We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Macroeconomic and Fiscal Outlook: Statements (Resumed)

Contributions 120–281 of 281. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Tá áthas orm deis a bheith agam labhairt ar an díospóireacht tábhachtach seo.

I know we are part of adversarial politics and this is highlighted by the nature of the Chamber in which we are. However, it is also important to try to rise above the temptation to be adversarial at times, particularly given the situation we are in, and to think more laterally than we are encouraged to do normally, perhaps through the media and other pressures on politicians to act in a certain way. I have listened carefully to the debate and the fact that we need to look at where we are in terms of the geographical and historical space has not yet been mentioned.

Since it was issued and separated from a tradeable stable commodity such as gold, the international monetary system has relied more than ever on confidence. This confidence is an extremely fragile commodity, if one can call it such. When I was Minister of State at the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, dioxins were an international issue which had to be worked at and confidence restored. This happened, but it takes serious focus to ensure confidence is at the heart of what we do. I am not speaking about false confidence, I am speaking about reasons to be confident. Without that confidence, the world of business, wealth creation and every transaction depending on money becomes problematic. This is why we need to reflect in a fair way that which is working and the positive trends as well as the problem areas, and this is not to shirk, shun or overlook those problem areas.

Unfortunately, good news does not make the biggest headlines so we need to try to ensure there is fair representation of good and bad news. It was reported in a very small article that food and beverage exports have increased and are 8% higher than this time last year. The Minister of State, Deputy Cuffe, mentioned this area as it is one of his responsibilities. It is important that we emphasise where we are doing well.

We state the Dublin bike scheme is part of life and that it is great but not everything. It is not everything but internationally, it reflects extremely well on Ireland. It is seen as the most successful, efficient and cleanest and the best. We need to take pride where we have reason to take pride and it is part of Dublin becoming a cleaner greener city. It is good for business in a very real sense.

Another small article reports that firms making a green switch report savings. A Vodafone survey of 100 companies found two thirds of businesses reported improved operating efficiencies, financial savings and more employment as a result of implementing environmentally friendly policies. These are aspects of Government policy — not the whole of Government policy — to which it is important to refer as they reflect something of which we want to see more, namely, people saving and making life more efficient with more employment and business opportunities.

The causes of the problems are difficult to deal with but they are being dealt with. Difficulties in our planning system landed us with the property bubble. This may be adversarial, but I am sorry to state that in local authorities Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael worked hand in glove. The Labour Party was not involved to the same extent. This had to be dealt with. It has been difficult but I admire the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, Deputy Gormley, for having the courage to face head on those vested interests. We have legislation in planning to take corporate patronage out of politics, which has been another cause of the problems we are debating.

The Green Party was right in forecasting problems that were symptomatic of planning corruption of the past. I was assaulted in Dublin County Council for highlighting that corruption back in 1993. It is now coming out in the wash. Unfortunately, at the time it was dismissed.

The Gulf of Mexico spill has cost the United States dearly and the environmental cost is international. It is seen as a BP calamity and a problem of human failure. However, if we were to be honest about it, it is a consequence of the end of the era of cheap oil. Unless we buy into the clear message and act on it rather than stating we cannot afford to act on it we will suffer. We will not win the businesses that will exist in future. Only economies without oil reliance will win those new businesses. The wake-up call is hitting us in a financial way and this is what is being reported, but let us not overlook the consequences and causes of those problems.

It is a disgrace how small and medium enterprises are being thwarted in their efforts to embrace and rise to those new challenges and create the employment needed. I listened to Deputy Varadkar and I agree with much of what he stated. Ulster Bank went into a company in my constituency and thank goodness there was the presence of mind to save the jobs when the receiver was forced to come in. I am afraid this was not thanks to the bank, and 15 farmers are now at a loss of €300,000 and business investors have lost their life work as a result of a bank acting when people were paying their bills. The company was still in business and in a good position to continue in business but the bank decided, in its own narrow self-interest, to enter into the equation. We have to rise above this and ensure regulation will deal with it and that the banks play their parts in getting us out of the problems in which they had huge part in creating.

Comment on this

We can go into the past and point to the macroeconomic decisions made by a previous Administration and the political consensus that existed at the time. We can speak about the lack of an apology for mistakes made or the relationship between builders, bankers, speculators, developers and donations to councillors throughout the country that led to and exacerbated the property bubble. We can speak about the lack of leadership shown by various political parties through their unwillingness to break the link by refusing to take donations from corporations, businesses and trade unions. However, time is limited and reality faces us.

We can speak all we want about the merits of dragging out our pain beyond 2014, even allowing for the extra interest payments we would have to make. However, the reality is that those poorly regulated monsters, the ratings agencies, which have called it wrong for Ireland before and will continue to do so, through the power they have been given to hold us by the throat. We made a commitment to our European partners and the European Central Bank to cut our deficit to 3% by 2014. Therefore, to give us a chance to retain what is left of our economic sovereignty we need to introduce a tough budget and front-load it with a balance rightly struck between taxation and cuts. It is a case of slash our wrists or someone will come in and stab us in the heart. Unfortunately, that is not much of a choice. We have a moral as well as a political duty to try to introduce the best budget and best four-year plan possible.

I stated previously that people need to be afraid — very afraid — lest we continue to believe the fantasy economics of those who can afford to hurl from the ditch and say we can stretch it out. This does not mean that as a country we cannot prevail. I believe we can and will get out of this mire. We have done it before and we will do it again. We are a creative and resourceful people. With our export sector continuing to thrive, our agricultural development and our tourism potential we have many jewels in the crown. Most of all, we have our people and their continuing high standard of education, a standard which I must emphasise needs to be maintained.

As Deputy Trevor Sargent stated, in getting through this period we need to be wary of the looming challenges of peak oil and climate change. Peak oil means the global standard of living faces a decline with energy shortages and massive increases in energy prices. We need to prepare for this decline in economic activity and live in a sustainable way. This recession is our opportunity. As a country, we are closer to Spain and Portugal than Germany but we borrowed from German pensioners to max out our credit cards. We can no longer do this. The price of imported fuel will continue to rise from a current price of €6 billion. We need to be able to produce that energy in this country and to store it as fuel to power transport vehicles, heat our homes and export it in order to create an extra revenue source. This is the future way forward, along with agriculture and technology.

The Green Party is prepared to make the tough budget decisions and to do the right thing but the budget still has to be fair and it must be seen to be fair and we must show political leadership. On previous occasions I have called for pay cuts for Deputies and Ministers and I do so again. We also need to scrap the ministerial Mercs as soon as possible, reallocate the Garda drivers back into working on the ground and create a pool of junior ministerial drivers. I acknowledge that Ministers need to work while travelling and they cannot be driving; it is very difficult to work and drive. I suggest a pool of drivers to drive Ministers in the Minister's own vehicles. This would send a message that we are not the elite. It appalled me to see Ministers driving into Farmleigh in their mercs as it sent out the wrong message. I, for one, do not agree with it. We need to show leadership. We need to show leadership and vision.

