Water Services Bill debate timetable
Opposition deputies object that scheduling the Water Services Bill for Friday without a vote undermines accountability and parliamentary scrutiny, while Joe Higgins condemns the Bill and calls for water charges to be abolished. The Tánaiste says 17 hours have been provided for Second Stage, there is no guillotine, and additional time can be arranged; the Friday sitting proposal is ultimately agreed.
No. When the Tánaiste's party was in opposition it promised, among many things, that there would be a democratic revolution in terms of the reform of politics. When people outside these Houses consider how it has attempted to reform politics they see abject failure. They see less accountability of Government here in the Dáil, less accountability of Ministers and less opportunity for people like us to hold the Government to account.
One of the window dressing exercises it engaged in was the introduction of Friday sittings of which there is one this week. The item on the Order Paper-----
Comment on this
-----purports to take business which is being discussed today and should that business conclude tomorrow, a vote will be deferred until the following week. I want clarification from the Tánaiste on the reason the Water Services Bill should conclude tomorrow when a vote will not be taken. This is yet another example of the sham political reform agenda the Government has engaged in and presided over because these Friday sittings have no accountability-----
Comment on this
When did the Deputy bring a Bill here on a Friday?
Comment on this
There is no opportunity to question leaders on Fridays.
Comment on this
How many times has the Deputy been here?
Comment on this
There are no opportunities to call votes. There are no committees sitting. There are no opportunities to question Ministers, and no Order of Business.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not show up on a Friday.
Comment on this
Why does it want to engage in this sham exercise of having business contracted in the Dáil when it will not allow an opportunity-----
Comment on this
-----if that business is concluded for there to be a vote?
Comment on this
The Water Services Bill 2014 is as cynical and duplicitous a piece of legislation as ever came before Dáil Éireann. Now we have a Government punch drunk by a revolt of people power against water charges and six years of austerity desperately trying to construct a fig leaf to cover the betrayals of the Labour Party in particular and to get it past the next general election.
The proposal for dealing with the Water Services Bill-----
Comment on this
-----is cynical in the extreme. There will be no Order of Business tomorrow so there will be no Taoiseach or no Tánaiste to be called to account.
Comment on this
There is never an Order of Business on a Friday.
Comment on this
How many times has the Deputy been here?
Comment on this
The vote is postponed until Tuesday-----
Comment on this
Why is the vote postponed until Tuesday? It is because tomorrow is a charade whereby the Government can disappear for the day but then pretend that it is not repeating the disastrous handling of the first water charges legislation.
This morning the Labour Party is teetering over the precipice of annihilation but it is still not prepared to listen to what the people are saying. Its members are full of self-delusion but I can assure them they are not fooling the people outside this House.
Comment on this
There is no need for concern, Joe.
Comment on this
A mass mobilisation on 10 December-----
Comment on this
The Trotskyites are going to take over.
Comment on this
-----and a mass boycott of the water charges in April will make sure of that.
Comment on this
Will you pay your bin charge?
Comment on this
I ask the Government to cut through the charade and abolish these water charges forthwith.
Comment on this
If the debate is not finished and there are speakers offering at 8 p.m. tomorrow, assuming that this goes through, will the Tánaiste indicate when the debate on the Bill will be resumed?
Comment on this
It nearly went to Christmas Day last year.
Comment on this
The proposition is very flawed for a Bill that has such import in terms of how it will impact on families and individuals throughout the length and breadth of this State. We are talking about providing for speaking time tomorrow. This is huge legislation and people are watching this with great interest. It is a fact of life that the Friday sittings will only apply to those who are actually scheduled to speak. We will not have a ministerial audience beyond whatever limited number the Government provides in order to hear the contributions. The contributions of Members who will speak here tomorrow are very important, and a great number of Members will not be here tomorrow if they are not actually scheduled to participate. That is not the case on a Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday because even if we are not in the Chamber we are following what is taking place, but that will not happen when those who are not required to be here are in their constituencies. It is unacceptable. The Friday sittings provide an opportunity to address legislation that is, by comparison, more minuscule in terms of its impact. This is seismic. There can be nobody under any doubt about it, and then the Government seeks to go on to Committee and Report Stages on Tuesday and Wednesday of next week.
The reality is that legislation of this consequence should have the normal provision of the period of time that applies, at least a couple of weeks, from its publication. This Bill was only presented on Tuesday evening and within a week the Government will have it pressed through the House because of its number of Deputies. As other speakers have said, the consequences will be severe on people but make no mistake, they will also be severe on the Members opposite in political life. I believe that will be demonstrated very clearly once again next Wednesday outside the gates of this institution when people will muster in huge numbers.
I say to the Tánaiste that she should draw breath on this. There is only one decision that has to be taken and that is to withdraw this legislation and not proceed with the water charges as proposed, which are unacceptable. I believe what the Government is doing and the approach it is taking is wholly unacceptable.
Comment on this
This is the Second Stage debate on the Water Services Bill and 17 hours have been provided for that. Yesterday, by way of example, the Social Welfare Bill to effect the budget changes such as increasing child benefit and the other changes that are providing additionality took place. I see some of the people who were here yesterday but at no stage were there more than five to eight people in the Chamber. Deputy Ó Snodaigh, Deputy O'Dea, Deputy Shortall, Deputy Daly, Deputy Wallace and a number of others were here.
Comment on this
As the Deputy knows well, that was a Wednesday and the people who were in the Chamber, by and large, were the party spokespersons on the issue. A full day has been set aside tomorrow for debate and any Deputy who wishes to speak on Second Stage will be facilitated. There is no guillotine. If Members want to come in on Monday or stay later on Tuesday, that can be facilitated. In terms of the timetable, 17 hours have been provided so far for the Second Stage debate.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowen wants to guillotine it.
Comment on this
----for all the Deputies who want to contribute on Second Stage, that can be accommodated.
Comment on this
The Water Services Bill will provide Ireland with €10 billion of investment in badly needed improvements in water and sewerage services at a modest cost, given all the changes which have been introduced.
Comment on this
What about Article 9.4 and the exemption?
Comment on this
I recognise that it is difficult for people to accommodate the changes that have been taking place, but it will provide for the provision of safe and clean drinking water, the conservation of water and the provision of water for industry, as well as dealing with the raw sewage being dumped in 42 rivers and harbours.
Comment on this
Last year the Tánaiste was blaming those with septic tanks for it.
Comment on this
The Bill will be seen to be in the interests of the people, notwithstanding the fact that they have a democratic right to protest against it. This is good for people's health, employment and the development of the economy. Members can have as much time as they wish. At such short notice, I cannot arrange a sitting on Saturday and Sunday, but if more time is needed, it will be available. The debate will not be guillotined.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Tánaiste has not addressed the question raised by Deputy Niall Collins, which effectively was to ask whether we could have a vote, as we should have, if Second Stage concluded on Friday.
Comment on this
No, in accordance with the order of the Dáil yesterday, the vote will take place on Tuesday.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the proposal for dealing with the sitting and business of the Dáil tomorrow in the event that the Water Services Bill 2014 does not conclude today be agreed to."
Do you agree with this result?