Order of Business
- Order of Business 2 speeches
The Tánaiste proposes taking the resumed second-stage debate on the Companies Bill 2012; the Chair reports that no other proposals require a decision.
Eamon Gilmore, Seán Barrett
- Maternal life protection Bill 14 speeches
Micheál Martin asks whether a maternal life protection Bill is circulating and when its heads will be published. The Tánaiste says the heads have not yet been circulated but are expected before Government shortly, with legislation to follow.
Micheál Martin, Aodhán Ó Ríordáin, Pat Rabbitte, Mattie McGrath, Eamon Gilmore
- Waterford Crystal pension ruling 6 speeches
Deputies seek legislation protecting Waterford Crystal workers and other defined-benefit pensioners after the European Court ruling. The Tánaiste says the judgment must first be considered by the High Court because the case remains sub judice.
Pádraig Mac Lochlainn, Eamon Gilmore, Kevin Humphreys, Seán Barrett
- Minimum wage increase 6 speeches
Patrick Nulty asks whether the Government will raise the minimum wage to restore its 2007 value; the Chair directs him to submit a parliamentary question because no legislation is promised.
Deputy Patrick Nulty, Seán Barrett
- Bank intimidation practices 8 speeches
Mattie McGrath alleges that bank representatives intimidate homeowners and businesses and seeks stronger Central Bank controls; the Chair and Tánaiste say the relevant Bill is already published for debate.
Mattie McGrath, Seán Barrett, Eamon Gilmore, Michael Healy-Rae
- Consultant oversight of school contractors 4 speeches
Michael Healy-Rae questions the Department of Education’s use of a consultant for employment-rights oversight and links the issue to the Construction Contracts Bill.
Michael Healy-Rae, Seán Barrett
- Farmers’ fodder crisis 17 speeches
Michael Healy-Rae repeatedly protests the Government’s inadequate response to the farmers’ fodder crisis, while the Chair rules the matter outside the Order of Business and suggests a Topical Issue.
Michael Healy-Rae, Mattie McGrath, Seán Barrett, A Deputy, Pat Deering
- School contractor employment standards 1 speech
The Tánaiste says the Education Minister is enforcing employment and safety standards for contractors on school projects.
Eamon Gilmore
- Farmers’ fodder crisis 3 speeches
Deputies continue pressing for an answer on the fodder crisis before the Chair moves to the next speaker.
Mattie McGrath, Michael Healy-Rae, Seán Barrett
- Maternal Bill passage timetable 3 speeches
Joe Higgins asks whether the maternal life protection Bill will pass all stages before the summer recess; the Chair says that commitment cannot be sought on the Order of Business.
Ray Butler, Joe Higgins, Seán Barrett
- Property tax collection powers 5 speeches
Joe Higgins objects to possible deductions from wages and social-welfare payments for property-tax arrears and seeks an amendment. The Tánaiste says no legislation to amend the property tax is promised.
Joe Higgins, Seán Barrett, Eamon Gilmore, Micheál Martin
- Pyrite levy legislation 2 speeches
Dessie Ellis asks when legislation will fund remediation of pyrite-affected homes; the Tánaiste says the pyrite levy Bill is due for publication this year.
Dessie Ellis, Eamon Gilmore
- Social housing regulation Bills 2 speeches
Ray Butler asks when two housing miscellaneous-provisions Bills will strengthen social-housing regulation; the Tánaiste expects No. 1 this year and No. 2 next year.
Ray Butler, Eamon Gilmore
- Common arrangements for gas Bill 1 speech
James Bannon asks when legislation extending gas connections to north-midlands towns will be introduced.
James Bannon
- Planning Bill after Mahon 1 speech
The Tánaiste says there is no publication date for the planning Bill implementing recommendations of the Mahon Tribunal.
Eamon Gilmore
- Increase in Dublin councillors 4 speeches
Barry Cowen asks whether forthcoming local-government legislation will increase Dublin’s councillor numbers; the Tánaiste says the local-government reform Bill is expected this session.
Barry Cowen, Seán Barrett, Eamon Gilmore
- Water services charges Bill 5 speeches
Brian Stanley asks whether the promised water-services legislation will impose a flat household charge and when it will appear. The Tánaiste says it will be published this year but cautions against presuming its contents.
