We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Financial Resolutions 2003. - Financial Resolution No. 5: General (Resumed).

Contributions 1–178 of 349. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I am glad to have the opportunity of continuing this important debate.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Deputy should speak for Dublin. He should save the airport.

Comment on this

I would like to deliver a message to the people of Portlaoise, Macroom, Enniscorthy, Carlow, Killarney, Mallow, Cavan, Clonakilty, Carrick-on-Shannon, Knock—

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

No disrespect to the Deputy, but I live in Dublin south-central.

Comment on this

—Furbo, Clifden, Gweedore, Newbridge, Curragh, Portarlington, Shannon, Thomastown—

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

It is a milk rás.

Comment on this

—Arklow, Waterford, Wexford, Tullamore, Kilrush, Listowel, Newcastle West, Trim, Kanturk, Claremorris, Youghal, Dungarvan, Limerick, Tipperary, Roscrea, Thurles, Longford, Navan, Drogheda, Buncrana, Donegal, Sligo, Monaghan, Carrickmacross, Mitchelstown, Shannon, Ballinasloe and Loughrea.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

Two places the Deputy was never in, I am sure.

Comment on this

I offer my apologies to anybody I left out of that list.

Comment on this

Birr.

Comment on this

The message I want to give on behalf of Fine Gael is that civil servants are not wanted in these towns. We now have an official Fine Gael policy—

Comment on this

We have a different message.

Comment on this

—against decentralisation of 10,000 civil servants from Dublin. The reason I strongly support this budget is that I understand the dynamics of Dublin.

Comment on this

That is a revelation.

Comment on this

I was Lord Mayor of this city between 2001 and 2002. The population of Dublin at present is 1.1 million. In 2030 it will be 1.6 million or 1.7 million. That is an increase of approximately 60% over the next 20 years. Anybody who feels this is sustainable and that we will be able to function is living in cloud cuckoo land. The Fianna Fáil Government since 1997 has invested hundreds of millions of euro in Dublin: the Luas project, the Dublin Port tunnel and the Ringsend sewage treatment plant, which on its own accounts for about €210 million.

Comment on this

The tunnel has to be expanded.

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Durkan will allow Deputy Mulcahy to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Durkan going to the opening of the Kildare bypass on Monday?

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

Wheel in Frankie Fahey.

Comment on this

Several billion euro have been invested in Dublin over the last few years. Anyone who says this Government has not been committed to proper investment in Dublin simply does not know what he or she is talking about. I am surprised that Fine Gael Deputies in particular have not done their homework. Anybody who knows anything about spatial planning realises that Ireland has the highest concentration of population in its capital of any country in Europe, except Luxembourg. These are some of the percentages: Belgium – Brussels 9.5%; Germany – Berlin 4.1%; Italy – Rome 4.3%; France – Paris 16.2%; Portugal – Lisbon 18.7%; Finland – Helsinki 10.8%; and Ireland – Dublin 28.7%. That is completely unsustainable from a planning point of view.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy check the populations of these countries?

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Durkan will have an opportunity to contribute to the debate.

Comment on this

If people took the trouble to read the statistics published by the Central Statistics Office, they would understand that the population of Dublin is due to increase by 60%. Fine Gael is now in favour of a 60% increase in house prices. Fine Gael is in favour of 60% more traffic congestion in our city. It is a sad day for Ireland when the major Opposition party cannot do its research and comes out against a rational plan for decongesting Dublin and supporting balanced economic development throughout the country.

I am not surprised because I took the trouble to read the speeches of Deputy Richard Bruton and Deputy Burton on the previous budget. If anyone takes the trouble to read the speeches from last year, they will see that both of them criticised two aspects on which they were entirely silent following this year's budget. Deputy Bruton criticised the special savings incentive account scheme and the pension schemes. He stated:

How can the Minister for Finance ask the lowest paid in our community to accept that there will be no increase in their tax credits . . . while at the same time he is going to protect those who can afford to save in these schemes? Where is the justice or equity in that?

There was no reference this year to the SSIA scheme. He went on to criticise the national pension reserve fund as follows:

It is not justice or equity that is inspiring this but pride and ego. That is where this Government has gone so badly wrong. There is €1,300 million being stashed in the Minister for Finance's great pension fund. I agree with the principle of the pension fund. I am glad it was put in place. I do not agree, however, that at a time of serious bottlenecks in our infrastructure we should be using €1,300 million of taxpayer's money, most of it borrowed this year, in order to invest in the stock exchanges of New York and Japan.

The fact is that the stock exchanges of New York and Japan will deliver large increases to the capital value of the national pension reserve fund for the next few years. The stock markets are recovering and the value of that pension fund will increase significantly over the next few years.

Last year Deputy Burton also criticised the SSIA and the pension fund by stating:

He cuts investment and insists on shovelling money into a pension fund, which will not be invested in the country's infrastructure and which is losing money hand over fist on international stock markets.

