Financial Resolutions 2011
Contributions 1–127 of 247. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
If I could have some ciúnas, we will proceed, as a limited time is available for this debate.
Comment on this
I move the following financial resolutions:
Financial Resolution No. 1: Excise (Mineral Oil Tax)
(1) THAT for the purposes of the tax charged by virtue of section 95 of the Finance Act 1999 (No. 2 of 1999), that Act be amended, with effect as on and from 8 December 2010, by substituting the following for Schedule 2 to that Act (as amended by section 64(1)(d) of the Finance Act 2010 (No. 5 of 2010)):
"SCHEDULE 2
Rates of Mineral Oil Tax
(With effect as on and from 8 December 2010)
Description of Mineral Oil | Rate of Tax
Light Oil:
Petrol | €576.22 per 1,000 litres
Aviation gasoline | €576.22 per 1,000 litres
Heavy Oil:
Used as a propellant | €465.70 per 1,000 litres
Used for air navigation | €465.70 per 1,000 litres
Used for private pleasure navigation | €465.70 per 1,000 litres
Kerosene used other than as a propellant | €38.02 per 1,000 litres
Fuel oil | €60.73 per 1,000 litres
Other heavy oil | €88.66 per 1,000 litres
Liquefied Petroleum Gas:
Used as a propellant | €88.23 per 1,000 litres
Other liquefied petroleum gas | €24.64 per 1,000 litres
Coal:
For business use | €4.18 per tonne
For other use | €8.36 per tonne
".
(2) It is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public interest that this Resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act 1927 (No. 7 of 1927).
Financial Resolution No. 2: Excise (Air Travel Tax)
(1) THAT section 55(2) of the Finance (No. 2) Act 2008 (No. 25 of 2008) be amended by substituting the following for paragraph (b)—
"(b) Air travel tax shall be charged, levied and paid at the rate of €3 per departure of a passenger on an aircraft from an airport.”.
(2) THAT this Resolution shall have effect as on and from 1 March 2011.
(3) IT is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public interest that this Resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act 1927 (No. 7 of 1927).
Financial Resolution No. 3: Excise (Vehicle Registration Tax)
(1) THAT, as on and from 1 January 2011—
(a) the repayment of amounts of vehicle registration tax in respect of the registration of certain new vehicles in accordance with the provisions of section 135BA of the Finance Act 1992 (inserted by section 107 of the Finance Act 2010)), be extended to such vehicles registered on or before 30 June 2011 up to a maximum amount of €1,250, and
(b) section 135BA of the Finance Act 1992 be amended in subsection (5) by substituting “that person’s spouse or civil partner (within the meaning of the Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Act 2010)” for “that person’s spouse”.
(2) THAT, with effect as on and from 1 January 2011, the Finance Act 1992 (No. 9 of 1992) is amended by substituting the following for section 135C (as amended by section 108 of the Finance Act 2010 (No. 5 of 2010) with effect from that date):
‘‘135C.—(1) In this section—
‘electric vehicle' means a vehicle that derives its motive power exclusively from an electric motor;
‘electric motorcycle' means a motorcycle that derives its motive power exclusively from an electric motor;
‘flexible fuel vehicle' means a vehicle that derives its motive power from an internal combustion engine that is capable of using a blend of ethanol and petrol, where such blend contains a minimum of 85 per cent ethanol;
‘hybrid electric vehicle' means a vehicle that derives its motive power from a combination of an electric motor and an internal combustion engine and is capable of being driven on electric propulsion alone for a material part of its normal driving cycle;
‘plug-in hybrid electric vehicle' means a series production vehicle that derives its motive power from a combination of an electric motor and an internal combustion engine, where the electric motor derives its power from a battery that may be charged from the internal combustion engine and an alternating current (AC) electric mains supply and is capable of being driven on electric propulsion alone for a material part of its normal driving cycle.
(2) (a) Where a person first registers a category A vehicle or a category B vehicle during the period from 1 January 2011 to 31 December 2012 and the Commissioners are satisfied that the vehicle is—
(a) a series production hybrid electric vehicle, or
(b) a series production flexible fuel vehicle,
then the Commissioners shall remit or repay to that person an amount equal to the lesser of—
(i) the vehicle registration tax which, apart from this subsection, would be payable in respect of the vehicle in accordance with paragraph (a) or (c) of section 132(3), or
(ii) the amount specified in the Table to this subsection which is referable to the vehicle having regard to its age.
(b) In this subsection ‘age’, in relation to a vehicle, means the time that has elapsed since the date on which the vehicle first entered into service.
Age of vehicle | Maximum amount which may be remitted or repaid
New vehicle, first registration | €1,500
Not a new vehicle but less than 2 years | €1,350
2 years or over but less than 3 years | €1,200
3 years or over but less than 4 years | €1,050
4 years or over but less than 5 years | €900
5 years or over but less than 6 years | €750
6 years or over but less than 7 years | €600
7 years or over but less than 8 years | €450
8 years or over but less than 9 years | €300
9 years or over but less than 10 years | €150
10 years or over | Nil
(3) (a) Where a person first registers a category A vehicle or a category B vehicle during the period from 1 January 2011 to 31 December 2012 and the Commissioners are satisfied that the vehicle is a plug-in hybrid electric vehicle, then the Commissioners shall remit or repay to that person an amount equal to the lesser of—
(i) the vehicle registration tax which, apart from this subsection, would be payable in respect of the vehicle in accordance with paragraph (a) or (c) of section 132(3), or
(ii) the amount specified in the Table to this subsection which is referable to the vehicle having regard to its age.
(b) In this subsection ‘age’, in relation to a vehicle, means the time that has elapsed since the date on which the vehicle first entered into service.
Age of vehicle | Maximum amount which may be remitted or repaid
New vehicle, first registration | €2,500
Not a new vehicle but less than 2 years | €2,250
2 years or over but less than 3 years | €2,000
3 years or over but less than 4 years | €1,750
4 years or over but less than 5 years | €1,500
5 years or over but less than 6 years | €1,250
6 years or over but less than 7 years | €1,000
7 years or over but less than 8 years | €750
8 years or over but less than 9 years | €500
9 years or over but less than 10 years | €250
10 years or over | Nil
(4) A category A electric vehicle or a category B electric vehicle first registered during the period 1 January 2011 to 31 December 2012 is exempt from vehicle registration tax where the Commissioners are satisfied that such vehicle is a series production electric vehicle.
(5) An electric motorcycle first registered during the period 1 January 2011 to 31 December 2012 is exempt from vehicle registration tax where the Commissioners are satisfied that such vehicle is a series production electric motorcycle.".
(3) IT is hereby certified that it is expedient in the public interest that this Resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act 1927 (No. 7 of 1927).
Financial Resolution No. 4: Excise (Vehicle Registration Tax)
(1) THAT, as on and from 1 January 2011, section 132(3) of the Finance Act 1992 (No. 9 of 1992), be amended by substituting the following for paragraph (d):
"(d) in case it is—
(i) a category C vehicle, or
(ii) a category N1 vehicle that, at the time of manufacture has less than 4 seats and has a technically permissible maximum laden mass that is greater than 130 per cent of the mass of the vehicle with bodywork in running order,
at the rate of €50,".
(2) IT is hereby certified that it is expedient in the public interest that this Resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act 1927 (No. 7 of 1927).
The taking together of Financial Resolutions Nos. 1 to 4, inclusive, was agreed by the House in the vote on the allocation of time motion. Financial Resolution No. 1, relating to mineral oils, petrol and diesel, provides for an increase with effect from midnight tonight to the rates of mineral oil tax on petrol and auto diesel which, when VAT is included, amounts to 4 cent on a litre of petrol and 2 cent on a litre of auto diesel. The rate of aviation gasoline, which is aligned to the petrol rate, and the rates for heavy oil use for non-commercial navigation and flying, which are aligned to the auto diesel rate, are increased accordingly. The expected yield from these increases, inclusive of VAT, is approximately €106 million in a full year. These measures will increase the consumer price index by approximately 0.13%.
Compared to Northern Ireland the price of petrol was around 10 cent cheaper in the State and auto diesel around 20 cent cheaper. While the increases being made tonight will narrow the differential, it will still remain significant.
It should also be noted that the UK is due to increase its standard VAT rate by 2.5% from 17.5% to 20% with effect from 4 January 2011. In addition, excise on petrol and auto diesel is due to increase by slightly under 1% from 1 January 2011. The overall effect of these changes will be to increase the price of petrol and auto diesel in the UK and Northern Ireland by around 4 cent per litre in early 2011.
Financial Resolution No. 2, relating to air travel tax, provides for the introduction, with effect from 1 March 2011, of a single rate of air travel tax of €3 per departing passenger on a temporary basis.
This new rate of tax replaces the existing distance-related rates of €2 and €10. People will recall that the €2 rate relates to trips of less than 300 miles and the €10 rate relates to those of more than 300 miles. Some 97% of the tax has been in respect of the €10 rate.
It is estimated this measure will cost the Exchequer approximately €56 million in taxation next year. Ireland is not unique in applying a tax on air travel and a number of countries within the EU apply similar taxes, including the UK and France. Going further afield, both Australia and New Zealand apply similar taxes. The US has introduced a tourist tax on tourists travelling there by air and furthermore, Germany and Austria are currently in the process of introducing an air travel tax to apply from January next year. The rates of tax applied by many of those countries are higher than Irish rates, and substantially so in some cases. The trend in Europe is towards applying a tax on air travel.
There have been calls to abolish the tax on the basis that it adversely affects the number of people travelling to Ireland. I have difficulty in accepting that proposition and consider that the impact of the air travel tax is being overstated. The numbers travelling appear to be more closely related to other factors, including the level of economic activity.
Notwithstanding reservations, it has been decided that a single revised rate of air travel tax of €3 will come into effect on 1 March 2011. Let me be clear that this is being applied on a temporary basis until the end of 2011 and the position will be reviewed next year; the rate will be increased unless there is clear and decisive evidence of an appropriate response from the airlines through increasing capacity and numbers travelling to Ireland by air. As the Minister for Finance stated in his Budget Statement, in conjunction with this initiative the Dublin Airport Authority is prepared to introduce an incentive scheme for 2011 whereby it will provide, subject to certain conditions, a full rebate of airport charges for additional traffic delivered above a certain threshold based on 2010 passenger levels. The DAA will provide further details of that scheme.
Financial Resolution No. 3 regards the car scrappage scheme and the vehicle registration tax, VRT, relief for hybrid and flexible fuel vehicles. This resolution amends sections 135(b) and 135(c) of the Finance Act 1992 to provide for an extension of the car scrappage scheme introduced in the 2010 budget until 30 June 2011, and to extend to 31 December 2012 the vehicle registration tax available with a lower threshold for certain hybrid and flexible fuel vehicles.
The key features of the extended scrappage scheme include it taking effect from 1 January next and running to 30 June 2011. Up to €1250 VRT relief will be provided and it is available against the VRT liability on the registration of new category A vehicles, or passenger vehicles, with a level of CO2 emissions of not more than 140 g/kg. This takes in bands A and B in motor tax. A passenger car over ten years old must be scrapped at an authorised treatment facility in the State and a certificate of destruction issued.
The scrappage scheme introduced in last year's budget has been successful in contributing towards a large increase in new car sales in 2010, as they have increased 57% on the same period the previous year. It has contributed to the maintenance of jobs in the motor industry. Approximately 16,500 low-emission cars have been sold under the scheme up to the end of November, and the scheme is being extended to allow the industry to get the maximum benefit from its traditionally busiest period for new car sales in the first half of the year.
