monaghan.
Comment on this
New prison places are being provided. We had nothing but promises of prison places for the previous eight and a half years.
Comment on this
This Minister is taking action and 800 places will be provided during her three years in office.
Comment on this
Others should be locked up too. The Minister has restructured the Garda Síochána. There are now five new Garda regions and 400 extra gardaí will be appointed. Additional court sittings will be provided and 15 new judges will be appointed.
Comment on this
We heard in the past two days about the three great Ministers for Justice in the previous Government, but their successor had to introduce ten new Bills in as many months.
The last Government fell because of a series of events, including the beef tribunal and the passport scandal when the then Taoiseach said he did not know his wife and family had received over £1 million. We all know that if someone wins £10 in the national lottery it will be talked about at the breakfast table, yet the then Taoiseach said he knew nothing about it, although a number of his Ministers made sure they received it.
Comment on this
I am glad I never had to go to court but I have visited the Land Registry. I hope the Minister will get time to improve the structures in that office so that people can do their business properly. I look forward to her being in office for many more years.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to express confidence in the work of the Taoiseach, the Tánaiste, the Minister for Social Welfare and, in particular, the Minister for Justice. Instead of attacking the Minister, members of Fianna Fáil should express regret at the state in which they left the criminal justice system, which was stretched to breaking point after eight years. We should focus on the extraordinary reforming zeal, energy, commitment and persistence which the Minister has shown in dealing with her brief. The beneficial effects of her reforming zeal will be felt in our criminal justice system for a long time.
Many demands are made on the Department of Justice on a daily basis and many decisions must be made. What is important is how people behave in a crisis. Let us look at how the Minister has behaved in this crisis. As soon as she realised what was happening, she initiated an inquiry. Natural justice demands that we await the results of that inquiry before we make a judgment or condemn individuals involved in this situation. The Minister came into the Dáil and answered questions and she will be here again when the results of that inquiry are known next week.
It is important to look at the Minister's record in the Department of Justice. People have talked about bail reform for many years, yet nobody except this Minister has asked the people to vote in a bail referendum. There has been much talk about what needs to be done but she has taken action in many important areas. People have talked about the need to reform our courts system but nothing was done for the past eight years. Before the announcement was made yesterday, the Minister had already asked Mrs. Justice Susan Denham to head up a commission of inquiry and had given a commitment to implement its recommendations. People talked about the lack of prison spaces and the revolving door syndrome in our prisons yet this issue was not tackled. This Government has taken a more proactive approach than any Government to this issue.
The Minister has initiated reform in many other areas. She has provided more Garda resources in Dublin and throughout the country. She has set in place a reorganisation of the Garda force and placed much more emphasis on the victims of crime, a much neglected area for many years. Last week she received a report on violence against women and is determined to act on that. For many years people talked about the seizure of criminal assets, but who took action? No one. Yet within two years the Minister for Justice took action and established the National Bureau of Fraud Investigation.
Comment on this
I am sorry to interrupt the Deputy but the time has come to call on the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign to conclude the debate.
Comment on this
I understand I am to wind up this debate and I am proud to support the motion before the House.
Comment on this
The Deputy's party failed to wind it up for the past two days.
This is a motion of confidence in the Government. This Government came to office in difficult and unusual circumstances and I will deal with that in more detail later. Despite that, the Government has presided over the most successful economic period in the history of the State. It has created more jobs in a two year period than in any comparable period in our history. It has repaired the damage to the social and economic fabric of our community that was inflicted on it during the period of three years when the Progressive Democrats and Fianna Fáil were in Government. It has and is presiding over some of the most complex negotiations in the recent history of Europe and is doing so in a manner that has attracted high praise throughout Europe.
The Government has reversed the shameful cuts in health, housing, education, welfare, aid to the developing world and a range of other areas that Fianna Fáil and the Progressive Democrats had so savagely implemented in their time in a disastrous Government. It has introduced free third level education for the first time in our history and an entire programme of far reaching reform in the education area. It has also introduced reforming legislation in the area of family law that had been sought for well over 25 years.
The Government has taken on the battle against an epidemic of crime and drugs that had been building up for many years. It has introduced wide-ranging reforms in this area and is totally committed to taking on the drug barons in every area of their activity.