In her speech this year there was no reference to the national pension reserve fund because she knows that the value of the pension fund will increase enormously over the next few years. She is embarrassed by what she said one year ago. I predict the fund will grow by 10%, 20% or even 30% over the next few years, while at the same time the Government has kept its promise of investing in this country. It is investing €5.5 billion a year in capital expenditure, which is a record across the EU.

I do not understand the Opposition's position in this regard. Does it oppose benchmarking and decentralisation? If so, what exactly does it support? I was dismayed by the speeches made by Deputy Richard Bruton and Deputy Burton. They had nothing positive to say. There were no words of congratulations for the Minister for Finance who in recent years has steadily brought us down to one of the lowest tax economies in Europe, which is essential. Ireland will be competing against the ten new countries joining the European Union. These ten countries, which have very low cost bases and many of which have very low tax bases, will compete with us job for job. If we do not have a low tax base, we will haemorrhage jobs to eastern Europe.

That is not to suggest that there is room for complacency. We must reduce our cost base. I do not understand the logic in the Opposition's point of view.

Comment on this

I wish to share my time with Deputy Connaughton. Last Wednesday when sitting here listening to the Minister, Deputy McCreevy, deliver his budget, I wondered when he would get to its main point. The Fine Gael spokesperson for rural development is sitting beside me and will speak for himself. Fine Gael is certainly in favour of decentralisation.

Comment on this

That is not what Deputy Gay Mitchell said.

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Enright, without interruption.

Comment on this

Perhaps Deputy Mitchell is representing his constituency. Deputy Mulcahy appears to want to represent everyone's constituency except his own, which is his choice.

Comment on this

What is the party policy?

Comment on this

It is something which will be reflected in time. I welcome decentralisation. However, I would like to clarify a few issues. I assume the Government's cap on employment in the public service still stands, which should be clarified for people. Laoighis-Offaly is getting 965 jobs, which I welcome, as I am sure do my constituency colleagues. However, we are not getting new jobs in the sense of replacement industry for the jobs lost. It is great for the people of Birr, Portarlington, Portlaoise, Edenderry and Tullamore that public servants will come to live in the constituency. It will benefit the towns and provide more business for shops, restaurants, etc. but it will not replace the jobs that have been lost. It will not replace the 400 jobs lost in Leoni in Birr, the hundreds of jobs lost in Flextronics and Daiber in Tullamore or the jobs lost in Powerscreen in Kilbeggan.

Comment on this

Hundreds of foreign workers are employed in Offaly.

Comment on this

The Minister of State should realise that there is a great deal of unemployment in Offaly. Birr is one of just three towns in the country which has had consistently increasing live register figures for the past five or six years.

Comment on this

That is—

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Enright, without interruption.

Comment on this

It is an important point to realise. While I welcome the benefits of decentralisation, it will not replace the jobs lost. The Government is not off the hook because of this announcement. It must be accepted that we still need replacement industries for those lost. I accept it is a nice position for the Government, but the reality is clear for the people who will not benefit from this measure in the sense that it will not create employment for them. The announcement on Wednesday was not relevant to the budget. It was a smokescreen to deflect from the proposals in the budget, a bit like the smokescreen of the smoking ban to divert attention from the conditions in many of our hospitals.

I would like to refer to the budget from an education perspective. These are some of the real issues we must accept. The Estimates announced last month indicated there would not be good news in the budget for education, which was confirmed last Wednesday. The Ministers for Finance and Education and Science have tried hard to create a myth that the budget will work for education. It will become clear that this is not the case because 2004 will produce real cutbacks. This is at a time when education services have already been cut back. If one examines the amount of money being spent on pay increases in the education sector, on the allocation to the institutional redress and child abuse boards and the demand-led schemes, current spending in the Department of Education and Science will have been reduced by €20 million for next year. I do not think there is any way of dressing that up and making it look better than it is. This will have a direct knock-on effect for everyone relying on the education system.

On Wednesday, the Minister announced an additional allocation of €30 million for the schools building programme. Given the appalling conditions in so many primary and post-primary schools, I welcome the allocation. However, it should be put in context and we should not clap ourselves on the back too quickly. Last year the Minister for Education and Science underspent on his capital allocation by more than €60 million. This was at a time when schools were crying out for grants for refurbishments and building extensions. There is no explanation why the money was not spent.

When attending the Committee on Education and Science yesterday, the Minister for Education and Science said that the money was or will be spent somewhere in his Department. That is not good enough. We are entitled to know why the money was not spent on the capital projects on which it should have been spent. Given the number of schools seeking building extensions, refurbishment and proper access for people with disabilities, I do not understand how the Minister could fail to spend €60 million.

More than 400 schools are on the school building programme, many of which have planning permission for their projects which are ready to proceed to tender, yet the Minister did not spend the money. There is no decent explanation for this. I do not believe that he can transfer willy-nilly €60 million to some other section, as he pretends. We need an explanation as to where exactly is that €60 million.

