Order of Business
- Order of Business 2 speeches
The Minister proposed the day’s legislative and private members’ business, and the House agreed to take two motions without debate.
Richard Bruton, Seán Barrett
- Cultural institutions Bill appointments 9 speeches
Dara Calleary asked whether the national cultural institutions Bill would address short-term board appointments linked to Seanad elections, criticising an alleged appointment for that purpose. The Chair ruled the electoral issue out of order, while the Minister said the Bill was expected late the following year.
Dara Calleary, Seán Barrett, Richard Bruton
- National paediatric hospital Bill 4 speeches
Aengus Ó Snodaigh questioned why the national paediatric hospital development board Bill had fallen to the C list. The Minister said it was not ready for publication but would seek an update.
Aengus Ó Snodaigh, Richard Bruton
- Seed capital relief for sole traders 3 speeches
Brian Walsh asked whether finance legislation would extend seed capital relief to sole traders; the Minister said the Finance Minister was examining the scheme.
Brian Walsh, Seán Barrett, Richard Bruton
- ESM and credit guarantee Bills 2 speeches
Bernard Durkan sought progress on the ESM direct recapitalisation and credit guarantee Bills. The Minister said the first had Cabinet approval and the second’s heads were approved and would go to committee.
Bernard Durkan, Richard Bruton
- Constitutional Convention reports 2 speeches
Jerry Buttimer requested a debate on outstanding Constitutional Convention reports, and the Minister said one was expected before the House the following week.
Jerry Buttimer, Richard Bruton
- GP contract and health information Bill 2 speeches
Michael Healy-Rae asked whether GPs would receive a workable contract and when the health information Bill would proceed; the Minister cited ongoing negotiations and said the Bill was due next year.
Michael Healy-Rae, Richard Bruton
- Low pay commission legislation 4 speeches
Willie O’Dea challenged the delay in legislation establishing a low-pay commission, questioning the Tánaiste’s commitment. The Minister said it remained a Government priority, with preparatory work under way but no immediate legislative proposal.
Willie O'Dea, Seán Barrett, Richard Bruton
- Social insurance and family leave Bills 2 speeches
Ray Butler asked about extending social insurance to the self-employed and the timing of family-leave legislation. The Minister said the insurance issue depended on budget decisions and the family-leave Bill was expected early the following year.
Ray Butler, Richard Bruton
- Child protection reports and adoption Bill 2 speeches
Robert Troy sought publication of the child-protection rapporteur’s report and progress on the mother-and-baby-homes inquiry. The Minister said the report would be laid shortly, the inquiry remained a priority, and adoption-tracing legislation was hoped for the following year.
Robert Troy, Richard Bruton
- Free GP care for under-sixes 7 speeches
Arthur Spring pressed for a firm timetable for free GP care for children under six. The Minister reaffirmed the commitment but said negotiations with doctors were necessary before setting a date.
Arthur Spring, Seán Barrett, Richard Bruton, Peter Mathews
- Technological universities and planning Bills 2 speeches
Pat Deering asked when legislation would establish technological universities and underpin Construction 2020. The Minister expected the universities Bill this session and planning legislation to advance during it.
Pat Deering, Richard Bruton
- Noise nuisance Bill 13 speeches
Thomas P. Broughan asked whether the noise nuisance Bill had been abandoned and briefly raised water charges, but the Chair directed him back to legislation. The Minister said he had no date for the noise Bill.
Thomas P. Broughan, Seán Barrett, Richard Bruton
- Inland fisheries modernisation Bill 2 speeches
James Bannon urged urgent legislation to address the spread of Asian clam in the River Shannon and protect native fish stocks. The Minister said the Bill was listed for the following year and would convey his concern.
James Bannon, Richard Bruton
- Thalidomide survivors’ compensation 2 speeches
Seán Ó Fearghaíl sought action for 32 Thalidomide survivors under a programme-for-government commitment. The Minister could not give details but undertook to refer the matter to the Health Minister.
