Leaders' Questions
- Mortgage interest supplement scheme 79 speeches
Micheál Martin criticises the phasing out of mortgage interest supplement for low-income families and asks that the statutory instrument be repealed. The Taoiseach refuses, saying it follows the Keane report and is intended to make banks negotiate solutions with borrowers.
Micheál Martin, Jerry Buttimer, Alan Shatter, Bernard Durkan, Simon Harris
- European summit jobs and growth agenda 43 speeches
Gerry Adams challenges the Taoiseach over the lack of Irish proposals on jobs, stimulus, structural funds and banking debt at the European summit. The Taoiseach cites Ireland’s action plan, project bonds and European Investment Bank funding, while rejecting federalism and defending the Government’s approach.
Joan Burton, Gerry Adams, Seán Barrett, Enda Kenny, Peadar Tóibín
- Repayment of Anglo bondholders 65 speeches
Richard Boyd Barrett condemns the repayment of Anglo Irish Bank bondholders while vulnerable citizens face cuts and homelessness, urging the Taoiseach to resist European pressure. The Taoiseach defends meeting Ireland’s obligations, warning that default would damage the country’s reputation and access to funding.
Seán Barrett, Richard Boyd Barrett, Pat Rabbitte, Tom Hayes, Arthur Spring
- Order of Business 29 speeches
The Taoiseach proposes the day’s scheduled business, including committee motions, criminal justice legislation and the Microenterprise Loan Fund Bill. Deputies and the Chair dispute whether the committee motion can be clarified or challenged before being taken without debate.
Enda Kenny, Seán Barrett, Emmet Stagg, Joe Higgins, Mattie McGrath
- Personal insolvency Bill timetable 22 speeches
Micheál Martin disputes the Taoiseach’s account of the Keane report and asks when the personal insolvency Bill will proceed. The Taoiseach says it will be published Friday, receive Second Stage before the recess if possible, and likely reach Committee Stage in October; Gerry Adams criticises the process.
Micheál Martin, Seán Barrett, Enda Kenny, Richard Boyd Barrett, Gerry Adams
- Housing Bill and homelessness 4 speeches
Richard Boyd Barrett asks when the housing Bill will address worsening homelessness linked to rent allowance cuts. The Taoiseach says its heads are due for approval later in the year and offers no specific date.
Richard Boyd Barrett, Seán Barrett, Enda Kenny
- Civil registration amendments 2 speeches
Anthony Lawlor asks about amendments allowing people who lose loved ones overseas to address registration issues; the Taoiseach says the Bill’s heads were approved and will go to a committee.
Anthony Lawlor, Enda Kenny
- Committee membership motion 18 speeches
Michael McCarthy seeks clarification on when the motion replacing Mick Wallace on a select committee takes effect and criticises the procedure. The Chair says the motion was properly scheduled without debate and that objections can be raised when it is formally agreed.
Michael McCarthy, Seán Barrett, Emmet Stagg, Mattie McGrath
- Emergency access to property data 7 speeches
Michael Healy-Rae asks whether An Post property-location data can be shared with emergency services under the data sharing Bill. The Taoiseach says there is no publication date for the Bill.
Michael Healy-Rae, Seán Barrett, Enda Kenny
- Industrial Relations Amendment Bill 3 speeches
Michael Healy-Rae asks about the Industrial Relations (Amendment) Bill 2011; the Taoiseach says it completed Committee Stage and awaits Report Stage.
Michael Healy-Rae, Seán Barrett, Enda Kenny
- Timetable for promised legislation 16 speeches
Bernard Durkan asks about the status and publication dates of legislation on collective investment schemes, the Central Bank and companies. The Taoiseach says the first Bill’s heads are unapproved, the Central Bank Bill is expected next year, and the companies Bill is expected late this year.
Bernard Durkan, Seán Barrett, Enda Kenny
- Insolvency Bill implementation 4 speeches
Willie O’Dea asks when the insolvency legislation will become operational and also seeks progress on valuation legislation. The Taoiseach expects Committee Stage in or around October and says training and appointments for the new advisory service must proceed in parallel.
Willie O'Dea, Seán Barrett, Enda Kenny
- Suspension of mortgage order 6 speeches
Aengus Ó Snodaigh asks the Taoiseach to suspend the mortgage-interest-supplement commencement order until the personal insolvency Bill is enacted, but the Chair rules that the issue has already been dealt with.
Aengus Ó Snodaigh, Seán Barrett
- Local government reform 5 speeches
Robert Dowds asks when local-government reform, including new revenue-raising powers, will be legislated. The Taoiseach says consultation is under way but cannot give a publication date.