Science facilities in many of our post-primary schools are sub-standard or non-existent. We have witnessed the difficulties faced by the Minister for Education and Science when he tried to introduce a new junior certificate science syllabus. We are told that only 12 of our post-primary schools have no science facilities. The reality is far different. I have seen schools that are considered to have science laboratories but they are so antiquated that they cannot be used. I was in one school where it is hoped the Health and Safety Authority will not come knocking on its door because, if it did, its science laboratory would be closed immediately because of its dangerous state. Yet that is considered to be a laboratory. I do not understand how the Minister can justify that. Given that the Minister for Education and Science knew there would be opposition to introducing the new junior certificate science syllabus because of the existing poor facilities, I do not understand how he can leave €60 million unspent from capital programme. The Minister said it was €30 million in the budget and €23 million in the Estimates, which amounts to €53 million. Even if he is recycling the money, as it seems he is, that still leaves an extra €7 million unaccounted for by the Minister.

This budget will cause severe hardship for children and their families, particularly those waiting for psychological assessments. These assessments are critical. They provide valuable assistance to parents and teachers in discovering the best way to teach a child who may have a specific learning requirement. The appropriate intervention, at an appropriate time and as early as possible, can have a positive effect on children for the rest of their education and for their lives. If children are assessed prior to the age of six or seven they can participate fully in the education system with fewer special requirements in the long-term.

The provision for the National Educational Psychological Service in the Estimates has effectively been cut. We have seen an increase of 1% in the allocation to the National Education Psychological Service. This will not meet the existing demands of NEPS, not to mention expanding and rolling out the scheme. As well as its current workload, the Education for Persons with Disabilities Bill which is being debated places huge demands on the National Educational Psychological Service. It envisages a far greater roll-out into the education system and more NEPS staff will be required to do what is required under the Bill. We are proposing to pass legislation when we are cutting the funding from the agency that is supposed to provide this service. It does not make any sense. I do not believe NEPS will be able to meet the challenge.

Even in parts of the country where the highest number of its psychologists are deployed, more than one school in ten is not covered by NEPS. The figures for the mid-west, north-west and the midlands are truly appalling. In the mid-west region 71% of schools are not covered, in the north-west region 57% of schools are not covered and in the midlands region 44% of schools are not covered. The figures for other parts of the country are similarly worrying.

In his recent report, the Comptroller and Auditor General revealed that since 2002 the Department has spent more than €2 million funding private psychological assessments because its own service has not been rolled out as efficiently and comprehensively as it should have been. In the absence of the NEPS in one's locality, it is right and proper that children are allowed get a private assessment but it does not make sense to continue to do it in this way. If the service was rolled out properly and the money put into a fully fledged national service there would no need to spend this amount on private assessments. Unfortunately neither the NEPS system nor the provision of private assessments reach all the children in need of these service. This is deeply worrying. In recent months a number of families in my constituency have spent €1,200 each to have their children assessed because of the inadequacy of the service provided by the Department of Education and Science. Many of these families have borrowed to meet this expense. For children waiting for an assessment from NEPS the message from the budget is clear, "Hold on and keep waiting and we might get around to you in a year or two".

I wish also to focus specifically on the National Educational Welfare Board. A year and a half after its establishment the board is nowhere near to meeting its targets for the recruitment of education and welfare officers. As with NEPS, huge parts of the country have no access to the National Educational Welfare Board. The announcement earlier in the week of an expansion of the service is still seriously short of what is required. The number of education and welfare officers employed to date is far short of the target sought by the National Educational Welfare Board. The lack of funding provided by the Government has created this situation.

Prior to the establishment of the board, schools could report any prolonged student absences to the Garda Síochána but since last year the Garda has no statutory entitlement to any function in this area. This is a shift in emphasis which I welcome. It was not appropriate for the Garda to be involved but there was no other system in place at the time. It is away from prosecution from forcing children into schools and is a more holistic approach looking at the reasons behind a child's absence from school. The chronic shortfall in officers means the Government has not provided any alternative form of assistance to schools with these problems. The Garda Síochána is not entitled to be involved, yet the officers of the National Educational Welfare Board are not in place.

It is unacceptable, despite the Minister's attempt to create the impression of a huge improvement, that some counties, including Laois and Offaly which I represent, are left without any dedicated welfare officer. Some 73 are employed throughout the country. yet those two counties do not have one between them, not to mention one each. The increase of 1% for the National Educational Welfare Board in the Estimates will not even be in line with inflation. The board wanted to recruit its officers in three phases to roll out a nationwide service. However, the allocation to the board in the Estimates will not allow it complete the first phase. The Minister is deliberately ignoring the fact that the National Educational Welfare Board has a statutory duty to carry out specific functions, a duty it cannot fulfil without the proper provision of funding by the Minister.

All the long-term positives for individuals and society that arise from tackling early school leaving and drop-out rates are being ignored by a Government that cannot see a bigger picture. I fully accept the Minister's point that we do not need or want a duplication of services. That is a waste of money. I do not believe the National Educational Welfare Board is trying to duplicate its services. At present it is barely able to react in basic way and in some places it is not reacting at all. Its function is not just to be reactive but to offer positive answers and ways of addressing drop-out rates rather than the heavy-handed forcing of people into a school situation.

