Order of Business
- Order of Business 2 speeches
The House agrees the proposed Friday, 19 April sitting arrangements and scheduled business.
Pat Rabbitte, Seán Barrett
- Personal insolvency income guidelines 2 speeches
Michael McGrath asks whether proposed minimum-income guidelines for indebted borrowers will require legislation or bind banks; Pat Rabbitte says no legislation is contemplated.
Michael McGrath, Pat Rabbitte
- Croke Park II and FEMPI legislation 5 speeches
Mary Lou McDonald questions whether the Government will legislate for public-sector pay and conditions under Croke Park II. Rabbitte declines to intervene in union ballots and confirms there will be no new FEMPI legislation.
Mary Lou McDonald, Pat Rabbitte, Emmet Stagg
- Ministerial allowances and monuments Bill 10 speeches
Bernard Durkan seeks publication dates and procedural details for legislation on ministerial and parliamentary allowances and a monuments Bill, amid political heckling. Rabbitte says the first Bill’s heads are being drafted for publication this year and the Government is considering the monuments proposal.
Bernard Durkan, Michael McGrath, Willie O'Dea, Seán Barrett, Pat Rabbitte
- Construction contracts and banker pay 18 speeches
Mattie McGrath presses for the Construction Contracts Bill to protect subcontractors and raises related concerns about banking legislation and executive pay. Rabbitte expects the Construction Contracts Bill to conclude within weeks, says no legislation is planned on the other issue, and notes the existing cap on banker pay.
Mattie McGrath, Seán Barrett, Arthur Spring, Pat Rabbitte, Timmy Dooley
- Bail Bill publication 2 speeches
John O’Mahony asks when the bail Bill will be published; Rabbitte says its heads have not reached Government and publication is unlikely this year.
John O'Mahony, Pat Rabbitte
- Mental capacity legislation 3 speeches
Joan Collins asks about legislation reforming the Lunacy Act 1871; Rabbitte says the mental capacity Bill is expected early in the next session, with its heads still unconfirmed.
Joan Collins, Pat Rabbitte
- Sunbed use by minors 6 speeches
Peter Fitzpatrick seeks legislation prohibiting minors from using sunbeds; Rabbitte says the public health sunbed Bill will be introduced later this year.
Peter Fitzpatrick, Pat Rabbitte, Timmy Dooley
- Garda compensation legislation 6 speeches
Timmy Dooley highlights low Garda morale, a protest and the intimidation of a Clare garda, seeking expedited compensation legislation. Rabbitte deplores the incident and says the Bill’s heads were cleared in July, with publication later this year.
Timmy Dooley, Seán Barrett, Pat Rabbitte
- Property tax appeals workload 3 speeches
Michael Healy-Rae asks whether more appeals commissioners will be appointed to handle property-tax appeals; Rabbitte says no legislation is promised and reports no evidence that the existing commissioners cannot cope.
Michael Healy-Rae, Pat Rabbitte
- Inquiry into illegal adoptions 2 speeches
Aengus Ó Snodaigh asks whether the Government will investigate historic illegal adoptions; Rabbitte says no legislation is promised and will request a direct response from the relevant Minister.
Aengus Ó Snodaigh, Pat Rabbitte
- Property repossession legislation 2 speeches
Willie O’Dea asks about the land and conveyancing amendment Bill removing barriers to bank repossessions; Rabbitte confirms it will proceed and was approved by Government the previous week.
Willie O'Dea, Pat Rabbitte
- Domestic waste collection waivers 5 speeches
Brian Stanley seeks the promised waiver for domestic waste charges, particularly for low-income households in Laois. Rabbitte says no legislation exists and attributes the difficulty to privatised waste collection, while Stanley reiterates the programme-for-government commitment.
Brian Stanley, Seán Barrett, Pat Rabbitte
- Bogus charities and sub-prime mortgages 2 speeches
Ray Butler requests legislation on bogus clothing charities and sub-prime mortgage companies; Rabbitte treats both as serious issues and expects legislation by year-end.
Ray Butler, Pat Rabbitte
- Legal services and upward-only rents 2 speeches
Pádraig Mac Lochlainn asks about progress on legal-services regulation and possible constitutional action on upward-only rents. Rabbitte says amendments are still being prepared for the Legal Services Bill and does not expect an additional autumn referendum.
Pádraig Mac Lochlainn, Pat Rabbitte
It is proposed to take No. 3, Health (Alteration of Criteria for Eligibility) Bill 2013 - Second Stage (resumed).
It is proposed, notwithstanding anything in Standing Orders, that for the purposes of Standing Order 117A the first Friday of the month for April shall be Friday, 19 April, and the time and date by which notice of a Bill in connection with that sitting shall be received by the Clerk shall be 11 a.m. on Thursday, 28 March 2013; and related Standing Orders shall apply accordingly. Private Members’ business, which shall be No. 98, motion re disability supports (resumed), shall be taken on the conclusion of the Order of Business and shall, if not previously concluded, be brought to a conclusion after 90 minutes.