Seán Ó Fearghaíl, Richard Bruton
- Credit guarantee Bill timing 2 speeches
Joe Carey again asked when the credit guarantee (amendment) Bill would reach the House; the Minister said its approved heads would first go to committee before introduction.
Joe Carey, Richard Bruton
It is proposed to take No. 15a, motion re ministerial rota for parliamentary questions; No. 15b, motion re membership of committees; No. 4, Health (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2014 - Second Stage (resumed); and No. 5, Sport Ireland Bill 2014 - Order for Second Stage and Second Stage. It is proposed, notwithstanding anything in Standing Orders, that Nos. 15a and 15b shall be decided without debate. Private Members' business shall be No. 159, motion re housing (resumed), to conclude at 9 p.m. tonight, if not previously concluded.
It is proposed that tomorrow's business, after Oral Questions, shall be No. 4, Health (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2014 - Second Stage (resumed); and No. 5, Sport Ireland Bill 2014 - Second Stage (resumed).
Comment on this
There is one proposal to be put to the House. Is the proposal for dealing with Nos. 15a and 15b agreed to? Agreed.
Comment on this
The national cultural institutions Bill, which is on the long list, will revise the governance arrangements for cultural institutions, including the Irish Museum of Modern Art. Will this Bill include provisions dealing with the short-term appointment of board members in order that they should qualify for Seanad elections? What is the Minister's view, as a Minister of considerable experience and integrity-----
Comment on this
This is the Order of Business. Does the Deputy have a question on promised legislation?
Comment on this
-----of the charade that is occurring in the other House, with the appointment of a person to the board of a cultural institution which will come under the Bill to which I referred, in order to qualify that individual to stand for a Seanad by-election?
Comment on this
I referred to the national cultural institutions Bill. In addition, an election to the other House is a matter of business for this House.
Comment on this
However, it is not in order to raise it on the Order of Business. The Deputy can raise it at another time.
Comment on this
The Bill to which the Deputy referred will be brought forward late next year.
Comment on this
It is sometimes fun to go through the new legislative programme at the beginning of the parliamentary year to discover which Bills have fallen backward, moved forward or remained in the same position. Section A lists Bills that are expected to be brought forward this term, while section B includes those Bills for which the heads have been agreed. In the last session, the then Minister for Health promised that the national paediatric hospital development board (amendment) Bill would be forthcoming in that session, the same undertaking having been given in previous sessions. Now we see that the legislation has moved to section C on the legislative programme. The announcement by the Government at the beginning of its term in office of its intention to proceed with the establishment of a national children's hospital was welcome. The question is why there is this delay in putting together a legislative framework for the development board, which is already in place? Why is it not possible to indicate at this stage when that Bill will be published? It should be one of the priority Bills, given that it is concerned with underwriting a huge investment by the State in paediatric services.
Comment on this
There is a great deal of planning going on within the Department of Health on this particular project, but I do not have a publication date for the Bill. The A list is put together by the Whips and the Office of the Parliamentary Counsel, based on their confidence of which business can be delivered to the House. The publication of the legislative programme gives Deputies an opportunity to prepare for the debate on those Bills which are closest to delivery. It is a normal approach to managing business. However, I will seek information on the Deputy's behalf regarding the status of the particular Bill to which he referred.
Comment on this
The problem is that it has dropped from the B list to the C list. This indicates that the heads of Bill have not even been agreed, whereas the indication last session was that it had reached that stage.
Comment on this
In general, where Bills are included on the A list, it means their heads have been agreed by Government and they are expected to be published this session. The Bill we are discussing is not yet at that stage.
Comment on this
The Minister will be the first to agree that the seed capital relief scheme has been very successful in attracting investment in companies. In the context of the finance Bill, does he expect any amendments to be brought forward to allow those provisions to cover sole traders who might wish to avail of a similar relief?