The budget is a sharp blow also to the third level sector. Our universities and third level colleges have been through a period of uncertainty and confusion. Last year the planned release of vital investment to build and equip laboratories and scientific research facilities was put on hold, even though it was a stated objective of the Government to ensure Ireland developed a world class research capability. I welcome the fact that this hold has been removed. We have to plan for this sector in a more definite way. Research and attracting researchers from abroad cannot work if we put it on a stop-go. They have to know that if they come to Ireland they will be able to continue to carry out their research here.

This year, it was the turn of capital programmes in the universities and institutes of technology to suffer savage cutbacks. There was a reduction of 47% in building grants and capital costs at the institutes of technology, and a 45% reduction in the same area for universities. How does this square with the commitment in the Fianna Fáil-Progressive Democrats programme for Government to support advanced research in the physical renewal of third level campuses? It is not good enough to say it cannot continue to apply for new buildings and expect them to be funded. It is only a year and a half since the programme for Government was drawn up. Our campuses have not changed or improved dramatically since that time. Did the Government believe what it negotiated then? Why include something in a programme for Government if there is no intention of doing anything about it? It appears to me that it was nothing more than a token nod to our universities and institutes of technology. Rather than a real attempt by Government to foster and assist in the development of a dynamic, forward looking education sector with well-developed research facilities, capable of attracting people from all over the world, we have taken out the scissors and cut.

Already we are hearing about university libraries closing earlier. One college is taking an extended Christmas break to save on heating and lighting bills. That is not acceptable. If this is what the budget means for the third level sector we have to be worried about the long-term damage this may do to third level education in Ireland, the third level facilities being curtailed, the consequences for the students of today and tomorrow and Ireland's reputation as a knowledge-based economy. After the last general election third level students had to cope with a 69% increase in college registration fees. Those fees have increased again by €80 to €750 per annum. The idea of free education is one that does not hold much sway on the other side of the House.

I wish to refer to the effect of the budget on those involved in youth work nationally. I met representatives of the National Youth Council on Wednesday evening who were a very disappointed group. The importance of youth work programmes and other similar initiatives in the non-formal education sector has been overlooked by the Department of Education and Science. Youth work will receive very small increases in funding in 2004, far less than the organisations involved hoped for. The National Youth Council said the budget bypasses young people and raises serious questions about the Government's commitment to them. The Government has failed to recognise the benefits that derive from youth work programmes. The Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform would not require so much money for his budget if more was given to the Department of Education and Science.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

Were it not for decentralisation, this would have been a non-budget. There was nothing to talk about. All the ills that existed previously still exist.

I spent a lifetime seeking decentralisation of Departments and other facilities. As far as this change goes, I welcome it. There is no reason Departments will not work in these areas. There might be some difficulties at policy level but they can be overcome. We are led to believe that the thousands of people who would like to live and work in their own areas will be facilitated.

I do not know, however, which Minister will be handling the programme. The Minister of State at the Department of Finance takes up the front page of half of the national daily newspapers to congratulate himself and I do not know what the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government is at now. There seems to have been a change of policy because the decentralisation of jobs will be arranged in an extraordinarily uneven manner. When speaking on the national spatial strategy, the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government gave us a lesson on sustainability. We were told that unless there were sustainable hubs and gateways, the focus for future development would be lost. He said that we need a counterbalance to Dublin and that unless the centres are sustainable economically and socially, Dublin's problems will continue to get worse.

For four years the Minister for Finance would announce from the side of his mouth at various elections that there would be decentralisation. One year followed another but all of a sudden we get the message for 2004. The fact that 11 June is the date for European and local elections never crossed the Minister's mind.

Comment on this

The Deputy's colleague was complaining last week in the local newspapers that decentralisation had been put on the long finger.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

When the Minister of State goes around the doors canvassing in June, the people will have plenty of questions for him.

Comment on this

I am looking forward to it.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

They will tell him that they will wait in judgment on decentralisation because many of them will not see it for five years, not even until after the next general election. They will have questions to ask of the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform as well.

Comment on this

He never leaves Dublin.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

They will ask where the 2,000 gardaí went and why schools that were promised were not built. The Minister of State should make sure he has answers because those promises require finance and hard decisions that he cannot make.

Many people in Dublin seem to think Lucan is in County Mayo, that is the culture. Between Fianna Fáil, the Progressive Democrats and the Minister for Finance, Departments will move out of Dublin but not too far to the west. Knock got a Department and I support that. The Minister for Arts, Sport and Tourism managed to decentralise his Department to Killarney. Everything else will be in the midlands or closer to Dublin. The Government took this decision on a political basis and, like the Milk Rás, it went everywhere. There is nothing wrong with that for those who benefit but I am sorry the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government is not here because Tom takes responsibility for everything in the midlands.

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must refer to Ministers as "Minister".

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

I apologise, the Minister of State at the Department of Finance, Thomas Parlon, Esquire.

I will read a list similar to the one Deputy Mulcahy read to give the House an idea of where the decentralised jobs went. At the top of the list, County Cork came out with 930 jobs. Well done to Cork.

