Financial Resolution No. 15: General (Resumed)
Contributions 1–131 of 248. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Yesterday the Ministers, Deputies Noonan and Howlin, delivered the Government's second budget. This is not an easy budget for the people of Ireland nor could it have been, but it is a necessary step as part of our long-term plan for economic renewal. This budget is about supporting jobs, and about ensuring that the burden of the adjustment is fair. To fulfil our potential as an economy and as a country, we have to restore the public finances to a healthy condition. That is our real challenge as a country.
The budget will deliver the necessary fiscal adjustment, but it will also provide extra support for job creation and for small Irish businesses. Our role is to build the supportive environment so that the private sector can deliver the jobs that our people and our economy need.
I do not accept that we must be saddled indefinitely with current high rates of unemployment, slow growth and a squeeze on disposable incomes. These are neither inevitable nor tolerable. Our ambition is to move beyond the progress achieved to date, and to tackle these key issues head on.
Without the difficult action taken by the Government, the economy would not be on a solid pathway towards recovery and growth once again. Since taking office less than two years ago, the Government has worked to address the economic crisis we inherited from the previous Administration.
Some commentators attribute all of our economic difficulties to the banks and the enormous bailouts given to them by the previous Government. The reckless behaviour of banks and the equally reckless bank bailouts of the previous Government remain a major burden on the Irish people, and one which our European partners have now promised to reduce through renegotiation of the bailout deal, but reducing the burden of the bank bailouts will not, by itself, keep our economy on a sustainable path back to prosperity and full employment. This requires that we tackle with equal determination the two other economic legacies of recent Fianna Fáil-led Governments - the damage done to our export and foreign direct investment-led economic model during the credit-fuelled property boom and the massive underlying deficit we inherited in the public finances.
Even if the State had no banking-related debts whatsoever, we would still be dealing with an unprecedented gap between Government revenues and spending - the legacy of the reckless unfunded spending commitments of the previous Government and its "when we have it we spend it" philosophy. Even if the State had no banking-related debts whatsoever, we would still be dealing with the massive job-destruction legacy of the property and construction crash - the legacy of what one might call the "Galway tent" school of economics that left hundreds of thousands of our people without work and in need of re-skilling for the more sustainable, enterprise-led economy that we are trying to recreate.
Since taking office less than two years ago, the Government has worked hard to address the economic difficulties we inherited. We have prioritised fixing the public finances, restoring the banking system to some sense of normality, and supporting job creation and economic growth. Our economy finally returned to growth last year with GDP increasing by 1.4%, the first annual increase in GDP since 2007. We anticipate further modest growth this year. It proves that the Irish economy can grow even during a period of necessary and difficult budgetary consolidation and in a very challenging international environment.
The labour market has shown encouraging signs of stabilisation in recent months. While unemployment is still unacceptably high and its effects are felt far too wide, the most recent quarterly figures show that the employment situation has stabilised. The pro-job measures in the budget aim to build on these tentative steps to encourage greater job creation and investment.
Over the past year 20,000 new private sector jobs have been created following the loss of over 250,000 jobs in the private sector during the previous three years. The package of measures in the budget announced yesterday aimed at the small business sector will encourage businesses throughout the country to start expanding and hiring again. They will restore a much needed measure of confidence to the job creation sector.
The budget is a building block in the transition from the old failed economic plan based on property speculation and debt to a new competitive Irish economy based on enterprise, exports and innovation. That competitiveness is crucial for continued investment so that jobs can be created.
We have also seen signs of stabilisation in other parts of the economy, such as the property market. Residential property prices show a modest increase over the most recent three-month period, and the pace of annual decline is at its slowest since September 2008. While there is some way to go before the market returns to more normal levels, the latest surveys show the past quarter having the largest volume of mortgage loans issued since the end of 2010 - 3,983 for the third quarter of the year.
Budget 2013 also sees Ireland continue to face up to its economic challenges. Ireland and its people are recognised internationally for its sensible and pragmatic approach in dealing with our financial difficulties. This has greatly helped the Government in its important work of restoring Ireland's international reputation, which, as the House will be aware, had been badly damaged under the previous Administration. We continue to make very significant progress and there are many clear signs that Ireland's reputation has steadily improved.
In recent months the country has taken it first steps to restoring its economic independence by returning to the international markets for funding. Both pillar banks have raised money in the markets without State guarantee. Last year saw exports reach new heights of a record €173 billion - some 10% higher than in 2007, the highest pre-crisis figure. A good export performance is expected again this year. Nobody can deny the importance of that.
Budget 2013 will build on this progress by reducing the transport and export costs of small and medium sized businesses. Export transport is provided by hauliers, the majority of whom themselves are small businesses. I am pleased to note the introduction of a rebate on diesel with effect from the middle of next year.
This will also benefit the export orientated foreign multinational sector. Over the past year we have seen a strong line of investment decisions from new and existing multinationals creating thousands of new jobs.
Important job announcements from both indigenous and foreign companies include the Kerry Group, Voxpro, Paddy Power, EA Games and Arvato Finance, to name but a few. These are all strong signs of confidence in Ireland and show that our considerable efforts to rebuild our reputation are bearing fruit. A significant amount of work remains to be done and the challenges before us are great.
We will continue to work to enhance our international reputation. Our EU Presidency, starting in January, will give us another opportunity to demonstrate our strengths as a nation. The one thing that no money can buy, however, is a reputation for hard work, creativity, skill and strength of character. The Government is not complacent about the challenge ahead. We acknowledge and fully understand the hard work of the Irish people to get us to this position. They know that there are no easy answers to restoring this country’s prosperity and future progress. I thank them for their indulgence, understanding and patience.
