Bank guarantee and mortgage distress
Deputy Mary Lou McDonald condemns the “vampire tapes,” criticises the Government for protecting senior banking figures, and argues that struggling households face an unfair system while arrears continue to rise. Minister Joan Burton defends the Government’s debt-resolution measures and blames Sinn Féin and others who supported the bank guarantee for transferring banking losses to the public. The discussion largely becomes a heated dispute over responsibility for the financial crisis.
Whether vampires exist in reality, the characters we heard on the now infamous tapes are not fictional. All of us can appreciate the disgust, although not the shock, people felt at hearing the macho diatribes between these individuals. The disgust felt by the tens of thousands of families across the State who are in mortgage distress is all the deeper. To listen to Mr. David Drumm describe how he planned to go to the Central Bank with his arms swinging to demand "the moolah" for his bankrupt bank is revealing. We know there will be no option for struggling families to refuse to pay the moolah or to pluck the figures from their posteriors.
It is all the more shocking to be confronted with the details of a new code of conduct for mortgage arrears on the same morning that we hear these revelations. The Minister has indicated this is part of a supportive process, but I challenge her on that claim. It abolishes the previous limit of three contacts per month from banks to customers in arrears. In other words, it allows opportunities for the harassment of families already under pressure. It introduces a three month notice period before a bank can move to seek a repossession order, or eight months in the case of new arrears cases. Whatever about kicking the can down the road, this appears to be a case of acting with indecent haste. The code of conduct is best understood as part of a wider, co-ordinated attack on struggling homeowners. The Government has already passed legislation to make it easier to repossess family homes and tax the family home. At the behest of the troika, it has now introduced the new code of conduct which ignores much of the advice given by organisations that work with struggling homeowners.
I ask the Minister to explain to those families with whom she has sympathised this morning the difference in treatment between the macho men of the banking world and the struggling householder.
Comment on this
The Deputy's party voted for the guarantee.
Comment on this
Deputy Emmet Stagg's party voted to extend it twice.
Comment on this
I find Deputy Mary Lou McDonald's comments interesting. I recall discussing at length with her predecessor as finance spokesperson in this House the reasons the Labour Party was voting against the bank guarantee and advising him to consider doing the same. I do not know why he did not or would not do so. All I can say about the impact of banking issues on the lives of families who are worried about holding onto their houses is that Deputy Mary Lou McDonald needs to think a little about the structures the Government has put in place. I agree with her that the country should never have been brought to this point, but I remind her that her party, among others, voted for the guarantee.
Comment on this
The Minister's party has voted to extend it twice.
Comment on this
It has resiled from that position ever since. The record of the House shows what happened.
Comment on this
The Minister thinks she is still in opposition.
Comment on this
We have to deal with the catastrophe visited on the country and its people. Those who voted for the bank guarantee, including Sinn Féin, handed us the responsibility, as citizens and as a country, to deal with the awful and irresponsible actions about which we hear on the tapes. Deputy Mary Lou McDonald referred to those involved as the men after the moolah. If there is responsibility to be taken, it must be taken by everybody who voted for the guarantee.
Comment on this
Is the Minister blaming Fine Gael now also?
Comment on this
The representatives of Sinn Féin are among those who have to take responsibility because they were leading lights in agreeing to the guarantee.
Comment on this
Fine Gael supported the guarantee also.
Comment on this
The Minister is taking cynicism to a whole new depth.
Comment on this
Can I comment on what we have set out in relation to families?
Comment on this
The Minister is the queen of cynicism.
Comment on this
Sinn Féin did not know what it was doing. It was supporting Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
The Minister is the queen of spin.
Comment on this
Do the Deputies have any idea how they sound on radio and television? I ask them to, please, allow the Minister to respond without their smart remarks.
Comment on this
I would not mind if they were smart.
Comment on this
We have set up a process. Anyone who has ever been involved in debt resolution - I am speaking as an accountant - will appreciate that it is necessary to get the borrower and the lender to come together to reach an agreement that allows the borrower to recover and get back on his or her feet and also allows the lender to recover proportionate amounts of money that are recoverable. If one examines the detail of the Central Bank code of conduct, one will find that it refers to contact that "is proportionate and not excessive". Anyone who has ever been owed money, even at a domestic level, will know that people who owe money get so stressed that they turn away and fail to engage. We are providing for an engagement process that will allow families to reach a sustainable solution. If Sinn Féin is holding out the prospect of anything else, or suggesting there should not be an actual resolution between the borrower and the lender, it is making a false promise that cannot be delivered on, even if it does not intend to do so. We must help families to sort out their difficulties, slowly but surely. The structures are now in place to facilitate this. The Department of Social Protection provides support for 12,000 families, in terms of their mortgage interest payments, on a monthly basis. It also provides a telephone advice line that is run through the Citizens Information Board and funds the Money Advice and Budgeting Service. The Government and the Dáil recently established the Insolvency Service of Ireland. We now have the structures in place to allow families to come to sustainable solutions. That is what I want for families. I hope it is what Sinn Féin wants also.
