Order of Business
- Order of Business 2 speeches
The Tánaiste proposes the day’s legislative business, sitting times and handling of Topical Issues; the House agrees to all three proposals.
Eamon Gilmore, Michael P. Kitt
- Strategic investment fund legislation 2 speeches
Michael McGrath seeks an early National Treasury Management Agency amendment Bill to establish the €6 billion strategic investment fund; the Tánaiste expects publication later this year.
Michael McGrath, Eamon Gilmore
- Marriage equality and Magdalen redress 6 speeches
After a light exchange about the Brighter Evenings Bill, Mary Lou McDonald asks about the Government’s response to the marriage-equality report and a Dáil debate on the Quirke report and Magdalen redress. The Tánaiste promises compliance with the four-month response deadline and says the debate can be discussed by the Whips.
Mary Lou McDonald, Mattie McGrath, Eamon Gilmore
- Legal Services Regulation Bill 2 speeches
Pádraig Mac Lochlainn criticises delays and limited Committee Stage time for the Legal Services Regulation Bill; the Tánaiste says Government amendments are under consideration.
Pádraig Mac Lochlainn, Eamon Gilmore
- Criminal justice miscellaneous Bill 2 speeches
Bernard Durkan requests legislation to strengthen the law on fraud with criminal intent; the Tánaiste says the Bill’s heads are approved and publication is expected later this year.
Bernard Durkan, Eamon Gilmore
- Former Garda station sales 3 speeches
Michael Healy-Rae objects to the proposed sale of 40 former Garda stations, citing commitments to make them available to community groups; the Chair directs him to use a parliamentary question or Topical Issue request.
Michael P. Kitt, Michael Healy-Rae
- GP evidence for welfare schemes 2 speeches
Healy-Rae asks the Government to reverse a policy requiring consultants’ letters instead of GP evidence for social-protection schemes; the Tánaiste says no legislation is promised on the matter.
Michael Healy-Rae, Eamon Gilmore
- Water services legislation 2 speeches
Brian Stanley asks how water-service assets and public-private partnerships will transfer to Uisce Éireann; the Tánaiste says legislation is being drafted following approval of its heads.
Brian Stanley, Eamon Gilmore
- Victims’ rights legislation 2 speeches
James Bannon seeks an update on the long-promised criminal justice victims’ rights Bill; the Tánaiste says preliminary work is under way but gives no publication date.
James Bannon, Eamon Gilmore
- Central Bank enforcement and banking accountability 24 speeches
Pearse Doherty argues that the Central Bank enforcement Bill is undermined by the Government’s failure to question public-interest directors about recorded regulatory breaches. The exchange becomes heated, with the Tánaiste attacking Sinn Féin’s record during the banking crisis and Doherty alleging protection of political and banking interests.
Pearse Doherty, Michael P. Kitt, Eamon Gilmore, Mary Lou McDonald, Mattie McGrath
- Bank property auctions and consumer protection 31 speeches
Mattie McGrath describes distress at an auction of properties, alleging banks and purchasers are worsening hardship for homeowners and businesses, and asks for stronger banking and consumer protections. The Tánaiste says the Central Bank enforcement Bill will provide an opportunity to address such issues and defends the Government’s banking reforms.
Michael P. Kitt, Mattie McGrath, Emmet Stagg, Pearse Doherty, Eamon Gilmore
- Banking reform dispute 1 speech
Bernard Durkan briefly challenges Mattie McGrath during the dispute over the Government’s banking record.
Bernard Durkan
- Universal health care legislation 4 speeches
Dessie Ellis asks when legislation for universal health care and free GP access will be produced; the Tánaiste says health legislation is advancing and confirms delivery before the Government’s term ends.
Dessie Ellis, Eamon Gilmore
- Mediation Bill 6 speeches
Eamonn Maloney asks when the mediation Bill will be published, joking that it may require a guillotine. The Tánaiste says its heads have been approved and publication is expected later this year.
Eamonn Maloney, Eamon Gilmore, Dessie Ellis, Barry Cowen
- Dublin local authority members 4 speeches
Barry Cowen asks about legislation creating 50 to 60 additional Dublin local-authority members; the Tánaiste says the Bill is expected later this year.
Barry Cowen, Eamon Gilmore
- Explosives legislation 2 speeches
Brendan Griffin asks that the explosives Bill be prioritised following discoveries of explosive devices and components; the Tánaiste expects it later this year.
Brendan Griffin, Eamon Gilmore
- Sunbed regulation 2 speeches
Brian Walsh seeks legislation regulating sunbeds because of their skin-cancer risks; the Tánaiste says the Bill’s heads are approved and publication is expected later this year.
