Order of Business
- Order of Business 2 speeches
The Tánaiste proposes the day’s scheduled Bills and Friday business; the Ceann Comhairle confirms there are no further proposals.
Joan Burton, Seán Barrett
- Irish Water constitutional referendum 2 speeches
Timmy Dooley asks whether the Government will legislate for a referendum protecting Irish Water in the Constitution or whether Labour Senators acted personally.
Timmy Dooley, Seán Barrett
- M50 congestion legislation 12 speeches
Dooley asks when road-traffic legislation will address congestion and possible M50 tolling; the Tánaiste says road-traffic legislation is expected next year.
Timmy Dooley, Seán Barrett, Joan Burton
- Irish Water referendum controversy 5 speeches
Deputies challenge the Tánaiste over Labour Senators’ support for the Irish Water referendum proposal, but the Chair restores order.
Barry Cowen, Timmy Dooley, Billy Kelleher, Seán Barrett
- Symphysiotomy redress scheme 2 speeches
McDonald seeks time to discuss the new symphysiotomy redress scheme; the Tánaiste confirms a €34 million programme for survivors.
Mary Lou McDonald, Joan Burton
- Mother and baby homes inquiry 3 speeches
McDonald requests an update and publication date for the mother and baby homes inquiry terms of reference; the Tánaiste says departmental work remains ongoing.
Ruth Coppinger, Joan Burton, Seán Barrett
- Istanbul Convention ratification 1 speech
The Tánaiste says legislation enabling ratification of the Istanbul Convention on violence against women is expected next year.
Joan Burton
- Symphysiotomy debate request 1 speech
Billy Kelleher asks that the Dáil make time to debate concerns about the symphysiotomy redress scheme.
Billy Kelleher
- Political party funding 8 speeches
Kelleher seeks a debate on political-party funding and corporate donations; the Chair refers the matter to the Whips, with the Tánaiste supporting discussions.
Seán Barrett, Billy Kelleher, Joan Burton
- Independent policing authority Bill 2 speeches
Niall Collins asks when the independent policing authority legislation will be published; the Chair treats the query as appropriate to Parliamentary Questions.
Niall Collins, Seán Barrett
- Guerin commission terms 6 speeches
Collins asks when the Guerin-related commission’s terms of reference will be published; the Tánaiste says proposals are being finalised for Government consideration.
Niall Collins, Seán Barrett, Joan Burton
- Secretary General vacancy 3 speeches
Collins seeks debate time over the lack of a successful applicant for a senior departmental post, but the Chair rules it out of order.
Seán Barrett, Joan Burton
- Irish Water PPS-number data sharing 11 speeches
Dessie Ellis questions local authorities’ sharing of tenants’ PPS numbers with Irish Water and asks about data-sharing legislation; the Tánaiste disputes his party’s position and says the relevant legislation was already debated.
Dessie Ellis, Joan Burton, Aengus Ó Snodaigh, Emmet Stagg, Seán Barrett
- Minimum alcohol pricing Bill 4 speeches
James Bannon urges publication of the public health alcohol Bill and minimum unit pricing; the Tánaiste expects it before the House next year.
James Bannon, Seán Barrett, Joan Burton
- Official Languages Amendment Bill 1 speech
Michael P. Kitt asks about the Official Languages (Amendment) Bill; the Tánaiste says it is on the session’s priority list.
Michael P. Kitt
- Mother and baby homes debate 1 speech
The Tánaiste says the Whips should be able to arrange a debate on mother-and-baby homes once the inquiry work is complete.
Joan Burton
- International tax cooperation Bill 7 speeches
Broughan raises the tax-cooperation Bill amid reports of Luxembourg tax avoidance and asks about recalling European officials; the Chair permits only the legislative query, which the Tánaiste says will be taken this session.
Thomas P. Broughan, Seán Barrett, Joan Burton
- Water charges debate 2 speeches
Joe Higgins asks for the time and duration of a debate on water charges, but the Chair refuses to reopen the subject.
Joe Higgins, Seán Barrett
- Corporate tax avoidance 3 speeches
Higgins condemns alleged corporate tax avoidance and asks when the international tax-cooperation Bill will proceed; the Chair limits him to the Bill.