We must protect education. In the programme for Government the Green Party secured major reversals in education cuts and the protection of the education budget at a very difficult time last year. This time there is significant pressure to slash and burn the education budget. This is a regressive step that will cost us hundreds of millions of euro over the years. Finland invested in education during a time of recession. It is a country with a similar population to Ireland and now it is reaping the rewards of that investment. Accepting the pressures to front-load, we must admit it is impossible to avoid a hit on education but the Department of Education and Skills must be seen to perform better than every other Department. In that context, the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Education and Skills and the Taoiseach, must know that some areas are sacrosanct to the Green Party. Capitation must be maintained and the extra teachers promised must be provided. Language support and special needs must be protected. The delivery of school buildings and capital projects cannot be slashed too much as this will affect job creation and make the situation worse.

We must keep teachers in the schools. Education is the way forward. It will reap an economic benefit and therefore it needs to be protected.

Comment on this
Brendan Howlin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I call Deputy Frank Feighan and advise him there are seven minutes remaining before I call for questions to the Minister.

Comment on this

I propose to share time with Deputy Lucinda Creighton.

Some 94 years ago, the people who fought for the independence of this country proclaimed the Irish Republic and the right of the people of Ireland to the ownership of Ireland and the unfettered control of Irish destinies to be sovereign and indefeasible. The Republic also guaranteed religious and civil liberties, equal rights and equal opportunities to all its citizens.

We thought we lived in a democracy which is defined as a political form of government in which the government is derived from the power of the people. Effectively, we did not live in a democracy but rather in an oligarchy. This was a system ruled by a few persons. We were ruled by an elite group whose members were not the wealthy; this was an elite group of trade unionists, social partners, politicians and the wealthy. They made the decisions in this country and this House was left without any powers. Until the powers are returned to the House, we will not live in a democracy. We are answerable to the people who vote for the 166 Members of this House.

These are extraordinarily difficult times for the people of Ireland and the Government has announced that €15 million is required. People are angry with those who created the mess and this anger is tangible. This anger has been inflamed by the fact that the bankers, who contributed to our economic freefall, seem to be walking away scot free while small businesses and ordinary people are being hauled through the courts for relatively small loans.

As public representatives we sometimes spend too much time in the House trying to score points while thousands of Irish people are suffering incredible hardship with, unfortunately, much more to come. The people of Ireland know what the problems are and they want to see credible solutions, backed up by strong leadership. However, right now, they want to see a unity of purpose across this House in order to fix these deep-rooted problems. The least we owe to the people who elected us is for all of us to show strong leadership in this time of crisis. I agree with Deputy Gogarty that we have to get rid of ministerial cars and we should consider the gardaí who guard Leinster House. We are not in a time of war but rather in a time of crisis and we could free ourselves from these trappings of power. We have to show leadership.

Politicians have to review how the business of the House is carried out. Deputy Kenny said he would ask the people to decide in a referendum on the need for an Upper House. If politicians expect the people of this country to take the pain, we have to lead by example. I have no difficulty in saying that we have to take a cut in pay. I have already taken a voluntary cut in pay. I refer to Senator Donie Cassidy's remarks about the difficulty of living on €65,000 a year which is an insult to the people who are worried. We must unite together and we will get out of this mess through hope and leadership.

Comment on this

This situation of economic meltdown in which we find ourselves is a direct result of political failure. Politics in this House and in this country has been cocooned and completely disconnected from reality. It has been driven by populism and has proven itself to be more about self service than public service. The political system has failed us and it continues to fail our people. It focused primarily on individuals being re-elected rather than focusing on political accountability and proper governance of the State. It is time to change.

There has been much talk recently about sovereignty in the context of the IMF coming in to salvage our economy. There has been much talk about sovereignty in the context of the European Union and the European Central Bank. I contend the greatest threat to our democracy and to our economic wellbeing and economic and political sovereignty, is the prospect of Independent Deputies and Government backbenchers holding this country to ransom at the next budget or the following budget or the one after that. I am not prepared to allow this to happen. I am not prepared to allow narrow, local — albeit important in the local context — interests to be given priority by the Government ahead of the national interest and ahead of the political and economic priorities facing this State. Gombeenism and parochial politics have no place in the recovery of this country and the recovery of this economy. My main message to the Government is that we cannot allow Independents and backbenchers to hold the Government or this country to ransom. All Members of this House have a responsibility to ensure this does not happen and that it is not allowed to happen on 8 December.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We now move to the question and answer session which has been provided for. There is provision for the Minister to reply at the conclusion of the session. I invite Members to ask questions. I suggest that questions should be grouped.

Comment on this

I note that everywhere people are angry with those who got us into this mess, the bankers and even politicians. They are angry that these people do not seem to be answerable. After two years, what is the Government doing to bring these people to account for wrecking our country?

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister about the deficit target. We know it has to be 3% in 2014, but what percentage targets have seen set for 2011, 2012 and 2013 as we try to achieve the 2014 target? Will those targets be stated in the four-year fiscal plan? The Department of Finance's growth predictions are different from those of the ESRI. The variation between both opinions is significant. Will the four-year plan set out the various growth scenarios? Will it be realistic? Will it consider the possibility of negative growth, as well as the likelihood of positive growth? We hope we will have positive growth, but we do not know.

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister is aware that Germany and France have agreed a pact, the aim of which is to amend the Lisbon treaty. They intend to seek support for the pact within the EU. They would like penalties to be imposed on member states that do not stay within the limits of the Stability and Growth Pact. It has been suggested that voting rights may be withdrawn from member states as part of this new pact. Given that the Stability and Growth Pact is such a fundamental aspect of our current economic circumstances, does the Minister have a position on the proposed pact? Regardless of our disagreements about the target of 3% of GDP, I would like to know whether the Minister has a view on the matter. Can he tell the House what he will say when he meets his German and French counterparts in the near future?

Comment on this

Deputy Feighan expressed public anger about the country's economic position. I am sure he has examined the Watson and Regling report, which traced the causation of the economic crisis we are in. One of the great strengths of this country's economy has been its continued robust export performance. There was a substantial increase in the number of people in the workforce in the 1990s and the 2000s. Much of that strength has remained in the economy. A major crisis was created by the extraordinary property bubble, which was fuelled by and large by the availability of cheap credit after Ireland's admission to the eurozone. It is not just a question of the banks, however. The property bubble made increased tax receipts available to successive Governments. Those moneys were used to finance expenditures which were unsustainable. That is the essential reason for this country's severe economic downturn in late 2008 and 2009. If the Members of the House do not collectively understand the reasons this happened, we will not devise the correct policies that will enable us to emerge from these difficulties. I understand why people are angry with bankers, as Deputy Feighan said. When we talk about the gap between receipts and expenditure that has to be filled, we should bear in mind that the estimated annualised cash cost of the long-term write-offs in Anglo Irish Bank and Irish Nationwide is €1.5 billion. Apart from that, the gap this year between our receipts as a State and our expenses as a State is €19 billion.

The biggest impropriety in the banking sector was the degree and pattern of reckless lending. NAMA has established that such lending took place markedly in the case of Irish Nationwide and Anglo Irish Bank and to a lesser extent in AIB and EBS. The pattern of reckless lending was the core problem in the banking system. At the time of the nationalisation of Anglo Irish Bank, I pointed out that in addition to all the difficulties at the bank, there were serious issues of corporate governance. The Garda Síochána and the Office of Corporate Enforcement have initiated a full investigation into these matters. My understanding is that a large number of personnel from the Garda and the office are involved in these investigations. I understand the relevant interviews have taken place, or are to take place, as part of this wide-ranging inquiry. I also understand that the relevant files are being prepared for submission to the Director of Public Prosecutions. That is how criminal investigations are conducted in this jurisdiction and in neighbouring jurisdictions. I accept that inquiries on the other side of the Atlantic tend to be much sharper and quicker than they are here. The nature of our criminal justice system is such that investigations in this jurisdiction, like those in the UK and France, which are not any different, take a substantial period of time. I refer to complex cases involving commercial wrongdoing with criminal implications. I assure the House that those investigations are well under way and well advanced.