The resolution also extends the VRT relief available against the purchase of series production hybrid and flexible fuel vehicles which is due to expire at the end of the December. It is being extended for a further two years until 31 December 2012, with the maximum VRT relief available in that period of €1,500. To the end of November 2010, approximately 3,000 flexible fuel and 1,200 hybrid vehicles have been purchased.
Financial Resolution No. 4 addresses an unanticipated consequence of a provision introduced in the Finance Act 2010 which was to amend section 130 of the Finance Act 1992, whereby a small number of light commercial vehicles which would previously have been charged at the category C VRT rate of €50 will from 1 January 2011 without this amendment be charged the category B rate of 13.3% of the open market selling price. In order to rectify this anomaly and ensure that these vehicles will continue to retain the low VRT rate, it is necessary to amend the charging provisions for category C vehicles to ensure that such light commercial vehicles remain within that category.
The revised classification for vehicles introduced in the Finance Act 2010, with effect from 1 January 2011, was introduced as an anti-avoidance measure, as in some cases people were altering the specifications of vehicles; for example, extra body weight may have been added to the vehicle so as to change the classification and thereby considerably reducing the VRT liability. Many such alterations are also seen to be a safety risk.
Comment on this
On the point on which we voted, it is unfortunate——
Comment on this
I advise the House that we will have limited time to discuss these resolutions and there are many hands reaching towards me.
Comment on this
The Ceann Comhairle should have said that to the Taoiseach while he was at it.
Comment on this
If the Taoiseach is going to read out a ten-minute script at the start of each one of these, the 20 minutes will not be long being used.
Comment on this
I know the Taoiseach was doing the best he could to get through the speech.
Comment on this
I will try to be as concise as possible.
Comment on this
It is unfortunate that we must debate four resolutions at the same time because we support some but disagree with others. We must vote against all four as a result of the way this is structured. On the mineral oil excise, I do not understand why the cost of fuel is not being increased by applying an increase in carbon tax.. Perhaps the Taoiseach will explain why this is so. In the past number of budgets we have made a deliberate effort to introduce carbon taxation to Ireland to provide a cost for carbon and change the mindset towards carbon and its impact on the environment in terms of emissions.
There is no extra carbon taxation in the budget but there are increases in excises, and I do not understand why we are pursuing an excise increase when we could have raised the same amount of money by applying an increase in carbon taxation on fuel and by continuing to pursue the carbon strategy, which has now stalled. Perhaps I could get a response from one of the Government spokespersons on that issue.
The measure relating to air travel tax is the reason we are voting against this grouping. Fine Gael believes it is insane to charge people for the privilege of coming to Ireland on their holidays or on business while we are trying to stimulate activity in the Irish tourism sector. We raised approximately €105 million this year by charging people €10 to leave this island and next year we will continue to charge them €10 until March, although we know the measure does not work and is reducing passenger numbers through Irish airports. Even after this we will continue with the folly of charging people for the privilege of coming here while we spend considerable sums marketing Ireland abroad to get them here in the first place. It is a disincentive to people coming through Irish airports if we charge for the privilege, although it is difficult to calculate exact figures. Fine Gael has long made the case that we should abolish the air travel tax because it has not worked and is not working. The damage being done in terms of the tourist industry and visitor numbers to Ireland far outweighs the revenue stream provided for the Government.
The Taoiseach mentioned the incentive which the Dublin Airport Authority announced today, which is also flawed. If passenger numbers travelling through Cork, Dublin and Shannon airports next year go above a value of €23.5 million, the DAA will give a rebate to the effect of what it would have cost those extra passengers to travel through Irish airports. This will go to all the airlines, depending on the percentage of passengers attributable to different airlines. In other words they are not incentivising airlines to increase passenger numbers because even if that does not happen, an airline will get the benefit. If, for example, Ryanair provides extra passengers to get us past the €23.5 million value, all the airlines will get the benefit rather than the airline which provided the extra passengers. That makes no sense.
Comment on this
Each individual airport, whether Cork, Dublin or Shannon airport, should incentivise airlines.
Comment on this
Today's announcement by the Dublin Airport Authority relates to Dublin, Cork and Shannon airports. The same position applies to Knock Airport.
Comment on this
The Deputy is discriminating against Knock Airport.
Comment on this
I am not discriminating against anybody.
Comment on this
The Deputy's Government will shut down regional airports in the second half of 2011.
Comment on this
Will Deputy Flynn vote against the motion?
Comment on this
The public service obligation for regional airports will be cut by 50% next year. Deputy Flynn should read what her Government is proposing.
Comment on this
We need to have an aviation strategy that allows airports to incentivise airlines to increase passenger numbers.
I welcome the extension of VRT relief for electric transport, in particular, plug-in vehicles. I encourage the Government to be more proactive and aggressive in having a charging infrastructure established that such vehicles can use.
Comment on this
I will focus on two aspects of this group of proposals. Like the Fine Gael Party, the Labour Party proposed the abolition of the air travel tax. While I acknowledge that the Government has made a move in that direction by reducing the tax and has applied some conditionality to its application, this is one of the taxes, the disincentive effect of which is as much the fact that it is in place as it is the level at which it applies. While I understand that when the budget was being framed and calculations were being made, the Minister examined the amount and arrived at the proposal before us, in terms of its impact on passenger numbers and tourism leaving the tax in place means there is still a difficulty.
If the Government was moving in the direction of increasing excise on petrol and diesel, I, like Deputy Coveney, do not understand the reason this was not done by way of the carbon tax or carbon levy. This would have had a more general application than the use of the excise method. While I expected the budget to include an excise package — it is an understandable measure — I am puzzled as to the reason the excise measure is focused on petrol. Why, for example, was the Irish Cancer Society's recommendation on excise on cigarettes not taken up? Why were the various recommendations to increase excise on alcohol for health reasons not taken up? There were expectations and a certain amount of speculation that the budget would include increases on excise in these areas.
Increasing excise on petrol and diesel affects the one area where costs have increased significantly in recent times. Even in recent days, the price of petrol and diesel has increased on the forecourt. Such increases impact directly on working people. The cost of travelling to work, doing business or running a van or vehicle associated with work will increase as a result of this measure. The proposal is misplaced. If excise was to be increased, other options were available. If the Government wanted to focus on carbon, it should have increased the carbon levy.
Comment on this
On behalf of the Sinn Féin Deputies, I oppose outright the proposed increase in excise duties on petrol and automotive diesel. It is incredible that the Government has made this choice. There is no question that this is a further tax on work and business. When one considers that those fortunate enough to have work must travel ever greater distances to access their employment one realises the net impact of what is involved here. People no longer use their cars for social purposes. The bulk of car use is directly related to accessing employment or the furtherance of specific business pursuits. The level of car use for social activities and such like is limited.
The proposition will have a hugely detrimental impact in the Border counties where we already have evidence of retail petrol and diesel outlets closing or significantly curtailing their business throughput because of the exodus north of the Border across a variety of attractions. We are putting another nail in the coffin of business outlets throughout the Border region, from Donegal through Sligo, Leitrim, Cavan and Monaghan to Louth and for a significant distance beyond these counties. That is one of the most certain outworkings of what is proposed. The measure is anti-business and anti-employment and the Government has again made a very bad choice.
On the air travel tax, while the reduction from €10 to €3 is welcome, the abolition of the tax would have had a much more imaginative impact in terms of the tourism sector and tourism market overseas. For the sake of €3, the Government could have gone the whole hog and had a major impact on the consciousness of tourism providers and organisers globally in terms of Ireland as a more keen destination for tourist traffic. A golden opportunity was lost by applying the brake in reducing the tax from €10 to €3. The Government should have gone the whole way and abolished the tax. This would have given a valuable fillip to the tourism industry, one of the most important sectors in terms of having any prospect of rejuvenated economic activity over the short time ahead.
Comment on this
I greatly welcome the Government's decision to reduce the travel tax for international flights to €3. While there is no hard evidence to show this measure will result in an increase in the number of visitors to the country, there is, nevertheless, a perception that this is the case. The air travel tax, allied to airport charges, has been advocated by the chief executive of Ryanair as one of the principal reasons we are unable to attract the number of visitors we should attract. It is also cited as a reason Mr. O'Leary and his company should abandon PSOs. The proof of the pudding is in the eating and it is now a matter for Mr. O'Leary, Ryanair and other low charge airlines to establish the fruit of their words by increasing the number of visitors coming to Ireland in response to these changes.
I was interested in Deputy Ó Caoláin's intervention. The old Sinn Féin philosophy of "only our rivers run free" has been extended to having our petrol and diesel and even our drink run free.
Comment on this
The world, as we are probably all aware, does not work like that. I wish we could go to utopia and have a utopian time. Unfortunately, Deputy Ó Caoláin appears to be stranded at a crossroads somewhere between paradise lost and utopia, from which he has not returned.
With regard to Deputy Coveney's response to Deputy Flynn's legitimate intervention to the effect that she should read her brief, I resent that imputation. Deputy Flynn is one of our brightest young Deputies. Then again, coming from one of the few Cork men I know who does not know the difference between a pint of Guinness and a pint of Murphy's, his comment does not come as a surprise.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Donoghue should bear in mind what will happen to the PSO for Kerry airport.
Comment on this
Speaking as a Deputy who represents a constituency that is deeply affected by the air travel tax, it is clear the Government does not understand the aviation business.
Comment on this
The cost of administering the tourism tax greatly outweighs the likely income from the tax. The Government has been selective in referring to countries which apply a similar tax. The Netherlands, for example, which has one of the busiest airports in Europe, Schiphol, abandoned its travel tax last year. It is one of the busiest airports around. There was a golden opportunity here but it has been missed. It is a sad reflection of how the Government——
Comment on this
——treats tourism, the third largest industry in the country.
Comment on this
I would love to accommodate every Member in the House but I do not have the time. I must call the Taoiseach and I am affording him ten seconds to reply.
Comment on this
This is an issue I have raised many times in the House.
Comment on this
The Finance Bill will be debated in the new year and Deputies will have plenty of opportunities.
Comment on this
May I ask the Taoiseach a question?
Comment on this
What the Government has done in this regard does not make sense. It has actually increased the tax by one euro.
Comment on this
Deputy, I have to implement the order of the House for today, as was agreed. Resume your seat.
Comment on this
I have one question for the Taoiseach that has not been asked. What right does the Dublin Airport Authority have to provide an incentive scheme in regard to a Government tax? Surely it is the function of the Revenue Commissioners to collect the tax, which cannot be forgone by the DAA. Surely that matter is not appropriate to the authority.
Comment on this
On the same issue, a Cheann Comhairle——
Comment on this
What about the rest of the country?
Comment on this
I, too, am concerned about this. I mentioned it to Deputy Coveney because I thought he would be interested given that his party leader occupies the same constituency as I do. I would like to know about the impact of this decision. Has it been considered in terms of Knock Airport——
Comment on this
——which is targeting the same core business as Shannon, Cork and Dublin Airports? I appreciate incentives must be provided but there should be a level playing field——
Comment on this
——and I would like to see the issue addressed later in the week.
Comment on this
That was not part of Deputy Flynn's deal with the previous Taoiseach.
Comment on this
This is a very emotive issue for everybody.
Comment on this
Deputy Carey, you have been on your feet but the House has picked up the issue. I call the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
What is the Taoiseach talking about?
