Quinn's challenge over the Taoiseach's budget statement
Quinn sought to challenge the Taoiseach’s statement about where a recast budget should be announced, arguing that a Finance Minister’s press statement warranted a correction. The Chair ruled the matter inappropriate during Question Time and repeatedly tried to proceed with the Order Paper; Quinn eventually resumed his seat but said he would pursue the issue, and the Chair declined another point of order.
On a point of order, am I correct in raising a statement made by the Taoiseach on the Order of Business which he might like to correct in the light of the press statement that has been issued by the Minister for Finance? I will read from the "blacks" transcript of this morning's Order of Business and you may wish to adjudicate, Sir. The net point was—
Comment on this
Deputy, I would prefer if you raised this matter at another time. Question Time is limited and this is not appropriate at the start of Question Time.
Comment on this
When we come to budget matters will you allow me to raise this matter? The House was misled by the Taoiseach this morning—
Comment on this
—and I thought that, following normal practice, when this was brought to his attention the Taoiseach would, at the earliest possible opportunity, have the courtesy to correct it. As the Taoiseach said, he does not tell lies.
Comment on this
I am asking a question. Would the Taoiseach like to correct the record where he said, "If the budget is to be recast the place to announce it is in the House".
Comment on this
Deputy, you are out of order. You may raise a point of order at some time but not during Question Time. This is not the appropriate time.
Comment on this
I am giving you question number one. When will the Minister for Finance come into the House—
Comment on this
There is a long standing tradition in this House. Question Time is from now until 4.15 p.m.
Comment on this
You are not asking a question. Deputy Bruton's is Question No. 1. We are now taking Deputy Bruton's question.
Comment on this
Deputy Quinn, you are being disorderly. You must show respect for the Chair. The House cannot function if a Member does not show respect for the Chair.
Comment on this
I am showing respect for the people of this country, Sir. I am showing respect for this establishment.
Comment on this
Deputy Quinn, you do not have the right to continue to speak when the Chair is on his feet. There must be respect for the Chair in this House.
Comment on this
The Chair will not defer. I call Question No. 1. Deputy Quinn, I am asking you, for the last time to resume your seat. Do you intend to resume your seat?
Comment on this
In deference to yourself, Sir, I will resume my seat but I will not let go of this issue.