Robert Dowds, Seán Barrett, Enda Kenny
- Sunbed restrictions for minors 2 speeches
Kevin Humphreys asks when legislation banning under-18s from using sunbeds will be taken; the Taoiseach says it is expected towards the end of November.
Kevin Humphreys, Enda Kenny
- Debate on communications committee report 3 speeches
Martin Ferris asks whether the House will debate an all-party communications, energy and natural resources committee report. The Taoiseach expresses support and refers the matter to the Chief Whip.
Martin Ferris, Seán Barrett, Enda Kenny
- High Court undertaking and financial legislation 9 speeches
Joe Higgins asks which financial measures are affected by the State’s High Court undertaking concerning Deputy Pringle’s challenge to the European Stability Mechanism. The Chair declines the matter without prior notice, and the Taoiseach declines to comment on ongoing proceedings.
Joe Higgins, Seán Barrett, Emmet Stagg, Enda Kenny
The Government established a special Cabinet committee on mortgage arrears. We have had the Keane report. There has been much soul-searching as part of the attempt to provide answers to the 118,000 people who are in significant mortgage arrears of over 90 days. The Irish Examiner summed up yesterday's rushed press conference very well when it referred to it as a "newsless news conference". Another columnist described it as "a very moving waste of time".
Comment on this
How many reports did the Deputy commission when he was in government?
Comment on this
In many ways, it sums up the Government's approach, which is really more about spin than about substance.
Comment on this
The Deputy is the King Kong of spin.
Comment on this
This serious issue affects people in mortgage arrears. I would like to mention something that was not announced yesterday. It did not merit a Government press release or press conference. Last week, the Minister, Deputy Burton, commenced a statutory instrument and laid it before the House. It was buried in Iris Oifigiúil. Essentially, it begins the phasing out and cutting of mortgage interest supplement, which is the most practical scheme that helps low-income families to avail of State support to keep the banks at bay and stay in their houses. Where is the social solidarity? The broken promise of burning the bondholders will get its final burial this week, when €1 billion is paid by the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
One would think the Deputy had never been in government.
Comment on this
Where is the social solidarity? How can the Labour Party stand over the phasing out and ending of the mortgage interest supplement scheme, which has been of benefit to 19,000 families?
Comment on this
We all know that figure has jumped significantly in the last two years.
Comment on this
Thanks to the Government of which the Deputy was a part.
Comment on this
It is likely to jump again. The low-income families that have been able to avail of this scheme will no longer be in a position to do so. They will have to deal with the banks first. They will have to make payments for 12 months before they will be considered for the mortgage interest supplement scheme. The Taoiseach briefed the banks yesterday, but he would not brief this House or the public on the details of the Bill.
Comment on this
We have tabled a notice asking for the statutory instrument in question to be annulled. Will the Taoiseach agree to annul the instrument, which will make it much more difficult for low-income families to apply for mortgage interest supplement relief in the future?
Comment on this
I am not interested in the speculation to which the Deputy has referred. Newspapers are entitled to write their reports as they see fit. That is their business.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Dea writes some of them.
Comment on this
He is job-sharing with the Sunday Independent.
Comment on this
Representatives of the Economic Management Council and the banks met each other yesterday evening. At that meeting, the banks did not receive any detail in addition to that provided when we announced that the Government had approved the personal insolvency legislation. Unlike meetings that were held in Government Buildings in the past, a full written account of this meeting will be available as a record of it for posterity.
Comment on this
Will there be a file on it or will it be shredded?
Comment on this
I want Deputy Martin to understand that the mortgage arrears sub-committee has met six times in the last six or eight weeks to push this through to a conclusion. The legislation will be published and the details will be provided on Friday. I want to make it perfectly clear that this is not about people who cannot pay - it is about people who will not pay. The lenders do not have to wait for the legislation to be implemented before they start to sit down with their customers and borrowers to work out solutions. If the banks respond to the Keane report by actually pushing through the options and facilities that will be made available to them, the need for the personal insolvency legislation to be used will be greatly diminished. The statutory instrument mentioned by Deputy Martin arises from people entering into the mortgage arrears process within the Keane report. It is for that reason that the Minister initiated the statutory instrument. That will proceed.
Comment on this
Can the Taoiseach explain that again? His last comment-----
Comment on this
It is recommended in the Keane report.
Comment on this
I am not asking the Minister. The Taoiseach seems to be completely unaware-----
Comment on this
It is not about the Keane report. It stems from the Social Welfare Act.
Comment on this
As per a recommendation in the Keane report.
Comment on this
It is commencing an order emanating from the Social Welfare Act. The Taoiseach does not seem to be aware of that. When he held his big press conference yesterday and all the lights and cameras were there-----
Comment on this
The Deputy would not read his own reports when he was in government.
