Ceisteanna–Questions (Resumed).
- Roads programme schedule 8 speeches
Noonan presses the Taoiseach to say whether the roads programme is four years behind schedule; the Taoiseach rejects that claim without giving the direct yes-or-no answer sought.
Michael Noonan, Michael Smith, Ruairí Quinn
- National development plan delivery 6 speeches
The Taoiseach describes the planning and expected timelines for major roads, noting that some projects may run into 2007. He also acknowledges delays in work-permit processing and says a Bill and additional staff are intended to help.
Charles Flanagan, Bertie Ahern, Ruairí Quinn, Jack Wall
- Road land acquisition costs 2 speeches
Howlin says fair compensation and replacement land could obstruct infrastructure projects. The Taoiseach agrees the issue needs a structural solution and says he will raise it with the relevant Minister.
Brendan Howlin, Bertie Ahern
- Work-permit recruitment and processing 6 speeches
Howlin asks about the countries supplying permit holders. The Taoiseach says workers come from a wide range of countries, including Australia, Canada and the United States, and stresses the need for an effective system to recruit skilled workers.
Brendan Howlin, Bertie Ahern
- Slane bridge replacement 4 speeches
Farrelly asks whether funding could be made available to replace or bypass the dangerous Slane bridge, where deaths have occurred. The Taoiseach says the matter is for the Environment Minister; they also agree that landowners should be able to buy replacement land.
John V. Farrelly, Bertie Ahern, Brendan Howlin
- Plastic bag levy legislation 9 speeches
Gormley accuses the Taoiseach of delaying the plastic-bag levy. The Taoiseach says it will be included in the forthcoming Waste Management Bill, explaining that the Finance Bill had been an alternative if no suitable legislation arose.
John Gormley, Séamus Pattison, Ruairí Quinn, Bertie Ahern
I want something much simpler, I want to know if the chairman of the Progressive Democrats is correct when he says the roads programme is four years behind schedule.
Comment on this
Yes or no. I do not want a tour of the 32 counties without an answer to the question.
Comment on this
Is he right or is he wrong? Is the roads programme behind schedule? We will have to complain to Deputy Harney.
Comment on this
On the same matter, is the Taoiseach telling the House that there will be a dual carriageway from Dublin to Cork in four years? Regarding An Action Programme for the Millennium, and acknowledging an increase in employment, one of the major obstacles we face is a major skills shortage. How does the Taoiseach propose to ease the visa restrictions to allow immigrants work permits and greater access to work permits?
Comment on this
On the national development plan and the roads to Belfast, Galway, Limerick, Cork and Waterford, the NRA was given the task of putting project teams together to design those either in blocks or in large contracts. I mentioned the Belfast road. The NRA recently set out Waterford which will be in two contracts; there will be a number in Cork. They are designing and planning in a way that can—
Comment on this
Yes, I accept that. When this was being discussed some years ago, everyone stated that we could not do what we have done in Waterford. I acknowledge that Deputy Quinn did raise that. It was done across county councils. The experts say that in the case of Waterford the project has been shortened by five years.
Comment on this
Some will drift into 2007. Some of these roads were not expected to be completed until 2012.
On the second part of the question, a work permits Bill is coming before the House. Last year 20,000 non-EU people came through that system, compared to 800 more recently. It is a large number of people. There is a problem in that employers have a long delay, particularly in certain industries. I acknowledge that they need greater certainty and a faster turn around. Additional staff were employed to expedite matters. With the range of countries from which people come and the checking system, it is still too slow. They are streamlining that again to make it less bureaucratic and simpler. The old system which dealt with only a few hundred applicants is too cumbersome. Subject to correction, the new system was introduced earlier this year and that is desirable.
The Deputy is correct in that our unemployment rate is under 3.5% . In a number of the key sectors there is no unemployment. The information communication technologies sectors tell me they have 50 or 60 vacancies. The system has to be faster because people will come from non-EU countries. We want to do that. I hoped we could do without the legislation but it is due.