Comment on this
If we were to go the carbon tax route that would increase green diesel, home heating oil, etc. Under the programme, carbon tax increases are due in 2012 and 2014 and for that reason the excise duty was brought in as a route that would avoid increasing the price of other fuels. Advocating further increases on other fuels would not be a very sensible way to go and that is why we are not taking the carbon tax route on this issue.
We will see an increase in VAT rates from the British Exchequer. This is to keep the differential. What we are doing is presaging a change that is happening in the United Kingdom. Deputies will know that the price of diesel and petrol at filling stations is much less on the Republic side of the Border. I do not know what way it is with other operations.
It is important that we ensure this measure for the DAA where there is an increase in overall numbers. As an airport authority, it is entitled to incentivise airlines and has often done so.
Comment on this
The Government tax is separate. This is about increasing numbers. We must find a public-private arrangement that will help taxpayers generally by bringing more tourists to the country, perhaps even sending them down to parts of the county from where the Deputy comes. If we are to do that we must provide some incentivisation. The European Union is opposed to different rates or amounts being charged for different journeys. We can bring this to a uniform rate, to €3.
Deputy Flynn raised a very important question which needs to be addressed in the Finance Bill, namely, that we ensure airports that are not within the DAA remit but which have services available to the UK and elsewhere and would have attracted the higher rate heretofore are not disadvantaged as they seek to innovate and prosper.
Comment on this
As it is now 7.40 p.m. I am required to put the following question in accordance with the order of the Dáil of this day.
Comment on this
The Dáil divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I move the following Financial Resolutions:
Financial Resolution No. 5: Income Tax
(1) THAT section 790A of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 (No. 39 of 1997) be amended —
(a) with effect as on and from 1 January 2011, by inserting the following after subsection (3)—
"(4) Notwithstanding subsection (2), for the purposes of subsection (1) the earnings limit for the year of assessment 2011 shall be €115,000.",
and
(b) as respects the year of assessment 2010, by inserting the following after subsection (4) (inserted by this Resolution)—
"(5) Notwithstanding subsection (2), for the purposes of subsection (1) the earnings limit for the year of assessment 2010 shall be deemed to be €115,000 for the purpose of determining how much of a contribution or qualifying premium, as the case may be, paid by an employee or an individual in the year of assessment 2011, is to be treated by virtue of section 774(8), 776(3), 787(7) or 787C(3), as the case may be, as paid in the year of assessment 2010.".
(2) IT is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public interest that this Resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act 1927 (No. 7 of 1927).
Financial Resolution No. 6: Income Tax
(1) THAT Chapter 2C of Part 30 of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 (No. 39 of 1997) be amended—
(a) in section 787O—
(i) in subsection (1)—
(I) in the definition of "maximum tax-relieved pension fund" by substituting "7 December 2005" for "the specified date",
(II) in the definition of "personal fund threshold"—
(a) by substituting the following for paragraph (a):
"(a) (i) where the individual is an individual to whom the Revenue Commissioners have, before the specified date, issued a certificate in accordance with subsection (5), the amount stated in that certificate as being the individual’s personal fund threshold, and
(ii) in any other case, for the year of assessment 2010, as on and from the specified date, and for the year of assessment 2011, the lower of—
(I) €5,418,085, and
(II) (a) where no benefit crystallisation event in relation to the individual has occurred on or after 7 December 2005 and the individual has uncrystallised pension rights on the specified date, the amount of the uncrystallised pension rights on the specified date in relation to the individual, where the amount of those rights on that date exceed the standard fund threshold, or
(b) where one or more than one benefit crystallisation event in relation to the individual has occurred on or after 7 December 2005 and the individual has uncrystallised pension rights on the specified date, the aggregate of the amounts crystallised by those benefit crystallisation events and the amount of the uncrystallised pension rights on the specified date in relation to the individual, where the aggregate amount of those crystallised and uncrystallised rights exceed the standard fund threshold, and”,
and
(b) in paragraph (b) by substituting the “year of assessment 2011” for “year of assessment 2006”,
(III) by substituting the following for the definition of "specified date":
"‘specified date' means 7 December 2010;",
and
(IV) in the definition of "standard fund threshold"—
(a) by substituting the following for paragraph (a):
"(a) for the year of assessment 2010, as on and from the specified date, and for the year of assessment 2011, €2,300,000, and”,
and
(b) in paragraph (b) by substituting the “year of assessment 2011” for “year of assessment 2006”,
and
(ii) by substituting the following for subsection (2)(b):
"(b) Where the administrator of a relevant pension arrangement has, before the specified date, used a valuation factor (in this subsection referred to as the ‘first-mentioned factor’) other than the relevant valuation factor referred to in paragraph (a), then, in such a case, the first-mentioned factor is the relevant valuation factor for the purposes of this Chapter and Schedule 23B.”,
(b) in section 787P—
(i) by substituting the following for subsection (1):
"(1) An individual's maximum tax-relieved pension fund shall not exceed—
(a) the standard fund threshold, or
(b) the personal fund threshold, where—
(i) the condition set out in subsection (2) is met and the Revenue Commissioners have issued a certificate in accordance with subsection (5) or a revised certificate in accordance with subsection (6), or
(ii) the Revenue Commissioners have, before the specified date, issued a certificate in accordance with subsection (5).",
and
(ii) in subsection (5)—
(I) by substituting "Subject to subsection (6), the Revenue Commissioners" for "The Revenue Commissioners",
(II) by substituting the following for all of the words from "shall, on being satisfied" to the end of the provision:
"shall, within 30 days of receipt of the notification or, as the case may be, the late notification, or such longer time as they may require for the purposes of this subsection, issue a certificate to the individual stating the amount of the personal fund threshold.",
and
(III) by inserting the following after subsection (5):
"(6) Notwithstanding subsection (5), the Revenue Commissioners may at any time withdraw a certificate issued in accordance with that subsection (in this subsection referred to as the ‘first-mentioned certificate') and issue a revised certificate if, following the issue of the first-mentioned certificate, the Commissioners are not satisfied that the calculation of the personal fund threshold contained in the notification referred to in subsection (2) or, as the case may be, the late notification referred to in subsection (4) was correct.",
(c) in section 787Q(1) by substituting “7 December 2005” for “the specified date”,
(d) in section 787R—
(i) by substituting the following for subsection (2):
"(2) The persons liable for income tax charged under subsection (1) shall be the administrator of the relevant pension arrangement under which the benefit crystallisation event arises and the individual in relation to whom the benefit crystallisation event occurs and their liability shall be joint and several.",
and
(ii) in subsection (4)—
(I) by deleting "on or after the date of passing of the Finance Act 2006",
(II) in paragraph (b) by substituting “7 December 2005” for “ the specified date”, and
(III) in paragraph (d) by inserting “whether issued before or after the specified date,” after “under section 787P(5),”,
and
(e) in section 787S—
(i) by substituting the following for subsection (1):
"(1) The administrator of a relevant pension arrangement shall, within 3 months of the end of the month in which the benefit crystallisation event giving rise to the chargeable excess occurs, make a return to the Collector-General which shall contain—
(a) the name and address of the administrator,
(b) the name, address and PPS Number of the individual in relation to whom the benefit crystallisation event has occurred,
(c) details of the relevant pension arrangement under which the benefit crystallisation event giving rise to the chargeable excess has occurred,
(d) the amount of, and the basis of calculation of, the chargeable excess arising in respect of the benefit crystallisation event, and
(e) details of the tax which the administrator is required to account for in relation to the chargeable excess.”,
(ii) by deleting subsection (2), and
(iii) in subsection (7)(b) by substituting “0.0219 per cent” for “0.0273 per cent”.
(2) THAT Schedule 23B to the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 (No. 39 of 1997) be amended—
(a) in paragraph 2(d) by substituting “7 December 2005” for “the specified date”,
(b) in paragraph 4 by substituting “7 December 2005” for “the specified date” in each place, and
(c) in paragraph 5 by substituting the following for subparagraph (2):
"(2) The adjustment referred to in subparagraph (1) is the amount crystallised by the previous benefit crystallisation event multiplied by the higher of 1 and the number determined by the formula—
A
B
where—
A is the standard fund threshold or, as the case may be, the personal fund threshold at the date of the current event, and
B is the standard fund threshold or, as the case may be, the personal fund threshold at the date of the previous benefit crystallisation event,
and where an individual did not have a personal fund threshold at the date of the previous benefit crystallisation event, the standard fund threshold at that date shall be used for B in the formula.".
(3) THAT this Resolution shall have effect as on and from 7 December 2010.
(4) IT is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public interest that this resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act 1927 (No. 7 of 1927).
Financial Resolution No. 7: Income Tax
(3) THAT, as respects an amount regarded as a distribution of a specified amount made on or after 31 December 2010, the formula in section 784A(1BA)(c) of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 (No. 39 of 1997) for determining the specified amount be amended by substituting “5” for “3”.
(4) IT is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public interest that this Resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act 1927 (No. 7 of 1927).
Financial Resolution No. 8: Income Tax
(1) THAT the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 (No. 39 of 1997) be amended by substituting the following for section 790AA:
"Taxation of lump sums in excess of the tax free amount.
790AA (1) (a) In this section—
‘administrator', in relation to a relevant pension arrangement, means the person or persons having the management of the arrangement, and in particular, but without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing, references to the administrator of a relevant pension arrangement include—
(i) an administrator within the meaning of section 770(1),
(ii) a person mentioned in section 784, lawfully carrying on the business of granting annuities on human life, including the appointed person mentioned in section 784(4A)(ii), and
(iii) a PRSA administrator within the meaning of section 787A(1);
‘excess lump sum' shall be construed in accordance with paragraph (e);
‘relevant pension arrangement' means any one or more of the following—
(i) a retirement benefits scheme, within the meaning of section 771, for the time being approved by the Revenue Commissioners for the purposes of Chapter 1,
(ii) an annuity contract or a trust scheme or part of a trust scheme for the time being approved by the Revenue Commissioners under section 784,
(iii) a PRSA contract, within the meaning of section 787A, in respect of a PRSA product, within the meaning of that section,
(iv) a qualifying overseas pension plan within the meaning of Chapter 2B,
(v) a public service pension scheme within the meaning of section 1 of the Public Service Superannuation (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2004 (No. 7 of 2004),
(vi) a statutory scheme, within the meaning of section 770(1), other than a public service pension scheme referred to in paragraph (v);
‘specified date' means 1 January 2011;
‘standard chargeable amount' means the amount equivalent to the amount determined by the formula—
(SFT) - TFA
4
where—
SFT is €2,300,000, and
TFA is the tax free amount;
‘standard rate' means the standard rate of tax in force at the time the lump sum is paid;
‘tax free amount' means €200,000;
‘tax year' means a year of assessment within the meaning of the Tax Acts.
(b) (i) For the purposes of this section, a reference to a lump sum is a reference to a lump sum that is paid to an individual under the rules of a relevant pension arrangement by means of commutation of part of a pension or of part of an annuity or otherwise.
(ii) Without prejudice to the generality of subparagraph (i), the reference in that subparagraph to the commutation of part of a pension or of part of an annuity, shall, in a case where an individual opts in accordance with section 772(3A) or, as the case may be, section 784(2A), be construed as a reference to the commutation of part of the pension or, as the case may be, part of the annuity which would, but for the exercise of that option, be payable to the individual.