Brian Stanley, Seán Barrett, Eamon Gilmore
- Referendums later this year 2 speeches
Dara Calleary asks when information for planned referendums will be published; the Tánaiste confirms the proposed Seanad referendum but says the number of referendums is not yet decided.
Dara Calleary, Eamon Gilmore
- Free GP care legislation 2 speeches
Thomas P. Broughan asks when legislation for free GP care will arrive; the Chair promises information, and the Tánaiste notes that the relevant GP-services legislation has already been enacted.
Thomas P. Broughan, Seán Barrett
- Home help service cuts 7 speeches
Broughan condemns continuing reductions in home-help hours for vulnerable older people and urges action; the Chair rules the policy complaint outside the Order of Business.
Thomas P. Broughan, Seán Barrett, Eamon Gilmore
- Sale and pricing of alcohol Bill 2 speeches
Patrick O’Donovan asks when the alcohol sale-and-pricing Bill will be brought forward because of its impact on rural pubs; the Tánaiste says work continues but gives no publication date.
Patrick O'Donovan, Eamon Gilmore
From this morning’s Irish Independent, it seems the protection of maternal life Bill is circulating around the Government.
Comment on this
This would seem to vindicate The Sunday Times report by Sarah McInerney from last Sunday, which, when I put it to the Taoiseach earlier this week he said he had no idea in the world from where it came. It now seems this Bill has been circulating in the Department of Health. I note and accept that the Ministers of State, Deputies Kathleen Lynch and White, are furious that it was suggested they had been consulted on this Bill. Will the Minister confirm this is the Bill that is circulating?
Comment on this
Not even Deputy Martin is that naïve.
Comment on this
What is Deputy Rabbitte suggesting?
Comment on this
The Minister should get back from Dublin Castle to the real world.
Comment on this
I see the new pope has taken on the mantle of Francis of Assisi. Deputy Martin can no longer go around pretending he is Francis of Assisi.
Comment on this
Will the Tánaiste confirm that this is the Bill which the Taoiseach referred to last week on the Order of Business? He said to me last week that the heads of the Bill in question would be circulated this week. This suggested it was well into its preparation, if not prepared. Is there work under way to produce a new or different Bill? Will he update and clarify the position on this Bill? Can we expect the heads of the Bill next week?
Comment on this
I am delighted to see Deputy Martin has taken up reading. It might encourage him to improve the quality of what he reads.
Comment on this
He was a great one for not reading reports when he was a Minister.
Comment on this
Some of the Tánaiste’s Ministers of State need a bit of help as well. It seems the Minister for Health is sharing nothing with anyone.
Comment on this
What about the stuff the Tánaiste was reading about 20 years ago?
Comment on this
The heads of the Bill or the memorandum on it have not yet been circulated. I expect the Minister for Health, Deputy Reilly, to bring the heads of the Bill to the Government shortly. The Government intends to act after 20 years of no action on this difficult issue. Everyone knows this, as well as the fact, the preparation and content of the legislation requires care and attention. I expect the heads of the Bill will be before the Government shortly and the legislation published thereafter.
Comment on this
This morning the European Court of Justice found in favour of the case against the State taken by the former Waterford Crystal workers on the losses to their pensions. The court found that offering retirees half of what they are entitled to is not going to wash. In response to this, what legislation does the Government intend to introduce to give proper protection to workers when they are made redundant, and in the Waterford Crystal case, abandoned?
Comment on this
I am aware of this morning’s ruling by the European Court of Justice on the Waterford Crystal pension schemes. The case follows a reference from the High Court to the European Court of Justice for its opinion on several questions concerning European law in this area. We have not yet had an opportunity to study the full judgment of the European Court of Justice. The ruling will now be the subject of a full hearing by the High Court in the coming months. Until then, the matter remains sub judice and we cannot comment further on it.
Comment on this
I welcome the European Court of Justice decision on the Waterford Crystal pensioners. I raised this issue with Deputy O’Dea on the need for legislation on defined benefits. Since raising this matter, several people have informed me they are taking redundancy settlements to protect their pensions’ futures. At the time when I raised this matter, the Taoiseach said it was an extremely complicated area and it will be some time before legislation comes to the House. This is a matter of urgency and I know there is great pressure on drafting legislation.
Comment on this
Can we give this matter priority?
