We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Leaders’ Questions.

Rebecca O’Malley and Barrington’s reports

Summary

Gilmore pays tribute to Ahern and raises the HIQA reports on Rebecca O’Malley and Barrington’s Hospital. The Taoiseach confirms the Government accepts all 15 O’Malley recommendations and outlines findings of delayed cancer diagnoses in the Barrington’s review.

I join Deputy Kenny in marking the significance of the Taoiseach's statement this morning. I welcome the decision he has made. I appreciate how difficult that decision has been for him personally. As the Taoiseach said this morning, it was a decision he made in the best interests of the country, which I accept. It is a course of action I have been advocating to him for some time. In doing so I have always acknowledged the contribution he has made to the political life of this country. In particular I again acknowledge and pay tribute to the enormous personal and political effort he made to bring about a settlement in Northern Ireland. I wish him well personally. I hope he accepts that the political duty I have had to perform was done on a political basis and not on a personal basis. I believe his decision today will enable this House and politics generally to move on to put at the top of our political agenda issues that are of immediate concern to the people of this country.

I want to ask the Taoiseach about one of those issues. While all of us in this House are concerned about the future and in the main the political future generally of parties, individuals and so on, there are many men and women who are concerned about their future in a different way. I speak in particular about those people who have undergone cancer tests and are now uncertain about the results of those tests. Notwithstanding the other concerns he has had in the past few days, I am sure the Taoiseach will be aware of the reports that have been published in recent days, the report from the north-eastern region that thousands of X-rays are now being re-examined, the report into what happened with the misdiagnoses in Barringtons Hospital and the Rebecca O'Malley report, all of which add to the other reports we have had regarding misdiagnoses of cancer tests.

Does the Taoiseach agree with the comment made by Rebecca O'Malley who, when responding to the report in her case, said we really should ensure that Russian roulette is no longer played with patients' safety? Can he give some assurance to people who have either undergone a cancer test or are about to do so that the results of such tests will be accurate?

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Gilmore. Maybe in a minute I will say a few words and wrap up on my own issue.

On the Rebecca O'Malley case, to recall in June 2007 the Health Information and Quality Authority commenced an independent investigation into the care provided to Rebecca O'Malley by the HSE. As part of the investigation into the circumstances around the care of Rebecca O'Malley regarding her systematic breast disease, that investigation examined the pathology services provided by the HSE at Cork University Hospital and of course the systematic breast disease services provided by the HSE in the Mid-Western Regional Hospital. That report by HIQA was published today.

The main finding of the report, to record for the House, is that the interpretive error made by a consultant pathologist that led to the initial misdiagnosis was a single mistake of human error. However, the report notes the absence of triple assessment review in the case and the missed opportunities to correct the error. The report was also critical of the HSE in governance, management and communication of the way in which Rebecca O'Malley was informed of matters relevant to her care. Not to go into them all, the report makes 15 recommendations for the HSE, including matters relating to clinical practice and management. Obviously it is for it to make sure they are implemented. The board of the HSE has recently adopted a new interim policy and procedures on serious incident management which include learning from recent reports on the Portlaoise events and will, coupled with the implementation of the new policy on the development of centres of excellence for breast disease services, provide solutions to many of the recommendations in this report. If I can come back in a minute, I will also say a few words on the Barrington's issue which the Deputy asked me about. I will let him in first.

Comment on this

I ask the Taoiseach to expand on the report on the Barrington's Hospital case. I ask him specifically about the HIQA report on Rebecca O'Malley. As the Taoiseach said, 15 recommendations were made. Does the Government accept those 15 recommendations and can the Taoiseach assure the House they will be implemented?

Comment on this

On Rebecca O'Malley, the answer is yes, the Government accepts all 15 recommendations.

The report of the independent review of the Barrington's case was published yesterday, as the House will be aware. That report confirmed that two women who were among the original ten cases referred to HIQA had their cancer diagnoses delayed potentially causing them serious harm. The review process did not identify any other women who had a missed or delayed diagnosis. The report found that of the 285 cases reviewed, in 118 cases it was the clinical and professional judgment of the review team that the level of clinical care was not always what it considered as appropriate. That is a quote from the report.