(c) For the purposes of this section, references to a lump sum that is paid to an individual include references to a lump sum that is obtained by, given to, or made available to, an individual and references to a lump sum which was, or has, or had been paid to an individual shall be construed accordingly.
(d) For the purposes of this section—
(i) a lump sum (in this subsection referred to as the ‘first-mentioned lump sum') shall be treated as paid before another lump sum (in this subsection referred to as the ‘second-mentioned lump sum') if the first-mentioned lump sum is paid before the second-mentioned lump sum on the same day, and
(ii) a lump sum shall not be treated as paid at the same time as one or more than one other lump sum and, where but for this subsection they would be so treated, the individual to whom the lump sums are paid shall decide on the order in which they are to be deemed to be paid.
(e) For the purposes of this section the excess lump sum, if any, in respect of a lump sum that is paid to an individual on or after the specified date (in this paragraph referred to as the ‘current lump sum’) shall be—
(i) where no other lump sum has been paid to the individual on or after 7 December 2005, the amount by which the current lump sum exceeds the tax free amount, and
(ii) where before the current lump sum was paid, one or more lump sums had been paid to the individual on or after 7 December 2005 (in this section referred to as the ‘earlier lump sums'), then—
(I) where the amount of the earlier lump sums is less than the tax free amount, the amount by which the aggregate of the amounts of the earlier lump sums and the current lump sum exceeds the tax free amount, and
(II) where the amount of the earlier lump sums is equal to or greater than the tax free amount, the amount of the current lump sum.
(2) Where a lump sum is paid to an individual on or after the specified date, the excess lump sum shall be regarded as income of the individual in the tax year in which the lump sum is paid and shall be chargeable to income tax in accordance with subsection (3).
(3) Subject to subsection (4)(b)—
(a) where the excess lump sum arises in accordance with subsection (1)(e)(i), (1)(e)(ii)(I) or (1)(e)(ii)(II) (insofar as the amount of the earlier lump sums referred to in subsection (1)(e)(ii)(II) is equal to the tax free amount), then—
(i) so much of the excess lump sum as does not exceed the standard chargeable amount shall be charged to income tax under Case IV of Schedule D at the standard rate, and
(ii) so much of the excess lump sum, if any, as exceeds the standard chargeable amount shall be regarded as a payment to the individual of emoluments to which Schedule E applies.
(b) Where the excess lump sum arises in accordance with subsection (1)(e)(ii)(II) (insofar as the amount of the earlier lump sums referred to in that subsection is greater than the tax free amount), then—
(i) where the amount by which the earlier lump sums is greater than the tax free amount (in this paragraph referred to as the ‘first mentioned amount') is less than the standard chargeable amount—
(I) so much of the excess lump sum, as does not exceed an amount equivalent to the difference between the standard chargeable amount and the first mentioned amount shall be charged to income tax under Case IV of Schedule D at the standard rate, and
(II) so much of the excess lump sum, if any, as exceeds an amount equivalent to the difference between the standard chargeable amount and the first mentioned amount, shall be regarded as a payment to the individual of emoluments to which Schedule E applies, and
(ii) in any other case, the excess lump sum shall be regarded as a payment to the individual of emoluments to which Schedule E applies.
(4) (a) The administrator of a relevant pension arrangement shall deduct tax from an excess lump sum payment in accordance with this section and remit such tax to the Collector-General.
(b) In so far as any part of an excess lump sum—
(i) is to be regarded as income of the individual for a tax year and charged to income tax at the standard rate in accordance with subsection (3)(a)(i) or (3)(b)(i)(I)—
(I) such income—
(a) shall not be reckoned in computing total income for the purposes of the Tax Acts, and
(b) shall be computed without regard to any amount deductible from or deductible in computing income for the purposes of the Tax Acts,
(II) the charging of that income in such manner shall be without any relief or reduction specified in the Table to section 458 or any other deduction from that income, and
(III) section 188 shall not apply as regards income so charged,
or
(ii) is to be regarded by virtue of this section as a payment to the individual of emoluments to which Schedule E applies—
(I) the provisions of Chapter 4 of Part 42 shall apply to any such amount, and
(II) the administrator of the relevant pension arrangement under which the lump sum is paid shall deduct tax from the payment at the higher rate for the tax year in which the payment is made unless the administrator has received from the Revenue Commissioners a certificate of tax credits and standard rate cut-off point or a tax deduction card for that year in respect of the individual.
(5) Subsection (2) of section 787G shall apply in respect of any income tax, being income tax deducted from an excess lump sum by virtue of subsection (3) of this section, by an administrator of a relevant pension arrangement of a kind described in paragraph (iii) of the definition of ‘relevant pension arrangement' in subsection (1)(a) of this section, as it applies to income tax referred to in subsection (2) of section 787G.
(6) Where a lump sum is paid to an individual, on or after the specified date, under the rules of a relevant pension arrangement of a kind described in paragraph (iv) of the definition of ‘relevant pension arrangement' in subsection (1)(a), the excess lump sum, if any, shall be charged to tax under Case IV of Schedule D for the tax year in which the lump sum is paid to that individual at the rate or rates determined in accordance with subsection (3).
(7) This section shall not apply to a lump sum that is paid to —
(a) a widow or widower,
(b) a civil partner (within the meaning of the Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Act 2010 (No. 24 of 2010)),
(c) children,
(d) dependants, or
(e) personal representatives,
of a deceased individual.
(8) Section 781 shall have effect notwithstanding the provisions of this section.".
(2) IT is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public interest that this resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act 1927 (No. 7 of 1927).
Financial Resolution No. 9: Income Tax
(1) THAT, as respects any payment to which section 123 of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 (No. 39 of 1997) applies (in this Resolution referred to as the "lump sum") made on or after 1 January 2011—
(a) notwithstanding the provisions of section 201 of, and Schedule 3 to, that Act, income tax shall be charged by virtue of section 123 of that Act on the amount of the lump sum which exceeds the lesser of either—
(i) that part of the lump sum which, apart from this Resolution, would be exempt from income tax by virtue of section 201 of, and Schedule 3 to, that Act, including any deduction in computing the charge to income tax under paragraph 6 of that Schedule, and
(ii) €200,000,
(b) the amount of €200,000 referred to in subparagraph (a) of this paragraph shall be reduced by an amount equal to the aggregate amounts exempted from income tax, including any deduction in computing the charge to income tax under paragraph 6 of Schedule 3 to that Act, in respect of all payments to which section 123 of that Act applied which were paid before or at the same time as the payment of the lump sum,
(c) the amount determined in accordance with subparagraphs (a) and (b) of this paragraph shall be determined without regard to subsections (1A) and (2) of section 201 of that Act, and
(d) where 2 or more payments in respect of which tax is chargeable by virtue of section 123 of that Act are made to or in respect of the same person in respect of the same office or employment, or in respect of different offices or employments, for the purposes of this Resolution this paragraph shall apply as if those payments were a single payment of an amount equal to that aggregate amount and the provisions of subparagraph (a) of this paragraph shall apply to that amount accordingly.
(2) IT is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public interest that this Resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act 1927 (No. 7 of 1927).
I propose to speak on Financial Resolutions Nos. 5 to 8 together as they relate to pensions and on Financial Resolution No. 9, which concerns a related area, the taxation of tax-free termination lump sums. Against the very difficult and challenging budgetary situation facing this country, and as outlined in the national recovery plan, the tax base must be broadened and tax expenditure must be curtailed or abolished. Given the continuing very significant costs of pensions tax reliefs, such reliefs cannot escape attention in that regard. The national recovery plan specifically mentioned a number of the pension-related changes the Government has committed to making, in 2011 and over the three remaining periods of the plan. The changes announced in the Budget Statement today deliver on the commitment as regards 2011.
Apart from contributing to curbing the overall tax expenditure, these changes will bring further equity to the system by impacting, for the most part, on higher earners. Deputies will recall that the Commission on Taxation recommended that a pension lump sum taken on retirement should be tax free up to €200,000 and taxed at the standard rate of income tax on any balance above that amount. The commission also recommended that the correlation between the maximum tax relieved pension fund that can be built up by an individual, known as the standard fund threshold, and the annual earnings limit for pension contribution purposes should be maintained. This correlation has been broken in recent years as the earning limits fell from €275,000 in 2008 to €150,000 in 2009, with no corresponding contraction in the standard fund threshold. The commission recommended that ex gratia termination lump sums should also be tax free up to €200,000 and that any amount in excess of this should be taxed.
As flagged in the national recovery plan and as specified in the budget speech today, it has been decided to act on the commission's recommendations. A further reduction in the earning limits for pension contribution purposes is being made and the rate at which the national distribution for approved retirement funds is to be calculated is to be increased. The elimination of employee PRSI and pension contributions in 2011 and the changes to employer PRSI relief on employee pension contributions, which were announced today, will be dealt with in the context of legislation with which my colleague the Minister for Social Protection will deal. The Financial Resolutions before us give legislative effect, therefore, to the following budget measures pending the passing into law of the finance Bill of 2011.
Financial Resolution No. 5 provides for the reduction in the earnings limit which, in conjunction with age-related percentage limits, governs the maximum amount of tax relieved contributions an individual can make in any one year to pension products. The limit is being reduced from €150,000 in the current year to €115,000 for 2011. Deputies may be aware that the pension tax legislation provides for an individual who pays a pension contribution after the end of a tax year but on or before the return filing date for that tax year to elect to have the contribution treated as if paid in the earlier year. Clearly, with the reduction of the earning limits for 2011, individuals may well be tempted to retrospectively maximise their tax relief for 2010 where they have not done so already by allocating contributions made next year to 2010. This would give rise to significant tax refunds in 2011 that we simply cannot afford. Accordingly, the resolution seeks to limit such exposure by deeming the earning limits for this year to be €115,000 as well for the purpose of such elections.
Financial Resolution No. 6 provides for the reduction from €5.4 million to €2.3 million, with effect from today, in the limit on the maximum tax relieved pension fund that can be built up by an individual. This is known as the standard fund threshold. Individuals with pension rights in excess of this new lower standard fund threshold on budget day will be able to protect the capital value of those rights by claiming a personal fund threshold. Such transitional measures were also recommended by the Commission on Taxation to deal with circumstances where an individual's pension rights had already exceeded any revised lower limit. The legal advice to the Government was to the effect that the absence of such grandfathering arrangements, which also applied when the standard fund thresholds were first introduced on 7 December 2005, would be difficult to defend against constitutional and legal challenges. The personal fund threshold will be calculated on the aggregate of the capital value of pension benefits to which the individual has already become entitled since 7 December 2005 plus the capital value on budget day of any uncrystallised pension rights that the individual has — in other words, pension rights that the individual is building up but to which he has not yet become entitled. Where this amount exceeds the standard fund threshold of €2.3 million, that higher amount will be the individual's personal fund threshold.
However, that is subject to not exceeding the existing standard fund threshold of €5.4 million which would have been the maximum tax relief pension fund such individuals would have been able to build up before today. As before, a personal fund threshold will have to be claimed from the Revenue Commissioners by way of a notification and certification procedure. An individual who already has a personal fund threshold under the old regime will be able to retain it.
The resolution also ensures that the standard capitalisation factor for use in determining the value of defined benefit pension rights, for the purposes of estimating an individual's personal fund threshold and for the purposes of valuing pension rights when eventually drawn down, is to be 20 as before.