Comment on this
This case was at the European Court of Justice because the High Court referred it there for its opinion. The High Court must now hear the case. It is still under the High Court and is, therefore, sub judice. That said, we will of course be studying the judgment and seek advice on it.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste refers many times to having reversed the minimum wage cut introduced by Fianna Fáil. However, he will be aware that Ireland is one of only three EU countries, Estonia and Greece being the others, not to have increased its minimum wage to boost domestic demand.
Comment on this
Has the Government any intention to increase the minimum wage, even by 40 cent, to bring it into line with 2007 levels?
Comment on this
Increasing the minimum wage to match inflation requires legislation.
Comment on this
No, we are only dealing with promised legislation. I am told there is no promised legislation. I suggest the Deputy puts down a parliamentary question on the matter.
Comment on this
On the Central Bank (Supervision and Enforcement) Bill 2011, I will not mention names today but we know the bankers who are getting huge pay.
I raise this issue with the Tánaiste because of the actions of the banks. The Central Bank of Ireland does not have a code of practice by which it can restrain what can only be described as hit men who are going out and intimidating people, be they home owners or business owners, on a daily basis. There is no-----
Comment on this
It is the Central Bank (Supervision and Enforcement) Bill 2011. Hit men are going out and threatening people and beating them up.
Comment on this
That was a lengthy reply from the Tánaiste.
Comment on this
Why is the Department of Education and Skills hiring a consultant to do a job that we pay the quango, the National Employment Rights Authority, NERA, to carry out?
Comment on this
The Deputy should ask him after the Order of Business but not on the Order of Business.
Comment on this
I ask this question under the Construction Contracts Bill.
Comment on this
I want to raise another issue, namely, the woefully inadequate response from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine and the Government to the farmers' crisis in giving €1 million-----
Comment on this
It is an issue of major importance and the Government should wake up to the crisis that the farmers are facing.
Comment on this
Farmers are under terrible pressure. They are under financial-----
Comment on this
Deputy, please do not abuse the privilege. I call you on the understanding that you are inquiring about promised legislation so do not abuse the privilege.
Comment on this
I did exactly what you told me to do.
Comment on this
The Government is doing nothing to help the farmers of Ireland.
Comment on this
Deputy, the Order of Business is about promised legislation; it is not about issues.
Comment on this
What is Deputy Deering being smart about? Has he any interest in the farmers of Ireland?
Comment on this
I am sorry for ruffling the Deputy's feathers.
Comment on this
He should have some manners when he is talking about the farmers of Ireland.
Comment on this
The Construction Contracts Bill has already been published.
Regarding the Minister for Education and Skills, the Minister has taken action to ensure that contractors working on school projects comply with standards regarding employment conditions and safety at work. I could understand the Deputy raising this issue if no action was being taken but raising it when the Minister for Education and Skills is taking action on it is surprising.
Comment on this
What about the fodder crisis? He would not give an answer.
Comment on this
Deputy, eight other Members are offering and we have nine minutes remaining. I call Deputy Higgins.
Comment on this
The Deputies should give us all a chance to speak.
Comment on this
First, will the Tánaiste say definitively that the maternal life protection Bill will have passed all Stages by the summer recess?
Comment on this
The Tánaiste cannot give that answer on the Order of Business. The Deputy can ask that question some other way.
Comment on this
It is quite in order on the Order of Business.
Second, as the banks were announcing crippling increases in mortgage payments the Revenue Commissioners chairwoman, on the Tánaiste's behalf, was callously threatening to dip into the social welfare payments and wages of workers who object to his property tax, which is a tax too far. Will he amend the property tax to ensure that does not happen?
Comment on this
Are there any proposals on amending the property tax? Is there promised legislation in this area, yes or no?
Comment on this
First, I have a long reply on the fodder crisis but I was not asked about it on Leaders' Questions.
Comment on this
I appreciate that, Deputy Martin.
With regard to giving Deputy Higgins a commitment as to when legislation will be passed by the House, that is a matter for the House. The Government has made clear its intention with regard to bringing legislation before the Houses and there is no legislation promised on amending the property tax.