Is é an Rialtas seo a rinne mórbheart chun saol cultúrtha an phobail a athbheochan, comh maith lenár gcultúr agus ár dteanga arsa dúchais a caomhnú agus a leathnú. Ní amháin gur thaispeáin mór-éachtaí ealaíona ár scríbhneoirí, aisteoirí, rinnceoirí, filí agus amhránaithe go bhfuil mór-éileamh sa tír seo ar ár n-Oidhreacht, ach ini ainneoin na sceiptigh, cuireadh tús craolta le Telefís na Gaeilge le déanaí. Tá an obair a rinne an Rialtas i leith an ábhair seo as an nua go h-iomlán agus mairfidh sé do no glúine atá le teacht.
The Government has sought to build on the work of peacemaking started by its two predecessors. It has set out the parameters——
Comment on this
——of a lasting solution in Northern Ireland, in agreement with the British Government.
It has succeeded in getting a fixed date for all-party talks and their commencement. It has agreed the procedures and ground rules for those talks in intensive negotiations and discussions. The Government works night and day to try to rebuild the process of inclusion that was shattered by the Canary Wharf bomb. In short, the House is being asked to vote confidence in a Government born in turbulent circumstances, that has been in office for almost two years and can already account for historic achievements in the economy, job creation, Europe, social policy, family law reform, the battle against crime and in the painstaking struggle to further the cause of reconciliation and inclusion in Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
In the time left to the Government, its further commitments are many and varied and they will be honoured.
Of course, I am proud to support this motion. When I review the record and bear in mind the work still to be done, how could it be otherwise? I am also proud to say that I support the Minister for Justice and I reject the mean-spirited attacks that have been made on her.
Since 1977, Fianna Fáil Ministers have been in political control of the Department of Justice for some 13 years.
Comment on this
Those who have sought to blame the Minister for Justice, Deputy Owen, for the problems that undoubtedly exist in that Department might do well to reflect on that fact. It was Fianna Fáil Ministers, some of whom have taken part in this debate, who allowed a culture of obsessive secrecy to be built up in that Department. They failed to implement the Whitaker report, allowed the management of the courts to get into such a state that they have been in crisis for years and allowed the free legal aid service to run down to a point where battered wives and their children had to be turned away from the centres.
I have worked closely with the Minister for Justice, Deputy Owen, during the past two years as she has spearheaded the fight against crime and introduced the legal and management reforms necessary in that area.
I have also worked with her in relation to Northern Ireland at intergovernment level and in the all-party talks. In all those areas she has been an excellent colleague and contributor and has carried a huge workload with energy and commitment.
I have also worked with the Attorney General in the same areas and have relied heavily on his advice in others. One of the more unwarranted attacks in this spurious debate must surely be the attacks on him. What is the allegation against the Attorney General?
Comment on this
The allegation is not that he did not do his job. His job is that of legal adviser to the Government. In his correspondence with the Minister, he raised the issue of fact with possible legal implications. He is criticised not for this, but because he did not follow up the queries himself and take the necessary action. He is criticised, in other words, for not doing an administrative job within the Department of Justice.
Comment on this
The Deputy would not stand on a box because he would fall off it. He would not attempt to get up on a pedestal.
Comment on this
I must ask Deputy Treacy to desist from making constant interruptions. If the Deputy feels he cannot listen to the Member in possession, he has a remedy. There are many exists from this Chamber.
Comment on this
It is even suggested by some distinguished commentators who should know better that if the Attorney General had done nothing he would have been blameless, but that when he took the step of proffering advice he had a duty to follow it through and ensure it was followed. This is absolute nonsense. The Attorney is adviser to the Government as a whole and its 15 individual Ministers.
Comment on this
He advises them on a huge range of issues from constitutional law, to administrative law, to public international law, to criminal law, to commercial and contract law — every branch of the law and every issue with which a Government becomes involved which has a legal dimension which, in modern society, means virtually every issue.
Is it seriously suggested that on top of all of this, on top of doing his work as Attorney General and giving legal advice, he is supposed to ensure that his advice is implemented and acted upon? In my experience a lawyer must advise his client, but it is not his responsibility to ensure that his client acts on that advice.