Financial Resolution No. 7 provides for an increase in the annual notional distribution for approved retirement funds which is calculated on the value of assets in an approved retirement fund as of 31 December each year. The amount of the notional distribution will be 5% of the value as compared to 3% as currently provided for. This new rate will apply to asset values at 31 December 2010.
Financial Resolution No. 8 provides for the taxation of pension lump sums above €200,000 with effect from 1 January next year. This resolution replaces the existing provision in the Taxes Consolidation Act of 1997 which already places a lifetime limit on the amount of tax free pension lump sum that can be taken by an individual from 7 December 2005. This limit was set at 25% of the old standard fund threshold and amounts to €1.3 million.
Under the new approach the maximum lifetime pension tax free sum will be €200,000 as from 1 January 2011. Amounts in excess of this tax free limit will be subject to tax in two stages. The portion between €200,000 and €575,000 will be taxed at the standard rate of 20% while any portion above that will be taxed at the individual's marginal rate of tax. The figure of €575,000 represents 25% of the new lower standard fund threshold of €2.3 million mentioned earlier and retains the link to the old approach. The standard rate charges effectively ring-fence to ensure that no reliefs, allowances or deductions may be set or made against that portion of a lump sum subject to that charge.
It should be appreciated that tax free retirement lump sums taken on or after 7 December 2005 when the original limit was introduced will count towards using up the new tax free amount. In other words, if an individual has already taken tax free retirement lump sums of €200,000 or more since 7 December 2005, any further retirement lump sum paid to the individual on or after 1 January 2011 will be taxable. There is no question of those individuals somehow getting an additional tax free amount. These earlier lump sums will also count towards determining how much of a lump sum paid on or after 1 January 2011 is to be charged at the standard or marginal rate as appropriate.
It is also important to note that this is a lifetime limit and therefore it will apply to a single lump sum or where an individual is in receipt of lump sums from more than one pension product to the aggregate of those lump sums. The restriction applies to all pension arrangements including occupational pension schemes, retirement annuity contracts, PRSAs, public sector and statutory schemes. As before, there are certain exclusions from the pension lump sum tax charge. It will not apply, for example, to lump sum death-in-service benefits paid to widows.
Resolution No. 9 sets out the basis for the imposition of a lifetime limit on exempt ex gratia lump sum payments made primarily in respect of termination of employment as recommended by the Commission on Taxation. With effect from 1 January 2011, where an individual is in receipt of an ex gratia payment from their employer the aggregate amount which can be paid tax free will be €200,000, taking into consideration the tax free elements of any previous payment that individual had received. This restriction will have no relevance to the majority of employees. Its impact will primarily be confined to those in receipt of large ex gratia payments. I commend the resolutions to the House.
Comment on this
I again register our objection to taking four or five resolutions together. It is not necessary to do that and it means that when we are in a position to agree on something with the Government, as with some of these, we cannot vote for it because we do not agree with lumping the resolutions together.
We have a serious problem with Resolution No. 5, which I will address, but I want to first comment on Resolutions Nos. 8 and 9. While the tax changes to the lump sum are welcome, most people have a problem with the lump sum itself, especially when they see the figures being paid out to retiring Ministers and various top civil servants. That is something not addressed in this budget bar through the tax system. The wrong message is going out on that but that is a separate discussion we can have during the debate on the entire budget. People become very annoyed when they see those lump sums being paid out at a time when they are struggling.
As a party we have a concern with Resolution No. 5. We proposed many changes to the pensions area in our alternative budget published last Friday. Some of them are very good but we tried to tackle the overall pension fund in a different way to individual people contributing into it. My concern is that this measure limits the amount of money a person can put into his or her pension fund in certain years. Fine Gael's proposal was to allow a person accumulate a fund that will give him or her an annual maximum pension of approximately €60,000 a year. We would discourage above that figure but we said we would facilitate a person accumulating enough of a fund to have a pension of €60,000 a year. That means that if a person is late starting to contribute to a fund he or she might not get a chance to accumulate enough money for that payment. The Government is preventing that.
In the current climate it is quite common for self-employed people to stop paying into their pension fund for several years because they just cannot make the contributions. They cannot even pay a wage, other than cashing in other investments and so on to survive. In a few years time when Fine Gael is in government, the country has recovered and those in self-employment have a chance to earn more money, they will be discouraged from putting money into their pension fund to pay out a pension to which they are entitled based on their years of work. This measure is unfair in that regard. It is penalising the wrong person.
The Government must realise the times in which we now live. Not everybody in business made money in the good times but certainly in recent years many people in business could not pay into their pension fund. They should be allowed to pay extra in years to come but they will not be able to do that because this measure will restrict them in that it will not be worth their while. It is a pity the Minister has lumped these resolutions together because we will oppose this one.
Comment on this
I welcome the fact that finally the Government has recognised a need to do something on the pensions front. For years it has been in denial about the fact that our pensions system was more about facilitating tax avoidance than encouraging pension provision. The way in which it operates, as the Minister and her officials will be aware, has been inequitable. That is the reality. A total of €3 billion has been spent per year on tax relief on pensions and the vast bulk of that has gone to the top 20% of earners.
Side by side with that outrage, as I would regard it, almost 50% of workers do not have any private pension provision and therefore as a policy it was ineffective while the manner in which it operated was inequitable. I welcome these first steps in implementing reform in this area, but overall the Minister is not going anywhere near far enough.
The Labour Party, in its pension proposals, has estimated that it would be possible to save a minimum of €400 million in the coming year, and possibly up to €600 million, if there was a proper root and branch reform of the pensions tax relief system. That could be done in a way that would not impact on people with incomes of up to €100,000. We could ensure that there was still a major incentive for people on middle and modest incomes to make pension provision but, unfortunately, the Government has chosen to take a different route.
I find it extraordinary that in each of these five measures the Minister has a costing and a figure for each one of those. The Labour Party is extremely concerned that we have spent the past three years trying to get costings from the Minister for Finance, the Department of Finance and the Revenue Commissioners for different aspects of our pension provision and on every single occasion we have been refused and told that no figures were available. The reply to my last parliamentary question a few weeks ago denied that figures were available anywhere. I was told the Department was now approaching the pensions industry to try to get some estimates.
The Minister was not in a position to provide figures to the Labour Party in spite of the fact that a service was offered that she would cost our pre-budget proposals, and today she could come up with figures for each one of those measures. How did that come about? If she was unable to provide those figures last week and was unable to provide them over the past three years when we have been asking for them, can we believe these figures now? Are they accurate and how is it that the Government can just come up with them suddenly?
In respect of the individual proposals, we will not oppose the annual earnings limit but it could have been done in a much better way. We should take our example from what is happening in the UK where a cap is being introduced on the total amount of tax relief that can be claimed, whether the contribution is made by the employee or the employer. That is the weakness in these proposals and in the proposals signalled in the four year plan. All the Minister is talking about doing is limiting the employee contributions. The really big money, as the Minister well knows, is in the employer contributions and it makes no sense to exclude those from any new limits. Let us stop codding ourselves on what is happening in the pensions area. Why does the Government continue to facilitate persons in jobs where their employers can fund their pensions generously and what is the rationale for not applying the same kind of limits to employer contributions as employee contributions?
On Financial Resolution No. 6, the maximum allowable pension funds, the Minister proposes to reduce the maximum standard fund threshold from the current €5.4 million to €2.3 million. It is a move in the right direction, but why has the Minister not gone further? A fund of €2.3 million will entitle a person to a pension of €100,000. I see no justification for taxpayers subsidising pensions for persons who end up with a pension of €100,000 at a time when the Minister introduced the universal social charge, which will impose additional taxes on persons on modest pensions. Pensioners with an income of under €40,000 will now be hit for an additional €2,000 through the universal charge and through the tax changes, and yet the Minister is saying it is acceptable that somebody would be subsidised to the tune of the top rate of tax relief to enable him or her to have a pension of €100,000. There is no justification or rationale for that. The Labour Party favours reducing the total fund to €1.6 million.
Financial Resolution No. 7 is a reasonable proposal and we do not have a difficulty with that. On Financial Resolutions Nos. 8 and 9 on the retirement lump sum, my party agrees with reducing the lump sum. The current lump sum of €1.3 million, that the wealthiest in society are entitled to take without paying a single cent of tax, is indefensible. It is an outrageous amount of money. There is no justification, socially or economically, for having such a regime. It is about time that lump sum was lowered. In recent years when we have had to take such austerity measures and when there is such hardship being caused to persons on low incomes, how can the Minister defend a situation where the wealthiest are walking off with €1.3 million tax free on retirement? It is scandalous that it was ever the case and it is scandalous that the Minister has allowed it to continue up to now.
I welcome the fact that the Minister is talking about now reducing that maximum tax-free lump sum to €200,000. I still think it is too high. It should come down below €150,000. That would be reasonable still.
I refer to the Minister's proposals for the transitional arrangements for persons who currently have funds in excess of the new threshold being proposed where he is allowing them to take a tax-free lump sum. He is changing this tonight — we are voting on it shortly — but the Minister will still continue to allow persons who have bigger funds to withdraw tax-free lump sums of €575,000. There is no justification——
Comment on this
——for allowing that additional generosity. There is no basis for doing that.
However, the worst aspect of Financial Resolutions Nos. 8 and 9 is that they do not take effect until 1 January. Essentially, the Minister is telling those wealthy individuals to——
Comment on this
——move their money fast. They have three weeks to take €1.3 million tax-free and run. At a time when people cannot afford to put food on the table for their children and people are having their electricity cut off and cannot afford to heat their homes, the Minister is telling the wealthiest people coming up to Christmas to take the money and run, and the Government is prepared to allow them to take €1.3 million tax-free. It is a scandal. It is a disgrace that the Tánaiste should allow that to transpire.
Comment on this
I will be brief because I appreciate that others want to get in as well.
On Financial Resolution No. 5, my party would like to see the pension cap reduced. We propose its reduction to €100,000. I note the Minister has provided for €115,000 here. We also propose standardising pension tax reliefs, which, unfortunately, is not in this document.
On Financial Resolution No. 6, the Minister is allowing for a maximum pension fund on retirement for tax purposes to be set a €2.3 million. I suppose €2.3 million is not bad, really, when one measures it against the Minister's expectation that somebody can survive on €186 per week on jobseeker's allowance. Given the evidence, I remain to be convinced on a fair society.
On the retirement lump sums cap of €200,000, I note that has come down substantially in recent years. Not that long ago it was €500,000. There has been a significant move here but, in fairness, it should have been lower.
Comment on this
There is a difference of perspective on a number of these issues that have been raised. In Fine Gael, there is a view that the sum, which will be €2.3 million and which was previously €5.4 million, might not even be adequate to deal with——
Comment on this
Address the points made. We know the policies.
Comment on this
Deputy English raised this issue and he is entitled to an answer.
Deputy English's view was that perhaps this would be more restrictive on persons who at a later stage in life may not be in a position to get an adequate pension.
Comment on this
I suppose our perspective is that it was €5.4 million and it is now moved down to €2.3 million, and there would be adequate space in that for persons——
Comment on this
——to address their financial needs, which, perhaps, is an opposing point which Deputy Shortall would have.
Deputy Shortall is correct in stating that this is a progressive tax measure being introduced into pension legislation. We now see a €200,000 limit as opposed to what was there heretofore. Anything over and above that will be taxable.
She raised an issue on others who have an established right to the money that they have accumulated. The legal advice to the Department of Finance is that these persons have their provision grandfathered and they have established a legal right to their entitlement.
