Wildlife (Amendment) Bill 2010: Second Stage
Contributions 150–290 of 290. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 15 of 2010 ›
I am delighted to have this opportunity to contribute to this important debate. Many people are highly concerned about this Bill and are fearful for the many other rural pursuits that are practised and engaged in. This legislation is being perceived as an attack that will lead to a ban on all field sports. The organisations opposed to the Bill represent more than 300,000 people involved in country pursuits. Rural field sports are family-orientated activities that are not ageist, sexist or racist. Generations of Irish people have taken part in such healthy, outdoor and family activities. Rural sports are an important economic activity in many rural communities and provide important support to the farming and bloodstock industry. As a rural Deputy, I represent an area in which there are two hunt clubs on my doorstep, namely, the Ballymacad Hunt and the Meath Hunt. I know exactly how important both these hunts are to the local community. They have major support across a broad area. Foxhunting nationally is a major contributor to the economy in the absence of any State support.
The Government has decided that stag hunting should cease for animal welfare and public safety reasons. The purpose of the Bill is to give legislative effect to the commitment in the renewed programme for Government to ban the practice of stag hunting with a pack of hounds. I call on the Minister to conduct a full regulatory impact assessment before proceeding with this Bill and to consult further with all stakeholders. A ban on the Ward Union Hunt will remove €1.4 million in spending power annually from the north-east region. A similar ban or restriction on other field sports would reduce spending power nationally by well over €100 million.
Hunting is part of the bedrock foundation of the €1.1 billion thoroughbred racing business. Each year, 80,000 visitors come to this country to take part in or watch equestrian sports and they spend an estimated €53.9 million. Deer hunting is closely monitored by Government inspectors. It operates under the terms of a strict licensing, inspection and monitoring system imposed by the Minister.
Hunts make a vital contribution to farming by providing farmers with a fallen animal collection service on a daily basis. Dead cattle and sheep are disposed of through this service. Without it there are risks in terms of animal disease control and to animal husbandry. Farming costs will increase as a result of the ban. What alternatives will be put in place by the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food to facilitate a cost-effective fallen animal collection service and on-site post mortem facilities? The prompt and secure removal and appropriate disposal of fallen stock is essential to mitigating the potential effect such carcases might have on human, animal and environmental health. What is a farmer to do with a dead carcass on the farm? In most cases farmers wish to know what caused the death of a cow, sheep or other animal and they call their local vet to carry out a post mortem examination on the carcass. By law, this cannot be done on the farm and must be carried out only after the Enfer BSE test shows a negative result. The test is carried out at the Ward Union Hunt kennels.
I am not happy, despite the assertion of the Minister, Deputy Gormley, that the legislation will not have any implications for other country pursuits such as fox hunting, hare hunting, hare coursing, shooting, fishing, greyhound racing or deer stalking. I consider the Bill to be an assault on rural Ireland and its traditions.
Comment on this
This is not the time to elaborate, but the Bill is not an isolated attack on rural Ireland. As a rural Deputy I cannot stand back and witness the destruction of traditions going back generations. There comes a time to say enough is enough——
Comment on this
I did not interrupt other speakers. This afternoon I find myself wavering along a very fine dividing line. I plead with the Minister to think again on the issue. Rural Ireland is rightly concerned and annoyed about the devastating impacts for employment in farming and for rural traditions. It is not realistic to focus on no more than three incidents that occurred out of more than 400 hunts conducted in the past ten years. That is particularly so when no account is being taken of the number of deer that are injured or killed on roads and in the Phoenix Park. Is that not a much more serious public safety issue? Banning a hunt in order to address concerns over public safety is an over-reaction.
I stress the major importance and significance of all rural pursuits and the benefits that accrue from them to rural Ireland. I plead for more time and consultation for this debate. I call on the Minister to conduct a full regulatory impact assessment and to consult further with all stakeholders. I had a different view on the Ward Union Hunt following the occurrence of certain incidents, especially the Kildalkey incident. Deputy Wallace outlined the visit to the kennels which led me to reassess my view. Those involved in the Ward Union kennels have put safety measures in place since that incident. Animal welfare is No. 1 on its list. I compliment the kennels on the measures that were put in place, which were explained in detail to us. Those involved showed us the hounds and the deer. The animal welfare in the kennels is first class.
In the context of cruelty to animals, will the Minister indicate what will happen to the beautiful pack of hounds that are in the Ward Union kennels?
Comment on this
Is it not cruel to put the hounds down by shooting or in whatever other way? Likewise, what will happen to the deer, of which here are 150? As Deputy Mattie McGrath said, we all have deer roaming free in our area. Will the gates be opened and those 150 deer let loose? Is it right to bring someone in to put them down? I do not think so.
I was the first person to speak on the issue at our parliamentary party meeting following the agreement of the programme for Government. I was concerned. I did not know much about the Ward Union Hunt because it is not exactly in my area. However, I know enough about fox hunting and the Ballymacad Hunt and the Meath Hunt. I follow them whenever I am at home, especially around Christmas time. I get great enjoyment from them. I got a commitment from the Taoiseach that evening that nothing else would be affected. That is why, like many of my colleagues, I agreed to the programme for Government.
I say to the Minister, Deputy Gormley, to the Taoiseach and other members of the Government, that if any of the other country pursuits such as fox hunting——
Comment on this
——hare hunting, hare coursing, shooting, fishing, greyhound racing and others are threatened, they cannot depend on my support whether this Dáil lasts two months or two years. They will not have my support if anything else is tinkered with.
Comment on this
There is a vote for the Government.
Comment on this
I will vote with the Government on Tuesday night because I have given that commitment.
Comment on this
I endorse the final statement of my colleague, Deputy Johnny Brady.
Comment on this
Deputy Byrne will be voting with the Government as well.
Comment on this
Nuair atáimid ag caint faoi bheith ag fiach nó ag seilg, táimid ag caint faoi stair agus oidhreacht na hÉireann. Ó aimsir Fionn Mac Cumhaill agus Diarmuid agus Gráinne, tá muintir na hÉireann ag seilg le haghaidh spraoi, bia agus maireachtáil. The old Irish words for hunting — "seilg" and "fiach" — are all the evidence one needs to show that this is an ancient Irish pastime. No translated words from the English, German or Latin languages are required to explain something about this country that has existed for so long. That is the most important point; that hunting must be recognised. In the United Kingdom it has become a class issue. It is not a class issue in this country and it should never be allowed to become one.
The people I represent in East Meath are by and large strongly opposed to the legislation. Farmers are opposed to it, in particular because of the services for fallen animals that the Ward Union Hunt provides and because of the enjoyment they have during the winter watching the hunt passing through their lands. The community itself enjoys the hunt and it binds them together. The racing community is opposed to the Bill because of the economic benefits attached to the hunt. There are four racecourses in County Meath in Laytown, Bellewstown, Navan and Fairyhouse. The Ward Union Hunt itself is the smallest part of the equation. It is quite a small organisation but the benefits that accrue from its activities are spread far and wide throughout the county.
The Ward Union Hunt itself would say that it has not got everything right in the past. People with a contrary view to mine have contacted me and the Minister in that regard. That must be acknowledged. However, in fairness to the Ward Union Hunt, it has made efforts to change and improve things and the improvements are noticeable.
Public safety is raised constantly. We cannot keep talking about an incident, however unfortunate, that took place four years ago in Kildalkey. We cannot keep harping on about that. An incident also occurred at Christmas. They are individual isolated incidents that occur every few years. It is unfortunate that the Minister could not be specific about another incident.
My biggest concern is that we are legislating to target one particular hunt. I question whether it is constitutional to do that. Has the Attorney General advised in that regard? Can one legislate to punish one individual or group? The legislation has similarities to the old Bills of attainder which are not constitutional. How can we as legislators target individuals, people we know? It is not right. They are doing things they and their ancestors have done for generations.
That is the way they live. My colleague and friend, Deputy Mary Wallace, referred to proportionality, which has constitutional implications. President McAleese might consider raising this Bill with the Council of State before assenting to it.
This is a very difficult issue for me. I am committed to the Government. I was elected to represent the Fianna Fáil Party in Meath-East and believe we are implementing the right economic policies to get the country back into shape. I must be committed to my constituents, who are absolutely opposed to this legislation. Why are we even spending time on it when there are so many other problems facing the people?
Comment on this
The Deputy is right about that.
Comment on this
I ask the Minister to state in his closing remarks that if this Bill is passed he will have no issues to deal with in regard to animal welfare other than the couple of very minor ones in the programme for Government. The people do not believe there are no other issues. I am trying to explain to them that this Bill is Green Party policy. I want Deputy Gormley, in his capacity as Minister, to explain that there are no other issues. Deputy Johnny Brady outlined his very stark position on this and I agreed with him. The backbenchers of Fianna Fáil certainly agree.
Confidence and reassurance need to be given, particularly to gun clubs, which seem to be of the view that they will be targeted. The confusion is not lessened by some of the Minister's colleagues who differentiate between certain types of shooting and sports activities in their statements. That the Minister make the strongest possible statement on other pursuits is essential.
This is a difficult issue and has become very political. It is right that it has become a political issue. My seat will be one of the most prized by the Opposition parties at the next general election. This must also be acknowledged.
I acknowledge the remarks of Deputy McEntee, who said this is a difficult issue for us. He will receive great praise from the people of his constituency for his fight on this issue. He has been reasonable to his Government colleagues and this favour will certainly be returned if the Deputy is in a difficult position if his party is ever in Government.
The Minister's Department is causing many problems in Meath-East over one-off housing applications. I refer to its making submissions on one-off housing applications inside and far away from the Newgrange buffer zone. This is generating great mistrust. I do not know what business the Minister's officials have making submissions on the planning applications of young couples. It is terrible that the Department spends time on this. There is no national policy interest whatsoever in this regard.
When I talk to the people of my constituency, it is not just the issues of the Ward Union Hunt that arise. The Minister must understand that. People ask why he objected to their planning permission applications and makes submissions thereon. The Department is doing so in his name. I ask that it cease doing so because it cannot be legal.
I have always complimented the Minister on his progressive action on zoning and local area plans and I fully endorse and support what he is doing this week through the planning investigations. I come from an area where this activity could not but be supported because of the damage done through bad zoning. However, my problem is with the response to one-off planning applications whose acceptance would keep a community together and give young people a chance to build their own home at a lower cost. If accepted, the couples would not have to go on the council's list or live in certain areas where the facilities are not as good. They would have the opportunity to live in their own communities. The Minister is making it difficult for himself, the Government and me as a Member. I ask the Department to stop making submissions on the applications to which I refer.
This legislation is not right and the Oireachtas should not be targeting individual organisations or groups. I welcome the provision that the Minister is including in the legislation that regularises licensing for shooting game and wildlife. That may give some reassurance to the gun clubs although many of the constituents I spoke to on it today were not convinced.