Comment on this
Yes, it would. All I can say is that the Minister for Finance is examining that particular scheme.
Comment on this
The European Stability Mechanism (amendment) Bill is promised legislation to allow for the creation and operation of the ESM's direct recapitalisation instrument. Have the heads been cleared by Cabinet and is it likely to be brought before the House before the end of this session? Have the heads of the credit guarantee (amendment) Bill been cleared and is it likely to be brought before the House?
Comment on this
The first Bill was cleared by Cabinet this week and will be discussed by the end of October. The heads of the credit guarantee (amendment) Bill have been approved and we will bring them to the committee so that it can have an input into the pre-legislative phase.
Comment on this
The Constitutional Convention, of which I was a member, successfully concluded its deliberations. There are a number of outstanding reports to be debated in the House and to which the Government must respond. Will the Chief Whip, on behalf of the Government, give us a date for a debate because it is important we bring the work of the Constitutional Convention to finality in this House?
Comment on this
I understand the Chief Whip has had a meeting on that and he is hopeful one of the reports will be before the House next week for debate.
Comment on this
Will general practitioners get a proper, practical and workable contract rather than the unworkable contract which is on the table currently? This relates to the health information Bill.
Comment on this
That Bill will be taken next year. On the wider issue, I understand discussions are taking place with the Irish Medical Organisation.
Comment on this
On assuming the leadership of the Labour Party, the Tánaiste expressed great concerns about the levels of pay in this country and announced that as part of her price for continuing-----
Comment on this
-----in government, the Government would immediately bring in legislation to establish a commission on low pay. According to this list, the legislation just to establish the commission to look at the subject will be brought forward at some unspecified time next year. It has not even been approved by Government yet. Will the Minister confirm that is the case because if it is, it calls the Tánaiste's genuineness into account?
Comment on this
It is certainly promised legislation. It is part of the revised agreement between the parties which the Deputy rightly said followed the Tánaiste assuming the leadership of the Labour Party. It will be developed by the Minister of State in my Department, Deputy Nash. He has already engaged in a number of meetings both here and in other jurisdictions to examine best practice in this approach. This is a priority for Government but it will not be on this list until a legislative proposal is set out in a framework. Work is very actively being undertaken in my Department and we will be in a position to brief Cabinet in due course of the approach that will be taken.
Comment on this
I refer to the social welfare Bill and measures to be announced in the budget. Will the Government look at the Mangan report on the new social insurance stamp for the self-employed? It is a huge issue and everybody wants such a stamp. When is publication of the family leave Bill to consolidate with amendments all family leave legislation expected?
Comment on this
As the Deputy knows, there is an annual social welfare Bill which incorporates any changes that would be introduced into systems, such as social insurance. That would be a matter for budgetary consideration. The family leave Bill will be introduced early next year.
Comment on this
Last week I raised the issue of the Government's independent rapporteur on child protection. His report was given the Minister for Children and Youth Affairs in January or February of this year and it has yet to be laid before the House. Could I get an indication as to when that report will be laid before the House?
I refer to the independent commission of investigation into the mother and baby homes. We all agree it is important that we get the terms of reference right. The Minister for Children and Youth Affairs has engaged widely with the interested parties but the Government promised that the terms of reference would be published before the summer recess in July of this year. It is now almost October and we are still awaiting publication of the terms of reference. One of the key issues here relates to the adoption (tracing and information) Bill to give people who were adopted, whether forcibly, illegally or otherwise, the right to their identity. When will the terms of reference be published and when will the important adoption (tracing and information) Bill be brought before the House?
Comment on this
I understand the Tánaiste is replying to the Deputy in regard to the rapporteur's report. The hope is that it will be laid before the House shortly. In regard to the terms of reference, there have been some changes in ministerial office but it continues to be a priority so I do not think there will be a delay. I think the adoption (tracing and information) Bill will be brought forward next year. Much work has been done by the Attorney General in that regard and advice has been given. It is hoped that Bill will be presented next year.