Comment on this
Why does that not apply to public sector pensioners? The Tánaiste seems to think it was all right to dip into public sector pensions.
Comment on this
After that, the changes will take place.
On the other issue Deputy Shortall raised, which is the employer's contribution, which is an argument which has been traditionally made by many on applying limits to the employer contribution, which would prevent the funding of certain individual pensions, there are issues being considered by the Department at present. It is under consideration.
Comment on this
No. This issue is being considered by the Department and the Minister in the context of the finance Bill which will be prepared for later on. The overarching message from these measures is that those who have acquired and who would prefer to acquire larger lump sums tax-free will not do so. We are now setting a threshold of €200,000.
Comment on this
We are also preventing situations whereby people obtained large ex gratia payments which were not taxed. This matter has also been addressed. Many of the concerns raised in providing an equity argument in the context of pension legislation are now being addressed in these resolutions being put to the House.
Comment on this
We need to move on and make a decision. As 30 minutes have now elapsed I am required to put the question in accordance with an order of the Dáil of this day.
Comment on this
The Dáil divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I move the following Financial Resolutions:
Financial Resolution No. 10: Income Tax
(1) THAT section 15 of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 (No. 39 of 1997) be amended in the following manner for the year of assessment 2011 and each subsequent year of assessment :
(a) by substituting “€23,800” for “€27,400” in subsection (3),
(b) by substituting “€32,800” for “€36,400” in column 1 of Part 1 of the Table to that section,
(c) by substituting “€36,800” for “€40,400” in column 1 of Part 2 of the Table to that section, and
(d) by substituting “€41,800” for “€45,400” in column 1 of Part 3 of the Table to that section.
(2) IT is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public interest that this Resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act 1927 (No. 7 of 1927).
Financial Resolution No. 11: Income Tax
(1) THAT the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 (No. 39 of 1997) be amended in the following manner for the year of assessment 2011 and each subsequent year of assessment :
(a) where an individual is entitled to a tax credit under a provision of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 mentioned in column (1) of the Table to this Resolution the amount of the tax credit shall, instead of being the amount specified in column (2) of the Table, be the amount of the tax credit specified in column (3) of the Table opposite the mention of the amount in column (2).
Statutory Provision | Existing tax credit | Tax credit for the year 2011 and subsequent years
(1) | (2) | (3)
Section 461
(basic personal tax credit)
(married person) | €3,660 | €3,300
(widowed person bereaved in year of assessment) | €3,660 | €3,300
(single person) | €1,830 | €1,650
Section 461A
(additional tax credit for certain widowed persons) | €600 | €540
Section 462
(one-parent family tax credit) | €1,830 | €1,650
Section 463
(widowed parent tax credit)
(1st year) | €4,000 | €3,600
(2nd year) | €3,500 | €3,150
(3rd year) | €3,000 | €2,700
(4th year) | €2,500 | €2,250
(5th year) | €2,000 | €1,800
Section 464
(age tax credit)
(married person) | €650 | €490
(single person) | €325 | €245
Section 465
(incapacitated child tax credit) | €3,660 | €3,300
Section 466
(dependant relative credit) | €80 | €70
Section 466A
(home carer tax credit) | €900 | €810
Section 468
(blind person’s tax credit)
(blind person) | €1,830 | €1,650
(both spouses blind) | €3,660 | €3,300
Section 472
(employee tax credit) | €1,830 | €1,650
,
(b) in section 461, by substituting “€3,300” for “€3,660”, in both places where it occurs, and “€1,650” for “€1,830”,
(c) in section 461A, by substituting “€540” for “€600”,
(d) in section 462, in subsection (2), by substituting the following for “€1,830” and all the words following that amount to the end of that subsection:
"€1,650, but this section shall not apply for any year of assessment—
(i) in the case of a husband or a wife where the wife is living with her husband,
(ii) in the case of civil partners (within the meaning of the Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Act 2010) who are living together, or
(iii) in the case of cohabitants (within the meaning of the Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Act 2010).",
(e) in section 463(2)—
(i) in subparagraph (i), by substituting "€3,600" for "€4,000",
(ii) in subparagraph (ii), by substituting "€3,150" for "€3,500",
(iii) in subparagraph (iii), by substituting "€2,700" for "€3,000",
(iv) in subparagraph (iv), by substituting "€2,250" for "€2,500",
(v) in subparagraph (iv), by substituting "€1,800" for "€2,000", and
(vi) by substituting "cohabitants (within the meaning of the Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Act 2010)" for "a man and woman living together as man and wife",
(f) in section 464, by substituting “€490” and “€245”, respectively, for “€650” and “€325”,
(g) in section 465, by substituting “€3,300” for “€3,660” in subsection (1),
(h) in section 466, by substituting “€70” for “€80” in subsection (2),
(i) in section 466A, by substituting “€810” for “€900” in subsection (2),
(j) in section 468, by substituting “€1,650” and “€3,300”, respectively, for “€1,830” and “€3,660” in subsection (2), and
(k) in section 472, by substituting “€1,650” for “€1,830”, in both places where it occurs, in subsection (4).
(2) IT is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public interest that this Resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act 1927 (No. 7 of 1927).
Financial Resolution No. 12: Income Tax
(1) THAT section 188 of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 (No. 39 of 1997), in relation to income tax age exemption and associated marginal relief, be amended for the year of assessment 2011 and each subsequent year of assessment by substituting "€36,000" for "€40,000" and "€18,000" for "€20,000" in subsection (2).
(2) IT is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public interest that this Resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act 1927 (No. 7 of 1927).
Financial Resolution No. 13: Universal Social Charge
(1) THAT—
(a) in this Resolution—
"aggregate income for the tax year", in relation to an individual and a tax year, means the aggregate of the individual's—
(i) relevant emoluments in the tax year, including relevant emoluments that are paid in whole or in part for a tax year other than the tax year during which the payment is made, and
(ii) relevant income for the tax year;
"Collector-General" means the Collector-General appointed under section 851 of the Principal Act;
"employee" and "employer" have the same meanings as in section 983 of the Principal Act;
"excluded emoluments" means emoluments which have been gifted to the Minister for Finance under section 483 of the Principal Act;
"income tax month" means a calendar month;
"PAYE Regulations" means the Income Tax (Employments) (Consolidated) Regulations 2001 (S.I. No. 559 of 2001);
"Principal Act" means the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 (No. 39 of 1997);
"relevant emoluments" and "relevant income" shall be construed in accordance with paragraphs (a) and (b), respectively, of the Table to paragraph (2) of this Resolution;
"similar type payments" means payments which are of a similar character to social welfare payments but which are made by—
(i) the Health Service Executive,
(ii) the Department of Community, Equality and Gaeltacht Affairs,
(iii) the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation,
(iv) the Department of Education and Skills,
(v) the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, or
(vi) An Foras Áiseanna Saothair, in respect of schemes mentioned in clauses (I), (II) and (III) of section 472A(1)(b)(i) of the Principal Act,
"social welfare payments" means payments made under the Social Welfare Acts;
"tax year" means a year of assessment within the meaning of the Tax Acts;
"universal social charge" has the meaning assigned to it by paragraph (2) of this Resolution,
and
(b) other words and expressions used in this Resolution have, except where otherwise provided or where the context otherwise requires, the same meaning as in the Tax Acts.
(2) THAT, with effect from 1 January 2011, there shall be charged, levied and paid, in accordance with the provisions of this Resolution, a tax to be known as "universal social charge" in respect of the income specified in paragraphs (a) and (b) of the Table to this paragraph.
TABLE
(a) The income described in this paragraph (in this Resolution referred to as “relevant emoluments”) is emoluments to which Chapter 4 of Part 42 of the Principal Act applies or is applied, including-
(i) any allowable contributions referred to in Regulations 41 and 42 of the PAYE Regulations,
(ii) the initial market value (within the meaning of section 510(2) of the Principal Act) of any shares, excluded from the charge to income tax by virtue of section 510(4) of that Act, appropriated in accordance with Chapter 1 of Part 17 of that Act,
(iii) the market value (determined in accordance with section 548 of the Principal Act) of the right referred to in section 519A(1) or 519D(1) of that Act, and
(iv) any gain exempted from income tax by virtue of section 519B(3) or 519D(3) of the Principal Act,
but not including—
(I) social welfare payments and similar type payments,
(II) excluded emoluments,
(III) expenses, in respect of which an employee may be entitled to relief from income tax, which fall within Regulation 10(3) of the PAYE Regulations,
(IV) any amount in respect of which relief is due under section 201(5)(a) of the Principal Act and paragraphs 6 and 8 of Schedule 3 to that Act,
(V) emoluments of an individual who is resident in a territory with which arrangements have been made under subsection (1)(a)(i) or (1B)(a)(ii) of section 826 of the Principal Act in relation to affording relief from double taxation, where those emoluments are the subject of a notification issued under section 984(1) of that Act.
(b) The income described in this paragraph (in this Resolution referred to as “relevant income”) is income, without regard to any amount deductible from or deductible in computing total income, from all sources as estimated in accordance with the Tax Acts, other than—
(i) relevant emoluments,
(ii) any emoluments, payments, expenses or other amounts referred to in clauses (I) to (V) of paragraph (a) of this Table,
(iii) any gains, income or payments to which any of the following provisions apply:
(I) Chapter 4 of Part 8 of the Principal Act;
(II) Chapter 5 of Part 8 of the Principal Act;
(III) Chapter 5 of Part 26 of the Principal Act;
(IV) Chapter 6 of Part 26 of the Principal Act;
(V) Chapter 1A of Part 27 of the Principal Act;
(VI) Chapter 4 of Part 27 of the Principal Act,
(iv) where section 825A of the Principal Act applies in respect of an individual for a tax year, an amount equal to the difference between—
(I) the individual's total income for the tax year had that section not applied for that year, and
(II) the amount of total income which if charged to income tax for the year would have given an amount of income tax payable equal to that which would be payable by virtue of the operation of that section,
(v) where section 1025 of the Principal Act applies in respect of an individual, the amount of any deduction for any payment to which that section applies, made by an individual pursuant to a maintenance arrangement (within the meaning of that section) relating to the marriage for the benefit of the other party to the marriage, unless section 1026 of that Act applies in respect of such payment,
(vi) where an individual is entitled to an allowance under section 284(1) of the Principal Act, other than where such an allowance is made on a lessor and an allowance made on an individual who is not an active partner (within the meaning of section 409A of that Act), an amount equal to the amount of that allowance,
(vii) where an individual is entitled to an allowance under subsection (3) of section 272 of the Principal Act of an amount determined in accordance with paragraph (a), (b), (c)(iii), (da), (db), (e) or (g) of that subsection, other than where such an allowance is made on a lessor of an industrial building or structure and an allowance made on an individual who is not an active partner (within the meaning of section 409A of that Act), an amount equal to the amount of that allowance, and
(viii) where an individual is entitled to an allowance under subsection (2) of section 658 of the Principal Act of an amount determined in accordance with paragraph (b) of that subsection, or an allowance under section 659(2)(a) of that Act determined in accordance with subsection (3A), (3AA) (3B) or (3BA) of that section, other than where such an allowance is made on an individual who is not an active partner (within the meaning of section 409A of that Act), an amount equal to the amount of that allowance,
and as if sections 140, 141, 142, 143, 195, 232, 234 and 664 of the Principal Act were never enacted and without regard to any deduction—
(a) in respect of double rent allowance under section 324(2), 333(2), 345(3) or 354(3) of the Principal Act,
(b) under section 372AP of the Principal Act, in computing the amount of a surplus or deficiency in respect of rent from any premises,
(c) under section 372AU of the Principal Act, in computing the amount of a surplus or deficiency in respect of rent from any premises,
(d) under section 847A of the Principal Act, in respect of a relevant donation (within the meaning of that section), or
(e) under section 848A of the Principal Act, in respect of a relevant donation (within the meaning of that section).