I ask the Minister to confirm in his closing remarks that there is nothing else he wants to target. He has made such a statement time and again but we badly need to hear one once more.
Comment on this
I am very angry about this issue. I do not have the experience of the Ward Union Hunt that Deputies Johnny Brady, Mary Wallace and Thomas Byrne have. They spoke from the heart about it, specifically on the hunt. I want to follow up on Deputy Byrne's remarks. People believe the Minister is against the Irish countryside. He has his idea of the countryside and does not mind what happens to communities, community groups, football clubs, schools, churches or any other body.
Deputy Thomas Byrne mentioned one-off housing, which is irrelevant to this Bill, but it is related to the attitude that informs it. People know the Minister and his party are trying to ensure those who want to live on the farms on which they were born and reared, or near thereto, will no longer have the opportunity to do so.
The Ward Union Hunt has a proud tradition. During the debate on this issue, I became annoyed by the efforts of some to claim the Ward Union Hunt is an old British club that has nothing to do with Ireland. It has a long association with Irish traditions, as Deputy Thomas Byrne stated. It is certainly not tied to the elements that have been suggested.
The Bill is short and one could deal with it in five minutes. Its purpose is to deal with the Ward Union Hunt and to make some changes to the fines regime. It makes some welcome changes, as has been said.
The Minister referred to the history of the Ward Union Hunt and outlined the dangers of hunting. He stated his concerns are shared by some of his predecessors. He referred to public safety issues and said it is simply not possible for hunters to prevent deer in flight from leaping through hedges onto public roads. He recalled the incident regarding one deer who entered a children's playground. It is easy to pick out one incident.
Yesterday I spoke to the Minister's colleague from County Meath, the Minister for Transport, Deputy Noel Dempsey, about the road from Derry to Dublin. It links the capital to the fourth biggest city and Donegal. We are planning to give the Northern Ireland Assembly £400 million to provide a road from Derry to Aughnacloy, yet we have no plans to construct a road from Aughnacloy to Castleshane.
Only a few months ago, a juggernaut came around the corner in Emyvale village and drove straight into a group of houses. It was a miracle that nobody was killed. One family was in Scotland for a few days for a family function and the others were not at home at the time. The houses can be seen by anybody.
Many people have been killed on the road between Monaghan and Emyvale but there is not the same urgency in the House about it as there is about this Bill. We must get our House in order and realise where we can save human lives. I am not saying we should abuse stock; I love stock, I am a farmer and have lived with stock all my life. To isolate this issue and make a big deal about it is a sham.
The Minister states hunting is dangerous to people and hard on the animals. From reports I have read, there are very different views on this. As the Minister's Fianna Fáil colleagues have said, further study needs to be done on it and a report needs to be produced before a hammer is used to crack a nut. There must be some common sense in that. While the Minister's Fianna Fáil colleagues requested such a study, unfortunately, they went on to state that they were, because of party structures, voting for this Bill regardless.
I attended two meetings organised by the hunting and shooting fraternity. I can tell the Minister that those meetings were packed. One of them was in the Westenra Arms Hotel in Monaghan town, the other was in the Lavey Inn in Cavan. These meetings were packed with people who had only an interest in a bit of sport. They were not vicious, they were not antagonistic, they were just begging for the right to carry on the traditions that their people have carried on for the past hundreds of years.
My neighbours are deeply involved in both hunting and shooting, and some of them in other hunt clubs. Those people, if they are in a hunt club, contact the people in the area in which they will hunt. They do not do it behind people's backs. They are welcome. Especially on my own farm, they are extremely welcome wherever they want to go, let it be hunting, shooting or whatever else.
While the Minister is saying today that it is only the Ward hunt club that he is interested in, they are in no doubt whatsoever, from the information they are getting from the websites and elsewhere in the Green Party, that this is the first shot at all of the different aspects of Irish culture and Irish life. When I think of all the joy that those people have got down through the years in all sorts of areas of hunting, shooting, etc., I am scared for the future of this country,——
Comment on this
——and I can tell the Minister that the majority of people are scared at present under Green government.
Only a couple of years ago, shortly after the Green Party came in, a good friend of mine who spent over €10,000 looking for planning permission on the border of County Meath, was to get the planning agreement on a Tuesday. On the Sunday night, the Minister blocked that area of rural Monaghan from getting any more planning permissions. We know exactly how the Minister operates.
We know exactly how the Minister operates on other issues. I remember getting a letter from him, through the county council, stating that he had dealt with the matter the previous January, at which time he was sitting behind me here. It was clear that he had not even read the letter that he was supposed to have signed. Those are simple facts.
We are extremely worried about where this is leading. Turf-cutting is another issue. When I think of all the people who cut their few bits of turf, the bogs are there for generations. I have been on them, I live beside them and I do not have to be told by anybody that they will not be there hundreds of years from now. We were told that there would be no more snow and no more sun, but we got both snow and sun this year. We must have some idea of what we are talking about.
This is an ongoing assault by the Minister on rural Ireland.
Comment on this
I was born in a parish where the people had to leave in the 1950s and there was hardly anyone over the age of 15 and 16 who had not gone to England, America or elsewhere. I am proud of that parish today. I was secretary of the development committee in 1963 and we brought that parish up from nothing to a living, working community. There are very few people on the dole in it. There are very few people not living in reasonable comfort, but it is no thanks to Deputy Gogarty's type of rules. I can assure him of that.
Comment on this
Have a bit of manners for a senior Deputy.
Comment on this
We had peace and quiet before Deputy Gogarty came in. Could he please listen to the person who has the floor.
Comment on this
I wish Deputy Gogarty was listening with conviction. I can tell him there is a football club there which has its own clubhouse. There is a community centre. There are churches and schools that are reasonably full.
It is all right talking but if the Minister's rules on planning go through, there will not be another house built in that area if he can possibly stop it. That is a fact. The regulations are so tight on effluent and other issues that it will not happen. All that has happened is houses have replaced other houses that were there for a previous generation. They are now nearer the public roads than they were previously, but those are the facts and I can stand over them.
Other issues the Minister raised in his speech were extremely interesting. He spoke of the need for culling of deer. He realises at this stage that the Bill, as initiated, restricted groups such as hunting groups to two dogs and that simply cannot work. He has agreed to amend that and some other issues, which I welcome.
It is impossible to understand this. I often go through the Phoenix Park where there are deer, but there is a 30 mph restriction and it is not too bad if a deer runs out in front of you because you should be able to stop. What if one is going along the road at Dartry at 80 km/h and a deer jumps out in front of one? I can tell the Minister the number of persons who were maimed and seriously injured as a result of that wood and that situation. The only way that can be controlled is, as the Minister stated here, to allow for proper structures and proper licensing. There is no guarantee if he lets three or four dogs in through that wood, as there is no fence along the road, that a deer will not come out in front of a car or someone else. This issue about one incident with the Ward hunt just does not make sense. However, I welcome the fact that that issue is dealt with.
The Minister also spoke here about the new computerised procedures for issuing gun licences. We blame Brussels all of the time for the delicate and difficult forms one must fill in. The number of people who I have had into my home and into my office regarding that gun licence over the past number of months was unbelievable. They got this nine-page form to fill in for a simple single-barrel shotgun that they have had in their house for generations and they had to get people to sign that they were of good behaviour and they had to get their photograph put on their licence. They had to get all sorts of things. When one reads of all the guns that are flying about through this city, Limerick and elsewhere, one wonders what the system is all about. We blame Brussels for all the bureaucracy when it suits us, but here was bureaucracy brought in by the Government.
Comment on this
At the end of the day, lo and behold, with all nine pages, we hear an admission by the Minister that the Government did not provide for a hunting licence attachment and therefore the new certificates do not meet the legal requirements. It is unbelievable. So many aged farmers living on their own and all they wanted was to have the gun in their house to shoot a few crows, rabbits or whatever, and have it for safety as well. They had to go through all of this rigmarole. At the end of the day, the people who really needed the licences could not get them because the Bill was not properly drawn up. I worry that all this rushed legislation that is going through will give rise to many such difficulties. The Minister stated that by the time the oversight was identified, it was not practicable to recall the certificates issued nor to change the licensing process that was in train. I have spoken with many of those involved. They were alarmed by the stupidity shown during the dog issue and by the failure to get the licensing right.
The Government has a record on issues such as this, in that legislation is being rushed through just to stop the Ward hunt. I am not directly involved in that hunt, although I have known of it and the enjoyment it has given people for many years. Some people do not like it, which is their right, but it provides considerable employment and a good service, as mentioned by Deputy Brady and others. I hope the Minister will spell out what will happen to all of that. Who will shoot all the hounds and do away with the deer?
The Dog Breeding Establishments Bill 2009 has frightened the life out of many people. The sorts of regulation it will introduce will affect ordinary people in the hunt business. Will the Minister ensure that realistic changes are made to the Bill by the time it enters the Dáil so that it will not abuse an ordinary person who keeps a few beagles for winter hunting, cost him or her massive amounts of money and force him or her to meet all sorts of unjustified regulation?
I have no love or support for anyone who abuses the system. When we spoke at a meeting in Monaghan, a colleague from not too far away from me who spoke on the Minister's behalf stated he knew of an outrageous dog kennel located only one mile from his house. He did not name the kennel, but I have been living in the area long enough to be able to check out the only dog kennel of which I know in the locality. The owner is a huntsman who keeps the place pristine. I visited the following weekend to check whether the kennel had deteriorated since I had last seen it. I assure the Minister it was perfect. I just wish all humans were being looked after as well as that group of hounds. A flippant remark like that to try to justify unjustifiable actions does no one any good.
State-run dog kennels are causing serious problems for their neighbours, yet no effort is being made to silence the former. It is wrong that some of the people attending my office cannot sleep at night or, if they work at night, sleep during the day because someone visiting the house next door raises the noise of the dogs. I am referring to something that is being run with the support of the State as a local authority dog pound. This example gives the Minister an idea of some of the difficulties with State-run kennels. They are not perfect and I hope they can improve, but accusations are being made against decent people who are going about their business and having a bit of sport. They are being abused.
The Minister has the weekend to consider what his colleagues sitting behind him are saying. I am not asking him to consider what I have stated. His County Meath colleagues, who have lived with this hunt for generations, know what it is all about. For God's sake, listen to and be guided by them. It is not too late to decide to withdraw this Bill. I know people in the Enniskillen hunt, which goes into the Clones area. Members of one of the families involved are my best friends and invite me to the hunt regularly. It is nothing but sport. It is not abuse or anything else. Were we dealing with the crisis in health or social welfare——
Comment on this
I will conclude. I am dealing with a case in which someone was supposed to get a social welfare payment in April 2009. Yesterday, the person was told the appeal could not be dealt with for another six months.
Comment on this
The Minister should forget about this type of Bill. He should consider the humans and ensure they are given first chance.