Comment on this

It is the largest county.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

The next largest county is Galway but it came 21st on the list in terms of the number of jobs decentralised.

Comment on this

We would have given more but Deputy Gay Mitchell objected.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

County Kildare comes next. It received 750 jobs. That is a long way from Dublin, a significant decentralisation. County Laois got 510 jobs, County Clare got 450, County Meath got 370, County Tipperary got 480, County Waterford got 500 and County Wexford got 540. East County Galway got 150 jobs. Ballinasloe got 110. Why do I mention Ballinasloe? I do so because the leader of the Progressive Democrats is from just outside the town and she spent the last ten years telling the people there that she will solve their problems. No other town in Ireland has been ravaged by unemployment like Ballinasloe. We lost 1,100 jobs in five years and we got 110 decentralised jobs out of 10,000.

Comment on this

How many people work in Portiuncula Hospital?

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

How many work in the mental hospital that is almost closed? How many work in AT Cross? How many work in Dubarry on a three-day week? Every single one was cleared out.

Comment on this

They can get good jobs in Galway city.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

That is the Minister of State's answer, send them 50 miles to Galway city.

Comment on this

They will be working in their own county.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

The Minister of State must want to do on a local basis what he did in the national newspapers this morning. His comments will appear on the front pages of the Galway newspapers tomorrow –"Send them to Galway, says Tom Parlon". Send them anywhere, that is his answer.

What is the Minister of State, Deputy Treacy, doing? Is anyone listening to him? What about the Minister for Community, Rural and Gaeltacht Affairs? What about the Minister of State at the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment? County Galway got next to nothing. Why would it, when we consider the antics on the plinth last week? Clifden got a few jobs and Na Forbacha got five or six.

Comment on this

Are those towns not in County Galway? How many Galways are there?

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

Those are the figures, the county is 21st on the list. There is a turf war going on in west Galway but it is having a huge effect on the lives of everyone in the county. The Minister of State, Deputy Fahey, appeared on the plinth to argue for the community employment schemes, something we would all back because the ethos of the Government is far removed from the people who work in the schemes and from the communities that use their services. On the other hand, the Minister for Community, Rural and Gaeltacht Affairs, Deputy Éamon Ó Cuív, in the same constituency would have to do something to help Deputy Fahey. In one day we heard about the savage cuts in the CE scheme and a new scheme born, namely, the social employment scheme for farmers who are on farm assist.

Comment on this

It is all a scheme.

Comment on this

It is a scam.

Comment on this

A scam, yes.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

Are we not speaking about the same people? One who would qualify for a CE scheme is also likely to qualify for Deputy Ó Cuív's scheme. The Government cut the CE scheme savagely four years ago. Deputy Parlon, Minister of State at the Department of Finance, should understand this because his Minister capped it so one could not work more than three successive years on a FÁS scheme. That is when the damage was done, not today or in the last election or the last budget. The Progressive Democrats are trying to run the schemes down and they are extremely good at it. When their candidates call to the houses in advance of the elections next June the people in every halfparish, parish and county will ask them, "Why did you not give us an opportunity to work for the community?"

Comment on this

I am looking forward to next June. I can hold my head high.

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Allow Deputy Connaughton speak without interruption.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

The Progressive Democrats might not have many councillors by the time they are finished. They have few enough now and they will have very few then.

Comment on this

It is easy to talk.

Comment on this

There might be potential for the leadership there.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

I hope people will understand what happened in this House on budget day and last week concerning the community employment scheme. The Government had no intention of doing anything about it and has none for the future. It is as well for it to be realistic and honest, and say so.

I heard much talk about the benefits of decentralisation and I agree with the policy. How is it that under the national development plan last year, the spending on roads in and out of Dublin was 50% more than was programmed for, while 47% less was spent in the BMW area? That is a fact. What type of Government can oversee that sort of spending? If it will not change its ethos and approach on planning for the future of the regions it should at least ring-fence whatever sum it decides to spend in a particular way in a region. The Government did not do so. Its behaviour on the roads projects in the BMW region is a scandal. The Minister for Transport tried to tell me last week that somehow much of the money spent on Heuston Station in Dublin, of which we all approve, was good for the BMW region. It is difficult to understand how that could be.

Comment on this

There is no point in having a train from Galway if there is no station to take it.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

If that is the case what is spent in Brussels is good for us.

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has one minute left.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

I am sorry I do not have 21 minutes.

Comment on this

We are disappointed too.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

I know.

Comment on this

There is a lot more to be said.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

Why is the Government trying to put the boot into every young person trying to build or buy a house? What does it have against young people? What has it decided to do over two years?

Comment on this

That is a good question.

Comment on this

The people who made the country.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

That is right, the people who made it and will make it and they will be lying in the long grass for Progressive Democrats candidates when they appear. The first-time buyer's grant is gone, now the development contributions in several counties amount to between €5,000 and €12,000. That, added to the increase in house prices since last year, obliges more young people to pay at least €15,000 or €16,000 extra because of the Government's actions.

Comment on this

It is €90,00 in taxes.