Brian Walsh, Eamon Gilmore
- Betting legislation and thalidomide survivors 2 speeches
Seán Ó Fearghaíl asks about the betting Bill and the promised meeting with thalidomide survivors; the Tánaiste says the betting legislation is under consideration and will seek a direct response from the Health Minister.
Seán Ó Fearghaíl, Eamon Gilmore
- Sale of written-off bank debt 2 speeches
Ray Butler seeks protection for people whose written-off bank debts are sold to debt-purchasing companies; the Tánaiste says no legislation is promised but accepts that the issue requires attention.
Ray Butler, Eamon Gilmore
- Assisted decision-making legislation 2 speeches
David Stanton asks whether the assisted decision-making capacity Bill will be published before the summer break; the Tánaiste expects publication during the current session.
David Stanton, Eamon Gilmore
It is proposed to take No. a1, Central Bank (Supervision and Enforcement) Bill 2011 - amendments from the Seanad; and No. 1, Health (Amendment) Bill 2013 [Seanad] - Second Stage, to adjourn at 5 p.m. today if not previously concluded.
It is proposed, notwithstanding anything in Standing Orders, that the Dáil shall sit later than 5.45 p.m. tonight and shall adjourn on the conclusion of Oral Questions; Topical Issues will be taken on the adjournment of No. 1, and the order shall resume thereafter with Oral Questions; the Dáil shall sit tomorrow at 10.30 a.m. and shall adjourn not later than 4 p.m., and any divisions demanded shall be taken immediately after the Order of Business on Tuesday, 9 July 2013; there shall be no Order of Business within the meaning of Standing Order 26 and, accordingly, the business to be transacted shall be as follows: No. 1, Health (Amendment) Bill 2013 [Seanad] - Second Stage (resumed), and the proceedings thereon shall, if not previously concluded, be brought to a conclusion at 1 p.m.; in regard to the Brighter Evenings Bill 2012, the following arrangements shall apply: the opening speech of Deputy Thomas Broughan and of the main spokespersons for Fianna Fáil, Sinn Féin, the Technical Group and of a Minister or Minister of State, who shall be called upon in that order, and who may share their time, shall not exceed 15 minutes in each case, the speech of each other Member called upon shall not exceed 15 minutes and such Members may share their time, a Minister or Minister of State, who may speak twice, shall be called upon not later than 3.30 p.m. to make a speech which shall not exceed 15 minutes, and Deputy Thomas Broughan shall be called upon to make a speech in reply which shall not exceed 15 minutes.
Comment on this
There are three proposals to be put to the House today. Is the proposal that the Dáil shall sit later than 5.45 p.m. tonight agreed to? Agreed. Is the proposal for dealing with Topical Issues agreed to? Agreed. Is the proposal for dealing with the sitting and business of the Dáil tomorrow agreed to? Agreed.
Comment on this
I wish to raise a couple of Bills. The Government has announced again that the strategic investment fund will be established on a statutory basis, with the Bill in question the National Treasury Management Agency (amendment) Bill. It comes almost two years from the original announcement in September 2011 but it is a very important Bill that will help to channel upwards of €6 billion to viable commercial projects, which we welcome. Will the Tánaiste give a commitment that we will have that Bill early in the autumn session, as I do not see why it has taken this long? Will he at least commit to the element that will allow commercial investment to start flowing? We should deal with that as quickly as possible.
I am sure the Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation, Deputy Bruton, is tired of being asked about the consumer and competition Bill, which has been delayed significantly. Will the Tánaiste give as specific a date as possible on when the Bill will be taken in this House?
Comment on this
The heads of the National Treasury Management Agency (amendment) Bill have been approved. It is a very important piece of legislation, as the Deputy noted, and there is a commitment in the programme for Government to establish the strategic investment fund. That amounts to a €6 billion fund to get some growth and movement in the economy. The Bill will be published later this year. The consumer and competition Bill is to be published this session.
Comment on this
I commend Deputy Broughan on bringing forward such a lovely sounding Bill in the form of the Brighter Evenings Bill. It is almost poetic.
Comment on this
It certainly made me smile.
I want to ask the Tánaiste about two things. The report on marriage equality from the Convention on the Constitution has been laid before the Oireachtas this week. Will the four month deadline for a response from Government be adhered to and when does the Tánaiste envisage a referendum being put to the people on that matter?
I asked last week about a debate in the Dáil on the Quirke report and the redress scheme for survivors of the Magdalen laundries. I appreciate that Mr. Justice Quirke has brought his report forward but I think it merits time for discussion in this House, not least because the UN Committee against Torture has written to the Government raising some serious concerns about the treatment of the Magdalen issue from start to finish.
