Unemployment and economic confidence
Kenny cited record January jobless figures and falling confidence, blaming Government policy, rising costs and housing pressures; the Taoiseach attributed difficulties partly to the global downturn. They disputed broadband and employment prospects, while the Taoiseach defended capital investment in schools and other projects, training for tourism and construction, and the need to sustain productivity.
I know it is "Super Tuesday" but we have matters we must attend to in our own country. I am genuinely concerned at the leaking confidence evident now in the Irish economy. January saw the largest monthly increase in jobless figures since such records began, up 7,800 or 4.4% since December. That was the biggest monthly rise in percentage terms since 1980 and the largest increase in numerical terms ever.
Most commentators believe this comes from the slowdown in the economy, particularly the construction industry area. There were 6,400 males among the over 7,800 registered in that increase. FÁS has predicted that we can expect up to 30,000 job losses this year, a staggering amount, and it has also reported a 50% fall in the number of apprenticeships in what were known as the wet trade. This includes plumbing, painting, bricklaying and one well known to the Taoiseach, plastering.
There is anecdotal evidence about firms leaving off apprentices before they have completed training, a matter of genuine concern and hurt. Job losses are not a funny matter, nor are they limited to the house building sector. There were more redundancies notified in January from the non-construction sector of manufacturing than for construction, which speaks for itself.
As a result, almost 8,000 young people under 25 are registered on the live register. What is the Government's plan to deal with this issue? The Taoiseach and his anointed one recently stated that if we followed the macroeconomic plans of Government, all would be fine, everything is rosy in the garden and we will weather this storm. The Taoiseach does not appreciate the level of concern out there; people's lives do not lie and they can smell the change on the streets. What is the Government's plan to provide job opportunities and careers for young people in Ireland in the future?
Comment on this
We should be realistic. Deputy Kenny knows or will at least be aware that since 12 August there has been a financial market crisis throughout the entire world. That has had a knock-on effect into the last quarter in a very severe way on practically every economy of OECD countries — effectively the whole world. From a very strong position in the middle of the year, there have been ripple effects right through all sectors of international economies. It is not only in the United States, where there has been significant job losses and company closures, but throughout European communities.
It had long been predicted that we would see a slowdown in our housing market and whether it would happen in 2006, 2007 or 2008 was the only issue of debate. We had been building at a rate of between 70,000 to 88,000 houses per year, with the latter number the figure for 2006. It was not sustainable to build houses at four times the rate in the United States of America, six times the rate of the United Kingdom and approximately eight times the rate in the rest of Europe. That is not a surprise. While unprecedented numbers of houses are being built and unprecedented numbers are in employment, the figures are pulling back. House building is a labour intensive industry and I have said several times in the past few months that there has been a deterioration in labour market conditions, which was expected.
Available data show that employment in construction went well past that peak in the last quarter of last year. Employment in other sectors, however, is expected to offset the decline in construction, although in aggregate terms only a modest increase in employment is in prospect. The figure predicted at the beginning of the year was 24,000 net new jobs, equivalent to an increase of approximately 1%. For the past few years, employment has grown by approximately 3.5%. When the figures are placed side by side, one can see the difficulty.
At an aggregate level, there has been some decline in house prices over the past few years. That appears to reflect several factors, including the large increase in housing supply and the fact that a number of houses — it is debatable how many because different commentators give different figures — in the market, caused by an oversupply, have not been sold which has created a drag in the market. It will be some time before that moves through.
In other sectors, employment is still high. We are the fifth largest exporter of international services in the world. In manufacturing, we continue to be strong despite what people predicted a few years ago. We have lost some manufacturers, such as Allergen in Arklow last week, but today Zimmer, one of the top companies in the world, announced that it is coming here for the first time, with a €50 million investment. This shows an underlying confidence in the Irish market. Both companies are medical suppliers, one pulling out and going to Puerto Rico, the other coming here for the first time. We will see some results from that, depending on the product.
Other countries are putting the financial stimulus and impetus into the market that we have already put in. We have significantly increased the capital programme, with the State's investment of €8.4 billion which will help to drive the economy in many areas. That is approximately 1.5% of GDP. Other countries are considering a similar measure, as well as some of the changes we have made in tax policies for indigenous companies through the business expansion schemes and others. This is a difficult time, although over 2 million people are working and employment is increasing and we have a strong position on the purchasing index.
We do not need to knock this country as others in the financial services sector in Europe are trying to do because we are a strong competitor in the foreign direct investment market. I am not saying Deputy Kenny said that but he is aware that at least two operators in Europe have been doing this for the past few months. We must be conscious of that aspect.
Everyone is facing difficulty, and we must manage our difficulties, but this year we are talking about growth at 3%, with a low debt to GDP ratio, the ability to have a high capital programme and to continue to win significant foreign direct investment. We must manage ourselves through this position and we have already taken action. In terms of what else we need to do, we need to focus strongly on where the gains are for us. The issue is not about exports and imports; if our net exports are stronger than our imports, that adds growth. We get to that position based on productivity.
Comment on this
Sorry, a Cheann Comhairle. Productivity equals jobs which equal investment. That is why we must make sure we maintain and sustain a level of productivity that allows us to hold what we have in this difficult period and be able to move again as the cycle improves.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach should take heed when the Ceann Comhairle says he is over time. It is time for the Taoiseach to go. That is a warning from the Chair.