Comment on this
The Minister of State, Deputy Mansergh's mobile telephone is playing lovely music, but I am afraid he must turn it off.
Comment on this
It is finishing with Bach.
Comment on this
I understand the Minister of State will be sharing his time with Deputies Seán Power, Máire Hoctor and Maureen O'Sullivan.
Comment on this
Passage of the Wildlife (Amendment) Bill 2010 for the purpose of placing a ban on stag hunting is part of the revised programme for Government and pacta sunt servanda — agreements between parties — should be honoured.
Comment on this
As I have stated several times, I am generally supportive or tolerant of all existing field sports, but cock fighting and badger baiting are not permitted today and even coursing, in which regard Clonmel is the capital of Ireland, operates today under more stringent conditions than previously. The stag is a noble animal and I hold no brief for stag hunting, which is confined to County Meath and is not directly an issue for County Tipperary. It is wrong to believe that all people living in the country are uncritically supportive of field sports. A telephone or Internet poll in the Tipperary Star that I would not necessarily trust completely asked whether blood sports should be banned and received a two thirds response in favour.
Stag hunting raises different health and safety issues than fox hunting. Stags are large animals capable of killing people if they collide with them or their vehicles. There is a difference between the sports, in that the fox knows most of the terrain in which it is being hunted whereas a carted stag released into the countryside does not. The ban in this legislation is, if I understand the Minister correctly, without prejudice to lawful stalking or culling.
The Bourbons are entering into our debates regularly. One does not need to be a female Minister to be likened to Marie Antoinette. Later Bourbons were criticised by Talleyrand as having learned nothing and forgotten nothing. I prefer his statement, "Not too much zeal", which might apply to both extremes of the blood sport debate. Last Sunday, a political correspondent referred to a comment attributed to Louis XV and-or Madame de Pompadour — "After us, the deluge" — in respect of my party. The Bourbons were indefatigable hunters responsible for significant animal carnage. Louis XV reportedly killed 204 stags in one year and his grandson, the ill-fated Louis XVI, famously wrote a single word, "Nothing", in his journal on 14 July 1789, the day of the fall of the Bastille, because he had not succeeded in killing a stag. Stag hunting was reserved to the privileged and was the subject of a string of complaints by the Third Estate. The privileged nomenclature of the Soviet Union likewise indulged in the sport. An 1875 picture of the Ward Union Hunt featuring the Earl of Meath was recently sold in the auction rooms. Nowadays, it is a sport favoured by, among other worthy people, one or more builders and property developers who have figured prominently in dispatches. I am sure they will be pleasantly surprised——
Comment on this
I knew there was a reason, although it is an obscure one.
Comment on this
——to have the Labour Party on their side in this matter.
Not just government, but society is based on compromise, not one group having everything its own way. Lobbying on this issue has been out of proportion to other arguably far more important issues.
Comment on this
No fewer than three registered letters were in my mailbox, as I am sure is the case for other Tipperary Deputies. I cannot remember receiving the same amount on any other issue. Is stag hunting in County Meath really worthy of this degree of priority and attention?
Probably to my future cost, I hold a Burkean view of the duties of a Deputy, in that he or she owes constituents not just his or her industry, but his or her judgment. The Deputy is in Parliament to support his or her opinion of the public good and does not form an opinion to get into or continue in Parliament. I hope we are not spineless lackeys of the last opinion poll or the last angry person or lobby group to get in touch with us. While I respect the opinions of all my constituents, I do not agree that this is a matter of such importance that the Government should stand or fall on it. I am surprised at the opposition of the Labour Party, which presumably means the measure will be repealed if the Labour Party is in government with Fine Gael alone.
Comment on this
Just listen, please. It is interesting that the Tory party in Britain has long-fingered a repeal of the British Labour Party hunting ban because they are in coalition with the Liberal Democrats. I reassure my constituents field sports will continue without interference and with no risk whatsoever, despite vastly exaggerated claims to the contrary. Stag hunting is simply not relevant to the broader interests of the equine industry, which is of great importance to this country.
Comment on this
Ask Paul Carberry. The Minister of State does not know his sport. He need not waffle here. He can waffle on the radio on Sunday.
Comment on this
I tried not to interrupt; it would be great if Deputy McEntee had the manners to do the same.
Comment on this
It is a pity the Minister of State does not know his horse-racing.
Comment on this
The other night, when a small crowd outside was shouting to ban all bloodsports, I could not help asking myself whether parliamentary life or media political coverage as we know it would be possible if that call was heeded
Comment on this
I was born in Kildare and have lived there all my life. It has become known as the thoroughbred country and I admit a certain love for horses. They are a major part of life in Kildare. The industry is a large employer in Kildare. Whether people are employed in the industry or enjoy horses for sport, it is something we are familiar with in Kildare. Training yards and stud farms provide valuable employment, mainly in rural areas where it would be difficult to find alternative employment should the need arise.
The hunt has a long and distinguished record in Ireland and a proud tradition. Most villages have pictures of hunts going back over many years and there is something beautiful about watching a hunt in action. Man has always hunted. Today, that hunt takes on a different meaning but people appreciate that it has a proud historic record. This Bill has attracted much publicity. People who do not hunt or engage in rural activities have little understanding or appreciation of why others partake in the activity and the joy, fun and craic that people have on a hunt.
The renewed programme for Government, which was agreed in October 2009, included a commitment to end deer hunting by stag hounds. The Ward Union Hunt Club has been operating for more than 150 years and is the only club with a stag hunt. It has approximately 200 active members. I know some of these people personally and I regard them as normal, natural people. In any group of 200 people one can select a few and try to tarnish them all with the same brush. The same could be said of the 166 Deputies. The members of the Ward Union Hunt Club are normal people who enjoy a particular activity. From my knowledge of them, they are animal lovers who take great pleasure in participating in a stag hunt. It was with surprise that these club members realised we were introducing legislation to ban an activity they, their parents and their grandparents had enjoyed for many years. Why are they being singled out? Why is the Government pushing ahead with this legislation? The Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, Deputy John Gormley, has provided the licence that has allowed the activity to take place in recent times. We are proposing to ban an activity that has taken place for generations. If the legislation is passed, these men and women who decide to continue their hobby will become criminals.
The debate that has taken place would lead one to believe deer are killed every day a hunt takes place but the facts tell a different story. During the hunt of 11 December 2009 a deer collided with a vehicle and, following the intervention of two vets, the animal had to be put down. However, during the hunt season 2009-10, no other deer died. Many people, the majority of whom are not members of the hunt, are asking whether this legislation is the start of a major attack on rural pursuits. This Minister has said that it is not but I ask the Minister to publish a list of proposals presented by the Green Party during negotiations for the renewed programme for Government. This will clarify the issue of the genuine fear of many rural people. I regret we are debating the legislation in this way. I regret the application of the guillotine on this debate. Many Members would like to contribute for far longer than the time the allocated. I regret the introduction of legislation to criminalise a long and proud tradition in Ireland.
Comment on this
Táim an-bhuioch as ucht an deis atá agam um thráthnona, labhairt faoin mBille seo atá ós ár gcomhair inniu. I am pleased to have speaking time on this proposed Bill, even if it is confined to five minutes. I was grateful to receive the co-operation of the Chairman of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, Deputy Sean Fleming, to speak at the committee meetings on the proposals in this Bill. I had reservations and concerns about the original proposals.
As a rural Deputy from North Tipperary, where the horse, hound and deer are synonymous with rural life, it was with regret that I learned last October that the ban on the 200 year tradition of the Ward Union Hunt in County Meath was part of the newly agreed programme for Government. It was brought about with absolutely no negotiation or consultation with the Fianna Fáil backbenchers, which makes it all the more difficult to proceed in supporting this Bill. I acknowledge the correspondence and telephone calls I received from Meath and people all over Ireland, seeking the retention of the Ward Union Hunt Club. I also acknowledge the anti-blood sports groups who, in a much smaller volume, made known their thoughts to me. I am fully aware of the high standards of animal welfare practice undertaken by the members of the Ward Union Hunt Club, some of whom are personal friends of mine. These people are of the highest decency and integrity, strongly involved in their communities and in activities outside the Ward Union Hunt Club. I acknowledge the co-operation of the Ward Union Hunt Club in the provision of vets, road marshals and volunteer workers. They all work with the Ward Union Hunt Club to increase safety of humans and of animals in the hunt procedure.
I regret there was no consultation with the Ward Union Hunt Club and the absence of a regulatory impact statement prior to introducing this legislation. There are no solutions offered, following the enactment of the Bill, to the loss of jobs and the future of the very valuable fallen animals service carried out by the Ward Union Hunt Club. I acknowledge the work of the fallen animals service, efficiently carried out by the Ward Union Hunt Club. That service must be replaced. On that basis, I support my colleagues' call on the Minister to carry out that impact assessment and permit another licensed season to the Ward Union Hunt Club pending the assessment of the financial impact on County Meath as a result of this legislation.
On section 3, it is clear also that Coillte and the National Parks and Wildlife Service were not consulted in the original drafting of the Bill. It is a recognised and long-established procedure that in the event where two or three deer stalkers hunt together they each might be accompanied by a tracker dog. I note that in other European countries, in the absence of a dog, qualified and authorised tracker dogs are brought in to hunt down the fallen animal to ensure the least pain is endured by the animal in the event of hunting.
I am pleased that the Minister, Deputy Gormley, has acknowledged that the original proposals in section 3 were not viable. It is a requirement of hunting leases issued by Coillte that a hunter is either accompanied by a tracking dog or that they have access to a tracking dog when stalking deer. The use of dogs is a humane requirement to ensure the swift tracking of wounded deer. Had a regulatory impact assessment been carried out prior to the publishing of the Bill, the deletion of the proposals would not have to be visited now. I say to the Minister that amendments to section 3 are not required. The deletion of section 3 is all that is needed.
I understand the Minister's officials had a positive meeting recently with the representatives of the Wild Deer Association and the Irish Deer Association but, unfortunately, the Minister has not met with the associations. Much of the confusion surrounding the practice of these rural pursuits would be eliminated if the Minister were to meet with them. I encourage the Minister to do so and to address the other outstanding issues in regard to rural pursuits in the Dog Breeding Establishments Bill. My written concerns are on the Minister's desk and I would welcome the opportunity to discuss those with him. I am grateful for the opportunity to express my concerns regarding the matters I have outlined.
Comment on this
Tugaim fíor-thacaíocht don Bille seo, ar mo shon féin agus ar son Tony Gregory, a d'oibrigh go dian dícheallach ar son na cúise seo i rith na mblianta. Bhí an-díomá air nach raibh níos mó déanta ar an ábhar seo sar a fuair sé bás.
I wish to focus on the hunt aspect and the proposal to prohibit stag hunting with hounds in Ireland, which will apply to the Ward Union Hunt. I believe this is a humane and an enlightened initiative that is long overdue.