I understand the Government is to give a response in respect of Bethany Home in Rathgar. Could the Tánaiste indicate a precise date on which the Government will make clear its position?
Comment on this
I am greatly relieved. I thought she was against everything. In respect of the reports from the Convention on the Constitution, it is planned to have a debate in the House on the first report in the last week of our sitting. The Government intends to comply with the four month deadline we have set ourselves to respond to each report so I expect in respect of the second report, which deals with the issue of marriage equality, that we will give a response within four months.
The question of a debate on the Quirke report can be discussed by the Whips. The issue of Bethany Home is still under consideration by the Minister and Minister of State.
Comment on this
It is now 18 months since Second Stage of the Legal Services Regulation Bill. I am sure the Tánaiste will agree that this is a hugely important Bill in terms of the administration of law in this State and its impact on many people, particularly in respect of cost. We were supposed to take Committee Stage next Wednesday. The Opposition worked extremely hard this week to get our amendments in for the deadline of 11 a.m. today but we now learn that the Government is pushing that back by a week. We will have one and a half hours to discuss this Bill on Committee Stage and then we are into the summer recess and the autumn. Does the Tánaiste agree that this is absolutely outrageous at this stage? We have been waiting 18 months for this Bill to get to Committee Stage and it is now put back by another three months and one and a half hours is offered for debate. What was all the work we put into amendments this week for?
Comment on this
I know there are some amendments to this Bill which are being proposed by the Minister for Justice and Equality and being considered by the Government. The timing and arranging of the meetings of the committee are matters for the committee itself. I am sure it will be able to arrange its timing itself but there are amendments under consideration by the Government in respect of that Bill.
Comment on this
Is it possible to bring forward the criminal justice (miscellaneous provisions) Bill, which was promised, in an effort to tighten the law relating to fraud with criminal intent and to ensure that persons suspected of such activity are brought before the courts at the earliest opportunity with a view to ensuring that the law is adequately provided for in that respect?
Comment on this
The heads of the criminal justice (miscellaneous provisions) Bill have been approved by the Government and it is expected to be published later this year.
Comment on this
I will. The Government is selling off 40 former Garda stations because it cannot identify alternative State uses for the buildings. This is a disgrace. I am raising this issue in respect of the criminal justice (miscellaneous provisions) Bill. I ask the Tánaiste not to sell off these buildings because we were promised in this Chamber that they would be made available to local community groups.
Comment on this
The Deputy should table a parliamentary question or Topical Issue request on the matter.
Comment on this
We were given that commitment in the House and I want the Tánaiste to tell me why the Government is doing a U-turn on that commitment.
The second item relates to the Health (Amendment) Bill. The Department of Social Protection has ensured that in the majority of cases, GP evidence is no longer acceptable and consultants' letters are required when applying for the many schemes it administers, putting another financial burden on already struggling householders. Will the Government reverse this policy?
Comment on this
There is no legislation promised in respect of either of those matters. There is nothing to prevent local organisations or local authorities from acquiring the Garda stations that are no longer in use and that are available for alternative use.
Comment on this
I wish to ask the Tánaiste about promised water services legislation. We have a significant number of assets which must be transferred from local authorities to Uisce Éireann. They include water treatment plants, networks and sewage treatment plants. Will these require votes in each council chamber under section 183 of the existing local authority legislation or will the Bill the Government is bringing forward supersede all of this? There are hundreds of public private partnerships, PPPs, which are mainly design, build and operate, DBO, projects. Will Uisce Éireann take over all of them with their associated liabilities and debts? When will we see the Bill and what are its main provisions because we are in the dark? We have tried to get this information out of the Minister for the Environment, Community and Local Government but we are in the dark on this issue. Even the Brighter Evenings Bill might shed some light on it. I hope the Tánaiste can shine some light on it this morning. What will happen to the DBOs and the transfer of assets from local authorities to Uisce Éireann?
Comment on this
I understand that the Minister and his Department have reached agreement with the trade unions representing staff in the local authorities on the transfer of water services under the new arrangements. We are proceeding with the drafting of that Bill to give effect to that. The preparation of the heads of the Bill was recently approved by the Government so work is under way on that legislation.
Comment on this
Shortly after the Government entered office, it introduced the Criminal Law (Defence and the Dwelling) Act 2011, which gave people rights to protect their property and homes. The criminal justice (victims rights) Bill has been outstanding for quite a long time. It is important we make communities safer by focusing on victims' rights and making life tougher for criminals by properly resourcing our gardaí. This is an important Bill that has been promised for quite some time. Could the Tánaiste give us an update as to when it will come before the House?