Joe Higgins, Seán Barrett
- Garda conduct during water protests 9 speeches
Higgins alleges Garda brutality against water-charge protesters and demands Government action; the Tánaiste says Gardaí serve the State professionally and that wider tax abuses require European and global cooperation.
Seán Barrett, Joe Higgins, Anthony Lawlor, Joan Burton
- Court of Appeal access 4 speeches
Mattie McGrath describes a constituent being directed to an apparently empty Court of Appeal and is told to table a Parliamentary Question.
Mattie McGrath, Seán Barrett
- Judicial Council Bill 3 speeches
McGrath asks when the Judicial Council Bill will be introduced; the Tánaiste expects it during the current session.
Mattie McGrath, Seán Barrett, Joan Burton
- Personal Injuries Assessment Board Bill 2 speeches
Frank Feighan asks about the Personal Injuries Assessment Board (Amendment) Bill; the Tánaiste expects it next year.
Frankie Feighan, Joan Burton
It is proposed to take No. 5, Finance Bill 2014 - Second Stage (resumed); No. 6, Social Welfare Bill 2014 - Order for Second Stage and Second Stage; and No. 34, Garda Síochána (Amendment) (No. 3) Bill 2014 - Second Stage (resumed). Tomorrow's fortnightly Friday business shall be No. 60, Social Welfare Appeals Bill 2013 and No. 19, report on the design and layout of ballot papers used in the Seanad referendum in October 2013.
Comment on this
In the light of the decision of Labour Party Senators yesterday to support a Fianna Fáil motion in the Seanad to have a referendum held to enshrine the protection of Irish Water in the Constitution, will the Tánaiste tell us whether she intends to bring a Bill before the House shortly to give effect to that decision, or was it the case that the Senators were acting in a personal capacity?
Comment on this
It relates to promised legislation in the light of that decision.
On the road traffic Bill, in the light of the upgrade works at Newlands Cross and the impact these works are expected to have on traffic activity on the M50, we face the prospect of congestion-----
Comment on this
We are not talking about traffic congestion at Newlands Cross. This is the Order of Business.
Comment on this
I accept that, but does the Government have any view on the need to bring forward legislation providing for congestion charges, in line with proposals made by the NRA which suggested the introduction of multi-point tolling on the M50?
Comment on this
It falls under the heading of the road traffic Bill.
What other promised legislation is on the way on pensions? As the Tánaiste knows, the deferred pensions of airline-----
Comment on this
The Deputy should resume his seat. The Order of Business is about promised legislation.
Comment on this
With respect, all of the issues raised concern promised legislation.
Comment on this
I must confess that I am not up to speed on the situation at Newlands Cross. However, if the Deputy is referring to road traffic legislation, I understand it is due to be published next year.
On the issue of congestion charges, does Fianna Fáil now have a new policy? Is it proposing the introduction of congestion charges and tolling for everyone coming into Dublin?
Comment on this
I am asking when the Government intends to bring it forward.
Comment on this
What about the referendum to protect Irish Water?
Comment on this
Who are the independent Labour Party Senators?
Comment on this
What about their former Senators?
Comment on this
I have three matters to raise. First, I notice the symphysiotomy redress scheme has been announced today. Will time be made available for a discussion of this in the Dáil?
Second, can I have an update on the terms of reference for the commission of inquiry into the mother and baby homes? Is the Tánaiste in a position at this stage to give even an indicative date for the publication of those terms of reference?
Finally, I have raised with the Tánaiste before the matter of the reformed and consolidated domestic violence Bill, which would enable Irish ratification of the Istanbul convention. She has told me previously that it will be seen at some point in 2015. Can she be more exact than that in terms of the date of publication?
Comment on this
On the first point, a €34 million redress scheme has been agreed for symphysiotomy survivors, as has been announced. The programme for Government committed to addressing that issue. I want to pay tribute to all of the groups who have worked so hard in this regard. I had the privilege of meeting quite a number of the women involved. I know many continue to suffer physical and mental anguish. I believe and I hope the redress scheme will bring some comfort and recognition for the women involved of the many decades of suffering they have endured. I know many members of their families have suffered alongside them as a consequence of what happened.