Despite the many changes made as a country, we continue to spend more than we collect in revenue. This has to be addressed. Fixing our national finances and putting them back on a sound footing is an absolute prerequisite for job creation and economic growth. It is absolutely necessary for confidence and certainty in our economy. To this end, the Government remains fully committed to the 2013 deficit ceiling of 7.5% of GDP and to reducing our deficit to below 3% of GDP by 2015. For 2012, we will be well within our deficit target agreed with the troika.
In May, the Irish people voted overwhelmingly to ratify the fiscal stability treaty. This much needed reform will ensure that governments now and in the future will manage the public finances appropriately and sustainably, so that what happened in the past will never recur. In recognition of mistakes made by previous governments, this budget has broadened the tax base. For too long, successive governments have relied on a very narrow source of revenues. The introduction of a fair, progressive and proportionate property tax will help us to address the budget deficit and will help to avoid additional taxes on income. Increasing income taxes at this time would only serve to destroy jobs, hit working families and affect our competitiveness. These families and their futures are the central focus of this budget.
As the Minister for Finance reiterated in his speech, in order to underpin the high levels of foreign direct investment and sustain indigenous enterprise and job creation, we will maintain Ireland’s 12.5% rate of corporation tax, which is a long-standing and core element of our enterprise strategy. Ireland’s corporation tax regime is transparent, easy to navigate and very close to the effective rate of 11.9%. This is to provide certainty to Irish businesses so that they can plan for the future with clarity and confidence, and thereby create more jobs.
Obviously, the Government is not satisfied with the high level of unemployment throughout the country. For this reason we have deliberately focussed on job creation and are committed to ensuring that our policies support strong and sustainable employment growth. We are committed to adding 100,000 jobs to the economy by 2016 and to have 2 million people in employment by 2020. To achieve this, as I have said on many occasions, I want Ireland to be recognised as the best small country in the world in which to do business by 2016.
Earlier this year we launched a comprehensive and detailed action plan on jobs. That action plan is about taking incremental and necessary steps right across Government to support enterprises to grow, create and retain jobs - quarter by quarter, reform by reform and step by step. In tandem with our action plan, we launched Pathways to Work, which is a fundamental reform of the way we support, engage with and treat jobseekers. The recently launched new, integrated service Intreo transforms the way we support jobseekers back into jobs, treating people looking for work as real contributors to our society and not as mere statistics. This new service is already working well, offering new hope and new opportunities for the future.
We have sought to maximise private investment in much needed infrastructure. Last year, we announced the establishment of NewERA and the Strategic Investment Fund. NewERA is a key commitment in the programme for Government and is central to the Government’s plans for job creation, investment and reforming how the Government manages its semi-State companies. In August, the Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources, Deputy Rabbitte, published a national broadband plan which sets ambitious targets for the roll-out of high-speed broadband throughout the entire country. Some 200 secondary schools are currently being connected throughout the country as part of that plan, thus giving young people the opportunity to connect with the world.
To improve the availability of credit for business, the credit guarantee scheme commenced in October of this year. Initially, the scheme will facilitate up to €150 million of additional lending per annum to small and medium enterprises, in addition to the lending targets set for the pillar banks. It will provide a 75% State guarantee to banks against losses on qualifying loans to firms with growth and job creation potential. A microfinance scheme also opened for business in October. This will provide loans on a commercial basis for start-up businesses and micro-enterprises, which are very important for communities all over the country. Over a ten year period, it is expected that over €90 million in additional lending will be provided to 5,500 micro-enterprises with the potential to support the creation of an anticipated new 7,700 jobs. This drive is being led by the Minister of State at the Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation, Deputy Perry.
This budget is about building on the progress of the past 18 months to create more jobs and support small Irish businesses. It introduces further measures to support Irish business and sustain our economic recovery. As in our first budget, we have not raised income tax. We want to make work pay for families. We do not want to add extra taxes onto jobs and investment, which would be a step back on our path of national recovery.
Supporting small and medium-sized Irish businesses, which have a presence in every townland across the country, is absolutely essential if we are to get our country working again. Therein lies the key to Ireland’s future prosperity. The ten-point tax plan for small business is therefore a central feature of this year’s budget. The plan includes a series of measures that, taken together, will make a real difference to small and medium enterprises. New measures in that plan include, first, a 25% increase in the threshold for VAT cash receipts basis accounting, to improve cashflow for small and medium enterprises, which is so important and so often raised with us. The threshold will be increased from €1 million to €1.25 million. Second, a doubling of the amount of expenditure on research and development by small and medium enterprises eligible for tax credit, to support more innovation by businesses. The threshold has been increased from €100,000 to €200,000. I see evidence of this all over the country when I visit these small and medium enterprises. This issue means real progress for many such SMEs. Third, extending the employment investment and incentive scheme, which was due to run out in 2013, to 2020. This supports investment in businesses by providing tax relief of up to 41% on investments up to €10 million in companies. This extension gives clarity and definition to the horizon for planning and investment by these companies. Fourth, measures to reduce the burden of tax compliance for start-ups and small businesses, including an extension of the three-year corporation tax relief scheme and moves to look at ways of reducing costs of compliance for micro businesses. As Ministers are aware after engaging with so many businesses around the country, this is an issue that has been raised on many occasions. Fifth, an extension of the foreign earnings deduction scheme, to support companies putting personnel abroad - or “boots on the ground”, as they say - in eight more countries, which will help our agricultural sector in particular to export more. I am always enthused by the energy and ambition of so many young people to work abroad in promoting Ireland and selling the country's brand products. This extension of the foreign earnings deduction scheme to eight new countries offers opportunities for further trade, exports and therefore more jobs all over the country here in Ireland.
As we know, credit is the lifeblood of business and this is recognised in the budget.