Comment on this
It was called the action plan for mortgage arrears.
Comment on this
The Deputy was there for 15 years. He is like Peter Pan.
Comment on this
He seemed to be blissfully unaware about a very significant measure taken by the Minister for Social Protection which will restrict the ability of low-income families to access mortgage interest supplement relief, which is a very practical step-----
Comment on this
What did the Deputy do in government?
Comment on this
Do not be getting shirty about it because you know it hurts.
Comment on this
These people over here know it hurts.
Comment on this
The only job the Deputy was after was Brian Cowen's job.
Comment on this
The Labour Party arm of the Government, in particular, promised that there would be social solidarity.
Comment on this
I asked a very basic question of the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
I will repeat the basic question I asked the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
The Deputy is only codding the people.
Comment on this
Will he repeal the wrong decision that has been taken?
Comment on this
The statutory instrument is a wrong decision. I think it should be repealed.
Comment on this
It is very difficult with the kind of heckling that is going on.
Comment on this
The Deputy ought to be ashamed of himself. He is a fraud.
Comment on this
In fairness, a Cheann Comhairle, I am doing my best to put the question.
Comment on this
It is likely that thousands of people will get into mortgage arrears in the coming weeks and months. What was, essentially, a very practical scheme has been cut and phased out.
Comment on this
That is the impact of the statutory instrument. I asked the Taoiseach if he will repeal that statutory instrument.
Comment on this
There were no press conferences about it but he should do it. It is the honourable and right thing to do by low income families who will bear the brunt of this decision It is not the banks or anybody else, but those families who will get into difficulty in the coming weeks and months.
Comment on this
It is the banks which will get this money. This year it will cost about €50 million. This recommendation was made as part of the Keane report. It is an incentive for banks to sit down with their borrowers to work out solutions for people-----
Comment on this
The Taoiseach could not answer that question yesterday.
Comment on this
There is no intention of repealing the statutory instrument. Under this system and for those in this category, the banks will be in receipt of €50 million of taxpayers' money.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach cannot answer any question.
Comment on this
The Deputy deliberately misunderstands.
Comment on this
The Minister might find something under a trolley.
Comment on this
Please stay quiet and allow the Deputy to ask his question. There is a time limit on this. Will Deputies please pay the courtesy to the Chair of allowing the Deputy to ask his question, without the interruptions from both sides? Thank you.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach has another European crisis summit. In his interview in The Irish Times today he spent most of his time explaining why the issues affecting this State will not be raised by him. That has been his constant mantra before and after every summit he has attended. Yesterday, I asked the Taoiseach if he would bring a jobs stimulus plan to this summit; the answer was "No". I asked if he had concrete proposals about how the EU structural funds should work; the answer was "No". I asked if he had explored how funds from the European Investment Bank could be used in conjunction with the National Pensions Reserve Fund to stimulate growth and jobs; the answer was "No". He stated his position: "It is not Ireland that is in focus at this time." That is his explanation for not raising these issues.
He also welcomed the Van Rompuy report which sets out a charter for closer EU integration on a banking, fiscal and political union. The Taoiseach must know this means more co-ordination on tax policy, even more dilution of Irish sovereignty and stronger EU involvement in State budgets. Is that not the real reason he is not bringing forward his own proposals for growth that would get our people back to work? Is it not because he supports these federal EU propositions?
Comment on this
Deputy Adams is wrong on all counts, as he usually is. This Government has repeatedly made the case at European level, both politically and at official level-----
Comment on this
-----for the need for growth, jobs and a stimulus to drive and encourage movement in the European economies. The meetings on Thursday and Friday will deal with an increase in funding that is available from the European Investment Bank which, in turn, will leverage further moneys but it has to be made available to countries that are in vulnerable positions or those such as Ireland that are in a programme. That is the first answer, a "Yes", which Ireland will articulate very strongly.
Second, I refer to the approval of project bonds. This is an opportunity for flexibility to be shown by Europe in respect of these bonds which have only applied to huge intercontinental infrastructural developments such as motorways, autobahns or railroads. Project bonds would be useful for smaller countries but flexibility must be shown in that regard. That is an issue I will articulate, along with a number of other smaller countries, namely, that as part of the growth and jobs stimulus project bonds should be flexible enough to cater for smaller countries.
Third, I refer to creative ways of using structural funds that remain unspent in countries. This country has spent all the structural funds that were allocated to it. Greece, for example, was allocated €16 billion which it cannot spend because of the requirement to put up moneys from a national perspective. In an overall sense, significant amounts of structural funds will not be spent. The political challenge is to find a creative way of not withdrawing money from envelopes allocated to individual countries but finding a facility whereby when money is not spent over a range of countries a creative way can be found to use it.