Comment on this
Preliminary work is under way on the criminal justice (victims rights) Bill, which aims to strengthen the rights of victims of crime and their families and to give effect to a proposed EU directive. It is not possible at this stage to indicate when it will be published.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste referenced very important legislation coming before the House today. This is the Central Bank (Supervision and Enforcement) Bill 2011. I commend the Minister for Finance on his openness to accepting amendments. Given the discussion we had, what does it really mean? We can give all the powers we want to the regulator but the Government is unwilling to ask a public interest director in a State-owned bank who did not inform the Central Bank, which is the regulator, that tapes exist with recordings of individuals which are now deemed serious by the Central Bank and are being looked at for regulatory breaches.
Comment on this
What is the point of this Bill if we have a Government that is unwilling to lift the phone to a former Minister for Finance?
He was paid by the State to be a public interest director for the past four years.
Comment on this
Does it not send out a negative signal about the Bill, which is an important and good Bill?
Comment on this
We should try to tighten up enforcement and regulation in the banks.
Comment on this
I will tell Deputy Doherty what it means; it means Sinn Féin got it wrong twice. It got it wrong first when it fell hook, line and sinker for what the guys on the tapes were asking for, which was a bailout for Anglo Irish Bank. Sinn Féin agreed with it, voted for it and praised it.
Comment on this
The current Government extended it.
Comment on this
It got it wrong a second time when it opposed this Government's Bill to liquidate Anglo Irish Bank.
Comment on this
Will the Tánaiste lift the phone and ask the public interest director? This did not happen five years ago. Up to five months ago the public interest directors did not inform the Central Bank-----
Comment on this
-----of potential regulatory breaches of which they were in charge.
Comment on this
The Government is refusing to contact the banks because it is protecting the political elite-----
Comment on this
A former leader of Fine Gael, a former Minister for Finance, and a former Fianna Fáil Senator are on the board of a State-owned bank which did not inform the Central Bank of potential regulatory breaches up until five months ago.
Comment on this
It is absolutely disgraceful. We do not need an inquiry to find out this information.
Comment on this
Deputy Doherty is all mouth and however loud he shouts, the fact of the matter is Sinn Féin got it fundamentally wrong in 2008 and fell for what those guys on the tapes said.
Comment on this
The lies they were telling. Use the word.
Comment on this
They were looking for a bailout from the Irish taxpayer and Sinn Féin fell for it hook, line and sinker. It is about time Deputy Doherty explained and apologised to the Irish people for doing so.
Comment on this
Make the call. The Tánaiste will not make the call because he is protecting vested interests.
Comment on this
I call Deputy Mattie McGrath and I ask him to be brief as we are running out of time.
Comment on this
I will be as brief as I can and before the Tánaiste tells me I fell for it too, the late Brian Lenihan was lied to and I did vote for it. The Labour Party promised it would burn the bondholders and it did not.
Comment on this
I have come from a sad event at the Shelbourne Hotel this morning. At the Allsop auction 121 properties were put up for sale by an English group of auctioneers. There is supposed to be a code of practice for the Central Bank. Under the Central Bank (Consolidation) Bill and consumer protection law when will the Government deal with the banks? A total of 85% of the properties for sale this morning had no goodwill and in many cases they did not have proper title. Deputies Michael Healy-Rae and Tom Fleming and I went up-----
Comment on this
-----and saw for ourselves what was going on. The Tánaiste and his advisers should see what is going on with regard to ordinary people's houses, businesses and family homes. Misery is being perpetrated by the banks. The Tánaiste heaped opprobrium when on this side of the House. I ask him to open his eyes and see what is going on with the banks. It is appropriate the book is in red because there is blood money and Cromwell is back. I could quote Charles Stewart Parnell-----
Comment on this
I will not do so but I could. I ask the Tánaiste please to deal with the banks so they do not create misery for the ordinary people of Ireland on an hourly basis.
Comment on this
The Government will not even phone a friend.
Comment on this
I would like an answer to my question.
Comment on this
I asked about the Central Bank (Consolidation) Bill and consumer protection law. The Tánaiste was not as quiet when he was over here. Hellfire was going to be hotter than the bondholders' fire. I would like an answer to my question please.
Comment on this
Under the Central Bank (Consolidation) Bill will the Government deal with the code of practice for the bankers and chancers who are creating misery for people? Under consumer protection legislation will ordinary householders be protected?
Comment on this
Yesterday we had an eviction Bill.