Do we have some romantic view of the hunt in terms of the red jackets, the men and women on horseback and, I understand these days, on quads and jeeps, with the horns blowing, the dogs baying and the so-called thrill of the chase? The words I use are animal cruelty. There are incidents of deer becoming entangled in barbed wire, drowned and chocked to death. Do we really want to see images of hunted deer covered in blood, wounded, bitten and bruised, with steaming tongues hanging out as they drop to the ground exhausted? The hunt is causing unnecessary suffering to these animals. It is a gruelling experience that can last up to and even longer than three hours.
I cite, as the late Deputy Tony Gregory did in the Dáil debate of October 2007, the veterinary documents which show the injuries and fatalities. They include fractured ribs, ruptured aortic aneurysms, a deer collapsing and dying after desperately trying to escape over an 8 ft high wall. There is considerable photographic and video evidence of the cruelty, and reports in newspapers of numerous incidents of cruelty. Is it sport to terrify an animal so unnecessarily and for what?
A significant aspect regarding the Ward Union Hunt is its hunting of tame domesticated deer. Where is the fairness or the sport in pursuing a domesticated deer — domesticated like the Minister's dog or mine — and hunt it down to the point of exhaustion? We are aware of the incident of the stag being hunted into the school yard. Savage hands set on the stag and it was then hunted onto a public road and was pursued until it collapsed, and that is considered sport. Apart from the cruelty to the animals there is also the risk to road users and members of the public.
A significant number of farmers object to their farms and land being invaded, trespassed upon and vandalised, with fences, crops and livestock damaged and destroyed. They want their lands preserved from stag hunting which is threatening their work to produce healthy, quality food. Their "No Hunting" signs are being blatantly ignored by the hunt.
The Ward Union Hunt states that it has implemented a wide range of health and safety measures in recent years. That is equivalent to telling a prisoner that after being tortured a doctor will be on hand to bandage the wounds. What health and safety measures can be brought in that will alleviate deliberate suffering and torture of an animal? That is a total contradiction.
I am fascinated by the notion of monitoring a hunt, which I find ludicrous. Will some of the conditions be that the hounds can bite only five times instead of 20, the stag will be chased for only one hour instead of three or the hunt will use only 20 hounds instead of 40. Perhaps specific injuries will be allowed? How can we tell a hound that it cannot directly kill the deer; just terrify and exhaust it to death.
I represent Dublin Central but I have many affiliations with rural Ireland, including down the road from where the Ward Union Hunt operates. This is not an attack on rural Ireland and to see it portrayed as thus is scare-mongering and deliberately clouding the issue. The Bill simply aims to protect deer from being hounded to exhaustion, injury and death for so-called fun. Is it the view of those opposing the Bill that fun equals subjecting an animal to prolonged and agonising torture and hounding it to death? I support the Bill and hope to see it passed in the House.
Comment on this
I wish to share my time with Deputy Michael D. Higgins.
Comment on this
I will be opposing this Bill and would like to briefly outline the reason that is the case.
Many rural communities are very concerned that they are being used as political footballs for the Green Party to score points in the absence of any other tangible achievement since they joined Fianna Fáil in Government. There is a feeling that the Green Party members need to deliver something to their constituency and that the handiest way of doing that is to ban some form of hunting.
That may be a cynical view but in the absence of the Green Party having been unable to prevent the swingeing cuts across all areas of public and social provision that they said they would oppose when in Opposition, it does make sense. It is also the case that the Green Party's constituency, or what remains of it, is inimical to and, some might claim, ignorant of much of what happens in rural Ireland.
There are also claims in some quarters that the Green Party regards this as their Stalingrad and have intimated that if the legislation is not passed as proposed and that if all Fianna Fáil Deputies do not vote for it they may consider pulling out of Government. That might appear ill-conceived but given that the Green Party has little if any chance of retaining its existing seats as matters stand, it might make some sense.
It might be regarded as a cynical view if they were to take that course. It might also be seen to be somewhat hypocritical of the Green Party to take such a strong and principled position on the rights of deer while having spent the past three years meekly supporting various measures that have impinged on the lives and indeed rights of hundreds of thousands of Irish people.
It is a bit much that a party that was prepared to support the health cuts, impose wage cuts on public servants, and preside over the bailing out of the speculators that they were so eloquent in denouncing when they were on this side of the House should choose this issue as the one on which to make a stand. It is perhaps commendable that they have at least retained some vestiges of the principles they claim, but we are entitled to balance that against all the other things which they have done since they have been in power.
In regard to the issue of banning hunting, and the belief that this current Bill if successful will be followed by attempts to ban other rural pursuits, a number of issues need to be borne in mind when making this decision. There is the legitimate argument that the State, the State acting on behalf of a section of the electorate or, in this case, one political party, ought not to have the right to ban activities just because someone else does not like them. There are many people who do not like this form of hunting, and they are entitled to their beliefs. However, they are not entitled to have it banned simply on that basis.
The only basis on which they would be entitled would be if it could be proved that the practise in question was either cruel, deliberately designed to kill the animal being pursued or that the animal in question was an endangered species. None of that applies as far as I can see in this instance.
There is also the argument, including on behalf of people who have no particular interest in or affection for stag hunting, that if this activity is banned the way will be open to ban other sports involving animals. That could include hare coursing, for example, and I have little doubt that if this Bill is successful that will be the next target.
There is also the belief that the desire to ban rural pursuits would not stop there, and some of the leading advocates of banning blood sports have made no secret of their opposition to horse racing, fishing and greyhound racing. I have been on radio programmes on occasions with some of those people and they have refused to say that is not part of their agenda. If the bottom line is that humans should not use animals for sport then the logic would certainly lead to that.
My party's position is clear. At the Ard Fheis earlier this year, we passed a motion upholding the right to organise regulated and licensed hunting, as long as there is stringent regulation to protect the sustainability of a given population and to prevent the infliction of unnecessary cruelty through hunting practice.
We cannot support an outright ban on the form of hunting as proposed in this Bill in the absence of clear evidence of risk to population sustainability and of evidence of cruelty. Risk to the sustainability of the red deer population is not an issue and no sustainability evidence has been adduced. The only issue to be assessed is whether stag hunting with hounds generally, or the specific practice of carted stag hunting in particular, constitutes cruel practice in hunting.
The 1997 Kane report found no intentional cruelty related to the Ward Union Hunt. However, it found inhumane practice related to the manner and design of cart transportation and that domesticated deer in particular are generally unfit for prolonged chase. Importantly, the 1998 Kane and Guthrie report on the welfare of deer, which appears to have been much more thorough and scientific in its approach and methodology, did not find significant health and welfare issues related to this practice.
There is also the fact that hunts often proceed illegally in the face of an outright ban. Such illegal hunts would not be subject to the controls that currently apply to the now highly regulated Ward Union Hunt. These were made even more stringent with the introduction of new licensing conditions in 2008, including monitoring by the National Parks and Wildlife Service and veterinary supervision.
Regarding the economic aspects of this issue, it is estimated that the Ward Union club keeps approximately 30 people in direct, indirect and ancillary employment. This breaks down to four full-time equivalents in direct employment, 13 grooms in indirect employment and 11 in ancillary trades. Income to the locality is estimated at approximately €1 million per annum. Hence in the worst case scenario, the legislation could result in the loss of up to 30 jobs and a loss of €1 million per annum to the local economy in Meath.
For all these reasons Sinn Féin will be opposing the Bill as drafted.
Comment on this
It would be a great pity if a simplistic rural-urban divide emerged in the debate about the welfare of animals and our heritage. Issues around these areas must be treated with respect for their complexity and each considered on their merits.
Between 1993 and 1997, I had ministerial responsibility for many of the matters contained in this legislation. Before the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, Deputy John Gormley, leaves the Chamber, I must say it is absolutely outrageous to suggest that I and any Member of the Labour Party are in favour of cruelty to animals or bloodsports. When I was Minister for Arts, Culture and the Gaeltacht, I ended by regulation the possibility of any deer being killed and my colleague, Deputy Brian O'Shea, regulated for greyhounds to wear muzzles to eliminate the kill in coursing. Those are the facts. I want this debate to be unemotive and practical.
Between 1988 and 1996 no licence had been issued to the Ward Union Hunt. I took the position that the Wildlife Act 1976 had not been properly observed. Accordingly, I asked for time to investigate how the Ward Union Hunt took place.
The results of my actions are contained in my replies to parliamentary questions then. For example, Parliamentary Question No. 25 on 20 February 1997, tabled by Deputy Sargent, asked about the outcome of the monitoring of deer hunting activities by the Ward Union Hunt and if I would have regard to the many landowners, road-users and compassionate members of the public, both rural and urban, who object to deer hunting with hounds before deciding on future policy on this activity.
I believed this activity should have been monitored and controlled but it had not between 1988 and 1996. In my reply, I drew his attention to my reply to Parliamentary Question No. 126 on 22 October 1996 which gave a historical background to the issue. I also informed Deputy Sargent:
Following this reply there was an exchange of correspondence between the National Parks and Wildlife Service of my Department and the Ward Union hunt club in relation to the requirements for a licence under the 1976 Act for carted stag hunting. Ultimately, this correspondence resulted in an application for a licence.
The reply also listed the conditions I had attached to the licence which included the health and condition of the animal before and after the hunt, the treatment of the animal during the hunt, the control of the hounds and the behaviour of those on horseback. I was seeking to operate with as much consensus as I could to ensure no allegation of cruelty could be made.
Due to the deer used in the hunt being reared domestically, I decided to hand over the responsibility of ongoing examinations to the then Department of Agriculture. I also commissioned a report on the Ward Union Hunt from K.W.S. Kane, a veterinary inspector, which was presented to me on 16 May 1997. Mr. Kane made criticisms about how the deer were transported to the hunt, that is, carting and so forth. As I was about to leave office, I wrote a note for my officials stating that we should address the additional necessary conditions to ensure there was no stress on the deer. I had already eliminated the kill element in deer hunting, as did Deputy Brian O'Shea with the hare in coursing. It is an outrageous untruth — I cannot use the other word that I would like to use — to suggest the Labour party has changed its position. It does not serve the Minister, Deputy Gormley, well and adds to his reputation for bitter pills.
I had ministerial responsibility for heritage when it was managed properly. I took decisions that were not popular but necessary. Why did the Minister not use the conditions I had laid down? If he felt there were new circumstances surrounding public safety, why did he not add them as new conditions and require them to be attached to a licence? Instead, the Minister has done a sloppy thing by taking the capacity of the Minister out of the 1976 Act. That is lazy. If he had left it untouched, he would have given himself the space and obligation to put in conditions that would guarantee no cruelty would be experienced. The Minister must explain why he went instead for the simplistic approach. By striking down this section, he has removed certain other ministerial capacities.