Comment on this
The Government promised there would be free GP for those under six years of age. It then promised the legislation would be enacted by July 2014. The Minister for Health has indicated that he is unsure of the timeframe for when it will be implemented. It is a deliverable for this Government but we do not have a timeframe for it. Is there any certainty in Cabinet as to how this will be developed and is there a timeframe around the negotiations with the Irish Medical Organisation and the general practitioners?
Comment on this
It is not really a matter for the Order of Business because it has nothing to do with legislation.
Comment on this
It relates to promised legislation.
Comment on this
This is part of the revised programme for Government. The Government intends to implement this but negotiations are an essential part of rolling out this commitment. The Minister is committed to delivering it as quickly as he can but the State must negotiate terms for the delivery. One cannot set a firm date until one has-----
Comment on this
The issue of negotiations is a crucial part of this.
Comment on this
The lesson is not to make promises.
Comment on this
As the Minister well knows, the south east of the country faces a difficulty from an unemployment point of view. One of the best ways to try to sort out that issue is through education. As the Minister is probably aware, Carlow IT and Waterford IT have done much work in proposing the formation of a technological university. Will the Minister give me a timescale on when the technological universities Bill will be introduced? In regard to planning legislation, when will legislation be introduced to underpin the Construction 2020 strategy?
Comment on this
I understand the technological universities Bill will be taken this session. I know the planning legislation is being treated as a priority by the Minister for the Environment, Community and Local Government, Deputy Kelly, and it is hoped it will be brought to Government this session.
Comment on this
I was going to ask about the planning legislation also. Has the noise nuisance Bill completely gone off the clár? There are a couple of issues in the Minister's and my constituency and this could be important legislation in respect of them.
I refer to an earlier discussion and the proposal by the Minister for Health, Deputy Varadkar, to give families €5 or €10 per week back in the budget in a few weeks time. Has any consideration been given simply to scrapping the water tax at least until the general election? Perhaps the general election could be used as a referendum to decide whether we should go ahead with this morass that is Irish Water and this terrible imposition.
Comment on this
This is becoming the straw that broke the camel's back.
Comment on this
-----if the Government will give consideration to removing this tax.
Comment on this
That could be a proposal for budget 2015.
Comment on this
As Deputy McDonald said earlier, we are crushing-----
Comment on this
Deputy, please resume your seat. I call the Minister to address the noise nuisance Bill.
Comment on this
In light of the presence of Asian clam in the hot water stretch of the River Shannon at Lanesborough, County Longford, we have had previous outbreaks in 2010 in the rivers Barrow and the Nore. This is a dangerous species which can wipe out native fish stocks. It can be carried by nets, boats, fishing rods, clothing and cruisers. When will we have the inland fisheries (modernisation and consolidation) Bill? I understand it is expected in 2015 but it is urgently needed now. We have been forewarned and we should bring the Bill forward at the earliest opportunity.
Comment on this
It is listed for next year but I will convey the Deputy's concern to the relevant Minister.
Comment on this
I have acknowledged on a number of occasions the good work that the Government has done on the issue of the Magdalen laundries. However, there was a specific commitment in the programme for Government regarding the 32 survivors of Thalidomide. The previous Minister for Health, Deputy Reilly, abysmally failed to address the plight of those people. Can we get an assurance that the present Minister for Health, Deputy Varadkar, will now take on board the commitment made in the programme for Government and will do something concrete to resolve their plight?
Comment on this
I am not in a position to give the Deputy a detailed answer. I will bring the matter to the attention of the Minister, Deputy Varadkar, so that he can issue a reply to the Deputy.
Comment on this
I ask the Minister when he expects the credit guarantee (amendment) Bill to come before the House?
Comment on this
I addressed that issue already in response to Deputy Durkan. We have approved the heads of the Bill and they are going to the Oireachtas committee to give its members an opportunity to comment on the proposals. We will then proceed to introduce it to the House.