That is the logic of the Opposition attack on Dermot Gleeson. He is criticised for neglecting his job, even though he did it and did it very well. He is also criticised for not doing the administrative work of the Department of Justice. The criticism is patently unjust. I refer to the equally spurious charge that we have, in some way, removed key responsibilities from the Minister for Justice. Did the Minister for Finance cease to carry responsibility for the national debt when the NTMA was set up? Was the Minister for Communications deprived of power when Telecom Éireann and An Post were established? As Deputies are aware, the answer is no.
Comment on this
We are implementing reforms which the Minister for Justice supports and which, in some cases, have been demanded by all sides of the House for years. The independent and permanent body to manage a unified courts system is something we pressed for in our negotiations, first with Fianna Fáil, then with Fine Gael and Democratic Left. It forms an integral part of the programme, A Government of Renewal. The Minister for Justice's commitment to it stands up well to examination by comparison with that of her predecessor.
Yesterday not one but both leaders of the parties in Opposition referred with obvious approval to a speech I made in the House on 16 November 1994.
Comment on this
I do not recall Deputy Ahern receiving that speech with such approval at the time it was delivered but, clearly, it has grown on him in the intervening period. Selective quotation of speeches is not always a great idea. It seems Deputies Ahern and Harney agree absolutely with the principle of accountability as I tried to define it then, the notion that a Minister is accountable to the Dáil even in respect of a situation in which he or she is not directly culpable. As they see it, accountability means that one is fired or resigns.
Deputies Ahern and Harney should perhaps have read that speech a little further. I went on to set out what it was the Labour Party was trying to achieve at that time. Three or four paragraphs after the section Deputies Ahern and Harney quote with such approval I put it simply and clearly: "What the Labour Party wants is an accounting, a true and fair accounting, and nothing more than that".
Instead of concentrating on what is important, the serious problems that must be addressed and resolved, this House is being invited to compare what has happened on this occasion with what happened in 1994. I am happy to do so.
In 1994 we had a Government that had set out with high hopes two years earlier to bring about change and peace on this island. Throughout that year it struggled to deal with issues of trust brought about, in every single instance, by actions not of the Labour Party's making.
We all know about the accumulation of incidents throughout 1994 and the breaches of trust involved. We all know about the attempts to implement Government decisions as faits accomplis. I notice that my absence from Ireland on EU and Presidency business has been a source of great complaint by some of the Fianna Fáil speakers in this debate, even though, in their usual two-faced way, they never tire of demanding that I sort out any problem with an international dimension from Russia to the Great Lakes region.
Comment on this
They never used to complain in the days when they tried to use my absence on Government business to ram decisions through the Cabinet. In November 1994 we had a major issue which demanded public accountability, a serious scandal which caused outrage among decent people everywhere.
Comment on this
We demanded that accountability in writing at the Cabinet table. Those letters have been published. We demanded it from the law officer who had overall responsibility for a debacle that should never have happened. We demanded that there should be accountability before that law officer was promoted to the second highest judicial office in the land because real accountability would not be possible after his promotion but we did not get it. The Dáil was denied it. Instead we got a Cabinet meeting which rejected the Attorney General's explanations for the fiasco and then went on to promote him to a post where he was immune from further questioning.
The Taoiseach who rammed that decision through on a Friday tried to pressurise the same person into resigning the following Monday, went on to defend him and all his actions on the Tuesday and excoriated him on the Wednesday.
Comment on this
The same information — the Duggan case — was used to pressurise Mr. Whelehan in secret on the Monday, concealed from this House on the Tuesday and then revealed with great fanfare on the Wednesday. Does anyone in their right mind and without an axe to grind really believe that that situation is comparable to the difficulties we now face?
Comment on this
The Minister for Justice, Deputy Owen, did not come into the House last Thursday seeking to evade responsibility or to justify the promotion of anyone to a position where they were immune from accountability. She did not receive advice from the Attorney General and then tell him it was not going to be used. She had no note in front of her which said, "if pressed, keep repeating the above". Instead, she came into the House and offered a true and fair accounting, exactly what we looked for in 1994. Even before she came into the House she had begun an investigation. This did not happen in 1994 when the explanations had been rejected and the decision made anyway.
The situation at the heart of this controversy is a grave and serious one but it is being treated with seriousness and honesty. On this occasion the investigation will be conducted independently and its outcome published. The ramifications and implications of that investigation will be followed wherever they lead.
