Government programme commitments
Deputy Micheál Martin challenged the Taoiseach on several unfulfilled programme commitments, including tenancy deposits, paid paternity leave, the living wage, public-sector pensions and rural transport. The Taoiseach gave partial assurances on rural transport and the living wage, while saying other matters remained under consideration or required later clarification; exchanges were repeatedly curtailed as the House moved on.
In the programme for Government, there is a commitment to establish a tenancy protection scheme to put an end to disputes regarding the return of deposits. Could the Taoiseach outline to the House the position on this commitment? When can we expect the legislation on it?
With regard to paid paternity leave, the Minister of State with responsibility for equality, Deputy Aodhán Ó Ríordáin, stated on 21 January, "I am as confident as I can be at this stage that there will be two weeks' paid paternity leave in that [family leave] legislation". It was suggested that this would not be very expensive, with a figure of €10 million mooted. In response to a parliamentary question, the Tánaiste indicated the introduction of paid paternity leave would have significant cost implications for employers, the Exchequer and the Social Insurance Fund. That seems to indicate the costings have not been done. Can the Taoiseach indicate when paid paternity leave is to be introduced? The Minister of State, who is in the Taoiseach's Government, made a solemn commitment. Perhaps the Government makes it up as it goes along; I do not know. The Taoiseach might confirm whether the Minister of State's statement was made up as he went along.
On the issue of a tax relief for landlords who agree not to increase rent, the Government made a commitment, apparently through the Irish Independent, that it would introduce this.
The third matter I want to mention is the free second year of child care and tax relief. When is it proposed to introduce that?
Comment on this
The Deputy has a lot of information on that phone.
Comment on this
These are all Government commitments.
Comment on this
It is extracts from the commitments made by the Taoiseach's Ministers. It is very impressive. The Government says it will reduce or abolish the public sector pension levy: "The public sector pension levy is "likely" to be reduced significantly or abolished ahead of the general election, senior Government sources have told the Irish Independent."
Comment on this
The Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, Deputy Brendan Howlin, has made a comment that an annual report will be provided to the Dáil.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste has promised the introduction of a living wage. When will that be?
Comment on this
These points are on legislation promised by Ministers.
Comment on this
Yes. They promised this. There is obviously some incoherence at the heart of the Government-----
Comment on this
Either the Government side is winding up the Irish Independent or both are winding up the nation; work it out.
The last item is the commitment in the programme for Government on rural areas. Can the Taoiseach allow Government time for debate in the House on that issue, given Bus Éireann's decision yesterday to cut vital services to people in towns, particularly across the south east? Approximately 100 rural bus routes are to be cut by the company. This seems to be in direct contradiction of the commitment in the programme for Government. I would appreciate it if the Taoiseach allocated Government time to debate this issue.
Comment on this
Yes. In due course, there will be no problem at all. We will wait until the rural development programme is officially confirmed by the European Commission in the coming weeks. We will be able to discuss the change in retention figures for small schools and have a debate here.
Comment on this
Rural transport, of course, will be part of that.
With regard to the living wage, the low pay commission has its first meeting this week. Obviously it will report before the summer and the Government will act accordingly in respect of that and employers. The Deputy will recall that the first thing we were able to do with what is now termed "the institution" - the troika - was to reverse the cut to the minimum wage brought in by a previous Administration.
Comment on this
The question of the second year of child care is a matter for consideration in advance of the budget. I will have to revert to the Deputy on the return of deposits legislation and the tax relief for landlords.
The Government has not considered the comments made by the Minister of State on paid paternity leave.
Comment on this
He said, "I am as confident as I can be."
Comment on this
I actually believed, when Deputy Martin was reading from his mobile phone, that he was going to tell us when he was going to produce the Fianna Fáil policy on the health system.
Comment on this
He said, "I am as confident as I can be at this stage."
Comment on this
What policy has the Taoiseach on health?