Comment on this

There will be 60,000 houses built.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

At what cost?

Comment on this

Built for the landlords.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

The well-heeled members of the Progressive Democrats might be able to pay for them but the ordinary people cannot do so. If the only thing the Government has to offer next June is decentralisation there will be few Progressive Democrats councillors re-elected.

Comment on this

There will be 60,000 houses.

Comment on this

They should tell people with no homes that there will be 60,000 houses.

Comment on this
Michael McDowell Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform (Mr. McDowell) Progressive Democrats

With the Ceann Comhairle's permission, I intend to share time with Deputies Parlon and Jacob.

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister will share time with Deputies Parlon and Jacob.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

I am surprised. I did not think Deputy Parlon had that much to say.

Comment on this

It is a pleasure to be here this morning in the wake of a very successful budget. The ritual hand-wringing and loud breast-beating from the Opposition has been more than usually empty and vacuous on this occasion.

Comment on this

So was the budget. The Minister is the specialist in that area.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

We will hear a sermon now.

Comment on this

On taxation particularly, the Opposition seems to speak from a position of abject political and moral bankruptcy. Far from occupying the moral high ground it is lying in wait on the moral equivalent of the grassy knoll.

Comment on this

That is a habitat well-known to the Minister.

Comment on this

It has always believed in high tax, high spend and high unemployment policies, and still does.

Comment on this

The Minister should not leave out value for money.

Comment on this

We need to pinch ourselves sometimes to ensure that its published statements are not part of some political hallucination or nightmare.

Comment on this

Like climbing a pole.

Comment on this

In the last seven years Ireland has undergone an unprecedented revolution in taxation and employment creation. Hundreds of thousands of people have found employment in a dynamic fast-growing economy that has weathered the storm of international recession. Far from being a society of mass unemployment and emigration, ours has become a society of low unemployment and substantial immigration.

Comment on this

They want to go again.

Comment on this

While the tax strategy is not the only ingredient in the recipe for economic success, it is one of its most important components. Each part of the strategy, which has underpinned the dramatic change for the better in terms of substantive social justice, has been opposed, derided and fought tooth and nail by the erstwhile rainbow coalition and by most of the hard left, including some members of the Technical Group, Sinn Féin and the Green Party. The Opposition parties have all opposed and voted against every step in the reduction of income tax to 20% and 42% which contrasts with the regime of 35% and up to 68% when they were in office during periods of mass unemployment and emigration.

Comment on this

There were different standards.

Comment on this

They have all opposed the halving of capital gains tax from 40% to 20% even though the yield rose by 500%.

Comment on this

We opposed its abolition.

Comment on this

I do not know why they want to do that. Do they want to reduce the yield to its former levels? Are they so ideologically driven that they are blind to the consequences for the Exchequer?

Comment on this

What does the Minister call development charges? They amount to €13,000 for a house in Laois.

Comment on this

They are stealth taxes.

Comment on this

Yes, stealth taxes.

Comment on this

Some but not all of the Opposition parties – I excuse the Labour Party on this point – are opposed to the 12.5% corporation tax. The Green Party and Sinn Féin are strongly opposed to that. They do not want foreign direct investment on the scale we have had in the past. All of the left-wing Deputies have advocated raising our tax levels to the European norm which would decimate our employment and investment levels. The leader of the Labour Party, Deputy Rabbitte, has also revived the Labour Party's proposal for a wealth tax on property. Neither the media nor his potential allies in the Fine Gael Party have asked him what exactly he is talking about.

Comment on this

Coalition allies.

Comment on this

Tell that to the people who have to pay development charges. They are a penalty tax on houses.

Comment on this

They are a penalty.

Comment on this

The Government is making sure that those who do not have houses will never have them.

Comment on this

The Minister should wake up.

Comment on this

The Labour Party is on record in this House as stating it will reintroduce a wealth tax on property. It is time someone asked it what form this tax will take.

Comment on this

The Minister put a wealth tax on the homeless. Was that the policy of the Progressive Democrats?

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister, without interruption.

Comment on this

I am interested to note that Deputy Durkan in his excited interventions is still not coming off the fence as to whether he will support the Labour Party's demands for a wealth tax.

Comment on this

That would go down well in Kildare.

Comment on this

The Minister would know all about the wealth. He has been there long enough.

Comment on this

The Green Party and Sinn Féin Members called last week for the raising of the top rate of tax from 42% to 50%. All this shows is that the real choice is between a successful economic policy which has been adopted in the face of an Opposition which is in effect a shattered mosaic of ideological misfits—

Comment on this

The Minister is describing his own condition.

Comment on this

—and a disastrous high tax, high spend, high unemployment strategy based on a willingness to revert to the failed policies of the past which beggared and stunted this country in the pursuit of ideology and office.

We should remind ourselves of a few little items which appear in the budget tables. People are inclined to ignore the contents of the budget tables because the news is too good.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

In 1997 a single worker earning €12,000 had 18% of his or her earnings confiscated in rainbow coalition income tax.

Comment on this

The year 1997 was in a different century.