The Government has provided for the delivery of a range of new and improved supports for companies in need of credit and is using resources to leverage funding from the private sector to provide credit for all business sectors. Among the new initiatives in this regard is a €700 million seed and venture capital scheme in which €175 million in Exchequer funding is expected to leverage a further €525 million in private sector funding. I strongly support this and expect that more than 100 innovative Irish companies will benefit with the potential for the creation of thousands of jobs and hundreds of millions of euro in additional exports expected as a consequence. An additional Exchequer allocation of €25 million under the development capital scheme will now provide a total of €225 million in funding to mid-sized indigenous firms to target the development of a really strong indigenous sector comprised of strong indigenous companies. The National Pensions Reserve Fund is also developing a range of support funds for the small and medium enterprise sector, initially ranging in size from €100 million to €400 million, to provide equity, credit and recovery investment.
Another area in which I perceive great potential for Irish business and especially the tourism sector is the extension and reform of the Irish film relief scheme. The decision to extend the film tax relief scheme to 2020 will put Ireland on the map and make us even more attractive for foreign film and television productions. This is an area the Government intends to pursue strongly in the new year and I note the hospitality sector also will gain from the retention of the lower level of VAT. I want Irish agencies to promote Ireland proactively in major production centres around the world. We have the talent and support services, as well as a land and cityscape, that should be attracting new business and productions.
The budget is fair because at its heart is a plan to create new opportunities for jobs and income growth for struggling low and middle-income families. There is no doubt that this is a difficult budget and it will have an impact on families across Ireland. However, it is as fair and equitable as possible. The Government has ensured that those who can afford to contribute most will do so. Primarily, it is supporting hard-working families struggling to make ends meet by not increasing income taxes. Moreover, it is providing an additional 6,000 after-school child care places to help hard-pressed working families balance working and family life. It is ensuring that everyone makes a contribution to the national effort by widening the tax base and introducing a property tax, including a higher rate for those who have houses worth more than €1 million.
While it is true that the Government wants to encourage those on average incomes to save for pensions, it can no longer allow pensions of the scale previously accepted to be accumulated at the expense of taxpayers. In this regard, tax relief on pension contributions will only serve to subsidise pension schemes that deliver incomes of up to €60,000 per annum. Tax relief on pension contributions will continue at the marginal rate of tax and the pension levy announced as part of the jobs initiative will not be renewed after 2014. In addition, while it will only contribute a modest amount to the total fiscal adjustment, the Government has introduced new reforms to political pay, expenses and allowances. It was an overdue step to introduce vouched expenses for politicians. It has also ended the practice of severance payments for officeholders and has introduced proper auditing of the leader's allowance following a cut of 10%. In the new year, I expect to appoint a referendum commission on a permanent basis. Next autumn will see the people decide on the future of Seanad Éireann by referendum and consideration will also being given to recommendations put forward by the Constitutional Convention.
This budget is a building block in the transition to a new enterprise-focused economy. It will ensure we reduce our deficit towards a more sustainable level. It has introduced a number of targeted measures to support business, job creation and growth across all sectors. The Government will do everything it can in 2013 to make sure its policies support job creation and growth. The measures announced in this budget are only the first steps in this effort. Work is well advanced on our action plan for jobs report for 2013, which will be published early in the new year. The Government will continue to work with our European partners to address banking debt issues, which are of such importance to us and I note Ireland's Presidency of the Council of the European Union commences formally in January.
A Cheann Comhairle, I wish to acknowledge the severe and damaging impact on Ireland as a result of the economic crisis of recent years. The scale of the cumulative budgetary adjustments to date, though necessary, has been painful and challenging and is very difficult. Every day, I speak to people who share their experiences of hardship, whether through losing a job or as a result of the impact of changes to valued public services. The Government is committed to making sure it does everything in its power to restore this country’s economic prosperity in everyone's interests. Just as I expect our country to emerge from the troika programme next year, so too do I intend to put an end to austerity budgets and while this will not be easy, it is achievable. One must not forget or neglect the many strengths of this country. We have faced a very serious and destabilising economic crash, unprecedented in its scale and have done what has been necessary.
I see a bright future ahead for our people. We have already seen many positive signs including renewed private sector job creation, sustained and significant foreign investment, strong exports and restored access to international funding markets. I acknowledge these developments may not yet translate into visible improvements at the local and community level. We are on a difficult journey but we are travelling with a sense of purpose, a clear objective and a clear goal. My vision of Ireland is one where those who are unemployed can find jobs, where rising incomes reward hard work, where the most vulnerable in our society are supported by reformed and reinvigorated public services and where we can grow old with a sense of dignity. This is a fair, equitable, and pro-jobs budget. The Government has set the country on the path to recovery and will get Ireland working again. I commend the budget to the House.
Comment on this
This is a difficult and hard budget that will hit many people’s pockets. However, it also is a necessary, honest and fair budget. This budget is not an end in itself but is a step that, as a country, we must take on the road to recovery. This is the budget that takes us 85% of the way and it is a bridge to the future. For weeks, all one has heard from the Opposition is fairytale economics. As for Fianna Fáil, there is no such thing as BC or AD as history begins in March 2011. As for Sinn Féin, what it does in government in Northern Ireland has absolutely no bearing on what its Members say down here and for the Technical Group, arithmetic is an imperialist plot.
We would all love to go back in time and to start again from a different and more favourable place. We would all like to undo and roll back the damage that was done to the people by the greed of the few. While it would be wonderful if a small group of other people could pay for everything, the Irish people know that is not possible. What we can and must do is repair the damage, pursue the guilty and then wipe our feet on the mat and move on. This budget is a bridge to the future, because it is necessary to get us from where we are to where we need to be. The mission of the Government is simple, namely, to fix the economy in order that it works for the people and delivers for the needs of the many, not the greed of a few. Moreover, the Government's means of doing that is not by shouting at the problem but by taking the difficult yet necessary decisions that must be taken.