There are differences between us on our ministerial approaches to this issue. When I was Minister, I began with animal welfare while this Minister, Deputy Gormley, has begun with a ban. For example, I foresee serious problems arising in respect of stalking if the legislation does not specify the conditions under which a person may shoot at a deer. Sometimes deer are wounded and wander in a wounded condition, something which directly affects an animal in a way far greater than an animal that has been carted. I am not making comparisons for idle purposes. Other issues arise such as the question of how irresponsible it would be to make the animal welfare conditional on property ownership. Under this proposed legislation, if one owns property one can take as many dogs as one wishes to drive a deer off one's property. How can one declare that represents animal welfare? How can one say that enhances public safety? These are glaring blemishes in the legislation although the Minister and I are agreed that we wish to end up in the same place.
It is outrageous to make a cheap comment to the effect that I have changed my mind on animal welfare. I have not. I would simply do this in a different way. I could have taken these conditions and the Minister could have built on them.
The Minister has done something politically dangerous. During his speech this afternoon, he provided a number of guarantees. He has said it will only be this and this alone. In doing so, he has enabled other issues to be removed from the agenda. He has provoked a reaction that will provide a shelter for those who do not want other issues to be addressed. Many people who objected to the Ward Union Hunt — I am familiar with some of these people — objected to some of the participants as much as the practice itself. They took the view that it was ridiculous that some of the best know speculators would mount on horseback and behave like the new gentry and go galloping across people's land. I have some sympathy for that view because I recall in my youth getting a half a crown in County Clare for opening the gate for people propped up on horseback. We were entertained to guess how quickly they would fall off.
We must draw a distinction. I hold no brief for the social composition of the Ward Union Hunt. I refer to other members of the hunt. When I made my moves in 1996 I distinctly remember some very distinguished families from County Meath, including relatives of the then Taoiseach, Mr. Bruton, coming to see me and explaining the outrageousness of my proposals. The point is my approach was very different from that of the Minister, Deputy Gormley. I met the Irish Council Against Blood Sports. I provided the date of the meeting in the answer to the question. I also met the Ward Union Hunt. I used the Heritage Council to prepare a report. I consulted as widely as possible. I took the view that although I was proceeding slowly, it was the way to achieve the best result. I finished putting in place these conditions in 1996 or 1997. It is true that two reports were carried out, namely, the Kane report and the Guthrie report. As far as I was concerned, if this activity could never be sufficiently controlled with conditions attached to licence, one should keep adding to the licence conditions until it had withered on the vine.
This is not what the Minister has done. He has made a gesture out of the legislation. I listened patiently to the speeches given from all sides of the House. The Minister has enabled a reaction to be composed and that reaction will oppose other issues. I do not believe the Minister is against rural Ireland and it is outrageous for people to suggest as much. We should be mature about how we approach these matters. It is unfortunate that the content of the legislation is so flawed and that the tactics in bringing this legislation to the House are equally flawed. It is disastrous that the issue has been so divisive.
Heritage issues within the Minister's Department have been damaged, which is a great pity. People have made very reasonable points. I refer to parts of the country where people who were farming would not cut the hooves of their donkeys. The poor old ass was crippled with neglect. I refer to the cruelty of those refusing to allow the issue of the urban horse to be addressed, which is scandalous. These are real issues.
I dealt in a complicated way with a point the Minster has in the proposed legislation. His officials will advise him on whether the Attorney General has waived on the matter. I dealt with the issue of when an animal is considered feral according to the description under the Wildlife Act 1976 or when an animal is considered domesticated, in which case it is a matter for the Minister with responsibility for agriculture. It is a genuine attempt by the Minister in the relevant section to use the phrase "any other deer". I suggest the Minister examines this seriously before Committee Stage because I suspect it is legislatively fragile. I do not say this to score a point but this was an area for which I held responsibility.
It is not the case that there has been any great change in the Labour Party's position. It is simply a matter of the way in which this legislation is put together, the context in which it has been delivered and the consequences it has with regard to dividing communities that should combine to treat heritage issues adequately. This is why the Labour Party has a reservation on the matter. Our opposition to cruelty, our love of animals, our loyalty to urban and rural animals and so forth remain the same.
Comment on this
I wish to share time with Deputy Trevor Sargent. We may offer different views on this Bill.
Comment on this
I have no connection with the hunt or the people involved. However, I speak as someone with a love of animals. We have always kept dogs in the family home and currently we keep two beautiful cavaliers. I represent a vast number of constituents from Dublin North who are actively involved in the hunt and others not involved in the hunt but who support it.
Let us consider the history of the Ward Union Hunt over 150 years. It has produced many famous people in the horse riding business, including members of the Carberry family, Paul, Philip and Nina, as well as Barry Geraghty, Kevin Manning and the trainer, Noel Meade. As Irish people, we roar on these people whether at race meetings on the television such as Cheltenham and the Aintree Grand National or at home. All of these people honed their skills by participating in the Ward Union Hunt and by riding out their ponies and becoming accomplished horse riders.
We should carry out an impact assessment on the business activities related to the hunt. A total of four direct employees are involved with the Ward Union Hunt and it has a business turnover of €1.4 million. We are all aware that the horse breeding business is of the order of €1 billion for the Irish economy. If we were discussing any other aspect of business life, there is no way any Member would suggest we do something arbitrarily that would impact on a €1 billion business or a local business worth almost €1.5 million. One need only consider the activities involved to realise how that business is comprised. Apart from the buying and selling of horses, at issue is jobs in animal feed, including feed for horses and hounds tack and riding equipment, transportation, farriers and vets. That is to ignore the local shops, pubs and restaurants, all of which attract great business during the hunting season. I do not subscribe to the view that we should write off that business without a thorough investigation. I do not subscribe to that. I implore the Minister that before he makes this decision to ban the hunt, he does what we call for in all walks of life, namely, that we investigate this. As a courtesy to this House and the Seanad, I ask him to bring us a report and to come back in the autumn or mid-winter after we have gone through all the facts and figures to discuss them. If there are issues in terms of animals suffering, let us deal with them.
As I said, I do not have any involvement in this but I have had discussions with many people. There is general consensus that there is no animal cruelty involved. I would like the Minister to give an assurance that he will carry out an assessment and give us three or four months to investigate this, which is reasonable.
Other speakers referred to the fallen animal service the Ward Union Hunt provides. Has the Minister discussed with his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, Deputy Smith, what replacement service will be put in place if the Ward Union Hunt ceases to exist? Almost 5,000 dead animals are collected all over north Dublin and Meath. They are collected quickly, efficiently and at a subsidised cost to the farmer. I know from talking to one of the veterinarians involved in this process that we will not have this service whereby the animal is collected from the farm within hours, which is very important from the point of view of our reputation as a food producing nation. Will we replace that service quickly, efficiently and at the same cost?
I listened attentively to Deputy Higgins. The conditions and restrictions he imposed as Minister were reasonable and practical and were further refined last year by the Minister, Deputy Gormley. There is no reason we should not endeavour to continue to refine them. We can avoid similar incidents to the one or two which occurred with the licensing arrangements but it is not right to ban this because there has been one incident.
The whole purpose of any consultation process is to thoroughly investigate. I am not saying people should not have different opinions to mine but we should thoroughly investigate how we can improve this before we reach the ultimate decision to ban the activity.
From my observations of deer, I believe they are wild animals. They are brought up as wild and to run. Instinctively, I believe they expect to be hunted. I am not suggesting for one second that they should be mauled by hounds or anything like that. I would abhor that. I would have a greater problem with hare coursing where I believe greyhounds get very close to the unfortunate hare.
Will the Minister put this Bill on hold for the next three or four months? Let us carry out an assessment on how we can regulate more if we need more regulation and restrictions. In terms of the business aspect, people in north Dublin, Meath and elsewhere enjoy a good business and God knows we need to protect and courage business given the job losses and the recession.
I hope the Minister will make a pragmatic decision and will ask for a report. He has asked for many other reports. Currently, he is correctly looking for reports on local authorities. He has not sought to abolish Cork County Council because he is investigating it. He has merely asked for an investigation and he should do the same in this case.
I listened to Deputy Higgins speak about his involvement. He met the Ward Union Hunt. Will the Minister meet these people who are Irish people? The Ward Union Hunt may have started out in the 1850s with British aristocrats but the majority of the members of the hunt comprise ordinary Irish men and women and young people. They deserve to be able to put their case to the Minister. There is no reason the Minister would not afford them the opportunity to meet him and for him to put his concerns to them. If he has concerns, he has the right to put questions on animal welfare or, if he suspects any, animal cruelty to them. Will the Minister give this House the opportunity to consider an assessment and revisit this matter towards the end of the year?
Comment on this
Ar dtús báire ba mhaith liom a rá go gcuirim fáilte roimh an Bhille um Fhiadhúlra (Leasú) 2010. Mar chuid den chlár Rialtais, tá an Bille seo i measc go leor rudaí eile atá aontaithe le déanamh ag an Rialtas agus sin an chúis go dtacaím leis.
All of us who signed up to the programme for Government may have issues with items along the way but it is the nature of politics to arrive at the most practicable, workable and broadly based compromise. This Bill is one aspect of that and it is quite short. In that regard, the discussion must reflect that the Bill comprises five paragraphs and is quite limited.
I hope we can get back to dealing with the issues most people outside this House probably want us to deal with in terms off ostaíocht, rialú ceart na mbanc, caomhnú fuinnimh, an córas taistil, pleanáil ceart agus go leor rudaí eile lena bhfuil an Comhaontas Glas ag plé agus ar a bhfuil sé ag obair go tréan. Ina measc tá cosaint na ndaoine is boichte sa tír, talmhaíocht, gnó bia, an córas sláinte agus córas tinnis, truailliú, cumarsáid, foraoiseacha, an comhshaol, scolaíocht agus cúram leanaí. Tá a lán ábhair idir lámha ag an Rialtas seo agus ag Airí Glasa agus ag an Comhaontas Glas i gcoitinne. This is but one.
Even in areas where this is quite hotly debated, such as Garristown in north County Dublin which Deputy Kennedy and I represent, tonight most people there are probably more concerned with their water being cut off at 6 p.m. until 8 a.m. and having to depend on a couple of water tankers.
That said, let us deal with this matter in the way that it must be dealt with because it is outstanding. It has gone to the courts. The Minister tried to regulate it, as Deputy Higgins suggested, but unfortunately that did not go down too well and it ended up in the High Court. It comes down to a difficulty in trying to make progress on this. The Bill takes the live quarry out of the equation in a hunt but does not ban hunting. Drag hunts will continue and traditions, kennels, horsemanship and the fallen animal service do not require a stag to be part of the equation. This reality needs to be discussed.