Deputy Flanagan raised the question of the 3% target of GDP, as our borrowing requirement, which has to be reached by 2014. With the exception of Sinn Féin, all parties in this House have signed up to that target. He then asked about the targets for 2011, 2012, 2013 and 2014. Of course the fiscal plan will set out those targets and the growth scenarios. The Deputy mentioned negative growth. There is no question of negative growth being a scenario in the four-year plan for growth and budgets.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach indicated yesterday that the annualised average growth that is predicted for the four years in question is 2.75%. Greater clarity will be brought to that matter in the plan, which will set out the target figure for next year. Work is under way in the Department of Finance to examine the various assumptions. A great deal of information has already been shared with the Fine Gael, Labour Party and Sinn Féin spokespersons on finance. I am doing everything in my power to expedite my Department's efforts to ensure information is put at the disposal of the Members of this House in a way that enables them to make judgments about what is possible in this year's budget.

Deputy Morgan mentioned the Deauville pact between France and Germany. I have participated in the Van Rompuy task force. This country's position is that the fiscal rules need to be tightened. Indeed, Ireland is the best example of why that needs to happen. Throughout the period when the asset bubble developed in Ireland, we were in full formal compliance with the Stability and Growth Pact. If one examines the Irish report on the Stability and Growth Pact for the years leading up to 2008, one will see that Ireland complied with the borrowing requirements and the rule about the size of the national debt. It is clear that the Stability and Growth Pact was——

Comment on this

As did Spain.

Comment on this

I am talking about the EU Stability and Growth Pact. It was not fit for its purpose of assessing the degree of risk to which Ireland was exposed. Issues like the competitiveness of unit labour costs and the development of asset price bubbles will be part of the revised Stability and Growth Pact. I have argued strongly for that at EU level. To date, the task force has focused on questions of fiscal rules and practices, such as the example I have just given, which would strengthen the pact and the practices associated with it. It is keen to provide for greater scrutiny and surveillance of national budgets in a Community-wide and eurozone-wide framework.

Deputy Morgan rightly referred to the recent declaration by France and Germany of their wish to see treaty changes. We are examining the implications of the proposed changes in our own domestic legal order, as well as in the European legal order. We have not yet expressed a firm position on the proposals, which lack clarity despite the impressive venue at which the declaration was made. The Government is formulating a position in this regard. I have made it clear that we are not, in principle, opposed to all treaty changes in these matters. However, we would take issue with any treaty change that would involve a fundamental change in the character of the Union itself.

Comment on this

Does the Minister support the punitive element of the suggestion?

Comment on this

Again, it is not clear how punitive the element of the suggestion is and that matter still requires exploration. That is as far as I can put it for Deputy Morgan at this stage.

Comment on this

On a point of order, will the Minister keep his replies a bit shorter because we want to ask many more questions on the behalf of the people?

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am sure he will bear that in mind.

Comment on this

I will keep my questions short.

In preparation for the budget, has the Minister any indication as to the ratio anticipated in the correction between current spending cuts and tax increases? In regard to the reforms under way under the Croke Park deal, what savings have been made through reforms to date and how are they benchmarked? What savings are envisaged in 2011 and how will they be assessed?

What specific measures does the Minister anticipate or are at least under consideration in terms of stimulating the enterprise economy, in particular the SME sector? If the Minister is to achieve his target growth rate of 2.75%, the SME sector will need quite a degree of stimulation and that has not happened to date. Effectively,the SME sector has been ignored in the past three budgets.

In regard to wobbly backbenchers and Independent Deputies, does the Minister envisage a scenario where the Government will do bilateral deals with these individuals to keep them on board in order to pass the budget?

Comment on this

The Independent Deputies are not wobbly.

Comment on this

Will the Government put national interest ahead of parochial local interest?

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister will have seen the following article but I would like to refer to it. In today's edition of The Irish Times, the economics editor stated in an article that: “Given all the factors [analysing the economic crisis] it is hard to avoid the conclusion that it is now as likely as not that the State will have no option but to resort to a bailout.” Will the Minister comment on that statement? The economics editor gives a very detailed analysis. Does the Minister share it?

Comment on this

I have not read it yet.

Comment on this

Okay.

This morning a Deputy referred to our country as a banana republic. While this country needs much reform, it is not a banana republic; it is a democracy. My party is willing to go into Government to sort out the ills that have beset the country. This is not some African country; it is a mature democracy and a member of the European Union.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are anxious to get as many questions in as we can. The Deputy is imparting information rather than asking questions.

Comment on this

The Minister acknowledged, by way of a reply to a parliamentary question tabled by me, that the bondholders in Anglo Irish Bank which matured at the end of September, the anniversary of the guarantee, were repaid in full on the evening of 30 September. Does he agree it was tactically foolish not to disclose that information to the Dáil and, therefore, allow and encourage a debate in regard to those bondholders, or that element of them which I believe is approximately €9 billion, and negotiation with them? In fact, he knew they had been paid in full. Had that statement been made——

Comment on this

The Deputy should be careful on that subject.

Comment on this

The Minister can answer the question.

Comment on this

I will answer the question.

Comment on this

We read the Minister's statements about it. He was going to the markets in New York for a bondholders conference shortly after that. Why did he not tell the Dáil——

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I remind the Deputy this is a question and answer session and not a Second Stage debate.

Comment on this

Why did the Minister not tell the Dáil and stop that speculation? In fact, the speculation he allowed to run on, tactically, enabled the markets to take a worse view of Ireland than was justified.

I would like to ask the Minister about his tactics and those of the various organisations under the remit of his Department. I ask him now, because time has elapsed, how was the redemption of those bondholders funded because I understand they were not rolled over under the ELG and were repaid in full? What was the rate of interest of that redemption? Was it current market rates which at that point I believe would have been approximately 6.25%? Is this along with the further €6 billion that the Minister proposes to issue in promissory notes by the end of the year which on today's rates would be at 7.25%?

Does the Minister have any strategy to rebuild confidence in our country which is not, and will not become, a banana republic if the Labour Party goes into Government?

Comment on this

I do not know from where the Deputy took the reference to the banana republic. Who referred to this country as such?

Comment on this

The Minister's officials will tell him.

Comment on this

It is not a very good sign of all-party co-operation when the source of particular information cannot be disclosed.

Comment on this

It is on the record.

Comment on this

I am not aware of who advised that this country was a banana republic. I agree with Deputy Burton that it is not one. However, I am concerned she raised a question which seems to be based on a story that appeared in a newspaper this morning. I am in correspondence with that newspaper. Obviously, I would not have been aware of the repayment of the bonds because they were a commercial matter between the bank in question and the holders of the debt. As I understand the position, they were guaranteed instruments and, therefore, the scope for negotiation, to which Deputy Burton referred, was not open.