Comment on this
Some €100 billion of new money went to Spanish banks.
Comment on this
Romania, for example, cannot draw down all its structural funds and there are a number of other problems in that regard. In those three areas, in respect of the growth and jobs agenda, Ireland will be very strong in articulating what is in both our interest and the interest of the eurozone. The problem, however, is the banking crisis and that is the issue for Friday's meeting. The problem we face here is that if one accepts the principle of European decision-making and sharing of liability, the corollary is also true. In Ireland's case what happened was that the direction was given from Europe and the Government lay down in front of it and accepted that the Irish people should shoulder all of that liability. That is where there needs to be change. That is the design flaw that applies within the eurozone.
As I stated in that interview, the eurozone banking crisis is holding back this and every other country. As an exporting nation we need other European economies to be thriving and getting stronger so that they will buy our goods. Europe as a whole buys from other countries around the world; it is a global situation. The real opportunity on Friday is for political leadership. Speculators and those who write and comment can say what they like. This must be a political process with a political decision that will set clarity of structure and strategy in which markets and investors can have confidence and understand the strength of and the future of the euro and the eurozone. That is a political problem that must be dealt with by political leaders. We - and I - will articulate this. I will articulate that argument very strongly on behalf of the Irish Government and the people. What was accepted in the past is the cause of the problem. The principle of acceptance of European decision making and sharing of liability was not applied in the case of this country - to our cost.
Comment on this
Once again, the Taoiseach has totally ignored the question. He also engaged in extreme revisionism.
Comment on this
Shake the hand that shook the hand.
Comment on this
What was the question I put to the Taoiseach? It was about his support for the Van Rompuy proposals for a federal Europe. His rhetoric about wanting to be the Taoiseach who restores sovereignty is only that. It is like the nonsense from his partners in the Labour Party. The fact is he is not bringing forward proposals for job stimulus
Comment on this
He is not bringing forward any of the propositions we put to him.
Comment on this
He knows there needs to be a clear plan for renewal, growth, jobs and investment but his Government does not have that. There needs to be a clean-up of the toxic banking debt.
Comment on this
Please stop the behind the scenes shouting. Please put your question, Deputy Adams. There is one minute for a supplementary question.
Comment on this
The question is this. It is only a month since we had a referendum on the austerity treaty, which was advocated by the Government and Fianna Fáil. We pointed out at the time that it would not work.
Comment on this
What is the question? Please put the question. Will the usual suspects ever stay quiet, just for two more minutes?
Comment on this
Will the Taoiseach accept that the people who voted, through gritted teeth-----
Comment on this
-----in favour of that treaty will feel very badly let down by him when he says to them, "Before you go". Imagine if this was a Munster final.
Comment on this
Ireland is not the focus at this time. Why turn up? The Taoiseach is going as a spectator instead of a player and I am very disappointed in that.
Comment on this
The Deputy is wrong again. I reported to the other political leaders on the Government's publication of its own action plan for jobs nationally, with 270 propositions to open the doors of business. I reported and discussed with the other leaders the renegotiation of the memorandum of understanding by the Government in respect of job opportunities and taking the lower paid out of a requirement for certain payments and so on. In addition, I presented a report to the other leaders in respect of small and medium enterprises and how the doors for opportunities could be opened. That will be reported on again and responded to by the Commission very shortly.
The Van Rompuy report sets out a strategy for greater cohesion but for the development of the eurozone and the European Union. I support the question-----
Comment on this
-----of creative use of Structural Funds. I support the question of flexibility for project bonds suitable for smaller countries and I support the leveraging up of extra finance for the European Investment Bank.
Comment on this
The Deputy should know this is about the opportunity to provide other moneys for infrastructure here, be it bundles of schools, primary care centres or other pieces of infrastructure. In that sense it is not about a federal Europe, which I do not support.
The Deputy mentioned the phrase "extreme revisionism". This is a day of particular significance for the country. For the Deputy, extreme revisionism is something that he could be open about now because while we differ here on all of these political issues, there is one thing that I have in common with him-----
Comment on this
-----and it is that in the context of extreme revisionism neither he nor I were members of the IRA or the IRA army council.
Comment on this
I thank the Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
As the Taoiseach rightly suggested, Fianna Fáil bankrupted this country by providing a blanket guarantee to bankers and bondholders-----
Comment on this
-----yet the Taoiseach's Government has continued this disastrous policy at a terrible cost to ordinary citizens who have lost their jobs and seen their incomes and services butchered. The Taoiseach has extended that policy by continuing to pay off unsecured and unguaranteed bondholders.