I live in north County Dublin and I know many of the people who ride out with the WUH. However, the majority of those who raised this issue with me are opposed to the activity for a number of reasons, many of which relate to animal welfare. There is no getting away from that. The Irish Farmers’ Journal printed a report in 2007 of a deer choking to death. In 2005 a deer died having broken a rib leading to an aortic rupture. The stress endured by the animals must be acknowledged. A 300 kg stag aged five bolted through a hedge and was hit by a car last December and that gave us a salient warning. Thank God there were no human fatalities but the deer had to be put down.
These issues cannot be brushed under the carpet as if everything is a picnic and there is no animal welfare issue. We must not be blind to it. As a former Minister of State with responsibility for food and horticulture, I have met many people with an agricultural background who are not at all happy. Horticulturists find it difficult to make a living and they do not want horses and hounds traversing their land. I live near a farmer who has a field of turnips. The gate was left open by the hunt members. Generally they disregard the difficulties people face in trying to make ends meet and to maintain their livelihoods. We must have consideration for the wider community in this regard.
Condensing the issue down to wide open fields and rural communities does not tell the full story. I recounted an incident earlier to Deputy Kennedy of a stag appearing in a man's garden while he worked in his house. Nobody was chasing it but it was distressed having escaped the hunt at least momentarily. A veterinarian was called and the stag had to be tranquilised. The tranquiliser did not take effect immediately and because this large animal was agitated, it took off again towards Rivervalley, a highly built up area in Swords. The tranquiliser only kicked in when the stag had made it 2.5 miles down the Brackenstown Road. When a stag is trying to escape, it will try to do anything. It will go into a school yard, the grounds of a church, a graveyard or a garden. It will do whatever it has to do to escape. That is the reality in the name of the WUH.
I hope Fine Gael and the Labour Party will reflect on the position they are taking.
Comment on this
I am not sure whether they are united. Deputy Shatter held a much higher position in the Irish Council Against Blood Sports than I could ever aspire to but he has not contributed to this debate. Perhaps he has been silenced in more ways than one.
Comment on this
Perhaps he is cycling in front of a squad car.
Comment on this
Perhaps he is slightly embarrassed. Labour Party members signed petitions seeking a ban on stag hunting for years. I received a text message from a man in Galway who is mystified by the Jesuitical hand wringing on this matter of Deputy Michael D. Higgins. He asked since the Deputy had signed a petition what his position is now. It may be Augustinian — "Lord make me pure but not yet".
Comment on this
He explained his position clearly.
Comment on this
But the man in Galway is still wondering and questions remain for Deputy Higgins. All I can do is give this man a copy of the debate and let him make his own mind up.
If there is a fatality, will Fine Gael and the Labour Party say they are sorry they blocked the Minister and his attempt to regulate this sport in order that road safety would not be compromised and they are sorry for the fatality? Let it be on their conscience that they did not put an end to that risk when they had an opportunity. I regard that as irresponsible. I hope we can pass this legislation quickly and we can move on with the weightier issues of State, which must be dealt with for the country to prosper.
Comment on this
That is what the Green Party should put first.
Comment on this
That is what we have been doing.
Comment on this
I am grateful for the opportunity to contribute to the debate. I always knew the time would come. With regard to Deputy Sargent's contribution, the people of north County Dublin might be worrying which way the Meath flag is flying on Sunday evening but whatever happens, happens. The six Members from County Meath will travel to Croke Park together on Sunday to shout for our team and before we leave, we will join up with our Dublin counterparts who have joined us in Meath. We love the number of Dublin people who have moved to our county. They brought their wit, culture and so on but I have not been contacted by one of them since this debate started two or three years ago asking me to stop my way of life.
I could be emotional about this issue but I am clear about it. I can also be risen easily but when one knows one is right and there is compromise at the end of the day, it is easy to speak. I was elected to the House in a by-election by people from different walks of life and people of different political persuasions. Almost 2,000 Fianna Fáil supporters gave me a first preference. Labour Party, Green Party, Sinn Féin and Independent supporters gave me their lower preferences and I am here to represent all of them.
Two years ago when the issue raised its head, there was a struggle and the Minister implemented regulations. Within six months, members of the WUH were happy they were implemented because they made it easier for them and it worked out well. I could not believe my ears when I heard we were back to this again because I am a person who believes in live and let live. We should respect each other's culture and each other's party. I could make great hay in my county about this issue, as my party colleague said, but I will not because that would be a short-term reaction. The six Members from County Meath are all of the one type and I am under no illusions that we are in the House on behalf of the people. I keep in contact with my people. Sometimes I must make up my own mind on the spur of the moment like I did last night with two Members from Fianna Fáil and the Labour Party regarding an amendment to another Bill where common sense worked at the end of the day. I guarantee common sense will prevail next Tuesday evening. There is a great deal of common sense in the Green Party.
I support the Green Party on one issue. I do not support it on a lot of things and I did not vote with it the first night I was in the Dáil. I left the House, even though its Members were on this side of the House, because I was not clear on the issue. Anything I knew about the Green Party told me that its agenda was not in the interest of County Meath at the time. However, there is one thing in County Meath in which I have an interest — that is, the opening of Panda, where there is recycling instead of incineration. It was one of the best days I had since I was elected and I know it was one of the best days the Minister had.
There is no one better than me to throw muck, as Deputies know. Sometimes one does not like doing it, but one needs to. Deputy Mansergh said I was biased and he is right. I was taught to fight fire with fire. That is the only way it can be done. We can beat around the bush as much as we like, but when I am hit with fire I hit back with fire. Ultimately, we will all need to come back here and talk about far more important issues. This is needlessly bringing us down.
I know the Green Party has its issues about animals. Those who hunt are great people — I have listened to them. I know these people, who are of a farming background. Contrary to what Deputy Kennedy said — although I will not get annoyed about it — they are true Irishmen. There is not an ounce of English blood in them. They are not gentry; I know them. They are true Irishmen. I did not like that comment.
Comment on this
Fionn Mac Cumhaill was a great hunter.
Comment on this
The Deputy can say things like that. That is fair. However, I am telling the Deputies that I know these people. They can take my word for it. I grew up with them from the age of 12.
Comment on this
The Deputy can go into that and try to rag me; that is fair enough. I have no bother with that.
Comment on this
I did not say Deputy McEntee; I said his party. I have more respect for the Deputy than for some in his party.
Comment on this
That is fair enough. However, we have come to a point at which decisions must be made. What Deputy Brady said was true. I was at an environmental meeting and I found it hard to accept that people in the industry were not consulted. That is a fact and it is on the record. It is not right. Deputies Higgins and Broughan are correct; this measure will be challenged. Fine Gael and the Labour Party do not want to have to reintroduce stag hunting when Fianna Fáil and the Green Party leave Government, whether it is now or in two years' time. We do not want to have to spend time on that. However, we will bring it back in. That is guaranteed. The Green Party has a lot of good ideas. If it wants the trust of the Irish people, it must ask why it ended up with no councillors.
Comment on this
I ask the Deputies to take this in the right spirit. They must consider why they have so few councillors. Its principles did not follow from this side of the fence to that side.
Comment on this
The same will happen to us if we do not reintroduce stag hunting, and the same will happen to the Fianna Fáil Deputies. Its rural Deputies know, when they walk in here next week, that they must face their fate. That is where RISE comes in. Rural Ireland did not allow the Ward Union Hunt to be hung out to dry.
Hunting is a pursuit that is an escape from ordinary life, similar to fishing, Gaelic football, soccer or badminton. When things get tough, one has a pursuit at the weekend. We have open battle on Sundays. More blood will be spilled in Croke Park on Sunday than in the next ten stag hunts — that is for sure. That is the way it will be.
Comment on this
It is an organised campaign, and I compliment the Minister on what he has done to get the legislation to this point. I ask him to listen to what I am saying. What is another year? Let it be right. Why put these people out of a pastime? I know how hard they work. Their children get up in the morning and look after their ponies. It is their way out from drugs and everything else. It is hard enough. I come into Dublin and I see cruelty. I walk down the street every day and give every penny I have in my pocket to those poor people.
I cannot accept the Bill that the Green Party is introducing. The principle is right, but it should not isolate one group of people. Up to last Wednesday, everybody accepted everybody. The Thirty-two Counties accepted each other. Next Tuesday we will cause a divide, and that is wrong. One part of the community, which is 150 years old and pure Irish, will be isolated. The industry provides jobs and keeps kids off the street. I am asking the Minister to draw back, and I will continue to ask him up to the last minute on Tuesday evening, because I believe in democracy and in doing the right thing. I know the Green Party will do it and I know my colleagues in Fianna Fáil will do it. They must do the right thing.
In politics, one must do the right thing and one is there to represent people. I represent the people of Meath, regardless of their politics or sporting pursuits. Deputies have seen over the last six months how political a country we are when things are tough. The Government knows we supported its side on the night the bank guarantee was introduced. Let us be right or let us be wrong — we know what is ahead of us. We must not interfere with sport and with a way of life. The Government may wish to get this over quickly, but it will be the longest drawn out battle of all time. The Green Party will have no support from the Government. It is the only thing it will get done. There are many Green Party issues that must be addressed.
Two years ago a letter was sent which stated that pack hounds would not be included in the Dog Breeding Establishments Bill, but it was not true. It was a broken promise. Why should anyone trust the Green Party Members a second time? I trust them to do the right thing, as I trust every person elected in this House to do the right thing in the interests of the people who elected him or her.
Deputy Sargent is right when he says we should not be spending our time on this. We did not bring it up; I thought it was dealt with. We must act responsibly in situations such as this. There are many things in my party that I am not happy with and that I would like to bring up, but one must take it bit by bit and prioritise.
The banning of the Ward Union hunt when the country is on its knees in debt is appalling. There was a man in my office the other day who had been buying the cheapest possible food for himself because he had four children who were home for the summer. Yet here we are talking about removing €1.3 million from the County Meath economy. The Green Party has its principles, which I respect, but it should not destroy people's way of life. That is what it is doing.
Why has RISE succeeded? It is because the hunting men, the fishing men and the shooting men simply do not believe the Green Party.
Comment on this
It is not. I ask Deputy Sargent to listen, because if he does not then not only will the Green Party lose all its councillors but when the next election comes it will be more extinct than the stag. There will not be a Green Party Deputy in the House. Any Fianna Fáil Deputy who walks with the Green Party Deputies is narrowing his or her chances too. I accept it is up to those in my constituency to nominate me; I have been in politics since I was 14 years of age. If my party members do not want me to run I will not run. If they want me to put up posters I will do so. However, I will listen to them and I will do what I am told, up to a point, although I will have a mind of my own.
I will finish on this note. The Green Party has lost all its councillors because the people did not trust it. It is all down to votes. The Deputies should be in no doubt about that. If they want to implement more of their policies they should show that they have an ability to compromise. They should not be single-minded, as the Minister of State, Deputy Mansergh, said about me. I am more single-minded, but ultimately I have an ability to compromise a little. Each of the Deputies has also. They should go back and think about it for three months over the summer. They can get all the organisations together, sit down and sort it out. If they railroad the Bill through, it will be no good to anybody.