As I said, I am in correspondence with the newspaper in question and I would prefer to leave the matter at that other than to correct the Deputy. She was not as inaccurate as the article but she implied in her question that, in some way, these bonds were ones which were capable of having discussions with the institution in question. They were, in fact, guaranteed bonds. She also implied that I had an awareness in regard to these matters. As I understand the matter, they were redeemed in the ordinary course of business.

Comment on this

Why did the Minister not say that on the record?

Comment on this

I was not aware of the fact.

Comment on this

I asked the Minister several times.

Comment on this

I was not made aware of the fact. I am not made aware of the routine operations of such organisations. There was a very large amount of redemption of guaranteed bonds in all the institutions coming up to the guarantee date. There was nothing unusual in that. The effect of the guarantee was that institutions were able to raise finance on the markets with the benefit of a sovereign guarantee and those instruments generally were expressed to lapse as and from the lapse of the guarantee itself. These instruments were no different in character. The suggestion that I would have a special awareness of it or issue a special sanction or a special approval in regard to this matter is entirely inaccurate and not in accordance with the facts. I am glad the Deputy has given me an opportunity to put that on the record.

In regard to the views of particular journalists on the question of whether Ireland needs a bailout, the whole purpose of what we are engaged in is to ensure that we do not need one. The position is that the National Treasury Management Agency was in a position to raise funds in October and November but the interest rates in the secondary markets were very high. On ten year money at the last bond auction, they went to 6.4%.

Comment on this

It is 7.4% today.

Comment on this

I will check that for the Deputy. It is on a very thin market. On the interest rate of 6.4%, the view was taken by the National Treasury Management Agency at that stage that the best course of action was not to go to auction in October and November but to do so in January 2011. That remains the position, as the Deputy is aware.

Comment on this

I asked two further questions. The balance of the promissory notes which are to be issued by the end of the year for Anglo Irish Bank and Irish Nationwide Building Society is approximately €6 billion. Under the terms arranged by the Government, the notes will have to be issued at the prevailing rate of interest, which stands at more than 7% today. Has the Department factored in the interest rates at which they will be issued?

The senior debt in Anglo Irish Bank was redeemed on 30 September. How was the debt redeemed? Was it done with further borrowings?

Comment on this

It was this that resulted in an increase in the Government's figure for savings from €7 billion to €15 billion. It would make up the difference.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Many other Deputies wish to ask questions.

Comment on this

As I indicated, I am not aware of the normal commercial operations of the bank. On the question concerning the promissory note, I have not received any submission to date regarding the precise terms surrounding the execution of this note. Therefore, I am not in a position to advise the Deputy at this stage as to what precise interest rate will be charged or how it will be computed.

Comment on this

The Minister's officials indicated the rate charged will be the current rate.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should refrain from imparting information.

Comment on this

I answered the Deputy's question when I indicated I had not received a submission in the matter yet.

On Deputy Creighton's question, the ratio between expenditure, both current and capital, and taxation, will be set out in the national plan. It is, however, a matter of general economic wisdom that a correction is more effective if it leans on the expenditure rather than taxation side. Budgetary corrections which rely to an excessive degree on the imposition of taxation have generally not been as successful as budgetary corrections which lean on the expenditure side. That is not to say the Government is not examining both taxation and expenditure options in the context of the plan and budget. While everything has to be examined, my general assessment is that a correction which relied, for example, by as much as 50% on the taxation side would do much more damage to the economy than a correction that would lean to a lesser degree on taxation. The economic literature bears out that contention very strongly.

On the question regarding Independent Deputies, while I am not engaged in any bilateral discussions with Independent Deputies, they are entitled to make their views known about the general direction of budgetary strategy. I am sure they will do so with me.

Comment on this

The Minister will have to sanction funding for any deals that are done.

Comment on this

Will he rule out such a scenario?

Comment on this

On the Croke Park agreement, I do not have a figure to hand. The various matters raised in the agreement are being implemented through the relevant bodies. The agreement contains an assurance that there can be no compulsory redundancies or pay reductions for those who are taking the benefit of the agreement. However, I have made it clear to the staff side that the savings that must be secured under the agreement must be more ambitious than those provided for and agreed therein.

On the issue of stimulus, there has been a substantial element of stimulus in the economy since 2008 through the extensive borrowing that has taken place to sustain the operations of the State. If this borrowing had not taken place, much more radical adjustments would have been required. The difficulty for the State is that we cannot rely indefinitely on this stimulus. It has brought too much pressure to bear on us in the financial markets and exposed the unsustainable character of our expenditure and taxation base.

Comment on this

Other countries have held debates similar in nature to this one. The British and German Governments also attempted to introduce legislation to curtail the activities of bondholders and hedge hunters who may have had recourse to secret bank accounts in Switzerland. Both governments were concerned to proceed in this area. Has the Government or Minister initiated any inquiries arising from a similar concern to those expressed by the British and German Governments?

When I asked a question concerning the identity of bondholders the Minister, as a shy individual, was modest about imparting information in the matter. Will he indicate whether it would be advantageous to the debate if the identities of some of the bondholders with an interest in this jurisdiction were to become known?

Comment on this

Having listened for two days to the helpful views expressed in this debate by all sides and given that budget day is only four or five weeks from now, will the Minister give a clear idea of what the Government will propose in terms of front-loading in the forthcoming budget? In the context of the Hallowe'en horror that is the savings announced for the next four years, will the Minister be more transparent than the Taoiseach has been about how the €15 billion figure was reached? Many decisions will emanate from the change in the figure.

Does the Government have a view regarding the threat from the French-German alliance to introduce a new treaty to impose penalties for breaches of the Stability and Growth Pact? Is the Minister aware that Germany and France breached the pact in the early 2000s and action was not taken to penalise them?

Comment on this

The HERMES computerised model for the economy used by the ESRI is the only economic model that is accepted. The Minister has taken a strong position on the need for the adjustment over four years to be €15 billion. Achieving this target is highly contingent on the growth rate applied in the model. As far as we can ascertain, the Department of Finance does not have a well developed economic model.

I draw the Minister's attention to remarks made by Professor Philip Lane of Trinity College Dublin when he appeared before the Joint Committee on Finance and the Public Service recently. He stated:

Macroeconomic models are of limited value if there is an insufficiency of adequate macroeconomic data. While the Central Statistics Office has a very good reputation for high-quality statistics, it is also the case that limited resources and inadequate coordination across State agencies means that there is a scarcity of timely data in relation to a number of key areas. For instance, the earnings data are insufficiently detailed to provide clear guidance on the full distribution of wage dynamics across the economy. The lack of a survey of consumer finances until now means that key financial dynamics at the household level are not adequately tracked. Similarly, the inadequate data on the distribution of transacted housing prices and commercial property prices has restricted analysis of the macroeconomics of the boom-bust cycle in the property sector.

When Professor Lane can identify three essential pieces of data that any modern economy would use to measure economic growth, it is difficult for the Opposition to rely on the Minister's figure of €15 billion as that which will be required to close the gap, as it will be based on whatever growth figure the Minister includes. It also is difficult to rely on the Minister's prediction of an average growth rate of 2.75% over four years. I presume that encompasses a growth rate of 2% in 2011 followed by three years of growth at 3%, which averages out at a rate of 2.75%. However, given that the Department of Finance has no sophisticated economic model that I know of, given the ESRI's model is coming up with different answers and that Professor Lane has stated there is an inadequacy in the data coming from the CSO in any model used in Ireland, are the Minister's estimates on growth and on the correction needed something of a punt or a guesstimate, rather than anything that is soundly based?