Comment on this
Yet no matter how much the Taoiseach grovels to the troika and to Angela Merkel she snubs her nose at us and insists that we take more pain and now she wants to do the same to Spain and Italy. Yet against this background this week the Taoiseach's Government is in the process of paying over €1 billion to Anglo Irish Bank and Irish Nationwide bondholders. Is not the equation in terms of this transaction very simple and very cruel? Somewhere in the Mediterranean or the Caribbean a multimillionaire speculator will be cracking open a bottle champagne to celebrate his profits bonanza and the stupidity of the Irish Government-----
Comment on this
-----while somewhere in rural Ireland-----
Comment on this
What would the Deputy know about that?
Comment on this
-----a community fears for the future of their school, or the parents of children with intellectual disabilities-----
Comment on this
The Deputy would know nothing about rural Ireland.
Comment on this
-----fear for their child's future because of the loss of vital supports, or more families are made homeless as a result of the Government's cuts in rent allowance.
Comment on this
Why does the Taoiseach not save these vulnerable people more suffering by refusing to enrich the multimillionaire speculators in Anglo Irish Bank bonds and go to the European Council and tell Angela Merkel that we have had enough-----
Comment on this
Keep your money, Angela, we will be fine.
Comment on this
-----that the people of this country have had enough suffering and they will not continue to take the pain for her and the multimillionaire speculators?
Comment on this
I am not sure what Deputy Boyd Barrett's question is. I thought he was going to tell me-----
Comment on this
Go to the European Council and tell them-----
Comment on this
The Deputy does not want any more supports from them either, is that it?
Comment on this
I thought Deputy Boyd Barrett was going to tell me what day he has chosen for his day of national protest.
Comment on this
It is 18 July. I am glad the Taoiseach mentioned it.
Comment on this
I have made it clear before that we share the public's dismay at the cost of honouring the banking debts, considering the role of the banks in the economic crisis. When the Government was appointed we raised this with the ECB and with the various authorities at European level. The fact is the vast majority of Anglo Irish Bank debts were paid off by our predecessors in office. Some €15.7 billion was paid out in senior unsecured bonds since the Government of the day issued a blanket guarantee back in September 2008 and €160 million remains to be paid after this week. If one allows Anglo Irish Bank to default clearly that would create doubt over future funding being made available by the European Central Bank to Irish banks at very low interest levels and we would see a renewed flight of funds and ever tighter credit conditions being placed on potential Irish job creators. We cannot and will not have that.
As I said to Deputy Adams on many occasions, we are not going to default, especially as we have rebuilt the reputation, trust and the confidence of this country. What we need now at political level is a political decision to deal with the eurozone banking crisis. The changes being made by Government are challenging and great credit is due to the people in accepting those changes and for the clarity of their decision, not least in the Deputy's constituency, in respect of the fiscal stability treaty. The crisis of the moment is the banking crisis within the eurozone.
The Van Rompuy paper, referred to by Deputy Adams, is a strategy and a roadmap where growth and opportunity can be created but for me and for the other leaders, the question is what political decisions can be made on Friday in regard to the immediate crisis in the banking situation within the eurozone and to set out that pathway and strategy where confidence, trust and stability can be restored. It is important for investment into the eurozone, investment here, purchases of goods and dealing in the euro. All of those areas require political decisions and that process has to start on Friday.
Comment on this
If I understand the Taoiseach correctly, what he is saying is that maintaining our good reputation with some multimillionaire on a yacht who is celebrating tonight his good fortune-----
Comment on this
-----over the decision to pay back bonds is more important than the future of children with intellectual disabilities------
Comment on this
-----who have to face the year ahead without vital supports that they need-----
Comment on this
He probably went to St. Michael's-----
Comment on this
-----or small rural schools that face closure-----
Comment on this
-----or families that are being turfed out on the streets.
Comment on this
That is what the Taoiseach is saying.
Comment on this
Today and tomorrow the Taoiseach intends to pay €0.5 billion back to these bondholders in order that our reputation is good with them. Is that what the Taoiseach is saying?
Comment on this
Of course, the bondholders must love us; Angela Merkel must absolutely adore the Taoiseach at this stage.
Comment on this
Is our reputation with those people more important than the future of vulnerable citizens and children and ordinary people in this country who are being crucified with the cuts that are having to be made in order to repay these speculators-----
Comment on this
-----and bondholders?
Comment on this
The Deputy is delighted with austerity.
Comment on this
What sort of priorities are those?