There are many in this House whose favourite word is "austerity" and the word is bandied around at every possibility. However, the Government is not engaged in a policy of austerity. It is engaged in a policy of solvency. Our country is in an EU-IMF programme because the last Government reached a point where no-one would lend money to Ireland. After 14 years of misgovernment and after the fatal mistake of the bank guarantee that Sinn Féin supported, the point was reached at which no-one would lend Ireland money at any price.
That is the key point as a country that cannot fund itself cannot function, and the economy of that country cannot function either. Once the creditworthiness of the State is undermined, there are profound implications for the rest of the economy, for firms large and small and for families young and old.
The first step on the route to recovery is to restore financial stability and rebuild the creditworthiness of the economy. This budget is part of that process. Such was the extent of the property bubble that this year, even after all the consolidation we have done, the Government will take in €12.6 billion less than it will spend. We will borrow €42 million per day to finance the State. That is simply not sustainable or just, as we are passing on debt to the next generation. This budget takes us another step closer to bridging that gap and bringing our deficit down to a sustainable level.
The Government has been clear that fiscal consolidation on its own will not solve our problems. We have a three-dimensional crisis and we need a three-dimensional solution involving restructuring the banks, dealing with the budget deficit and doing everything possible to promote employment. Our employment strategy is itself built on a number of pillars, each of which involves major programmes of change and reform. During the summer, we launched a major stimulus package, progress on which was reported in the statement by the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, Deputy Howlin, yesterday. Pathways to Work is nothing less than a transformation of the way in which we think about and deliver social welfare services. Yesterday, my colleague, the Minister for Social Protection, Deputy Joan Burton, was able to announce a further 10,000 activation places to assist people on the live register. The Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation, Deputy Bruton, is driving the implementation of a suite of supply side and competitiveness measures and working with other colleagues to develop a plus-one initiative to tackle long-term unemployment. The Minister for Finance, Deputy Noonan, yesterday announced a suite of measures to assist small business and the agrifood sector, including funding for enterprise from the strategic investment fund, to add to measures taken last year.
The domestic economy, which is still a major challenge, is beginning to stabilise. The budget measures announced last year assisted the normalisation of the property market that is taking place, and further measures on commercial and residential property are contained in this year’s budget. Allowing early withdrawal of additional voluntary contributions, AVCs, which has the potential to stimulate domestic activity, will be provided for in the new finance Act. The Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources, Deputy Rabbitte, is bringing forward a major programme to promote construction activity in the retrofit area.
The biggest drain on the domestic economy is the uncertainty and fear that surrounds the problem of household debt. Before the end of the year, the Personal Insolvency Bill, a massive undertaking, will pass all Stages in the House, and the personal insolvency service will go live on 1 February. As families begin to sort out their debt issues and as others see there is light at the end of the tunnel, we will begin to see an impact on consumer confidence and investment.
In my own portfolio, the Minister for Finance, Deputy Noonan, announced the extension of the foreign earnings deduction for companies that are sending key personnel to develop new trade opportunities in developing countries and emerging markets. We are expanding support for exporters so that the foreign earnings deduction will now include Africa, a continent home to seven of the world’s ten fastest growing economies. In particular, we are targeting Algeria, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Egypt, Ghana, Kenya, Nigeria, Senegal, and Tanzania.
Nobody in this Government is under any illusion about the scale of the challenge we face. The problem of unemployment and the tragedy of forced emigration are a significant loss of human and economic potential to our country. We all know that the export sector is performing well but the domestic economy is still a major issue. Nonetheless, where there are signs of progress, we should acknowledge them.
The notional cost of borrowing as expressed in the bond yield has fallen to new low levels. The National Treasury Management Agency is making a phased return to the market and yield on long-dated paper is today approximately 4.5%. Several major Irish banks and companies have been able to borrow money on international markets, our bank deleveraging programme is on target, and we are progressively reducing our reliance on European Central Bank funding. In the last quarterly national household survey, there were modest signs of recovery in private sector employment. Export performance remains strong. The economy is growing again and our balance of payments surplus for this year is expected to reach 3.4% of GDP in a sign that our economy can reduce debt and grow at the same time.
To sustain that progress, there is no alternative to getting our public finances under control. A deficit of 8.2% of GDP, while falling, is still extraordinarily high and we must reduce it; there is no good or painless way to do that. The measures contained in this budget will affect many people but we can say the budget is fair. We have protected weekly rates of social welfare because we believe that as a people we must look to the needs of those on the lowest incomes. To achieve this end, both Ministers, Deputies Howlin and Noonan, have found resources to reduce the quantum of measures needed in social protection from €540 million to €390 million. Although difficult measures are being taken, we have also found resources to take a number of positive steps, including 6,000 additional after-school child care places for low income parents and an additional €2 million for school meals.
We have also made an important commitment to an area-based child poverty strategy, which will build on a number of highly successful pilot projects that were jointly resourced by the State and Atlantic Philanthropies. I pay tribute to Atlantic Philanthropies for the vision it has shown and the results that have been achieved in developing these schemes. I am hopeful that our partnership will continue, and I congratulate Deputy John Lyons in particular on the work he has done in promoting this cause.
Despite the immensely difficult financial circumstances, we have managed to find resources to continue providing new social housing units and to maintain the effort in urban regeneration. This fairness agenda was only possible because we found additional resources from a tax package which is manifestly fair and which asks most of those who have most. The tax measures in this budget are reforming and progressive. The budget measures contain a wealth tax package that amounts to over €500 million in full-year terms. Several of these measures will take time to introduce precisely because they are fundamental changes to the structure of the tax system.
