FÁS spending and accountability
Enda Kenny challenged lavish and possibly unauthorised FÁS expenditure, citing travel, credit-card and other costs. The Taoiseach acknowledged serious concerns and said the Comptroller and Auditor General, the Committee of Public Accounts and other investigations would establish the facts and accountability.
I am not going to stand up in the House and impugn the personal integrity of any person. The House has discussed on a number of occasions the capacity of appointees of the Government to do the job for which they are appointed. One of the primary considerations of this Government has been to focus on the business of wastage of money. It is now perfectly obvious that there is something radically wrong in regard to the organisation known as FÁS or Foras Áiseanna Saothair. This organisation has an expenditure of €1 billion at its disposal. Since the latest revelations, my office has been flooded with claims. I do not know whether they are valid but they are coming from most unusual sources. In light of the fact that the fraud squad is undertaking an investigation; the Comptroller and Auditor General has been ordered in by the Tánaiste or at least she has attempted to order him to conduct an investigation; and the Committee of Public Accounts is investigating various matters concerning FÁS, I wish to remind the Taoiseach of what he said in June when he stated that the chief executive of that organisation was a person he held in the highest regard and whose integrity he would defend at all times.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste said that this matter was all in the past. I would like to hear the Taoiseach's view on what has gone wrong because something is radically wrong.
The latest revelations are about some place in Florida and somebody in my office picked out some information about it for me from the Internet.
One of the more affordable vacation spots in all of Florida, there is never a lack of exciting things to do and see in and around Cocoa Beach. Besides offering the best of sun and fun while on the Space Coast, you can go deep-sea fishing or parasailing, try your luck aboard a casino cruise ship or take a fabulous eco-tour to get up close and personal with Florida's awesome wild life.
Comment on this
Does the Taoiseach consider it appropriate that a sum of $400 of Irish taxpayers' money should be spent on some person in a nail bar in west Cocoa Beach? Is this appropriate expenditure of Irish taxpayers' money when 10,000 people a month are losing their jobs? Is the identity of the person concerned known to the Taoiseach?
Comment on this
The answer to the second question is "No". The serious point to be made is about the fact that as a result of the Comptroller and Auditor General looking into public procurement issues in FÁS, the Tánaiste asked for a further investigation into the management and systems in FÁS to ensure that wrongdoing, if there is any, cannot be prevented from being disclosed.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste and Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment also asked it to examine the corporate services aspect of that operation since 2000. This process is in place and both the chairman and the chief executive officer were anxious that it would take place to get to the bottom of any issues that need to be addressed. No one is suggesting issues should not be examined or addressed. There is a question of process and ensuring we get to the bottom of it.
The Committee of Public Accounts is engaging in its own process. The Comptroller and Auditor General has been asked to follow up on a report he compiled on the organisation. That is as it should be. That is where matters stand and we need to get it resolved as quickly as possible. The Committee of Public Accounts is coming to a conclusion in respect of its investigation. That is what accountability is about.
Comment on this
What is the Taoiseach going to do about it? Up to 10,000 people a month are losing their jobs while these revelations come out week after week. To claim the process is in place and the Committee of Public Accounts will come to a conclusion displays a massively cavalier approach from the Government. Material was sent to the committee by FÁS that had entries blacked out. I understand there is an extensive range of information coming from FÁS offices, following on from freedom of information requests. In 2005, for example, the total cost for the Science Challenge week came to €886,000, €772,000 of which was spent on advertising. How is it that persons involved can have credit cards with €76,000 limits? This is incredible.
The Taoiseach is in charge of the Government. He has quite rightly spoken about cutting out wastage of public money. This, however, is a litany of extraordinary expenditures, facilities and requirements given to this organisation at a time when we need a massive drive in re-training and upskilling.
I did not catch the Taoiseach's reply on the identity, or other words, of the person at the nail bar in West Cocoa Beach, Florida. There might be an interest in this person's identity. Obviously, I do not have any indication as to who it is.
Comment on this
It was the Minister for Defence, Deputy Willie O'Dea.
Comment on this
It was the Minister for Social and Family Affairs, Deputy Mary Hanafin.
Comment on this
What is the Taoiseach's view on a €76,000 credit limit on a credit card issued to the persons involved? Will he explain beyond what the Tánaiste and Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment said was all in the past?
The situation is that the Comptroller and Auditor General, the fraud squad and the Committee of Public Accounts are examining the organisation. Various people associated with various elements of this organisation over the past several years are beginning to spill the beans at an inordinate rate. The Taoiseach is in charge. What is he going to do about it? How can he stand over this? Action is taken in other countries in cases involving the abuse and wastage of public moneys.
I am being careful not to impugn the personal integrity of any person. However, I am concerned about what appears to be extravagant wastage, abuse of privilege and failure to account for the taxpayer's money. The Taoiseach can sit over there claiming the process is in place and we will get an answer in due course. That is not good enough; it is too cavalier an approach. The Taoiseach heads up the Government, people pay their taxes and 2,500 people are going on the unemployment list every week while these stories about wild extravagance on West Cocoa Beach in Florida emerge.
Comment on this
They were working on their golf handicaps.
Comment on this
I am not standing over any profligate or unauthorised spending. No one can stand over that. The process that is being undertaken is being conducted by the Committee of Public Accounts. The Comptroller and Auditor General has been asked to examine all this and detail the situation so that decisions can be taken on it. Obviously, there are questions to be answered. This needs to be dealt with as urgently and expeditiously as possible.
Comment on this
There are many questions that need to be answered.
Comment on this
On Deputy Enda Kenny's point about information being brought to the Committee of Public Accounts, I understand from listening to a radio interview this morning with the committee's Vice Chairman that it was agreed between the committee's legal advisers and FÁS that certain data protection issues arose as to why certain stuff was redacted. That is a matter for legal advice.
The real issue is that the truth has to be established and accountability provided for those responsible with detailed consequences arising from that. We are in the process of doing this. It is not being ignored. It is a question of having the means by which it is dealt with comprehensively and factually in fairness to the organisation concerned and the taxpayer. That is the process that is in place. The quicker it is resolved, the better. In the first instance, it is a matter for the board of FÁS to bring forward a report on any recent controversies to the Minister.