Comment on this
Deputy Boyd Barrett does not seem to understand or appreciate the consequences of default. His whole philosophy in this House has been negative, a case of do nothing, work for nothing, pay for nothing. Part of the discussions-----
Comment on this
People are working very hard.
Comment on this
-----increasing the extent of funds available to the European Investment Bank which will, please God, have a direct impact on many of those communities whose schools are in poor shape. What is being negotiated is the opportunity to provide bundles of primary care centres or schools under the PPP, public-private partnership, system, provided the conditions can be applied and that the extra funding made available through the EIB can be provided for countries in vulnerable positions such as Ireland. This is in addition to the €17 billion capital programme which the Government has set out for the next number of years in order to deal with the provision of a range of facilities, including some of those to which the Deputy referred.
The Deputy well knows that every country has to borrow money. Does he think in that ruthless world of commercial lending, where these situations apply-----
Comment on this
Ruthless is the right word.
Comment on this
-----that this country could expect to continue to be funded if we were to default or not measure up to our responsibilities?
Comment on this
Do not guarantee the bonds.
Comment on this
Ireland's reputation is of a country that will do what it says it will do, that it will meet its requirements, provided we get the extra assistance and flexibility. This country has made significant progress in the past 15 months. The Deputy seems to argue that we should get the money, not pay it back and expect to get more at the same level.
Comment on this
That is absolute nonsense. The Deputy does not live in the real world if that is his philosophy.
Comment on this
It is proposed to take No. a8, motion re ministerial rota for parliamentary questions, without debate; No. b8, motion re membership of committees, without debate; No. 1, Criminal Justice (Withholding of Information on Offences Against Children and Vulnerable Persons) Bill 2012 [Seanad] - Second Stage (resumed), to adjourn at 5.30 p.m. if not previously concluded; and No. 6, Microenterprise Loan Fund Bill 2012 - Order for Second Stage and Second Stage.
It is proposed, notwithstanding anything in Standing Orders, that the Dáil shall sit later than 9 p.m. tonight and shall adjourn not later than 10 p.m.; Private Members’ business shall be No. 56, motion re arts and culture (resumed), to conclude at 9 p.m. tonight, if not previously concluded.
Comment on this
He did. For some reason or other, the Ceann Comhairle refused him and said he could raise it on the Order of Business. It is a matter to be put to the House and agreed.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Stagg object to what is being proposed? I asked if it is agreed and nobody said it was not agreed.
Comment on this
We wanted clarity before it was agreed.
Comment on this
He is entitled to ask for clarity on an issue before it is agreed.
Comment on this
On what issue? Is it the proposal regarding motion re ministerial rota for parliamentary questions and membership of committees agreed?
Comment on this
He wishes to raise the motion on membership of committees.
Comment on this
It is on the Order Paper. Can Deputy Stagg read?
Comment on this
The Ceann Comhairle was putting a question to the House as to whether we agreed to that being taken without debate-----
Comment on this
Deputy McCarthy was looking for clarity on the motion before it was put to the House.
Comment on this
That is a new Standing Order which the Ceann Comhairle is making up.
Comment on this
I do not respect wrong decisions by the Chair.
Comment on this
Deputy Stagg should read the Order Paper which contains the Order of Business. That is where he will find it.
Comment on this
The reason Deputy Higgins is raising his voice is that he is a second Wallace under house arrest.
Comment on this
We would not get away with that.
Comment on this
None of us would get away with it.
Comment on this
On forthcoming legislation, I wish to point out to the Taoiseach that the Keane report did not recommend the ending of the mortgage interest supplement scheme. In my view he should not have distorted its recommendations in his response to my earlier questions. The report looks for sustainable models but nowhere in the Keane report is there a recommendation for the ending or the phasing out of the mortgage interest supplement scheme, which is a scandal in terms of what-----
Comment on this
Will the Taoiseach give the House an indication and an outline as to when it is proposed to circulate the personal insolvency Bill, the timetable for Second Stage debate and for Committee Stage and ultimate implementation and commencement? We need some idea of the timeline for implementation of the proposed measures.
Comment on this
The personal insolvency Bill will be published and circulated on Friday and a full press conference will be held on Friday to deal with any questions on the details of the Bill. It is expected that Second Stage will be taken probably next week. It is not a fact that the banks must wait for the Bill to be enacted before they start dealing with their customers and their borrowers. The very fact that the legislation is being produced and published and is going through the process, is an opportunity for banks and lenders to sit down and work it through with their customers. The Bill will be published on Friday and all the details of the technicalities will be available on Friday. The Whips will make arrangements for the Second Stage to be taken probably next week. I expect a lot of interest in this Bill. We will accommodate the House by making as much time as possible available for the Second Stage debate, given the proposal for a summer recess. However, I want to see Second Stage concluded after everyone has had an opportunity to participate in the debate.