The Green Party in government will be remembered as the party that banned the stag hunt. That will be the end of the story. Fianna Fáil will not back the Greens any more; its members have said so now. They will back the Greens in nothing and there are still two years left to go for this Government. I predict it will last two years but nothing will be achieved by the Greens.
I am a backbencher and that is why I am sitting here all day. I do not always listen to what the front benchers say; I am going to fight my corner and they know that. We come out and we come out united. I am asking all the Green Party Deputies to go back and talk to Deputy Johnny Brady, Deputy Mary Wallace, Deputy Thomas Byrne and Deputy Noel Dempsey. They are their partners in government. I urge them to come up with a compromise and throw out this Bill. We will come back in the middle of July if we have to. I urge the Minister not to railroad this Bill down our throats. That is all I am asking and I will give a greater warning. They should not railroad this Bill down our throats or they will have no party and Fianna Fáil will have a lot fewer Deputies because the people in RISE come from Donegal to the end of Kerry. A total of 9,700 people — voters — in my constituency have signed up to support RISE. That number is a quota on its own. As I said in Simonstown last night, I do not want that. I want my colleagues in Fianna Fáil, whose supporters are in the Public Gallery, to get them to do the right thing, to do what is good for County Meath and not to look for some short-term gain. The Green Party would have support in County Meath. I ask them to open their minds and not to be so god-damned narrow-minded about everything. This is a country of 4.5 million people and that population will build up to 6.5 million within 30 years when we will need food, electricity and a lot of green agendas. I urge the Green Party Deputies not to end up like their councillors on the scrap heap because that is the bottom line. These are the facts. The reporters are here and they can write about it. The facts are that the Green Party has no councillors and it will have no TDs if its Deputies do not listen to people. They will bring people along with them if they listen to them.
How much time have I remaining, Acting Chairman?
Comment on this
What will I say in four and a half minutes that I have not said already?
Comment on this
Maybe I will talk about the match on Sunday.
I have nearly said all I can say. As I said two years ago, we came in and we fought and it was hot and heavy. I was delighted with the Minister. A system was set up. It cost a few pounds but everything was regularised and it worked very well. There were no complaints. I remind the House there were no children in the schoolyard the day the stag broke in. That is a case of being hit by a bus when there is no bus.
I remind the House that 30,000 deer are illegally killed every year. Who is killing them? Is it the gun clubs of County Meath or County Waterford or County Kerry? Is it the fishermen? If I am wrong in those figures, I stand to be corrected because that information was given to me but one cannot always be right in everything. However, there is a large number of deer killed illegally in this country. Does the Minister of State not think they are the ones that should be looked after in an animal welfare Bill? I think they are.
I know all the people involved in the Ward Union Hunt and in other hunts. They are all farming-minded people, so to speak. As Deputy Michael Kennedy said, he was not a farming person but these people are all animal lovers. They would stay up at night to mind a calf that was born two months premature. They would get up ten times at night to make sure it lived. They would do it for any animal. They are not cruel people and I resent that insinuation from anybody. The sport has been regularised and the Minister has done a good job in that regard. The vets have done a good job. Why not just leave things alone and leave the people alone? The Green Party is getting people's backs up. A total of 300,000 people are up in arms. The names, addresses, phone numbers and e-mails addresses of all those people are now on a system. That makes a total of 30 quotas in an election. The Minister of State knows what we are all like in elections; we can be nice fellows but it is votes we want.
I say to the Green Party and to my five colleagues, including Deputy Damien English, I expect us to stand together on Tuesday night but I also expect in the meantime that the north County Dublin Deputies — I will not name them — and my colleagues in County Meath, will sit down with the Green Party, somewhere, not the Green Isle Hotel, but somewhere else, to sort this out and to come back on Tuesday or the week after. It is the right thing to do and many of the Green Party members know it is the right thing to do.
There are too many arguments when a subject is raised. I was gung-ho when it came to the Road Traffic Bill, as was the Minister, Deputy Noel Dempsey and Deputy Broughan but we saw common sense during the day yesterday and we amended the Bill in the House, in the interest, as I said, of fair play. All I am asking for is fair play on behalf of these people who work so hard from one year to the next, who mind their stock, who work in offices, who are plumbers or carpenters or farm labourers or shopkeepers. They all go out together, they have their bit of fun, they mind their horses, they do nothing that will do harm to these stags.
I thought I would not have anything to say in this debate, having listened to Deputy Wallace, Deputy Brady and Deputy Byrne but there was one little thing they did not get right: they said they would be voting with the Government. That is the only part they did not say right. They know the consequences. Deputy Johnny Brady put it very well. If Members think I am passionate about this matter, he is twice as passionate. I have seen him standing on a box outside mass 30 years ago and he would put the hair standing on one's head when talking about Fianna Fáil; so much so, I would nearly join it myself. What he said in the debate was right. Deputy Michael Kennedy was right. He advised them to sit down between now and next Tuesday. It should not be the case that people are coming up from Cork and Kerry. We should not be fighting among ourselves in the House because we have far too many issues to discuss. I am asking the people opposite to talk. I know the Minister of State is a hunting woman. I ask her to give the lead, as a Carlow Deputy. She knows what it means. If an agreement is not possible, then so be it, but at least they should try. That is all I have to say.
Comment on this
I wish to share my time with Deputy Paul Gogarty.
I thank Deputy McEntee. I come from a rural background and I am pleased to have a few minutes to say that I am alive and well as a rural Deputy representing Carlow-Kilkenny. Some of the information coming from RISE has been totally disingenuous. Its members have disregarded my democratic mandate; they have disregarded my very existence; they have disregarded the fact that I used to hunt.
I used to have a little pony called Lucky, when I had little yellow plaits. I used to follow the Bray Harriers when I was ten. Then I grew up. My father could not afford the pony — he used to rent them from Delahunt's stables in County Wicklow — but my sister and I loved ponies. We loved the rural way of life. I live under the Blackstairs mountains in County Carlow. I am great friends with many members of the Carlow Farmers Hunt and I support them on many of their fund-raising activities. There are two sad aspects to this debate. One is the completely erroneous statements from RISE about the origins of the Green Party's policy on this issue, the completely erroneous statements that the Greens know nothing about rural Ireland. I know a lot about rural Ireland. I was brought up in rural Ireland, I married somebody from rural Ireland and I live in rural Ireland. For many years, I used to shoot and fish to feed my family. I know what it is like to hook a salmon. I know what it is like to shoot a pheasant. However, the countryside has changed in Meath and in north County Dublin; it has become increasingly urbanised. Deputy McEntee knows this and he spoke very passionately and honestly and I respect that. However, he must also respect my views that the Green Party members are aware of how the countryside ticks. We do not all live in the middle of cities such as Cork, Dublin or Galway, where we have elected members. Some of us live and breathe the country air and know how the country works.
The Labour Party has executed a complete volte face and it is now deciding to vote against this Bill. The Labour Party supported it and many of its Deputies, whether it was Deputy Rabbitte or Deputy Gilmore, were against stag hunting. Now the party has done a complete 180 degrees turn.
It may have made that turn because of the pick and mix politics in which it now engages or because of the very comfortable position it holds on most of its policies — sitting on the fence.
Many people watch hunting sitting on the fence because they like the colour and glamour of the hunt as it passes. However, Labour Party policy now is a policy of sitting on the fence, which is a very comfortable place to be. However, it is about time the Labour Party members came off the fence and told us where they stand, rather than watching the polls and tick-tacking to see which way the wind blows. It is very interesting that Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council moved a motion calling on the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government to honour his commitment to outlaw stag hunting and to cease immediately providing licences for the purpose of carrying out stag hunts. This motion was passed in Deputy Gilmore's constituency.
We must be genuine in our debates here. I will be genuine and recognise Members' genuine concerns. However, we have not talked about the genuine concerns of people who had near fatal accidents as a result of stag hunting by the Ward Union hunt. We are all aware of the incident where the stag went into Kildalkey school yard. We heard about it and saw the photograph of the little children with their faces pressed against the classroom windows as they looked out terrified as the stag came into the school yard. We are also aware of the incident that occurred before Christmas where a stag jumped onto the bonnet of a car, which nearly had disastrous consequences. We know too about a gardener — a friend of mine and of Deputy Trevor Sargent — into whose garden a stag entered when the hunt chased it.
This issue passes all political boundaries. It is an issue of safety and we should recognise that and that the urban environment is increasingly encroaching on the countryside of both Deputy McEntee's constituency and the constituency of Dublin North. I gave up shooting and fishing because the countryside has changed. If I am having a go at the Labour Party, I am doing it with scientific facts. There is hardly a fish in our rivers now. We have catch and release for salmon and some rivers are still closed. The reason this is the case is because when Deputy Gilmore was Minister of State, he legalised monofilament drift netting. We are still suffering from that decision in the great riverine constituency I represent, with the Nore, the Barrow and the Slaney. This is the reason also that tourism is falling. People used to come here to fish but because monofilament drift netting was legalised, we lost billions in revenue. We are still losing billions because of these walls of death in our sea capturing salmon and almost causing them to become extinct.
The issue we are debating today is an issue that goes beyond party politics. It is an issue of safety. If I or any reasonable person had a daughter in Kildalkey school on the day the stag entered the yard, we would have asked why it was deer could run into the yard or over car bonnets and cause distress to local people. We have not addressed the issue of animal welfare either. I attended a meeting recently in the Royal College of Physicians at which a vet spoke about the distress caused to the deer. I know the Deputy said the deer is only carted out once every so often and is then returned to its place in Meath. However, the vet told me and hundreds of others at the meeting that there is huge stress on the animal. Therefore, we must talk about animal welfare and about man as a thinking being with control over animals under his care. Is it right that he gets pleasure from the hunt?
Perhaps we should have a philosophical discussion on whether we get pleasure out of causing fear and anxiety to animals. Perhaps people do not think about that, but only about the thrill of the chase. The stag is a farmed animal whose antlers have been cut off. When the stag is cornered with the hounds at bay, grown men jump on the stag, bring it to the ground and wrestle it back into the horsebox. Man is a sentient being with a higher mind than an animal. Is it right for him to take pleasure in this? That is what is at the heart of this Bill. The issue is not jobs or pleasure, but about man as a superior being having control over animals. This is the philosophical question.
Comment on this
We catch fish to eat them. People are not chasing the deer to eat it. As the Deputy knows, we are not afraid of culling deer when they need to be culled in our national parks when they overgraze or over populate an area. I know the statistics. I am a country woman born and bred.