I cannot recall whether the Minister was present yesterday when Deputy Gilmore asked the Taoiseach what were the assumptions that were entered into the model to produce the projected growth levels and the figure of €15 billion. He received a very dusty answer from the Taoiseach and the Minister might reflect on this in his reply. If he wishes to bring Fine Gael with him for part of the road, it would like to be going on correct, rather than incorrect figures. Moreover, I am highly conscious that practically every figure the Minister has announced in this House over the past two and a half years subsequently proved to be wrong.

Comment on this

Let us deal with forecasting. Let us deal with the forecasts for GDP this year to ascertain how wrong they were. That would be a good point of departure, rather than the generalised statement with which Deputy Noonan concluded to the effect that every forecast was wrong. For example, in respect of GDP forecasts for this year, my Department was wrong because it was too pessimistic. Last year, in budget 2010, it predicted a rate of -1.3% but it now is at 0.3%. The Department was out by 1%. On the positive side——

Comment on this

The year is not over yet. The figures for the last quarter are not yet available.

Comment on this

No, one should be clear about this. At the time of budget 2010, the IMF predicted a contraction in GDP of 2.5% for this year, whereas there has in fact been a contraction of 0.25%. Consequently, it was wrong by 2% in a negative direction last year. The ESRI predicted last year that GDP growth would be -1.1%. As it now stands at -0.25%, the ESRI was wrong in a negative sense, albeit by a smaller margin. The Central Bank predicted that forecasted GDP this year would be a contraction of 2.3%, whereas we now are at 0.2%. We have turned a corner in the past year, even in respect of the aforementioned forecasts, all of which erred on the negative side.

Comment on this

That does not explain the additional €7.5 billion.

Comment on this

When discussing the reliability of forecasts, I accept Deputy Noonan's point that there is scope for error but that does not absolve the Government from making judgments and assessments, as it is obliged to do. These were the forecasts made in respect of 2010 but if one considers the IMF's forecast for 2011, it stood at 1% at the time of budget 2010 whereas it now stands at 2.3%. One can discuss forecasts and models and I acknowledge the ESRI has a HERMES model, which, as I understand it, is the single fully developed model in the country. However, I note that in 2009, the HERMES model predicted very substantial growth next year, which will not materialise. Moreover, in respect of the four-year adjustment, the Deputy referred to Professor Lane's observations on macroeconomic models and the adequacy of data. I agree with the Deputy regarding the property market about which our data are somewhat inadequate because of the absence of any transparent information thereon. However, regardless of the forecasting data, the Government must make a judgment and as I indicated to the House earlier, I will endeavour to supply Members with as much information as possible, even in advance of the four-year plan, on such matters in order that they can make their own forecasts and compare them with those of the Department. However, my Department looks at the different bodies concerned, considers the different data available to them and makes an assessment on that basis.

Deputy Costello asked about the extent of front-loading and this is a crucial issue on which the Government must make a final determination and which will be announced, at the latest, in the four-year plan itself.

Comment on this

Is the Minister anywhere close to so doing?

Comment on this

Deputy Costello also asked about the Franco-German declaration but I already answered that question when it was put to me by Deputy Morgan.

Deputy Durkan reverted to the question of bondholders. I wish to return to this subject because Deputy Burton raised an issue about payments to investors in Anglo Irish Bank. The fact that more than €7 billion of Anglo Irish bonds were maturing by September 2010 was pointed out in the 2009 annual accounts published in March 2010——

Comment on this

And the Minister referred to it in his speech.

Comment on this

——and in its interim report in 2010. I refer to note 26 on page 56.

Comment on this

The Minister understands the point being made by Deputy Burton. He is playing games.

Comment on this

I wish to put this on the record of the House and I——

Comment on this

The Minister referred to this himself in his speech.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Burton, many Members wish to ask questions and if you continue with these interruptions, they will not get in.

Comment on this

Members insist on some answers.

Comment on this

The funding profile of any financial institution is a commercial decision for the institution and is monitored by the Financial Regulator. Bonds are a usual source of funding for all financial institutions——

Comment on this

This is more tooth fairy stuff. This is the tooth fairy view——

Comment on this

——and I understand this source of funding has been replaced by a number of funding sources, including the issuance of new term debt.

Comment on this

——but Ireland does not have a tooth fairy.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I ask the Deputy to listen.

Comment on this

Deputy Burton should note that Members will not have a sensible debate in this House if she accepts defamatory stories in particular newspapers at face value.

As for Deputy Durkan's question——

Comment on this

I do not think the article I have to hand is defamatory. Is the Minister suggesting the article in The Irish Times is defamatory?

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Please, could we have the Minister, without interruption?

Comment on this

No, the Deputy knows exactly which article to which I refer and it is not that article.

Deputy Durkan asked a question——

Comment on this

It is the story that appeared in the Daily Mail?

Comment on this

Is the Daily Mail article defamatory?

Comment on this

In respect of——

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Sorry Minister. Deputy Burton, please. If you persist I will be obliged to ask you to leave, although I do not wish to do so.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Please respect the Minister.

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest the Daily Mail was defamatory?

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy, please.

Comment on this

When an inaccurate story is printed in a newspaper and the Deputy insists on giving it further ventilation in this House, I am at least entitled to put the matter on the record of the House to protect myself.

Comment on this

The Minister gave me a parliamentary reply on the issue last night.

Comment on this

Deputy Durkan asked about the arrangements regarding the identity of those who hold bonds. As I believe I have pointed out to him previously, there is no register of their identities. Such instruments are traded because they are in a sense tradeable deposits. That is their character. They are issued on a certain basis with the coupon representing the detachable interest claimable in the specified period of years and they are traded as commercial paper in markets on that basis. There are no registers embodying who they are. There can be from time to time speculation regarding their identities and of course those to whom they are issued in the first instance may be listed. However, if they are discounted in the market they are traded and there is no register of the current holders.

As for a double tax arrangement with Switzerland, I will ask my officials to look into the matter. As the Deputy is aware, both the United Kingdom and Germany have concluded a good arrangement with the Swiss authorities.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The next speaker is Deputy Rabbitte, to be followed by Deputies Brian Hayes and Coveney, in that order.

Comment on this

When does the Minister envisage he will be in a position to tell Members what growth rates he expects for next year? Given his remarks, it is his intention not to tell Members the deficit figure at which he is aiming until budget day? On the figure of €7.5 billion that was projected last year but that now has become €15 billion, I ask him to inform the House what elements make up that €7.5 billion. The Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources, Deputy Ryan, provided Members with a version of its make-up earlier today.

I refer to the sum of €1.5 billion that is the guesstimated cost of the promissory notes to Anglo Irish Bank and Irish Nationwide. The Minister will recall that when Members dealt with the NAMA business, he told them that the cost of the bailout of the banks could be ring-fenced off the national accounts. Members are familiar with subsequent developments in respect of EUROSTAT. However, does the Minister envisage any prospect of the sum of €1.5 billion in interest repayments being financed outside of the national accounts?

Finally, does the Minister not think he ought to summon up the courage to send a message to the Franco-German Declaration that, whatever they are contemplating, the last thing this little country wants is to have another referendum on the Lisbon treaty imposed on it.