Comment on this
What is the timeline for Committee Stage?
Comment on this
I will not give the Deputy a timeline for Committee Stage because I do not expect this will be concluded before the summer recess. There is a great deal of interest in this legislation but if we can have concluded Second Stage before the summer recess we will be doing very well.
Comment on this
I would say that is probably a realistic time period, when the Dáil resumes after the summer recess. We can work through the Committee Stage process. October is a good bet, I would think. We are anxious to have it finalised appropriately around that time.
Comment on this
Ceann Comhairle, please.
Comment on this
I think a wee dose of rescue remedy for the Government Deputies might be useful in these sessions.
The process outlined by the Taoiseach for dealing with the personal insolvency Bill is most unsatisfactory. It is obvious the Bill is ready.
Comment on this
It is not a case of the personal insolvency Bill not being brought to the House. On Friday, I want Members to have a copy of the Bill, the explanatory memorandum and the questions and answers across a spectrum of areas dealing with this.
Comment on this
That is the reason it will be brought to the House next week. It is not a case of having it physically available for Government Deputies; it has to be done for everybody. It was approved yesterday, will be published on Friday and all the details will be in the House next week for the start of the process.
The fiscal stability legislation will be introduced in this session also.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach cleared this Bill with the banks first, before coming to the House.
Comment on this
This is not a case of having to go to any bank to seek approval to publish. The banks have no control over any reforms this Government wishes to introduce in legislation.
Comment on this
Last week, I raised with the Tánaiste the deepening crisis as a result of cuts in the rent allowance, which has seen more families being made homeless or threatened with homelessness. In that context, when will we discuss the housing Bill on the legislative programme? Despite asking several times, we have been given no specific timeline for when that Bill will be discussed. Given the serious crisis of homelessness or threatened homelessness for thousands of families across the country-----
Comment on this
-----can the Taoiseach say when the Bill will be introduced? Can he accelerate the process so we get a chance to discuss this most serious issue?
Comment on this
I cannot tell the Deputy when it will be discussed because the heads of the Bill are due for approval later this year. We will try to expedite it but I cannot give the Deputy an answer to his question about a specific date.
Comment on this
When is it proposed to bring forward amendments to the Civil Registration Act 2004, as has been discussed by a number of Ministers and Ministers of State, with regard to people who have lost loved ones overseas?
Comment on this
Approval was given for the heads of the Bill on Tuesday. It will now go before the health committee or the social protection committee for discussion.
Comment on this
A Cheann Comhairle, I am seeking clarification on No. b8, motion re membership of committees. When does that take effect? No. b8 on the Order Paper confirms that Deputy Mick Wallace is to be discharged from the Select Committee on Investigations, Oversight and Petitions and be replaced by Deputy Boyd Barrett. I wanted to confirm that Injun Joe has done a hatchet job on Deputy Mick Wallace.
Comment on this
Let me clarify one thing. I was asked by the Government Whip to put an Order of Business announced by the Taoiseach to the House, which is that a motion on this matter be taken without debate. I put that question to the House and nobody objected. Later, I will put the question that the motion be agreed. If the Deputy has objections to it, that is the time to raise it. Please do not start roaring and shouting at me because I am doing my job in accordance with the order.
Comment on this
I was not roaring and shouting.
Comment on this
I was not roaring and shouting. I asked a question under Standing Orders-----
Comment on this
You were not entitled to do it and you were told to resume your seat. I call Deputy Healy-Rae.
Comment on this
I am entitled to ask the question under Standing Orders.
Comment on this
I am not wrong. You should go and learn the Standing Orders and something about the Order of Business.
Comment on this
Are you saying nobody can say anything about it?
Comment on this
On a point of clarification, a Cheann Comhairle, is the Deputy not half of the Government Whip?
Comment on this
I thought he was half of the Government Whip. He is confusing us all now.
Comment on this
With regard to the data sharing Bill, could the data held by An Post on the location and grid co-ordinates of all properties in Ireland be included in this legislation and shared exclusively with emergency services?
Comment on this
I wish to raise another item, a Cheann Comhairle.
Comment on this
The other Bill is the Industrial Relations (Amendment) Bill 2011. Should there be a requirement-----
Comment on this
What is the current position with the collective investment schemes consolidation Bill, which is promised and for which there is an obvious and pressing need? Similarly, the Central Bank (consolidation) Bill is also promised and is also very much required.
Comment on this
We do not need the added comments. Will the Deputy just ask the question? There are many Deputies here.