Comment on this
There is one proposal to be put to the House. Is the proposal for dealing with the sitting and business of the Dáil on Friday, 19 April, agreed to? Agreed.
Comment on this
There are reports that the Minister for Justice and Equality, Deputy Shatter, and the new head of the insolvency service will next week publish minimum income guidelines to be used in assessing people's indebtedness in an effort to formulate solutions for such people. They will apparently deal with issues such as whether people may keep a second car, go on holiday or have a Sky Sports package. Will those guidelines require legislation in the House? Will they be mandatory or will it be possible for banks to reject them?
Comment on this
I understand that what is in contemplation is that the head of the personal insolvency agency is likely to publish some guidelines for the engagement between borrower and lender in respect of the legislation to which Deputy McGrath referred. My understanding is that no legislation is contemplated.
Comment on this
I wish to ask about the new Croke Park deal and the Government's proposed legislation arising from that. We all know the deal unfairly and deliberately targets front-line workers and, yesterday, representatives of An Garda Síochána picketed outside the Oireachtas. I hope the Minister knows that public sector workers, like everybody else, have mortgages to pay and children to feed and clothe, and many of these people are struggling. Does the Government intend to introduce financial emergency measures in the public interest, FEMPI, legislation to cut public sector pay? Does it intend to legislate to slash the terms and conditions of public sector workers and civil servants? Will this legislation be introduced regardless of the ballot on the Croke Park II deal?
Comment on this
Proposals emerged under the umbrella of Croke Park II between the employer side and the trade unions and those proposals are being put to ballot or are being dealt with in accordance with the rules and procedures of each union. It would not be helpful for any member of the Government or Member of the House to intrude in the process until we get a result. The unions present at the negotiations understand perfectly well what is the process and I do not want to be seen to seek to intrude into those affairs.
Comment on this
I asked specific questions on proposed legislation. Will there be new FEMPI legislation and will there be additional legislation dealing with the terms and conditions of public sector workers? I am not asking the Minister to comment on the ballot.
Comment on this
When is it proposed to introduce the Oireachtas (ministerial and parliamentary offices) Bill, which will implement changes to party leaders' allowances and minor amendments to other allowances? Has this promised legislation been discussed by the Cabinet, have the heads been approved and when is it likely to come before the House?
Similarly, another piece of legislation is to commemorate the exertions of the Opposition when the parties were in government. I am inquiring about the monuments Bill and a possible citation for the undying efforts and dedication of the Opposition when those parties were in government. It may be a suitable Bill.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not even funny. He should sit down.
Comment on this
There is a village looking for an idiot.
Comment on this
The heads of the first Bill are being drafted and the reforms will be published this year. The heads of the monuments Bill were approved by the previous Government and this Government is looking at the feasibility of nominating a particularly unfinished estate to include in the list of monuments.
Comment on this
Some Labour councillors can orchestrate that.
Comment on this
The Minister made much of the jobs plan but it is over two years since a big construction company, Pierse Construction, went into liquidation in Dublin, leaving 500 subcontractors affected. Many hundreds of people have been affected since. Where is the Construction Contracts Bill? Much good work was done by the last Government, Senator Feargal Quinn and many others, and people are depending on this for some shred of defence when big companies go into liquidation and leave subcontractors, staff and creditors penniless. Is there any possibility in considering the Central Bank consolidation Bill that it will include bankers' pay issues?
Comment on this
I call Mr. Richie Boucher "Richie Voucher" as he likes to spend money.
Comment on this
There must be some meaningful way of correcting this as all the talk in the world will not do it.
Comment on this
We cannot ignore it forever and a day.
Comment on this
These people are laughing all the way to the bank.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows all about the banks, including Anglo.
Comment on this
Of course. Is that an allegation?
Comment on this
I spoke to a conference of the Construction Industry Federation this morning on the issue.
Comment on this
That is the construction industry sorted.
Comment on this
The Bill has completed Second Stage and if amendments are required, they are likely to be approved by the Cabinet very shortly. I expect the Bill to be concluded within a few weeks. There is no legislation on the other issue raised by the Deputy. The arrangement for the particular chief executive referred to was entered into in 2009 and I understand he has a contract to that effect. Since this Government came into office there has been a cap on banker pay which has been enforced.
Comment on this
When will the bail Bill be published? On a daily basis we see people out on bail committing crime, so this is an important Bill.
Comment on this
The heads have not yet come to the Government and as the Deputy knows, the Minister for Justice and Equality has a large legislative schedule. I do not envisage the Bill being published this year.
Comment on this
In last night's debate it was mentioned that legislation to reform the Lunacy Act 1871 is to be introduced before the summer. This has been on the A list since last spring and we are still waiting for the legislation to come through. When will the heads of the Bill be approved and when will the legislation come before the Oireachtas?
Comment on this
The Deputy is referring to the mental capacity Bill. It will be early next session.
Comment on this
Have the heads of the Bill been approved?