(3) THAT universal social charge shall not be payable for a tax year by an individual who proves to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that his or her aggregate income for the tax year does not exceed €4,004.
(4) THAT for the tax year 2011, and for each subsequent tax year, an individual shall be charged to universal social charge on his or her aggregate income for the tax year—
(a) at the rate specified in the second column of the Table to this paragraph corresponding to the part of aggregate income specified in the first column of that Table where the individual is aged under 70 years, and
(b) at the rate specified in the third column of the Table to this paragraph corresponding to the part of aggregate income specified in the first column of that Table where the individual is aged 70 years or over at any time during the tax year.
Part of aggregate income | Rate of universal social chargeIndividuals aged under 70 years | Rate of universal social chargeIndividuals aged 70 years or over
The first €10,036 | 2% | 2%
The next €5,980 | 4% | 4%
The remainder | 7% | 4%
(5) THAT—
(a) an employer shall be liable in the first instance to pay universal social charge due in respect of any payment of relevant emoluments,
(b) as respects any payment of relevant emoluments made to or on behalf of an employee on or after 1 January 2011, universal social charge shall be deducted from such emoluments by the employer at any or all of the following rates:
(i) 2 per cent where the amount of the relevant emoluments does not exceed €193, in the case where the period in respect of which the payment is being made is a week, or a corresponding amount where the period is greater or less than a week;
(ii) 4 per cent on the amount of the excess:
(I) where the amount of the relevant emoluments exceeds €193, but does not exceed €308, or
(II) where, in the case of an employee who is aged 70 years or over at any time during the tax year, the amount of the relevant emoluments exceeds €193,
in the case where the period in respect of which the payment is being made is a week, or a corresponding amount where the period is greater or less than a week;
(iii) 7 per cent on the amount of the excess where the amount of the relevant emoluments exceeds €308, in the case where the period in respect of which payment is being made is a week, or a corresponding amount where the period is greater or less than a week,
and notwithstanding that the relevant emoluments are in whole or in part for some tax year other than that during which the payment is made,
(c) the provisions of Part 4 of the PAYE Regulations, with any necessary modifications, shall apply to universal social charge in respect of relevant emoluments and universal social charge payable by an employee shall only be recoverable from him or her by his or her employer by deduction in accordance with those provisions,
(d) within 14 days of the end of every income tax month the employer shall remit to the Collector-General the total of all amounts of universal social charge which the employer was liable to deduct from relevant emoluments paid by the employer during that income tax month,
(e) the Collector-General may, in writing, and unless the employer objects, authorise the employer to remit to the Collector-General, within 14 days from the end of such longer period (if any) but not exceeding one year, as may be so authorised, the total of all amounts of universal social charge which the employer was liable to deduct from relevant emoluments paid by the employer during that longer period,
(f) where a remittance referred to in subparagraph (d) of this paragraph is made by such electronic means (within the meaning of section 917EA of the Principal Act) as are approved by the Revenue Commissioners, that subparagraph shall apply and have effect as if “within 23 days of the end of every income tax month” were substituted for “within 14 days of the end of every income tax month” but, where that remittance is not made within that period of 23 days, subparagraph (d) shall apply and have effect without regard to the provisions of this subparagraph, and
(g) on payment of universal social charge, the Collector-General may send, make available or cause to be made available to the employer concerned a receipt in respect of the payment.
(6) THAT—
(a) an employer shall, in the case of an employee to whom he or she makes a payment of relevant emoluments, give to the employee, on the cessation of the period of employment to which the payment of universal social charge in respect of the employee relates, a certificate showing—
(i) the total universal social charge as respects the employee which the employer was liable to remit for the tax year in which the cessation occurs up to and including the date of cessation,
(ii) the dates of commencement (where applicable) and cessation within that year of the employment of the individual,
(iii) the rate of universal social charge payable as respects the employee, and
(iv) the total relevant emoluments paid to the employee in that year up to and including the date of cessation,
and
(b) the certificate specified in subparagraph (a) of this paragraph shall be in such form as may be provided or approved of by the Revenue Commissioners.
(7) THAT an employer shall record the following particulars in respect of each employee to whom payment of relevant emoluments has been made in a tax year—
(a) the amount of each payment of relevant emoluments,
(b) the amount of universal social charge deducted from each such payment,
(c) the total amount of universal social charge which the employer is liable to remit in respect of each such payment, and
(d) the dates of commencement and cessation within the tax year of the employment of the individual, where applicable.
(8) THAT the records specified in paragraph (7) of this Resolution shall be in a form approved of by the Revenue Commissioners and shall be retained by an employer for 6 years after the end of the tax year to which they refer.
(9) THAT sections 989, 990, 990A, and 991 of the Principal Act shall apply to universal social charge payable on relevant emoluments as they apply to income tax.
(10) THAT, where universal social charge is payable for the tax year 2011 in respect of aggregate income of an individual for that year, section 958 of the Principal Act shall apply and have effect as if, in accordance with this Resolution, universal social charge was payable for the tax year 2010.
(11) THAT universal social charge is under the care and management of the Revenue Commissioners and Part 37 of the Principal Act shall apply to universal social charge as it applies to income tax.
(12) THAT repayments of income levy (within the meaning of section 531A of the Principal Act) paid for the tax years 2009 and 2010 shall, to the extent that insufficient income levy has been paid in 2011 or a later year, be made out of universal social charge.
(13) THAT—
(a) where any income levy (within the meaning of section 531A of the Principal Act), in relation to an employee, remains unpaid for the tax year 2009 or 2010 and is not otherwise recovered (in this subparagraph referred to as the “underpayment”), the employer shall be treated, on receipt of a notice from an inspector of taxes or other officer of the Revenue Commissioners to the effect that this paragraph applies, as making a payment of relevant emoluments (within the meaning of paragraph (1) of this Resolution) to the employee in the tax year 2011 of an amount equal to the amount referred to in subparagraph (b) of this paragraph (in this paragraph referred to as “notional emoluments”),
(b) the amount of the notional emoluments shall be an amount which would produce an amount of universal social charge equal to the amount of the underpayment and which amount shall be set out in the notice issued under subparagraph (a) of this paragraph,
(c) where an employer is treated as making a payment of notional emoluments in the tax year 2011, the amount of the notional emoluments for the tax year shall be apportioned over the tax year to each week, in a case where relevant emoluments are paid weekly, or such corresponding period where relevant emoluments are paid for a period either greater or less than a week, and
(d) the employer shall deduct universal social charge in accordance with this Resolution by reference to the part of the notional emoluments for the tax year apportioned to each such week or a corresponding amount where the period is greater or less than a week and, for the purposes of determining the amount of universal social charge to be deducted in accordance with this subparagraph, the part of the notional emoluments so apportioned shall be treated as the highest portion of the employee’s relevant emoluments (within the meaning of paragraph (1) of this Resolution) for that week or other period.
(14) THAT, where any income levy (within the meaning of section 531A of the Principal Act) or universal social charge, as the case may be, remains unpaid after the end of a tax year, the amount of tax credits (within the meaning of the PAYE Regulations) and the standard rate cut-off point (within that meaning) appropriate to an employee for any subsequent tax year may be adjusted as necessary by an inspector of taxes or other officer of the Revenue Commissioners to collect unpaid universal social charge or income levy which is not otherwise recovered.
(15) IT is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public interest that this Resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act (No. 7 of 1927).
Financial Resolution No. 14: Income Levy
(1) THAT the tax known as income levy imposed by section 531B (inserted by section 2 of the Finance (No. 2) Act 2008) (No. 25 of 2008) of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 (No. 39 of 1997) shall cease to be charged with effect as on and from 1 January 2011.
(2) IT is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public interest that this Resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act (No. 7 of 1927).
In 2010 it is estimated that almost 45% of income tax earners will be exempt from income tax and only 14% will pay income tax at the higher rate. For a single individual, the entry point to income tax is €18,300. A married, one income family does not start paying income tax until income levels are in excess of €31,950. It is evident that this situation has become unsustainable. We arrived at this situation by the very generous increases in credits and bands over several years. The combined value of the personal tax credit and the PAYE tax credit has increased by 92% since 2001, from €1,905 to €3,600 in 2010. The single standard rate band has increased from €17,780 in 1999 to €36,400 in 2010. This is an increase of 105%.
It is clear that we cannot afford such generous tax reliefs on income. In this budget, therefore, we have reduced the personal and PAYE tax credits by approximately 10% to €1,650 each from €1,830. We have reduced the single standard rate band to €32,800 from a value of €36,400. The married one income band has been reduced to €41,800 from €45,400 and the married two earner band has been reduced to €65,600 from €72,800. These measures will reduce the entry point to income tax for a single individual to €16,500 and for a married one income family to €28,800. These measures will return tax credits and bands to where they were in 2006. As a result of these measures, the numbers exempt from income tax in 2011 will be reduced to 38% from 45%. The numbers exempt will be reduced to 843,400 from the 2010 figure of 982,900 — a reduction of almost 140,000.
Most important of all in these difficult times, it is estimated these measures will raise €830 million in 2011 and €1.1 billion in a full year. We will also reduce the age exemption limits from €20,000 for a single person and €40,000 for a married couple to €18,000 and €36,000, respectively. It is not unreasonable in these difficult times to reduce the entry point to tax for a married couple aged under 65 years with no children to €24,750 but maintain the entry point to tax at €40,000 for a couple over 65 years.
A new universal social charge is being introduced to replace the income levy and the health levy. The universal charge will be applied at a rate of 2% up to €10,036, 4% above that amount but below €16,016 and 7% above €16,016. A lower exemption threshold of €4,004 will apply. Income earners over 70 years of age will not be liable for the higher rate of 7%. As with the levy, payments made by the Department of Social Protection will be exempt from the universal social charge. The charge is more equitable and has a wider base and lower rate when compared with the combined income levy and health levy. It is designed to apply across income levels in a smoother progression while addressing the irregularities caused by the step effects in the current system of levies and PRSI. The current combination of income levy, health levy and PRSI creates a number of anomalies due to the entry point steps to each of these charges. The health levy has a step of 4% to €26,000, which results in an anomaly whereby an individual earning €25,500 per annum can receive an increase in income of €1,000 but only €320 in net pay. The introduction of the universal charge will resolve this issue. An individual on €25,500 who receives an increase of €1,000 will now be €690 better off. The charge is the first step in removing the irregularities due to the combination of levies and PRSI in the current system. The charge is revenue neutral in 2011 and will yield €420 million in a full year.
Financial Resolution No. 10 reduces the level of the standard bands. The single standard band is reduced from €36,400 to €32,800. Financial Resolution No. 11 reduces the level of income tax credits by approximately 10%. Personal PAYE credits will be reduced from €1,830 to €1,650. Financial Resolution No. 12 reduces the threshold for the exemption limit for persons aged 65 or older to €18,000 for a single or widowed person and €36,000 for a married couple where either spouse is aged over 65 years. Financial Resolution No. 13 gives statutory effect to the budgetary announcement that a new charge called the universal social charge will be introduced on 1 January 2011.