Comment on this
We do not want to go through this every morning. Just ask the question about the legislation.
Comment on this
If I did that, a Cheann Comhairle, I would not be able to represent the people who sent me here. The third legislative measure is the companies Bill. This is also promised and there is an obvious and pressing need for it. Have the three promised legislative measures been discussed by the Cabinet, have the heads been approved-----
Comment on this
It has been standard practice in the House for as long as I have been a Member, unless it has been changed and I do not know about it. Have the heads of the respective Bills been approved? Can some indication be given as to when they are likely to be brought to the House and when they are likely to become law?
Comment on this
The heads of the collective investment Bill have not yet been approved and there is no date for the publication of the Bill. The Central Bank (consolidation) Bill will be published next year. The heads of the companies Bill were cleared a number of years ago. There are 1,300 sections in the Bill and it is expected to be published late this year.
Comment on this
I wish to raise two items. When can we expect the valuation (amendment) Bill, to amend the Valuation Act? Second, with regard to the insolvency Bill, the Taoiseach indicated that it will be October, at the earliest, before Committee Stage is taken. He will be aware that a big administrative mechanism must be put in place to bring this Bill into effect. When does he expect the legislation to be in operation?
Comment on this
No, a Cheann Comhairle. When will the legislation actually be in operation? Is it realistic to state that it will not be in operation until early 2013, at the earliest?
Comment on this
I expect the Bill to be on Committee Stage in October but if we can get it onto that Stage before the end of September when the Dáil resumes, so much the better. It will go straight from Second Stage to Committee Stage. If we conclude Second Stage before the recess, that will be better. Obviously arrangements must be made in respect of training and appointing personnel for the advisory service that must be provided. That is part of the process that must take place as the legislation proceeds. Parallel with that, banks and lenders now know the legislation will be published on Friday and that it will become a reality. There is nothing to stop them increasing their interaction with their customers in respect of working out solutions for their circumstances and their mortgage situations.
I expect the valuation (amendment) Bill to be ready in the next session.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach has just mentioned the personal insolvency Bill and that it would be published on Friday. Last week a commencement order regarding the mortgage interest supplement was laid before the House.
Comment on this
I know that but since the Taoiseach has indicated that the banks must engage with the lenders who are in distress, and we do not know what is contained in the personal insolvency Bill because we have not seen it yet, could he ask the Minister for Social Protection to suspend that commencement order-----
Comment on this
-----pending the passage of the personal insolvency Bill because the two are connected?
Comment on this
In the context of promised legislation, and I realise this is looking into the future, could the Taoiseach indicate when there will be substantial reform of local government? Will part of that local government reform include extra finance raising powers for local authorities?
Comment on this
Will such legislation be completed before the next local elections?
Comment on this
The general intent is that responsibility should be devolved to local authorities. The consultation process for reform of this is under way with the Minister for the Environment, Community and Local Government, councils, local authorities and anybody else who is interested. The Minister will reflect on the findings of that and bring a memorandum to Government in due course. I regret that I cannot give the Deputy a date for publication of the legislation. It would be a matter for Cabinet to decide on arising from the reports prepared by the Minister for the Environment, Community and Local Government.
Comment on this
I welcome the Government support yesterday for the Bill currently before the Seanad to prohibit the use of tobacco in cars. A total of 8,000 new cases of skin cancer are diagnosed each year. Many of them are young people under the age of 18. When will the Bill to control the use of sun beds for those under 18 be taken?
Comment on this
That is an important issue that has been referred to on many occasions. That Bill will be brought in towards the end of November.
Comment on this
In recent weeks the committee on communications, energy and natural resources published an all-party report on which there was unanimous agreement by all members. That report is being debated in the Seanad today. Are there any provisions to put that before the House to allow every Deputy the opportunity to debate it?
Comment on this
I assume it is a matter for the Whips. There is no objection from here to having a debate on it. I will ask the Chief Whip to raise the matter at the normal meeting.
Comment on this
I have a question on financial legislation but to be helpful could I first advise that Deputies Stagg and McCarthy should have taken their Milk of Magnesia this morning. It would have a calming effect-----
Comment on this
-----on their interventions here.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Higgins want to hide what he was doing?
Comment on this
Second, they should read Standing Orders and get to know them.
Comment on this
Yesterday in the High Court the State, on behalf of the Government, gave an undertaking that certain financial measures in proposed legislation would not be proceeded with until the action by Deputy Pringle with regard to the European Stability Mechanism and the necessity for a referendum thereon would be dealt with. Does the Taoiseach know about that and what aspects of legislation will be affected?
Comment on this
That is not really a suitable matter for the Order of Business without prior notice.