Comment on this
The Minister, Deputy Hogan, has set up an expert group to oversee the problems of homes affected by pyrite. In recent months we had the report on pyrite resolution. We were told that process would be moved forward quickly and the Minister indicated at the time that legislation would be required to levy the industries concerned to raise the necessary funds. Will the Tánaiste indicate when that legislation will be forthcoming? Thousands of people are living in sub-standard housing. Serious health and safety issues arise regarding those and we must move quickly on this issue.
Comment on this
When will the housing (miscellaneous provisions) (No. 1) Bill and the housing (miscellaneous provisions)(No. 2) Bill to further strengthen the regulatory framework of social housing be brought forward? We saw the documentary shown the other night. Many counties, including County Meath, do not have ghost estates and housing waiting lists are very long. We have 7,000 to 8,000 people on housing waiting lists from as far back as 2007. I would like to see houses being bought or built.
Comment on this
The housing (miscellaneous provisions) (No. 1) Bill is expected to be published this year. The housing (miscellaneous provisions) (No. 2) Bill is expected next year.
Comment on this
Many towns in the north midlands are at a serious disadvantage because of the high cost of energy. When can we expect the common arrangements for gas Bill to come before the House to extend gas spurs from the main gas line to those towns? Also, the planning Bill to implement the recommendations of the Mahon tribunal report is long overdue.
Comment on this
There is no date yet for the publication of the common arrangements for gas Bill, which is to amend the Electricity Regulation Act 1999 and allow arrangements be put in place to facilitate an all-island gas market. It is not possible to indicate at this stage when the planning Bill, which is to provide for the implementation of the planning recommendations of the report of the Mahon tribunal and other matters, will be published.
Comment on this
When will the Government bring forward legislation to give effect to its intention to increase the number of councillors in Dublin by upwards of 60 or more?
Comment on this
The Government is carrying out the most fundamental reform of local government since the late 19th century. That reform of local government is long overdue. The legislation to give effect to that is expected to be published this session.
Comment on this
Does that include the huge increase in Dublin?
Comment on this
I ask the Tánaiste about the water services Bill promised for this year. I understand there is a provision in that Bill to give the Energy Regulator the power to set the charges for water. The Government has agreed that water charges will bring in €500 million by 2015 in its programme with the troika. We have 1.3 million households and that works out at a flat charge of €385 per household.
Comment on this
As meters will not be installed, will the legislation reflect the fact that this will be a flat charge on households of on average €385? When will we see the legislation?
Comment on this
The question as to when we will see the legislation is the only one in order. The Deputy can deal with the other part of the question some other way.
Comment on this
The legislation will be published this year. In the meantime, the Deputy should not presume what will be in it.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach has stated that he informed the Chief Justice that referendums will be held later this year and has asked for a judge to be assigned to the Referendum Commission. When will the relevant information to allow us prepare for those referendums be published?
Comment on this
It has been indicated that the Government intends to hold a referendum on the Seanad later this year. No decision has been taken yet as to the number of referendums to be held on that occasion. I expect that issue will be addressed and decided in the near future.
Comment on this
With regard to the proposal on free GP care in the programme for Government, when can we expect legislation? Second, is it intended to introduce any additional funding for home help services? Given that we have all seen horrendous instances of home help hours being slashed for vulnerable older people - the Tánaiste will remember that when he was on this side of the House he would have been jumping up and down about home care services and would have been getting very agitated-----
Comment on this
-----and excited about the fact that the then Fianna Fáil-Green Party Government was imposing savage cuts on home help services. It is the Tánaiste's watch now and this is going on. People are suffering.
Comment on this
I just want the Tánaiste to know this. I can give him chapter and verse.
Comment on this
This is not the type of policy that any Labour Party member would pursue.
Comment on this
I want to allow one other Deputy to contribute, so I ask the Tánaiste to respond in regard to the Bill.
Comment on this
There are a number of health Bills. The consultative process on the health (amendment) (No. 2) Bill is under way and it is expected the Bill will be published this year. Further heads have been approved for the health (amendment) Bill and it is expected to be published this session. The Health (Provision of General Practitioner Services) Bill has already been enacted. A number of other pieces of legislation are expected either late this year or early next year.
Comment on this
I asked previously about the sale and pricing of alcohol Bill and the Tánaiste said progress on it was not as advanced as had been expected. Given that this Bill has implications for a huge number of rural pubs, when can we expect to see the heads finalised and the Bill come before the House?