The difficulties in the sub-prime lending sector in the United States did not cause the problem here with house prices because the Taoiseach, his Minister for Finance and the Government have presided over soaring costs and a range of stealth taxes that have created this leaking of confidence in the economy. The Taoiseach rightly points out that we are the fifth largest exporter in the world, but our broadband rating is 33rd out of 35 countries in the developed world. There are oceans of euros available to be invested in e-commerce companies, but they will not site here because they do not have access to broadband or do not have the speeds when they do set up here.
People's lives do not lie. They can smell the change on the streets, the local chemist shop is going to close down, the price of milk has gone up 20% and post offices and Garda stations have closed down. People see more parking spaces in shopping centres, the cost of living has increased disproportionately and mortgage repayments have increased, causing many social pressures as houses are re-acquired. The Taoiseach has presided over that during a decade of an unprecedented economic opportunity to prepare for the future. While people on the street know what is happening, Governments seem to be completely out of touch. I know the Taoiseach is not responsible for what happens in the United States or Japan, but there are issues he can deal with here over which his Government should have control.
Last week, I asked the Taoiseach whether he was prepared to direct FÁS, as it in his remit to do, to change tack in terms of training and upskilling to areas where there is a shortage, be it in sustainable development, the health or caring sectors, HGV drivers, chefs and the food industry. Will he direct FÁS to shift its resources to training for situations where there is employment and there is still a skills shortage?
On account of the enormous profits made by the construction industry over the past ten years, most construction firms should, and to be fair probably will, ensure that their apprentices will be allowed to complete that apprenticeship. Will the Taoiseach see to it that happens? It would be most unfair to young people who have entered into a chosen career in training or apprenticeship to find that it has been taken away from them because of a decision by the company.
Will the Taoiseach change the priorities in the national development programme to double the number of schools provided? Last Thursday, I saw the unprecedented sight of all the Fianna Fáil chickens gathering round Mama Hanafin's goody bag for the announcement of the schools that was in all the local papers last weekend. That is not how a democracy or a Government should operate in terms of providing jobs and dealing with the people's concerns. It should double the number of schools being built and bring the skills from the construction industry into that sector, rather than have parents fighting, as they are today, in the High Court for their children's right to an education. That is disgraceful.
Although the Taoiseach is presiding over our economy while the fundamentals are still strong, confidence is leaking and the Taoiseach is not addressing that issue. How does he expect to deal with the 30,000 jobs to be lost this year, according to FÁS? The Taoiseach says they will be offset in other employments. Where will they be? Burlington, Allergen, Jacobs and Kingspan account for the loss of 1,500 jobs in a short time. How will the Taoiseach deal with that aspect? Will he give us a weekly update on how he is going to steer the economy through this crisis?
Comment on this
I have been doing that successfully for the past ten years and will continue to do so.
Comment on this
What about all the young people in negative equity?
Comment on this
This economy, carefully handled by Governments I have led, will continue to drive employment.
Comment on this
The Deputy misunderstands the effect of the sub-prime issue so there is no point in my going back into all of that area.
Comment on this
That has nothing to do with house prices escalating here, with a 50% increase in a year. That has nothing to do with sub-prime loans.
Comment on this
As for broadband, while I do not know who incorrectly informed Deputy Kenny, technology companies such as Google, Apple and Dell all continue to expand and invest——
Comment on this
I will provide the Taoiseach with the figure. Ireland is placed 33rd of 35 countries.
Comment on this
——and are moving to higher rate of advancement in Ireland with huge investment. Moreover, none is even thinking of pulling away from us because of broadband. They continue to develop their capacity within Ireland, of which we should be proud, as well as of our young qualified engineers who go through our excellent education system. In addition, they all use this country as their research and development base.
Comment on this
Fine Gael is patchy throughout Ireland
Comment on this
While the House can discuss County Cavan another day, I am discussing the Republic of Ireland and Members should keep to that.
Comment on this
These companies are increasing their investments and operate their European plants using the high quality people who work here. This is happening everywhere. Deputy Kenny may take a certain satisfaction from the international economic downturn.
Comment on this
If he had anything useful to say he would be supporting the Government's policies to increase the capital programme.
Comment on this
I have proposed three ideas to the Taoiseach that he could adopt now if he so wished.
Comment on this
Deputy Kenny asked the Government to put more money into schools. The capital programme has been increased to 6% of gross domestic product. Nowhere else in Europe is doing so.
Comment on this
The Government should build 60 schools instead of 30.
Comment on this
We have gone way beyond the figure in Europe so we can put stimulus into the economy. We will spend €600 million this year on the capital programme. Last year, 1,400 schools received investments under various school investment programmes.
Comment on this
When I took over as Taoiseach, 14 projects per year were being undertaken while the figure is 1,400 at present.
Comment on this
I can take the Taoiseach to County Wexford to show him plenty of obligations.
Comment on this
Such investment may not take place to the same extent this year.
As far as FÁS is concerned, I remind Deputy Kenny that CERT looks after the catering trade. The Government is ensuring the continuing provision of training in all those sectors in which it believes employment opportunities exist, including the tourism sector. The Government would like to see more employers give first chances to Irish people in that sector. Pay and rates are good and in a more difficult time they should consider so doing notwithstanding the fact that excellent people of other nationalities can come here.
Comment on this
However, they can give preference to our workers.
As for construction, an enormous amount of development is taking place in major capital projects in the non-residential sector. We must ensure that this can be sustained. As I noted at the outset, productivity becomes essential when international markets experience a downturn. We must ensure that in 2008 and 2009, as we have done many times previously, we get the best value for the resources we invest. We must achieve high levels of productivity with an excellent workforce that provides good flexibility. This will see us through a period during which the economy is still growing by 3%, which is greater than in most OECD countries, and will enable us to achieve stronger growth in the medium term.