Comment on this

Market analysts tell me and others that if a country is serious about reducing the amount of interest it pays on its national debt it must reduce its budget deficit to under 10%. We currently have a budget deficit in the region of 12%, which is the highest in the eurozone. When the Minister publishes the four year plan in November, is it his intention to give us that figure? Is it his view that in order to reduce the punitive charges we are currently paying on our debt we have got to get our deficit below 10% if the package, in its broadest possible light, is to be interpreted by the markets as a serious one? What is the Minister's view on this?

In his reply to Deputy Creighton, the Minister said the Croke Park agreement would have to show more ambitious savings. Can I take it from the Minister's reply that it is the Government's view that the agreement will be renegotiated? If there are to be more ambitious savings we will require a new agreement or an amendment of the existing one. Is that a correct interpretation of what the Minister said earlier?

Comment on this

I have three questions, all relating to bond markets and the ability of the State to issue bonds in the first quarter of next year. To develop on what my colleague, Deputy Hayes, said, what percentage of GDP does the Minister expect the bond markets to require our deficit figure to be in order for us to issue bonds next year? From the briefings the Minister has given to Opposition spokespeople and from people outside the House and his Department, I take the figure Deputy Hayes cited to be accurate. If so, what level of front-loading will be required to achieve that figure?

Up to what level of interest will the Government issue bonds? What is the cut-off figure that would make it no longer viable for us to raise capital? My understanding is that it is around 6%, and we have been well above that for quite some time. At what figure will the Minister instruct the NTMA not to attempt to sell Government bonds?

Third, and perhaps most important, in an effort to bring stability and certainty to markets at the earliest possible opportunity, has the Minister considered the option of bringing the budget forward to a day or so after the announcement in mid-November of the four year budgetary framework strategy, when that is agreed? This could convince the markets, over two or three days, of real action around a four year budgetary strategy to which the Government is committed, followed by real action in the form of the first instalment of that four year strategy. Is that something the Minister is thinking about? It is being spoken of openly outside the House and the Minister should give some clarity on it.

Comment on this

Most Deputies followed the same ground as Deputy Rabbitte in his first question. The deficit figure will not be postponed to budget day. It will be contained in the four year plan, as will the forecasts for particular years. My Department continues to work on those.

Deputy Rabbitte's second question related to the growth figure being fixed at €15 billion. A number of factors need to be considered in understanding why that additional correction is now needed. First, the overall size of the economy is now smaller, reflecting revisions by the CSO to last year's figures. Second, the level of nominal growth is now anticipated to be lower in the coming years. This affects the fiscal position in two ways. It reduces the ability to generate resources and directly impacts on the debt to GDP ratio. Third, given the outlook for interest costs, servicing the national debt is more expensive, adding to pressure on the public finances.

World growth for this year is now likely to be stronger than was previously expected and this is reflected in the upward revision of real growth for the year. In the last budget, real GDP was forecast to contract by over 1% but is now assumed to be broadly flat, or marginally positive. I gave those figures earlier in reply to Deputy Noonan. The global outlook is, however, more uncertain, with downside risks. In particular, notwithstanding yesterday's very good results, the activity in the United Kingdom economy, a major trading partner, is now forecast to be weaker in the coming years.

All of these factors suggest that the outlook for growth, both real and nominal, is less favourable than a year ago. It means we have to undertake a greater budgetary correction and in so doing there is an additional negative impact on the forecasts. That is why my Department now believes that a central forecast for the period out to 2014 would see average real growth of about 2.75% for the period, with growth being considerably lower than in 2011. Finally, most other commentators have revised downward their view of growth prospects in Ireland.

Deputy Rabbitte then referred to the fact that the cost of NAMA had been ring-fenced outside the national accounts for Stability and Growth Pact purposes. That is correct. This was achieved in regard to the National Asset Management Agency. However, the promissory notes are, in their terms, captured by the Stability and Growth Pact.

With regard to the Franco-German Declaration, I quite agree with Deputy Rabbitte. Were international negotiations to be embarked upon and were the State to commit itself to any fresh treaty relating to these matters, the Government would be anxious to ensure that any such treaty would not entail an amendment to the Constitution. That, of course, would turn on the terms of the treaty itself.

Comment on this

Is there is no hope of getting the €1.5 billion interest repayment off the national accounts?

Comment on this

As the note stands, that is the position. They are captured by the Stability and Growth Pact.

Comment on this

The Secretary General of the Department of Finance told me he was going to explore that possibility. Has he done any explorations?

Comment on this

Explorations are constant in my Department on a wide variety of matters.

Comment on this

We suggested that to him.

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy would not be surprised to hear that I suggested it to him as well. Explorations are constant and ongoing in my Department on the accountancy treatment of a wide variety of matters.

Deputy Coveney made a request in regard to the deficit figures themselves. That was the main focus of his questioning. The precise figures will be given in the four year plan for growth and budgets. The required deficit figure is closely related to the question of front-loading and the amount of front-loading, which will be given at the same time.

With regard to the yield levels at which we are prepared to borrow, I am guided by the advice of the NTMA in that matter. I am not prepared, at this stage, to assign a precise percentage beyond which we will not borrow. I emphasise that we were not shut out of the markets. We could have borrowed in October and November. We opted not to. I will take the advice of the NTMA in that matter.

Deputy Hayes also asked about the deficit figure required by markets themselves. That is a matter of very fine judgment. I will be guided by the advice of the NTMA in that matter also.

Comment on this

What is that advice?

Comment on this

No final advice has been given to me on that matter. Clearly, views are expressed from time to time but given the volatile state of the markets I will take that advice when the Government comes to make its decision on the issue.

I think I dealt with most of Deputy Coveney's questions. Did I neglect anything?

Comment on this

I asked about bringing forward the budget?

Comment on this

I apologise, I knew he had raised another issue. The budget is set for a fixed date in December and the only change we made this year is based on the belief that we can give greater credibility to the budgetary process by laying out a four year track whereby projections for anticipated growth, measures to foster growth and employment and adjustments to expenditure and taxation will be set out in advance of the budget. Furthermore, the end of November returns are an important element in the calculation of the annual budget because they allow for as precise a figure as can be obtained in regard to tax receipts.

Deputy Brian Hayes explored the question of reaching the 10% debt to GDP ratio. He rightly pointed out that our current debt to GDP ratio is the highest in the eurozone. However, until August we were able to borrow at attractive rates because the underlying strengths of the Irish economy were recognised by many international investors. These strengths include our robust export performance, flexible workforce and capacity to adjust our wage and price levels and asset values. Above all, we are moving towards a balance of payments surplus notwithstanding the substantial public borrowing required to fund the State. These factors are recognised in international markets and are among the reasons Ireland has been permitted to be an outlier for so long. The fact remains, however, that our current debt level is not sustainable and it is an exercise in judgment as to how far below it we should go. The Deputy referred to the market sources with whom he had discussed the matter but, while I will certainly take account of his, albeit second-hand, opinion, ultimately I will be guided by the NTMA in my assessment.

I already outlined the basic undertakings given by the State in respect of the Croke Park agreement. The agreement sets out procedures on a definite slate of items but it also provides a framework for the exploration of other issues.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I ask Deputies to make their questions short and concise.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

In respect of the €15 billion correction required over the next four years, what was the average rate of interest used in estimating Government borrowing? I am specifically interested in the figure for 2011.