Comment on this
-----the Central Bank (Supervision and Enforcement) Bill. Deputy McGrath will have an opportunity to discuss the matter. When the Bill has completed its passage-----
Comment on this
The Government has introduced more legislation in the past two years to reform the-----
Comment on this
It is all toothless. The banks have a veto.
Comment on this
The Government has introduced more legislation on reforming our banking system and improving regulation in the past two years than was done during the previous 14 years.
Comment on this
That is simply not true. On a point of order what the Tánaiste has just said is not true.
Comment on this
I could call it something else but I will not do so.
Comment on this
I will not. It is not true and it is an insult to say it. We did not come down in the last shower.
Comment on this
Delivery of a universal health scheme was promised by the Minister, Deputy Reilly, and was also in the programme for Government. We were told it would be delivered before the end of the term of the Government, which is in just over two years' time. People are no longer able to afford private health care and are being forced to leave it. The Tánaiste and his party believe in a public health care system, as do we. We have not seen the bones of the universal health care system which is planned. When will we see legislation prepared for it and when will it be brought before the House? When will we see what is planned, because massive problems exist across the board. I would rather see a public health care system but let us see what the plans are for this universal health care system.
Comment on this
Work is advanced on a range of legislation to reform the health service in line with the programme for Government. The health (amendment) Bill will be published this year. A health general practitioner medical service Bill and a number of alternative options for the phased implementation of a universal GP service without fees are under consideration at present. Other legislation will come at various stages. Work is proceeding on the various pieces of legislation.
Comment on this
Will we see it before the end of the term of this Government?
Comment on this
I wish to inquire about a Bill which may be of some assistance when dealing with agitated backbenchers. It is the mediation Bill. After this morning's session it is becoming more desperate. Will the Bill be published by the end of the year?
Comment on this
I think it should be guillotined, by the way.
Comment on this
Is Deputy Maloney not into mediation?
Comment on this
There has been an epidemic of that.
Comment on this
I am not sure whether mediation would work in here because there must be willingness. Mediation only works if every party is willing to participate, and there is nothing that will satisfy some people on the Opposition benches. The last thing they would ever agree to is mediation. The heads of the mediation Bill have been approved by the Government and it is expected to be published later this year.
Comment on this
When does the Government propose to bring forward legislation to give effect to the creation of between 50 and 60 new local authority members in Dublin?
Comment on this
Deputy Cowen is probably referring to the most extensive and radical reform of local government since the end of the 19th century, which is long overdue.
Comment on this
It will provide some possibility for improvement for the Labour Party.
Comment on this
On a light note I suggest the Brighter Evenings Bill should begin an hour earlier tomorrow in keeping with the spirit of the proposed legislation. On a far more serious note, a number of discoveries of explosive devices and components were made by gardaí in Dublin last night. What is the timeframe with regard to the explosives Bill? We need to prioritise it.
Comment on this
I presume most Members received correspondence in recent days from the Irish Cancer Society regarding the lack of regulation in the area of sunbeds. One point raised in the documentation is that the risk of skin cancer from sunbed use is more than double that of spending the same length of time in Mediterranean sun. In the programme for Government a commitment was made to introduce legislation to regulate this industry. When will we see this legislation?
Comment on this
The heads of the public health (sunbeds) Bill to introduce a number of measures to regulate the use of sunbeds including a prohibition on their use by people aged under 18 years have been approved by the Government and it is expected to be published later this year.
Comment on this
The betting (amendment) Bill is on the A list of legislation and it was to be published before the end of this term. Have the heads of the Bill been considered by Government and will the Bill be published before we adjourn for the summer recess?
While I am on my feet I wish to allude briefly to an item referred to in the programme for Government, namely, the plight of the 32 survivors of thalidomide, which I have raised with the Tánaiste on numerous occasions. I understand the Minister for Health was to meet with those people. Has the meeting taken place yet?
Comment on this
The betting legislation is currently under consideration by the Government. I do not know whether the Minister for Health has met the victims of thalidomide but I will ask him to respond directly to the Deputy.
Comment on this
I was going to speak about the Central Bank (consolidation) Bill but I will not do so. The consumer and competition Bill is currently being prepared. I would like to see legislation on banks that have written off debts and sold it on to companies that are popping up all over the place. They are buying debt for very little and making people’s lives a misery. It is a huge issue. I am hearing much about it in my constituency office. I would welcome legislation on banks selling on bad debt, second hand, which they have already written off. It will become a huge problem in the future.
Comment on this
There is no legislation promised in the area but I accept what the Deputy has said. I agree it is an issue that must be addressed.
Comment on this
When will the assisted decision-making (capacity) Bill, formerly known as mental capacity legislation, be published? I believe it is imminent. Will it be published before we break for the summer or during the summer?