Comment on this

This young man, Deputy English, was not born then.

Comment on this

The Deputies should listen.

Comment on this

This is not comparing like with like.

Comment on this

In 2003 such earnings attract no income tax at all. In 1997 a single worker earning €25,000 had 33% of his or her earnings confiscated in rainbow coalition income tax. In 2003, such earnings attract tax at the rate of 14.7%. In 1997 a couple with two children and one income of €20,000 paid 20.7% of their income in rainbow coalition tax.

Comment on this

People could buy a house.

Comment on this

That couple now pay 4.7% of their income in tax.

Comment on this

Some of the people who were paying those low rates now pay the high rates.

Comment on this

In 1997 a couple with two children and two incomes totalling €30,000 paid 22% of that total in rainbow coalition income tax. That couple now pay 6%.

Comment on this

A couple today cannot afford two children.

Comment on this

They had lives in 1997.

Comment on this

The Deputy ignores the major revolution in child benefit since 1997.

Comment on this

They can no longer afford to have children. They are not having children.

Comment on this

It is interesting to compare the equity in our tax system then and now. In the tax year 1997 the percentage of income tax which came from those earning incomes below the average industrial wage was 14%.

Comment on this

Child benefit is only 21 cent per day.

Comment on this

This year, 6% of income tax will come from those earning below the average industrial wage. I lay those facts before the House. This year's figures show real tax equity.

There is no greater agent of social justice or poverty fighter than a job. The Government has put another 400,000 people into the workplace.

Comment on this

That is the continuation of the book. The Minister should move to the economy proper.

Comment on this

We have moved from a society of mass unemployment to one where there is constant growth in employment. This coming year, in difficult international circumstances, 23,000 extra jobs will be created in this country. This is the achievement of a Government which has always understood one thing: there is no social justice without participating in the economic life of the country and that it is the failed policies of the left and the hard left in Ireland which led us to the situation of human set-aside.

Comment on this

That is what we have now. We have human set-aside.

Comment on this

Entire communities had 80% of their households without a bread winner. Some houses had third generation unemployment. These policies will never be revisited in Ireland.

Comment on this

The Deputies on the benches opposite will have no say in it.

Comment on this

The differences that have come about are substantial. The minimum wage has been introduced by the Government which will increased it by 10% next year.

Comment on this

Those people will lose their medical cards.

Comment on this

Those who were previously exploited by people who pretended to be socialist in office are now protected from being exploited at the lower end of the earnings ladder.

Comment on this

They are not on the ladder. Under this Government they have fallen off.

Comment on this

I understand fully why a speech of this nature is bound to evoke mere bluster and noise and hot air from people who, when confronted with the truth, can only shout and roar about it.

Comment on this

The speech is bluster. The Minister protests too much.

Comment on this

I made a speech on my first day in the House in reply to the budget presented by the then Minister for Finance, Ray MacSharry, in 1987. Having little or no time to prepare it, I listened carefully to what Mr. MacSharry said, and realised that a sea change had taken place in politics and that employment was now taking centre stage. I praised the then Minister for that. I said that, as long as I was in the House – although my presence here has been interrupted by the odd brush with democracy—

Comment on this

I wonder why.

Comment on this

—I said I would focus on one aspect.

Comment on this

The Minister would not get much praise from the Deputies opposite.

Comment on this

I would focus on what is the cornerstone of social justice, namely, the question of whether budgets were pro-jobs or anti-jobs.

Comment on this

What was the name of that book?

Comment on this

It is that philosophy which has transformed this country and has led to the huge sense of hope and confidence in Ireland.

Comment on this

There is hopelessness.

Comment on this

I am proud that this budget has focused on the weaker elements of society and that €600 million extra has been allocated to social welfare.

Comment on this

A large part of the population has been ignored and continues to be ignored.

Comment on this

I am proud that the tax burden on the lowest paid in society has been reduced and that the result will be that, this time next year when the Government produces the next budget, growth in employment and tax equity will have been consolidated.

Comment on this

The Minister should explain that to the homeless people.

Comment on this

I strongly support the budget.

Comment on this

What about the homeless?

Comment on this

In response to that, 60,000 houses have been built this year.

Comment on this

That is a joke.

Comment on this

They were built for the financial institutions. They were built for landlords. If they are allowed continue like that there will be no houses for people.

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Allow the Minister to speak.

Comment on this
Tom Parlon Minister of State at the Department of Finance (Mr. Parlon) Progressive Democrats

Last Wednesday, the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, presented the seventh budget for the Fianna Fáil-Progressive Democrats Government. The budget implements our strategy for economic and social progress in every county, especially the 25 outside Dublin. Despite Deputy Connaughton's concerns, every county was accommodated.

The budget has four key objectives: to encourage employment and growth in every region by means of decentralisation, to target tax reform and social support for people on lower incomes, to continue to manage our public finances well and to secure competitiveness by controlling inflation.

This is a strategic budget, one which will begin to transform the regions. It will be known for many years as the decentralisation budget. It follows the publication of the Government's national spatial strategy last year. It also follows a clear pledge given by the Tánaiste in April last year at the annual conference of the Progressive Democrats in Galway that this would be the year of action on decentralisation.