Many of my colleagues, some of the Deputy's colleagues and members of all parties in the House, including the Fine Gael Party, have had fairly constant contact with the different groups-----
Comment on this
-----in particular, the Minister of State, Deputy Ged Nash, and Senator Mary Moran in the case of the Labour Party. Given many of the women are at an advanced age-----
Comment on this
I am just responding to the question. Second, the work is ongoing in regard to the mother and baby homes. I believe I told the Deputy on the last occasion that it had gone to each Department to get their responses, and that work is ongoing. I do not have an indicative date as yet.
In regard to the Deputy's concerns around violence against women and abuse of women, I understand the ratification of that will be next year.
Comment on this
I wish to raise two issues. On the issue of the symphysiotomy redress scheme, I ask that time would be made available at some stage for a debate, given there are still concerns in this regard.
On the second issue, I suppose the Tánaiste in one way made a career out of the whole issue of political funding, how we fund political parties and ethics in office. The issue of the funding of political parties is very much coming to the fore again and I wonder whether we could have a debate in this House on what we consider appropriate in regard to how we fund our political parties.
Comment on this
In view of issues that were raised earlier by the Tánaiste with regard to some political parties now being funded by corporate America, and suckling at the teat of corporate America, is it possible-----
Comment on this
Yes, but I am asking the Tánaiste whether it is possible for us to have a meaningful debate here in view of the fact some political parties in this House receive large sums of funding from unnamed sources that can have a direct impact on how we fund democracy in this country.
Comment on this
I believe it would be appropriate that we would have a debate to ensure we have an ethical approach to how we fund political parties in this Parliament.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Whips could have a discussion on this. I am sure appropriate arrangements could be entered into that all the parties would probably agree with.
Comment on this
First, will the Tánaiste tell us when the legislation for the establishment of an independent policing authority will be published? We were promised during previous debates that this authority would be up and running before Christmas but it is obvious this will not now be the case.
Second, following the Guerin report, which the former Minister for Justice and Equality is challenging and seeking to have expunged in the courts, can the Tánaiste tell us when we will have the terms of reference of the commission of investigation which is to flow from the Guerin report?
Finally, on an issue I have sought to raise through a series of Topical Issue requests which have not been granted, there has been an unprecedented situation in this country where the vacancy for Secretary General of the Department of Justice and Equality had no applicant.
Comment on this
Sorry, that is not a matter for the Order of Business. It is a matter for Parliamentary Questions.
Comment on this
That is a damning indictment of the Government-----
Comment on this
----given a situation where we have had no applicant for a position of Secretary General in a major Government Department.
Comment on this
Would the Government consider making time available to debate that?
Comment on this
In regard to the independent policing authority, I am happy to say the heads were cleared on Tuesday and it is a priority for drafting. That is very good progress in regard to an issue which is very important for our democracy and for the Garda Síochána, which is so important for the protection of our citizens.
In regard to the terms of reference for Guerin, I do not have an exact timeline. Deputy Moynihan was contacted recently by the Minister, Deputy Fitzgerald, to indicate that she is finalising proposals and that she will be bringing those proposals to Government shortly.
On the issue of the filling of vacancies and TLAC-----
Comment on this
As the Tánaiste is aware, there is serious disquiet over the request by Irish Water for the PPS numbers of all members in the household. It is reported that local authorities are passing on details of their tenants to Irish Water, including their PPS numbers. People are refusing to give this type of information but, now, we find local authorities are doing it anyway. There is a data sharing Bill due before this House. When will this happen? Will this Bill address the laissez-faire attitude to citizens' personal details which is evident in the case of Irish Water?
Comment on this
My understanding and recollection is that Deputy Ellis's own party in the debate on this matter was quite keen that PPS numbers as unique identifiers would be used in regard to Irish Water.
Comment on this
No, we were not. We did not even have a debate.
Comment on this
The legislation in regard to the PPS numbers was last year. I am not aware there is pending legislation in regard to the Deputy's query.