Comment on this
The Government got it completely wrong in this case. We oppose this group of Financial Resolutions because they will hit low and middle income earners. The imposition of income tax as proposed by the Government will destroy the traditionally low level of tax levied on the wedge between the employer's bill and the take home pay of the employee. The Government is going to force down the standard of living for those on low and middle incomes.
Fine Gael proposed not to increase income taxes in 2011 and we demonstrated this could be done by making savings of €250 million through 6,000 further redundancies in back office and administration throughout the public sector. There are further alternatives for making savings, such as greater cost reductions and further changes to the public service.
Under this imposition, a single person on the minimum wage will be worse off by €879 annually or €17 per week. If one takes account of the changes made in respect of income tax and the universal charge, such an individual will lose twice as much as if he or she was on welfare. This is a savage imposition on the lowest earners. It is not the kind of progression we need and, from that point of view, must be rejected.
According to the figures outlined in the budget, the income tax that is now to be imposed means a couple with three children and a single gross income of €50,000 will be worse off by €1,800. Such a family would be better off by €1,600 under the alternative plan proposed by Fine Gael, which makes it clear that it is not necessary to increase income tax in 2011.
The Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Harney, was previously an advocate of streamlining income tax and reducing the tax burden. She will be aware, therefore, that these proposals are short-sighted, lack ambition and will force down the living standards of people on low and middle incomes. They contain a series of landmines which were never acknowledged by the Minister for Finance. They are appallingly short-sighted and retrograde and, for these reasons, I oppose them resolutely.
Comment on this
I wish to ask the Minister some questions about the universal social charge, which represents a significant change to our tax code. In effect, people will be charged for what they commonly understand as social provisions. I acknowledge that the PRSI rate of 4% is not being touched for most people but the universal charge is described in paragraph 2 of Financial Resolution No. 13 as a tax. It replaces the old health contribution and the levies that have applied since the advent of the financial emergency. As a tax, it will go into the general pool of taxation, whereas its name gives people to understand that it will be dedicated to social provision, including the areas of health and children.
The current health contribution is charged at a rate of 4% on income up to €75,000 but employees earning up to €500 per week, or €26,000 per year, are exempt. Under the new system, everyone with an income over €4,000 will be subject to the universal social charge at a higher rate. The rate of the levies in 2010 for an individual earning less than €75,000 was 2%. The universal social charge comes in at a very low level and individuals who earn more than €4,000 must pay the levy on their entire income.
The levy is reduced slightly for those who are aged 70 years and older. Every Deputy will be aware that medical card holders, including those who are aged 70 years or older, were exempt from the health contribution. I would be delighted to hear that the small print provides for this.
There are eight pages of text dealing with this levy, but I cannot find where it says that people in receipt of a medical card or who are over 70 are exempt from this new universal social charge. It is called a charge because it is general taxation and breaches the contributory principle that is at the heart of the social welfare contributory system, which is that one contributes when one works and receives entitlements in one's old age. I am surprised that Fianna Fáil opted for this measure. Perhaps it is a Progressive Democrat or a Green Party idea. I am surprised at the severity with which this measure is set out.
Can the Minister tell me I am wrong about medical card holders? As we all know, getting a medical card at present is pretty tough.
Comment on this
May I ask two questions, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle?
Comment on this
In the Budget Statement, the Minister for Finance gave us information I had heard a month ago when I was in the Department of Finance with my colleagues. The Minister said those earning more than €75,000 represent approximately 8% of all income tax payers and those 8% of taxpayers pay 60% of all income tax. Following the changes to income tax rates, how is that figure likely to change?
Second, Deputy Burton has made an important point. It is my understanding that the social insurance fund works on the basis that an individual makes a pay related social insurance, PRSI, contribution and that contribution goes into the social insurance fund. This is not a finance measure; it is a social welfare measure. In good times we take money from the social insurance fund and in bad times we supplement it. What will now happen to the social insurance fund? Will it remain in place? With the abolition of the two levies, will the new charge go into that pot of money?
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance said those earning the new reduced minimum wage would not be brought into the tax net. I seek clarification in this regard. Financial Resolution No. 12 states:
That, with effect from 1 January 2011, there shall be charged, levied and paid, in accordance with the provisions of this Resolution, a tax to be known as "universal social charge".
This is an acknowledgment that the universal social charge is a tax.
What is the situation in respect of the minimum wage? The charge will not be levied on incomes up to €4,000, at 2% on incomes up to €10,036 and at 4% on the next €5,980. There needs to be further clarification of the position of people who are earning the minimum wage. The Labour Party interpretation is that this charge is a tax to be levied on those in receipt of the new reduced minimum wage. If that is the case, it is grossly unfair.
Comment on this
The Minister described these measures as more equitable. This is completely wrong because low income earners will be paying a substantially higher proportion of their incomes than high income earners. That is grossly unfair. The Government could have introduced a wealth tax but it chose not to do so.
The universal social charge is not a social charge. It is a tax, and that is the end of it. A person earning the minimum wage has already been tapped for €40 per week. The Government now proposes to go back to the economic carcass of that person for a further €360 per annum. Can the Minister for Health and Children confirm that people on the new minimum wage will have to pay a charge of €360 per annum under this so-called social charge? This is far from fair or equitable.
I welcome the abolition of the income and health levies, which were unfair. However, they did, at least, contain some element of relativity in that they captured higher income individuals.
Comment on this
What has been done with regard to tax credits is appalling. They have been cut by 10%, as the Minister for Health and Children has outlined. This is more than the percentage cut to ministerial pensions. A tax credit applied to carers, who save the taxpayer an average of €40,000 per year. We are not giving them basic recognition in the taxation system. Given the anomalies in the respite care grant, the tax credit is the only recognition some carers receive. That recognition is now being reduced by the proposal before us.
People with a disability and those who are visually impaired incur additional costs in going to work, and have a low rate of employment in any event. The visually impaired have additional costs in making adaptations to allow them to live independently or to get to and from work. It does not make sense to penalise the small number of people who avail of this tax credit, which will be the effect of the proposed measures.
The lowest cut of all is the reduction in the tax credit for a widowed person in the year of assessment. In the year when a person loses his or her spouse, we are cutting their tax relief by 10%, which is greater than the cut to the pensions of Ministers who will be leaving Government in a few months' time.
I ask the Minister for Health and Children to justify these measures and explain why she, if she decides to retire, should be entitled to less of a cut than a widowed person in the year he or she becomes widowed. This is unacceptable, as is the cut in tax relief to someone looking after an incapacitated child. Some 64% of children with a disability must remain at home, saving the taxpayers €70,000 per year.
Comment on this
What will contributors get in return for the universal social charge? This is a con trick. It is more taxation.
Comment on this
The income levy was imposed as an emergency measure because of the financial circumstances the country was in. It was accepted on the basis that it would be dispensed with at some point. We are being asked to facilitate a con trick. We are being asked to pretend we are doing something that will give services to the public. We are about to concrete the income and health levies forever.
I can see an argument for breaking up the PRSI fund among the various health, pension and social welfare entitlements. That would have made sense to me. However, this universal social charge is an absolute con trick. I sincerely hope the public will see through it. How can the Minister for Health and Children stand over this income levy being consolidated into our tax code on an ongoing basis?
Comment on this
Does the universal social charge relate exclusively to the income and health levies being combined or will it encompass all PRSI payments? The Minister for Health and Children says the charge is revenue neutral. Will the tax be progressive or will the lower paid be charged a greater percentage of their incomes than higher earners?
The Minister says all taxpayers will suffer an equal hit. However, people earning approximately €16,000 will be coming into the tax net for the first time since 2006. They will also be liable for the universal social charge. How will revenue from the charge be used? The health levy was originally introduced for health use but I am not certain it was ever used for that purpose.
Comment on this
I agree that this is a complete con. It is a new tax. We have been given all kinds of assurances about people on minimum wages not being included in the tax net. They are not in the income tax net but they are caught in the net with this charge. This charge started as a universal social contribution with an element of contributing and getting something back but this recently changed to a charge. It is a new tax, a new way of squeezing money out of people. It is shifting the burden of taxation from the better-off to low income people. This is the whole purpose of this charge and the Government should be honest about this purpose.
A number of points of clarification are required. Will the current exemptions applying to the health and the income levies apply to the universal charge? How will it interact with family income supplement? This charge kicks in for low income people at the level of €4,000. It is designed to bring people with incomes in the region of €4,000 into the tax net and it is fundamentally unfair. Pensioners are now going to be caught with the combination of this universal charge and the lowering of the age exemption, so that a pensioner couple, with an income of just under €40,000 will be caught for an additional tax of €2,000 a year as a result of this measure. This is about hammering people on low and modest incomes and nothing else.
Comment on this
I refer to people on very low incomes being taxed because that is what this charge does. To continue the point made by Deputy Barrett, what are the benefits of this tax? We all know that PRSI, pay-related social insurance, provided certain benefits which were available when needed but where are the benefits of this charge? Who decided on the different categories? It was always accepted that certain groups with particular needs were exempted. However, it now seems there are two categories of people with regard to social welfare, the old-age pensioners — who, in this weather, would begrudge them the couple of bob they receive — and all the others. I could never understand how widows under 66 years and left with young families through no fault of their own and on a meagre income, have not been given the household package.
A friend of mine asked me to raise this question. I refer to those employed before 1995 and post-1995 in the public sector and to whom different rates of PRSI apply. The people employed after 1995 were given an increase in their salary because it was recognised they were paying a higher contribution. Will all of those people be caught for the one charge if they earn €75,000?
Comment on this
I refer to the tax wedge mentioned by Deputy Kenny. Even after the changes made today, Ireland will have the lowest tax wedge in the EU for a single person, at 31.4%——
Comment on this
——and the tenth lowest in the OECD. The rate of 31.4% places Ireland first in Europe and tenth in the OECD.
Comment on this
We are taking income tax, or take-home pay, back to where it was in 2006. With regard to the questions raised by Deputy Burton, it applies to all income other than income of less than €4,000. It does not include welfare income.
Comment on this
It includes an occupational pension.
Comment on this
Any income less than €4,004 is excluded but all income over €4,004 is included. This is applied at 2% up to €10,000, at 4% between €10,000 and €16,000 and at 7% above that.
Comment on this
No, I mentioned in my opening comments that if somebody on a salary of €26,000——
Comment on this
People on €26,000 were exempt from the old health contribution.
Comment on this
The health levy only applied to salaries over €26,000 and the income levy applied to salaries over €15,000. The minimum wage will still be excluded from tax but will be included in this charge.
Comment on this
The Minister's script describes this charge as a tax. The Minister's statement is——
Comment on this
I will explain. The health levy is going and approximately €2 billion from the health levy will go into the health service.
Comment on this
Please allow the Minister to respond to a whole series of questions as we have only three minutes left.
Comment on this
The health levy goes to fund the public health system, a total of approximately €2.1 billion in 2010 with a shortfall of €400 million because of the level of unemployment. We recently moved a Supplementary Estimate to provide for this. Instead of this being an appropriation-in-aid from the Revenue and the Department of Social Protection, it will go into the central Exchequer and will be re-diverted back. This means an element will go to fund the health system but PRSI is not being included. The Minister said last year that he intended to include PRSI but it became very complicated to do this in one year so it is not being done at the moment.
In reply to Deputy Naughten, it is not——