Comment on this

It is talk, not action.

Comment on this

As the Tánaiste said yesterday, politics is about getting things done. The budget proves it. It will happen.

Comment on this

Let us look at what has happened. The Minister of State should stop exaggerating. It is talk, not action. It is a lie.

Comment on this

Deputy Enright said last week that decentralisation had again been long-fingered by the Government.

Comment on this

That was the response I received to a parliamentary question from the Minister of Finance.

Comment on this

I will be delighted to see Deputy Enright correcting her statement in the local media next week.

Comment on this

I welcome it. It was certainly well-delivered.

Comment on this

It is a budget which delivers fairness in a new way, not alone in tax reform and social welfare but in where and how Government spending will be distributed across the country, even in Deputy Enright's county.

The Government has decided that eight Departments and the Office of Public Works will move their headquarters outside Dublin. As many as 10,000 civil and public servants will be involved. This radical change will offer substantial benefits for the communities to which the Departments will move, for the Departments themselves and for the staff who will be involved.

The Office of Public Works will work from a new office in Trim and will co-ordinate the implementation group to oversee the process. I am pleased that Mr. Phil Flynn has agreed to chair the group. He is an experienced negotiator and his impartiality and fairness are respected by all. He is joined by a team of people with a track record at top management and I am looking forward to working with them in this programme of strategic change for Ireland. I am sure they can also count on the support of this House in getting the job done.

This radical and reforming budget is only possible because our economic and social strategy has worked for people, for jobs and for our communities. Our main economic objective is to consolidate the gains that have been made in recent years and to build on our future prosperity. The significant gains made by Ireland in recent years are due in large part to the Government's sound budget policies. The proof of these policies is in our achievements. Over the course of the past decade a thriving economic climate has been created in Ireland and we have recorded one of the best economic performances in the world. Employment is up by 50% and about 600,000 more people are at work. From 1997 to 2002 Irish GDP grew by an average of 9% compared to an average of approximately 2.5% in the EU.

The fruits of this economic success have been put to good use. Taxes have been cut and the tax system has been reformed. We have invested in public services. Our top three spending areas are social welfare, health and education, in that order. Our public finances have been put on a sound footing. We are increasing spending at a rate we can afford and manage. The general Government debt level has been more than halved from 74% of GDP in 1996 to just 33% in 2003, the second lowest in the European Union. This means public resources can be used for services and investment instead of heavy debt payments. Provision for the future has also been made with the establishment of the National Pensions Reserve Fund. This budget aims to build on these successes and strengthen the resilience of our economy.

Our economy has had to cope with a much more challenging environment over the past 18 months or so. However, we can conservatively expect GDP growth of 2% and GNP growth of 2.5%. These rates of growth are still well above the European average. The European Commission expects EU growth to average just 0.4% this year.

The economic performance of our country is excellent. It means we have a very sound basis for future social and economic development. Governments and policy makers around Europe now want to learn from Ireland and thousands of people come here for jobs and opportunity. That speaks for itself.

In recent years inflation has been a cause of concern. However, it has eased significantly this year from a high of 5.1% in February to 2.8% in October, its lowest level in four years. We now expect that it will average 3.5% this year and fall to 2.5% in 2004. This is a very positive development for all our people, including consumers, pensioners, savers and investors. Low inflation is critical for the business environment and competitiveness. This is what creates jobs and wealth and generates the resources needed to build the sort of society we want. We must continue to focus on competitiveness and value for money for our future progress. The more competitive we are the more we will benefit from the international upturn.

We are also investing in the future by putting record levels of investment in research and development. We are providing €340 million across enterprise, agriculture, health and education. We have also introduced, this year, a research and development tax credit to encourage private sector research. Our future is based on knowledge and innovation.

We expect that our economy will respond to the international recovery as it develops so that Irish growth levels will remain significantly above the European average and will return to a trend growth rate of approximately 5% by 2006 if we continue to manage our economy prudently.

The Government is committed to providing public services which are of a high quality and give value for money. Since 1997 there have been real and effective increases in public spending on social welfare, health, education and infrastructure. We will continue to provide substantial funding for these key priority areas.

We are committed to pursuing policies which improve social inclusion, protect those most in need, reduce the numbers living in poverty and raise living standards. The budget builds on our work to date and provides substantial funding for the most vulnerable in our society. The improvements announced in the budget provide total social welfare expenditure in 2004 which is €750 million higher than this year. All the social welfare rate increases in this budget are well ahead of projected inflation. The lowest social welfare rates will be increased by more than three times the rate of inflation.

Old age pensions will be increased by €10 a week. This brings the old age contributory pension to €167.30 per week and the old age non-contributory pension to €154 a week.

Comment on this

That is €1.64 per day. If those people smoke a few cigarettes they will not have much left out of it.

Comment on this

If I had my calculator I would give the Deputy the amount his Government granted, down to the last decimal point. They were so minuscule they could hardly be worked out.

Comment on this