The wealth tax package includes the reduction in the standard fund threshold so that the State will no longer subsidise pensions of more than €60,000 per annum. There is a progressive structure in the property tax so that houses valued at more than €1 million will pay a higher rate of 0.25%. Changes to PRSI will mean that unearned incomes will also be liable to social insurance contributions and there will be a higher rate of universal social charge on pensions over €60,000 and a €200,000 cap on top-slicing relief. There will be increases in the rates of capital taxes, which bring all rates to 33%, and a 10% reduction in the thresholds for capital acquisitions tax. These rates now mean there is a far greater parity between taxes on capital and taxes on labour, ending a distortion introduced by Fianna Fáil. The vast bulk of these taxes will be borne by those who are better able to bear them. This is a real wealth tax package, in contrast to the make-believe fairy tale figures that every Sinn Féin Deputy is ordered to parrot.
The reform of pensions policy comes after years of debate and analysis that highlighted the inequity of what was once some €3 billion in tax reliefs. By capping relief rather than standard rating, we are maintaining an incentive for people on middle incomes to contribute to their pensions while removing the biggest tax shelter in the Irish tax code. The scale of this reform is such that it will bring some €250 million into the Exchequer and affect some 30,000 higher earners.
The introduction of a property tax will impact significantly on households across the country. I do not expect people to be happy about paying a property tax but it must be recognised that this is a major reform that will provide a stream of revenue to local authorities without taxing work and will enhance the quality of local democracy.
Those who oppose the property tax will have to explain to their electorates how they intend to provide services on the very same streets they are canvassing. When combined with the changes to local government announced by the Minister for the Environment, Community and Local Government, Deputy Phil Hogan, we are driving the most fundamental modernisation and reform of local government since 1898.
This budget is not only about deficit reduction but also about reform. It is not only about building a financial bridge to a more stable future but also about shaping that same future. While this financial crisis imposes real constraints on what the Government can do, it is also the case that we are not wasting the crisis. This budget has prioritised education by reducing to a minimum the expenditure reduction measures in the Department of Education and Skills. There is an increase in capital spending to provide schools to serve demographic needs. We are driving ahead with fundamental reforms of what happens in the classroom, including junior certificate reform, the national literacy and numeracy strategy and a sensitive reappraisal of the position on patronage.
In social protection, we are developing a system that is far better suited to the needs of a modern open economy, in line with principles similar to the "flexicurity" approach driven by social democrats in Scandinavia. While social protection needs to provide income support for those who lose jobs or suffer illness, we are moving to a system whereby one's first day on the live register is also one's first day on the route back to education, training and a job.
In health, we are driving ahead with our primary care strategy and have published a roadmap setting out the steps towards universal health insurance. Despite all the financial problems and the planning issue thrown up by the mistakes of the previous Government, we will begin construction of a national children’s hospital.
Notwithstanding the many financial constraints we face, the Minister for Justice and Equality, Deputy Alan Shatter, has been one of the most reforming justice Ministers of the modern era and has made real strides on penal reform with limited resources. In addition, the Minister for Children and Youth Affairs, Deputy Frances Fitzgerald, is working to end the practice of committing 17 year olds to St. Patrick’s Institution.
After a series of hard budgets, we now have an income tax code which is among the most progressive in the developed world. This budget makes the system even fairer. The challenge we face, however, is to ensure that when people pay their taxes, the State makes the best possible use of their money. The work the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, Deputy Brendan Howlin, is doing in driving reform in the public service is driven by that principle. I am committed to ensuring we have the best quality, service driven public services. To achieve this objective we need to make the best possible use of public funds. Such is our commitment to better schools, hospitals and local services that we are determined to take back control of our financial destiny.
We are also bringing transparency and reform to the system of political funding. I note that no single measure caused as much outrage among members of the Technical Group yesterday as the suggestion that they be required to audit their leader’s allowance in the same way as political parties.
Comment on this
The hypocrisy we have heard from that quarter now comes with a price attached.
Comment on this
For the people of Ireland, what this budget does is bring the end into sight. No one can understate the sacrifices and no one should overstate what has been achieved. However, we can see progress and it is being made with a purpose. Even in these most difficult times, we have the resources to drive important reforms and we have protected those who most need to be protected.
This is the centenary year of the Labour Party. The men and women whom I have the honour to lead in this House know full well the cost this budget will bring to the families and communities they represent. However, they also know this budget is not about today or tomorrow but is a bridge to the future. Delivering it is part of our commitment to bringing our country back from the abyss to a stronger better future. While none of this is easy, it is necessary. In the future, people will look back and ask the following three questions of the Members and parties who were in this House at this time. Did they take responsibility for solving the problem or seek to exploit it? Did they act with fairness? Did they think of the future? In respect of all three questions, the Labour Party and this Government will be able to answer "Yes", which is something of which I, for one, am proud.
Comment on this
Irish people have shown time and again that they are willing to accept hard choices. They understand there is no easy way out of an unprecedented crisis which has engulfed Ireland and much of Europe and the world in recent years. However, their support is based on measures meeting two core principles. They want budgets which are both fair and make a clear contribution to returning growth and job creation. This budget fails on both measures.
Last year, having won a mandate from the people promising a radical and progressive Government, Fine Gael and the Labour Party chose to abandon their promises and introduced by far the most regressive and unfair budget in many years, as shown in independent assessments. This year they have done it again. In some cases, Ministers appear to have sat down to find new ways of making sure the most vulnerable suffered more. To take only one example, how else can one explain first cutting home help and then cutting respite care?
In the ever growing mountain of documents and press releases which have accompanied this year’s budget one thing is already clear. This is a deeply unfair budget presented by a Government that has no strategy for growth and job creation other than hoping something will turn up. Driven purely by the short-term political tactics of competing parties, it systematically betrays election promises and places the heaviest burden on those who are least able to bear it. Its budget will further damage the confidence that is essential for recovery.
