Minister’s meeting with NAMA
McDonald repeatedly seeks to establish whether the Tánaiste knew of Health Minister James Reilly’s meeting with NAMA about primary-care-centre locations, including Balbriggan. The Tánaiste says he cannot track every Minister’s diary, prompting procedural disputes over the one-question rule and accusations that he is avoiding the issue.
What about the Minister and NAMA?
Comment on this
What about the Minister? There was a third question.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste deliberately ran down the clock.
Comment on this
The questions were answered in the order they were asked.
Comment on this
I thought a Deputy was entitled to ask one question only, not five.
Comment on this
We cannot have comprehensive questions being asked all over the place. This is Leaders' Questions.
Comment on this
Let us be reasonable and we will do the best we can. I ask Deputy Mary Lou McDonald to proceed.
Comment on this
This is the Labour Party's custodial democracy.
Comment on this
I have asked reasonable questions.
Comment on this
Deputy Mary Lou McDonald asked five questions.
Comment on this
That is too many for the Labour Party. One a week is all it wants.
Comment on this
On the mobility allowance, in 2008 the State acknowledged that it was acting outside the law in having an upper age limit.
Will the Tánaiste tell us if the Government proposes to rectify the situation? There is no question but that the State is acting outside the law. It must bring this scheme within it. I also ask the Tánaiste to answer my question on the meeting between the Minister, Deputy James Reilly, and NAMA in April.
Comment on this
Did the Tánaiste speak to the Minister about this matter? Did he tell the Tánaiste that he had met NAMA?
Comment on this
The Deputy is only entitled to ask one question.
Comment on this
Did the Minister tell the Tánaiste that they had discussed the issue of primary care centres and their locations? Did he tell him that Balbriggan was part and parcel of that discussion? If the Tánaiste knew all of this, did it not set alarm bells ringing? He stood up here and gave a very long, elaborate answer on one issue that I had raised, but he is clearly dodging the issue of NAMA and the Minister. Did he know that the meeting had taken place and if he did not, will he raise the matter with the Minister?
Comment on this
Before the Tánaiste responds, I wish to make a point. I do not like to interrupt Deputies when they are asking questions, but I want to make it clear that in the future they cannot bring in three or four topics when asking questions.
Comment on this
It does not matter because they do not answer questions anyway.
Comment on this
We allow a question to the Taoiseach or the Tánaiste. I ask Deputies to respect this.
Comment on this
I am willing to answer questions raised here, but it is my understanding that during Leaders' Questions, when questions are asked without notice, the rule of the House is that the representative of each party can ask one question. I will be quite happy, if the rules are changed, to answer four or five questions, if necessary. I would have no problem with this.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste makes up the rules as he goes along.
Comment on this
One question a week is enough for the Tánaiste.
Comment on this
I have tried to give a comprehensive answer. Deputy Mary Lou McDonald asked about the children's hospital and the mobility allowance.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste is going to talk it out again.
Comment on this
Having given Deputy Mary Lou McDonald a comprehensive answer to those questions, she is now saying I did not answer the other one.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste needs to cut the waffle and answer the question.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste is fairly handy himself at parliamentary tricks.
Comment on this
We recognise what the Tánaiste is doing too - he is not answering the question.
Comment on this
Regarding the question on the mobility allowance, we have the report from the Ombudsman which is under consideration by the Government. We must obtain legal advice on how to proceed because, obviously, the recommendation made in the report concerns compliance with the terms of the Equal Status Act. We are obtaining that advice. The second report issued by the Ombudsman yesterday will be considered by the Government.
Regarding individual Ministers, who they meet and what is in their diaries, I cannot track, nor do I want to, the diaries of every Minister, who they met-----
Comment on this
The Tánaiste wanted to do it when he was in opposition.
Comment on this
Therefore, the Tánaiste did not know about the meeting.
Comment on this
The Labour Party Minister of State resigned over this.
Comment on this
Did the Tánaiste know about the meeting?
Comment on this
Does the Tánaiste know that it is illegal to lobby NAMA?