Comment on this
That Bill was debated over a period of nearly two months and the Deputy's party contributed on it.
Comment on this
We need to tackle the scourge of binge drinking that is having a huge impact on services within the State, in particular in terms of crime and the pressure it is putting on the health services.
Comment on this
When can we expect the public health (alcohol) Bill to provide for minimum unit pricing for retailing of alcohol products? This Bill is long overdue and I would like to see it come before the House soon.
Comment on this
I understand a lot of work has been done on this, as the Deputy is aware. I expect it to come before the House next year.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Tánaiste the current status of the Official Languages (Amendment) Bill to implement the recommendations arising from the review of Official Languages Act 2003.
Deputy McDonald raised the issue of the mother and baby homes. Will there be a debate on that issue? Many people are still trying to get information about their own personal records in regard to Tuam, County Galway.
I would like that information made available either through a debate or replies to those people.
Comment on this
I understand the Official Languages (Amendment) Bill is on the "A" list to come before the House during this session. In respect of facilitating a debate on mother-and-baby homes in Tuam and other areas of the country, when the work is completed, a discussion among the Whips will almost certainly facilitate a debate in the House.
Comment on this
I am enquiring about two pieces of legislation, one of which is the International Agreements on Mutual Administrative Assistance in Taxation Bill. In light of the appalling revelations this morning in The Irish Times and The Guardian about the massive tax evasion facilitated by the state of Luxembourg over the past 18 years, with the Irish company Glanbia mentioned in those dispatches, will the Irish Government take action on this? Is there a mechanism whereby the President of the European Commission, Jean-Claude Juncker, could be recalled?
Comment on this
At the same time, could we recall Commissioner Phil Hogan who got the country into this water mess?
Comment on this
I understand the Bill referred to by the Deputy will come before the House in this session.
Comment on this
What about the substantive question?
Comment on this
Will the Tánaiste give me the time, date and duration of the debate on water charges? People deserve to know the level of charges the Government will force them to boycott en masse in January.
Comment on this
In respect of the International Agreements on Mutual Administrative Assistance in Taxation Bill, on the morning when The Irish Times exposes the most incredible tax dodging by Irish corporations purporting to work in Luxembourg, where they have as much work as they would have on the Blasket Islands, when will the Government stop this incredible scamming on tax by major corporations when working-class people are pulverised for yet more taxes?
Comment on this
I am speaking about the International Agreements on Mutual Administrative Assistance in Taxation Bill. Yesterday, women in their sixties were manhandled by the gardaí.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy resume his seat? He knows as well as I do that he is not allowed display items like that in the Chamber. He is here a long time. I ask the Deputy to resume his seat.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste is responsible for this disgraceful situation. What will she do to stop gardaí brutalising local communities for opposing water charges?
Comment on this
If the Deputy abuses the Order of Business, I will not call him. I ask him to resume his seat. He knows he is out of order.
Comment on this
I am saying that right around this country, there is an insurrection against the Government's new austerity tax. People are being manhandled and brutalised by her gardaí and I am calling her to account to stop it.
Comment on this
What about the Deputy's people abusing the gardaí?
Comment on this
Gardaí have an oath of loyalty to the State and not to any particular politician - Deputy Joe Higgins, me or anyone else.
Comment on this
No, the Government is abusing them.
Comment on this
It is a professional force, as it ought to be. In respect of Deputy Joe Higgins's query about taxation, the legislation to which he referred will come before the House this session. In my view - the Deputy has been a member of the European Parliament - these matters can be addressed only by close co-operation across Europe and on a global basis if we wish to address them properly.
Comment on this
Ten days ago in a blaze of glory we saw a new Court of Appeal set up and rolled out on foot of a referendum that was held over a year ago. The referendum was rushed but the people decided. A constituent of mine went to lodge an appeal in the Supreme Court last Friday-----
Comment on this
He was sent to the new Court of Appeal to find empty offices-----
Comment on this
When will the Judicial Council Bill come before the House and when will we see some sense made of what is going on down in the courts?
Comment on this
When will the Personal Injuries Assessment Board (Amendment) Bill come before the House?