Comment on this
I have parents coming into my constituency office in Dundalk who are very concerned about the use of sunbeds and the damage they can do. They want to know what measures will be taken to prohibit the use of sunbeds by minors. When can we expect the publication of the public health (sunbed) Bill?
Comment on this
I apologise, I am not an expert on sunbeds.
Comment on this
I have never personally insulted Deputy Dooley.
Comment on this
The Minister might be red around the gills but he could not be described as tan.
Comment on this
The legislation will be introduced when the sun is at its zenith, meaning later this year.
Comment on this
The Minister is aware that morale is low within the Garda Síochána. The GRA was protesting outside yesterday and the association recently passed a motion of no confidence in the Minister for Justice and Equality, an unprecedented occurrence.
Comment on this
Earlier this week a garda had her private car burned out outside a Garda station in County Clare as an act of intimidation.
Comment on this
As a result, I am asking that the Garda Síochána (Compensation for Miscellaneous Injuries) Bill be brought forward very shortly to deal with the attacks on gardaí that are taking place on a daily basis. What happened to that young garda was outrageous.
Comment on this
I deplore the incident referred to by the Deputy. The heads of the Bill were cleared in July and it will be published later this year.
Comment on this
We already have two overworked appeals commissioners. They are now being told they must deal with appeals related to the property tax. They cannot cope with the current level of work. Is legislation promised to beef up the functions of appeals commissioners and to appoint more commissioners to carry on the already heavy workload? It will be crazy if they are already overworked to expect them to deal with appeals related to the property tax, which will come flooding in.
Comment on this
No legislation is promised. Neither the Minister for Finance nor I have any evidence the appeals commissioners cannot cope with their backlog of work. I do not know if the Deputy envisages they will have additional work as a result of the application of property tax but until now the two gentlemen concerned have been able to dispose of their workload as required and in a reasonable timeframe.
Comment on this
What will happen from now on?
Comment on this
Yesterday I raised the issue of Thalidomide victims and the promise in programme for Government to act on that matter during the Topical Issue debate. Another issue similar to that has emerged in recent years as a result of the reports on the Magdalen laundries and other residential institutions - illegal adoptions. The Australian Government today apologised to those who were illegally adopted in the 1940s, 1950s and 1960s. Does the Government intend to establish an inquiry to look into that practice, which happened in this State as well as in Australia and Britain? Is legislation needed to address the falsification of adoption records in some State institutions, including hospitals?
Comment on this
There is no promised legislation in this area. I do not have any expertise in this area but I will ask the relevant Minister to reply to Deputy Ó Snodaigh directly.
Comment on this
No. 25 on the legislative programme, the land and conveyancing law reform (amendment) Bill, is designed to remove any barriers in the way of banks that wish to repossess property from people to whom they have lent money. Does the Government intend to proceed with this legislation? If so, when will we see it?
Comment on this
Yes, we intend to proceed with it. It was approved by Government last week.
Comment on this
I wish to ask about the commitment in the programme for Government on the waiver for domestic waste collection. I have raised this a number of times in the last two years and been given all sorts of fluffy answers. Three weeks ago the Taoiseach told me he would reply on the issue but in spite of the solemn commitment in the programme for Government, only some counties have a waiver. County Laois has not had a waiver in 25 years. We mentioned property taxes and water charges earlier and waste collection fees are placing further unbearable pressure on low income households. The Minister and I both know what is happening with illegal dumping all over the State. The countryside is covered in litter. We have clean towns and dirty roadways because illegal dumping is taking place. The Government must tell the House if it intends to introduce a waiver scheme for low income households.
Comment on this
I have been told there is promised legislation on it.
Comment on this
There is no legislation. The Deputy understands that when local authorities collected waste, there was a waiver system. Unfortunately a campaign grew up, led by Members of this House, that led to the privatisation of waste disposal and, as a result, the application of a waiver system is far more difficult.
Comment on this
What about the commitment in the programme for Government?
Comment on this
When will the criminal justice Bill be published to deal with bogus charities collecting clothes in light of the documentary that was recently broadcast on this topic? It is not illegal to set up a bogus charity and go from door to door collecting clothes. Gangs are making serious money doing this.
Will the Government publish legislation on sub-prime mortgage companies? This is a serious problem. We are looking after those dealing with regular institutions but we really need legislation to deal with sub-prime mortgage companies.
Comment on this
Both of these are serious issues and I expect legislation will be published by the end of the year.
Comment on this
When will the Legal Services (Regulation) Bill move to the next Stage in the House? This has been delayed for some time. It is a major issue for those who face enormous costs to secure justice or pursue a case.
The programme for Government also promised action on upward only rents. Will the Government consider a constitutional amendment later this year on the day of the referendum to deal with the issues preventing legislation from addressing the upward only rent system?
Comment on this
The Legal Services (Regulation) Bill is a complex Bill and amendments are still being prepared for Committee Stage. I do not know how soon the committee can take it but the amendments are still being drawn up so the fault does not rest with the committee. It is unlikely there would be any constitutional referendum this autumn other than as already announced.