It also concluded that "their care did not meet the standards which would have been acceptable at their time of treatment". The Minister anticipates that the Medical Council, the regulatory body for the profession, will fully examine the findings of this report. It again highlights the need for the continued implementation, in both the public and private health care sectors, of the national quality assurance standards for systematic breast disease services which were approved last year by the Health Act. The standards will clearly have implications for private facilities, some of which have already ceased providing systematic breast services. A total of 16 public sector hospitals with low case volumes have now ceased providing breast care services.

The issue of safety in the delivery of health services lies at the heart of any care system which has the confidence of the people using those services. The Minister established the Health Information and Quality Authority in May last year. The process in which the regulatory regime such as that given to HIQA will be introduced first in the public sector, which is a feature of such developments in other jurisdictions. The extension of this type of monitoring and control to the private sector is not an easy matter and is considered very complex. The Minister has referred the matter to the Commission on Patient Safety and Quality Assurance. The commission is due to report in July, with the overall objective of developing clear and practical recommendations to ensure that quality and safety for patients is paramount throughout the entire health care system. The commission has been asked by the Minister to bring forward proposals that will provide for the licensing of all health care facilities, including private hospitals such as Barringtons.

A Cheann Comhairle, if I can just very briefly refer to my own statement today. I want to acknowledge what Deputy Kenny and Deputy Gilmore have said and confirm to Dáil Éireann and to my colleagues in this House that on 6 May I will, pursuant to the Constitution, place my resignation in the hands of the President. I believe it is in the best interests of the country and the Government that a new Taoiseach take charge and lead Ireland forward.

Today is not an end, in my view, it is a new beginning. It is with a sure faith in our shared future and with great hope and with no regret that I have come to that decision. I made that decision alone, with the sense of responsibility that this Republic charges all our citizens. I know that we will continue on the path of progress that marks Ireland out around the world and will surely mark this generation out in history.

Public service is a great privilege and a great honour. It is a great privilege and a great honour for everybody in this House, particularly for Members on all sides who have been office holders. It is a privilege and an honour I have enjoyed for over 30 years and been lucky to do so. I have been humbled by the responsibility and the trust that the people have placed in me. Today is not an occasion to give account of what I have done or, quite frankly, left undone. It is, rather, a fitting moment to say to Dáil Éireann and to the Irish people that I am humbled to have been entrusted for so long with so great a responsibility of leading my country. To have been chosen from my own community as a representative in this House, to have been called by successive Taoisigh to serve in government, to have been elected by the people on so many occasions and to have been elected here in this House on three occasions is an honour and responsibility beyond the capacity of any citizen to fully repay. All I want to say for myself today is that in all these years I have never ceased to try, to the utmost of my ability, to fully discharge those responsibilities to my community, the country and to this House.

The past 30 years have been times of great trials and great triumph for all of us on all benches of this House. For much of that time, the vision of a country that could one day prosper and be at peace seemed far off and almost impossible to maintain. Unemployment and emigration were harsh realities that made hope and optimism hard to sustain at times. The cloud of sectarian violence and political conflict hung over all of us and hung over the whole island. That deeply darkened our national life and brought unspeakable pain to thousands and yet, change did come, optimism did triumph and our hopes have been realised. As Deputy Kenny said, I share that work with many others, from all sides, and I acknowledge that.

Opportunity has replaced despondency, peace has replaced bloodshed and we have a new beginning. The Irish people did not surrender to the common enemy of despair. They have never ceased to believe that better times would come. Time and again they looked to politics and to politicians — the people they chose to represent them in this House and elsewhere — to give leadership in the challenge of thinking about old problems in new ways. By brilliant innovation and hard lessons alike, this country has overcome a difficult past and shaped a new beginning.

The lesson of my political lifetime is that by keeping faith with the future, we discharge our responsibility to history and to ourselves. People in politics have kept faith with one another. I acknowledge all of the contributions of the people I have worked with in this House and those I have worked with in Government from various parties. If there is any single achievement that this generation can boast of it is that it has realised the hopes bequeathed to it. We hand on confidence as our legacy and we leave tenacity as our testament. As we look forward to a new beginning in a new Ireland we have nothing to be complacent about. We have much to be confident in. This is a time of unparalleled opportunity in a country of great possibility.

Politics is never over. I acknowledge what Deputy Kenny and Deputy Gilmore have said. I totally acknowledge that they do their job here in a democratic system and in a political way. I fully appreciate that and hold no grudges or animosity towards anybody inside or outside this House, although sometimes I think there is a chamber outside this House that does not have the fairness of this establishment, but that is for another place and another day.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this