Comment on this
Does the Taoiseach accept, given his most recent comment, that the two nations most prominent in visas were Australia and Canada? Other nations from where we want to recruit people are not well represented. More importantly, does he accept that a major obstacle in completing the national roads programme and other infrastructural projects is the difficulty with land? Does the Taoiseach accept the requirement to pay land owners a fair price will be a big obstacle to fulfilling the ambitions laid out in the national roads programme and other infrastructural projects? The imposition of a national indicative price for land is having a disastrous impact on the progress of many road projects, two of which in my constituency will not progress until a more realistic price is paid. Will the Taoiseach accept that no progress will be made unless the money paid allows a farmer to buy replacement land?
Comment on this
Deputy Howlin asked me the same question a few weeks ago, and the answer is yes. Progress has to be made as all land is not the same. The NRA, the Minister for the Environment and Local Government, and the Minister for Finance have tried to rectify the matter; it has to be dealt with. Farm bodies, who I have been meeting on other issues, have raised this issue. I acknowledge there will not be a resolution unless the structure is changed. Solutions have been found in a number of areas, and I am disappointed Wexford is not one of them. I will mention this to the Minister for the Environment and Local Government.
Comment on this
The range of countries from which people are given work permits surprised me. I believe people came from 63 or 73 different countries. Admittedly, countries like Australia, the United States, Canada—
Comment on this
—and a number of European countries that are not in the EU are supplying many people. People in certain countries are now focusing on this country as a place to work, and that will probably extend to other countries. It is important that the system works, as the private sector says it has to go to these countries to get the skilled people it requires. The enormous figure for Australia can be attributed to one or two year visas given to nurses.
Comment on this
Is there a possibility of amending the roads programme in the national development plan to include Slane bridge? The replacement of that disastrous bridge is not included in the plan despite the fact that 22 people have been killed there. If the NRA tells the Government it wants to bypass Slane with a new bridge, will money be made available? As we cannot put a price on life, would such a request be given favourable consideration, particularly as the Minister for the Environment and Local Government, Deputy Dempsey, is from that constituency.
Three major roads are to be built through the Meath constituency, the N2, N3 and N4, and this will affect a large number of farmers. If the land issue is not dealt with, the roads programme will not go ahead on time. People are being asked to accept one third of the money it would take to replace an acre of land. This is not acceptable and, as my leader said, unless it is dealt with these programmes will take four years longer than necessary to complete.
Comment on this
The Slane bridge issue is not within my remit, but I am sure the Deputy will pursue it with the Minister for the Environment and Local Government. We are all aware of the recent tragedy at the bridge, as well as those that have taken place over many years. I have discussed the difficulties regarding land prices with Deputy Howlin and at the infrastructural committee, and an effort is being made to resolve them. People must be realistic about prices.
Comment on this
Is it not reasonable for a person to want to buy an acre of land to replace the one taken from him or her to build a road?
Comment on this
Deputy Noonan said the Government's record on the environment has been less than satisfactory, to put it mildly. Does the Taoiseach accept his record in that regard has been appalling, and that he has an old-fashioned attitude towards the environment? Does he accept his manifesto, which he mentioned, was high on aspirations which have not been delivered? I draw his attention to the levy on plastic bags. That would have been a very small gesture, but it has not been delivered. On 25 October last, the Taoiseach stated, "As I told the Deputy previously—
Comment on this
Does the Taoiseach accept he said to me this could be done by regulation or through the Finance Bill and does not require separate legislation? Why did the Taoiseach say that when he is now drafting separate legislation? The Taoiseach is deliberately dragging his feet on this matter because he does not want people to pay for plastic bags coming up to an election. That is his mindset.
Comment on this
I think I have an insight on this one. Why has the Taoiseach not delivered on this small point?
Comment on this
Deputy Gormley got his insight wrong on this one. I admit I said it would be included the Finance Bill if there was not another suitable legislative measure. It will be passed in the Waste Management Bill which will be before the House shortly. If there had been no suitable Bill, it would have been included the Finance Bill. I agree with Deputy Gormley on the plastic bags issue.