Comment on this
It is a philosophical debate whether man takes pleasure from causing pain to a lower being. That is the question we must ask. This Bill is being introduced to ensure we protect animal welfare and an increasingly urbanised environment in the area represented by the Deputy. In picking Meath County Council as one of the councils for a review of planning practice, the Minister shows he is conscious of the extensive nature of over-rezoning and planning in that area. This fleshes out my argument. Meath has become completely urbanised in parts and the hunt has the capability to drive a stag into that urban environment. That is not good.
As a person who understands the countryside well and who was brought up in the countryside, I used to follow the Bray harriers. I used to fish, but now there are no fish in the rivers. I used to shoot, but my local environment has changed and because of climate change and the fact the bogs have been drained, the wild birds such as woodcock, pheasant and snipe are no longer there. Let no person from Rural Ireland Says Enough, RISE, tell me I do not understand the countryside because I do. Let no person from RISE tell me this Bill is the thin edge of the wedge. It is not. There is nothing in the programme for Government that will put a stop to fishing or shooting, and the Deputy knows that. This Bill is not part of some salami slicing agenda that the people in RISE, Fine Gael or the Labour Party want to latch on to. This is a simple Bill to protect the people of north Dublin and to protect animals.
I appreciate the concerns of Deputy McEntee, who spoke from the heart. I speak as a practical countrywoman who was elected by the people of Carlow-Kilkenny and who knew the Green Party policies when the people elected me to this House with their votes. I have no fear about the future. The people will either reject me or return me, but I must be honest with myself. As a country person, I know how the countryside ticks. I find it despicable of RISE not to take into account where I come from as a rural Deputy. I am happy to point out that Mr. Mike Bailey and the Labour Party are now in the same tent as they are both on the one side.
Comment on this
Deputy Tuffy described this far-reaching Bill as a small Bill and — as one of many pieces of legislation for which the Green Party is responsible — as a trophy Bill. She suggests it is a Bill that will cover up areas where we have not achieved. I do not intend to spend too long on that argument because it is laughable.
We have made achievements, particularly following the programme for Government negotiations of 2009. Deputy Tuffy asked what was the difference between our achievements of 2007 and of 2009. The simple answer is mathematics. In 2007, the Green Party was not absolutely required and we had less of an input. However, we decided to enter Government anyway in order to achieve what we could. That was the right thing to do rather than hurl from the ditch. There was, of course, an alternative. We are all aware of the story of how Deputy Kenny rang my colleague, Deputy Sargent, and asked him to talk to Sinn Féin. That was done, but a couple of years later he denied it and basically accused me and Deputy Sargent of lying. I am speaking about "honest Enda" as he has been described by some of his colleagues. We know there could have been an alternative, but there was not.
The only alternative, therefore, was Fianna Fáil and the Green Party. The mathematics mattered in 2009 and because the Green Party numbers had a more relative import then, we had more clout in the programme for Government negotiations. Therefore, we achieved more in areas such as sustainable measures to deal with the impact of climate change, widening the tax base, protecting the education budget at a time of economic recession, stopping the reintroduction of third level fees, creating new green jobs and cleaning up the planning mess caused over many years among the larger parties. In addition to these legislative achievements, we also took tough, but necessary and unpopular decisions to sort out a mess that was not of our own making.
Comment on this
A total of 450,000 people are unemployed.
Comment on this
I am a GAA man and am as able to muck it as any man from County Meath. Members already had this debate at Christmas and it would be the easiest thing in the world to jump off the ship and start a populist rant to the effect that one could not do something because it is unprincipled. It is far more principled to stay until the last blow of the whistle and to take all the knocks because one stands up for one's team. My country is this team.
Comment on this
In this context, the Green Party is introducing legislation in the belief that it is the right thing to do. It has nothing to do with popularity. Deputy Tuffy also asserted that this legislation was an attempt to save a seat or two for the Green Party but again, this is baloney. Deputy Tuffy lives a couple of doors away from me and I am sure she will testify directly or under a lie detector that were she asked about me specifically, she would acknowledge that rarely if ever has she seen any reference to animal rights in my leaflets. I talk about dodgy planning by Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael. I talk about school infrastructure, the Liffey Valley Shopping Centre and issues within the community. I do not talk about animal rights, even though it is something about which I am passionate, because my constituents, to be honest, are not that concerned about it.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy check all the Green Party's members? Has he done that?
Comment on this
If asked, the majority of people in Ireland wish to have stag hunting banned. The majority of people, including those living in rural areas, also wish to have hare coursing banned.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows what I am talking about too.
Comment on this
Politics is the art of the possible and this is what the Green Party is attempting to do. I have never included anything about animal rights on my leaflets because I work for my community. This is all about doing the right thing. It may cost me votes. I will not gain a single vote for standing up for animal rights but may lose a few for so doing. While I may lose the votes of those who do not wish this legislation to be passed, it will not gain any votes for me. However, it is the right thing to do, which is the reason I support it.
Unfortunately, in this instance the Labour Party, if Members pardon a pun that may have been used earlier, appears to be running with the hare and hunting with the hounds. I used to believe the Labour Party had principles and I know this used to be the case. Deputy Tuffy is someone for whom I have great admiration and she certainly has principles. I question the decisions by some Labour Party members, such as the example provided by Deputy White of the introduction of monofilament drift netting by the then Minister of State, Deputy Gilmore. My favourite is the introduction of incineration by Deputy Stagg, as well as the votes in favour of the Ringsend incinerator in the Dublin regional waste management plan by Labour Party councillors, among others. Despite this, poor old Deputy Gormley now receives all the harangues and harassment about the subject although its introduction was not his fault.
Comment on this
I have been accused by the Labour Party about raising the issue of bad planning decisions and I acknowledge that very few dodgy or corrupt decisions were made by Labour Party members. However, many bad ones were made. For instance, in the home of the Mullingar accord, enough land was rezoned to last until 2083, which constitutes bad planning. Similarly, it is bad planning when Deputy Gormley has been obliged to reverse decisions made by councillors across the country because they are creating unsustainable communities.
Comment on this
The Deputy should go back to his own party members.
Comment on this
I argue that the fabric, heart and soul of rural communities throughout the country have been destroyed to a far greater extent by bad or dodgy planning in exchange for a few legitimate donations or because of poor thinking than because of stags or hare coursing.
Comment on this
The Deputy should go back to his own party members. People in glass houses should not throw stones.
Comment on this
People in glass houses should not throw stones.
Comment on this
——and the clout do not add up for the Green Party to ban hare coursing although we have expressed our desire to get rid of hare coursing.
Deputy Higgins had principles and introduced legislation on this issue. Had he been in power with the Green Party in a left-leaning alliance, he would have managed to ban stag hunting outright. However, he was in coalition with Fine Gael and so he did what he could. The Green Party is in coalition with Fianna Fáil and I make no apologies for doing what we can to implement Green Party policy as befits the mandate we are given by the people. I respect those who work to achieve what they can based on what they know to be right and to take the flak when they are obliged to make what might be an unfair decision, albeit for the right reasons.
However, new Labour in particular is not like that. It now appears to be the stand-for-nothing party. It is the party that offends no one and which avoids offending its trade union donors or potential new rural voters. It will share common cause with the Bailey brothers if that means turning into a rural catch-all party like Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael. Deputy Tuffy stated that this legislation would divide communities and that we need rural and urban to work together to pull the economy forward.
While tourism is a great way to bring people together and to pull them forward, the tourism industry has been decimated because of bad and dodgy decisions. As for the issue of jobs and the influence of the Ward Union Hunt this issue does not pertain to jobs. It is about the boys on top of the horses not being willing to drag hunt. They are not willing to lay down a scent for the hounds to follow as they can do everything else with the arrangement of the farmers. However, they want to cause wanton cruelty and to engender dread in the stag. There is no other reason for it because they can do everything else. They can dress up in their finery; they can lord it over every field and can pee off some of the farmers who do not wish them to go across their land. However, they do not wish to do this if they are dragging a scent. They want to have the fun implicit in scaring the bejasus out of a dumb animal. I say that they, and not the stags, are the dumb animals in this instance.
Many proud rural traditions have been stopped over the years. Several hundred years ago, although some chauvinists among Members might call for its reintroduction, a woman who scolded a man could be dumped into the river. That legislation was only repealed in the United Kingdom in 1967. Although it was a proud tradition in many communities that a woman who spoke up for herself could be sorted out, that now has gone. I acknowledge this is a frivolous argument. However, in respect of the issue of female genital mutilation, which has been mentioned previously in the media, a much sorrier tradition is being carried on. One is accused of being an imperialist Westerner when one dares to suggest that this is a cruel and abhorrent practice. The same sort of cultural imperialism message, to paraphrase Edward Said, is coming across in this spurious rural-urban argument to the effect that somehow, anyone who suggests it might be wrong to treat an animal cruelly is purely a jackeen who knows nothing about rural issues.
Comment on this
Deputy White has proved that point to be wrong and many people in rural areas also consider this practice to be wrong. The programme for Government is the wedge and there is no other thin end or hidden agenda. The Green Party has the input based on its numbers and that is what will happen. I assure Deputy McEntee that this legislation will be passed next week, after which we will move on to the Planning and Development (Amendment) Bill and we will sort out dodgy planning once and for all.
Comment on this
The Green Party will get some mess when that it is introduced. The Deputy should look at his own party's members.
Comment on this
I call Deputy Sherlock for a very brief contribution. Although this debate will adjourn shortly, he will be in possession when it resumes.
Comment on this
I appreciate the time yielded to me by Fine Gael on this issue. In the short time available to me, I do not intend to go into some of the comments I have just heard. I have no intention of personalising this issue even though people have referred to me and to my colleagues. In the view of the Labour Party, the bottom line is whether this legislation is necessary at present, whether it is purely politically motivated or whether it is based on true animal welfare. In 2007, the Minister, Deputy Gormley, issued a licence to the Ward Union Hunt on which, unless I am mistaken, he placed 27 conditions. In 2008, he issued a licence to the Ward Union Hunt on which 34 conditions were placed. In 2009, he issued a licence to the Ward Union Hunt, unless I am mistaken, on which he placed 35 conditions.
If one speaks to the rights of man, common sense or a man's motivation, if at that time, he as Minister issued a licence for that hunt to proceed, surely that includes a tacit understanding that he recognised its right to exist as a hunt?
Comment on this
—— and the solution proposed by Deputy Higgins in 1997 was a reasoned, rational and responsible approach.
Comment on this
I asked the Deputy to move the adjournment. He will be in possession when we resume next week.
Comment on this
The absolute fundamentalists who exist within this Parliament legislate on an absolutist approach. It is the wrong way to do so because I foresee trouble ahead in respect of this legislation. It is the wrong way to legislate.
Comment on this
I invite Deputy Sherlock to move the adjournment of the debate. He will be in possession on its resumption.
Comment on this
It remains to see whether Fianna Fáil will stand up to the Green Party. The Green Party is in for a surprise on Tuesday evening.