Comment on this
The attempts to compare this situation with what happened in 1994 are spurious. Members of Fianna Fáil were no innocent bystanders, they were actively engaged, some with more understanding than others of what was involved, in seeking to deprive this House of the explanations to which it was entitled. It almost worked.
Comment on this
If I had not discovered the truth, I would have voted confidence in that Government that day. I would not have checked information I got with the then Attorney General and got his precise, firm and simple explanations.
Comment on this
The Deputy should please allow the Tánaiste to conclude. There is no point of order.
Comment on this
I request the writer of this rubbish to come into the House and face the people instead of acting as a ventriloquist's dummy.
Comment on this
As it always does, the truth would have come out eventually. Despite that, to this day, not one Fianna Fáil person has ever said, "we got it wrong in 1994, we should have insisted that Albert Reynolds went into the Dáil and told the whole truth before Harry was promoted". As even the most cursory reading of Sean Duignan's book will reveal, there were some at least who knew they were sacrificing a Government of solid achievement to the whims of their leader and they were afraid to lift a finger.
Comment on this
That is what really hurts Fianna Fáil. They were done in by the truth, nothing more, nothing less. They cannot bear it now when they see a Government Minister facing up to a difficult situation truthfully and honestly, coming into the House and offering the accountability it requires and deserves.
This three-party coalition under the Taoiseach's leadership has been a good Government. It is a Government that is prepared to account for mistakes, tell the truth to the House and face the consequences. It is also a Government that has much work to do. By the time it faces the electorate it will have added yet more achievement to its record. It is our intention to continue the work of reform, growth, dynamism and peace. It will be for the people ultimately to decide who understands and is committed to the principle of accountability.
I accept fully that the issue of accountability must remain at the heart of our political life. In addition to the reforms and measures we have already announced, I would like to believe that the belated but welcome conversion of Fianna Fáil would guarantee support for a package of measures that could be finalised quickly and which would make certain that accountability would become, in the phrase of a former Fianna Fáil Minister, a core value of Irish politics.
Comment on this
Such a package would challenge every party in the House to accept a new wording for a referendum on Cabinet confidentiality on which the Taoiseach has commissioned further work. There is no reason such a referendum could not take place either before or alongside next year's general election. I know Fianna Fáil would welcome this.
Comment on this
It would also include rapid processing through the Oireachtas of the Freedom of Information Bill, the heads of which have already been published, debated and accepted by a Dáil committee, together with a thorough review of the Official Secrets Act and secrecy provisions in other legislation——
Comment on this
Is the Tánaiste serious? We cannot get answers to parliamentary questions or access to files.
Comment on this
——the speedy enactment on an all-party basis of the Public Service Management Bill; the rapid processing through Committee of the Privilege and Compellability of Witnesses Bill, a measure I am sure Fianna Fáil will be anxious to support; acceptance of a Bill to amend the Ombudsman Act and to extend his powers and remit to act on behalf of the citizen — I know how supportive Fianna Fáil has been of the Ombudsman in the past and an administrative procedures Bill which would give citizens a range of new rights in relation to decision-making in the public service.
Comment on this
The man who attacked Jimmy Tully is still here. If the attitude of Fianna Fáil to accountability is as genuine and sincere as the temper of this debate would suggest, there is no reason to believe that a detailed accountability package along these lines could not be enacted into law within the next 12 months of this Government. A great deal of the necessary background work on these measures is almost complete.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste voted down every Dáil reform proposal put before the House recently. There were 11 votes against the reforms.
Comment on this
Sincerity is not a concept one would readily associate with Fianna Fáil, but I am offering that party an opportunity to work with us to enhance the whole spirit and reality of accountability. No doubt when the clamour of point-scoring has died down, it will be able to reflect on how valuable a high degree of accountability will be on any future occasion it manages to get into office.
We will, in any event, carry on the work of reform and change. The Government has a long way to go before its work is done. It will not be deflected by the attitude of Fianna Fáil or the Progressive Democrats. We will remain solid and united——
Comment on this
——working together on a basis of trust and determined always to account to this House when that is necessary. Of course, as is human, we will make mistakes, but unlike some of the people opposite, when we do there will be no fudging, evasion, misleading or pretence. This is an honest Government with an outstanding track record and a vision of change. I commend the motion to the House.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?