Yet again, the Labour Party and Fine Gael used true, half true and completely false leaks during negotiations. Their growing band of Malcolm Tucker wannabees were constantly on the telephone to journalists briefing for and against different Ministers and talking up the resolve of their parties. Now we know that for all the tough talk from the Labour Party, ongoing muttering from its Backbench Deputies and soothing words of its Ministers, the party has once again been shafted. On the other hand, the Fine Gael Party used every tactic it could muster in an ultimately successful move to protect the highest earners from taking more of the load. It was a direct trade-off. Every one of the regressive welfare cuts could have been avoided with an increase in the universal social charge for the highest earners, a proposal which enjoys widespread political and public support. Fine Gael should have the honesty to explain the reason it demanded that supports for the poorest families be cut rather than hitting those who earn the most.
For all of its smug sense of having prevailed over its coalition partner, the Fine Gael Party must also explain the reason it did not lift a finger to try to stop a family home tax, which the Taoiseach once described as "unjust, immoral and illegal."
Comment on this
No, we did not. The memorandum of understanding refers to a completely different type of tax from the one the Government has introduced.
Comment on this
The only Government strategy evident this week is a public relations strategy.
Comment on this
The Government has been putting its trust in the idea that people will not compare the claims it is making-----
Comment on this
I did not interrupt the Taoiseach and I would appreciate an opportunity to make my contribution to the House.
Comment on this
I am merely reminding the Deputy of the truth that his party supports a property tax.
Comment on this
The Government has been putting its trust in the idea that people will not compare the claims it is making with the substance of what it has decided to do. Most Ministers have been making claims which are the direct opposite of the truth and have been using unprecedented gimmicks to try to cover up the hard reality of their choices. In the next few weeks, they will have to explain exactly what is involved in many of the general adjustments in their allocations. At that point, there is no doubt we will find many more unfair, damaging and avoidable cuts. However, from what is already known there is more than enough to see the mean spirit and lack of direction which lie at the heart of this budget.
The overall fiscal framework for next year is widely accepted and we believe it to be correct. It did not originate from the troika but is a required next step in bringing the deficit to a sustainable level. As the budget documentation points out, the major part of the fiscal adjustment was done in previous years, with next year and the year thereafter being easier than previous years in relative terms.
We are all somewhat amused by the Tánaiste's use of the phrase that we are 85% there, given the fact that, year after year, the Taoiseach, the Tánaiste and their parties voted against 80% of that journey and every single measure involved.
Comment on this
They always claimed that there was a better and easier way.
Comment on this
Labour and Fine Gael made reckless commitments and promises before the election that they could not fulfil.
While the targets are correct, there is reason to believe that they might not be met and that public support for them has been undermined by the crass and growing inequity of the decisions being taken by the Government. A new concern is that these targets may not be met because of a combination of overspending and reduced revenue. In spite of Government claims about having an iron hand on spending, including the repeated claims by the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, Deputy Howlin, that everyone would stay within budget, the two largest Departments are showing major overruns this year. The inclusion of large amounts of unspecified savings in these Departments for next year suggests that exactly the same situation will obtain.
On the revenue side, last week's figures showed a serious undershooting of key taxes, particularly the €300 million deficit in income tax receipts. For 2012, the combination of overspending and lower receipts has been covered up by a number of one-off measures and the benefit of the Greek interest rate deal being automatically passed on to all countries. These will not be available next year and there is no reason to believe that this year's problems have been effectively tackled.
One of the most striking elements of the budget is how little it has to say about the economy. Beyond empty generalities, there is no analysis of the direction of growth or employment or discussion of the budget's impact on any economic indicator. There is no attempt to set out anything that updates plans made two years ago. In a major departure from tradition, most economic projections were relegated to appendices that the Ministers did not mention. It is in these that one finds the detail of a Government that has already missed every one of its targets for broad economic indicators.
This year, targeted growth of 2.5% will actually be less than 1%. The target of 3% growth for next year has been halved. These are not cold, irrelevant statistics. They have a real impact on people’s lives, particularly in terms of employment. It is for this reason that they were not mentioned in the Ministers' speeches.
Last year, the Government claimed that it was all about jobs. It had a jobs budget, which it downgraded to an initiative, and the Budget Statement was almost entirely given over to claims of jobs being on the way. The Minister for Finance, Deputy Noonan, predicted a growth in employment of 0.5% for this year. The reality is minus 1.2%. He predicted a fall in unemployment to 13.7%, but it will be nearly 15%. Yesterday, all that he had to say about the failure to hit any major economic target was that everything is Europe's fault. While the Taoiseach was speaking with the Minister of State, Deputy White, I outlined all of the budgetary targets for this year that have been missed by the Government. To blame Europe for everything is untrue. The Government's policies have had a direct impact on reducing growth and employment. Front-loading a major VAT increase, removing investment funds from the economy through a significant levy on pension funds and threatening employers with extra costs for every employee were among the measures that helped to drive down domestic demand and confidence, the two elements that our economy needs most if it is to recover.
In this debate last year, the Government was told that implementing these policies would damage the economy, but it went ahead with the measures anyway. Let no one be in any doubt - the policies of this Government have directly damaged domestic confidence and thereby reduced growth and employment this year. They will do so again next year unless there is significant external growth that drags us up with it.
What is also striking is that the Government is silent on the vital issue of debt sustainability. We are apparently seeking a deal to make our debt sustainable, but no member of the Government has yet said what he or she believes we need our debt to be for it to be sustainable.
Domestic demand and confidence are the most important elements that we require to build a strong recovery, but the situation in Europe is also important. To date, the Government's approach to Europe has been to hope that others can win concessions that will be automatically extended to us. Every development has been overspun and underdelivered. Getting a substantial deal to reschedule the promissory notes would provide significant extra resources. Ireland's case is strong. As the Taoiseach finally admitted in October, "Ireland was the first and only country which had a European position imposed upon it in the sense that there was not the opportunity, if the Government so wished, to do it their way by burning bondholders."