The Minister spoke about the prohibitive level of our bond yields, which today reached a record high of 7.06%. Can he explain why they have reached such an alarming level? We appear to lack credibility in the markets. Will the interest that is accruing on our promissory notes be paid and can we persuade the EU to allow us to keep it off balance sheet?

The Minister and the Financial Regulator both stated it was mutually beneficial to all parties concerned that negotiations be held on the bonds of Anglo Irish Bank. Are such negotiations now underway between the bank and its senior bond holders?

Comment on this

In the past two days of so-called debate, we heard very few positive or hopeful notes from the Government side. Anyone who listened to the debate would want to go to bed and never get up.

In the context of the Franco-German proposals on further restricting member states, has Ireland made any positive suggestions on making available finance from foreign banks which are not at present trading here? Two of our retail banks are not trading and, as a result, people cannot start or maintain businesses. Has the Minister entered into discussions on ways and means of making it easier for people to borrow money from good banks in other member states?

Why do we depend on independent rating agencies about which we know very little to determine the interest rates we pay on our debt? Has there been any debate at European Council level on introducing a European rating system controlled by an independent body that would be accepted as reasonable and fair by member states? This could facilitate grouped borrowing by member states. If one is big and strong, one can get better terms than a small person. Why not allow the EU's 27 member states to rate Ireland? We may still have to pay higher interest on our borrowings than a country with a higher rating but it would not be as high as 7%. We should pursue these ideas rather than continually dwelling on how governments can be further restricted in dealing with their finances. We must come up with positive proposals that will help people start or maintain businesses.

My final question pertains to the talk about Dáil reform. I served on the Select Committee on Finance and the Public Service for three years, during which time I sat through three Finance Bills. Neither the Minister nor his predecessor accepted a single amendment over that period. Is the Government serious about Dáil reform or is it merely conning the people? We sat for days to debate NAMA but every amendment we proposed was rejected.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Barrett, many other Deputies wish to contribute.

Comment on this

Will the Minister give us a guarantee that he will consider genuine and positive amendments to the next finance Bill in the interest of the consensus he claims to desire?

Comment on this

Does the Minister agree we may be in breach of Article 9 of the Lisbon treaty, which specifically protects employment, education and social services? Does he accept that taking €15 billion out of the economy over four years will lead to a dramatic increase in unemployment?

Comment on this

A question of credibility arises in regard to the Government's ability for achieving savings. The way in which expenditure flew out of control in the past decade suggests it will be incapable of meeting its targets. What changes will be made to ensure we make the requisite savings while protecting services? Will new cost accountants and budget experts be brought in? If the plan is not credible, the markets will not believe it.

What interest rate does the Government expect to pay in the coming year? Our interest bill is heading towards €8.5 billion for the next four years and even a small change could add an extra €500 million. We know the UK managed to reduce its rate and we need a plan in place to reduce ours.

As public expenditure was allowed to run out of control, wages and social welfare increased. The Government made decisions based on false foundations, using housing money to set in place spending. When people received increased wages and social welfare, they also put spending plans in place, borrowed money and made commitments. Given the Minister is trying to cut back, they will be caught with commitments made and no money to match them. Will the budget and the four-year plan have some realism in terms of new measures to try to deal with people's short-term debts through deferral over a long period or by some other means to try to close that gap? If we do not do something, people cannot function. It is as simple as that. If the Minister's plan is not credible, interest rates will increase yet again.

Comment on this
John O'Mahony Deputy John O’Mahony Fine Gael

All Members agreed in the past two days of debate that people and businesses are looking for hope. I raised an issue yesterday on which I would like a direct answer. A small trader was informed by one of his suppliers last week that the supplier had a letter from his bank cancelling his overdraft of €50,000 and his direct debits. He contacted his local bank manager, who did not know anything about this. When he contacted the business section of the relevant headquarters in Dublin, a faceless official, instead of apologising for what had happened, told him not to try to put him on a guilt trip and that he would sleep easily in his bed that night.

The Minister owns all the banks in the country at present. Will he give a direction that these faceless people treat the business sector, particularly the small business sector, with respect? This case involves a sole trader who is providing 14 jobs. He has reneged on none of his debts and will not renege on any of them but he needs to be treated with respect. There are thousands like him. Given the Minister owns the banks at present, will he tell them to treat the people with respect?

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should pursue that matter by way of parliamentary question.

Comment on this

What specific measures will the Minister introduce to stimulate growth and to create and protect jobs? Will this form an element of the budget and the four-year plan? With regard to the travel tax and its impact on the economy of the mid-west, will the Minister give an assurance to the House that he will abolish this tax in the forthcoming budget?

Comment on this

Am I correct that the Croke Park deal commits to a saving of €1 billion over the lifetime of the deal? If so, has it been worked out how it will be implemented?

Comment on this

To follow on from Deputy O'Mahony's point that viable businesses are now closing, will the Minister at this late stage not reconsider a bank guarantee, which is the norm throughout Europe? It would get the economy moving, create wealth and assist the retention not alone of existing jobs, but of existing companies as well as the creation of new jobs. It is a no-brainer. Will he consider such a guarantee to ignite the backbone of the country and kick-start the economy? It is about small business.

Comment on this
Brian O'Shea Deputy Brian O’Shea Labour Party

First, I understand Irish private pension schemes have some €20 billion invested in the bonds of other states, particularly German and French bonds with a return of some 2% to 3%. Obviously, the spread on Irish bonds is much higher than that. Has the Minister proposals to make it attractive for these pension funds to invest in Irish bonds? It would seem that this would be a win-win situation because 75% of our private pension funds are in deficit at present, and a higher return would help to bridge that gap.

Second, personal savings increased by some 13% last year and this increase is continuing. I understand some €100 billion is in private savings in this country. Has the Minister proposals to attract that money into the Exchequer to help with the problem of having to pursue borrowings at very high interest rates?

Comment on this

In response to Deputy O'Shea, the pension schemes have substantial assets and, traditionally, they have not invested in Irish bonds. The NTMA is in discussions with them on that issue.

In regard to personal savings, I will examine proposals put forward on any side of the House as to how to release them. I must say, however, that proposing marginal tax rates in excess of 60% is probably likely to increase further the volume of precautionary savings in the banking system.

Deputy Perry asked on the question of bank guarantee schemes——

Comment on this

That is such a misquotation. That is why the Minister is where he is, unfortunately.

Comment on this

Deputy Perry asked on the question of bank guarantee schemes and whether a guarantee can be given to small lenders. What I say to him and to Deputy O'Mahony is that the Credit Review Office deals with appeals in regard to traders and has power to issue directions to banks in regard to the cancelling of overdraft facilities for small businesses. As to whether there should be a wider guarantee scheme, which is what Deputy Perry has advocated, we must remember that the cause of a great deal of our difficulty has been reckless lending. Any scheme that is designed to extend guaranteed credit to small business must ensure this risk is not repeated.

Comment on this

That would not be reckless lending.

Comment on this

Deputy Timmins referred to the Croke Park deal and the saving of €1 billion. Clearly, the Croke Park deal permits the redeployment of public servants in many branches of the public service. The jobs reduction programme that can be implemented as a result would save very substantial money to the Exchequer over the programme period.

Deputy Joe Carey referred to the whole question of the need to stimulate growth and protect jobs, and also inquired about the travel tax. Again, I will consider all of these matters in the context of the budget.