Comment on this
The Minister is an accountant and that was an accountant's answer, if I ever heard one. We all know that there has to be a resolution process for families in debt.
Comment on this
That has never been contested. The Government is proposing a process that will give the banks a veto.
Comment on this
The Government is not providing for a level playing pitch for the struggling household and the macho men, many of whom are still in place in the financial system.
Comment on this
It is neither even-handed nor fair to pit the moolah boys against the struggling householder.
Comment on this
Did the Deputy's party appreciate that when it voted for the bank guarantee?
Comment on this
I ask the Minister to revisit her accountant's mindset and perhaps factor this in. She and her colleagues are always telling us how right they were on the banks.
Comment on this
If that is the case, why did they leave the Anglo Irish Bank boys who treated the State with such contempt in place for five years after the guarantee on salaries of €175,000 and more?
Comment on this
Where is Anglo Irish Bank now?
Comment on this
They are presiding over circumstances in which none of these moolah men has been brought to account.
Comment on this
Not one of them has faced time in jail.
Comment on this
The Deputy should ask the man sitting beside her about that.
Comment on this
The Government certainly does not have a charter for harassing them. There is one law for the rich and another for the poor.
Comment on this
Where is Anglo Irish Bank now?
Comment on this
The Deputy should go to Clontarf Garda station and make a complaint.
Comment on this
The Minister is polishing her halo with regard to the banks.
Comment on this
That only makes what the Government is doing at this time all the worse. It has protected these people.
Comment on this
The Government has allowed them to stay in highly paid positions. At the same time, its response to the plight of struggling homeowners has been heartless.
Comment on this
According to figures released last week, the number of people in arrears has increased for the 14th quarter in a row since September 2009.
Comment on this
She is nearly at the end of the script.
Comment on this
This has happened on the Government's watch.
Comment on this
Excuse me, a Cheann Comhairle-----
Comment on this
-----you gave the Minister considerable latitude.
Comment on this
I would like to be afforded the same courtesy.
Comment on this
Where did it all go so horribly wrong?
Comment on this
It went wrong on the night of the bank guarantee.
Comment on this
Since when does the Labour Party back the big bankers and punish families?
Comment on this
Is that now the way of the Labour Party and its accountant Minister?
Comment on this
I doubt that any accountant in Ireland knows as much about banks and banking as certain elements of Sinn Féin.
Comment on this
There the Minister goes again. She is just the same as the Taoiseach. They always resort to the low blow.
Comment on this
The knowledge any of the rest of us has pales by comparison with Sinn Féin's relationship with the banks and their moolah.
Comment on this
It is unbecoming to let something that is so important to families degenerate-----
Comment on this
It is unworthy of Deputy Mary Lou McDonald.
Comment on this
The Minister has no consideration for families whatsoever.
Comment on this
It is not her normal standard to make such comments.
Comment on this
Of course, the Minister's comments are entirely worthy.
Comment on this
The Minister is on the side of the bankers.
Comment on this
Deputy Mary Lou McDonald asked where it had all gone wrong. Unfortunately for the country, it went wrong on the night of the bank guarantee-----
Comment on this
The Government has extended it on a number of occasions.
Comment on this
-----when Sinn Féin and others decided to transfer the debt to the backs of the people.
Comment on this
The Government has extended it.
Comment on this
That is why it is so tragic and sad to listen to the tapes.
Comment on this
Where are the tapes of the promises the Labour Party made before the election?
Comment on this
In the three years after the bank guarantee, the country lost 250,000 jobs. The connection between this and Deputy Mary Lou McDonald's question is that many of the families in question are now struggling to meet their mortgage payments. What have we done as a Government?
Comment on this
The Government has penalised the people in question.
Comment on this
We have set up a procedure to find a resolution between the borrower and the lender.
Comment on this
It voted to extend the guarantee repeatedly. The Government extended the guarantee again and again, even when it knew the full facts.
Comment on this
All we get from the Minister is spin and cynicism. The Sunday Independent devotes its front page to it every weekend.