In spite of the claims made since June, nothing was agreed in respect of Ireland's debts and the news this week from Brussels marks a significant setback. The German Minister explicitly stated that he did not intend to support Ireland and Portugal getting major concessions and that the banking union, which was supposed to be operating from January and which is essential for our banks, has been delayed to some unspecified time. Given how important Europe is, after nearly two years in office it is time for the Government to set out a policy on Europe that goes beyond hoping that something turns up that can be claimed as a great victory.
The number of promises broken by both parties in this budget is even larger than anyone imagined. The defence being trotted out is the usual one, in that they are being forced to break their promises because circumstances changed. In reality, the only element that has changed is that Fine Gael and Labour are in government and their reckless campaigns to win votes has left them needing to justify the systematic abandonment of pre-election promises. The budgetary constraints faced by this Government were fully known to Fine Gael and Labour before they made their promises. In fact, last year the situation was ahead of what was targeted. No one forced them to make these promises and no one is forcing them to break them.
The overpowering cynicism of their campaigns is summed up by Labour's "Every Little Hurts" advertisement. In the closing days of the campaign and as the Taoiseach well remembers, Labour decided that it needed to attack Fine Gael. Labour drew up a list of cuts and extra charges it said would be implemented if Fine Gael got in without Labour there to stop it.
Comment on this
The report card shows that every one of those cuts and charges has been delivered.
Comment on this
Labour even went so far as to say that there were red lines-----
Comment on this
-----it would never cross. Everyone should replay the current Tánaiste's interview with RTE about child benefit.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste was absolute about it.
Comment on this
Does the Taoiseach want to discuss Roscommon hospital?
Comment on this
Deputy Mattie McGrath allowed the previous Government.
Comment on this
Let us also remember the response of the current Minister for Finance, Deputy Noonan, at the time.
Comment on this
At a press conference, the Minister had journalists rolling in the aisles as he found new and creative ways to dismiss Labour's warnings as empty scaremongering. How right he was about Labour's capacity to stop any of this from coming about.
Comment on this
Less than two years later, we know that every little does hurt. Labour has implemented everything it claimed it would never do.
Due to the mounting wave of negative commentary about the Government's regressive policies and lack of any real innovation in almost two years, it yesterday unveiled a new tactic. This involved changing the baselines wherever doing so might give a better result. As the Government believes that it can claim success in some areas, it refers to what has happened since March 2011. In most areas, however, it has started using earlier dates to present a better picture.
Yesterday, there was messing with the presentation of figures in a range of areas from fiscal adjustments to the reduction in public service numbers. However, the brass neck award must go to the attempt to claim that budget policy has been progressive. The Minister, Deputy Noonan, referred to how we had one of the most progressive tax systems in the developed world and stated that the role of recent budgets in this was contained in an annexe to his speech.
Comment on this
It has been acknowledged independently.
Comment on this
We are not saying it. It is what is being said around the world.
Comment on this
When one takes the time to read the annexe, one discovers that our tax system is progressive only because of two budgets against which every member of the current Cabinet voted.
Comment on this
Including the Minister, Deputy Hogan.
Comment on this
The Government is right about the system being progressive, but its members voted against every measure in the two key budgets that made it so.
Comment on this
If one includes just the budgetary decisions of Fine Gael and Labour, one finds a deeply regressive impact.
The backing away from a real reform of the political and budgetary process has been obvious to anyone paying attention. Last year’s budget fortnight has been abandoned and a traditional budget day restored. In the Oireachtas, discussion was allowed in advance of the Estimates, but there is nothing in what has been published which even slightly reflects Oireachtas input. Within Government, the increasingly ineffective Economic Management Council has destroyed collective responsibility with Ministers actively distancing themselves from unpopular decisions on the basis that they were not properly consulted. Sitting around doing nothing for hours and ordering in pizza might be okay for teenagers with a few days off, but it is not what you expect from a Cabinet.
Comment on this
What the final budget decisions reveal is a Government that holds many meetings with outside groups but rarely ever listens to what is being said. How else could one explain all the meetings with children’s organisations which were followed by the targeting in this budget of families with children?
Yesterday’s announcement that 100 Garda stations will be closed will rightly lead to demonstrations throughout the country. When closing stations the Government repeatedly said they were only marginal stations, which were more trouble than benefit. In seeking to close 100 stations this excuse is irrelevant. It is a programme to change policing in Ireland radically by making it more distant from the community and exposing large sections of the country to significantly reduced coverage. If one believes the Garda make a difference to keeping us safe - I have no doubt that is the case - then one must accept that this radical and dangerous proposal must be stopped before it goes any further.
Each one of the welfare cuts imposed in the budget could have been avoided if the proposal to target the highest income earners had been adopted. Instead, Fine Gael insisted that social welfare must feel the pain and the Minister for Social Protection, Deputy Burton, went about designing a set of cuts which is deeply mean spirited. Families with children have been singled out for major cuts in their income. Last year the Government told us that Scandinavian child care was on the way. This year the Fine Gael and Labour vision of Scandinavian child care is being implemented, with cuts to child benefit, taxing of maternity benefit, cuts to clothing and footwear allowances and a handful of extra child care places. When she was in opposition the Minister, Deputy Burton, liked nothing more than to find ways of attacking welfare packages no matter how generous they were. She was particularly happy to have coined the term "savage 16" and said of the Minister concerned, “her actions make Margaret Thatcher look like a socialist.” Today, the conscience of the Labour Party in government-----
Comment on this
-----is justifying cuts which are dramatically more severe and targeted against the most vulnerable. When challenged about cutting basic support for clothing and footwear, her callous response is to tell people “there is a lot of good value in shops”.