Deputy English said we had not much credibility in regard to managing savings in the public finances. As a matter of record, €14 billion is the total amount I have reduced or corrected in fiscal terms in the budgets since my appointment as Minister for Finance, which is a very substantial amount of savings.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

It has not worked.

Comment on this

Perhaps not, but it is a very substantial amount. It has been resolutely opposed in this House by Opposition parties.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

The Minister's policies have not worked.

Comment on this

The Deputy's party specifically has refused at any stage to look in a realistic way at the structure of public expenditure. They talk about administrative savings and budget managers when we all know what exactly the structure of public expenditure is and where the difficult decisions have to be made.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

The Minister's policies do not stand up.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Allow the Minister to reply without interruption.

Comment on this

I am entitled to reply to questions in this House. With regard to Deputy Finian McGrath's question, Article 9 of the Lisbon treaty commits the Union to a number of worthy objectives. However, none of these worthy objectives can be secured unless the basic financial system of the economy of a member state is on a sustainable basis. The Deputy referred to taking €15 billion out of the economy over the next few years. Of course, he is anticipating that others outside the country will lend us all the money in order to keep that money in the economy, which is a very far-fetched assumption and one that is not and cannot be entertained in our current position.

Deputy O'Donnell raised the question of the current very high rates in secondary market. I accept they are very high but it is a very thin market where Ireland is concerned at present. The developments in Portugal and Greece have been negative and there has been a corresponding deterioration in Ireland's position as a result.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

What is the average rate?

Comment on this

The average interest rate over the past two years, 2009-10, taking the options as a whole, was 4.75% for ten-year money.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

What was the underlying interest rate, the average rate, that the Minister was factoring in?

Comment on this

The interest rate bill will be dealt with in the plan.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

How did the Minister arrive at €15 billion?

Comment on this

Deputy Michael Noonan.

Comment on this

We have made those assessments.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

With due respect, if we are to have a questions-and-answers session, we should have responses. I ask the Minister to answer the question.

Comment on this

I am entitled to reply.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I ask Deputy O'Donnell to resume his seat.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

Is the Minister willing to answer the question?

Comment on this

I am willing to answer a vast range of questions. I pointed out to the Deputy that the information will be provided in the plan.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

How did the Minister arrive at €15 billion?

Comment on this

Deputy Barrett referred to the question of credit for business. The European Investment Bank——

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are over time.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

With due respect, I am entitled to ask questions.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I allowed Deputy O'Donnell to ask his question but we are running over time. I ask the Deputy to allow the Minister to reply.

Comment on this

I am entitled to reply to the debate. I now have only four minutes in which to reply as a result of——

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

If that is the case, he had better start answering questions.

Comment on this

——trying to assist the House by answering a very wide variety of questions.

Deputy Barrett should note the European Investment Bank already provided a substantial facility for lending to new businesses.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

He will not answer the question.

Comment on this

The matter of rating agencies has been discussed at European level. There is no doubt that the rating agencies talked up a lot of countries, businesses and firms worldwide on the way up and that they have been talking down many of them on the way down. The reality is that the rating agencies exist and have a right to free speech.

Comment on this

Why can Europe not do something?

Comment on this

What they say depends on the credence one decides to give to them. They have never given any opinion on me as a person or Minister for Finance and they do not do so.

Comment on this

They just rate his bonds.

Comment on this

On the question of borrowing on a group basis, as raised by Deputy Barrett, Germany, France and all the countries in the eurozone would be required to agree to borrow at a common interest rate. To date there has been no willingness on their part to engage in such an operation.

Comment on this

It would mean that we would have to pay a higher rate than Germany.

Comment on this

There is no enthusiasm or appetite within Germany, in particular,——

Comment on this

I ask that the idea be advocated.

Comment on this

——for any such common arrangement. It has often been advocated by other member states.

I thank the Deputies for their contributions to the debate over the past few days. They have touched on many issues. The main points that need to be made can be summarised briefly.

Over the past two years, the Government has not hesitated to take big decisions to stabilise the banks and the public finances. Despite the fact that we are achieving stability in the financial sector and that Exchequer revenues are also stabilising, it is imperative that the Government demonstrate again that it has the ability to act decisively by making further adjustments. There have been unfavourable developments, referred to in my replies, that have affected the overall economic outlook and market sentiment. We cannot put off decisions to address the €19 billion gap in the public finances. The longer we wait to do this, the higher the proportion of our taxes that will have to be devoted to servicing our debt. Such a delay would be predicated on the unlikely assumption that markets would allow it without at least increasing the interest rates on Irish debt. It is neither credible nor sensible to delay making the adjustments to meet the deficit target of 3% of GDP by 2014.

Making these adjustments will be difficult, but in doing so the Government will be mindful of the economic impact of whatever it will do and will, therefore, seek to minimise any harm it might cause to the economy. At all stages, we must protect the vulnerable in so far as we can but we must not allow any section of the community believe it cannot make any contribution. Everyone must make a contribution and those who have most must contribute most, but everybody will have to contribute something. As a result of the briefing that the Opposition parties have been given by my Department and from the speeches of the Taoiseach over the course of this debate, the Opposition should now have a clear picture of the issues facing us in dealing with the public finances.

It is clear that the adjustments that will have to be made will be painful for living standards but it is essential that we all keep a sense of perspective on this matter. Over the past decade or so, living standards for all, including for those dependent on social welfare payments, have increased considerably. Over the past five years, even the lowest rate of welfare payment rose by some 45%, several multiples of the increase in prices over this period. On the labour market side, while there have been serious job losses in construction, employment in other sectors has held up well, such that we have close to 1.9 million at work earning wages that had also increased above the cost of living. Following the adjustments that have to be made, we will still hold on to most of the substantial gains in living standards that we achieved in recent years.

The four-year plan will not confine itself to adjustments to the public finances. They, on their own, cannot deliver economic growth. A key part of the plan will focus on structural reform, both to increase employment and economic output and income. We must change the way in which the economy works, both in the public and private sectors. The public service has a critical role to play in our economic recovery and in underpinning growth over the longer term. Public service numbers have to fall. The costs of public services have to be reduced and the way in which these services are delivered has to be reformed and transformed. This is why the Croke Park agreement is important as a framework under which these changes can be delivered. In making these points, I do not imply any general criticism of the public service and must say that many of the criticisms miss the mark, often by a wide margin.

In the private sector, we must make proposals to reduce costs further and continue to improve competitiveness. These proposals will be a critical part of the plan if we are to base our economic future on export-led growth. Already, our exports have recovered strongly in response to the recovery in wage and cost competitiveness. We must also support our indigenous companies, especially small businesses, by helping them to reduce their costs and administrative burdens. For all sectors we have to do more than just improve cost competitiveness. We must ensure the workers available to fill future jobs will be suitably qualified and trained. We must take action to ensure that all businesses — whether selling to the export or domestic market — operate in a wider economic environment where all sectors operate efficiently and none acts as an expensive or inefficient drag on another.

In the weeks ahead, the Government will agree a framework and plan for the next four years which will be critical for our economic recovery. Acting on this plan will involve difficult decisions because they will cause pain for many, but we have no choice but to make them. If we make the adjustments now, we will ensure a better hereafter for our economy and our children. If we act resolutely, the reward for all of us will be the securing of a strengthened economy and renewed society for us and the next generation.

Comment on this