Comment on this
The mounting evidence that the Department of Health is out of control is clear to everyone in the country but the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
Even other Cabinet Ministers are saying that the Minister for Health, Deputy Reilly, is turning tough conditions into a crisis. In this budget we see more about the truth of a regressive and cynical health policy. The move by the Government to restrict the over-70s medical card is especially shameless given its past campaigning on this issue.
Comment on this
What about the situation of Fianna Fáil?
Comment on this
The Minister, Deputy Reilly, tabled a motion demanding an extension to medical card eligibility and said it was merited because-----
Comment on this
Does Deputy Martin remember poor Máire Hoctor?
Comment on this
This is what the Minister said-----
Comment on this
-----“Those are the people who made this country what it is today....They raised us, nursed us when we were sick, protected us from violence, grew our food”. That is what the Minister said not so long ago in this House about medical cards for over-70s. The Taoiseach joined in that debate with great gusto.
Comment on this
I have all the Taoiseach's speeches in a large file, demonstrating his hypocrisy and lack of sincerity.
Comment on this
There is great value in the Taoiseach's speeches.
Comment on this
The shredder broke down because it could not cope with all the reports generated by Deputy Martin when he was Minister. They cost €130 million.
Comment on this
There was not room to file them all away.
Comment on this
The Minister, Deputy Reilly-----
Comment on this
The Minister's speech might well rate in history alongside the visit by the Minister for Education and Skills, Deputy Quinn, to the front gate of Trinity College for breathtaking cynicism.
Comment on this
That was the breaking of a promise made before the election, the trebling of prescription charges does that and adds to it the breaking of a post-election announcement.
Comment on this
I have not heard a constructive suggestion from Deputy Martin since he began to speak.
Comment on this
One should remember that the Minister, Deputy Reilly, was only days in office when he summoned journalists to hear that he intended not just cutting, but abolishing prescription charges.
Comment on this
The Government cannot even keep the promises it made after the election, let alone before.
Comment on this
The prescription charge is €1.50. Many pensioners are on medication and use six to nine items a month. The Government might not have cut the old age pension but through this measure alone it is taking approximately €20 off them - €19.50 - as a result of the prescription charge. The Government fulfils its election rhetoric by saying that core rates will not be changed but it gets people in other ways. It is a completely cynical approach.
Comment on this
The Government is taxing the hearse.
Comment on this
The cut in the respite care grant is callous when added on top of the cut to home help. How could the Government distribute thousands of leaflets claiming to have delivered a fair budget when it has done that? I heard people on the radio this morning-----
Comment on this
Deputy Martin distributed 1,000 leaflets about the property tax during the children's referendum campaign even though his party in government designed the scheme.
Comment on this
----interrupting the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, Deputy Howlin-----
Comment on this
-----with a passion and conviction that left the Minister speechless.
Comment on this
The Government will have to reverse the cut.
Comment on this
I ask the Taoiseach to reverse the cut.
Comment on this
Mistakes were made in the previous budget as well. There were appalling attacks on DEIS schools. The most disadvantaged schools were affected in last year's budget.
Comment on this
St. Augustine. We want it, but not yet.
Comment on this
The Minister of State, Deputy Costello, is a Labour Deputy.
Comment on this
We fought a campaign against that and the Government eventually reversed the cuts to DEIS schools. The Minister for Education and Skills, Deputy Quinn, came to the House and apologised for what he did.
Comment on this
I thought Deputy Martin said it was the Labour backbenchers.
Comment on this
I put it to the Taoiseach that he must examine the matter again. The saving identified is approximately €26 million.
Comment on this
Can you not go over behind him if-----
Comment on this
If I might continue, €26 million is involved. People watching are not interested in that kind of tomfoolery, they are interested in whether anything can be done about the respite grant.
Comment on this
It can be done and it should be done.
Comment on this
I plead with the Taoiseach on the matter today. This is what the debate is about; for people to listen to what we are saying and to take on board some of it, at least a bit of it. Of all the things that have been done, I urge the Government to restore the respite grant because it is paid to people who care on a 24-7 basis for relatives, people with severe disabilities and for people with special needs. We must do that if we respect the caring ethos, which is fundamental to how we look after the elderly in this country, and those with special needs. In many instances the State is not doing all it would like for carers and people who need care. Given what people across the floor are saying, the Government has time to do so in the context of the social welfare Bill. We will table amendments to secure the reversal of the decision and the restoration of the grant. We brought the grant up to the current level because it can be helpful to people, even those who are not in receipt of carer's allowance. Most of the people contacting offices this morning say the payment is used for basic things such as heating, transport and to keep the household going. It is important that the Taoiseach would examine the issue again.
In the third-largest Department, Education and Skills, cuts are once again being targeted at disadvantaged families and communities. The increases in third level fees will continue and now an effort is being made to ensure that more and more families have to pay the fees. Combining an increase in fees with a reduction in eligibility for grants means that the reversal of advances in equal access will be accelerated. I do not understand why such a sneaky, underhand move was made on the means threshold for third level grants because education will be central to coming out of this crisis. We want young people to continue on to third level and fourth level. Due to the mess caused by SUSI for the first time in a long time I have met students on the street who said they were contemplating leaving college.
Comment on this
Deputy Martin should not be so silly. When he was Minister for Education and Science we got a number of complaints about grants and he never did anything about them. Grants were not available until after Christmas.
Comment on this
I was in Castlebar three weeks ago and a young student doing biomedical engineering in UCG said he was contemplating leaving because the grant had not come through and he had no information about it. I do not like saying that.
Comment on this
SUSI is a new mechanism to improve the awarding of grants.
Comment on this
Students have no confidence in the Minister of State, Deputy Costello.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil had 15 years to get it right.
Comment on this
The system only came in this year. How could we put it right when it has only just been introduced?
Comment on this
This year was the first time a centralised system was introduced. The Deputy should look at the beam in his own eye.